Congenital generalized lipodystrophy with insulin-resistant diabetes

Body Fat Distribution Contributes to Defining the Relationship between Insulin Resistance and Obesity in Human Diseases

The risk for metabolic and cardiovascular complications of obesity is defined by body fat distribution rather than global adiposity. Unlike subcutaneous fat, visceral fat (including hepatic steatosis) reflects insulin resistance and predicts type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. In humans, available evidence indicates that the ability to store triglycerides in the subcutaneous adipose tissue reflects enhanced insulin sensitivity. Prospective studies document an association between larger subcutaneous fat mass at baseline and reduced incidence of impaired glucose tolerance. Case-control studies reveal an association between genetic predisposition to insulin resistance and a lower amount of subcutaneous adipose tissue. Human peroxisome proliferator-activated receptorgamma (PPAR-γ) promotes subcutaneous adipocyte differentiation and subcutaneous fat deposition, improving insulin resistance and reducing visceral fat. Thiazolidinediones reproduce the effects of PPAR-γ activation and therefore increase the amount of subcutaneous fat while enhancing insulin sensitivity and reducing visceral fat. Partial or virtually complete lack of adipose tissue (lipodystrophy) is associated with insulin resistance and its clinical manifestations, including essential hypertension, hypertriglyceridemia, reduced HDL-c, type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and kidney disease. Patients with Prader Willi syndrome manifest severe subcutaneous obesity without insulin resistance. The impaired ability to accumulate fat in the subcutaneous adipose tissue may be due to deficient triglyceride synthesis, inadequate formation of lipid droplets, or defective adipocyte differentiation. Lean and obese humans develop insulin resistance when the capacity to store fat in the subcutaneous adipose tissue is exhausted and deposition of triglycerides is no longer attainable at that location. Existing adipocytes become large and reflect the presence of insulin resistance.

Congenital lipodystrophies and dyslipidemias

Lipodystrophies are rare acquired and genetic disorders characterized by the selective loss of adipose tissue. One key metabolic feature of patients with congenital inherited lipodystrophy is hypertriglyceridemia. The precise mechanisms by which the lack of adipose tissue causes dyslipidemia remain largely unknown. In recent years, new insights have arisen from data obtained in vitro in adipocytes, yeast, drosophila, and very recently in several genetically modified mouse models of generalized lipodystrophy. A common metabolic pathway involving accelerated lipolysis and defective energy storage seems to contribute to the dyslipidemia associated with congenital generalized lipodystrophy syndromes, although the pathophysiological changes may vary with the nature of the mutation involved. Therapeutic management of dyslipidemia in patients with lipodystrophy is primarily based on specific approaches using recombinant leptin therapy. Preclinical studies suggest a potential efficacy of thiazolidinediones that remains to be assessed in dedicated clinical trials.

Lipodystrophy: lessons in lipid and energy metabolism

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Lipodystrophies are rare inherited and acquired disorders characterized by the selective loss of adipose tissue. Despite marked phenotypic and genotypic heterogeneity, most lipodystrophic syndromes predispose to similar metabolic complications seen in patients with obesity, such as insulin resistance, diabetes mellitus, hepatic steatosis and dyslipidemia. The purpose of this review is to highlight the current understanding of the mechanisms underlying dyslipidemia in patients with lipodystrophies.

RECENT FINDINGS

Marked hypertriglyceridemia and reduced levels of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol are commonly seen, and the severity of these metabolic abnormalities seems to be related to the extent of fat loss. The precise mechanisms by which the lack of adipose tissue causes hypertriglyceridemia remain unknown. Anecdotal kinetic studies in hyperglycemic patients with lipodystrophies have revealed accelerated lipolysis and increased free fatty acid turnover, which drives hepatic triglyceride and very low-density lipoprotein synthesis. Other mechanisms may also be involved in causing dyslipidemia and ectopic triglyceride accumulation in the liver and skeletal muscles that remain to be identified.

SUMMARY

Understanding the pathophysiology of dyslipidemia in these rare disorders of lipodystrophies may offer insights into the normal role of adipocytes in maintaining metabolic homeostasis, and its disturbances in common forms of obesity.

The molecular basis of genetic lipodystrophies

OBJECTIVES

Hyperinsulinemia is often associated with a cluster of metabolic abnormalities, which usually presents before the onset of frank diabetes. Lipodystrophy syndromes are frequently associated with hyperinsulinemia and may act as models for insulin resistance. Lipodystrophy is characterized in broad terms by loss of subcutaneous adipose tissue. Despite heterogeneous causes, which include both genetic and acquired forms, lipodystrophy syndromes have similar metabolic attributes, including insulin resistance, hyperlipidemia and diabetes.

RESULTS

Recently, the molecular basis of two genetic forms of lipodystrophy, namely Dunnigan-type familial partial lipodystrophy (FPLD; MIM 151660) and Berardinelli-Seip complete lipodystrophy (BSCL; MIM 269700) have been reported. There is evidence for genetic heterogeneity for both types of lipodystrophy. In addition, murine models of lipodystrophy have provided key insights into alterations of metabolic pathways in lipodystrophy.

CONCLUSIONS

Delineation of the human molecular genetic basis of two distinct forms of inherited lipodystrophy may have relevance for the common insulin resistance syndrome and for acquired lipodystrophy syndromes.

Insulin resistance in limb and trunk partial lipodystrophy (type 2 Köbberling-Dunnigan syndrome)

We studied insulin action in two patients with limb and trunk partial lipodystrophy with hirsutism and acanthosis nigricans. Glucose was normal in one of the patients and slightly above normal in the other during an oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT). An intravenous glucose tolerance test (IVGTT) was normal in both patients. Basal and glucose-stimulated insulin levels were elevated in both the OGTT and IVGTT in both patients. The response of plasma glucose to exogenously administered insulin was decreased. A euglycemic-hyperinsulinemic clamp performed in patient no. 2 indicated insulin resistance, which was not corrected by reducing the increased basal level of serum free fatty acids (FFAs). Binding of insulin to neck adipocytes was normal in both subjects, but glucose transport and oxidation in these cells was impaired. Insulin binding to abdominal adipocytes was increased in one patient whose adipocytes displayed higher glucose transport at low insulin concentrations. Glucose oxidation was decreased in abdominal adipocytes of both patients. We conclude that insulin resistance in Köbberling-Dunnigan type 2 partial lipodystrophy is not related to an alteration of the insulin molecule or to changes in insulin binding, but is more likely associated with a postreceptor defect, since glucose oxidation was impaired in adipocytes of the neck and abdomen.

Köbberling-Dunnigan syndrome: a rare cause of generalized muscular hypertrophy

A 36-year-old woman presented with muscle hypertrophy (particularly of the calves) since puberty, occasional muscle cramps, a musculine habitus, and a loss of subcutaneous fat on limbs and trunk sparing her face, neck, and vulva. Multiple lipomas were found on her trunk, and acanthosis nigricans on her neck. Laboratory testing revealed hyperlipidemia and pathological glucose tolerance with hyperinsulinemia. Physical and laboratory findings are consistent with Köbberling-Dunnigan syndrome, a rare inherited form of lipoatrophy. The patient's mother had the same body habitus and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. These cases suggest that partial lipodystrophy also affects muscle and is a cause of genuine muscular hypertrophy.

Studies of insulin resistance in congenital generalized lipodystrophy

Two well-characterized patients with congenital, generalized lipodystrophy have been studied by the euglycaemic hyperinsulinaemic clamp technique in combination with indirect calorimetry. Furthermore, glycogen synthase in muscle biopsies was studied in one patient with regard to enzyme activity, immunoreactive protein and mRNA levels. The patients had fasting hyperinsulinaemia, and the rate of total glucose disposal was severely impaired, primarily due to a decreased non-oxidative glucose metabolism. In the patient studied with muscle biopsy, the expected activation of glycogen synthase by insulin did not occur. In both patients there was severely increased hepatic glucose output in the basal state, suggesting a failure of insulin to suppress hepatic gluconeogenesis. During insulin infusion a substantially elevated rate of lipid oxidation remained in the patients, in contrast to the almost completely suppressed lipid oxidation in the controls. It is concluded that patients with congenital generalized lipodystrophy may present severe insulin resistance with regard to hepatic glucose production as well as muscle glycogen synthesis and lipid oxidation. The results suggest a postreceptor defect in the action of insulin in congenital generalized lipodystrophy. The further localization of such a defect is hampered by the still incomplete understanding of the pathways that link insulin-stimulated tyrosine phosphorylation to the ultimate action of insulin upon target cells.

Generalized lipodystrophy, congenital and acquired (lipoatrophy)

This review is based on longitudinal studies on our seven patients with congenital generalized lipodystrophy, our patient with acquired generalized lipodystrophy, and published papers on these subjects. An inability to store energy in adipose tissue is of pathogenetic importance. In congenital lipodystrophy, insulin resistance is present from birth, resulting in hyperinsulinaemia, dyslipidaemia. and insulin-resistant diabetes with an anabolic syndrome worsened by a voracious appetite. Clinically, we observed increased height velocity in pre-school age children, and organomegaly with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, which seems to be lethal in early adulthood: three of our patients died at the ages of 24, 32 and 37 years. The oldest alive, 39 years, suffers from stenocardia. Regarding treatment, it is most important to reduce energy consumption. The congenital form is recessively inherited. The aetiology may be related to insulin receptor or postreceptor mechanisms. Acquired generalized lipodystrophy seems to be an autoimmune disorder with secondary destruction of the adipose organ: the anabolic syndrome with insulin-resistant diabetes is secondary. Our patient died when 24 years old from pneumonia.

Insulin resistance in total lipodystrophy: evidence for a pre-receptor defect in insulin action

The cause of insulin resistance in lipodystrophic diabetes is unknown but has generally been ascribed to dysfunction at either the receptor or post receptor level. In a 14 year-old girl with total acquired lipodystrophy, subcutaneous and intravenous insulin requirements approximated 600 units daily. However, circulating total and free insulin levels were not increased, and during testing by the euglycemic clamp method, the glucose response to increasing free insulin concentrations was within the range found in eight subjects with insulin-dependent diabetes. Insulin clearance during the euglycemic clamp was 43, 98, 115, and 116 mL/kg/min at each of four insulin infusion rates compared to means of 13, 13, 12, and 11 in the control subjects with diabetes. No detectable degrading activity was present in serum, and serum inhibited insulin degradation normally. Binding of insulin to IgG, IgM, and IgE was not increased, insulin binding to monocytes and erythrocytes was not sufficiently abnormal to account for the the insulin resistance, and insulin receptor increased insulin clearance or accelerated degradation of insulin by tissues.

Very low-density lipoprotein metabolism in an unusual case of lipoatrophic diabetes

Complete acquired lipoatrophic diabetes (LD) is characterized by nonketotic insulin-resistant diabetes, elevated very low-density lipoprotein (VLDL) triglyceride (TG) levels, and absent subcutaneous fat. We studied a young child in whom LD atypically developed after the onset of type 1 diabetes mellitus. On uncontrolled home diet the patient had triglyceride levels over 1,000 mg/dL on multiple occasions. In order to demonstrate the effects of caloric and dietary-fat restriction on VLDL metabolism, 3H-glycerol and autologous 125I-VLDL were used to quantitate the turnover of VLDL-TG and VLDL-apolipoprotein B (apo B) during two periods of caloric restriction. Consumption of a 900-kcal 40-g fat diet resulted in a plasma triglyceride level of 1383 mg/dL (ten-fold elevation). This hypertriglyceridemia was associated with markedly increased production rates of both VLDL-TG (73.7 mg/kg/h) and VLDL-apo B (126.9 mg/kg/d). Consumption of a 900-kcal 25-g fat diet resulted in a plasma TG level of 663 mg/dL. This reduction in plasma TG was associated with a 40% decrease in VLDL-TG production rate (PR) (45.1 mg/kg/h). There was no change in the production rate (PR) of VLDL-apo B. The hypertriglyceridemia in this patient was due to marked over production of VLDL. Furthermore, the studies demonstrate: (1) the independent benefits of caloric and dietary-fat restriction in the treatment of LD, and (2) that fat restriction lowered plasma triglyceride by its effect on the VLDL-TG production rate.

The new insulins. Their characteristics and clinical indications

In the past 10 years the techniques of gel filtration and ion exchange chromatography have made available insulins of markedly enhanced purity. These highly purified insulins have made immunological insulin resistance a rarity, and result in absent or clinically insignificant levels of insulin antibodies in insulin-treated diabetics. Insulin allergy has not been reported with highly purified insulins alone, and is rare even when the patient has previously received recrystallised insulin. Generalised allergic reactions to insulin and insulin resistance are associated with the enhanced immunological reaction to intermittent insulin therapy. The use of highly purified insulins for short courses of treatment is therefore mandatory, particularly in patients with infections. Injection-site lipoatrophy, a relatively common occurrence with the older insulins, disappears on changing to highly purified preparations. Following a change to highly purified insulins, insulin dose requirements will fall gradually with insulin antibody levels. When switching from conventional beef to highly purified pork insulins, a more immediate change in dose requirements may occur so that prospective reductions in insulin dose are indicated. It is still uncertain whether moderate levels of insulin antibodies are associated with any difference in metabolic control. This is partly a reflection of difficulties in measuring diabetic control, and partly a lack of properly designed studies. Current insulins of both older and newer types give plasma insulin profiles that are far from physiological. Insulin antibodies cross the placenta and may contribute to increased fetal insulin secretion and neonatal hypoglycaemia. Pre-pregnant patients should be changed to the newer preparations. Highly purified insulins cost little more than conventional insulins in the free market, and should be used in all newly diagnosed insulin-requiring diabetics. More recently, human insulin has become available through both DNA recombinant technology and amino acid substitution techniques. It has proved to have identical characteristics to pork insulin both in vitro and in normal subjects. Clinical trials with human insulin are at present in progress.

Insulin-induced lipoatrophy: evidence for an immune pathogenesis

Skin biopsy samples from 14 diabetic patients with lipoatrophy at injection sites and from five insulin-treated diabetic patients without such lipoatrophy (controls) were examined by immunofluorescence for the deposition of immunological components. Also sera from 13 of the patients with lipoatrophy and from all of the controls were assayed for insulin-binding capacity. Biopsy samples from the edge of lipoatrophic areas (eight cases) invariably showed abnormal deposition of immunological components in dermal vessel walls, whereas no such deposition was seen in the control samples. Mean serum insulin-binding capacity was 33.1 microgram/l in the patients with lipoatrophy compared with only 4.6 microgram/l in the controls. These findings suggest that insulin-induced lipoatrophy results from the local formation of immune complexes, complement fixation, and release of inflammatory mediators from the cellular infiltrate.

The syndromes of primary hormone resistance

The clinical features, genetics, pathophysiology, and management of endocrine diseases in which primary hormone resistance is the fundamental defect have been reviewed. Primary hormone resistance has been documented for nearly all hormones--vasopressin, parathyroid hormone, growth hormone, adrenocroticotropin, thyrotropin, gonadotropins, insulin, androgens, cortisol, aldosterone, progesterone, thyroid hormones, and vitamin D. A striking exception is estradiol, a steroid that may be vital for early embryonic development. Most of the hormone unresponsiveness syndromes represent only partial defects, and it is likely that most such patients go unrecognized. Therefore, hormone resistance should be suspected not only when a patient presents with hypofunction of particular endocrine system combined with high endogenous hormone levels but also whenever apparently normal function of an endocrine system is associated with inappropriately elevated levels of the corresponding hormone. The value of these defects in hormone responsiveness as a natural laboratory for the study of the normal mechanisms of hormone action is discussed.