Tamoxifen ‘sex reverses’ alligator embryos at male producing temperature, but is an antiestrogen in female hatchlings

Mini review: Asymmetric Müllerian duct development in the chicken embryo

Müllerian ducts are paired embryonic tubes that give rise to the female reproductive tract. In humans, the Müllerian ducts differentiate into the Fallopian tubes, uterus and upper portion of the vagina. In birds and reptiles, the Müllerian ducts develop into homologous structures, the oviducts. The genetic and hormonal regulation of duct development is a model for understanding sexual differentiation. In males, the ducts typically undergo regression during embryonic life, under the influence of testis-derived Anti-Müllerian Hormone, AMH. In females, a lack of AMH during embryogenesis allows the ducts to differentiate into the female reproductive tract. In the chicken embryo, a long-standing model for development and sexual differentiation, Müllerian duct development in females in asymmetric. Only the left duct forms an oviduct, coincident with ovary formation only on the left side of the body. The right duct, together with the right gonad, becomes vestigial. The mechanism of this avian asymmetry has never been fully resolved, but is thought to involve local interplay between AMH and sex steroid hormones. This mini-review re-visits the topic, highlighting questions in the field and proposing a testable model for asymmetric duct development. We argue that current molecular and imaging techniques will shed new light on this curious asymmetry. Information on asymmetric duct development in the chicken model will inform our understanding of sexual differentiation in vertebrates more broadly.

Effects of tamoxifen on autosomal genes regulating ovary maintenance in adult mice

Environmental endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs), known to bind to estrogen/androgen receptors and mimic native estrogens, have been implicated as a main source for increasing human reproductive and developmental deficiencies and diseases. Tamoxifen (TAM) is one of the most well-known antiestrogens with defined adverse effects on the female reproductive tract, but the mechanisms related to autosomal gene regulation governing ovary maintenance in mammals remain unclear. The expression pattern and levels of key genes and proteins involved in maintaining the ovarian phenotype in mice were analyzed. The results showed that TAM induced significant upregulation of Sox9, which is the testis-determining factor gene. The results showed that TAM induced significant upregulation of Sox9, the testis-determining factor gene, and the expression level of Sox9 mRNA in the ovaries of mice exposed to 75 or 225 mg/kg bw TAM was 2- and 10-fold that in the control group, respectively (p < 0.001). Furthermore, the testicular fibroblast growth factor gene, Fgf9, was also elevated in TAM-treated ovaries. Accordingly, expression of the ovary development marker, forkhead transcription factor (FOXL2), and WNT4/FST signaling, were depressed. The levels of protein expression changed consistently with the target genes. Moreover, the detection of platelet/endothelial cell adhesion molecule 1 (PECAM-1) in TAM-treated ovaries suggested the formation of vascular endothelial cells, which is a further evidence for the differentiation of the ovaries to a testis-like phenotype. During this period, the level of 17β-estradiol, progesterone, and luteinizing hormone decreased, while that of testosterone increased by 3.3-fold (p = 0.013). The activation of a testis-specific molecular signaling cascade was a potentially important mechanism contributing to the gender disorder induced by TAM, which resulted in the differentiation of the ovaries to a testis-like phenotype in adult mice. Limited with a relatively higher exposure, the present study provided preliminary molecular insights into the sexual disorder induced by antiestrogens and compounds that interrupted estrogen signaling by other modes of action.

Masculinization of the European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) by treatment with an androgen or aromatase inhibitor involves different gene expression and has distinct lasting effects on maturation

The objective of this study was to contribute to our understanding of the role of sex steroids in fish sex differentiation and male maturation. Sexually undifferentiated sea bass were administered 17alpha-methyldihydrotestosterone (MDHT), estradiol-17beta (E(2)), fadrozole (Fz), cyproterone acetate (CPA) or tamoxifen (Tx). MDHT produced 100% males whereas E(2) and Tx resulted in 100% females. Fz produced 95% males while CPA did not alter sex ratios. E(2) treatment did not affect gonadal aromatase (cyp19a) expression levels, supporting the possibility that the feminizing effect of exogenous E(2) are not directly related to cyp19a regulation. Both MDHT and Fz decreased cyp19a expression. Moreover, androgen receptor (ar) expression levels increased during development in all but the MDHT group, suggesting that early exposure to an androgen down-regulates subsequent ar expression in males and that Fz does not interact with the androgen receptor. Together, these observations indicate that although MDHT and Fz result in a similar phenotype, the molecular pathways involved are likely different, and show that Fz masculinization is the consequence of inhibited ovarian differentiation rather than of a direct androgenic effect. Further, since CPA did not alter sex ratios when administered during the period of highest androgen sensitivity, we suggest that androgens are not required for initial testicular differentiation in the sea bass. MDHT and Fz did not alter the number of precocious males but reduced and increased, respectively, their gonadosomatic index (GSI). In addition, Fz had lasting effects on the GSI of precocious and non-precocious males, probably due to alterations of estrogen function in the testis.

Alligator aromatase cDNA sequence and its expression in embryos at male and female incubation temperatures

In all species of crocodilians, sex is determined not by genetic mechanisms, but by the temperature at which the egg is incubated. In the American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) the thermosensitive period (TSP) for sex determination is a 7- to 10-day window within stages 21-24 of development, around the middle third of the incubation period. Treating embryos with estrogen during the TSP produces female offspring, even at male incubation temperatures. Conversely, blocking embryonic estrogen synthesis at female-inducing temperature prevents development of the female phenotype. Therefore, it has been suggested that estrogen plays a role in determination of sex in the alligator. Estrogen is produced from an androgen substrate by cytochrome P450 aromatase (CYP19). If estrogen plays a critical role in sex determination, there should be differences in aromatase expression between embryos at male- and female-producing temperatures during the TSP. Therefore, to address this question, we cloned and characterized the alligator CYP19 cDNA. Based on the sequence information, a quantitative kinetic reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (TaqMan) assay was designed to measure expression of the alligator aromatase gene in RNA extracted from the gonadal and brain regions of alligator embryos incubated at male- or female-producing temperatures from prior to the TSP through hatching. Aromatase expression was detected in the brain region from the earliest stage tested (stage 20) through hatching. The hypothalamus had significantly higher expression than the forebrain or hindbrain in both male and female embryos. Expression was not significantly different in the gonadal region between embryos at male and female temperatures until after the TSP, when there was a dramatic increase in expression at female temperature. These data indicate that aromatase expression and, thus, estrogen production, are not the initial trigger for sex determination but play an essential role in ovarian differentiation in the alligator. J. Exp. Zool. 290:439-448, 2001.

Temperature-dependent sex determination and gonadal differentiation in reptiles

In many reptile species, sexual differentiation of gonads is sensitive to temperature (temperature-dependent sex determination, TSD) during a critical period of embryonic development (thermosensitive period, TSP). Experiments carried out with different models including turtles, crocodilians and lizards have demonstrated the implication of estrogens and the key role played by aromatase (the enzyme complex that converts androgens to estrogens) in ovary differentiation during TSP and in maintenance of the ovarian structure after TSP. In some of these experiments, the occurrence of various degrees of gonadal intersexuality is related to weak differences in aromatase activity, suggesting subtle regulations of the aromatase gene at the transcription level. Temperature could intervene in these regulations. Studies presently under way deal with cloning (cDNAs) and expression (mRNAs) of genes that have been shown, or are expected, to be involved in gonadal formation and/or differentiation in mammals. Preliminary results show that homologues of the WT1, SF1, SOX9, DAX1 and AMH genes exist in TSD reptiles. However, the expression patterns of these genes during gonadal differentiation may be different between mammals and TSD reptiles and also between different reptile species. How these genes could interact with aromatase is being examined.

Involvement of estrogens in the process of sex differentiation in two fish species: the rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and a tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus)

In order to study the physiological implication of sex steroid hormones in gonadal sex differentiation in fish, we first investigated the potential role of estrogens using two fish models: the rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and a tilapia species (Oreochromis niloticus). All experiments were carried out on genetically all-male (XY) and all-female (XX) populations. In vivo treatments with an aromatase inhibitor (ATD, 1,4,6- androstatriene-3-17-dione) result in 100% masculinization of an all-female population in rainbow trout (dosage 50 mg/kg of food) and 75.3% in tilapia (dosage 150 mg/kg of food). In tilapia, the effectiveness of the aromatase inhibition by ATD is demonstrated by the marked decrease of the gonadal aromatase activity in treated animals versus control. No masculinization is obtained following treatment with an estrogen receptor antagonist (tamoxifen) in both species. Aromatase and estrogen receptor gene expression was studied in rainbow trout by semi-quantitative RT-PCR in gonads sampled before, during and after sex-differentiation. Aromatase mRNA is specifically detected in female gonads, 3 weeks before the first sign of histological sex-differentiation, i.e., first female meiosis. Aromatase expression in male gonads is at least a few hundred times less than in female gonads. Estrogen receptor gene is expressed in both male and female gonads at all stages with no dimorphic expression between sexes. Specific aromatase gene expression before ovarian differentiation was also demonstrated using virtual Northern blot, with no expression detected in male differentiating gonads. From these results it can be concluded that estrogen synthesis is crucial for ovarian differentiation, and transcription of the aromatase gene can be proposed as a key step in that process in fish.

Acetylcholinesterase-positive innervation is present at undifferentiated stages of the sea turtle Lepidochelis olivacea embryo gonads: implications for temperature-dependent sex determination

In embryos of different reptile species, incubation temperature triggers a cascade of endocrine events that lead to gonad sex differentiation. The cellular and molecular mechanisms by which temperature sets in motion this process are still controversial. Here, we begin evaluating the possible participation of the nervous system in temperature-dependent sex determination by showing the existence and origin of acetylcholinesterase (AchE)-positive nerve fibers in undifferentiated gonads of the Lepidochelys olivacea (L. olivacea) sea turtle putative male and female embryos, along the thermosensitive period for sex determination (TPSD; stages 20-27). AChE-positive nerve bundles and fibers were readily visualized until developmental stage 24 and thereafter. DiI injections and confocal imaging showed that some of these gonadal nerves arise from the lower thoracic and upper lumbar spinal cord levels, and might thus be sensory in nature. Because the vertebrate spinal cord is capable of integrating by itself thermoregulatory responses with no intervention of uppermost levels of the central nervous system, we also evaluated spinal cord maturation during the TPSD. The maturation of the spinal cord was more advanced in putative female than in male embryos, when sex determination is taking place for each sex; this process starts and ends earlier in male than in female embryos. Together these observations open the possibility that the spinal cord and the innervation derived from it could play a direct role in driving or modulating the process of temperature-dependent gonad sex determination and/or differentiation, particularly in female L. olivacea embryos.

Reptiles as models of contaminant-induced endocrine disruption

Historically, reptiles have been used as bioindicators of environmental contaminants and, currently, reptiles have the potential to elucidate the mechanisms of a newly described group of environmental contaminants--endocrine disrupters. Reptiles are particularly good models for studying endocrine altering compounds due to the fact that different species of reptiles have varying modes of gender determination (genotypic sex determination or temperature-dependent sex determination) and parity modes (oviparity or viviparity). This review focuses both on laboratory and field studies of contaminant-induced endocrine alterations in reptiles. Laboratory studies of oviparous reptiles with temperature-dependent sex determination reveal that embryonic exposure to natural hormones and many man-made chemicals (including the ubiquitous PCBs and common herbicides) can permanently alter the functioning of the reproductive system. It is hypothesized that similar permanent, organizational changes occur in wild reptiles exposed to endocrine-disrupting contaminants.

Temperature-dependent sex determination in the red-eared slider turtle, Trachemys scripta

Temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) in the red-eared slider turtle, Trachemys scripta, has been the subject of a variety of past studies. Incubation temperature appears to affect sex determination in a dose-dependent fashion. This suggests that temperature could be affecting a dosage-sensitive element in the sex-determination cascade. Sex determination in T. scripta is sensitive to estrogen, and data from many studies support the hypothesis that endogenous estrogen production may be involved in female sex determination. However, this hypothesis has not yet been evaluated through aromatase expression studies in this species. Several recent studies have cloned cDNAs for genes that could be involved in sex determination and/or sex differentiation. The cDNAs for SF-1 and MIS have been cloned in T. scripta, indicating that these may represent conserved elements in the sex-determination/sex-differentiation cascade of reptiles. The SOX9 cDNA also has been cloned in T. scripta (Spotila et al., '98), and it shows a sex-specific expression pattern. Future studies targeted at aromatase expression as well as the expression of factors such as SOX9, SF-1, and MIS will begin to provide a more comprehensive picture of the events involved in TSD in T. scripta. Further, such studies could help pinpoint the temperature-sensitive element(s).

The molecular biology of temperature-dependent sex determination

Many reptiles do not have heteromorphic sex chromosomes and for these species sex is determined during embryogenesis by the temperature of egg incubation rather than at conception. The phenomenon of temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) was discovered almost thirty years ago, but few advances have been made towards the elucidation of its mechanism. In the past few years substantial progress has been made in the understanding of the molecular basis of XY chromosomal (genetic) sex determination (GSD) through the discovery of SRY. It is now possible to start comparing TSD with GSD. TSD is found in some evolutionarily ancient vertebrates and has been postulated to be the ancestral process from which GSD has evolved. If this is true then the two mechanisms may share a common molecular basis. This paper details the current knowledge of TSD, our progress on the investigation of the involvement of SRY-type proteins, and finally presents some of the problems that need to be resolved to gain an understanding of the molecular basis of TSD.

Role of P-450 aromatase in sex determination of the diamondback terrapin, Malaclemys terrapin

Sex determination in the diamondback terrapin, Malaclemys terrapin, is temperature-dependent. Eggs incubated at 31 degrees C, and above, hatch in approximately 45 days as females. Eggs incubated below 27 degrees C hatch in about 60 days as males. Sex is not reversible after hatching. Nest temperatures in the wild can be as low as 20 degrees C and as high as 37 degrees C with as much as a 10 degrees C diel cycle. The shortest incubation time measured in nature was 56 days and the longest approaching 120 days. Nests in our study site produced predominantly (> 95%) male hatchlings. Treatment of developing embryos with estrogen produces females at male producing temperatures while treatment with fadrozole (a nonsteroidal aromatase inhibitor) induces partial male-like gonads. Treatment with a steroidal aromatase inhibitor (4-hydroxyandrostenedione, 4-OHA) had no effect on sex determination. Both fadrozole and 4-OHA are potent competitive inhibitors (Ki approximately 40-50 nM) for terrapin in vitro aromatase activity. These findings are consistent with aromatase expression being a key step in sex determination of terrapins. We have cloned a partial single copy P-450 aromatase from the terrapin using a cDNA library constructed from ovarian mRNA. This partial clone is highly homologous to other vertebrate aromatases.

Disruption of ovarian development in alligator embryos treated with an aromatase inhibitor

It has been suggested that sex differentiation in vertebrates is steroid hormone dependent, that estrogens play a critical role in ovarian differentiation, and that male sex differentiation will occur in the absence of estrogens. Using the model of the alligator in which sex can be manipulated by incubation conditions (eggs incubated at a constant temperature of 30 degrees produce 100% females, and at 33 degrees produce 100% males), a series of experiments using antiestrogens, antiandrogen, estradiol-17 beta, dihydrotestosterone (DHT), and aromatase inhibitors were performed. Test substances were injected into alligator eggs prior to gonadal sex differentiation and the eggs were incubated at male or female temperatures until just before expected date of hatching. Gonads were excised and the sex was verified histologically. Control embryos injected with vehicle produced the expected sex: females at 30 degrees and males at 33 degrees. Estradiol in eggs at 33 degrees (male temperature) produced 100% females and did not alter female development in eggs at 30 degrees. Antiandrogen, DHT, and a steroid antiestrogen had no discernible effect in either the 30 degrees or the 33 degrees eggs at the doses tested. The aromatase inhibitors aminoglutethimide and 4-hydroxyandrostenedione caused a moderate disruption of ovarian development and had no apparent effect on testicular development. The nonsteroidal aromatase inhibitor, Ciba Geigy 16949A, caused inhibition of ovarian development in all treated embryos. The Mullerian ducts did not appear to be affected by this treatment, or by any of the other treatments, and the gonads did not appear masculinized. We conclude that estrogen appears to be necessary for normal ovarian development, but that inhibition of estrogen synthesis alone is insufficient to cause masculinization. Likewise, exogenous androgens appear unable to masculinize embryonic gonads. The evidence suggests that testicular differentiation in amniote vertebrates is dependent on factors other than androgens or level of estrogens.

The effects of norethindrone on the mullerian ducts of the American alligator

Norethindrone, a reported aromatase inhibitor, has been used to examine the role of estrogens in the unilateral regression of the mullerian ducts that occurs in female chick embryos. The mullerian ducts are embryonic oviducts that regress in most male vertebrates under the influence of the testicular hormone, mullerian inhibiting substance (MIS). The ovaries of the chick also produce MIS during early development, but only the right duct regresses. Based on the finding that the left duct contains significantly more estradiol binding sites than the right duct, it has been proposed that the left duct is protected from the effects of MIS by preferentially binding estradiol from the ovaries. In support of this theory, norethindrone (0.1 and 0.5 mg) injected into the airsac of chick eggs results in regression of the left mullerian duct of female embryos, presumably by blocking the synthesis of estradiol. In the present study, it was hypothesized that crocodilians, because of the common ancestry they share with birds, would respond in a similar manner by exhibiting regression of both mullerian ducts in response to norethindrone. However, the application of norethindrone (0.5 mg) to the chorioallantoic membrane of female alligator embryos in ovo resulted in significant hypertrophy of the ducts, indicating that norethindrone had an estrogenic effect in the alligator rather than acting as an aromatase inhibitor. There was no effect of norethindrone on the gonads.