Oral tolerance and the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis

Oral mixture of autologous colon-extracted proteins for the Crohn’s disease: A double-blind trial

AIM: To evaluate the safety and efficacy of oral administration of Alequel™, an autologous protein-containing colon extract.

METHODS: A total of 43 patients were enrolled in a randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind trial. Patients were orally administered with autologous protein-containing colon extract three doses of autologous study drug per week for 15 wk, for a total of 45 doses. Patients were followed for safety parameters. Remission was defined as a Crohn’s disease activity index (CDAI) score of less than or equal to 150. All patients were followed for changes in subsets of T cells by fluorescence-activated cell sorting analysis.

RESULTS: Analysis was performed on a total number of evaluable patients of 14 in the study drug group and 15 in the placebo group. Treatment was well tolerated by all patients. No major treatment-related adverse events were reported or observed in any of the treated patients during the feeding or follow-up periods. Between weeks 6 and 9 of the study, six of the 14 (43%) evaluable subjects who received the study drug achieved a CDAI of 150 or lower. In contrast, five of the 15 (33%) evaluable subjects in the placebo group achieved remission. Between weeks 9 and 12, the remission rates were 50% and 33% for the drug group and placebo group, respectively. Among the drug-treated subjects who achieved remission, the effect of the drug was judged as stable in eight of the 14 subjects as measured by at least two CDAI scores indicating remission in the 15-wk treatment period. A decreased percentage of peripheral natural killer T regulatory cells (a decrease of 28% vs an increase of 16%) and an increased ratio of CD4⁺/CD8⁺ T lymphocytes (an increase of 11% vs a decrease of 9%) were noted in subjects with a significant clinical response.

CONCLUSION: Oral administration of the autologous colonic extract could be a safe and effective for the treatment of patients with moderate to severe Crohn’s disease.

Oral administration of Alequel, a mixture of autologous colon-extracted proteins for the treatment of Crohn's disease

The pathogenesis of Crohn's disease involves an immune-mediated damage to the gut mucosa. Current developed therapies are based on the use of immunosuppressive drugs that can lead to significant drug-related adverse responses. There is a need for a therapeutic strategy that is more specific and less global in its effect on the immune system. Oral tolerance is an active process wherein oral administration of antigens is associated with the induction of regulatory cells and the suppression of effector cells directed toward specific and nonspecific antigens. Studies in animal models of experimental colitis suggest that oral administration of proteins extracted from the gut can induce tolerance and alleviate the disease symptoms. Recent clinical trials showed that oral administration of Alequel, an autologous protein-containing colon extract, to patients with Crohn's disease is safe and may be effective as a therapeutic modality for treating the disease. This treatment was associated with disease-associated antigen alterations of the immune response in the patients. Oral administration of Alequel could provide a patient-tailored approach that is side-effect-free for the treatment of patients with Crohn's disease.

Oral tolerance: can we make it work?

Mucosal tolerance remains an attractive approach for the treatment of autoimmune and inflammatory diseases. The agents used in these treatments lack toxicity, can be easily administered, and enable the promotion of antigen-specific immune responses. The limited success of clinical trials over the past 2 decades has led to the fear that the beneficial effect observed in animal models cannot be repeated in humans. Successful application of mucosal tolerance for the treatment of human diseases will depend on strategies that target the correct cells in the gut-liver axis, improve antigen presentation, alter the administered dose and formulations, utilize potent mucosal adjuvants, develop immune biomarkers enabling follow-up of the effect, utilize combination therapies with other immune modulatory agents, and target the right patient populations. Here, we discuss 12 of the major questions related to oral tolerance and its clinical application to humans with immune-mediated disorders.

Oral tolerance

Multiple mechanisms of tolerance are induced by oral antigen. Low doses favor active suppression, whereas higher doses favor clonal anergy/deletion. Oral antigen induces T-helper 2 [interleukin (IL)-4/IL-10] and Th3 [transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta] T cells plus CD4+CD25+ regulatory cells and latency-associated peptide+ T cells. Induction of oral tolerance is enhanced by IL-4, IL-10, anti-IL-12, TGF-beta, cholera toxin B subunit, Flt-3 ligand, and anti-CD40 ligand. Oral (and nasal) antigen administration suppresses animal models of autoimmune diseases including experimental autoimmune encephalitis, uveitis, thyroiditis, myasthenia, arthritis, and diabetes in the non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse, plus non-autoimmune diseases such as asthma, atherosclerosis, graft rejection, allergy, colitis, stroke, and models of Alzheimer's disease. Oral tolerance has been tested in human autoimmune diseases including multiple sclerosis (MS), arthritis, uveitis, and diabetes and in allergy, contact sensitivity to dinitrochlorobenzene (DNCB), and nickel allergy. Although positive results have been observed in phase II trials, no effect was observed in phase III trials of CII in rheumatoid arthritis or oral myelin and glatiramer acetate (GA) in MS. Large placebo effects were observed, and new trials of oral GA are underway. Oral insulin has recently been shown to delay onset of diabetes in at-risk populations, and confirmatory trials of oral insulin are being planned. Mucosal tolerance is an attractive approach for treatment of autoimmune and inflammatory diseases because of lack of toxicity, ease of administration over time, and antigen-specific mechanisms of action. The successful application of oral tolerance for the treatment of human diseases will depend on dose, developing immune markers to assess immunologic effects, route (nasal versus oral), formulation, mucosal adjuvants, combination therapy, and early therapy.

Potentiation of immunological tolerance induction in adult mice by co-administration of pooled normal IgG and oral tolerogens: a potential therapeutic approach for autoimmune diseases

Oral tolerance can be defined as the inability of an adult animal to produce specific antibodies or cellular immune responses upon conventional immunization, after oral antigenic administration. Recently, the oral administration of antigens has gained renewed interest because of the possibility of inducing tolerance in nonimmunized adult animals and, consequently, opening up the theoretical possibility of preventing or treating diseases caused by malfunction of the immune system. This strategy has been proven to be useful in the prevention of allergic and autoimmune diseases in rodents, as well as in the amelioration of certain autoimmune diseases in humans. Although there is experimental and clinical evidence for the usefulness of oral tolerance in medical practice, the mechanisms responsible for this phenomenon are still poorly understood, and the results obtained are not always satisfactory. Herein, we show that the thymus is required for the induction and maintenance of oral tolerance, providing evidence that it is not a pure form of clonal deletion-based peripheral tolerance. Oral tolerance could therefore depend on the formation and release to the periphery of regulatory T cells, such as gammadelta or alphabeta T cells, by the thymus. This finding may have profound implications for the treatment of autoimmune diseases, since most of them are associated with thymic hypofunction. On the other hand, due to so far unknown mechanisms, the intraperitoneal co-administration of normal IgG to mice orally treated with tolerogen leads to a sustained and intense immunological tolerance, both in euthymic and thymectomized mice, including those of the lupus erythematosus-prone NZB x NZW lineage. This approach for inducing and maintaining tolerance in thymus-deficient conditions is discussed and put forth herein as a new evidence-based proposition for the therapy of autoimmune diseases.

Oral tolerance and gut-oriented immune response to dietary proteins

Dietary proteins induce both a local immune response characterized by IgA production and systemic immune response characterized by the production of TH2/TH3 cytokines. By influencing the class of immune response, the gut enhances the efficacy of immunity against proteins that enter the body through the diet while, at the same time, ensuring its own safety. This article reviews and summarizes the field of "oral tolerance," with emphasis on recent advancements.

Suppression of collagen-induced arthritis by oral or nasal administration of type II collagen

We directly compared the effects of oral and nasal administration of collagen type II (CII) on disease progression, cytokine production and T cell responses in DBA/1 mice. Lymphocytes were assayed for proliferation and cytokine production and cell lines established. T cells from fed or nasally treated groups proliferated significantly less and produced markedly less IFN-gamma than the non-fed immunized group 10 days after immunization and prior to onset of arthritis. T cell lines established from fed or nasally treated mice showed a pattern of cytokine production involving IL-4, IL-10 and TGF-beta, whereas T cell lines from the control group produced more IFN-gamma and IL-2. Suppression of clinical measures of arthritis was equivalent in the nasal and orally treated groups. Animals were then tested for IFN-gamma production 70 days after a booster immunization at a time when disease was apparent. Mucosally treated animals secreted less IFN-gamma as compared to controls, even at this late time point. Suppression of collagen induced arthritis (CIA) by nasal treatment of mice with CII was associated with diminished levels of TNF-alpha and IL-6 mRNA expression in the joints of tolerized mice, two cytokines known to be involved in the inflammatory and pathological process of CIA. These results demonstrate the induction of antigen specific Th2 and TGF-beta secreting regulatory cells following both oral and nasal treatment, which is associated with suppression of local inflammation in the joints and decreased Th1 type responses in the periphery throughout the course of the illness.