Avian osteoblast conditioned media stimulate bone resorption by targeting multinucleating osteoclast precursors

In vitro Models of Bone Remodelling and Associated Disorders

Disruption of bone remodelling by diseases such as osteoporosis results in an imbalance between bone formation by osteoblasts and resorption by osteoclasts. Research into these metabolic bone disorders is primarily performed in vivo; however, in the last decade there has been increased interest in generating in vitro models that can reduce or replace our reliance on animal testing. With recent advances in biomaterials and tissue engineering the feasibility of laboratory-based alternatives is growing; however, to date there are no established in vitro models of bone remodelling. In vivo, remodelling is performed by organised packets of osteoblasts and osteoclasts called bone multicellular units (BMUs). The key determinant of whether osteoclasts form and remodelling occurs is the ratio between RANKL, a cytokine which stimulates osteoclastogenesis, and OPG, its inhibitor. This review initially details the different circumstances, conditions, and factors which have been found to modulate the RANKL:OPG ratio, and fundamental factors to be considered if a robust in vitro model is to be developed. Following this, an examination of what has been achieved thus far in replicating remodelling in vitro using three-dimensional co-cultures is performed, before overviewing how such systems are already being utilised in the study of associated diseases, such as metastatic cancer and dental disorders. Finally, a discussion of the most important considerations to be incorporated going forward is presented. This details the need for the use of cells capable of endogenously producing the required cytokines, application of mechanical stimulation, and the presence of appropriate hormones in order to produce a robust model of bone remodelling.

The "love-hate" relationship between osteoclasts and bone matrix

Osteoclasts are unique cells that destroy the mineralized matrix of the skeleton. There is a "love-hate" relationship between the osteoclasts and the bone matrix, whereby the osteoclast is stimulated by the contact with the matrix but, at the same time, it disrupts the matrix, which, in turn, counteracts this disruption by some of its components. The balance between these concerted events brings about bone resorption to be controlled and to contribute to bone tissue integrity and skeletal health. The matrix components released by osteoclasts are also involved in the local regulation of other bone cells and in the systemic control of organismal homeostasis. Disruption of this regulatory loop causes bone diseases, which may end up with either reduced or increased bone mass, often associated with poor bone quality. Expanding the knowledge on osteoclast-to-matrix interaction could help to counteract these diseases and improve the human bone health. In this article, we will present evidence of the physical, molecular and regulatory relationships between the osteoclasts and the mineralized matrix, discussing the underlying mechanisms as well as their pathologic alterations and potential targeting.

Development of a chimaeric receptor approach to study signalling by tumour necrosis factor receptor family members

Members of the tumour necrosis factor receptor family play a pivotal role in cell differentiation, function and apoptosis. However, signalling by many members of the family remains to be elucidated. In the present study, we developed a chimaeric receptor approach for studying signalling by receptors belonging to this family. The chimaeric receptor comprises the human Fas external domain linked to the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains of a tumour necrosis factor receptor family member of interest. When the chimaera is expressed in mouse cells, the clustering of the chimaera induced by a human Fas-activating antibody activates the intracellular domain of the chimaera without affecting its endogenous counterpart. Since the antibody recognizes only human Fas, this approach can be used to dissect signalling by any tumour necrosis factor family member using any type of mouse cell including those endogenously expressing Fas. Moreover, we also showed that the chimaeric receptor approach can be used to study signalling at any stage of cell differentiation or function.

Functional identification of three receptor activator of NF-kappa B cytoplasmic motifs mediating osteoclast differentiation and function

Receptor activator of NF-kappa B ligand (RANKL) and its receptor activator of NF-kappa B (RANK) play pivotal roles in osteoclast differentiation and function. However, the structural determinants of the RANK that mediate osteoclast formation and function have not been definitively identified. To address this issue, we developed a chimeric receptor approach that permits a structure/function study of the RANK cytoplasmic domain in osteoclasts. Using this approach, we examined the role of six RANK putative tumor necrosis factor receptor-associated factor-binding motifs (PTM) (PTM1, ILLMT-REE(286-293); PTM2, PSQPS(349-353); PTM3, PFQEP(369-373); PTM4, VYVSQTSQE(537-545); PTM5, PVQEET(559-564); and PTM6, PVQEQG(604-609)) in osteoclast formation and function. Our data revealed that the RANK cytoplasmic domain possesses three functional motifs (PFQEP(369-373), PVQEET(559-564), and PVQEQG(604-609)) capable of mediating osteoclast formation and function. Moreover, we demonstrated that these motifs play distinct roles in activating intracellular signaling. PFQEP(369-373) initiates NF-kappa B, c-Jun N-terminal kinase, extracellular signal-regulated kinase, and p38 signaling pathways and PVQEET(559-564) activates NF-kappa B and p38 pathways in osteoclasts, whereas PVQEQG(604-609) is only capable of activating NF-kappa B pathway. Significantly, the revelation of these functional RANK cytoplasmic motifs has not only laid a foundation for further delineating RANK signaling pathways in osteoclasts, but, more importantly, these RANK motifs themselves represent potential therapeutic targets for bone disorders such as osteoporosis.

A Glanzmann's mutation in beta 3 integrin specifically impairs osteoclast function

Osteoclastic bone resorption requires cell-matrix contact, an event mediated by the alpha v beta 3 integrin. The structural components of the integrin that mediate osteoclast function are, however, not in hand. To address this issue, we generated mice lacking the beta 3 integrin gene, which have dysfunctional osteoclasts. Here, we show the full rescue of beta 3(-/-) osteoclast function following expression of a full-length beta 3 integrin. In contrast, truncated beta 3, lacking a cytoplasmic domain (h beta 3c), is completely ineffective in restoring function to beta 3(-/-) osteoclasts. To identify the components of the beta 3 cytoplasmic domain regulating osteoclast function, we generated six point mutants known, in other circumstances, to mediate beta integrin signaling. Of the six, only the S(752)P substitution, which also characterizes a form of the human bleeding disorder Glanzmann's thrombasthenia, fails to rescue beta 3(-/-) osteoclasts or restore ligand-activated signaling in the form of c-src activation. Interestingly, the double mutation Y(747)F/Y(759)F, which disrupts platelet function, does not affect the osteoclast. Thus similarities and distinctions exist in the mechanisms by which the beta 3 integrin regulates platelets and osteoclasts.

Mice lacking beta3 integrins are osteosclerotic because of dysfunctional osteoclasts

Osteoclasts express the alphavbeta3 integrin, an adhesion receptor that has been implicated in bone resorption and that is therefore a potential therapeutic target. To assess the role of this heterodimer in skeletal development in vivo, we engineered mice in which the gene for the beta3 integrin subunit was deleted. Bone marrow macrophages derived from these mutants differentiate in vitro into numerous osteoclasts, thus establishing that alphavbeta3 is not necessary for osteoclast recruitment. Furthermore, the closely related integrin, alphavbeta5, does not substitute for alphavbeta3 during cytokine stimulation or authentic osteoclastogenesis. beta3 knockout mice, but not their heterozygous littermates, develop histologically and radiographically evident osteosclerosis with age. Despite their increased bone mass, beta3-null mice contain 3.5-fold more osteoclasts than do heterozygotes. These mutant osteoclasts are, however, dysfunctional, as evidenced by their reduced ability to resorb whale dentin in vitro and the significant hypocalcemia seen in the knockout mice. The resorptive defect in beta3-deficient osteoclasts may reflect absence of matrix-derived intracellular signals, since their cytoskeleton is distinctly abnormal and they fail to spread in vitro, to form actin rings ex vivo, or to form normal ruffled membranes in vivo. Thus, although it is not required for osteoclastogenesis, the integrin alphavbeta3 is essential for normal osteoclast function.

Regulation of osteoclast activity

Osteoclasts are the primary cell type responsible for bone resorption. This paper reviews many of the known regulators of osteoclast activity, including hormones, cytokines, ions, and arachidonic acid metabolites. Most of the hormones and cytokines that inhibit osteoclast activity act directly on the osteoclasts. In contrast, most of the hormones and cytokines that stimulate osteoclast activity act indirectly through osteoblasts. Particularly interesting in this regard are agents that directly inhibit activity of highly purified osteoclasts yet stimulate activity of osteoclasts that are co-cultured with osteoblasts. Recent studies have demonstrated that the primary mechanism by which bone resorptive agents stimulate osteoclast activity indirectly is likely to be up-regulation of production of osteoclast differentiation factor/osteoprotegerin ligand (ODF/OPGL) by the osteoblasts. In addition to discussing regulators of osteoclast activity per se, this paper also reviews the role of osteoclast apoptosis to limit the extent of bone resorption.

Osteoclast differentiation requires ascorbic acid

Osteoclast differentiation assays are usually conducted in alpha minimal essential medium (alpha-MEM). We reasoned that determining which components of this media are critical for osteoclast differentiation might provide insight into the mechanisms that regulate osteoclast differentiation. This study demonstrates that ascorbic acid is the crucial component of alpha-MEM that stimulates differentiation of murine osteoclasts in cocultures with murine mesenchymal support cells. Thus, supplementation with ascorbic acid allows osteoclast differentiation to occur in basal MEM media as well as in RPMI-1640 and basal media Eagle (BME) media. The conclusion that osteoclast differentiation is stimulated by ascorbic acid was obtained whether osteoclast differentiation was induced by 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 or parathyroid hormone, whether ST2 or CIMC-2 cells were used as mesenchymal support cells, and whether osteoclast precursors were obtained from spleen or bone marrow. Time course studies revealed that although ascorbic acid only modestly increases the rate at which osteoclast precursors begin to express tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase, it strongly increases the rate at which precursors fuse into mature, multinucleated cells. Moreover, ascorbic acid strongly increases the life span of both osteoclasts and their precursors. The increases in precursor formation, fusion, and life span induced by ascorbic acid are together responsible for the stimulation of osteoclast differentiation by ascorbic acid. Given the known effects of ascorbic acid on differentiation of mesenchymal cells, it may stimulate osteoclast differentiation indirectly by regulating the differentiation state of the mesenchymal cells that support osteoclast differentiation.

Apoptosis is coordinately regulated with osteoblast formation during bone healing

The ultimate fate of the expanded pool of osteoblasts formed following a typical bone injury is unclear. Since necrosis has not been described in the latter stages of bone healing, there must be some other mechanism by which obsolete osteoblasts are cleared from an injury site. We therefore evaluated the possibility that their removal is pre-programmed, by investigating the occurrence of apoptosis in rats that received a standardized bone injury. Histological evidence identical to that found in tissues known to exhibit apoptosis was obtained, thereby showing that programmed cell death was a normal concomitant of fracture healing. The concentration of apoptotic bodies reached its maximum after the differentiative response had peaked, suggesting that the two processes were coordinated. The same result was found in a second group of rats that received the same bone injury plus a simultaneous standardized soft-tissue injury. The combined injuries resulted in more osteoblasts and more apoptotic bodies, but an identical temporal relationship between the peak responses in the two parameters. The results suggested that osteoblasts were removed from the injury site via apoptosis, and that the process was coordinately regulated with differentiation. Since the number of apoptotic bodies per osteoblast varied during healing, it is likely that apoptosis was associated with healing and not merely with osteoblast concentration.

Functional and structural interactions between osteoblastic and preosteoclastic cells in vitro

Osteoblasts are involved in the bone resorption process by regulating osteoclast maturation and activity. In order to elucidate the mechanisms underlying osteoblast/preosteoclast cell interactions, we developed an in vitro model of co-cultured human clonal cell lines of osteoclast precursors (FLG 29.1) and osteoblastic cells (Saos-2), and evaluated the migratory, adhesive, cytochemical, morphological, and biochemical properties of the co-cultured cells. In Boyden chemotactic chambers, FLG 29.1 cells exhibited a marked migratory response toward the Saos-2 cells. Moreover, they preferentially adhered to the osteoblastic monolayer. Direct co-culture of the two cell types induced: (1) positive staining for tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase in FLG 29.1 cells; (2) a decrease of the alkaline phosphatase activity expressed by Saos-2 cells; (3) the appearance of typical ultrastructural features of mature osteoclasts in FLG 29.1 cells; (4) the release into the culture medium of granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor. The addition of parathyroid hormone to the co-culture further potentiated the differentiation of the preosteoclasts, the cells tending to fuse into large multinucleated elements. These in vitro interactions between osteoblasts and osteoclast precursors offer a new model for studying the mechanisms that control osteoclastogenesis in bone tissue.

Bone resorption at the femoral neck is dependent on local factors in nonosteoporotic late postmenopausal women: an in vitro-in vivo study

Local mediators of bone resorption may be involved in bone loss in recently postmenopausal women and in osteoporosis. In the present study, we investigated the production of cytokines and the formation of osteoclast-like cells in marrow cultures from 16 late postmenopausal nonosteoporotic women (mean age: 66 +/- 8 years; time after menopause: 15 +/- 8 years) undergoing hip replacement for arthrosis. Marrow adherent mononuclear cells (MMNC) isolated from femoral diaphysis marrow were cultured for 10 days in the absence or in the presence of 1,25(OH)2D3. In vivo bone resorption was concomitantly assessed by histomorphometry on femoral neck bone sections. The number of TRAP+ multinucleated cells obtained after 10 days in MMNC cultured in the presence of 1,25(OH)2D3 correlated with the number of osteoclasts measured on the bone femoral neck biopsies (r = 0.65, p < 0.01), suggesting that the formation of multinucleated cells in vitro could reflect the osteoclast differentiation in vivo. Furthermore, the number of osteoclasts was related to the eroded volume and the trabecular separation of the femoral neck bone biopsies. Finally, the release of interleukin-1 (IL-1), IL-6, and TNF-alpha by cultures of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and MMNC was measured by radioimmunoassay. The cytokine levels of basal and 1,25(OH)2D3-treated MMNC decreased from days 2 to 5 and then reached a plateau to day 10. The number of TRAP+ multinucleated cells obtained after 10 days in MMNC cultures correlated with the basal IL-6 release in the same cultures determined at day 2 (r = 0.55, p < 0.01).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Osteoclast 121F antigen expression during osteoblast conditioned medium induction of osteoclast-like cells in vitro: relationship to calcitonin responsiveness, tartrate resistant acid phosphatase levels, and bone resorptive activity

Osteoclast differentiation from hematopoietic precursors into multinucleated cells uniquely capable of removing the organic and inorganic components of bone matrix occurs in multistep process, during which osteoclasts acquire the specialized characteristics necessary for bone resorptive activity and physiological regulation. Among those traits is a novel plasma membrane glycoprotein, reactive with the anti-osteoclast monoclonal antibody 121F, which is expressed during the course of osteoclast differentiation, shares structural and functional homologies with Mn2+/Fe2+ superoxide dismutase, and has been hypothesized to protect the osteoclast from the damaging effects of superoxide radicals generated during active bone resorption. We have reported previously that the expression of this membrane antigen is induced on multinucleated giant cells when the prefusion marrow mononuclear cells are cultured in conditioned medium from avian calvaria. The studies reported here were designed to investigate the relationship between expression of the 121F antibody-reactive osteoclast membrane antigen and tartrate resistant acid phosphatase levels, bone resorptive activity, calcitonin responsiveness, and ultrastructural features of avian bone marrow-derived multinucleated giant cells formed either in the presence or absence of diffusible osteoblast secreted factors. Parallel analyses of in vivo formed osteoclasts isolated from the same animals were performed for direct comparisons. In this report we demonstrate: (1) that the 121F monoclonal antibody-reactive osteoclast membrane antigen is stably induced in giant cells by soluble osteoblast-derived factors in a species nonrestricted but concentration- and temporal-dependent manner; (2) that osteoblast-mediated antigen induction is reflected in both increased numbers of cells and elevated expression of individual cells that are reactive with the 121F antibody, as determined by ELISA and histomorphometry; (3) that osteoblast conditioned medium, in addition to inducing this antigen in bone marrow cells, also elevates other defining osteoclast characteristics in these avian giant cells including their TRAP activity, cell retraction from the bone surface in response to calcitonin, bone resorptive function, and expression of a series of additional osteoclast antigenic markers; and (4) that secreted osteoblast products alone do not raise the levels of these traits for in vitro formed marrow giant cells to the extent associated with in vivo formed osteoclasts. Therefore, osteoblast soluble factors alone appear unable to promote the full differentiation of bone marrow cells in vitro into mature bone-resorbing osteoclasts.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Influence of osteoclasts and osteoclast-like cells on osteoblast alkaline phosphatase activity and collagen synthesis

Osteoblasts have been shown to modulate osteoclast activity, but the reverse process has not been investigated. In the current study conditioned medium (CM) was collected from osteoclasts and osteoclast-like cells and its effects on osteoblast alkaline phosphatase (ALPase) activity and collagen synthesis ([3H]proline hydroxylation) were determined. In primary chick osteoblasts, cultured chick embryo frontal bones, and UMR-106-01 cells, collagen synthesis and ALPase activity, but not [3H]thymidine incorporation, were inhibited by CM from chick marrow-derived giant cells, which possess some of the phenotypic characteristics of osteoclasts. However, collagen synthesis in chick embryo fibroblasts was not affected by giant cell CM. CM collected from cultures of chicken osteoclasts and human osteoclastoma cells and marrow-derived giant cells inhibited collagen synthesis in UMR-106-01 cells, but the effects of ALPase activity varied with the cell type. In contrast, mononuclear cell and fibroblast CM did not alter collagen synthesis. Initial characterization studies demonstrate that the inhibitor is a heat-labile factor with a molecular weight greater than 3500. In summary, authentic osteoclasts, tumor osteoclast-like cells, and chicken and human multinucleated giant cells produce a soluble factor that alters osteoblast collagen synthesis, suggesting that osteoclasts play a role in the modulation of osteoblast activity.