Detection of optic nerve lesions in optic neuritis using frequency-selective fat-saturation sequences

Beyond McDonald: updated perspectives on MRI diagnosis of multiple sclerosis

INTRODUCTION

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an essential paraclinical test to establish an accurate and early diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS), which is based on the application of the McDonald criteria.

AREAS COVERED

The objective of this article is to analyze, based on publicly available database since the publication of the 2017 McDonald diagnostic criteria, the clinical impact of these criteria, to discuss the potential inclusion within these criteria of the optic nerve to demonstrate dissemination in space, and to guide the acquisition and interpretation of MRI scans for diagnostic purposes. Finally, the authors will review emerging MRI features that could improve the specificity of MRI in the diagnosis of MS and consequently minimize the misdiagnosis of this disease.

EXPERT OPINION

Although the optic nerve has not been included as one of the topographies required to demonstrate demyelinating lesion disseminated in space in the 2017 McDonald criteria, new studies seem to show some improvement in the sensitivity of these criteria when this topography is considered. New radiological findings such as the central vein sign and iron rims, should be considered within the typical MRI features of this disease with the objective of minimizing MRI-based diagnostic errors.

Optical coherence tomography for detection of asymptomatic optic nerve lesions in clinically isolated syndrome

Objective

To evaluate the ability of intereye retinal thickness difference (IETD) measured by optical coherence tomography (OCT) to detect asymptomatic optic nerve involvement in clinically isolated syndrome (CIS).

Methods

We conducted a cross-sectional study of patients who recently presented a CIS (≤4.5 months). All patients underwent OCT and brain/optic nerve MRI. Optic nerve involvement was defined clinically (episode of optic neuritis [ON] or not) and radiologically (optic nerve hypersignal on 3D double inversion recovery [3D-DIR]). We evaluated the sensitivity and specificity of previously published IETD thresholds and report the observed optimal thresholds for identifying symptomatic optic nerve involvement but also for identifying asymptomatic optic nerve involvement (optic nerve hypersignal without ON history). Primary outcomes were ganglion cell–inner plexiform layer (GC-IPL) and peripapillary retinal nerve fiber layer IETD.

Results

The study group consisted of 130 patients. In the CIS with ON group, 3D-DIR showed a hypersignal in all 41 symptomatic optic nerves and in 11 asymptomatic optic nerves. In the CIS without ON group, 3D-DIR showed a unilateral optic nerve hypersignal in 22 patients and a bilateral optic nerve hypersignal in 7 patients. For the detection of symptomatic and asymptomatic optic nerve lesion, GC-IPL IETD had better performance. We found an optimal GC-IPL IETD threshold ≥2.83 µm (sensitivity 88.2, specificity 83.3%) for the detection of symptomatic lesions and an optimal GC-IPL IETD ≥1.42 µm (sensitivity 89.3%, specificity 72.6%) for the detection of asymptomatic lesions.

Conclusions

Detection of asymptomatic optic nerve lesions in CIS requires lower IETD thresholds than previously reported. GC-IPL IETD represents an alternative biomarker to MRI for the detection of asymptomatic optic nerve lesions.

Classification of evidence

This study provides Class I evidence that OCT accurately identifies asymptomatic optic nerve involvement in patients with CIS.

Robust selective signal suppression using binomial off-resonant rectangular (BORR) pulses

PURPOSE

To study the selective signal suppression capability of a binomial off-resonant rectangular (BORR) radiofrequency pulse method.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The BORR pulse consists of two consecutive rectangular pulses with a phase difference of π. The exact solution of the Bloch equations was used to simulate its frequency response. The BORR pulse was implemented in a gradient echo sequence and tested on phantoms, the knee, and the breast.

RESULTS

The frequency response of the BORR pulse acquired on the phantom confirmed the theory. Broad suppression bands ensured high suppression efficiency and robustness in both in vitro and in vivo scans compared with other saturation pulses.

CONCLUSION

The BORR pulse method provides a simple, efficient, and robust selective signal suppression alternative for three-dimensional short TR (repetition time) imaging.

Optic neuritis and the neuro-ophthalmology of multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is the most common cause of neurological disability in young adults. Since approximately 40% of the brain is devoted to vision, demyelination commonly affects visual function, resulting in a myriad of neuro-ophthalmic symptoms. In this chapter, we examine the seminal afferent and efferent neuro-ophthalmological manifestations of MS, highlighting those history and examination findings critical for the diagnosis and treatment of various visual and ocular motor disorders. Among the topics, a special emphasis will be placed on optic neuritis, the most common clinically isolated demyelinating syndrome. This chapter focuses on the evaluation and treatment of visual sensory and oculomotor disorders in MS. The objective is to provide the reader with a working model for enhancing their care of patients with demyelinating disease.

High-resolution anatomic, diffusion tensor, and magnetization transfer magnetic resonance imaging of the optic chiasm at 3T

PURPOSE

To evaluate techniques for anatomical and physiological imaging of the intracranial optic nerve (ON), optic chiasm (OC), and optic tract (OT) at 3T with the aim of visualizing axonal damage in multiple sclerosis (MS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Imaging was performed on a 3T scanner employing a custom-designed head coil that consisted of a coil array with four coils (30 x 30 cm(2)). Oblique fast spin echo (FSE) images, magnetization transfer (MT)-enhanced 3D gradient-echo (GRE) time-of-flight (TOF) images, and line scan diffusion images (LSDI) were obtained. Full diffusion tensor (DT) analysis was performed, and apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC), fractional anisotropy (FA), and fiber direction maps were obtained.

RESULTS

FSE anatomic images were obtained with an in-plane resolution of 0.39 x 0.52 mm(2). The in-plane resolution of the MT and LSDI images was 0.78 x 0.78 mm(2). The OC, intracranial ON, and OT can be seen on these images. The dominant fiber orientations in the OC, ON, and OT, as derived from the DT images, are displayed.

CONCLUSION

This study shows that by using 3T and a custom-designed, four-channel head coil, it is possible to acquire high-resolution anatomical and physiological images of the OC, ON, and OT. The pilot results presented here pave the way for imaging the anterior visual pathway in patients with MS.

[Magnetic resonance imaging in the diagnosis and understanding of the nature of pathologic changes in multiple sclerosis]

nema

ADC mapping of the human optic nerve: increased resolution, coverage, and reliability with CSF-suppressed ZOOM-EPI

The mean apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) of the human optic nerve (ON) has been quantified in vivo, and mean ADC maps are shown along the complete length of the nerve from the globe to the optic chiasm. The mean ADC, over the whole nerve, is shown to be 1058 x 10(-6) mm(2) s(-1) (standard deviation (SD), over nine 3-mm slices, 101x10(-6) mm(2) s(-1); range (833-1178)x10(-6) mm(2) s(-1)). The robustness of the method relies on acquisition of high-resolution coronal images of the ON using the ZOOM-EPI technique, which makes use of a shortened echo train length for increased resolution with decreased susceptibility-induced distortions. Suppression of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and fat signals from tissues that surround the ON also helps successful identification and delineation of the nerve. Averaging of magnitude images is used to compensate for the inherently low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the acquired images; the effects of the Rayleigh distributed noise in such images are allowed for during ADC calculations.

Imaging of the optic nerve and visual pathways

The visual pathway extends from the globes anteriorly to the occipital cortex posteriorly. A wide variety of disease processes may produce visual dysfunction. Because the optic nerve is a fiber tract of the brain covered by meninges, it can be affected by many of the same pathologic processes that occur in the brain and meninges. Physical examination and diagnostic tests of visual function performed by the clinician can frequently identify the anatomic location of the causative lesion in the patient with vision loss. This enables the radiologist to optimize the imaging evaluation of the patient. This article reviews the normal anatomy of the optic nerve and visual pathways, presents computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance (MR) imaging techniques for evaluation of these structures, and discusses the pathologic processes intrinsic to the optic nerve and visual pathways.

The contribution of magnetic resonance imaging in the differential diagnosis of optic nerve damage

In this paper we review the findings of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in optic neuritis and visual dysfunction due to other optic neuropathies. With advances in MRI technology, it has become possible to visualise optic nerve pathology. STIR and RARE sequences, contrast-enhanced sequences, and phased array surface coils are technical developments that provide fine anatomical detail and that are sensitive to pathological changes. MRI can offer information in the differential diagnosis of optic neuropathies, the monitoring of their treatment, and in some instances should provide new insights into the underlying pathophysiological mechanisms.

Technical issues for the study of the optic nerve with MRI

The optic nerve is technically challenging to investigate with Magnetic Resonance Imaging due to its small size, the effect of surrounding cerebrospinal fluid and lipid, and the presence of nearby bony structures. With careful optimization it is possible to obtain high quality T(1) and T(2) weighted images for qualitative assessment, however, although quantitative measurements of parameters such as relaxation times, magnetization transfer ratio and apparent diffusion coefficient may be problematic.

Prognostic value of magnetic resonance imaging in monosymptomatic optic neuritis

PURPOSE

Magnetic resonance imaging is able to depict lesions in the optic nerve in the acute stage of monosymptomatic optic neuritis. Most patients have lesions located intraorbitally, intracanalicularly, and/or intracranially. The goal of this study is to determine whether these lesions resolve after visual recovery, change in length or localization, or could be correlated to the visual function.

METHODS

Between 1987 and 1992, the authors examined 22 patients with acute optic neuritis using magnetic resonance imaging short-time inversion recovery sequences. Additionally, the authors determined visual acuity, visual field, color vision, contrast sensitivity, and visual-evoked responses. All patients were re-examined between 1993 and 1994 in the same manner. Visual recovery in the re-examination was divided into three groups: group 1 with complete visual recovery (visual acuity better than 20/25); group 2 with incomplete recovery (visual acuity better than 20/25 but defect in at least one of the other tests: visual field, color vision, and contrast sensitivity); and group 3 with partial recovery (visual acuity remained less than 20/25, defect in all the other tests).

RESULTS

All group 1 patients initially had lesions less than 17.5 mm, group 2 patients had lesions greater than 17.5 mm (44%) and/or lesions located intracanalicularly (66%), and most of group 3 patients initially had lesions greater than 17.5 mm (79%).

CONCLUSION

Eyes with lesions less than 17.5 mm in the optic nerve in acute optic neuritis have a good prognosis for visual recovery. Lesions greater than 17.5 mm or lesions involving the intracanalicular portion of the optic nerve lead to incomplete or partial visual recovery.

Lesion discrimination in optic neuritis using high-resolution fat-suppressed fast spin-echo MRI

Fast spin-echo (FSE) is a new sequence with acquisition times currently down to one-sixteenth of those obtained with conventional spin-echo sequences, which allows high-resolution (512 x 512 matrix) images to be acquired in an acceptable time. We compared the higher resolution of FSE with the medium resolution of a short inversion-time inversion-recovery (STIR) sequence in depicting the optic nerves of healthy controls and patients with optic neuritis. Optic nerve MRI examinations were performed in 18 patients with optic neuritis and 10 normal controls. Two sequences were obtained coronally: fat-suppressed FSE (FSE TR 3250 ms/TEef 68 ms, echo-train length 16, 4 excitations, 24 cm rectangular field of view, 3 mm interleaved contiguous slices, in-plane resolution 0.5 x 0.5 mm) and STIR (TR 2000 ms/TE 50 ms/TI 175 ms, in-plane resolution 0.8 x 0.8 mm, slice thickness 5 mm). FSE demonstrated much more anatomical detail than STIR, e.g. distinction of optic nerve and sheath. Lesions were seen in 20 of 21 symptomatic nerves using FSE and in 18 of 21 using STIR. Nerve swelling or partial cross-sectional lesions of the optic nerve were each seen only on FSE in 3 cases. Fat-suppressed FSE imaging of the optic nerve improves anatomical definition and increases lesion detection in optic neuritis.

Long time echo STIR sequence magnetic resonance imaging of optic nerves in optic neuritis

Magnetic resonance images of optic nerves were obtained in 20 patients with acute optic neuritis (ON), and assessed by means of clinical, visual field and visual evoked potential evaluations; the imaging was repeated 1 year later. The results of the conventional Short Tau Inversion Recovery (STIR) sequence obtained using short time echo (STE-STIR: 22 msec) were compared with those of the long time echo sequence (LTE-STIR: 80 msec). The conventional STE-STIR sequence revealed lesions in 57.2% cases of acute ON and in 42.9% of the optic nerves affected by previous ON; the LTE-STIR sequence was diagnostic in 95.2% of acute ON cases and in 85% of patients with previous ON. The calculated length of the optic nerve lesions was significantly longer in the images obtained using the LTE-STIR sequence than in those obtained using conventional STE-STIR sequences.

Long echo time STIR sequence MRI of optic nerves in optic neuritis

MRI of the optic nerves was obtained in 13 patients with acute optic neuritis and 13 with a previous optic neuritis (ON), assessed by clinical features, visual fields and visual evoked potentials. Results of the conventional short tau inversion recovery (STIR) sequence obtained with a short echo time (STE-STIR; 22 ms) were compared with those of a long echo time (LTE-STIR: 80 ms) sequence. The conventional STE-STIR sequence revealed lesions in the optic nerves in 78.5% of acute and 58.8% of previous ON. The LTE-STIR sequence showed abnormalities in 92.8% of acutely symptomatic nerves and 94.1% of nerves with previous ON. The optic nerve lesions appeared significantly longer with the LTE-STIR sequence than with the conventional STE-STIR sequences, in both acute and previous ON.

Availability of frequency-selective fat-saturation pulse (Fat-Sat) MRI in childhood optic neuritis

A 2-year-old boy with acute optic neuritis, confirmed by gadolinium-DTPA enhancement of the optic nerve using frequency-selective fat-saturation pulse magnetic resonance imaging (Fat-Sat MRI), is reported. Because it is difficult in very young children to sufficiently evaluate visual acuity, visual field, and retroocular pain on eye movement, and visual evoked potential during wakefulness, Fat-Sat MRI will be useful for revealing optic nerve inflammation and for monitoring treatment.

High resolution magnetic resonance imaging of the anterior visual pathway in patients with optic neuropathies using fast spin echo and phased array local coils

High resolution MRI of the anterior visual pathways was evaluated using frequency selective fat suppressed fast spin echo (FSE) sequences in conjunction with phased array local coils in patients with optic neuropathies. Fifteen normal controls and 57 patients were examined. Coronal T2 weighted fat suppressed FSE images were obtained in 11 minutes with an in plane resolution of 0.39 x 0.39 mm. The optic nerve and its sheath containing CSF were clearly differentiated. Central retinal vessels were often visible. In demyelinating optic neuritis and in anterior ischaemic optic neuropathy high signal within the nerve was readily delineated. Meningiomas and gliomas involving the optic nerve were precisely visualised both in the orbit and intracranially. Extrinsic compression of the optic nerves was readily visualised in carotid artery ectasia and dysthyroid eye disease. Enlarged subarachnoid spaces around the optic nerves were demonstrated in benign intracranial hypertension. High resolution MRI of the anterior visual pathway represents an advance in the diagnosis and management of patients presenting with optic neuropathy.

Long time echo stir sequence magnetic resonance imaging of optic nerves in optic neuritis

Magnetic resonance imaging of optic nerves was obtained in 13 patients with acute optic neuritis and in 13 patients with a previous history of optic neuritis (ON), assessed by clinical, visual fields and visual evoked potentials evaluations. Results of the conventional short tau inversion recovery (STIR) sequence obtained with short time echo (STE-STIR: 22 ms) were compared with long time echo (LTE-STIR: 80 ms) sequence. The conventional STE-STIR sequence revealed lesions in 78.5% of acute ON and in 58.8% of optic nerves affected by previous ON. The LTE-STIR sequence was diagnostic in 92.8% of acutely symptomatic nerves, in 94.1% of nerves with previous ON. The calculated length of optic nerve lesions was significantly longer in imaging obtained with the LTE-STIR sequence than with the conventional STE-STIR sequences, both in acute and previous ON.

Cranial MRI in idiopathic retinal vasculitis

Ten patients with clinically isolated idiopathic retinal vasculitis who had a positive family history for multiple sclerosis (MS) or positive typing for HLA B7 underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of brain and optic nerves in order to establish the frequency of clinically silent lesions. Brain MRI was normal in seven and abnormal in three: one had a single small white matter lesion, two had extensive white matter abnormalities resembling those seen in MS. In two patients a lesion was shown in the optic nerve. These findings suggest that a minority of patients with idiopathic retinal vasculitis have disseminated central nervous system lesions characteristic of MS, the frequency of such changes being less than in patients with isolated optic neuritis.