A comparison of static cytofluorometry and flow cytometry for the estimation of ploidy and DNA replication in human breast cancer

Flow cytometry in primary breast carcinomas. Prognostic impact of proliferative activity

From 1990 to 1996, 607 previously untreated, node-negative, invasive breast carcinomas were sampled by a pathologist for flow-cytometric DNA analysis. The aim of the present work was to study the correlations between flow cytometric results obtained thanks to the American Consensus (AC) guidelines of 1993 and the established clinico-pathological prognostic factors (T, grade, receptors), and despite a short global follow-up (mean of 4 years), to correlate flow cytometry with the outcome of the patients. In this study S-phase fraction (SPF) correlated strongly with tumor size, histological grade, lack of steroid receptors, histological type and was together with the mitotic activity a paramount prognostic factor even after multivariate analysis. This study compared also the technical criteria proposed by the AC with our own more stringent ones and concluded that the criteria of the AC are relevant and allow, thanks to the use of tertiles in the reporting of SPF values, a comparison of values obtained by different teams. Our review of the literature, focused on series using fresh material, enabled us to show that there is a rather wide agreement concerning the relationship between SPF and prognosis most often after multivariate analysis. This despite the lack of standardization in the design of the studies (implementation of the technical steps or reporting of results). When estimated from fresh or frozen material following AC's guidelines. SPF along with mitotic activity should become a prognostic factor used in the daily practice by oncologists in the management of breast carcinomas.

Models for use in wound healing research: a survey focusing on in vitro and in vivo adult soft tissue

Many different factors must be considered before selecting a wound healing model to use for a specific study. A wide variety of models have been developed that examine different aspects of the repair response, both in vitro and in vivo. In this review article, we focus on those systems that are most widely used for studies on adult soft tissue healing. Advantages and disadvantages of each are discussed, along with relevant background information to help guide decision-making.

Assessing prognosis for high-grade soft-tissue sarcomas: search for a marker

BACKGROUND

Although improved staging technology, limb-sparing surgery, and adjunctive radiation and chemotherapy have improved the outlook for patients with malignant soft-tissue tumors of the trunk and extremities, it is evident that we cannot predict which patients will develop distant metastases. Although local control is now frequently achieved, most series of high-grade soft-tissue sarcomas carry a mortality rate of > 50%.

METHODS

In a retrospective study of 93 patients with high-grade sarcomas treated between 1986 and 1992 for whom complete studies including size and volume measurements and DNA ploidy determinations as assessed by flow cytometry were available, a search for a marker for increased risk of metastasis or death was performed.

RESULTS

Grade of the lesion, sex, diagnosis, anatomical site, ploidic data (including mean DNA index and presence of an aneuploid peak), and treatment factors (including type of surgery, local recurrence, or radiation protocol) did not correlate with outcome. Age (younger patients did better), size (greatest diameter) and volume, and positive margins at surgery correlated with total survival.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the study, although negative, point out that using anatomical site, diagnosis, or ploidic analysis offers little toward anticipating outcome, whereas the size of the tumor is important.

Fluorescence image cytometry for measurement of nuclear DNA content in surgical pathology

A study was made on various methodological aspects of fluorescence image cytometry (FICM) for measurement of nuclear DNA content by using CCD cameras attached to an epifluorescence microscope. Cell nuclei of paraffin-embedded specimens from mouse tissues and human prostate carcinomas were isolated and stained with 4'-6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI). We found that fluorescence fading, lamp stability, and the homogeneity of the illumination can easily be controlled. A camera with a signal-to-noise ratio of 53 dB gave a slightly more precise measurement than did a 46-dB camera. The linearity of the analysis results was very good. The coefficient of variation of mouse kidney standard cells in the DNA histograms was about 5% and 7.4% in histograms of prostate carcinoma biopsies. Stained cell nuclei can be stored for long periods at -20 degrees C without impairment of quality. Comparative measurements of ploidy by FICM and flow cytometry confirmed the accuracy of the FICM analyses. Thus, FICM appears to be an easy method for quantifying the DNA content of visually inspected cell nuclei in surgical pathology.

The effect of transforming growth factor-beta on fibroblast cell proliferation in intact connective tissue in vitro

Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) has varying effects on cell proliferation, stimulating some cell types while inhibiting others. Its effect on proliferation has mostly been assessed in cell cultures without consideration for the influence of a tissue matrix. In the present investigation we studied the effect of TGF-beta on fibroblast cell proliferation in intact connective tissue in vitro using the membranous part of the rat mesentery. Mesenteric membranes were spread over the hole of a cytocentrifuge paper, incubated in vitro, and exposed to various concentrations of TGF-beta with or without serum added. At designated times after incubation, the specimens were fixed, spread out on microscope slides, and stained by the Feulgen reaction. Cell proliferation was estimated by counting mitoses in fibroblasts and mesothelial cells and by DNA cytometry of fibroblast nuclei using computer assisted image analyses. Higher concentrations of TGF-beta significantly increased proliferation estimated as either the percentage of cells in the S+G2 phase of the cell cycle or the mitotic index when serum was added. In medium without serum, TGF-beta did slightly, but not significantly, increase proliferation. The results show that TGF-beta stimulates connective tissue cell proliferation dose-dependently in intact connective tissue in vitro and that addition of serum to the medium is a prerequisite for optimal stimulation.

DNA index and S-phase in primary brain tumors. A comparison between fresh and deparaffinized specimens studied by flow cytometry

Forty-nine primary intracranial tumors (33 astrocytomas, eight acoustic schwannomas, five oligodendrogliomas, and three miscellaneous tumors) were studied by flow cytometry. Each tumor specimen was divided into two portions: one was studied as an unfixed suspension stained with propidium iodide and the other after formalin fixation and paraffin embedding. The 50-microns sections from the paraffin blocks were deparaffinized, rehydrated, and enzymatically disintegrated, and the cells in suspension were stained with propidium iodide. Flow cytometry of the two portions showed a significant correlation between fresh and fixed specimens regarding the S-phase (r = 0.87) and a very close correlation fo the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) index (r = 0.95). When the 33 astrocytomas were analyzed separately, similar results were obtained (r = 0.86 for S-phase and r = 0.93 for DNA index, respectively). This study demonstrated a high correlation between fresh and fixed specimens for DNA ploidy and S-phase both in primary intracranial tumors in general and also in the selected subgroup of astrocytomas.

Nuclear DNA content of human breast carcinoma: a comparison of results obtained by microspectrophotometry and flow cytometry of paraffin embedded tissue

This study compares 2 techniques for estimating the nuclear DNA content of tumor cell lines: (i) static cytometry of smears taken from fresh tissue and (ii) flow cytometry of cells extracted from paraffin embedded tissue. Parallel determinations of DNA content, using both techniques, were made on samples of tissue taken from 130 female patients with breast carcinoma. Using a simple classification into diploid and non-diploid groups, the 2 techniques yielded discrepant results in 11% of cases. The most frequent causes of disagreement were (a) the inability of static cytometry to distinguish between a diploid and a near-diploid peak and (b) for flow cytometry, the difficulty of determining whether a minor peak in the tetraploid region represented the G2 peak of a diploid cell line or the G0/G1 peak of a tetraploid cell line. If it is deemed necessary to accurately assess ploidy status, flow cytometry on paraffin embedded tissue, using modern statistical programmes, would seem to be most practical for routine use, but some neoplasms, particularly those with an equivocal ploidy peak in the tetraploid range by this method, will require static cytometry to accurately assess nuclear DNA content. Using this approach, it appears that the disagreement between the 2 techniques would be less than 5%.

Prognostic potential of flow cytometric S-phase and ploidy prospectively determined in primary breast carcinomas

In a prospective study of a consecutive breast cancer series accumulated in the period 1978-82, the S-phase fraction (SPF) and ploidy status were determined by flow cytometry performed on cell nuclei derived from samples of 580 primary tumors. Sixty percent of the tumors were non-diploid. After correction for debris the median SPF values were 7.3% overall, 12% for non-diploid tumors, and 2.9% for diploid tumors (2.6% when nodal subsets N2 and N3 and cases with metastases at presentation were excluded). The SPF values correlated both to tumor size (p = 0.008) and to the number of positive axillary lymph nodes (p = 0.03). At clinical follow-up in 1986, 467 unilateral breast cancer patients who had undergone radical treatment for cure could be evaluated with respect to the prognostic value of both the SPF value and ploidy status. The median duration of follow-up was then 59 months (range 2-90), and the median time-to-recurrence 24 months (range 2-69, n = 137). At follow-up in 1991, 201/467 of the patients had died, the median duration of follow-up being 50 months (range 2-126) for the decreased, and 119 (range 6-148) for the survivors. In multivariate analysis (Cox's proportional hazards models), the strongest independent predictors of distant recurrence-free survival (DRFS) were the number of positive axillary lymph nodes (p less than 0.0001), the debris-corrected SPF value alone (p = 0.003, versus p = 0.05 for uncorrected value), and ploidy status combined with the corrected SPF value (p = 0.0002). When age was taken into account, both the corrected SPF value and the ploidy-SPF combination were predictors of crude survival (p = 0.006 and p = 0.002, respectively). In univariate life-table analysis, the 5-year DRFS rate was 93% in node-negative (N0) cases with an SPF less than 7.3%, as compared to 80% in those with an SPF greater than or equal to 7.3% (p = 0.005). Among node-positive cases, the prognostic value of the SPF was confined to those with 1-3 positive nodes, the 5-year DRFS rate being 68% in cases with an SPF less than 7.3%, as compared to 40% in cases with an SPF greater than or equal to 7.3% (p = 0.01).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Tumor cytokinetic effects of acute starvation versus polyamine depletion in tumor-bearing mice

Previous investigations in our laboratory have demonstrated that both acute host starvation and polyamine depletion by means of the irreversible ODC-inhibitor (ODC = ornithine-decarboxylase) fluoro-methylornithine (DFMO) lead to pronounced growth retardation of rapidly proliferating tumors. The aim of this investigation was to elucidate how these different interventions affect cell kinetics and cell cycle phases in vivo. Adult nongrowing mice (C57Bl/J) bearing a poorly differentiated rapidly growing methylcholanthrene induced sarcoma were used. Combined measurements of bromodeoxyuridine incorporation into DNA and flow cytometric techniques were used. Starvation and DFMO treatment resulted in a prolonged cell cycle transit compared to freely fed animals. Tumor cells from DFMO-treated mice demonstrated an increased time for DNA synthesis and a relatively larger accumulation of cells in the G2M phase, whereas tumor cells from starved animals were accumulated in the G0G1 phase. The fractional cell loss of tumor cell during proliferation was calculated to be around 18% higher in DFMO-treated animals compared to starved and freely fed tumor-bearing mice. This study demonstrates that different mechanisms are involved in tumor growth suppression from substrate deficiency (starvation) and from inhibition of polyamine synthesis.

Ploidy, proliferative activity and prognosis. DNA flow cytometry of solid tumors

Flow cytometric study has been used to measure the cellular DNA content of solid tumors for the last decade, and of paraffin-embedded tumor specimens for the last 5 years. Ploidy and proliferative activity are the two properties commonly measured by DNA content flow cytometric study. The ability to study archival, paraffin-embedded tumors has hastened an appreciation of the prognostic utility of this assay. Either abnormal ploidy or elevated proliferative activity predict a worsened disease-free or overall survival in most common adult malignancies. Both abnormalities are associated with poor outcome in locoregional breast, non-small cell lung, and colorectal cancers, and in all stages of ovarian cancer. Abnormal ploidy is also a dire prognostic indicator for cancers arising from the kidney, bladder, prostate, and endometrium. Clinical management of patients with these diseases may be aided by studying their tumors for these objective markers of biological aggressiveness.

Cytophotometry in tumor pathology. A critical review of methods and applications, and some results of DNA analysis

In tumor pathology the quantitation of cellular substances can be of diagnostic value. Microscope cytophotometry and digital image analysis and, on the other hand, flow cytometry are supplementary methods for measuring, each with a typical spectrum of application. The methods are predominantly used for DNA analysis: Static and image cytophotometry are applicable to cytologic and histologic slides preferably for identifying stem lines in tumors of heterogenous morphology and in merely circumscribed lesions (e.g., precancerous lesions). On the other hand, sampling errors due to preselection, and the often low number of cells actually measured, may preclude the possibility of exact cell cycle analysis. This is, in fact, an important additional option of flow cytometry resulting from the high resolution of DNA histograms, which is explained by the large number of cells that can be measured in a short period. Sampling errors in flow cytometry may result from the preparation of single cell suspensions which in certain tumor entities may suppress a varying amount of particularly fragile cells or nuclei. The prognostic significance of DNA ploidy, stem line heterogeneity and S-phase fraction is clearly described in quite a number of tumor entities. Independent of its prognostic value, the cytometric identification of stem lines might be particularly useful in the follow-up of tumor patients, where it may indicate the effectivity of systemic therapy. The development of therapeutic concepts is aptly supported by flow cytometric cell cycle analysis which helps to assess the in vitro effect of combined cytostatics on the proliferative process. Moreover, multiparameter analysis of biopsy samples may provide greater accuracy in characterising individual tumor stem lines and may furthermore help to develop improved protocols for the therapy of solid tumors.

Flow cytometric measurements of DNA and other cell components in human tumors: a critical appraisal

Fundamental principles of flow cytometry with emphasis on DNA measurements and cell cycle analysis in human cells and tissues are summarized. Some of the pitfalls of cell preparation techniques and histogram interpretation are discussed at length. While consensus has been reached for some organs and tumors that DNA quantitation by flow cytometry (or image cytometry) may be of prognostic value, for most cancers studied to date the information remains incomplete. Thoroughly lacking are well-structured prospective studies because retrospective studies, while suggestive, may not necessarily be of the same value. Potential usefulness of other tumor markers is briefly discussed. Many fundamental questions concerning definitions of "diploid" and "aneuploid" tumors have not been satisfactorily settled. While the goal of "objective measurements" is worthy of further pursuit, the interpretation of results is often highly subjective. The biologic reasons for behavioral differences between diploid and aneuploid tumors are still totally obscure.

Intratumoral variations in DNA distribution patterns in mammary adenocarcinomas

Correlated flow-cytometric (FCM) and microspectrophotometric (MSP) techniques were applied to investigating whether intratumoral variations in the DNA distribution patterns of 21 primary mammary adenocarcinomas can occur. Although neoplastic cell populations with both diploid and tetraploid (i.e., euploid) distribution patterns could be found in varying proportions in some of the tumors, there was no evidence in any tumor nodule for the presence of euploid populations in one part and aneuploid populations in another. This statement was based on the results of the MSP technique, where the assessments were made on cytodiagnostically identified neoplastic cells. Also, when applying the FCM technique the statement was found to be essentially valid; only one of the tumor nodules showed a DNA distribution pattern that, by means of the criteria used in this procedure, was defined as being both euploid and aneuploid. Here, however, the technique consists of assessments made on a great number of microscopically non-identified cells. It was concluded that when conflicting reports are given from different laboratories on the prognostic value of the cytochemically assessed DNA distribution patterns in breast carcinomas, they are not likely to be attributed to intratumoral DNA heterogeneity but, rather, to differences in the methods used and in the criteria applied for the so-called ploidy assessments.

Prognostic value of DNA ploidy and S-phase fraction in relation to estrogen receptor content and clinicopathological variables in primary breast cancer

Tumors from 472 women with primary breast cancer were analyzed by flow cytometry. Divided into four categories, DNA ploidy showed significant association with disease recurrence and mortality. When allowance was made for its correlation with nodal status and estrogen receptor (ER) content, DNA ploidy did not add prognostic information. S-phase fraction was estimated in 290 DNA histograms. In contrast, it was significantly related to recurrence and mortality when controlling for nodal status, tumor size and ER content. When the follow-up was divided into two periods DNA ploidy and S-phase fraction showed association with disease recurrence in the first period only (less than 2.5 years), while the association with mortality was valid for both periods. Light scatter was measured in 234 samples. A low light scatter variability for the stemline nuclei was related to a high recurrence rate during the early follow-up period. In conclusion, DNA flow cytometry adds prognostic information concerning breast cancer patients.

Prognostic value of nuclear DNA content in breast cancer in relation to tumor size, nodal status, and estrogen receptor content

The prognostic value of nuclear DNA distribution pattern in relation to tumor size, axillary lymph node status, and estrogen receptor (ER) content was studied in 464 patients with primary, operable mammary adenocarcinoma. The median follow-up time was 3 1/2 years. Slide cytophotometric DNA analysis was performed on morphologically identified Feulgen-stained tumor cells. The tumors were classified into four subgroups according to their DNA histogram type. DNA content was significantly related to tumor size and ER level but not to nodal status. When all variables were stimultaneously introduced into Cox's proportional hazards model, tumor size, nodal status, and DNA profile remained as significant predictors of recurrence. Restricting the analysis to node-negative patients, both DNA profile and tumor size showed a significant prognostic value. DNA did not contribute significant prognostic information in node-positive patients. However, the trends in recurrence-free survival were similar to those in the node-negative subgroup: patients with aneuploid tumors tended to fare worse than those with euploid carcinomas.

Cellular DNA pattern, S-phase frequency and survival in papillary thyroid cancer

A series of 150 patients with papillary thyroid cancer diagnosed in Iceland during the 30-year period from 1955 through 1984 was retrospectively analyzed. Flow cytometric analysis of archival paraffin-embedded material was used to study the prognostic significance of cellular DNA content and s-phase frequency. DNA-aneuploidy was found in 12% of the tumors. It was significantly more common in the elderly, in moderately and poorly differentiated carcinomas, in males and in tumors with a high proportion of s-phase cells. Multivariate analysis using stepwise Cox's model showed aneuploidy, age at diagnosis, lymph node metastasis and tumor extension beyond the thyroid capsule as independent prognostic factors. The frequency of cells in s-phase was generally low (mean 2.7%). Patients with high s-phase frequency (greater than 2.5%) had less favorable prognosis than patients with low values (less than or equal to 2.5%).

Comparison of static and flow cytofluorometry for estimation of DNA index and S-phase fraction in fresh and paraffin-embedded breast carcinoma tissue

DNA index, S-phase and G2/M fractions were measured in breast carcinomas before and after paraffin-embedding. Unfixed tumors were analysed with flow cytometry, while cells prepared from fixed and paraffin-embedded tumors were analysed with both static cytometry and flow cytometry. Cells for static cytometry were prepared with pepsin and cells for flow cytometry were prepared with trypsin. In 44 of 51 paraffin-embedded tumors, analysed with flow cytometry, both DNA index and S-phase fraction could be estimated. There was a strong correlation between the three methods of obtaining DNA indices and S-phase fractions, but this was not true for G2/M fractions. Histograms from flow cytometry of archival material were corrected for background. We conclude that cells prepared from formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded breast cancer tissue can yield reliable estimation of DNA index and S-phase fraction.

DNA ploidy and S-phase fraction in primary breast carcinomas in relation to prognostic factors and survival for premenopausal patients at high risk for recurrent disease

Fine needle aspiration on small tumour pieces from 153 premenopausal women with primary breast cancer at high risk for developing recurrent disease has been used for flow cytometric DNA analysis; 133 of the tumours had either one or more cell populations different from diploid or a single, diploid cell population with an aspiration cytology showing presence of typical tumour cells. The distribution of tumour cell populations in this material was rather unusual with a high number of tetraploid populations. There were significant differences between various DNA ploidy classes with respect to prognostic factors such as lymph node involvement and oestrogen and progesterone receptor status. The S-phase fraction was significantly lower for diploid tumour cell populations compared to aneuploid populations. Diploid tumours with high S-phase fraction were not correlated to prognostic factors usually indicating a poor prognosis. Patients with an aneuploid tumour cell population classified as medium aneuploid had a significantly shorter recurrence-free survival than the rest of the patients. No conclusion on the effect of adjuvant treatment for patients with different tumour cell populations can be made at present.

Nuclear DNA content and prognosis in human breast cancer: a static cytophotometric study

Nuclear DNA content was measured by static cytophotometry in smears from breast carcinomas from 80 women, and the results were correlated with other prognostic variables and survival using multivariate statistical analysis. 49% of patients had diploid tumors and 51% hyperdiploid tumors. There was a strong correlation between DNA ploidy and axillary lymph node status, tumor size, ER status, and short term survival (median follow-up 40 months). Of all parameters measured, ploidy showed the strongest correlation with survival, and was a significant prognostic indicator even when other prognostic factors were taken into account.

The reliability of microspectrophotometric and flow cytometric nuclear DNA measurements in adenocarcinomas of the breast

The reliability of microspectrophotometric (MSP) and flow cytometric (FCM) nuclear DNA measurements has been studied in 50 human breast adenocarcinomas. The tumor material was obtained by means of fine-needle aspiration biopsy, and all samples except one were found to be highly representative. The results confirm earlier observations that a good correlation exists between modal value (MV) determined by MSP and DNA index (DI) determined by FCM. However, when tumors were classified into low and high malignant variants according to FCM/DI, FCM/S-phase percentages, and MSP histogram types, the concordance was less pronounced. This was found to be due mainly to the fact that in near-diploid tumors a discrepancy exists between MSP and FCM ploidy, as well as between MSP distribution pattern and the estimated percentages of cells in the S-phase region. Another source of discrepancy was observed in tumors with stemlines in the normal tetraploid region, including cells with highly scattered aneuploid DNA values. These tumors were judged by MSP as aneuploid/high malignant and by FCM as euploid/low malignant. In view of this discrepancy, we conclude that the simple determination of the stemline position by MSP/MV or FCM/DI is not sufficient for adequate cytochemical malignancy grading of breast carcinomas. We suggest that a combination of ploidy and percentage of cells scattered outside the modal peaks is a more sensitive method for optimal cytochemical malignancy grading in breast carcinomas.

Role of iron in the proliferation of the established human tumor cell lines U-937 and K-562: effects of suramin and a lipophilic iron chelator (PIH)

Suramin was used to analyze the growth-effects of blockade of iron uptake on two established human cell lines, U-937 (monocytoid) and K-562 (erythroleukemic). Suramin suppressed cell surface transferrin (Tf) binding and uptake of iron via inhibition of receptor-mediated endocytosis (RME). As a result, both lines accumulated in the S-phase. DNA synthesis and cell division were inhibited in the suramin-treated U-937, but not in K-562. Iron, supplied by a route alternative to Tf-to suramin-suppressed U-937 cells, reinitiated DNA synthesis and cell division, although at a lower level than in control cells. Multiple effects on iron-dependent enzymes and an inhibition of binding of undefined growth factors necessary for the transition through the cell cycle are suggested to be mechanisms by which suramin affects the U-937 cells. The results imply that clinically observed side effects of suramin may be caused by interference with cellular iron metabolism.