Evidence against transcription termination within the E. coli lac operon

Nanomolar Responsiveness of an Anaerobic Degradation Specialist to Alkylphenol Pollutants

Anaerobic degradation of p-cresol (4-methylphenol) by the denitrifying betaproteobacterium Aromatoleum aromaticum EbN1 is regulated with high substrate specificity, presumed to be mediated by the predicted σ⁵⁴-dependent two-component system PcrSR. An unmarked, in-frame ΔpcrSR deletion mutant showed reduced expression of the genes cmh (21-fold) and hbd (8-fold) that encode the two enzymes for initial oxidation of p-cresol to p-hydroxybenzoate compared to their expression in the wild type. The expression of cmh and hbd was restored by in trans complementation with pcrSR in the ΔpcrSR background to even higher levels than in the wild type. This is likely due to ∼200-/∼30-fold more transcripts of pcrSR in the complemented mutant. The in vivo responsiveness of A. aromaticum EbN1 to p-cresol was studied in benzoate-limited anaerobic cultures by the addition of p-cresol at various concentrations (from 100 μM down to 0.1 nM). Time-resolved transcript profiling by quantitative reverse transcription-PCR (qRT-PCR) revealed that the lowest p-cresol concentrations just affording cmh and hbd expression (response threshold) ranged between 1 and 10 nM, which is even more sensitive than the respective odor receptors of insects. A similar response threshold was determined for another alkylphenol, p-ethylphenol, which strain EbN1 anaerobically degrades via a different route and senses by the σ⁵⁴-dependent one-component system EtpR. Based on these data and theoretical considerations, p-cresol or p-ethylphenol added as a single pulse (10 nM) requires less than a fraction of a second to reach equilibrium between intra- and extracellular space (∼20 molecules per cell), with an estimated K_d (dissociation constant) of <100 nM alkylphenol (p-cresol or p-ethylphenol) for its respective sensory protein (PcrS or EtpR).IMPORTANCE Alkylphenols (like p-cresol and p-ethylphenol) represent bulk chemicals for industrial syntheses. Besides massive local damage events, large-scale micropollution is likewise of environmental and health concern. Next to understanding how such pollutants can be degraded by microorganisms, it is also relevant to determine the microorganisms' lower threshold of responsiveness. Aromatoleum aromaticum EbN1 is a specialist in anaerobic degradation of aromatic compounds, employing a complex and substrate-specifically regulated catabolic network. The present study aims at verifying the predicted role of the PcrSR system in sensing p-cresol and at determining the threshold of responsiveness for alkylphenols. The findings have implications for the enigmatic persistence of dissolved organic matter (escape from biodegradation) and for the lower limits of aromatic compounds required for bacterial growth.

OptSSeq: High-Throughput Sequencing Readout of Growth Enrichment Defines Optimal Gene Expression Elements for Homoethanologenesis

The optimization of synthetic pathways is a central challenge in metabolic engineering. OptSSeq (Optimization by Selection and Sequencing) is one approach to this challenge. OptSSeq couples selection of optimal enzyme expression levels linked to cell growth rate with high-throughput sequencing to track enrichment of gene expression elements (promoters and ribosome-binding sites) from a combinatorial library. OptSSeq yields information on both optimal and suboptimal enzyme levels, and helps identify constraints that limit maximal product formation. Here we report a proof-of-concept implementation of OptSSeq using homoethanologenesis, a two-step pathway consisting of pyruvate decarboxylase (Pdc) and alcohol dehydrogenase (Adh) that converts pyruvate to ethanol and is naturally optimized in the bacterium Zymomonas mobilis. We used OptSSeq to determine optimal gene expression elements and enzyme levels for Z. mobilis Pdc, AdhA, and AdhB expressed in Escherichia coli. By varying both expression signals and gene order, we identified an optimal solution using only Pdc and AdhB. We resolved current uncertainty about the functions of the Fe²⁺-dependent AdhB and Zn²⁺-dependent AdhA by showing that AdhB is preferred over AdhA for rapid growth in both E. coli and Z. mobilis. Finally, by comparing predictions of growth-linked metabolic flux to enzyme synthesis costs, we established that optimal E. coli homoethanologenesis was achieved by our best pdc-adhB expression cassette and that the remaining constraints lie in the E. coli metabolic network or inefficient Pdc or AdhB function in E. coli. OptSSeq is a general tool for synthetic biology to tune enzyme levels in any pathway whose optimal function can be linked to cell growth or survival.

Transcription and decay of the lac messenger: role of an intergenic terminator

Prior work has indicated that the polycistronic lacZYA mRNA of Escherichia coli is cleaved during decay at approximately intergenic sites (L. W. Lim and D. Kennell, J. Mol. Biol. 135: 369-390, 1979). In this work, we characterized the products by using probes specific for the different cistrons. This analysis indicated that six lac mRNA species are present in the following order of decreasing abundance: lacZ, -A, -ZYA, -ZY, -YA, and -Y. Very little lacYA and lacY mRNAs were present, whereas in cells induced to steady state, there was 10 times more lacZ than lacZYA mRNA. The lacZ mRNA appeared as a discrete species extending to a site in the lacZ-Y intergenic space (ca. residue 3150). This site is just distal to a potential rho-independent termination sequence. We examined the function of this sequence to determine whether it contributes to the distribution of the mRNAs. Although the termination sequence was shown to function in vitro, when it was recloned into an expression vector, no termination was seen in vivo. Moreover, direct examination of the kinetics of lac messenger synthesis revealed that after initiation, most transcription continued to the end of the operon. We conclude that during normal growth, the operon is transcribed in its entirety and that the individual lac mRNAs are formed by cleavage. These results confirm earlier work implying that the lac operon is transcribed in its entirety but are in conflict with several recent reports suggesting that internal termination occurs. Our findings indicate that the natural polarity of the operon (lacZ is expressed sixfold more strongly than lacA) is based on posttranslational effects and not on polarity of transcription.

Processivity errors of gene expression in Escherichia coli

Not all ribosomes that initiate translation of an mRNA sequence will successfully complete it and produce a full-length protein product. By comparing the amounts of lacZ monomer and lacZ dimer protein expressed from a plasmid in a strictly controlled assay, we calculate a dimer to monomer ratio of 0.76. We interpret this to mean that ribosomes have a 76% chance of completing the synthesis of a beta-galactosidase polypeptide. The remaining 24% of the initiated chains end in processivity accidents. For the wild-type, premature RNA polymerase termination is found to account for roughly one-third of the processivity accidents. For the hyperaccurate SmP mutant, we observe a processivity of 0.28, but the presence of streptomycin improves this to 0.50. Thus, the hyperaccuracy with respect to missense substitutions for this mutant is accompanied by a reduced processivity. Addition of streptomycin increase the first error class and reduces the second one. This finding is relevant to the optimization of ribosome function and the growth performance of ribosome mutants.

Transcription efficiency along the tissue-plasminogen-activator cDNA gene in Escherichia coli

Transcription along the human tissue-plasminogen activator gene (tpa) cloned in Escherichia coli was studied by inserting the 4.5S RNA gene at various locations within tpa, and measuring the accumulation of 4.5S RNA. A six-fold decrease in transcription of 4.5S RNA was observed as the distance from the Ptrc promoter to the 4.5S RNA gene increased. Independent measurements indicated that the quantity of initiations from the Ptrc promoter could not account for the differences observed. Because the 4.5S RNA is stable, the decrease in transcription was assumed to be due to premature transcription-termination within the tpa gene. This polar effect could contribute to poor expression of tpa in E. coli.

Specific endonucleolytic cleavage sites for decay of Escherichia coli mRNA

The polycistronic lac mRNA of Escherichia coli contains three messages. The rate of degradation of the second (lacY) message was observed to be equal to that of the third (lacA), and each decayed twice as fast as did the first (lacZ). Specific 5'- and 3'-ended lacY mRNA molecules could be recovered from cells; most likely, they are generated from endonucleolytic cleavages that are a part of the degradative process. They were observed by S1 nuclease mapping, and the exact 5'- and 3'-end oligonucleotides of many of them were identified by direct sequencing. Almost all of the molecules started with a 5' adenosine that would be preceded by a pyrimidine. The specificity was further restricted by neighboring nucleotides, and analysis of the data suggested that 5'-U-U decreases-A-U- is especially vulnerable. Also, computer analyses predicted the most stable secondary structures of selected segments of the mRNA and suggested that cleavages may only occur in regions of single strandedness. A model of mRNA degradation is proposed based on these observations and earlier ones. There is no unique target on a message for the initial inactivating attack: any region free of ribosomes is vulnerable, but for statistical reasons the initial attack of most molecules is near the ribosome-loading site. With no further ribosome loading, the newly unprotected 5' ends are "chopped off" at one of the next preferred target sites almost as fast as the last ribosomes moves down the mRNA.