Differences in the number of molecules produced by two allelic electrophoretic enzyme variants in D. melanogaster

A MULTILEVEL APPROACH TO THE SIGNIFICANCE OF GENETIC VARIATION IN ALCOHOL DEHYDROGENASE OF DROSOPHILA

Prior studies showed that differences in alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) activity across genotypes of Drosophila are decisive for the outcome of selection by ethanol. In the present paper, the effect on ADH activity and egg-to-adult survival of combinations of ethanol, propan-2-ol, and acetone in naturally occurring concentrations is examined. Propan-2-ol is converted into acetone by ADH in vitro. Acetone is considered a competitive inhibitor of ethanol for the ADH enzymes. The melanogaster-ADH-S allozyme is two times more sensitive towards inhibition by acetone than either simulans-ADH or melanogaster-ADH-F. The physiological implications of these in vitro differences for larvae were studied in short-term in vivo and long-term exposure experiments. No major differences in acetone accumulation or fitness parameters were found between the strains in response to ecologically relevant concentrations of acetone or propan-2-ol. Ethanol, however, strongly decreased egg-to-pupal survival in both Drosophila simulans strains and increased developmental time in four out of the five strains tested. Therefore, under physiological conditions only ethanol was shown to act as a selective agent on the ADH polymorphism during egg-to-pupa development in Drosophila.

Micro-evolution in a wine cellar population: an historical perspective

The population of Drosophila melanogaster inside the wine cellar of Chateau Tahbilk of Victoria, Australia was found by McKenzie and Parsons (1974) to have undergone microevolution for greater alcohol tolerance when compared to the neighboring population outside the cellar. This triggered additional studies at Tahbilk, and at other wine cellars throughout the world. The contributions and interactions of researchers and the development of ideas on the ecology and genetics of this unique experimental system are traced. Although the ADH-F/ADH-S polymorphism was found to be maintained by selection in the Tahbilk populations, the selection is not significantly associated with alcohol tolerance. The environment inside the Tahbilk wine cellar is not as rich in ethanol as was originally anticipated, and selection that affects the alcohol dehydrogenase polymorphism may be more concerned with the relative efficiency with which ethanol is used as a nutrient by D. melanogaster. The synthesis and modification of lipids, particularly in membranes, appears to be important to alcohol tolerance. The studies of the Tahbilk population are at a crossroad. New experimental approaches promise to provide the keys to the selection that maintains the alcohol dehydrogenase polymorphism, and to factors that are important to alcohol tolerance and stress adaptation. From these research foundations at Tahbilk very significant contributions to our future understanding of the genetic processes of evolution can be made.

Evolutionary genetics of the Drosophila alcohol dehydrogenase gene-enzyme system

Evolutionary genetics embodies a broad research area that ranges from the DNA level to studies of genetic aspects in populations. In all cases the purpose is to determine the impact of genetic variation on evolutionary change. The broad range of evolutionary genetics requires the involvement of a diverse group of researchers: molecular biologists, (population) geneticists, biochemists, physiologists, ecologists, ethologists and theorists, each of which has its own insights and interests. For example, biochemists are often not concerned with the physiological function of a protein (with respect to pH, substrates, temperature, etc.), while ecologists, in turn, are often not interested in the biochemical-physiological aspects underlying the traits they study. This review deals with several evolutionary aspects of the Drosophila alcohol dehydrogenase gene-enzyme system, and includes my own personal viewpoints. I have tried to condense and integrate the current knowledge in this field as it has developed since the comprehensive review by van Delden (1982). Details on specific issues may be gained from Sofer and Martin (1987), Sullivan, Atkinson and Starmer (1990); Chambers (1988, 1991); Geer, Miller and Heinstra (1991); and Winberg and McKinley-McKee (1992).

The alcohol dehydrogenase polymorphism in natural populations of Drosophila melanogaster: ADH activity variation restriction site polymorphism and the Adh cline

Alcohol dehydrogenase activity has been measured in 186 iso-second chromosome lines--104 from seven Australian populations and 82 from six Chinese populations. Restriction endonuclease variation in the Adh gene region in these lines has previously been described (Jiang & Gibson, 1991). The mean ADH activity of AdhF and AdhS lines was significantly higher in the Chinese samples than in the Australian samples. In each population on both continents the mean activity of the AdhF lines is significantly higher than that of the AdhS lines. Six lines homozygous for a thermostability variant, AdhFChD (detected in four of the Chinese populations), had intermediate levels of ADH activity and protein amount. In a subset of the lines with the highest and lowest levels of ADH, there was a correlation of 0.69 between ADH activity and ADH CRM. None of the restriction site variants was consistently associated with the amount of ADH activity. Associations between BamHI (-7.2), the Adh polymorphism and ADH activity suggest that there are modifiers of ADH 5' to the gene. The deletion (0.2) at position -2.8 on the restriction map (Jiang & Gibson, 1991) was associated with increased levels of ADH activity in AdhS lines from China. Two unique insertions in the gene region were associated with low activity in AdhF lines and a null activity allele had a deletion removing most of exon 2. A single line with a duplication of a part of the Adh coding region and of the 5' regulatory section had relatively high ADH activity. Considering all the data, the main factor affecting ADH activity levels in populations is the frequency of AdhF.

Quantitative analysis of RNA produced by slow and fast alleles of Adh in Drosophila melanogaster

The alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) locus (Adh) of Drosophila melanogaster in polymorphic on a world-wide basis for two allozymes, Fast and Slow. This study was undertaken to determine whether the well-established difference in ADH protein concentration between the allozymes is due to a difference in mRNA levels. RNA gel blot hybridization and an RNase protection assay were used to quantify ADH mRNA levels. Each method used an Adh null mutant as an internal standard. Several Slow and Fast allele pairs of different geographic origins were analyzed. The results provide strong evidence that the ADH protein concentration difference is not accounted for by RNA level.

The alcohol dehydrogenase polymorphism of Drosophila melanogaster in relation to environmental ethanol, ethanol tolerance and alcohol dehydrogenase activity

Ethanol levels in Drosophila breeding sites were higher in a winery storing fortified wines than in nearby grape pressings or in orchard fruits. The relative abundance of D. simulans to D. melanogaster was negatively correlated with ethanol levels. In D. melanogaster there were no significant differences in AdhF frequency between the orchard and winery populations. The ethanol tolerance of wild caught D. melanogaster males paralleled the levels of ethanol in the breeding sites but Adh alleles and ethanol tolerance segregated largely independently of each other. Levels of ADH activity were positively associated with the ethanol tolerance of the different populations and with levels of ethanol in the breeding sites, but it is argued that the ethanol levels are not causative. Flies from inside the winery had higher ADH levels due mainly to greater amounts of ADH-F. The difference in activity persisted for at least one generation in the laboratory. After ten generations of laboratory culture the differences in ethanol tolerance were still present but there were no significant differences in ADH activity.

Recent origin for a thermostable alcohol dehydrogenase allele of Drosophila melanogaster

The nucleotide sequence of the Fast-Chateau Douglas isolate of the thermostable alcohol dehydrogenase allele is compared with the sequences of the Slow and Fast alleles of Drosophila melanogaster. Conceptual translation of the FChD sequence indicates that the thermostable polypeptide has the diagnostic FAST amino acid replacement at residue 192 and an additional replacement of serine for proline at residue 214. This suggests a Fast origin for the thermostable Adh allele. However, some of the biochemical properties of the FCHD protein resemble those of the SLOW rather than the FAST polypeptides. The serine for proline replacement confers upon the thermostable polypeptide substrate specificities and some kinetic parameters similar to the SLOW protein. The same replacement substitution within the third coding exon also appears to alter the ADH protein concentration to a level similar to the SLOW polypeptide and the probable effect is at the level of mRNA concentration. The low level of nucleotide sequence variation, other than that leading to the amino acid substitution, suggests a recent origin for the thermostable allele. The time since divergence of the FChD sequence from Fast is estimated to be approximately 260,000-470,000 years.

The alcohol dehydrogenase alleloenzymes AdhS and AdhF from the fruitfly Drosophila melanogaster: an enzymatic rate assay to determine the active-site concentration

A rapid and reproducible enzymatic rate assay for the quantitative determination of the concentration of active sites is presented for the alleloenzymes AdhS and AdhF from Drosophila melanogaster. Using this procedure the turnover numbers as catalytic-center activities were found to be 12.2 sec-1 for AdhF and 3.4 sec-1 for AdhS with secondary alcohols. This showed a slower dissociation of the coenzyme from the binary enzyme-NADH complex with AdhS and hence a stronger binding of NADH to this alleloenzyme. With ethanol, the catalytic-center activity was 1.4 sec-1 for AdhS and 2.8 sec-1 for AdhF, and hence the single amino acid mutation distinguishing the two alleloenzymes also affected hydride transfer.

Activity differences between acid phosphatase allozyme variants ofDrosophila virilis: Differences in intracellular localization of allozymes

Three acid phosphatase allozyme strains (Acph-1, Acph-2 and Acph-4) ofDrosophila virilisshow large differences of enzyme activity when examined by means of starch gel electrophoretic technique, Acph-4 strain showing approximately four times the activity of Acph-1 and twice that of Acph-2, as reported previously (Narise, 1976). Crude extract difference between Acph-4 and Acph-1 strains is less than twofold and this compared with larger differences in supernatants. Cell fractionation and density gradient centrifugation demonstrated that the acid phosphatase resides mainly in lysosomes and becomes soluble in part during preparation without structural damage to lysosomes. The solubility of the allozymes from lysosomes was variable among the three strains. ACPH4allozyme was released in the highest degree. However, the release-rate of other lyso-somalenzymes, such as α-glucosidase, β-galactosidase and β-glucuronidase was similar among these strains. These results suggest that the strain variation in ability of the allozymes to be incorporated into lysosomes is due to the allozymes themselves, not due to alteration in the lysosomes.

Alcohol dehydrogenase from Drosophila funebris and Drosophila immigrans: molecular and evolutionary aspects

Alcohol dehydrogenase from Drosophila funebris and D. immigrans is evident at all developmental stages. The highest activity level appears in third-instar larvae and declines to a lower level at all later stages of development. Both species are monomorphic. The enzyme is a dimer consisting of two identical subunits with molecular weight 27,600. The pI values are 8.6 for D. funebris and 9.02 for D. immigrans. The optimum pH is 8.6 and 8.7 for D. funebris and D. immigrans, respectively. The Km values for NAD+, propan-2-ol, and butan-2-ol are 0.15, 2.90, and 2.08 mM, respectively, for D. funebris and 0.16, 1.53, and 1.49 mM, respectively, for D. immigrans. The half-life for the purified enzyme is 45 days for D. funebris and 18 days for D. immigrans at 4 degrees C. Data on the amino acid composition of both enzymes and peptide maps of alcohol dehydrogenase of D. immigrans reveal that they have marked homologies between them and also with alcohol dehydrogenases of other species. D. funebris shows reduced levels of alcohol dehydrogenase synthesis but has the highest specific activity reported to date for a Drosophila species. D. immigrans synthesises six times more enzyme but the specific activity is comparable to that of other species of Drosophila. This evidence could explain their different alcohol tolerance. The molecular properties of these alcohol dehydrogenases together with other species of Drosophila suggest that the alcohol dehydrogenase of Drosophila has arisen by divergent evolution from a common ancestral gene.

Genetical variation for enzyme activity in a population of Drosophila melanogaster. VI. Molecular variation in the control of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) activity

Four characters, ADH activity at 25 degrees, immunologically determined ADH protein level, total protein and body weight were measured upon 72 hour old adult female and male Drosophila melanogaster from 16 highly inbred lines, derived from the laboratory population, "Texas" (established 1966). The highest levels of ADH activity and ADH protein level were observed in the 2 lined homozygous for the AdhF allele. Amongst the 14 AdhS/S lines variation for ADH protein level was associated with genetical variation for ADH activity (r = 0.6). The genetical association between ADH activity or ADH protein level and either body weight or total protein in the 16 inbred lines was not statistically significant. A study of ADH activity, ADH protein and total protein in 8 lines representing all homozygous combinations of chromosomes I, II and III and derived from two inbred AdhS/S lines, chosen for their respective high and low ADH activities, showed that ADH activity was considerably modified by a post-translational event controlled from chromosome III. Total protein was controlled by different chromosomal effects from those controlling ADH activity. Michaelis constants for crude fly extracts of the two AdhF/F and the above two AdhS/S lines showed clear differences in affinity for isopropanol.

Variation in amount of enzyme protein in natural populations

Among strains of Drosophila melanogaster each derived from a single fertilized female taken from natural populations, there is variation in both alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) activity and the amount of ADH protein. The correlation between ADH activity and number of molecules over all strains examined is 0.87 or 0.96 in late third instar larvae depending on whether the substrate is 2-propanol or ethanol. With respect to the two common electrophoretic allozymic forms, F and S, segregating in these populations, the FF strains on the whole have higher ADH activities and numbers of ADH molecules than the SS strains. Over all strains examined, enzyme extracts from FF strains have a mean catalytic efficiency per enzyme molecule higher than that of enzyme extracts from SS strains when ethanol is the substrate, and much higher when 2-propanol is the substrate. One FF strain had an ADH activity/ADH protein ratio characteristic of SS strains.

Variation between electrophoretically identical alleles at the alcohol dehydrogenase locus in Drosophila melanogaster

A new variant of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH 7lk) was found in a laboratory stock of Drosophila melanogaster. ADH in this stock had the same electrophoretic mobility as the F variant both on acrylamide and on agar. Activity levels were similar to the levels in F flies at temperature between 15 and 25 C. But while ADH F enzyme is inactivated rapidly at 40 C, ADH 7lk is still active. Also, ADH S is not inactivated at this temperature, but has a far lower activity per fly than ADH 7lk. Genetic analysis showed that the new variant is an allele of the Adh locus.