The genetic engineering of production traits in domestic animals

Transgenesis and Animal Welfare

The two main techniques used in biomedical research for the production of transgenic animals have several implications for animal welfare in terms of the Three Rs of Russell & Burch. Some are intrinsic to the transgenic objectives, while others relate to the effects of mutations, transgene expression, associated methodologies, and husbandry or production systems. All of these actual and potential implications for animal welfare demand serious consideration within a broad ethical analysis of the technology. In the light, of the Three Rs, this may require a fundamental reappraisal of the processes by which such scientific procedures are approved.

Transgenic farm animals - A critical analysis

The notion of directly introducing new genes or otherwise manipulating the genotype of an animal is conceptually straightforward and appealing from the standpoints of both speed and precision with which phenotypic changes can be made. Thus, it is little wonder that the imagination of many animal scientists has been captivated by the success others have achieved in introducing foreign genes into mice. Transgenic mice not only exhibit unique phenotypes, but they also pass those traits on to their progeny. However, before transgenic farm animals become a common component of the livestock industry, a number of formidable obstacles must be overcome. In this review we attempt to identify the critical issues that should be considered by both those currently working in the field and those scientists considering the feasibility of initiating a transgenic livestock project. The inefficiency of producing transgenic animals has been well documented. This does not constrain investigators using laboratory animal models, but it has a major impact on applying transgenic technology to farm animals. The molecular mechanisms of transgene integration have not been elucidated, and as a consequence it is difficult to design strategies to improve the efficiency of the process. In addition to the problems associated with integration of new genes, there are inefficiencies associated with collecting and culturing fertilized eggs as well as embryo transfer in farm animals. Transgenic farm animal studies are major logistical undertakings. Even in the face of these practical hindrances, some may be pressured by administrators to embrace this new technology. As powerful as the transgenic animal model system is, currently there are limits to the kinds of agricultural questions that can be addressed. Some uses are so appealing, however, that several commercial organizations have explored this technology. Within the next decade or two, it is likely that many of the technical hurdles will be overcome. Combining new techniques with a better understanding of the genetic control of physiological systems will make it possible to improve the characteristics of farm animals in highly imaginative ways.

Precision editing of large animal genomes

Transgenic animals are an important source of protein and nutrition for most humans and will play key roles in satisfying the increasing demand for food in an ever-increasing world population. The past decade has experienced a revolution in the development of methods that permit the introduction of specific alterations to complex genomes. This precision will enhance genome-based improvement of farm animals for food production. Precision genetics also will enhance the development of therapeutic biomaterials and models of human disease as resources for the development of advanced patient therapies.

Altering nutrient utilization in animals through transgenesis

Improved domestic animal productivity is necessary in order to provide for an increasing world population over the next two to three decades and such improvement would be aided by an increase in the efficiency of nutrient utilization. This can be achieved by conventional genetic selection protocols but progress by this approach is slow. A more rapid but as yet largely unproven technique is the direct modification of the genome which can be achieved by the transfer of recombinant DNA to the nuclei of early embryos. This new technology is potentially powerful because it allows the direct transfer of genes without regard to inter-species barriers to breeding. However, it raises a new set of problems associated with the integration and expression of the foreign genetic information in the new genome. In this review the application of the technology to increasing nutrient utilization and increased productivity are discussed. Two areas have received substantial attention in the 15 years since the technique was first applied to domestic animals. First, the current status of the modification of growth hormone levels to improve productivity and feed utilization efficiency is reviewed, with current results suggesting that several of the projects may soon be approaching field trial status. Second, the introduction of novel biochemical pathways to domestic animals to provide them with different sources of the substrates required for growth and production is discussed. Recent results obtained in the introduction of a cysteine biosynthetic pathway to animals is reviewed. While this line of research remains some distance from commercial application, it provides a useful example of the powerful possibilities inherent in the new technology. However, it also serves to highlight some of the difficulties that might be expected as new genes are expressed to produce enzymes that must fit compatibly with existing animal biochemistry.

Transgene-mediated modifications to animal biochemistry

The application of gene-transfer technology to domestic animals provides a way for the introduction of genes encoding biochemical pathways that are currently nonfunctional in these animals. This might provide a mechanism for increasing the availability of specific substrates that currently limit certain production characteristics, such as the production of wool. The progress and problems associated with recent attempts to transfer a cysteine biosynthetic pathway and a glyoxylate cycle to sheep are discussed, in addition to the extension of this concept to other biochemical pathways.

Toward altering milk composition by genetic manipulation: current status and challenges

The implementation of large-scale genome mapping and sequencing has improved the understanding of animal genetics. A large number of gene sequences are now available to serve as regulatory elements or genes of interest. Although the central thrust of this work is focused on understanding disease states, the manipulation of normal metabolic processes is feasible. To date, the genetic manipulation of livestock has been limited to the permanent addition of genes of clinical interest. This study explores the utility of genetically engineered cattle as a means of altering milk composition to improve the functional properties of milk, increasing marketability. Improvements would include increasing the concentration of valuable components in milk (e.g., casein), removing undesirable components (e.g., lactose), or altering composition to resemble that of human milk as a means of improving human neonatal nutrition. The protracted time lines of genetically modifying dairy cattle has prompted the development of animal models. A model for dwarf goats is discussed in terms of circumventing the lengthy time lines involved in generating transgenic cattle and allowing for an accelerated expansion of research in molecular genetics of dairy animals. Thus, the genetic manipulation of dairy cattle is feasible and could have significant impacts on milk quality, attributes of novel dairy products, and human health.

Introduction and expression of the bacterial glyoxylate cycle genes in transgenic mice

The glyoxylate cycle, catalysed by two unique enzymes: isocitrate lyase (ICL; EC 4.1.3.1) and malate synthase (MS; EC 4.1.3.2), is necessary for the net conversion of acetate into glucose. This metabolic pathway operates in microorganisms, higher plants and nematodes. Two bacterial genes, encoding ICL and MS, were modified in order to introduce them into the mouse germ line. The ovine metallothionein-Ia (MT-Ia) promoter-ace B gene-ovine growth hormone (GH) gene (3' GH sequence) construct was fused to the ovine, MT-Ia promoter-ace A gene-ovine GH gene (3' GH sequence). Therefore, in this single DNA sequence, both ace A and ace B are under independent MT-Ia promoter control and can be induced by zinc. Transgenic mice were generated by pronuclear microinjection of the ace B-ace A gene construct. We now report the establishment of four mouse lines carying these two transgenes. Studies on the progeny of these lines indicate that one line (No. 91) is expressing both genes at the mRNA and enzyme levels in the liver and intestine, whereas another line (No. 66) has a much lower expression. Both enzyme activities were detected in the liver and intestine at levels up to 25% of those measured in fully derepressed Escherichia coli cells.

YAC transgenesis in farm animals: rescue of albinism in rabbits

The generation of transgenic mice with mammalian genes cloned in yeast artificial chromosomes (YACs) has generated great interest in the field of gene transfer into livestock. Many of the problems associated with standard transgenesis-such as lack of crucial regulator elements and position effects related to the integration site, which lead to variation in expression levels irrespective of the dose of the transgene-have been practically overcome. The large size of YAC-derived gene constructs (in excess of 1 Mb) facilitates the presence and transfer of all elements required for the faithful regulation of a gene. With the experiments discussed in this report, we have addressed the possibility of applying the obvious advantages of YAC transgenesis to farm animals. We have generated transgenic rabbits carrying a 250 kb YAC covering the mouse tyrosinase gene by pronuclear microinjection, and thus rescued the albino phenotype of the transgenic individuals. To date, this is the first demonstration of a successful transfer of large genetic units into the germ line of farm animals. This development might improve the occurrence of transgene expression at physiological levels and specific sites in livestock. YAC transgenesis therefore will be applied in genetic engineering, for example, in the production of pharmacologically interesting proteins encoded by large gene units and generating transgenic donors for xenotransplantation.

Improved wool production in transgenic sheep expressing insulin-like growth factor 1

Transgenic sheep were produced by pronuclear microinjection with a mouse ultra-high-sulfur keratin promoter linked to an ovine insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF1) cDNA. Five transgenic lambs resulted from the microinjection of 591 embryos; one male and one female showed IGF1 expression in the skin. A progeny test of the ram was carried out by matings to 43 non-transgenic ewes. Of 85 lambs born, 43 (50.6%) were transgenic. At yearling shearing (approximately 14 months of age), clean fleece weight was on average 6.2% greater in transgenic animals than in their non-transgenic half-sibs, with a greater effect in males (9.2%) than females (3.4%). Transgenics showed a small but significant increase in bulk, but male transgenics had a lower staple strength than female transgenics and non-transgenics which did not differ significantly. There were no significant differences in fiber diameter, medullation, and hogget body weight. To our knowledge this is the first reported improvement in a production trait by genetic engineering of a farm animal without adverse effects on health or reproduction.

Targeting gene expression to the wool follicle in transgenic sheep

To establish the feasibility of overexpressing foreign genes in the wool follicle, transgenic sheep were produced by pronuclear microinjection of a DNA construct consisting of a mouse ultrahigh-sulfur keratin promoter linked to the bacterial chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) gene. Four of 31 lambs born were transgenic. The overall efficiency of transgenesis was 1.1% of zygotes injected and transferred. Two transgenic rams were mated to nontransgenic ewes, and both transmitted the gene to their offspring in Mendelian fashion. CAT expression was found in the skin of one G0 ram and in 9 out of 26 transgenic G1 progeny. Two G1 lambs were sacrificed to study tissue specificity. Both had high levels of expression in skin but One had high expression in spleen and kidney with lower levels of expression in lung; the other had low expression in spleen, lung, and muscle. In situ hybridization demonstrated that transgene expression in the skin was confined to the keratogenous zone of the wool follicle cortex. Expression of CAT activity in skin was correlated with diet-induced or seasonal changes in the rate of wool growth. This keratin promoter appears useful for overexpressing factors in the wool follicle that might influence wool production or properties.

Expression of bacterial cysteine biosynthesis genes in transgenic mice and sheep: toward a new in vivo amino acid biosynthesis pathway and improved wool growth

It is possible to improve wool growth through increasing the supply of cysteine available for protein synthesis and cell division in the wool follicle. As mammals can only synthesise cysteine indirectly from methionine via trans-sulphuration, expression of transgenes encoding microbial cysteine biosynthesis enzymes could provide a more efficient pathway to cysteine synthesis in the sheep. If expressed in the rumen epithelium, the abundant sulphide, produced by ruminal microorganisms and normally excreted, could be captured for conversion to cysteine. This paper describes the characterisation of expression of the cysteine biosynthesis genes of Salmonella typhimurium, cysE, cysM and cysK, and linked cysEM, cysME and cysKE genes as transgenes in mice and sheep. The linked transgenes were constructed with each gene driven by a separate promoter, either with the Rous sarcoma virus long terminal repeat (RSVLTR) promoter or the mouse phosphoglycerate kinase-1 (mPgk-1) promoter, and with human growth hormone (hGH) polyadenylation sequences. Transgenesis of mice with the RSVLTR-cysE gene afforded tissue-specific, heritable expression of the gene. Despite high levels of expression in a number of tissues, extremely low levels of expression occurred in the stomach and small intestine. Results of a concurrent sheep transgenesis experiment using the RSVLTR-cysEM and -cysME linked transgenes revealed that the RSVLTR promoter was inadequate for expression in the rumen. Moreover, instability of transgenes containing the RSVLTR sequence was observed. Expression of mPgk-cysME and -cysKE linked transgenes in most tissues of the mice examined, including the stomach and small intestine, suggested this promoter to be a better candidate for expression of these transgenes in the analogous tissues of sheep. However, a subsequent sheep transgenesis experiment indicated that use of the mPgk-1 promoter, active ubiquitously and early in development, may be inappropriate for expression of the cysteine biosynthesis transgenes. In summary, these results indicate that enzymically active bacterial cysteine biosynthesis gene products can be coexpressed in mammalian cells in vivo but that expression of the genes should be spatio-temporally restricted to the adult sheep rumen epithelium.

Prospects for the genetic manipulation of dairy cattle: opportunities beyond BST

The dairy industry, with regulatory approvals of recombinant chymosin and bovine somatotropin (BST), has been at the forefront of food and agricultural biotechnology. The commercial fate of these products is one of several factors that may affect the success of future genetic manipulations in dairy cattle and dairy products. Other factors include technical and reproductive constraints in cattle and the cost of producing transgenic cattle. Early applications of genetic manipulation in cattle, for reasons of cost recoupment, may favor production of heterologous proteins in milk for pharmaceutical and medical use. Such applications could benefit genetic modification of milk and milk proteins for food use by providing advance knowledge and experience in mammalian protein expression. Other research opportunity areas that could affect prospects for genetic manipulation of dairy cattle include genome mapping, metabolic pathways, growth and development, and cattle/microbe interactions.

Introduction and expression of the bacterial genes cysE and cysK in eukaryotic cells

The coding sequences of the cysE and cysK genes from Escherichia coli, which encode the enzymes of the cysteine biosynthetic pathway, namely, serine acetyltransferase (EC 2.3.1.30) and O-acetylserine sulfhydrylase (or cysteine synthase [EC 4.2.99.8]), were modified for expression in eukaryotic cells and introduced into murine L cells. A number of fusion genes comprising the cysE or cysK coding sequences joined to the promoter of the ovine metallothionein-Ia (MT-Ia) gene and various portions of the ovine growth hormone (GH) gene were prepared. Significant differences in the level of transcription were observed, depending on the amount and arrangement of the GH gene sequences used, the highest levels being obtained with the constructs MTCE10 and MTCK7, which contained only the GH 3' untranslated gene sequences. These two constructs were fused to produce the gene MTCEK1. In this single DNA sequence, each bacterial gene is under independent MT-Ia promoter control. Expression of the cysK sequence in this construct (MT-Ia promoter-cysE-3' GH sequence-MT-Ia promoter-cysK-3' GH sequence) was elevated compared with expression of the cysK gene in MTCK7. However, expression of the cysE sequence in MTCEK1 was only 40% of that of the cysE gene cloned into MTCE10. The double-promoter configuration, which enhances the expression of the second gene in MTCEK1, is proposed as a model for the modification of bacterial genes in general.