Induction of apoptosis in oxygen-deprived cultures of hybridoma cells

Deep in situ microscopy for real-time analysis of mammalian cell populations in bioreactors

An in situ microscope based on pulsed transmitted light illumination via optical fiber was combined to artificial-intelligence to enable for the first time an online cell classification according to well-known cellular morphological features. A 848 192-image database generated during a lab-scale production process of antibodies was processed using a convolutional neural network approach chosen for its accurate real-time object detection capabilities. In order to induce different cell death routes, hybridomas were grown in normal or suboptimal conditions in a stirred tank reactor, in the presence of substrate limitation, medium addition, pH regulation problem or oxygen depletion. Using such an optical system made it possible to monitor real-time the evolution of different classes of animal cells, among which viable, necrotic and apoptotic cells. A class of viable cells displaying bulges in feast or famine conditions was also revealed. Considered as a breakthrough in the catalogue of process analytical tools, in situ microscopy powered by artificial-intelligence is also of great interest for research.

Methods for Oxygen Determination in an NMR Bioreactor as a Surrogate Marker for Metabolomic Studies in Living Cell Cultures

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) approaches have been described as a powerful method for measuring oxygen in tissue cultures and body fluids by using relaxation time dependencies of substances on pO2. The present NMR study describes methods to longitudinally monitor global, in situ intracellular, and spatially resolved oxygen tension in culture media and 3D cell cultures using relaxation times of water without the need to use external sensors. 1H NMR measurements of water using a modified inversion recovery pulse scheme were employed for global, i.e., intra- and extracellular oxygen estimation in an NMR-bioreactor. The combination of 1H relaxation time T1 and diffusion measurements of water was employed for in situ cellular oxygen content determination. Spatially selective water relaxation time estimations were used for spatially resolved oxygen quantification along the NMR tube length. The inclusion in a study protocol of the presented techniques for oxygen quantification, as a surrogate marker of oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS), provides the possibility to measure mitochondrial respiration and metabolic changes simultaneously.

Biocompatibility Evaluation and Enhancement of Elastomeric Coatings Made Using Table-Top Optical 3D Printer

In this experimental report, the biocompatibility of elastomeric scaffold structures made via stereolithography employing table-top 3D printer Ember (Autodesk) and commercial resin FormLabs Flexible (FormLabs) was studied. The samples were manufactured using the standard printing and development protocol, which is known to inherit cytotoxicity due to remaining non-polymerized monomers, despite the polymerized material being fully biocompatible. Additional steps were taken to remedy this problem: the fabricated structures were soaked in isopropanol and methanol under different conditions (temperature and duration) to leach out the non-polymerized monomers. In addition, disc-shaped 3D-printed structures were UV exposed to assure maximum polymerization degree of the material. Post-processed structures were seeded with myogenic stem cells and the number of live cells was evaluated as an indicator for the material biocompatibility. The straightforward post-processing protocol enhanced the biocompatibility of the surfaces by seven times after seven days soaking in isopropanol and methanol and was comparable to control (glass and polystyrene) samples. This proposes the approach as a novel and simple method to be widely applicable for dramatic cytotoxicity reduction of optically 3D printed micro/nano-scaffolds for a wide range of biomedical studies and applications.

JNK implication in adipocyte-like cell death induced by chemotherapeutic drug cisplatin

Recent evidence shows that tumor microenvironment containing heterogeneous cells may be involved in cancer initiation, growth and tumor cell response to anticancer therapy. Chemotherapy was designed to make toxic impact on malicious cells in organisms, however, the means to protect healthy cells against chemical toxicity are still unsuccessful. As known, the majority of tumor surrounding cells are cancer-associated adipocytes which influence cancer development, progression and treatment. Targeting the components of tumor microenvironment in combination with conventional cancer treatment may become an effective cancer therapy strategy. However, little is known about adipocyte death mechanisms during combined chemo- and targeted therapy. The importance of c-Jun-NH<inf>2</inf>-terminal kinase (JNK) signaling in tumor development and treatment has been demonstrated using various in vitro and in vivo cancer models. The aim of this study was to ascertain adipocyte viability during simultaneous stress kinase JNK inhibition and exposure to one of the most commonly used anticancer drugs cis-diamminedichloroplatinum II (cisplatin). Our model involved adipocyte-like cells (ADC) which were obtained during in vitro differentiation of adult rabbit muscle-derived stem cells. Cisplatin induced apoptotic cell death. During 24-hr cisplatin treatment gradual, strong and prolonged increase of both JNK and its target protein c-Jun phosphorylation was found in ADC. Pre-treatment of cells with SP600125 decreased cisplatin-induced activation of c-Jun and promoted apoptosis. Upregulation of proapoptotic Bax and downregulation of antiapoptotic Bcl-2 proteins were found to be regulated in JNK-dependent manner. Thus, the results prove the antiapoptotic role of activated JNK in adipocyte-like cells treated with cisplatin.

Neurotoxicity of coral snake phospholipases A2 in cultured rat hippocampal neurons

The neurotoxicity of two secreted Phospholipases A2 from Brazilian coral snake venom in rat primary hippocampal cell culture was investigated. Following exposure to Mlx-8 or Mlx-9 toxins, an increase in free cytosolic Ca(2+) and a reduction in mitochondrial transmembrane potential (ΔΨm) became evident and occurred prior to the morphological changes and cytotoxicity. Exposure of hippocampal neurons to Mlx-8 or Mlx-9 caused a decrease in the cell viability as assessed by MTT and LDH assays. Inspection using fluorescent images and ultrastructural analysis by scanning and transmission electron microscopy showed that multiphase injury is characterized by overlapping cell death phenotypes. Shrinkage, membrane blebbing, chromatin condensation, nucleosomal DNA fragmentation and the formation of apoptotic bodies were observed. The most striking alteration observed in the electron microscopy was the fragmentation and rarefaction of the neuron processes network. Degenerated terminal synapses, cell debris and apoptotic bodies were observed among the fragmented fibers. Numerous large vacuoles as well as swollen mitochondria and dilated Golgi were noted. Necrotic signs such as a large amount of cellular debris and membrane fragmentation were observed mainly when the cells were exposed to highest concentration of the PLA2-neurotoxins. PLA2s exposed cultures showed cytoplasmic vacuoles filled with cell debris, clusters of mitochondria presented mitophagy-like structures that are in accordance to patterns of programmed cell death by autophagy. Finally, we demonstrated that the sPLA2s, Mlx-8 and Mlx-9, isolated from the Micrurus lemniscatus snake venom induce a hybrid cell death with apoptotic, autophagic and necrotic features. Furthermore, this study suggests that the augment in free cytosolic Ca(2+) and mitochondrial dysfunction are involved in the neurotoxicity of Elapid coral snake venom sPLA2s.

Effects of dissolved oxygen levels and the role of extra- and intracellular amino acid concentrations upon the metabolism of mammalian cell lines during batch and continuous cultures

The effects of dissolved oxygen and the concentration of essential amino acids upon the metabolism of two mammalian cell lines (rCHO producing human active (t-PA) and a mouse-mouse hybridoma) were investigated in batch, chemostat, and perfusion cultures. Intracellular amino acid concentrations were measured for both cell lines during repeated batch cultures and the K(S)-values for the essential amino acids were calculated using Monod equations via computer simulation. The K(S)-values were in the range of 10 mmol L(-1) and the pool of most intracellular amino acids remained constant at about 10-100 fold higher in concentration than in the medium. No significant differences were observed between the hybridoma and CHO cell. The specific nutrient uptake rates corresponded with the cell specific growth rate and the effects of reduced dissolved oxygen concentrations only became evident when the DO dropped below 5% of air saturation (critical concentration below 1%). Nevertheless, a correlation between nutrient concentration and specific oxygen uptake was detected.

Daunorubicin induces cell death via activation of apoptotic signalling pathway and inactivation of survival pathway in muscle-derived stem cells

Daunorubicin (as well as other anthracyclines) is known to be toxic to heart cells and other cells in organism thus limiting its applicability in human cancer therapy. To investigate possible mechanisms of daunorubicin cytotoxicity, we used stem cell lines derived from adult rabbit skeletal muscle. Recently, we have shown that daunorubicin induces apoptotic cell death in our cell model system and distinctly influences the activity of MAP kinases. Here, we demonstrate that two widely accepted antagonistic signalling pathways namely proapoptotic JNK and prosurvival PI3K/AKT participate in apoptosis. Using the Western blot method, we observed the activation of JNK and phosphorylation of its direct target c-Jun along with inactivation of AKT and its direct target GSK in the course of programmed cell death. By means of small-molecule kinase inhibitors and transfection of cells with the genes of the components of these pathways, c-Jun and AKT, we confirm that JNK signalling pathway is proapoptotic, whereas AKT is antiapoptotic in daunorubicin-induced muscle cells. These findings could contribute to new approaches which will result in less toxicity and fewer side effects that are currently associated with the use of daunorubicin in cancer therapies.

Protection of hybridoma cells against apoptosis by a loop domain-deficient Bcl-xL protein

The ectopic expression of several members of the Bcl-2 family of anti-apoptotic proteins is a promising strategy to improve the viability of hybridoma cells in culture. However, the impact of post-translational modifications on the function of these proteins in murine hybridomas is unknown. To address this issue, the anti-apoptotic properties of a mutant of Bcl-xL devoid of the so-called "loop domain" (Bcl-xLtriangle up 46-83) were investigated using the Sp2/ O-Ag14 hybridoma model. Clones of Sp2/ O-Ag14 cells expressing Bcl-xLtriangle up 46-83 exhibited resistance against L-glutamine deprivation to similar levels than cells expressing the wild type protein. In contrast, protection against the cytotoxic effects of cycloheximide (CHX) was highly dependent on the level of expression of the Bcl-xLtriangle up 46-83 mutant. Analysis of the growth behaviour of the transfected cells showed that Bcl-xLtriangle up 46-83 was superior to the wild type protein in prolonging Sp2/ O-Agl4 cell viability in stationary batch culture. Furthermore, the prolongation of cell viability in batch culture was directly proportional to the level of expression of the mutated protein. Our results indicate that removal of the loop domain improves the anti-apoptotic activity of Bcl-xL in hybridoma cells grown in stationary batch culture.

Kinetic characterization of vero cell metabolism in a serum-free batch culture process

A global kinetic study of the central metabolism of Vero cells cultivated in a serum-free medium is proposed in the present work. Central metabolism including glycolysis, glutaminolysis, and tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA) was demonstrated to be saturated by high flow rates of consumption of the two major substrates, glucose, and glutamine. Saturation was reavealed by an accumulation of metabolic intermediates and amino acids, by a high production of lactate needed to balance the redox pathway, and by a low participation of the carbon flow to the TCA cycle supply. Different culture conditions were set up to reduce the central metabolism saturation and to better balance the metabolic flow rates between lactate production and energetic pathways. From these culture conditions, substitutions of glutamine by other carbon sources, which have lower transport rates such as asparagine, or pyruvate in order to shunt the glycolysis pathway, were successful to better balance the central metabolism. As a result, an increase of the cell growth with a concomitant decrease of cell death and a better distribution of the carbon flow between TCA cycle and lactate production occurred. We also demonstrated that glutamine was a major carbon source to supply the TCA cycle in Vero cells and that a reduction of lactate production did not necessary improve the efficiency of the Vero cell metabolism. Thus, to adapt the formulation of the medium to the Vero cell needs, it is important to provide carbon substrates inducing a regulated supply of carbon in the TCA cycle either through the glycolysis or through other pathways such as glutaminolysis. Finally, this study allowed to better understand the Vero cell behavior in serum-free medium which is a valuable help for the implementation of this cell line in serum-free industrial production processes.

Dissolved oxygen and pH profile evolution after cryovial thaw and repeated cell passaging in a T-75 flask

Routine cell culture is done in small-scale disposable vessels (typically 0.1-100 mL volumes) in academia and industry. Despite their wide use in bioprocess development (i.e., process optimization and process validation), miniature process scouting devices (PSDs) are considered "black boxes" because they are generally not equipped with sensors. In this study, we show that on-line monitoring of dissolved oxygen (DO) and pH in a T-75 flask-based PSD can be achieved during cell passaging and that this information can be linked to different cellular metabolic states. In this case, on-line monitoring of DO and pH show three distinctive metabolic regions in passages 1-18, 19-28, 29-54 and in particular, the shift in the pH curve, the specific oxygen uptake rate (q(O2)), and the lactate production rate to the oxygen consumption rate yield (Y(Lac/ox)) confirm the existence of these distinctive metabolic regions. These findings are particularly useful because they show that sensor equipped PSDs can help to monitor cell culture behavior after thaw, in pre- and seed culture prior to scale-up and in development/optimization studies. Such routine monitoring will help to develop more consistent cell culture techniques.

The effect of Bcl-2, YAMA, and XIAP over-expression on apoptosis and adenovirus production in HEK293 cell line

Many viruses induce cell death and lysis as part of their replication and dissemination strategy, and in many cases features of apoptosis are observed. Attempts have been made to further increase productivity by prolonging cell survival via the over-expression of anti-apoptotic genes. Here, we extend the study to investigate the association between virus replication and apoptosis, pertinent to large-scale vector production for gene therapy. Infection of an HEK293 cell line with a replication defective type-5-adenovirus expressing a GFP reporter (Ad5GFP) resulted in rapid decline in viability associated with increased virus titer. The over-expression of bcl-2 resulted in improved cell resistance to apoptosis and prolonged culture duration, but reduced virus specific and total productivity. In contrast, the over-expression of pro-caspase-3 (Yama/CPP32/apopain) resulted in reduced cell survival but increased virus productivity. The treatment of infected cells with caspase inhibitors support the preposition that caspase-3 dependent apoptosis, and to a lesser degree caspase-9 dependent apoptosis, represent important steps in virus production, thus implicating the intrinsic apoptosis pathway in the production of adenovirus from HEK293 cells. The suppression of apoptosis by the over-expression of XIAP (inhibitors of caspase family cell death proteases) further shows that caspase-mediated activation plays an important role in virus infection and maturation.

Induction of mammalian cell death by simple shear and extensional flows

In this work we investigated whether the type of shear flow, to which cells are exposed, influences the initiation of cell death. It is shown that mammalian cells, indeed, distinguish between discrete types of flow and respond differently. Two flow devices were employed to impose accurate hydrodynamic flow fields: uniform steady simple shear flow and oscillating extensional flow. To distinguish between necrotic and apoptotic cell death, fluorescence activated cell sorting and the release of DNA in the culture supernatant was used. Results show that Chinese Hamster Ovaries and Human Embryonic Kidney cells will enter the apoptotic pathway when subjected to low levels of hydrodynamic stress (around 2.0 Pa) in oscillating, extensional flow. In contrast, necrotic death prevails when the cells are exposed to hydrodynamic stresses around 1.0 Pa in simple shear flow or around 500 Pa in extensional flow. These threshold values at which cells enter the respective death pathway should be avoided when culturing cells for recombinant protein production to enhance culture longevity and productivity.

Anti-apoptotic genes Aven and E1B-19K enhance performance of BHK cells engineered to express recombinant factor VIII in batch and low perfusion cell culture

The engineering of production cell lines to express anti-apoptotic genes has been pursued in recent years due to potential process benefits, including enhanced cell survival, increased protein expression, and improved product quality. In this study, a baby hamster kidney cell line secreting recombinant factor VIII (BHK-FVIII) was engineered to express the anti-apoptotic genes Aven and E1B-19K. In high cell density shake flask culture evaluation, 11 clonal cell lines expressing either E1B-19K or a combination of Aven and E1B-19K showed improved survival compared to both parental and blank vector cell line controls. These cell lines exhibited lower caspase-3 activation and reduced Annexin-V binding compared to the controls. Parental and blank vector cell lines were less than 50% viable after 48 h of exposure to thapsigargin while cell lines expressing E1B-19K with or without Aven maintained viabilities approaching 90%. Subsequently, the best Aven-E1B-19K candidate cell line was compared to the parental cell line in 12-L perfusion bioreactor studies. Choosing the appropriate perfusion rates in bioreactors is a bioprocess optimization issue, so the bioreactors were operated at sequentially lower specific perfusion rates, while maintaining a cell density of 2 x 10(7) viable cells/mL. The viability of the parental cell line declined from nearly 100% at a perfusion rate of 0.5 nL/cell/day to below 80% viability, with caspase-3 activity exceeding 15%, at its lower perfusion limit of 0.15 nL/cell/day. In contrast, the Aven-E1B-19K cell line maintained an average viability of 94% and a maximum caspase-3 activity of 2.5% even when subjected to a lower perfusion minimum of 0.1 nL/cell/day. Factor VIII productivity, specific growth rate, and cell size decreased for both cell lines at lower perfusion rates, but the drop in all cases was larger for the parental cell line. Specific consumption of glucose and glutamine and production of lactate were consistently lower for the Aven-E1B-19K culture. Furthermore, the yield of ammonia from glutamine increased for the Aven-E1B-19K cell line relative to the parent to suggest altered metabolic pathways following anti-apoptosis engineering. These results demonstrate that expression of anti-apoptotic genes Aven and E1B-19K can increase the stability and robustness of an industrially relevant BHK-FVIII mammalian cell line over a wide range of perfusion rates.

Enhanced cell culture performance using inducible anti-apoptotic genes E1B-19K and Aven in the production of a monoclonal antibody with Chinese hamster ovary cells

Mammalian cells are used for the production of numerous biologics including monoclonal antibodies. Unfortunately, mammalian cells can lose viability at later stages in the cell culture process. In this study, the effects of expressing the anti-apoptosis genes, E1B-19K and Aven, separately and in combination on cell growth, survival, and monoclonal antibody (MAb) production were investigated for a commercial Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) mammalian cell line. CHO cells were observed to undergo apoptosis following a model insult, glucose deprivation, and at later stages of batch cell culture. The CHO cell line was then genetically modified to express the anti-apoptotic proteins E1B-19K and/or Aven using an ecdysone-inducible expression system. Stable transfected pools induced to express Aven or E1B-19K alone were found to survive 1-2 days longer than the parent cell line following glucose deprivation while the expression of both genes in concert increased cell survival by 3 days. In spinner flask batch studies, a clonal isolate engineered to express both anti-apoptosis genes exhibited a longer operating lifetime and higher final MAb titer as a result of higher viable cell densities and viabilities. Interestingly, survival was increased in the absence of an inducer, most likely as a result of leaky expression of the anti-apoptosis genes confirmed in subsequent PCR studies. In fed-batch bioreactors, the expression of both anti-apoptosis genes resulted in higher growth rates and cell densities in the exponential phase and significantly higher viable cell densities, viabilities, and extended survival during the post-exponential phase. As a result, the integral of viable cells (IVC) was between 40 and 100% higher for cell lines engineered to express both Aven and E1B-19K in concert, and the operational lifetime of the fed-batch bioreactors was increased from 2 to 5 days. The maximum titers of MAb were also increased by 40-55% for bioreactors containing cells expressing Aven and E1B-19K. These increases in volumetric productivity arose primarily from enhancements in viable cell density over the course of the fed-batch culture period since the specific productivities for the cells expressing anti-apoptosis genes were comparable or slightly lower than the parental hosts. These results demonstrate that expression of anti-apoptosis genes can enhance culture performance and increase MAb titers for mammalian CHO cell cultures especially under conditions such as extended fed-batch bioreactor operation.

Monitoring of dissolved oxygen and cellular bioenergetics within a pancreatic substitute

This work investigated the use of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy in combination with a mathematical model of an encapsulated cell system as a method for rapidly assessing the status of a pancreatic substitute. To validate this method, an in vitro experiment was performed in which the encapsulated cells were perfused in an NMR-compatible system and the dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration of the perfusing medium was lowered from 0.20 to 0.05 mM, then returned to 0.20 mM in a stepwise fashion. The cellular metabolic activity and bioenergetics were evaluated by measuring the oxygen consumption rate (via DO sensors) and nucleotide triphosphate levels (via (31)P NMR). By incorporating a perfluorocarbon emulsion into the alginate beads, the cellular oxygenation state was monitored by measuring the average intrabead DO (AIDO) concentration by (19)F NMR. The in vitro measurements were then compared with model predictions based on the measured external DO concentration and time. Model-predicted cell growth and AIDO closely matched the experimentally acquired data. As the DO concentrations both external to and within the pancreatic substitute are needed to apply this methodology in vivo, the feasibility of measuring the DO concentration from two distinct bead populations implanted in the peritoneal cavity of mice was established. It is concluded that PFC incorporation and (19)F NMR measurements, in combination with a mechanistic model of the encapsulated system, allow the tracking of the state of a pancreatic substitute in vitro and potentially in vivo.

Glycosylation of an immunoglobulin produced from a murine hybridoma cell line: The effect of culture mode and the anti-apoptotic gene,bcl-2

The impact of bcl-2 over-expression on the glycosylation pattern of an antibody produced by a bcl-2 transfected hybridoma cell line (TB/C3.bcl-2) was investigated in suspension batch, continuous and high cell density culture (Flat hollow fibre, Tecnomouse system). In all culture modes bcl-2 over-expression resulted in higher cell viability. Analysis of the glycans from the IgG of batch cultures showed that >95% of the structures were neutral core fucosylated asialo biantennary oligosaccharides with variable terminal galactosylation (G0f, G1f and G2f) consistent with previous analysis of glycans from the conserved site at Asn-297 of the IgG protein. The galactosylation index (GI) was determined as an indicator of the glycan profile (=(G2 + 0.5* G1)/(G0 + G1 + G2)). GI values in control cultures were comparable to bcl-2 cultures during exponential growth (0.53) but declined toward the end of the culture when there was a loss in cell viability. Low dilution rates in chemostat culture were associated with reduced galactosylation of the IgG glycans in both cell lines. However, at the higher dilution rates the GI for IgG was consistently higher in the TB/C3.bcl-2 cultures. In the hollow fibre bioreactor the galactosylation of the IgG glycans was considerably lower than in suspension batch or continuous cultures with GI values averaging 0.38. Similar low galactosylation values have been found previously for high density cell cultures and these are consistent with the low values obtained when the dissolved oxygen level is maintained at a low value (10%) in controlled suspension cultures of hybridomas.

Regulating apoptosis in mammalian cell cultures

Cell culture technology has become a widely accepted method used to derive therapeutic and diagnostic protein products. Mammalian cells adapted to grow in bioreactors now play an integral role in the development of these biologicals. A major limiting factor determining the output efficiency of mammalian cell cultures however, is apoptosis or programmed cell death. Methods to delay apoptosis and increase the longevity of cell cultures can lead to more economical processes. Researchers have shown that both genetic and chemical strategies to block apoptotic signals can increase cell culture productivity. Here, we discuss various strategies which have been implemented to improve cellular viabilities and productivities in batch cultures.

Combining caspase and mitochondrial dysfunction inhibitors of apoptosis to limit cell death in mammalian cell cultures

Apoptosis is now recognized as a significant problem in mammalian cell culture. Therefore, in this study, a single gene and multigene approach to inhibit apoptosis has been examined. Stable Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines were generated to overexpress different single, dual, and triple combinations of three apoptosis inhibitor genes. Two upstream inhibitors involved in the mitochondrial pathway, Bcl-X(L) and Aven, were expressed in addition to a downstream inhibitor of caspases. The caspase inhibitor, a variant of XIAP containing only the caspase inhibitory BIR domains (XIAP-BIRs), has been shown previously to enhance viabilities in mammalian cultures. Stable clonal cell lines were generated and tested for three apoptotic insults: Sindbis virus infection, the chemical reagent etoposide, and spent medium. For all single gene experiments, the Bcl-X(L)-containing cell lines provided superior protection to either the Aven- or XIAP-BIRs-containing cell lines following initial exposure to the insults. However, the cell lines expressing two or more anti-apoptosis proteins were more effective at inhibiting cell death than those expressing just one anti-apoptosis gene. The cell lines overexpressing Bcl-X(L) in combination with XIAP-BIRs were especially effective in delaying cell death for all three apoptotic insults. Expression of all three anti-apoptosis genes in concert was only slightly more effective than using Bcl-X(L) and XIAP-BIRs for some insults. During exposure to spent medium, CHO-BIRS + Aven + BclX(L) was the best inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) initially, whereas CHO-BIRs + BclX(L) was particularly effective at later times of the experiment. In conclusion, the utilization of a mitochondrial dysfunction inhibitor used in combination with a caspase inhibitor was more effective in thwarting the progression of apoptosis than either inhibitor expressed individually. Thus, the concurrent expression of multiple apoptosis inhibitors may be the most effective strategy to increase survival of mammalian cells in culture.

RNAi suppression of Bax and Bak enhances viability in fed-batch cultures of CHO cells

Bcl-2 family proteins play a crucial role in the regulation of the mitochondrial pathway that leads to apoptosis. Members of the Bcl-2 family can be divided into the anti-apoptotic proteins such as Bcl-2 and Bcl-X(L), and the pro-apoptotic proteins such as Bax and Bak and the BH3-only proteins. In this study, siRNA constructs to silence the Bax and Bak genes in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were generated. Stable CHO cell lines in which the expression of Bax and Bak were significantly knocked down were screened by Western blot analysis and confirmed by RT-PCR. CHO cells with both Bax and Bak knocked down showed a clear resistance against cytotoxic lectins and UV irradiation-induced apoptosis. Compared to original CHO-K1 cells, these cells also survived longer when cultured under extreme conditions such as complete nutrient depletion or in high-osmolality medium. CHO cells with both Bax and Bak genes knocked down displayed an extended lifespan as well as higher viable cell densities in fed-batch cultures, both in adherent form on microcarrier beads and in suspension. The IFN-gamma productivity by a rCHO IFN-gamma cell line in which both Bak and Bax were knocked down increased by 35% compared to the control cells. These results indicate that the genetic inactivation of Bax and Bak in recombinant CHO cells can be an effective strategy in delaying the onset of apoptosis in batch and fed-batch cultures.

Over-expression of hTERT in CHO K1 results in decreased apoptosis and reduced serum dependency

The enzyme telomerase plays a crucial role in cellular proliferation. By adding hexameric repeats to the chromosome ends, it prevents telomeric loss and, thus entry into senescence of limited life span cells. It is unclear, however, what would be the effect of over-expressing telomerase in an immortalised cell line, characterised by unlimited life span and high levels of apoptosis under sub-optimal growth conditions. In order to address this question, we have transfected the immortal cell line CHO K1 with the human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) catalytic subunit. Differences in the growth profile and apoptosis levels between the cells over-expressing hTERT (Telo) and the cells containing mock vector were found under standard growth conditions. Similarly, the Telo cells showed lower levels of apoptosis, greater attachment tendency and higher viable cell density under serum-deprived conditions compared to the control cell line, suggesting a major role for hTERT over-expression in stressed cultures. Using a mouse cDNA microarray, the collagen type III and V genes were shown to have at least a 10-fold higher expression in the Telo cells than the control cells, suggesting a role of hTERT in the cell attachment pathways.

Alterations in protein expression in HL-60 cells during etoposide-induced apoptosis modulated by the caspase inhibitor ZVAD.fmk

DNA topoisomerase inhibitors induce a specific signaling cascade that promotes an active apoptotic caspase-dependent cell death process. However, little is known about the initial signals elicited by these agents. In the present study, we compared apoptosis in HL-60 cells treated either with the chemotherapeutic drug etoposide (VP16) alone or combined with the broad caspase inhibitor ZVAD.fmk. Apoptosis was assessed by changes in cell morphology and agarose gel electrophoresis of extracted cell DNA. We found that ZVAD.fmk prevents VP16-induced DNA fragmentation and the appearance of an increased number of apoptotic cells in the culture. We also compared the effects of etoposide alone or together with the pan-caspase inhibitor ZVAD.fmk on proliferating cell nuclear antigen, Bcl-2, and actin expression in human promyelocytic leukemia HL-60 cells. In addition, we screened for proteins that were initially upregulated in a caspase-dependent manner. Indeed, some proteins were induced in the cytoplasm and subsequently accumulated in the nuclei after etoposide treatment. This process was slightly inhibited by the caspase inhibitor ZVAD.fmk. We suggest that these proteins are associated with the induction of specific signaling cascades that characterize the apoptotic cell death process.

Aven and Bcl-xL enhance protection against apoptosis for mammalian cells exposed to various culture conditions

A balance between proliferation and cell death is critical for achieving desirable high cell densities in mammalian cell culture. In this study, we evaluate a recently discovered anti-apoptotic gene, aven, and examine its effectiveness alone and in combination with a member of the Bcl-2 family, bcl-xL. The commercially popular cell line, Chinese hamster ovary (CHO), was genetically modified to constitutively express aven, bcl-xL, and the two genes in combination. Cells were exposed to several model insults that simulate severe bioreactor environments, including serum deprivation, spent medium, and Sindbis virus infection, as well as staurosporine, a known chemical inducer of apoptosis. CHO cells exhibited DNA fragmentation, a hallmark of apoptosis, after exposure to these model insults. After exposure to serum deprivation, 4- and 5-day spent medium, and staurosporine, cells expressing Aven provided limited protection against cell death when compared with the protection afforded by cells expressing Bcl-xL alone. However, the highest survival levels for all insults were achieved when Aven was expressed in combination with Bcl-xL. In fact, Aven appeared to act synergistically to enhance the protective function of Bcl-xL for several insults, because the protective function of the two genes expressed together in one cell line often exceeded the additive protective levels of each anti-apoptosis gene expressed alone. Surprisingly, Aven expression provided a mildly pro-apoptotic response in CHO isolates infected with Sindbis virus. However, CHO cells expressing both Bcl-xL and Aven showed protection against Sindbis virus infection due to the inhibitory properties of the bcl-xL anti-apoptosis gene. This study shows that combinatorial anti-apoptosis cell engineering strategies may be the most effective mechanisms for providing extended protection against cell death in mammalian cell culture.

Connexins and apoptotic transformation

We examined the influence of connexin (Cx) expression on the development of apoptosis in HeLa parental cells (coupling deficient cell line) and HeLa cells expressing wild-type Cx43 and Cxs fused with enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP). EGFP was attached to the C-terminus of Cx32 and Cx43, Cx32-EGFP and Cx43-EGFP, respectively, and to the N-terminus of Cx32, EGFP-Cx32. All fusion proteins assembled into junctional plaques (JPs) at areas of cell-cell contact, but only the C-terminal fusion proteins formed functional gap junction (GJ) channels as well as hemichannels. In each cell line, apoptosis was induced by treatment with various agents including anisomycin, camptothecin, cis-platinum, colchicine, cycloheximide, etoposide, staurosporin and taxol. Using fluorescence microscopy, time-lapse imaging and dual whole-cell voltage clamp techniques, we correlated the changes in functional properties of GJ channels and Cx distribution with the progression of apoptosis based on cells' labeling with acridine orange and ethidium bromide (EB). The early phase of apoptosis (a viable apoptotic (VA) state) was characterized by shrinkage of the cells and by increased internalization of JPs accompanied by decreased cell-cell coupling. The apoptotic reagents had no direct effect on electrical cell-cell coupling. Transformation from a VA to a nonviable apoptotic (NVA) state was faster in HeLa cells expressing Cx43 or Cx43-EGFP than in HeLa parental cells. The potent GJ uncoupler, octanol, slowed the transition of HelaCx43-EGFP cells into a NVA state. In the absence of apoptotic reagents, the rate of EB uptake was higher in HeLaCx43-EGFP than in HeLa parental cells consistent with the presence of open Cx43-EGFP hemichannels. However, in both cell lines the rate of EB uptake decreased proportionally during the development of apoptosis suggesting that membrane permeability ascribed to Cx hemichannels is reduced. Cells expressing Cx32-EGFP and EGFP-Cx32 demonstrate the same apoptotic patterns as HeLaCx43-EGFP and HeLa parental cells, respectively. Intracellular levels of ATP in HeLaCx43-EGFP cells were substantially lower than in HeLa parental cells, and ATP added to the medium abolished the accelerated transition from a VA to a NVA state in HeLaCx43-EGFP cells. In summary, Cx32 or Cx43 accelerates transformation of cells into a NVA state or secondary necrosis and this depends on the ability of Cxs to form functional GJ channels and hemichannels.

Bcl-xL expression interferes with the effects of L-glutamine supplementation on hybridoma cultures

While feeding protocols and ectopic expression of anti-apoptotic genes have been used to improve the viability of hybridoma cell lines, the effect of the expression levels of survival genes on the behavior of hybridomas following nutrient supplementation is unknown. In this study, we compared the behavior of the Sp2/0-Ag14 hybridoma (Bcl-xL(low)) and the P3x63-Ag8.653 myeloma (Bcl-xL(high)) following culture supplementation with the amino acid L-glutamine (L-Gln). Our data revealed that L-Gln addition substantially increased Sp2/0-Ag14 cell viability and total cell density, concomitant with a decrease in the rate of cell death. This effect was not seen when other amino acids or D-glucose (D-Glc) replaced L-Gln. The improvement in the culture behavior of Sp2/0-Ag14 cells was attributed to a reduction in the rate of accumulation of apoptotic cells. On the other hand, L-Gln supplementation had only a limited effect on the growth of the P3x63-Ag8.653 cells. Interestingly, Sp2/0-Ag14 cells over-expressing Bcl-xL showed a culture behavior upon L-Gln complementation that was similar to the P3x63-Ag8.653 myeloma. These results suggest that the anti-apoptotic gene expression profile of hybridoma cells can markedly impact on the beneficial effects afforded by nutrient supplementation.

Study of caspase inhibitors for limiting death in mammalian cell culture

Apoptosis in mammalian cell culture is associated with decreased bioproduct yields and can be inhibited through altering the intracellular signaling pathways mediating programmed cell death. In this study, we evaluated the capacity to inhibit caspases to maintain high viable cell numbers in CHO and 293 cultures. Two genetic caspase inhibitors, XIAP and CrmA, were examined along with a mutant of each, XIAP-BIR123NC, which contains three BIR domains but lacks the RING finger, and CrmA-DQMD, which has CrmA's pseudosubstrate site replaced with that of another caspase inhibitor, p35. Stable CHO pooled and 293 clonal cell lines expressing each protein were exposed to apoptotic insults, including spent medium, Sindbis virus, and etoposide. For each insult the mutated protein resulted in higher viabilities than its wild-type counterpart. However, the mutants provided different levels of protection, depending on the insult considered. CrmA-DQMD was the preferred inhibitor for spent medium-induced apoptosis, whereas XIAP-BIR123NC conferred better protection for etoposide-induced death. Addition of Z-VAD.fmk to the genetically engineered cells enhanced viabilities in the presence of spent medium or etoposide; however, the largest increases in viability were experienced by the control cells, indicating an overlap in caspase inhibition between the genetic and chemical inhibitors. Finally, parental 293 cells were treated with caspase-8 and -9 inhibitors, Z-IETD.fmk and Z-LEHD.fmk, in concert with spent medium or etoposide exposure. Spent medium-induced death was delayed more readily with the caspase-8 inhibitors, CrmA-DQMD and Z-IETD.fmk, and etoposide-induced death was stalled more so with XIAP-BIR123NC and Z-LEHD.fmk. These results suggest that the apoptosis pathways induced and the level of protection afforded by a particular caspase inhibitor may vary with the insult considered.

Inducible expression of Bcl-XL restricts apoptosis resistance to the antibody secretion phase in hybridoma cultures

B-cell hybridomas are widely used to produce monoclonal antibodies via large-scale cell culture. Unfortunately, these cells are highly sensitive to apoptotic death under conditions of nutrient deprivation observed at the plateau phase of batch cultures. Previous work has indicated that constitutive high-level expression of antiapoptotic genes in hybridoma cells could delay apoptosis, resulting in higher cell densities and prolonged viability. However, the constitutive high-level expression of antiapoptotic genes has been shown to have detrimental effects on genomic stability of other types of cultured cells. Inducible gene expression may be used to avoid this problem. In the present study, we first constructed an expression vector in which the promoter of a mammalian metallothionein (MT) gene drives the expression of bcl-XL in response to metal exposure. The vector was then used to exogenously control the expression of bcl-XL in D5 hybridoma cells. Our data show that stably transfected D5 cells (4G1.D9) expressed high levels of Bcl-X(L) following overnight exposure to ZnSO(4) concentrations (50 to 100 microM) that did not affect control cells. The level of Bcl-X(L) expressed after ZnSO(4) induction was sufficient to prevent apoptosis experimentally induced by cycloheximide and allowed 4G1.D9 cells to grow at higher densities and remain viable for prolonged periods in suboptimal culture conditions. The use of inducible bcl-XL expression permits extension of the viability of cultured B-cell hybridomas during the antibody secretion phase without the adverse genetic effects associated with constitutive long-term bcl-XL expression.

Observations on the shear damage to different animal cells in a concentric cylinder viscometer

A clear distinction is made between damage to the population of cells and damage to individual cells on exposure to shear stress. Work on mechanical damage to animal cells in suspension is reported for six different cell lines. Precisely controlled shears of 1 Pa, 10 Pa, and 100 Pa were generated in a viscometer and distortions in morphology of the cells-for instance, the formation of transient pores, cytoplasmic extrusions, and ghost-cell membranes-are presented with photographic evidence. Low shears are shown to be just as damaging as the higher shears, although the type of damage is different. It follows that bioreactors should be operated at intermediate shear levels for optimal yield. A mechanism to account for the unexpected stability of animal cells at intermediate levels of shear is presented.

Characterization of bimodal cell death of insect cells in a rotating-wall vessel and shaker flask

In previous publications, we reported the benefits of a high-aspect rotating-wall vessel (HARV) over conventional bioreactors for insect-cell cultivation in terms of reduced medium requirements and enhanced longevity. To more fully understand the effects that HARV cultivation has on longevity, the present study characterizes the mode and kinetics of Spodoptera frugiperda cell death in this quiescent environment relative to a shaker-flask control. Data from flow cytometry and fluorescence microscopy show a greater accumulation of apoptotic cells in the HARV culture, by a factor of at least 2 at the end of the cultivation period. We present a kinetic model of growth and bimodal cell death. The model is unique for including both apoptosis and necrosis, and further, transition steps within the two pathways. Kinetic constants reveal that total cell death is reduced in the HARV and the accumulation of apoptotic cells in this vessel results from reduced depletion by lysis and secondary necrosis. The ratio of early apoptotic to necrotic cell formation is found independent of cultivation conditions. In the model, apoptosis is only well represented by an integral term, which may indicate its dependence on accumulation of some factor over time; in contrast, necrosis is adequately represented with a first-order term. Cell-cycle analysis shows the percent of tetraploid cells gradually decreases during cultivation in both vessels. For example, between 90% and 70% viability, tetraploid cells in the HARV drop from 43 +/- 1% to 24 +/- 4%. The data suggests the tetraploid phase as the likely origin for apoptosis in our cultures. Possible mechanisms for these changes in bimodal cell death are discussed, including hydrodynamic forces, cell-cell interactions, waste accumulation, and mass transport. These studies may benefit insect-cell cultivation by increasing our understanding of cell death in culture and providing a means for further enhancing culture longevity. Copyright 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Apoptosis-resistant E1B-19K-expressing NS/0 myeloma cells exhibit increased viability and chimeric antibody productivity under perfusion culture conditions

We have shown previously that recombinant NS/0 myelomas expressing sufficient amounts of E1B-19K were resistant to apoptosis occurring in the late phase of batch culture and under stressful conditions such as cultivation in glutamine-free medium or following heat shock. However, no significant increase in monoclonal antibodies (MAb) was observed during the prolonged stationary phase of these batch cultures. Here, we show that E1B-19K can enhance cell survival and improve MAb productivity in high cell density perfusion culture. Typically, lymphoid cells grown under steady state in perfusion exhibit decreasing viabilities with concomitant accumulation of apoptotic cells. By modulating the ability of these cells to resist to induction of apoptosis in low nutrient environment, a 3-fold decrease in specific death rate from 0.22 day-1 for NS/0 control to 0.07 day-1 for E1B-19K cells was achieved, resulting in a significant improvement in cell viability throughout perfusion. E1B-19K cells at the perfusion plateau phase also exhibited a 3-fold reduction in specific growth rate concomitant with a lower percentage of S and higher percentage of G1 phase cells. This was associated with a 40% decrease in specific oxygen consumption rate, likely related to a reduction in the specific consumption rates of limiting nutrient(s). Expression of E1B-19K consequently had a significant impact on the steady-state viable cell density, allowing maintenance of 11.5 x 10(6) E1B-19K cells/mL versus 5.9 x 10(6) control NS/0 cells/mL for the same amount of fresh medium brought into the system (half a volume per day). Whereas MAb concentrations found in perfusion culture of control NS/0 myelomas were almost 3-fold higher than those found in batch culture; in the case of E1B-19K-expressing myelomas, the MAb concentration in perfusion was more than 7-fold higher than in batch. This was attributable to the 2-fold increase in viable cell plateau and to a 40% increase in the perfusion to batch ratio of specific MAb productivity (2.2-fold for E1B-19K myelomas versus 1.6-fold for NS/0 control).

Dose-dependent reduction of apoptosis in nutrient-limited cultures of NS/0 myeloma cells transfected with the E1B-19K adenoviral gene

It is now well documented that apoptosis represents the prevalent mode of death in lymphoid cultures and occurs spontaneously in late-exponential phase of batch cultures following nutrient exhaustion. In an attempt to enhance the cell survival of these cell lines, we have initially engineered nonproducing NS/0 myeloma cells with a vector expressing the adenoviral E1B-19K protein. NS/0 cells transfected with E1B-19K were found to be more resistant to apoptosis occurring in the late phase of batch culture and under stressful conditions such as cultivation in glutamine-free medium or following heat shock. In this study, we have characterised a number of NS/0 subclones constitutively expressing different levels of E1B-19K, as well as several subclones in which the expression of E1B-19K was regulated by a tetracycline-controllable gene switch. We have found that a threshold E1B-19K level was required in order to achieve protection against apoptosis. The extent of resistance against cell death induced by nutrient deprivation in glutamine-free medium and in the late phase of batch cultures correlated with the level of E1B-19K expression up to an optimal level where further increases in E1B-19K levels did not result in significant additional protection. To assess the effects of E1B-19K on antibody productivity, an apoptosis-resistant NS/0 clone was then transfected with a chimeric antibody construct. Despite their improved viability, the antibody productivity of E1B-19K clones in batch culture was not significantly improved. Moreover, while the use of E1B-19K considerably delayed cell death, cells eventually died by apoptosis. Surprisingly, E1B-19K had no beneficial effect on the efficiency of fusion of NS/0 myelomas and splenocytes for the generation of hybridoma cells. Furthermore, the resulting hybridomas, although expressing E1B-19K at levels comparable to the myeloma parent, were no longer resistant to apoptosis. This indicates that the ability of E1B-19K to prevent apoptosis is not only dose-dependent but also seems to be cell-type dependent.

Use of intracellular pH and annexin-V flow cytometric assays to monitor apoptosis and its suppression by bcl-2 over-expression in hybridoma cell culture

Accurate identification and quantitation of apoptosis is essential for developing efficient strategies for optimisation of culture viability and productivity in cell lines of industrial significance. We have examined the possibility of using carboxy-seminaphthorhodafluor-1-acetoxymethylester (carboxy SNARF-1-AM), a pH sensitive fluoroprobe and FITC-labelled annexin V (AV), a probe specific to phosphatidylserine exposed on the surface of apoptotic cells, to monitor apoptosis and to determine the relationship between intracellular pH (pHi), apoptosis and cell cycle in hybridoma cells. Temporal changes in the distribution of proliferative capacity (S phase), metabolic activity (pHi), and cell death population dynamics were effectively and reliably determined using flow cytometry. Intracellular acidification was shown to precede the occurrence of apoptosis during batch culture and after treatment with campothecin, staurosporine and under adverse bioreactor conditions such as glutamine deprivation and oxygen deficiency. These results showed that the decrease in pHi can be used as an indicator of cellular deterioration and cell death. AV in combination with propidium iodide permitted the identification of viable, transient apoptotic and necrotic cells in heterogeneous cultures of control (PEF) cells. Hybridoma cells over-expressing bcl-2 were protected from intracellular acidification and phosphatidylserine exposure, which was associated with the suppression of apoptosis in these cells. A decrease in pHi was apparent even before the accumulation of the normally acidic G1 phase and the development of a sub-G1 region, characteristic of apoptotic cell behaviour. The pHi assay can therefore be used as a tool to predict future cell culture performance. reserved.

Apoptosis and bioprocess technology

Optimisation of the production of biopharmaceuticals in animal cell lines has become a key area of research. The identification of apoptosis as the major mechanism of cell death during such processes has raised the importance of studies of cell death when implementing culture optimisation strategies. In this article we present an overview of the studies which have demonstrated the induction of apoptosis during the cultivation of industrially important animal cell lines. We also discuss studies which have shown that deprivation of factors such as amino acids, glucose, serum and oxygen are potent inducers of apoptosis in industrial cultures. The suppression of apoptosis under these conditions has been demonstrated by a number of recent reports, and we describe ways in which this knowledge may be applied in the development of novel solutions to some of the technical problems associated with the development of successful large scale culture process. The article concludes with a discussion of future directions for apoptosis research in bioprocess technology.

Apoptosis and cell culture technology

The importance of apoptosis in cell culture has now been widely recognised. Recent work has shown that this process is widely manifested during the in vitro cultivation of commercially important mammalian cell lines. In this review I summarise what is now known of the characteristics, significance and regulatory mechanisms of apoptosis. As the process of cell proliferation and cell death are now considered intimately related, particular attention is paid to highlight the progress and opportunities in the field of cell culture engineering. The strategies that have been undertaken to prevent the induction of apoptosis in cell culture and those which have been suggested as possibilities to improve culture productivity through the apoptosis route are discussed with given examples.

Apoptosis and its control in cell culture systems

Apoptosis is a form of programmed cell death which exhibits highly distinctive morphology. Research activity in this area has increased substantially in recent years, primarily due to the realisation that disregulation of apoptosis is involved in the development of a number of pathological conditions, including cancer and AIDS. However, it is now clear that apoptosis also represents the dominant form of cell death during the culture of industrially important cell lines. This review focuses on the induction of apoptosis during industrial cell cultures as well as the effects of the apoptosis suppresser gene bcl-2 on cell survival in conditions relevant to bioreaction environments. We also present new data which demonstrates that bcl-2 can protect cells from apoptosis induced by oxygen deprivation, a finding which has important implications for large scale and intensive cultivation of cells. We also describe experiments which suggest that bcl-2 can reduce the specific nutrient consumption rate of cells.