Chirality and stereochemical recognition in DNA-phytohormone interactions: a model approach

New Insights into Structural and Functional Roles of Indole-3-acetic acid (IAA): Changes in DNA Topology and Gene Expression in Bacteria

: Indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) is a major plant hormone that affects many cellular processes in plants, bacteria, yeast, and human cells through still unknown mechanisms. In this study, we demonstrated that the IAA-treatment of two unrelated bacteria, the Ensifer meliloti 1021 and Escherichia coli, harboring two different host range plasmids, influences the supercoiled state of the two plasmid DNAs in vivo. Results obtained from in vitro assays show that IAA interacts with DNA, leading to DNA conformational changes commonly induced by intercalating agents. We provide evidence that IAA inhibits the activity of the type IA topoisomerase, which regulates the DNA topological state in bacteria, through the relaxation of the negative supercoiled DNA. In addition, we demonstrate that the treatment of E. meliloti cells with IAA induces the expression of some genes, including the ones related to nitrogen fixation. In contrast, these genes were significantly repressed by the treatment with novobiocin, which reduces the DNA supercoiling in bacterial cells. Taking into account the overall results reported, we hypothesize that the IAA action and the DNA structure/function might be correlated and involved in the regulation of gene expression. This work points out that checking whether IAA influences the DNA topology under physiological conditions could be a useful strategy to clarify the mechanism of action of this hormone, not only in plants but also in other unrelated organisms.

DNA Damage and Chromatin Conformation Changes Confer Nonhost Resistance: A Hypothesis Based on Effects of Anti-cancer Agents on Plant Defense Responses

Over the last decades, medical research has utilized DNA altering procedures in cancer treatments with the objective of killing cells or suppressing cell proliferation. Simultaneous research related to enhancing disease resistance in plants reported that alterations in DNA can enhance defense responses. These two opposite perspectives have in common their effects on the center for gene transcription, the nuclear chromatin. A review of selected research from both anticancer- and plant defense-related research provides examples of some specific DNA altering actions: DNA helical distortion, DNA intercalation, DNA base substitution, DNA single cleavage by DNases, DNA alkylation/methylation, and DNA binding/exclusion. The actions of the pertinent agents are compared, and their proposed modes of action are described in this study. Many of the DNA specific agents affecting resistance responses in plants, e.g., the model system using pea endocarp tissue, are indeed anticancer agents. The tumor cell death or growth suppression in cancer cells following high level treatments may be accompanied with chromatin distortions. Likewise, in plants, DNA-specific agents activate enhanced expression of many genes including defense genes, probably due to the chromatin alterations resulting from the agents. Here, we propose a hypothesis that DNA damage and chromatin structural changes are central mechanisms in initiating defense gene transcription during the nonhost resistance response in plants.

Small molecule intercalation with double stranded DNA: implications for normal gene regulation and for predicting the biological efficacy and genotoxicity of drugs and other chemicals

The binding of small molecules to double stranded DNA including intercalation between base pairs has been a topic of research for over 40 years. For the most part, however, intercalation has been of marginal interest given the prevailing notion that binding of small molecules to protein receptors is largely responsible for governing biological function. This picture is now changing with the discovery of nuclear enzymes, e.g. topoisomerases that modulate intercalation of various compounds including certain antitumor drugs and genotoxins. While intercalators are classically flat, aromatic structures that can easily insert between base pairs, our laboratories reported in 1977 that a number of biologically active compounds with greater molecular thickness, e.g. steroid hormones, could fit stereospecifically between base pairs. The hypothesis was advanced that intercalation was a salient feature of the action of gene regulatory molecules. Two parallel lines of research were pursued: (1) development of technology to employ intercalation in the design of safe and effective chemicals, e.g. pharmaceuticals, nutraceuticals, agricultural chemicals; (2) exploration of intercalation in the mode of action of nuclear receptor proteins. Computer modeling demonstrated that degree of fit of certain small molecules into DNA intercalation sites correlated with degree of biological activity but not with strength of receptor binding. These findings led to computational tools including pharmacophores and search engines to design new drug candidates by predicting desirable and undesirable activities. The specific sequences in DNA into which ligands best intercalated were later found in the consensus sequences of genes activated by nuclear receptors implying intercalation was central to their mode of action. Recently, the orientation of ligands bound to nuclear receptors was found to match closely the spatial locations of ligands derived from intercalation into unwound gene sequences suggesting that nuclear receptors may be guiding ligands to DNA with remarkable precision. Based upon multiple lines of experimental evidence, we suggest that intercalation in double stranded DNA is a ubiquitous, natural process and a salient feature of the regulation of genes. If double stranded DNA is proven to be the ultimate target of genomic drug action, intercalation will emerge as a cornerstone of the future discovery of safe and effective pharmaceuticals.

Computer modeling of gibberellin-DNA binding

Computer modeling and molecular mechanics performed on the intercalation complexes of selected gibberellins or biosynthetic precursors with DNA dinucleotides revealed that under appropriate conditions the ligands insert (intercalate) between the base-paired double-stranded dinucleotide, 5'-dTdA-3'. Stabilization of the double-stranded dinucleotide after docking of a gibberellin between base pairs is inferred by the sum negative energy of hydrogen bonding and van der Waals contacts and the entropic changes which accompany the formation of each ligand-dinucleotide complex. In addition, the interactions of the gibberellins and dinucleotides, with the gibberellic acid-dinucleotide complex serving as the prototype, show optimum geometry and stereochemical hydrogen bonding recognition which are dependent upon the complementary chirality and stereochemistry of the individual components. Whether or not the gibberellins directly influence the uncoiling of DNA or gene expression at the transcriptional level via an intercalation mechanism is a matter of conjecture, albeit one that warrants intensive investigation.

Stereochemical complementarity of progesterone and cavities between base pairs in partially unwound double stranded DNA using computer modeling and energy calculations to determine degree of fit

Computer modeling was applied for the first time to investigate previously reported complementarity of progesterone and cavities formed between base pairs in partially unwound double stranded DNA. Computer graphics enabled a more objective assessment of complementarity; energy calculations provided a rigorous method to evaluate degree of fit. Graphics confirmed that the complementarity was virtually "lock and key", i.e. close contacts were formed between van der Waals surfaces in the progesterone/DNA complexes and hydrogen bonds were formed between the two carbonyl groups on opposite ends of the steroid and phosphate groups on adjacent strands of DNA. Molecular mechanics calculations revealed that insertion of the steroid resulted in a relatively stable complex i.e. both van der Waals and electrostatic energies were lowered due to favorable steric interactions and stereospecific hydrogen bonds, respectively. Three published X-ray crystal structures of progesterone exhibited similar complementarity. Ent-progesterone which does not occur naturally possessed very poor complementarity. These findings confirm that the structure of progesterone is directly reflected in the stereochemistry of DNA. While no mechanistic explanation for these results is proffered, we hypothesize that such complementarity must have played a decisive role in the evolution of steroid hormone structure and function.

Stereochemical complementary of DNA and steroid agonists and antagonists

Modelling studies in our laboratories over the past decade have demonstrated that a variety of natural products exhibit stereochemical complementarity with nucleic acids. In the case of steroid hormones, the basic cyclopentanophenanthrene skeleton fits between base pairs in partially unwound double stranded DNA; heteroatoms on the steroids form stereospecific donor/acceptor linkages to hydrogen bonding heteroatoms on the DNA. Each of the hormones appears to fit best in the site, i.e. 5'-dTdG-3'.5'dCdA-3'; the pattern of donor/acceptor linkages is unique for each type of hormonal activity. Steroid hormone agonists fit into the same site as the parent hormone; degree of fit correlates with degree of hormonal activity. Steroid hormone antagonists (e.g. RU 486; tamoxifen; anandron) fit into the same site as the agonists but possess different donor/acceptor linkages than the parent hormone; these linkages occur within the site between the base pairs or along the outside surface of the DNA helix in the major or minor grooves. A chronological review of the underlying concepts and observations leading to these discoveries is presented. Work in progress and some potential implications of the emerging technology are also discussed.

The stereochemical complementarity of DNA and reproductive steroid hormones correlates with biological activity

Modeling studies revealed that progesterone, testosterone, and estradiol are stereochemically complementary to the cavity formed between base pairs in the DNA sequence, 5'-dTdG-3' X 5'-dCdA-3'. Each steroid aligned precisely with the topography of the cavity and formed 2 stereospecific hydrogen bonds linking phosphate oxygens on adjacent DNA strands. Hydrogen bonding donor-acceptor relationships were different for each hormone. The remarkable stereochemical specificity of the hormone-DNA complexes was demonstrated by the lack of complementarity of steroid enantiomers and steroid analogs having alternate ring systems and/or changes in the position of functional groups. Fit of molecules into DNA in the manner of the parent hormone correlated with biological activity. Antagonists also fit into the cavity but differed from agonists in their hydrogen bonding linkages to DNA and/or extended out of the cavity beyond the helix. Unlike flat intercalating agents which form stable complexes with DNA, wedge shaped steroids may thus be capable of forming reversible sequence-specific complexes with DNA. We conclude that the stereochemistry of DNA can be used to predict hormonal activity.

Structure-activity relationships of some unique estrogens related to estradiol are predicted by fit into DNA

The estrogenic activity of 11 beta-acetoxy estradiol, 11 beta-hydroxy estradiol, 11 alpha-hydroxy estradiol and 9 beta-estradiol was compared to estradiol using the restoration of uterine weight and prevention of LH rise in immature ovariectomized rats as endpoints of the assay. There was a good correlation between results using the two methods and estrogenic activity was found to be in the following order: 11 beta-acetoxy estradiol greater than estradiol greater than 9 beta-estradiol greater than 11 beta-hydroxy estradiol greater than 11 alpha-hydroxy estradiol. The biological activities of these compounds could be explained on the basis of stereochemical complementarity to the structure of DNA.

Apparent stereochemical complementarity of estrogens and helical cavities between DNA base pairs: implications for the mechanism of action of steroids

The shape of the space occupied by a model of the estrogenic steroid hormone estradiol-17 beta conforms closely to a helical cavity between neighboring base pairs in partially coiled B-DNA. The orientation of estradiol-17 beta when fitted into DNA allows stereochemically complementary hydrogen bonding of both the 3- and 17 beta-hydroxyl groups to phosphate oxygens of the deoxyribose-phosphate backbone on adjacent strands. Changes in the chirality (handedness) of the steroid skeleton or in the absolute stereochemistry of hydrogen bonding groups prevent formation of complementary fits in the DNA. Synthetic estrogens can also adopt conformations which are stereochemically complementary to the cavities between base pairs. The complementary relationships between active estrogens and nucleic acids may be related to constraints on the evolution of the structure and the biological function of steroids.

Benzyl derivative facilitation of transcription in Escherichia coli at the ara and lac operon promoters: metabolite gene regulation (MGR)

A number of benzyl derivatives have been tested for their ability to induce the expression of the araBAD operon in an Escherichia coli K-12 strain. Those derivatives shown to be stimulatory include: benzoic acid (BA), para-amino benzoic acid (PABA), para-hydroxy benzoic acid (PHBA), ortho-amino benzoic acid (OABA), 3-hydroxy-4-methoxy phenylethylamine (MTA), and 4-hydroxy-3-methoxyphenol acetic acid (HVA). The araC gene product was necessary to facilitate the induction. To further characterize if the inductive effect was mediated at the level of transcription, an araBAD-tetracycline resistant (Tcr) operon fusion plasmid (pAP-B) was employed. Benzyl derivatives which induce expression of the araBAD operon in situ also induced a Tcr phenotype with pAP-B. Both indole acetic acid (IAA) and imidazole (IM), which were previously shown to circumvent the necessity for cAMP in the induction of the araBAD operon, also induced a Tcr phenotype with pAP-B. Induction of lac or other cAMP responding operons with the inducing molecules at the chromosomal level was not detectable when assessed by carbon utilization. However, a lacZYA-Tcr operon fusion plasmid (pLPI) did respond to IAA and several of the inducing benzyl derivatives. Catabolite repression of chromosomal araBAD expression was reversed when the exogenous concentration of OABA was elevated. Similar effects on the Tcr phenotypes conferred by pAP-B and pLP1 were observed when OABA or several other inducing benzyl derivatives were present exogenously.

First approximation of a stereochemical rationale for the genetic code based on the topography and physicochemical properties of "cavities" constructed from models of DNA

To examine the question of whether or not the genetic code has a stereochemical basis, we used artificial constructs of the topography and physicochemical features of unique "cavities" formed by removal of the second codon base in B-DNA. The effects of base changes on the stereochemistry of the cavities are consistent with the pattern of the genetic code. Fits into the cavities of the side chains of the 20 L amino acids involved in protein synthesis can be demonstrated by using conventional physicochemical principles of hydrogen bonding and steric constraints. The specificity of the fits is remarkably consistent with the genetic code.

Are there structural analogies between amino acids and nucleic acids?

Space-filling molecular models have been used to examine structural analogies between amino acids and nucleic acids. The three-dimensional structures of amino acid R groups appear to be stereochemically related to cavities formed by removal of single bases in double helical nucleic acids. The common L amino acids may thus be complementary to their codons.

Metabolite gene regulation of the L-arabinose operon in Escherichia coli with indoleacetic acid and other indole derivatives

The ability of indole derivatives to facilitate RNA polymerase transcription of the L-arabinose operon in Escherichia coli was shown to require the catabolite activator protein (CAP) as well as the araC gene product. Adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (cAMP) was not obligatory for araBAD transcription when the cells were grown in the presence of 1 mM indole-3-acetic acid or in the presence of indole-3-acetamide, indole-3-propionic acid, indole-3-butyric acid, or 5-hydroxyindole-3-acetic acid. However, these indole derivatives were unable to circumvent the cAMP requirement for the induction of the lactose and the maltose operons. Catabolic repression occurred when glucose was added to cells grown in the presence of L-arabinose and 1 mM indoleacetic acid or 1 mM cAMP. This effect was reversed at higher concentrations of indoleacetic acid or cAMP. The induction and the catabolite repression phenomena were quantitated by measuring the differential rate of synthesis of L-arabinose isomerase (the araA gene product). These results indicated that indole metabolites from various living systems may regulate gene expression and may be involved in "metabolite gene regulation."

Metabolite gene regulation: imidazole and imidazole derivatives which circumvent cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate in induction of the Escherichia coli L-arabinose operon

Imidazole, histidine, histamine, histidinol phosphate, urocanic acid, or imidazolepropionic acid were shown to induce the L-arabinose operon in the absence of cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate. Induction was quantitated by measuring the increased differential rate of synthesis of L-arabinose isomerase in Escherichia coli strains which carried a deletion of the adenyl cyclase gene. The crp gene product (cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate receptor protein) and the araC gene product (P2) were essential for induction of the L-arabinose operon by imidazole and its derivatives. These compounds were unable to circumvent the cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate in the induction of the lactose or the maltose operons. The L-arabinose regulon was catabolite repressed upon the addition of glucose to a strain carrying an adenyl cyclase deletion growing in the presence of L-arabinose with imidazole. These results demonstrated that several imidazole derivatives may be involved in metabolite gene regulation (23).