Antigen-presenting cells do not discriminate between self and nonself

Immune balance: the development of the idea and its applications

It has long been taken for granted that the immune system's capacity to protect an individual from infection and disease depends on the power of the system to distinguish between self and nonself. However, accumulating data have undermined this fundamental concept. Evidence against the self/nonself discrimination model left researchers in need of a new overarching framework able to capture the immune system's reactivity. Here, I highlight that along with the self/nonself model, another powerful representation of the immune system's reactivity has been developed in the twentieth century immunology. According to this alternative view, the immune system is not a killer of nonself strangers but a peace-maker helping to establish harmony with the environment. The balance view of the system has never become part of the dominant paradigm. However, it is gaining more and more currency as new research develops. Advances in mucosal immunology confirm that instead of distinguishing between self and foreign the immune system reacts to microbial, chemical and self-induced alterations to produce responses that counterbalance effects of these changes.

Parameter estimation and sensitivity analysis in an agent-based model of Leishmania major infection

Computer models of disease take a systems biology approach toward understanding host-pathogen interactions. In particular, data driven computer model calibration is the basis for inference of immunological and pathogen parameters, assessment of model validity, and comparison between alternative models of immune or pathogen behavior. In this paper we describe the calibration and analysis of an agent-based model of Leishmania major infection. A model of macrophage loss following uptake of necrotic tissue is proposed to explain macrophage depletion following peak infection. Using Gaussian processes to approximate the computer code, we perform a sensitivity analysis to identify important parameters and to characterize their influence on the simulated infection. The analysis indicates that increasing growth rate can favor or suppress pathogen loads, depending on the infection stage and the pathogen's ability to avoid detection. Subsequent calibration of the model against previously published biological observations suggests that L. major has a relatively slow growth rate and can replicate for an extended period of time before damaging the host cell.

The study of self-tolerance using murine haemoglobin as a model self antigen

T cell tolerance to self proteins involves both thymic and peripheral mechanisms. We have used allotypic differences in murine haemoglobin (Hb) to study the development of tolerance to the abundantly expressed self-protein. In Hb beta s/H-2k mice, the response to Hb beta d is directed against Hb beta d (64-76) presented by I-Ek molecules. Using T cell hybridomas and clones specific for this epitope, we have demonstrated that Hb(64-76)/I-Ek complexes and present on antigen-presenting cells in all lymphoid organs including dendritic cells, B cells and macrophages. In the thymus, the presence of these complexes results in negative selection of transgenic T cells with high levels of Hb(64-76)/I-Ek-specific receptor. However, cells with intermediate levels of specific receptor escape negative selection and can be found in the periphery. Under normal circumstances these cells remain tolerant, but can be activated by mechanisms which increase the number of Hb(64-76)/I-Ek complexes.

Processing and presentation of idiotypes to MHC-restricted T cells

Among the self antigens, immunoglobulins, and in particular idiotypes, are of special interest because of their extreme sequence heterogeneity and their postulated involvement in regulatory interactions in the immune system. We have therefore studied antigen processing and presentation of variable region peptides, processed idiotypes, to MHC class II molecule-restricted T cells. The immunoglobulin used has been the lambda 2(315) light chain produced by the BALB/c MOPC 315 plasmacytoma (alpha, lambda 2). The minimum length of a stimulatory synthetic idiotypic peptide comprises residues 91-101 of lambda 2(315) and is presented by the I-E(d) molecule to CD4+ T cells. T cell clones with specificity for the 91-101(lambda 2(315))/I-E(d) complex utilize a limited TCR repertoire and are of both Th1 and Th2 type. For presentation, extracellular lambda 2(315) requires endocytosis and processing, as previously described for conventional exogenous antigens. In addition, a B lymphoma cell can process and present its own endogenous lambda 2(315). This was shown by transfecting manipulated lambda 2(315) gene variants into B lymphoma cells, followed by evaluation of the APC function of the transfectants. These studies demonstrated that surface expression or secretion of lambda 2(315) is not necessary for presentation and suggested that the endoplasmic reticulum may be a processing compartment. To extend our findings to naive Id+ B cells and anti-Id T cells, we have generated lambda 2(315)-transgenic as well as TCR-transgenic mice. A model is presented for a T-B cell interaction based on presentation of processed idiotypes.

Tolerance to self and the processing and presentation of self antigens

Antigen processing and presentation is critical to the generation and maintenance of self tolerance. The hemoglobin system has provided important data on self antigen processing and presentation in vivo. Hemoglobin/Ia complexes were detectable in the thymus before the time of positive and negative selection. In addition, thymic epithelial cells were shown to lack the costimulatory factors necessary to trigger T cell clone proliferation. We have extended these findings to the renal proximal tubule. This class II MHC-expressing epithelial cell was demonstrated to process and present foreign as well as self antigens to T cell hybridomas. Current studies are examining whether this epithelial cell possesses the costimulatory factors required to fully stimulate T cell clones, or whether the proximal tubule may play an important role in the maintenance of self tolerance. In addition we describe the exciting model of murine autoimmune myocarditis. We have demonstrated that this is a T cell mediated disease and believe that cardiac antigen presenting cells constitutively process and present the inciting self antigen, myosin. These studies may provide important insights into autoimmunity and self tolerance.

Expression of myosin-class II major histocompatibility complexes in the normal myocardium occurs before induction of autoimmune myocarditis

Determining how an autoimmune response is initiated is essential to understanding the mechanisms of autoimmunity. Self-reactive T cells, self-protein, and a failure of tolerance to that self-protein are all involved in the pathogenesis of autoimmune disease; yet it is not clear how self-reactive T cells find the target self-protein to initiate an autoimmune response. Although a variety of self-proteins have been shown to be presented on both class I and class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules, the relationship of these self-proteins to autoimmune disease has not been established. To explore this further, we generated a T-cell hybridoma that recognizes mouse cardiac myosin, the self-protein that induces murine autoimmune myocarditis. Using this hybridoma as a probe to detect myosin-class II MHC complexes, we isolated a class II MHC+/CD45+ residential antigen-presenting cell (APC) population directly from the hearts of normal mice and looked for evidence of endogenous processing of cardiac myosin by these APC. In this report we show that myosin-class II MHC complexes are found on residential APC in the normal mouse heart. Induction of autoimmune myocarditis increased the expression of myosin-class II MHC in the heart and enhanced their APC functions. This result is a direct demonstration that epitopes of a self-antigen involved in initiating an autoimmune disease are endogenously processed and presented within the target organ.

Tolerance of self induced in thymus organ culture

F liver protein occurs in serum at low concentration, and therefore induces tolerance of self only in T cells. T cells which mature in cultured thymus lobes in the absence of this protein become reactive towards it but can be prevented from doing so by exposure to the protein while in culture. The threshold of tolerance induction for this soluble antigen is estimated in this way at approximately 1 microgram/ml, which is slightly less than the threshold of response of primed T cells in a proliferation assay. Freshly isolated thymocytes do not display reactivity to self-F protein, indicating that T cells normally become tolerant while still within the thymus.

The identification and cloning of the murine genes encoding the liver specific F alloantigens

The liver specific F alloantigen is a highly conserved abundant protein found in hepatic cytoplasm; smaller amounts are detected in renal tubule cells and the perikaryon cells of the central nervous system. Although the biological function of the F alloantigen is unknown, the immune response to F has been extensively studied as a murine model of tolerance and autoimmunity. Murine F exists in two allelic forms, designated F type 1 and type 2, each of approximately 43 kDa. The immune response to the allotypic form is restricted to mouse strains of I-Ak. Responding strains immunized with allotypic F break tolerance and produce precipitating antibody that reacts with both allelic forms, i.e., immunogen and self. Thus an autoantibody is produced. Using the previously isolated rat F cDNA as a probe, we report the cloning and sequencing of the two murine F allotypes. These two alleles are nearly homologous except at the extremes of the coding sequence. There are a number of regions within the F sequence that are similar to peptides that interact specifically with I-Ak. In particular, there is a sequence near the carboxy terminus, where the two allotypes differ, that has homology to the I-Ak restricted malarial antigen peptide of the ring-infected erythrocyte surface antigen (RESA).

Sequences of the mouse F protein alleles and identification of a T cell epitope

F protein is found predominantly in the liver and is of unknown function. The protein has been of interest to immunologists in the areas of self tolerance and the immunogenetics of the anti-F protein response. In the mouse there are two alleles (F1 and F2), and although mice are completely tolerant to the self form of the protein, mice of responder strains make a good antibody response to immunization with the non-self form. This response cross-reacts with the self form, implying firstly, that autoreactive B cells are present and that tolerance is therefore maintained at the T cell level, and secondly, that the difference between the two allelic products defines a T cell epitope. Primers based on the published sequence for rat F protein were used in the polymerase chain reaction to amplify the cDNA for the two mouse alleles. Subsequent sequencing shows a high degree of sequence identity between the rat and mouse cDNA. The two mouse cDNA are identical apart from a single A to G base change which predicts an asparagine (F1 protein) to aspartate (F2 protein) amino acid residue change. Using allele-specific oligonucleotide probes we confirmed that this base change has the same strain distribution as the previously determined F protein type. Isoelectric focusing shows that F1 protein migrates in a more basic position than F2 protein, as predicted by the asparagine to aspartate change. Finally, a synthetic peptide from the allovariable site of F2 protein will successfully restimulate T cells in vitro from an F1 type mouse primed in vivo with whole F2 protein, whereas the corresponding peptide from F1 protein will not. This is evidence that, as predicted, the allovariable site does indeed define a T cell epitope. Peptides covering the rest of the F2 protein molecule were not stimulatory.

MHC class II-restricted presentation of intracellular antigen

An endogenously produced immunoglobulin light chain (lambda 2(315] is processed and presented to T cells in association with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules. Using transfectants producing variant forms of lambda 2(315) that are neither expressed on the cell surface nor secreted, we demonstrate that intracellular lambda 2(315), which has never been exported outside of the cell, is the source of processed lambda 2(315) idiotype. This challenges the currently accepted paradigm that endogenous antigens are only presented by MHC class I molecules. Variants of lambda 2(315) protein that are retained in the endoplasmic recticulum (ER) are also presented. Variants that are expressed in the cytosol as well as those that are transported into the nucleus rather than the ER are not presented. Thus, the ER is likely to be the processing compartment.

Selection of anti-F protein B-cell repertoires in normal mice

The hypothesis that self-tolerance to F protein antigen exclusively concerns T cells was tested by determining the frequencies of B lymphocytes producing anti-F antibodies in bone marrow (BM), spleen and peritoneal exudate (PEC) cells from normal, immune or tolerant animals, and in responder and non-responder mouse strains. Using an ELISA spot assay and lipopolysaccharide stimulation, we found that anti-F frequencies were highest in BM and "naturally activated" large spleen cells, followed by resting spleen and PEC cells. Anti-F specificities were also induced among "natural" Ig-secreting cells of normal individuals. Specific immunization of responder mice doubled the splenic frequencies, while tolerization had no effect. Similar results were obtained in BALB/c and A/J mice, while C57BL/6 contained fewer anti-F B cells in spleen, but not in BM. These results support the notion that self-tolerance to F antigen can primarily be ascribed to T cells, but they also show F-antigen-specific selection of B-cell repertoires.

Antigen presentation and self-nonself discrimination

Self-nonself discrimination is primarily carried out by T cells. Since the ligand recognized by T cells is a complex formed by antigenic peptides bound to MHC molecules, positive and negative selection of T lymphocytes must be based on the recognition of complexes formed by self-peptides bound to MHC molecules. This requires that self-antigens are continuously processed, bound by MHC molecules, and presented to T cells under conditions inducing both positive selection of T cells potentially able to recognize foreign antigens and negative selection, either by physical deletion or functional inactivation, of potentially autoreactive T cells. Self-nonself discrimination is not confined to intrathymic development of T lymphocytes, but it is a continuing process among peripheral T cells. Accordingly, autoimmunity is induced when self-antigens, or foreign antigens cross-reactive with self antigens, bound to MHC molecules, are presented under conditions able to activate self-reactive T cells. Based on these premises, a way of interfering with the induction of autoimmune diseases could rely on blocking the MHC binding site presenting the autoantigen.

MHC class II-derived peptides can bind to class II molecules, including self molecules, and prevent antigen presentation

Seven synthetic peptides corresponding to the polymorphic regions of the alpha and beta chains of the I-Ak molecule were examined for their ability to inhibit the presentation of foreign antigens to antigen-specific, I-A-restricted T cell hybridomas. Two of the peptides, representing the sequences found in the first and third polymorphic regions (PMR) of the A alpha k chain (alpha k-1 and alpha k-3) were capable of inhibiting the presentation of three different HEL-derived peptide antigens to their appropriate T cells. In addition, the alpha k-1 peptide inhibited the presentation of the OVA(323-339) immunodominant peptide to the I-Ad-restricted T cell hybridomas specific for it. Prepulsing experiments demonstrated that the PMR peptides were interacting with the APC and not with the T cell hybridomas. These observations were confirmed and extended by the demonstration that the alpha k-1 and alpha k-3 peptides blocked the direct binding of HEL(46-61) to purified I-Ak and that the alpha k-1 peptide blocked the binding of OVA(323-339) to I-Ad. The binding competition experiments suggest that the alpha k-1 peptide binds to the I-Ak molecule from which it was derived with a Kd approximately 10(-5) M, while the alpha k-3 peptide binds slightly less well. These combined data, suggesting that class II-derived peptides can bind to MHC class II molecules, including the autologous molecule from which they are derived, have important implications for the molecular basis of alloreactivity and autoreactivity. Further, they suggest a possible mechanism by which selecting elements, involving only MHC molecules, may be generated in the thymus.

Nuclear myxovirus-resistance protein Mx is a minor histocompatibility antigen

Minor histocompatibility antigens (MiHAgs) cause slow-to-rapid organ transplant rejection by immunocompetent hosts and mild-to-severe graft-versus-host reactions in immunosuppressed hosts. MiHAgs are allelic forms of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-restricted self-antigens recognized by cytotoxic T cells and usually are defined immunogenetically. Although structurally not identified as yet, it is assumed that MiHAgs are internal cell antigens that are processed and then presented by MHC class I proteins similar to viral antigens. To define a MiHAg both molecularly and functionally, we took advantage of the allelic difference of the structurally characterized intracellular myxovirus-resistance protein (Mx) and investigated its antigenicity. Skin grafts from congenic Mx+ mice carrying the functional Mx1 gene were rejected by mice lacking a functional Mx1 gene (Mx- mice). In parallel, cytotoxic MHC class I-restricted effector T cells specific for Mx protein and the H-2Kk antigen (but not for several other allelic H-2 antigens) were strongly induced in Mx- mice immunized with spleen cells from interferon-treated Mx+ mice. These data show that allelic forms of cell internal proteins presented by MHC class I may act as MiHAgs.

Specialized functions of MHC class I molecules. I. An N-formyl peptide receptor is required for construction of the class I antigen Mta

Maternally transmitted factor (Mtf) is a mitochondrial gene that controls the antigenic polymorphism of the MHC class I maternally transmitted antigen (Mta). Synthetic peptides from the NH2 terminus of the mitochondrially encoded NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1 (ND1) mimic Mtf peptide activity in an allele-specific manner. We show that the minimal ND1-alpha peptide length recognized by Mtaa-specific polyclonal CTLs was between 8 and 12 amino acids, while some Mtaa-specific CTL clones recognized a six amino acid peptide. The N-formyl group at the NH2 terminus of ND1 was essential for Mta activity. Competition experiments using N-substituted ND1-alpha peptides showed that an N-formyl peptide receptor on the target cell, which differs from the chemotactic peptide receptor, was required for Mta expression. The specificity of this receptor can account for the distinct immune restriction of Mta in which Mtf peptides are uniquely restricted by Hmt. It is possible that the Hmt gene product is the N-formyl peptide receptor itself and that it represents a class I antigen presentation molecule specialized for binding, transport, and immune presentation of N-formyl-peptide antigens of mitochondrial and prokaryotic origin.

A monoclonal antibody recognizes a subset of the H-2Dd mouse major class I antigens

Binding studies and competition experiments have shown that a monoclonal antibody (mAb) named 28-8-6 recognizes only 5 to 10% of the cell surface Dd molecules. The molecules detected by 28-8-6 mAb appear to be genuine H-2Dd antigens on the basis of their MW and isolectric points. In addition, the detectability of the subset of cell surface Dd molecules by 28-8-6 does not depend on their degree of glycosylation nor on the presence of mouse beta-2-microglobulin. Several interpretations are discussed. mAb 28-8-6 might detect a particular conformation or a particular chemical derivatization of otherwise normal H-2Dd molecules. Also, because the epitope recognized by 28-8-6 lies close to the peptide binding site, it is possible that mAb 28-8-6 recognizes a subset of Dd molecules bearing a certain category of self peptides.

T cell immunity or tolerance as a consequence of self antigen presentation

In this study we investigated the basis for immunity or tolerance to a mouse serum protein, the fifth component of complement (C5). In C5-deficient mice this protein is absent from serum and therefore they are not tolerized. Immunization of C5-deficient mice with C5-sufficient serum generates CD4+ T cells, which recognize C5 presented in the context of class II. No C5-specific responses were observed in T cells from C5-sufficient mice. We show that this self protein is processed and presented with class II by cells from C5-sufficient tolerant mice and can be recognized by C5-specific T cell clones and hybrids in the absence of exogenously added antigen. The stimulation of C5-specific T cells by C5-sufficient antigen-presenting cells is not a consequence of C5 secretion and subsequent processing in vitro but rather employs C5 peptide/class II complexes generated in vivo. We conclude that this self antigen is presented in normal mice in a form recognizable by T cells to induce and maintain immunological tolerance.

Direct evidence for functional self-protein/Ia-molecule complexes in vivo

Through the development of a panel of murine hybridomas reactive to murine hemoglobin, we have been able to study the processing and presentation of self antigens by antigen-presenting cells. Our results demonstrate that peritoneal macrophages in vivo can process and potentially present the self-antigen hemoglobin. We have extended this finding to show that, directly after removal from the mouse, antigen-presenting cells from a variety of tissues stimulate our hemoglobin-specific hybridomas without any manipulation or addition of exogenous antigen. This constitutes direct functional proof that in a nondisease state self proteins are processed constitutively and can be presented in a fashion similar to that in which foreign antigens are presented. Our demonstration that antigen-presenting cells can process and potentially present self as well as foreign molecules implies that self-tolerance occurs at the level of the T cell. This constitutive processing and presentation of self antigens has potentially far-reaching implications in self-tolerance, autoimmunity, and alloreactivity.

Two types of liver-specific F antigen are encoded by a locus located on chromosome 5 in mice

Two types of liver-specific F antigen in mice were distinguished by an immunoblotting technique after IEF of liver extracts. The IEF banding patterns consist of several bands whose pI vary from 7.57 to 8.15. One type of antigen (designated F2 antigen) showed a pattern that lacked some basic bands which are present in the pattern of the other type of antigen (designated F1 antigen). The latter type was found in AKR, CBA, C3H, DBA/2, and SM strains, while the former type was found in A, C57BL, and many other strains. Breeding experiments indicated that this variation is controlled by a single autosomal locus designated Laf (liver antigen F). Linkage analysis showed that the Laf locus is linked to the Pgm-1 locus on chromosome 5. The recombination frequency between these two loci is estimated to be 0.173 +/- 0.037. The distribution of F1 and F2 antigen types among inbred strains is concordant with that of type 1 and type 2 F antigens, which have been previously distinguished by their immunogenic differences, i.e., whether alloimmunization with the liver extracts from a given strain of mice can produce the antibody to F antigen in certain strains of mice. It is suggested, therefore, that the Laf locus may encode an allogeneic moiety of F antigen molecules.

Self- and allo-specific suppressor T cells evoked by intravenous injection of F protein

The liver/serum protein F appears to inactivate clones reactive towards itself in the T helper cell but not the B cell compartment. To examine the extent of self-reactivity in the T suppressor cell compartment, the well-established procedure of i.v. injecting milligram doses of the protein was used. To detect suppression, an entirely in vitro proliferation assay was devised, based on use of immunopurified F antigen. In this way T suppressor cells could be detected after activation either by allogeneic F, or (though to a lesser extent) by self-F protein. Thus the T suppressor cell compartment contains potentially self-reactive clones, and to that extent the receptor repertoire of T suppressor cells overlaps with B rather than T helper cells.