Dimethyl dioctadecyl ammoniumbromide as an adjuvant for delayed type hypersensitivity and cellular immunity against Semliki Forest virus in mice

Cationic liposomal vaccine adjuvants in animal challenge models: overview and current clinical status

Cationic liposome formulations can function as efficient vaccine adjuvants. However, due to the highly diverse nature of lipids, cationic liposomes have different physical-chemical characteristics that influence their adjuvant mechanisms and their relevance for use in different vaccines. These characteristics can be further manipulated by incorporation of additional lipids or stabilizers, and inclusion of carefully selected immunostimulators is a feasible strategy when tailoring cationic liposomal adjuvants for specific disease targets. Thus, cationic liposomes present a plasticity, which makes them promising adjuvants for future vaccines. This versatility has also led to a vast amount of literature on different experimental liposomal formulations in combination with a wide range of immunostimulators. Here, we have compiled information about the animal challenge models and administration routes that have been used to study vaccine adjuvants based on cationic liposomes and provide an overview of the applicability, progress and clinical status of cationic liposomal vaccine adjuvants.

Effects of DDA, CpG-ODN, and plasmid-encoded chicken IFN-gamma on protective immunity by a DNA vaccine against IBDV in chickens

This study examined the adjuvant effects of dimethyl dioctadecyl ammonium bromide (DDA), CpG oligodeoxynucleotides (CpG-ODN), and chicken interferon-γ (ChIFN-γ) on a DNA vaccine (pcDNA-VP243) against the infectious bursal disease virus (IBDV). A plasmid encoding chicken IFN-ã was constructed. Twice at 2-week intervals, two-week-old chickens were injected intramuscularly and intraperitoneally with either a DNA vaccine alone or a DNA vaccine together with the respective adjuvants. On week 2 after the second immunization, the chickens were orally challenged with the highly virulent IBDV. The groups that received the DNA vaccines plus either DDA or CpG-ODN showed significantly lower survival rates than the group that received the DNA vaccine alone. However, the survival rates for the DNA vaccine alone and for the DNA vaccine plus ChIFN-γ were similar. The chickens had no detectable antibodies to the IBDV before the challenge but all the surviving chickens in all groups except for the normal control group showed the induction of antibodies to the IBDV at day 10 after the challenge. As judged by the lymphocyte proliferation assays using the a WST-8 solution performed on the peripheral blood and splenic lymphocytes, the stimulation indices (SI) of the peripheral blood lymphocytes in all groups except for the normal control group were similar immediately before the challenge. At 10 days post-challenge, the SI for DNA vaccine plus either CpG-ODN or ChIFN-γ was similar to that of the DNA vaccine control group. For splenic lymphocytes, the SI in the DNA vaccine plus CpG-ODN and DNA vaccine plus ChIFN-γ groups were higher than for the DNA vaccine control. These results suggest that DDA actually compromises the protection against the IBDV by DNA vaccine, and CpG-ODN and IFN-γ had no significant effect.

Protective antiviral immune responses to pseudorabies virus induced by DNA vaccination using dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide as an adjuvant

To enhance the efficacy of a DNA vaccine against pseudorabies virus (PRV), we evaluated the adjuvant properties of plasmids coding for gamma interferon or interleukin-12, of CpG immunostimulatory motifs, and of the conventional adjuvants dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide in water (DDA) and sulfolipo-cyclodextrin in squalene in water. We demonstrate that a DNA vaccine combined with DDA, but not with the other adjuvants, induced significantly stronger immune responses than plasmid vaccination alone. Moreover, pigs vaccinated in the presence of DDA were protected against clinical disease and shed significantly less PRV after challenge infection. This is the first study to demonstrate that DDA, a conventional adjuvant, enhances DNA vaccine-induced antiviral immunity.

T cell reactivity to heat shock protein 60 in diabetes-susceptible and genetically protected nonobese diabetic mice is associated with a protective cytokine profile

Spontaneous onset of pancreatic beta cell destruction in the nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse is preceded by the induction of autoreactive T cells, which recognize a variety of autoantigens. The 60-kDa endogenous (murine) heat shock protein 60 (hsp60) has been proposed to be one of the key autoantigens. Here we demonstrate that subcutaneous immunization of normoglycemic NOD mice with highly homologous mycobacterial or murine hsp60 activates T cells in the spleen that produce high levels of IL-10 upon restimulation in vitro with either hsp60 protein. In time, increasing levels of hsp60-induced IL-10 could be detected in NOD mice, but not in age- and MHC class II-matched BiozziABH mice, which lack any sign of pancreatic inflammation. These results suggest that the IL-10 responses in NOD mice are primarily driven by endogenous inflammation. Genetically protected NOD-asp mice, showing a less progressive development of insulitis, demonstrated a similar increase in hsp60-induced IL-10 in time compared with wild-type NOD mice. Taken together, our results suggest that endogenous hsp60 is not a primary autoantigen in diabetes but is possibly associated with regulation of insulitis. Moreover, the capacity to respond to (self) hsp60 is independent of the MHC class II-associated genetic predisposition to diabetes.

Adjuvant modulation of immune responses to tuberculosis subunit vaccines

Mice were immunized with experimental subunit vaccines based on secreted antigens from Mycobacterium tuberculosis in a series of adjuvants, comprising incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA), dimethyl dioctadecyl ammoniumbromide (DDA), RIBI adjuvant, Quil-A saponin, and aluminum hydroxide. Immune responses induced by these vaccines were characterized by in vitro culture of primed cells, PCR analysis for cytokine mRNA, detection of specific immunoglobulin G isotypes induced, and monitoring of protective immunity to tuberculosis (TB). The study demonstrated marked differences in the immune responses induced by the different adjuvants and identified both IFA and DDA as efficient adjuvants for a TB subunit vaccine. Aluminum hydroxide, on the other hand, induced a Th2 response which increased the susceptibility of the animals to a subsequent TB challenge. DDA was further coadjuvanted with either the Th1-stimulating polymer poly(I-C) or the cytokines gamma interferon, interleukin 2 (IL-2), and IL-12. The addition of IL-12 was found to amplify a Th1 response in a dose-dependent manner and promoted a protective immune response against a virulent challenge. However, if the initial priming in the presence of IL-12 was followed by two booster injections of vaccine without IL-12, no improvement in long-term efficacy was found. This demonstrates the efficacy of DDA to promote an efficient immune response and suggests that IL-12 may accelerate this development, but not change the final outcome of a full vaccination regime.

DDA as an immunological adjuvant

As compared to other adjuvants, DDA is a moderate or strong adjuvant for humoral responses and a strong adjuvant for CMI, especially DTH responses, against different types of antigens and in both laboratory animals and larger animals. DDA can collaborate with other immunomodulating compounds resulting in further enhanced responses. Mechanisms include interactions with both antigen and components of the host immune system and possibly, multiple beneficial effects contribute to the relatively strong adjuvanticity of DDA. Toxicity of DDA is not known but severe detrimental side effects were not seen. This adjuvant can be applied in experimental vaccines and in commercial vaccines for veterinary purposes, especially if cell-mediated immunity is considered to be important. In immunology, DDA can be of use to study T helper cells responsible for DTH responses (T helper cells type 1) and to characterize T helper cell epitopes on antigens (Snijder et al., 1992).

Adjuvant effects of dimethyl dioctadecyl ammonium bromide, complete Freund's adjuvant and aluminium hydroxide on neutralizing antibody, antibody-isotype and delayed-type hypersensitivity responses to Semliki Forest virus in mice

Outbred mice were inoculated subcutaneously with inactivated Semliki Forest virus (SFV) in saline and combinations of the virus with complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) aluminium hydroxide (Al) and dimethyl dioctadecyl ammonium bromide (DDA). The immune response was evaluated for delayed-type hypersensitivity, for total ELISA antibodies and antibody-isotypes and for neutralizing antibodies. DDA was the most efficient adjuvant in inducing DTH, CFA the second and Al induced a DTH response that was only slightly higher (statistically not significant) than that induced by the inactivated virus without adjuvants. All adjuvants enhanced the production of ELISA antibodies to similar levels. However, the levels of neutralizing antibodies induced were low in mice which were inoculated with the inactivated SFV alone or mixtures of the virus with Al. DDA induced high levels of neutralizing antibodies and CFA induced intermediate levels. The pattern of antibody-isotypes induced by DDA and CFA was different from the pattern induced by the inactivated virus or by the virus mixed with Al: DDA and CFA induced low amounts of IgG1 antibodies and relatively higher amounts of IgG2a and IgG2b antibodies while the inactivated virus and the mixture of the virus with Al induced higher proportions of IgG1 antibodies. In sera from convalescent mice the majority of antibody activity resided in the IgG2a and IgG2b immunoglobulin subclasses, while IgG1 antibodies were undetectable.

Identification of a DTH-inducing T-cell epitope on the E2 membrane protein of Semliki Forest virus

Mapping of T-cell epitopes on the structural proteins of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) was performed by measuring the ability of cloned SFV protein fragments to induce delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH). The cloned SFV protein fragments were expressed as hybrid proteins with cro-beta-galactosidase in Escherichia coli from constructed recombinant plasmids. DTH reactions were measured, as footpad swelling, in BALB/c mice after immunization with whole, UV-inactivated SFV and challenge with the hybrid proteins, and vice versa, using the adjuvant dimethyl dioctadecyl ammonium bromide to enhance DTH. Only two of the tested hybrid proteins induced DTH, and these DTH reactions were equally strong. The largest DTH-inducing hybrid protein contained the N-terminal 350 amino acids of E2 and part of E3, the smallest contained only the region from amino acid residues 115 to 151 of the E2 membrane protein without any other SFV protein parts. It was concluded that the segment between amino acid residues 115 and 151 of the E2 membrane protein of SFV was responsible for the observed DTH, and thus, contains a T-cell epitope. Sequence homology with known T-cell epitopes on other proteins makes it likely that the DTH-inducing T-cell epitope is located from amino acid residues 120 to 128 of E2.

Adjuvants

A number of adjuvants of importance in veterinary vaccines are reviewed. These include mineral salt adjuvants, oil adjuvants, hydrophilic and hydrophobic bloc polymers, hydrocarbons and surface active agents. The current and future applications of these substances and their possible modes of action are discussed. Creation of an adjuvant register by the newly formed European Adjuvant Group should facilitate accumulation of information on adjuvants.

Potentiating effect of adjuvants on humoral immunity to porcine parvovirus vaccines in guinea pigs

Fourteen different adjuvants, given either in single or combined form with another compound were compared in guinea pigs for their ability to potentiate humoral immunity to porcine parvovirus (PPV) antigen after 2 vaccinations. Two injections were given, the second 3 weeks following the initial vaccination. Antibody concentrations to PPV in sera from injected animals were measured over a 5-week period by the hemagglutination inhibition test. At the conclusion of the experiment, guinea pigs injected with the following adjuvants and PPV antigen: CP-20 961 (Avridin), 50% aluminum hydroxide gel, ethylene maleic anhydride (EMA), oil and water emulsion (O/W) and dimethyl-dioctadecyl-ammonium bromide (DDA) immunologically responded with high geometric mean HI titers (380, 224 and 427, 602, 512, 1202 respectively), whereas guinea pigs receiving Emulsan, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), L-121, combinations of Emulsan/aluminum hydroxide, SDS/aluminum hydroxide and B. pertussis/aluminum hydroxide responded with low mean titers (54, 64, 18, 27, 11, 64, 14, 20 respectively). Guinea pigs injected with antigen without adjuvant responded weakly with geometric mean titers of 3.3 and 16 for the 2 groups tested. Prior to booster injection, guinea pigs immunized with 13 of the preparations had low (less than 4) or undetectable antibody titers. Antibody titers from guinea pigs receiving DDA adjuvant continued to rise throughout the duration of the experiment and at the conclusion had the highest mean titers of the groups tested (1202). The 2 groups immunized with 50% aluminum hydroxide gel had high mean titers (224, 427), but in both instances there was a wide range of titers within a group evidenced by high standard deviations. In contrast, guinea pigs receiving either DDA, CP-20 961, O/W or EMA had antibody titers within a narrow range and small standard deviation. The significance of aluminum hydroxide gel concentration on immunogenicity is discussed.

Effect of the adjuvant dimethyl dioctadecyl ammonium bromide on the humoral and cellular immune responses to encephalomyocarditis virus

The effects of the adjuvant dimethyl dioctadecyl ammonium bromide (DDA) on the immune responses to encephalomyocarditis (EMC) virus were studied in mice. The humoral response, as measured by appearance of neutralizing antibodies, was slightly enhanced in mice immunized by the intraperitoneal route. Intracutaneously, DDA almost did not affect the humoral response but resulted in distinct enhancement of delayed type hypersensitivity (DH), as measured by the footpad swelling test. DH to EMC virus was found to be antigen-specific and could be passively transferred to normal mice with peritoneal exudate cells from immunized mice. Dose-response curves for DH and humoral antibody responses to EMC virus were not concordant. Low doses induced DH on day 6 without measurable circulating antibodies; high doses gave good antibody responses but suboptimal DH reactions. Immunization conferred a state of resistance to infection with virulent EMC virus. Protection seemed more related to DH than to the prevalence of specific antibodies at the time of infection.

Comparison of effects of adjuvants on efficacy of virion envelope herpes simplex virus vaccine against labial infection of BALB/c mice

A subunit virion envelope vaccine of herpes simplex virus type 1 was evaluated for its ability to protect labially infected mice from development of the primary herpetic lesion, encephalitic death, and latent virus infection in the trigeminal ganglion. Several adjuvants, including aluminum hydroxide and polyriboinosinic acid-polyribocytidylic acid complexed with poly-L-lysine and carboxymethyl cellulose were investigated for their ability to enhance protection of the subunit vaccine and were compared in effectiveness with complete Freund adjuvant. The subunit vaccine was demonstrated to be immunogenic, as shown by development of antibody detectable by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The humoral immune response was correlated with protection from herpetic encephalitis and, at a lower degree, with prevention of the appearance of primary herpetic lesions and acceleration of lesion resolution. The efficacy of the vaccine was most apparent in protecting mice from encephalitic death. To reduce or prevent the development of latent infection was most difficult, but was achieved with some vaccine regimens. Repeated administrations of vaccine with adjuvant were required for this protection. The most effective adjuvant was complete Freund adjuvant, but several synthetic adjuvants were effective, particularly aluminum hydroxide and the polyriboinosinic-polyribocytidylic acid-poly-L-lysine-carboxymethyl cellulose immunoadjuvant.