Advantages of handsewn over stapled bowel anastomosis

How Reliable Is Endoscopic Scoring of Postoperative Recurrence in Crohn Disease?: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Objective

Guidelines advise to perform endoscopic surveillance following ileocolic resection (ICR) in Crohn disease (CD) for timely diagnosis of recurrence. This study aims to assess the variation in endoscopic recurrence (ER) rates in patients after ICR for CD using the most commonly used classification systems, the Rutgeerts score (RS) and modified Rutgeerts score (mRS) classifications.

Methods

A systematic literature search using MEDLINE, Embase, and the Cochrane Library was performed. Randomized controlled trials and cohort studies describing ER < 12 months after an ICR for CD were included. Animal studies, reviews, case reports (<30 included patients), pediatric studies, and letters were excluded. The Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale and Cochrane Collaboration's tool were used to assess risk of bias. Main outcome was the range of ER rates within 12 months postoperatively, defined as RS ≥ i2 and/or mRS ≥ i2b. A proportional meta-analysis was performed. The final search was performed on January 4, 2022. The study was registered at PROSPERO, CRD42022363208.

Results

Seventy-six studies comprising 7751 patients were included. The weighted mean of ER rates in all included studies was 44.0% (95% confidence interval, 43.56-44.43). The overall range was 5.0% to 93.0% [interquartile range (IQR), 29.2-59.0]. The weighted means for RS and mRS were 44.0% and 41.1%, respectively. The variation in ER rates for RS and mRS were 5.0% to 93.0% (IQR, 29.0-59.5) and 19.8% to 62.9% (IQR, 37.3-46.5), respectively. Within studies reporting both RS and mRS, the weighted means for ER were 61.3% and 40.6%, respectively.

Conclusions

This study demonstrates a major variation in ER rates after ICR for CD, suggesting a high likelihood of inadequate diagnosis of disease recurrence, with potentially impact on quality of life and health care consumption. Therefore, there is an important need to improve endoscopic scoring of recurrent disease.

Optimising surgical anastomosis in ileocolic resection for Crohn's disease with respect to recurrence and functionality: two international parallel randomized controlled trials comparing handsewn (END-to-end or Kono-S) to stapled anastomosis (HAND2END and the End2End STUDIES)

BACKGROUND

The most common intestinal operation in Crohn's disease (CD) is an ileocolic resection. Despite optimal surgical and medical management, recurrent disease after surgery is common. Different types of anastomoses with respect to configuration and construction can be made after resection for example, handsewn (end-to-end and Kono-S) and stapled (side-to-side). The various types of anastomoses might affect endoscopic recurrence and its assessment, the functional outcome, and costs. The objective of the present study is to compare the three types of anastomoses with respect to endoscopic recurrence at 6 months, gastrointestinal function, and health care consumption.

METHODS

This is a randomized controlled multicentre superiority trial, allocating patients either to side-to-side stapled anastomosis as advised in current guidelines or a handsewn anastomoses (an end-to-end or Kono-S). It is hypothesized that handsewn anastomoses do better than stapled, and end-to-end perform better than the saccular Kono-S. Two international studies with a similar setup will be conducted mainly in the Netherlands (End2End) and Italy (HAND2END). Patients diagnosed with CD, aged over 16 years in the Netherlands and 18 years in Italy requiring (re)resection of the (neo)terminal ileum are eligible. The first part of the study compares the two handsewn anastomoses with the stapled anastomosis. To detect a clinically relevant difference of 25% in endoscopic recurrence, a total of 165 patients will be needed in the Netherlands and 189 patients in Italy. Primary outcome is postoperative endoscopic recurrence (defined as Rutgeerts score ≥ i2b) at 6 months. Secondary outcomes are postoperative morbidity, gastrointestinal function, quality of life (QoL) and costs.

DISCUSSION

The research question addresses a knowledge gap within the general practice elucidating which type of anastomosis is superior in terms of endoscopic and clinical recurrence, functionality, QoL and health care consumption. The results of the proposed study might change current practice in contrast to what is advised by the guidelines.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

NCT05246917 for HAND2END and NCT05578235 for End2End ( http://www.

CLINICALTRIALS

gov/ ).

Development and Validation of Task-Specific Metrics for the Assessment of Linear Stapler-Based Small Bowel Anastomosis

INTRODUCTION

Task-specific metrics facilitate the assessment of surgeon performance. This 3-phased study was designed to (1) develop task-specific metrics for stapled small bowel anastomosis, (2) obtain expert consensus on the appropriateness of the developed metrics, and (3) establish its discriminant validity.

METHODS

In Phase I, a hierarchical task analysis was used to develop the metrics. In Phase II, a survey of expert colorectal surgeons established the importance of the developed metrics. In Phase III, to establish discriminant validity, surgical trainees and surgeons, divided into novice and experienced groups, constructed a side-to-side anastomosis on porcine small bowel using a linear cutting stapler. The participants' performances were videotaped and rated by 2 independent observers. Partial least squares regression was used to compute the weights for the task-specific metrics to obtain weighted total score.

RESULTS

In Phase II, a total of 45 colorectal surgeons were surveyed: 28 with more than 15 years, 13 with 5 to 15 years, and 4 with less than 5 years of experience. The consensus was obtained on all the task-specific metrics in the more experienced groups. In Phase III, 20 subjects participated equally in both groups. The experienced group performed better than the novice group regardless of the rating scale used: global rating scale (p = 0.009) and the task-specific metrics (p = 0.012). After partial least squares regression, the weighted task-specific metric score continued to show that the experienced group performed better (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Task-specific metric items were developed based on expert consensus and showed good discriminant validity compared with a global rating scale between experienced and novice operators. These items can be used for evaluating technical skills in a stapled small bowel anastomosis model.

Preliminary evaluation of two-row versus three-row circular staplers for colorectal anastomosis after rectal resection: a single-center retrospective analysis

PURPOSE

Circular staplers for colorectal anastomoses significantly ameliorated post-operative outcomes after rectal resection. The more recent three-row technology was conceived to improve anastomotic resistance and, thus, lower the incidence of anastomotic complications. The aim of this study was to evaluate potential advantages of three-row circular staplers (Three-CS) on anastomotic leakage (AL), stenosis (AS), and hemorrhage (AH) rates after rectal resection as compared to two-row circular staplers (Two-CS).

METHODS

All rectal resections for rectal cancer between 2016 and 2021 were retrospectively included. Patients were classified according to the circular stapler employed in Two-CS and Three-CS cohorts. AL, AS, and AH rates were compared between the two populations. Additionally, the prognostic role of the type of circular stapler on AL onset was evaluated.

RESULTS

Three-hundred and seventy-five patients underwent a rectal resection with an end-to-end anastomosis during the study period: 197 constituted the Two-CS group and 178 the Three-CS cohort. AL rate was 6.7%, significantly higher in the Two-CS group (19-9.6%) as compared to the Three-CS cohort (6-3.4%) (p = 0.01). No difference was noted in terms of AL severity. Although not statistically significant, a lower incidence rate of AL was evidenced even in the subset of patients with low rectal cancers (4.5% vs 12.5% in the two-row cohort; p = 0.33). At the multivariate analysis, Two-CS was a negative prognostic factor for AL onset (OR: 2.63; p = 0.03). No difference was noted between the two groups in terms of AS and AH.

CONCLUSION

Three-row CSs significantly decrease the rate of AL after rectal resection. Further multicenter controlled trials are still needed to confirm the advantages of three-row CSs on anastomotic complications.

Endoscopic Recurrence or Anastomotic Wound Healing Phenomenon after Ileocolic Resection for Crohn's Disease: The Challenges of Accurate Endoscopic Scoring

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Adequate endoscopic scoring in Crohn's disease (CD) is crucial, as dictates the need for initiating postoperative medical therapy and is utilized as outcome parameter in clinical trials. We aimed to observe anastomotic wound healing in relation to endoscopic scoring of both inverted and everted stapled lines in side-to-side anastomoses.

METHODS

Two prospective patient cohorts were included: ileocolic resection (ICR) for CD, and right-sided colon resection for colorectal cancer (CRC). Videos taken during colonoscopy six months postoperatively were evaluated. The SES-CD and modified Rutgeerts score were determined. Primary outcome was the presence of ulcerations in CD patients on both the inverted and everted stapled lines. Secondary outcomes were the presence of anastomotic ulcerations in CRC patients and the number of cases having ulcerations exclusively at the inverted stapled line.

RESULTS

Of the 82 patients included in the CD cohort, ulcerations were present in 63/82 (76·8%) at the inverted- versus 1/71 (1·4%) at the everted stapled line. Likewise in the CRC cohort, ulcerations were present in 4/6 (67·7%) at the inverted versus 0/6 (0%) at the everted stapled line. 27% of the 63 patients in the CD cohort had ulcerations exclusively on the inverted stapled line.

CONCLUSION

Inverted stapled lines heal with ulcerations, whereas the everted stapled line heal without any ulcerations, both in CD and non-CD patients. The abnormalities at the inverted stapled line might interfere with endoscopic scoring of recurrence, with potentially an impact on patients' quality of life and on health-care costs if postoperative treatment is initiated incorrectly.

Double-layered hand-sewn anastomosis: a valuable resource for the colorectal surgeon

Hand-sewn anastomosis is an essential and fundamental skill for surgeons dealing with any gastrointestinal anastomosis. Despite the advances in minimally invasive surgery and stapling devices, there are still complex surgical circumstances when the surgeon’s surgical know-how are necessary. Therefore, a safe hand-sewn technique for bowel anastomosis is required to establish a tension-free, well-perfused, and sealed anastomosis that allows gastrointestinal continuity with no unexpected complications. We describe a step-by-step procedure for hand-sewn double-layered anastomosis that reflects these principles and is practical for small and large bowel anastomosis.

Fedora-type magnetic compression anastomosis device for intestinal anastomosis

BACKGROUND

Although previous studies have confirmed the feasibility of magnetic compression anastomosis (MCA), there is still a risk of long-term anastomotic stenosis. For traditional MCA devices, a large device is associated with great pressure, and eventually increased leakage.

AIM

To develop a novel MCA device to simultaneously meet the requirements of pressure and size.

METHODS

Traditional nummular MCA devices of all possible sizes were used to conduct ileac anastomosis in rats. The mean (± SD) circumference of the ileum was 13.34 ± 0.12 mm. Based on short- and long-term follow-up results, we determined the appropriate pressure range and minimum size. Thereafter, we introduced a novel “fedora-type” MCA device, which entailed the use of a nummular magnet with a larger sheet metal.

RESULTS

With traditional MCA devices, the anastomoses experienced stenosis and even closure during the long-term follow-up when the anastomat was smaller than Φ5 mm. However, the risk of leakage increased when it was larger than Φ4 mm. On comparison of the different designs, it was found that the “fedora-type” MCA device should be composed of a Φ4-mm nummular magnet with a Φ6-mm sheet metal.

CONCLUSION

The diameter of the MCA device should be greater than 120% of the enteric diameter. The novel “fedora-type” MCA device controls the pressure and optimizes the size.

Treatment of a Total Obstructive Anastomosis Stricture Using a Transanal Laparoscopic Approach and Intraoperative Colonoscopic Balloon Dilatation

An anastomosis stricture with a total obstruction is rare and treatment options are variable. We describe our experience with a combination of a single port transanal laparoscopic approach and intraoperative colonoscopic balloon dilatation. The patient was a 48-year-old man with rectal cancer. A laparoscopic single port lower anterior resection and diverting ileostomy were performed followed by a colon study and ileostomy takedown. The colon study and sigmoidoscopy revealed total obstruction of the rectum at the anastomosis level. We employed a transanal approach using a single port to correct this. We located the anastomosis stricture site and generated a lumen using a dissector and electocautery method to insert the balloon device. Colonoscopic balloon dilatation was subsequently successful. The patient was discharged with no postoperative complications. A laparoscopic single port transanal approach with an intraoperative colonoscopic balloon dilatation is a viable alternative approach to treating an anastomosis stricture of the rectum.

Kono-S Anastomosis for Surgical Prophylaxis of Anastomotic Recurrence in Crohn's Disease: an International Multicenter Study

INTRODUCTION

The Kono-S (antimesenteric functional end-to-end handsewn) anastomosis has been used for Crohn's disease in Japan and the USA since 2003 and 2010, respectively. This technique was designed to reduce the risk of anastomotic surgical recurrence. This study reviews the outcomes a decade after the introduction of the Kono-S anastomosis to clinical practice.

METHODS

This study was conducted at five hospitals (four in Japan and one in the USA). A total of 187 patients in Japan (144 patients, group J) and the USA (43 patients, group US) who underwent Kono-S anastomosis for Crohn's disease between September 2003 and September 2011 were included.

RESULTS

With a median follow-up of 65 months, two surgical anastomotic recurrences have occurred in group J. Kaplan-Meier analysis showed that 5 and 10 years surgical recurrence-free survival rate was 98.6% in group J. No surgical anastomotic recurrences have been detected in group US with a median follow-up of 32 months. The Kono-S anastomosis was technically feasible and performed in all patients.

CONCLUSION

The Kono-S anastomosis appears to be safe and effective in reducing the risk of surgical recurrence in Crohn's disease.

Efficacy of single-layer continuous suture of the posterior wall in anastomosis involving a difficult location of the digestive tract

Surgery for digestive tract disease predominantly consists of reconstruction and anastomosis. Due to the difficult location, anastomosis is extremely challenging and the risk of complication increases accordingly. Traditional manual anastomosis and the application of a stapling device are insufficient. Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate the feasibility and safety of a novel manual method in a difficult anastomotic location, consisting of a single-layer continuous suture in the posterior wall. In total, 15 beagle dogs were included in the study; eight underwent surgery with the novel manual method for reconstruction and anastomosis of the digestive tract, while seven underwent surgery with the stapler device as a control. The subsequent postoperative complications were observed and, three months later, the anastomotic ports were excised, and the pathological formation and morphological changes were evaluated. No statistically significant differences were identified between the total (50.0 vs. 57.1%; P=0.782) and anastomotic (0.0 vs. 28.6%; P=0.200) complication rates in the manual suture and staple suture groups, respectively. Compared with the control group, the operative expenditure was lower in the manual group (1726.7±33.5 vs. 2135.7±43.1 renminbi; P=0.001), the diameter of the anastomotic port was larger in the manual group (3.04±0.07 vs. 2.24±0.25 cm; P=0.004) and the thickness of the anastomotic port (in cm) was thinner in the manual group (2.94±0.06 vs. 5.07±0.85; P=0.002). Furthermore, the pathological formation of the anastomositic port in the manual group was improved. The results of the current study suggest single-layer continuous suture of the posterior wall in anastomosis of the digestive tract to be a novel method with feasibility and safety, particularly in difficult anastomotic locations.

Single-layer continuous suture contributes to the reduction of surgical complications in digestive tract anastomosis involving special anatomical locations

The key point of digestive cancer surgery is reconstruction and anastomosis of the digestive tract. Traditional anastomoses involve double-layer interrupted suturing, manually or using a surgical stapler. In special anatomical locations, however, suturing may become increasingly difficult and the complication rate increases accordingly. In this study, we aimed to investigate the feasibility and safety of a new manual suturing method, the single-layer continuous suture in the posterior wall of the anastomosis. Between January, 2007 and August, 2012, 101 patients with digestive cancer underwent surgery in Xi'an Gaoxin Hospital. Of those patients, 27 underwent surgery with the new manual method and the remaining 74 underwent surgery using traditional methods of anastomosis of the digestive tract. Surgical time, intraoperative blood loss, drainage duration, complications, blood tests, postoperative quality of life (QOL) and overall expenditure were recorded and analyzed. No significant differences were observed in surgical time, intraoperative blood loss, temperature, blood tests and postoperative QOL between the two groups. However, compared with the control group, the new manual suture group exhibited a lower surgical complication rate (7.40 vs. 31.08%; P=0.018), lower blood transfusion volume (274.07±419.33 vs. 646.67±1,146.06 ml; P=0.053), shorter postoperative hospital stay (14.60±4.19 vs. 17.60±6.29 days; P=0.038) and lower overall expenditure (3,509.85±768.68 vs. 6,141.83±308.90 renminbi; P=0.001). Our results suggested that single-layer continuous suturing for the anastomosis of the digestive tract is feasible and safe and may contribute to the reduction of surgical complications and overall expenditure.

Risk factors for colorectal anastomotic stenoses and their impact on quality of life: what are the lessons to learn?

AIM

The aim of the study was to analyse the incidence of benign colorectal anastomotic stenoses in consecutive patients operated on in a single institution and to assess risk factors for their development. Their impact on quality of life was also evaluated.

METHOD

Patient characteristics, indications for surgery, surgical technique and postoperative complications were prospectively recorded. Stenosis was evaluated by rectoscopy at regular intervals, and patients were treated only if symptomatic. After at least 6 months following surgery, patients were asked to respond to the Short Form 36-item quality-of-life questionnaire during a telephone interview.

RESULTS

Of the original 211 patients considered, 195 underwent a follow-up rectoscopy and were included in the study. Benign stenosis were found in 26 (13%), and 19 (73%) symptomatic patients were treated successfully (15 with endoscopic dilatation and four with radial diathermic surgical incisions). Risk factors for anastomotic stenosis according to univariate analysis were female sex, diverticulitis, mechanical anastomosis, and anastomosis located between 8 and 12 cm from the anal verge. The significant risk factors identified by multivariate analysis were diverticulitis (OR 5, P=0.002) and mechanical anastomosis (OR 9, P=0.04). The self-perceived quality of life of patients with stenosis was significantly worse compared with controls.

CONCLUSION

Since diverticulitis and mechanical anastomosis are risk factors for anastomotic stenosis, surgeons should take this into account when they are considering what type of anastomotic technique to utilize.

Comparison of the Compression Anastomosis Ring (EndoCAR) With a Circular Stapled Anastomosis in a Porcine Model

Purpose. The aim of this study was to compare characteristics of rectal compression and stapled anastomoses at multiple time points. Methods. A total of 50 domestic pigs underwent a rectal anastomosis with a compression device or a circular stapler. They were sacrificed at zero-time, 2 days, 1 week, 1 month, and 3 months. Burst and maximal tolerated pressure and sites of failure, internal diameters, and radiographic leak rates were assessed. Desmosine (elastin) levels were determined. Results. There were no clinical or radiographic leaks. Overall, 10 out of 27 (37%) compression anastomoses burst at higher pressures than the 14 out of 24 (58%) stapled anastomoses. Mean circumference and anastomotic index were greater for the EndoCAR at 1 week and 3 months. Desmosine levels were similar. Conclusions. In the porcine model, compression rectal anastomoses with the EndoCAR had improved bursting pressures and internal circumference compared with circular stapled anastomoses.

[CS circular staplers for rectal surgery--a multicenter prospective study]

While circular staplers are used worldwide - especially for rectal anastomoses - there are relatively few publications on the effectiveness of these instruments. Between May 2008 and March 2009 in a prospective multicenter surveillance study 136 patients were enrolled from nine surgical units in Hungary. Rectal anastomoses were performed mainly in the upper and middle third of the rectum. In 115 cases adenocarcinoma, in 16 patients other type of malignant tumors and in 5 cases with anastomosis in the distal third were estimated too. 20 laparoscopic and 116 "conventional" surgery was performed. 32 mm diameter type CS circular staplers were used in 50, 28 mm in 85, and 25 mm in one case. Intraoperative technical failure of the device occurred in four cases, immediate correction were performed successfully in all of these patients and they recovered without postoperative complications. Late anastomotic leaks were detected in five patients, of which three healed spontaneously and two required reoperation. In the whole series two patients died representing a 1.4 percent mortality rate. The CS circular staplers proved to be appropriate for infraperitoneal rectal anastomoses.

Long-term quality of life after endoscopic dilation of strictured colorectal or colocolonic anastomoses

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic balloon dilation is the first-line treatment for benign colorectal anastomotic strictures. We aimed to objectively assess its long-term results.

METHODS

Gastrointestinal symptoms and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) were assessed at long-term after balloon dilation of anastomotic strictures in 31 consecutive patients (excluding those with inflammatory bowel disease) as well as and controls, using the validated Gastrointestinal Quality of Life Index (GIQLI). Most colectomies had been performed for benign diseases, with anastomoses located at the colorectal junction.

RESULTS

Completed surveys were collected from 81 subjects, including 27 study patients (response rate 87%), 27 surgical controls matched for age, gender, and indication of colectomy, and 27 healthy subjects. At a mean of 3.9 +/- 2.3 years after the first endoscopic balloon-dilation, study patients self-reported significantly more gastrointestinal symptoms than controls; these included frequent and urgent bowel movements, bloating, food restriction (p < or = 0.001, all comparisons), diarrhea, excessive passage of gas through the anus (p < 0.01, all comparisons), constipation, and abdominal pain (p < 0.05, all comparisons). Health-related quality of life was significantly impaired in study patients versus surgical controls and healthy subjects (GIQLI scores, 104 +/- 20, 119 +/- 24, and 121 +/- 16, respectively; p = 0.005). Impaired HRQoL subdimensions included gastrointestinal symptoms (p < 0.001), stress by treatment (p < 0.05), and emotional status (p = 0.08). HRQoL was independent of the delay between stricture dilation and the survey. Follow-up endoscopy (performed in 21/27 [78%] study patients, including the 7 patients with the lowest HRQoL, and 19 [70%] surgical controls) disclosed anastomoses larger than 13 mm in all cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Health-related quality of life is significantly impaired at long-term after standard balloon-dilation of benign anastomotic colorectal strictures as a result of gastrointestinal symptoms and stress by treatment. This impairment might be related to the fact that an anastomotic diameter > or = 13 mm, although commonly used to define successful endoscopic treatment, is insufficient to provide long-term symptom relief in some patients, or to other, yet to be identified, factors.

End-to-end compression anastomosis of the rectum: a pig model

BACKGROUND

Generations of investigators have attempted to achieve compression bowel anastomosis by a sutureless device, providing temporary support to the tissue and facilitating the natural healing process. The biocompatibility of nickel-titanium alloy has made it attractive for use in medical implants and devices, and several studies have described the creation of a side-to-side compression anastomosis in colon surgery with a nickel-titanium clip. We evaluated the feasibility and safety of a newly designed gun for applying a nickel-titanium compression anastomosis ring (CAR) to create an end-to-end colorectal anastomosis in a porcine model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A segment of the proximal rectum was resected in 25 pigs. The bowel ends were anastomosed transanally by an end-to-end CAR device. The animals' follow-up continued for up to 8 weeks, and included general health status, weight gain, blood tests, and abdominal X-ray. They were then sacrificed. The anastomoses were studied for burst pressure, anastomotic index, and histopathology.

RESULTS

One pig died due to iatrogenic bowel injury unrelated to the CAR device. There was no other morbidity/mortality. The other animals recovered and gained weight. Burst pressure studies demonstrated a minimum pressure of 160 mmHg at time point 0 that escalated quickly to >300 mmHg. The mean anastomotic index after 8 weeks was 0.81. Histologic evaluation revealed minimal inflammation and minimal fibrosis at the anastomosis site.

CONCLUSION

The principles of compression anastomosis are better executed with the use of memory shape alloys. The promising results of this novel technique should encourage further studies of this technology.

Surgical Stapling Devices in Veterinary Medicine: A Review

OBJECTIVES

To review indications, benefits, and complications of surgical stapling in animals.

STUDY DESIGN

Literature review.

RESULTS

Benefits and complications of surgical stapling depend on the procedure performed. Use of surgical staplers does not improve wound strength but may decrease surgical time.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

In patients at significant risk for intraoperative contamination or morbidity from prolonged anesthesia time, use of stapling devices should be considered.

Treatment of rectosigmoid endometriosis by laparoscopically assisted vaginal rectosigmoidectomy

OBJECTIVE

To describe the use of mechanical anastomoses in cases of laparoscopically assisted vaginal rectosigmoidectomy for the treatment of rectosigmoid endometriosis.

METHODS

Pilot study evaluating eight patients with rectosigmoid endometriosis referred for surgical treatment. All patients were submitted to laparoscopically assisted vaginal segmental resection of the rectosigmoid with anastomoses performed using linear and circular staplers.

RESULTS

The average length of the surgical procedure was 177.5 min and average duration of hospitalization was 4.13 days. There were no intra-operative complications and integrity of the anastomoses was confirmed in all patients. One patient reported partial improvement of symptoms and 7 patients presented complete clinical remission 12 months following surgery.

CONCLUSION

Laparoscopically assisted vaginal segmental resection of the sigmoid infiltrated by endometriosis is a feasible surgical procedure. The technique combines transvaginal access with mechanical intestinal anastomoses performed using linear and circular staplers, and achieves good results with low morbidity.

Side-to-side stapled anastomosis strongly reduces anastomotic leak rates in Crohn's disease surgery

PURPOSE

Anastomotic configuration may influence anastomotic leak rates. The aim of this study was to determine whether a side-to-side stapled ileocolonic anastomosis produces lower anastomotic leak rates than those with a handsewn end-to-end ileocolonic anastomosis after ileocecal or ileocolonic resection for Crohn's disease.

METHODS

A series of 122 consecutive patients underwent elective ileocecal or ileocolonic resection with ileocolonic anastomosis for Crohn's disease from January 1998 to June 2003: 71 had handsewn end-to-end anastomosis and 51 had side-to-side stapled anastomosis. The choice between the two anastomoses was left to the surgeon's preference. A retrospective analysis was performed to assess if there was any difference in anastomotic leak rates.

RESULTS

The two groups were comparable in terms of age, gender, preoperative presence of abscess or fistula, history of smoking, and albumin levels. More patients were taking steroids in the handsewn group than in the stapled group. In the handsewn group there were 10 anastomotic leaks (14.1 percent) and in the stapled group there was 1 anastomotic leak (2.0 percent) (risk difference, +12.1 percent; 95 percent confidence interval, 1.7-22.2; P = 0.02). Anastomotic configuration was the sole variable that influenced anastomotic leak rates at univariate analysis. Mortality was 1.4 percent in the handsewn group and 0 percent in the stapled group. Complications other than anastomotic leak developed in 11 patients in the hand-sewn group and in 6 patients in the stapled group. Mean postoperative hospital stay was 12.3 days in the handsewn group and 9.7 days in the stapled group (P = 0.03). Excluding those patients who had an anastomotic leak, the difference was still present (handsewn group, 10.1 days; stapled group, 9.1 days; P = 0.04).

CONCLUSION

Although confirmation from randomized, controlled trials is required, side-to-side stapled anastomosis seems to substantially decrease anastomotic leak rates in surgical patients with Crohn's disease, compared with handsewn end-to-end anastomosis. Postoperative hospital stay decreased in the stapled anastomosis group, and this was not entirely a result of decreased anastomotic leak rates.

An alternative linear stapling technique for performing Roux-en-Y anastomosis

BACKGROUND

The use of stapling devices for performing gastrointestinal anastomosis has gained wide acceptance in the last decade. Linear cutting devices have been used routinely during gastrointestinal operations in our hospital since 1992. However, we still have shortage of stapling devices due to cost reduction politics.

METHODS

We propose a modification of the standard technique in order to reduce the number of devices used. Our technique employs a single stapled including the section of the jejunum and the side-to-side jejunoanastomosis.

RESULTS

We have used this technique for 1 year without complications related to the stapled anastomosis.

CONCLUSIONS

This technique may reduce the time of reconstruction of Roux-en-Y anastomosis without interfering in its final result. This modified technique may be useful in hospitals with reduced economic resources.

Short-term functional outcome following elective surgery for complicated sigmoid diverticular disease: sutured or stapled end-to-end anastomosis to the proximal rectum?

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this retrospective non-randomized study was to evaluate the short-term functional outcome following elective resectional surgery for complicated sigmoid diverticular disease, and to compare results of patients having hand-sewn or stapled end-to-end colonic anastomosis to the proximal rectum.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between 1983 and 1995, of 182 consecutive patients referred to our Institution for surgical treatment of complicated sigmoid diverticular disease, 137 underwent elective left hemicolectomy with primary colonic anastomosis to the proximal rectum, at a level above the peritoneal reflection. Twenty-one patients were excluded from the study because of a covering stoma (n=15), or a side-to-end (n=5) or side-to-side (n=1) anastomosis. All remaining 116 patients had an end-to-end anastomosis without covering stoma. Two groups were compared according to the type of anastomosis performed. Group I comprised the 67 patients who had a hand-sewn anastomosis, and group II the 49 patients whose anastomosis was stapled. Outcome was assessed at 6 months after surgery and compared in the two groups. Assessment included specific morbidity (anastomotic leakage, haemorrhage, fistulation and stenosis, pelvic sepsis), faecal incontinence, constipation, dyschesia, daily stool frequency, and stool consistency.

RESULTS

Preoperative patient details were comparable in both groups. There was no post-operative mortality, and the general morbidity rate was similar in both groups (P=0.85). There was no anastomotic leakage or haemorrhage, and no fistulation or pelvic sepsis in either group. One patient in group I, and two from group II, developed flatus incontinence, and a further patient from group II developed incontinence to liquid stool (P=0.17, group I vs group II). We observed better functional outcome following hand-sewn anastomosis. Three group II patients developed anastomotic stenosis compared with none in group I (P=0.04). Constipation (9% vs 28%, P=0.005) and dyschesia (18% vs 39%, P=0.03) were more frequent in group II. Excluding constipated patients (n=20), daily stool frequency was lower (mean 1.2 +/- 0.6 vs 2 +/- 1.3, P=0.0002), and more frequently of normal consistency (79% vs 43%, P=0.0001) in group I. Subgroup analysis failed to show significant differences in functional outcome in both groups in relation to the specific indications for surgery.

CONCLUSION

These retrospective data suggest for the first time in the reported literature that hand-sewn colonic anastomosis to the proximal rectum provides a better short-term functional outcome than stapled anastomosis following elective resectional surgery for complicated sigmoid diverticulosis.

Anorectal dysfunction following low anterior resection for rectal carcinoma: a comparison between handsewn and stapled anastomosis

Sphincter-saving resection for rectal carcinoma is frequently accompanied by anorectal dysfunction (increased stool frequency and varying degrees of faecal incontinence). Although numerous reports regarding this dysfunction have been published, the exact mechanism is still controversial. The purpose of the present study was to compare the functional results of low anterior resection (LAR) for rectal carcinoma following handsewn and stapled anastomosis. The patients with rectal carcinoma were divided into two groups: LAR with handsewn anastomosis (HS) (n = 15), and LAR with stapled EEA (U.S. Surgical Corporation) anastomosis (EEA) (n = 16; four with 28 mm stapler, 12 with 31 mm stapler). Sixteen patients with carcinoma of sigmoid colon who received high anterior resection (HAR) were taken as the control group. Anorectal functional study was performed preoperatively and post-operatively at 1 week and another after 6 months, whereas routine clinical assessment was carried out preoperatively and 6 months post-operatively. The post-operative maximal resting pressure was significantly reduced in both HS and EEA groups, while a tendency to recovery was observed in the HS and 28 mm stapler group 6 months later. A significant decrease in rectal capacity was noted in the EEA group. The return of rectoanal inhibitory reflex was observed in 67% of the HS group and 37.5% of the EEA group. Although clinically increased stool frequency was experienced in both HS and EEA groups, continence was significantly worse in the EEA group. LAR for rectal carcinoma results in impaired anorectal function, which might present clinically with increased stool frequency and minor faecal soiling. The former may be due partially to reduced neorectal capacity, while the latter may be due to internal anal sphincter dysfunction, possibly because of damage to innervation.

Handsewn vs. stapled anastomoses in colon and rectal surgery: a meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Trials comparing handsewn with stapled anastomoses in colon and rectal surgery have not found statistical differences. Despite this, authors have differed in their conclusions as to which technique is superior. To help determine whether differences in patient outcomes are present, a meta-analysis of all trials was performed.

METHOD

A meta-analysis of all randomized, controlled trials assessing handsewn and stapled colon and rectal anastomoses was done using a fixed-effects model. Outcome variables were mortality, technical problems, leak rates, wound infections, strictures, and cancer recurrence. Outcomes were assessed for all anastomoses involving the colon and for the subset of colorectal anastomoses.

RESULTS

Thirteen distinct trials met the inclusion criteria. Intraoperative technical problems were more likely to occur with stapled than with handsewn anastomoses for all anastomoses (P < 0.0001) and for colorectal anastomoses (P < 0.001). Strictures were also more common following stapled anastomoses (P = 0.015 for all anastomoses; P = 0.028 for colorectal anastomoses). All other outcome measures, including mortality, clinical and radiologic leak rates, and local cancer recurrence rates showed no difference between groups.

CONCLUSION

Although intraoperative technical problems and postoperative strictures were more common with stapled anastomoses, other outcome measures showed no difference between groups. Thus, both techniques are effective, and the choice may be based on personal preference.

Results of the double stapling procedure in colorectal surgery

In this report we review our results with the double stapling technique (DST) in 162 patients with colorectal diseases in an attempt to identify some of the potential pitfalls of this new technique. Among these 162 patients, there were 125 patients with colorectal cancer, 25 with chronic ulcerative colitis (UC), 9 with familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP), 2 with adult Hirschsprung's disease, and 1 with sigmoid colon fistula. A total of 46 anastomoses (28 for rectal cancer, 13 for UC, 3 for FAP, and 2 for adult Hirschsprung's disease) were performed at or near the dentate line. Of these, 10 had protective diverting colostomy or ileostomy. The results showed that 6 patients with rectal cancer had anastomotic leakage (3.7%); however, 4 of the 6 patients had also received preoperative irradiation. All the leaks healed after the patients had undergone diverting colostomy, but 7 patients with rectal cancer suffered from neurogenic bladder postoperatively (4.3%). Wound infection occurred in 4 patients (2.5%), anastomotic bleeding in 3 (1.9%), and anal pain in 1 (0.6%), respectively. One patient with rectal cancer and multiple liver metastases died of disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC). These results thus suggest that the double stapling technique provides a safe anastomosis at or near the dentate line not only for rectal cancer but also for UC, FAP, and adult Hirschsprung's disease.

A new device for the treatment of coloproctostomic stricture after double stapling anastomoses

OBJECTIVE

A new device of staple cutter was developed to evaluate the clinical effect for the treatment of rectal stricture after the double stapling anastomosis.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

The double stapling technique has become an established reconstruction method for patients with low anterior resection. The major complication of anastomotic stricture associated with circular stapling has been reported to be harmful and distressing. Because underlying mechanisms of stricture are not well understood, no prophylactic means have been developed and this results in postoperative dilation still being the only treatment available. Although various dilation methods are used for the treatment of stricture, none is fully satisfactory.

METHODS

Low anterior resection was performed in 30 patients with rectal carcinoma using a double stapling technique. First, the incidence of the anastomotic stricture and the clinical factors that contribute to the stricture formation were studied. Second, the clinical effects and advantages of the treatment of coloproctostomic stricture using the newly developed device (staple cutter) were evaluated.

RESULTS

Nine (30%) of 30 patients had anastomotic stricture with the symptom of distressing frequent bowel movement. There was no significant relation between the clinical factors and the stricture when compared with that of nonstricture patients. Excellent dilation was performed in all of the nine strictures using the staple cutter, and the symptom of stricture disappeared dramatically in eight patients (89%) within 1 week. The recurrence of stricture occurred in two patients; however, it has not been observed after one further use of this treatment. The staple cutter is safe and easy to use even at the bedside, and except for a conventional anoscope, no special equipment, including fluoroscope, was needed.

CONCLUSIONS

From the significant effects and advantages, the procedure using staple cutter is recommended highly for the treatment of circular stapling anastomotic stricture of the rectum.

Esophageal anastomosis: an experimental model to study anastomotic healing and the use of lyophilized collagen

This experimental study assessed the use of lyophilized collagen to reinforce cervical esophageal anastomosis in rabbits. Twenty New Zealand White rabbits weighing 2.3-3.2 kg were used. In group I (n = 10) a 1-cm-long segment of the esophagus was excised and the two free edges anastomosed, to mimic the conditions found in newborn esophageal atresia. Group II (n = 10) had a segmental esophageal resection and end-to-end anastomosis as in group I but the anastomotic site was circumferentially covered with lyophilized type I collagen film. The resected segments were processed immediately and served as controls for the postoperative tissue in each animal. The animals were starved for the first 24 h and water was given on the 2nd postoperative day; on the 3rd postoperative day the animals were allowed a normal diet. Two rabbits in group II died on the 7th and 8th postoperative days because of a fistula. All the rabbits were killed on the 10th postoperative day and 4-cm segments of esophagus with the anastomosis at the centre were removed. At this time gross leakage was detected in four animals (one in group I and three in group II). Each anastomosis was evaluated for bursting pressure, collagen content, and histologic appearance. Bursting pressure was higher in group I. Collagen (measured as hydroxyproline) levels in anastomotic and adjoining 1-cm segments were compared with concentrations in control segments resected during operation. In group II animals there was a significant reduction in the lowering of hydroxyproline concentrations around the anastomosis. Microscopic evaluation revealed no significant differences between the two groups. This experiment showed no demonstrable benefit from the use of lyophilized collagen in preventing the esophageal anastomotic leakage that occurs in repaired esophageal atresia.

Supraperitoneal colorectal anastomosis: hand-sewn versus circular staples--a controlled clinical trial. French Associations for Surgical Research

BACKGROUND

Although used widely for supraperitoneal anastomoses, circular stapled anastomoses have never been proved better than hand-sewn anastomoses. In the one prospective controlled trial that studied these anastomoses specifically, the only significant difference found was that there were more clinically obvious leakages with the circular stapled variety, but not in the overall clinical and roentgenologic leakage rates.

METHODS

One hundred fifty-nine consecutive patients (88 men and 71 women, mean age 65.8 +/- 12.1 years) were randomized to undergo hand-sewn (n = 74) or circular stapled (n = 85) supraperitoneal colorectal anastomosis after left colectomy.

RESULTS

Patient demographics were similar in both groups. Overall mortality was 1.3% (2 of 159; one in each group). No statistically significant difference (NS) was found in the rate of early complications, including anastomotic leakage (4 of 74 versus 6 of 85) in the hand-sewn and stapled anastomoses, respectively). Mishaps (n = 10) and hemorrhage (n = 5) occurred in the stapled group only. Stapled anastomoses took an average of 8 minutes less to perform (p < 0.001), but this time gain did not significantly influence the overall duration of operation (identical median times). The median duration of hospitalization was 13 and 14 days, respectively (NS). At 8 months there were 2 of 74 strictures in the hand-sewn group and 4 of 85 strictures in the stapled group (NS).

CONCLUSIONS

According to these results, there seems to be no advantage of routine or regular use of stapling instruments for supraperitoneal colorectal anastomosis.

Blood flow in colon anastomotic stricture formation

PURPOSE

The influence of both blood flow and anastomotic technique on the development of anastomotic stricture formation was studied using a dog model.

METHODS

Fifty-three dogs underwent distal colocolonic anastomosis with either an EEA (U.S. Surgical Corp., Norwalk, CT) circular stapler or a Czerny-Lembert two-layered, handsewn anastomosis. Blood flow was measured by Laser Doppler Velocimetry using the Laserflo BPM2 (Vasamedics Inc., St. Paul, MN). The animals were separated into three blood flow groups: greater than or equal to 62.5 percent of normal blood flow, between 37.5 percent and 62.5 percent of normal blood flow, and less than or equal to 37.5 percent of normal blood flow. Each blood flow group had an anastomosis performed by either stapling or by hand sewing techniques. At six weeks, the anastomoses were opened longitudinally and fixed to determine the anastomotic index (AI). AI is defined as two times the anastomotic circumference over the proximal circumference plus the distal circumference. Blood flow groups and anastomotic technique groups were compared with an interaction variable for the outcome, AI using a two-way analysis of variance.

RESULTS

The AI of the stapled anastomoses was found to be significantly higher than handsewn anastomoses (P < 0.006). There was no difference in AI between different blood flow groups and no correlation of observed histologic findings with AI.

CONCLUSION

Clinically relevant ischemia does not directly influence stricture formation in either handsewn or stapled distal colonic anastomoses.

Vaginal hysterectomy with the Autosuture stapler

Our objective was to assess the applicability of hysterectomy by the vaginal route completely performed with Autosuture staples. Between January 1992 and September 1993, 5 vaginal hysterectomies using Autosuture staplers were performed by the authors. Five vaginal hysterectomies matched for age, parity, and uterine size performed by the same surgeons using reabsorbable sutures during the same period were used as case controls. No febrile morbidity, cuff infections, thrombophlebitis, bladder injury, or hemorrhage complications were observed in the 10 women who entered the study. In summary, vaginal hysterectomy can be performed with Autosutures easily, probably faster with experience, and with less oozing from the operative field, thus providing a safe procedure.

Surgical stapling of the small intestine

Intestinal resection and anastomosis, bypass enterostomy, and typhlectomy are indicated for many intestinal disorders. The thoracoabdominal and end-to-end anastomosis stapling instruments all may be used to perform a variety of small intestinal surgical procedures.