Specific inhibition of natural killer (NK) activity against different alloantigens

The early days of NK cells: an example of how a phenomenon led to detection of a novel immune receptor system - lessons from a rat model

In this review, I summarize some of the early research on NK cell biology and function that led to the discovery of a totally new receptor system for polymorphic MHC class I molecules. That NK cells both could recognize and kill tumor cells but also normal hematopoietic cells through expression of MHC class I molecules found a unifying explanation in the “missing self” hypothesis. This initiated a whole new area of leukocyte receptor research. The common underlying mechanism was that NK cells expressed receptors that were inhibited by recognition of unmodified “self” MHC-I molecules. This could explain both the killing of tumor cells with poor expression of MHC-I molecules and hybrid resistance, i.e., that F1 hybrid mice sometimes could reject parental bone marrow cells. However, a contrasting phenomenon termed allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity in rats gave strong evidence that some of these receptors were activated rather than inhibited by recognition of polymorphic MHC-I. This was soon followed by molecular identification of both inhibitory and stimulatory Ly49 receptors in mice and rats and killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors in humans that could be either inhibited or activated when recognizing their cognate MHC-I ligand. Since most of these receptors now have been molecularly characterized, their ligands and the intracellular pathways leading to activation or inhibition identified, we still lack a more complete understanding of how the repertoire of activating and inhibitory receptors is formed and how interactions between these receptors for MHC-I molecules on a single NK cell are integrated to generate a productive immune response. Although several NK receptor systems have been characterized that recognize MHC-I or MHC-like molecules, I here concentrate on the repertoires of NK receptors encoded by the natural killer cell gene complex and designed to recognize polymorphic MHC-I molecules in rodents, i.e., Ly49 (KLRA) receptors.

Two structurally related rat Ly49 receptors with opposing functions (Ly49 stimulatory receptor 5 and Ly49 inhibitory receptor 5) recognize nonclassical MHC class Ib-encoded target ligands

The Ly49 family of lectin-like receptors in rodents includes both stimulatory and inhibitory members. Although NK alloreactivity in mice is regulated primarily by inhibitory Ly49 receptors, in rats activating Ly49 receptors are equally important. Previous studies have suggested that activating rat Ly49 receptors are triggered by polymorphic ligands encoded within the nonclassical class Ib region of the rat MHC, RT1-CE/N/M, while inhibitory Ly49 receptors bind to widely expressed classical class Ia molecules encoded from the RT1-A region. To further investigate rat Ly49-mediated regulation of NK alloreactivity, we report in this study the identification and characterization of two novel paired Ly49 receptors that we have termed Ly49 inhibitory receptor 5 (Ly49i5) and Ly49 stimulatory receptor 5 (Ly49s5). Using a new mAb (mAb Fly5), we showed that Ly49i5 is an inhibitory receptor that recognizes ligands encoded within the class Ib region of the u and l haplotypes, while the structurally related Ly49s5 is an activating receptor that recognizes class Ib ligands of the u haplotype. Ly49s5 is functionally expressed in the high NK-alloresponder PVG strain, but not in the low alloresponder BN strain, in which it is a pseudogene. Ly49s5 is hence not responsible for the striking anti-u NK alloresponse previously described in BN rats (haplotype n), which results from repeated alloimmunizations with u haplotype cells. The present studies support the notion of a complex regulation of rat NK alloreactivity by activating and inhibitory Ly49 members, which may be highly homologous in the extracellular region and bind similar class Ib-encoded target ligands.

The genes and gene organization of the Ly49 region of the rat natural killer cell gene complex

We here report the cDNA sequences of 11 new rat Ly49 genes with full and three with incomplete open reading frames. Although obtained from different inbred rat strains, these as well as six previously published cDNA represent non-allelic genes matching different loci in the Brown Norway (BN) rat genome, which is predicted to contain 34 Ly49 loci distributed over the distal part of the NK cell gene complex. Some of the cloned genes appear to be mutated to non-function in the BN genome, which harbors additional genes with full open reading frames, suggesting at least 26 non-allelic functional Ly49 genes in the rat. Of the encoded receptors, 13 are predicted to be inhibitory, eight to be activating, whereas five may be both ('bifunctional'). Phylogenetic analysis bears evidence of a highly dynamic genetic region, in which only the most distally localized Ly49 gene has a clear-cut mouse ortholog. In phylograms, the majority of the genes cluster into three subgroups with the genes mapping together, defining three chromosomal regions that seem to have undergone recent expansions. When comparing the lectin-like domains, the receptors form smaller subgroups, most containing at least one inhibitory and one activating or 'bifunctional' receptor, where close sequence similarities suggest recent homogenization events.

Positive and negative MHC class I recognition by rat NK cells

The prompt rejection of transplanted allogeneic lymphocytes by rat NK cells in non-sensitized recipients (allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity or ALC) is determined by MHC genes as well as by genes located in the NK complex. The same genetic control is found when NK alloreactivity is measured by an in vitro assay, and we have employed this assay to delineate the specificity of NK cells for the MHC. The MHC of the rat, RT1, contains class I genes situated on either side of the class II/class III region. The majority of these class I genes are located in the RT1.C region and expressed class I products usually behave as non-classical (class Ib) molecules. They do not serve as restriction elements for the vast majority of conventional alpha/beta T-cells, in contrast to those class I molecules encoded by one or more loci in the classical (class Ia) region, RT1.A. However, NK cells appear to recognize the products of either class I region. Immunogenetic studies suggest that NK cells are inhibited by RT1. A molecules, whereas RT1.C region molecules may have a dual role in regulating NK cytolytic activity, i.e. they either inhibit or activate natural killing. Based on these premises, a model is proposed in which identification of a target as self or non-self depends on different receptors for class I in single NK cells, interpreting coincident positive and negative signals from the various target class I molecules. The putative role of peptides presented by class I, the biological implications, and the evolution of the NK receptors and their ligands are discussed.

An autosomal dominant locus, Nka, mapping to the Ly-49 region of a rat natural killer (NK) gene complex, controls NK cell lysis of allogeneic lymphocytes

Natural Killer (NK) cells can recognize and kill MHC-incompatible normal bone marrow-derived cells. Presently characterized MHC-binding receptors on NK cells, including the Ly-49 family in the mouse, transmit inhibitory signals upon binding to cognate class I MHC ligands. Here we study in vivo NK-mediated lysis of normal allogeneic lymphocytes in crosses between alloreactivity-competent PVG rats and alloreactivity-deficient DA rats. NK cells from both strains are able to lyse standard tumor targets. We identify an autosomal dominant locus, Nka, that controls NK-mediated alloreactivity. Individuals carrying the dominant PVG allele in single dose were fully competent in eliminating allogeneic target cells, suggesting that Nka encodes or regulates a gene product inducing or activating alloreactivity. By linkage analysis and pulsed field gel electrophoresis, a natural killer gene complex (NKC) on rat chromosome 4 is described that contains the rat NKR-P1 and Ly-49 multigene families plus a rat NKG2D homologue. Nka maps within the NKC, together with the most telomeric Ly-49 family members, but separate from NKG2D and the NKR-P1 family. The Nka-encoded response, moreover, correlates with the expression of transcripts for Ly-49 receptors in NK cell populations, as Northern blot analysis demonstrated low expression of Ly-49 genes in DA NK cells, in contrast to high expression in alloreactivity-competent PVG, (DA X PVG)F1, and PVG.1AVI NK cells. The low Ly-49 expression in DA is not induced by MHC haplotype, as demonstrated by high expression of Ly-49 in the DA MHC-congenic PVG.1AVI strain. Finally, we have cloned and characterized the first four members of the rat Ly-49 gene family. Their cytoplasmic domains demonstrate substantial heterogeneity, consistent with the hypothesis that different Ly-49 family members may subserve different signaling functions.

Neonatally tolerant rats actively eliminate donor-specific lymphocytes despite persistent chimerism

Rats from the allotype-marked PVG-RT7b and PVG-RT1u-RT7b strains were injected at birth with semi-allogenic F1 bone marrow (BM) cells from athymic nude rats (PVG-rnu/rnu x PVG-RT1u-rnu/rnu) to induce neonatal tolerance. As adults, 97% of the animals accepted donor-specific allogeneic skin grafts and a majority (65%) of rats were chimeric, expressing the major histocompatibility complex class I and allotype marker of the donor strain. Similar results were obtained when PVG-RT1u-RT7b rats were injected at birth with fully allogeneic PVG-rnu/rnu nude BM cells: as adults, 94% accepted donor-specific skin allografts and 76% of recipients were chimeric. Donor derived CD4 T cells, CD8 T cells and B cells were found in low numbers (less than 2%) in peripheral blood of rats made tolerant by F1 BM cells. A large proportion of T cells bore the phenotype of recent thymic emigrants, suggesting that they were newly produced. All the evidence was consistent with clonal deletion tolerance, induced centrally within the thymus. The thymus was chimeric and thymocytes failed to respond in vitro to alloantigens of the donor-specific haplotype; donor-specific skin allografts survived indefinitely on athymic nude recipients reconstituted with CD4+CD8- thymocytes or peripheral CD4 T cells from tolerant animals. The chimeric state was interesting, since the PVG and PVG-RT1u rat strains contain a natural killer (NK) cell system that rapidly eliminates (within 24 h) intravenously injected allogeneic or semi-allogeneic lymphocytes--a phenomenon known as allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity or ALC. When neonatal tolerant rats were tested, the ALC index (a measure of cell killing) was unchanged in nonchimeric tolerant rats and significantly altered (reduced killing), but not abolished in chimeric animals. Hence, the injection of allogeneic BM cells which induced specific tolerance in the T cell population failed to tolerize the NK cell system, allowing the constant killing of newly produced donor-derived lymphocytes and putting at risk the very survival of the allogenic BM cells. This has interesting implications for clinical transplantation.

Control of rat natural killer cell-mediated allorecognition by a major histocompatibility complex region encoding nonclassical class I antigens

The ability of natural killer (NK) cells to eliminate normal allogeneic hemic cells is well established in several species including mice, rats, and humans. The controlling elements for NK susceptibility in these species map to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), but in contrast to findings in mice and humans, the mode of inheritance is not always recessive in rats. This finding is not easily explained by the missing self and hemopoietic histocompatibility (Hh) models for NK recognition, and has led to the idea that certain alloantigens may trigger NK cell reactivity. In our in vitro system for assessing rat NK alloreactivity, we have employed target and inhibitor cells from a large panel of MHC congenic, intra-MHC recombinant and MHC mutant rat strains, as well as appropriate F1 hybrids between them, and we show the following: (a) The nonclassical class I (RT1.C) region was most important in determining the susceptibility of target cells to alloreactive NK cells in vitro. Lymphocyte susceptibility to lysis in vivo also mapped to the C region, which supports the concept that the in vivo and in vitro alloreactivity assays reflect the same recognition process. (b) Four different RT1-controlled NK allospecificities (represented by the u, l, a, and n haplotypes) could be discerned when we used polyclonal NK cells from the PVG (RT1c) strain as effector cells. Three of the target specificities recognized were controlled mainly by the RT1.C region. (c) The expression of RT1.C region-controlled parental strain NK allodeterminants could be demonstrated in F1 hybrids heterozygous for the C region alone and were therefore inherited nonrecessively. (d) Loss of an RT1.C region-controlled NK allospecificity could be shown with the MHC mutant LEW.1LM1 rat strain characterized by a genomic deletion of about 100 kb of the C region. Taken together, these observations have demonstrated a major importance of the nonclassical class I region, i.e., RT1.C, in controlling rat NK allorecognition, and have thereby assigned a hitherto undescribed immunological property to this region. Furthermore, some of the present data are consistent with the existence of polymorphic NK-triggering alloantigens that are coded for by the RT1.C region.

Allospecific recognition of hemic cells in vitro by natural killer cells from athymic rats: evidence that allodeterminants coded for by single major histocompatibility complex haplotypes are recognized

We have previously shown that large granular lymphocyte (LGL)-enriched cell populations have the capacity to spontaneously recognize and kill allogeneic small lymphocytes and bone marrow cells (BMC) in vitro in certain strain combinations of rats. Here, we have studied the alloreactivity of natural killer (NK) cells from PVG nude (RT1c) rats against a panel of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) incompatible hemic cells. Both lymphocytes and BMC from the AO (RT1u), DA (RT1a), BN (RT1n) as well as the MHC-congenic PVG-RT1u (RT1u) rat strains were efficiently killed in vitro, whereas cells from syngeneic PVG rats were spared. The structures recognized on lymphocytes and BMC were probably similar since the two cell populations inhibited each other in cross-competition experiments. A number of features aligned the alloreactive effector cells with NK cells and not T cells. (a) Only about 5% of the effector cells from nude spleens expressed the T cell antigens CD3, CD5 or T cell receptor (TcR) alpha/beta whereas greater than 50% of the cells expressed markers present on NK cells (CD2, CD8, OX52 and the rat NK cell-specific marker NKR-P1 recognized by the monoclonal antibody 3.2.3). (b) The alloreactive cells were granular since pretreatment of nude spleen cells with the lysosomotropic agent L-leucine methyl ester which eliminated LGL, simultaneously abolished the cytolysis of both allogeneic lymphocytes and YAC-1 tumor cells. (c) Nude spleen cells stimulated with human recombinant interleukin 2 for 1 week in vitro generated large granular proliferating cells which were CD3-, CD5-, TcR alpha/beta-, but greater than 95% 3.2.3+. These cells efficiently killed allogeneic hemic cells from the same rat strains as did freshly isolated effector cells. (d) The cytolysis of allogeneic hemic cells could effectively be inhibited with unlabelled NK-sensitive (YAC-1 and K-562), but not NK-resistant (Roser leukemia) tumor cells. Cross-competition studies showed that PVG nude NK cells discriminated between AO, BN and DA BMC, suggesting that different alloantigens were positively recognized by subsets of NK cells. The mode of inheritance of the allodeterminant specifically recognized on AO BMC was investigated in crosses and backcrosses between AO and BN or DA rats. A gene dosage effect was observed in that this determinant was expressed at a slightly reduced level in F1 hybrids.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cellular requirements for renal allograft rejection in the athymic nude rat

This study has examined the ability of adoptively transferred CD4+ and CD8+ T cells to mediate rejection of a fully allogeneic DA renal graft in the PVG nude rat. Transfer, at the time of transplantation, of naive CD4+ T cells caused rapid graft rejection and primed CD4+ cells were several times more potent. In contrast, naive or specifically sensitized CD8+ cells were entirely ineffective at mediating renal allograft rejection. Whereas nonrejecting grafts showed only a mild cellular infiltrate, rejecting grafts in CD4+ reconstituted animals showed a substantial infiltrate and many of the infiltrating cells had a phenotype (MRC OX8+, MRC OX19-), consistent with NK cells. Experiments using a mAb (HIS 41) against an allotypic determinant of the leukocyte common antigen confirmed that the majority (greater than 80%) of the cellular infiltrate in rejecting grafts derived from the host rather than from the CD4+ inoculum. Infiltrating mononuclear cells, obtained from rejecting allografts 7 d after transplantation in CD4+-injected PVG nude hosts, showed high levels of in vitro cytotoxicity against not only kidney donor strain Con A blasts but also third-party allogeneic Con A blasts, as well as against both NK and LAK susceptible targets. When splenocytes from nontransplanted nude PVG rats were tested in vitro they also demonstrated high levels of lytic activity against both NK and LAK susceptible targets as well as allogeneic Con A blasts, which were not susceptible to lysis by spleen cells from euthymic rats. These findings suggest that injected CD4+ cells may cause renal allograft rejection by the recruitment of extrathymically derived, widely alloreactive cells into the kidney in this model of graft rejection.