Modern approaches to the study of mammalian cells in culture

The concept of telomeric non-reciprocal recombination (TENOR) applied to human fibroblasts grown in serial cultures: concordance with genealogical data

Since the discovery of the limited life span of human fibroblasts some 50 years ago, many genealogical studies have been undertaken to describe growth kinetics of fibroblasts in serial cultures by their individual division behavior. It is now accepted that proliferation capacities of human fibroblasts strongly depend on their telomere lengths and integrity. Telomeres shorten with each replication round, and there is a direct correlation between cell division capacity and telomere lengths; that is, the consumption of disposable telomeric DNA repeats during cell divisions progresses until critically short telomeres determining the replicative senescence of the cells are present. Recently, we have suggested that telomeres in fibroblasts can also become elongated during DNA replication by telomeric non-reciprocal recombination (TENOR). Here we discuss genealogical data collected over the last decades as well as more recent findings on the telomere-driven replicative senescence process, and we summarize both to give an integrated picture.

The population-dependent requirement by cultured mammalian cells for metabolites which they can synthesize

At least seven compounds synthesized by cultured cells in amounts which should suffice for sustained growth have nevertheless proved under certain conditions necessary for survival (asparagine, cystine, glutamine, homocystine inositol, pyruvate, serine). In every instance so far examined, that requirement has been population-dependent, disappearing at cell densities sufficiently large to bring the concentration in the medium and in the cellular pool to metabolically effective levels before the cells died of the specific deficiency. At population densities of less than 100 cells per ml, serine was required by all cultured cells so far studied. With more exigent strains, such as the RT6 strain of rabbit fibroblast and the P388 mouse leukemia, the serine requirement disappeared only at populations in excess of 50,000 and 150,000 cells per ml, respectively. The requirement for pyruvate by the latter cell as an alternative to serine also disappeared at that population density. In a cystine-free medium there were population-dependent requirements for cystine, homocystine, or serine, depending on the experimental conditions. With methionine and glucose as cystine precursors, the critical population density permitting cellular survival and growth was in excess of 200,000 cells/ml. The provision of homocystine as an intermediate reduced the critical population density to 10,000 to 60,000 cells/ml; with the further provision of serine, the critical cell concentration permitting growth was reduced to 50 to 500 cells/ml. Cells adapted to glutamic acid, and capable of utilizing it as a substitute for glutamine, nevertheless required exogeneous glutamine at cellular densities of less than 50,000 cells per ml. In some experiments, the provision of asparagine reduced the critical population density to 10,000 cells/ml, presumably because of its glutamine-sparing action. Inositol is required by most cell lines, despite their demonstrated capacity to synthesize it from glucose. With at least one cell line (HeLa), sustained growth was occasionally achieved in an inositol-free medium if the population density was maintained in excess of 240,000 cells/ml. The possible implications of these findings with respect to the loss of specific organ functions in dispersed cell culture are discussed.

Quantitative studies of the growth of mouse embryo cells in culture and their development into established lines

Disaggregated mouse embryo cells, grown in monolayers, underwent a progressive decline in growth rate upon successive transfer, the rapidity of the decline depending, among other things, on the inoculation density. Nevertheless, nearly all cultures developed into established lines within 3 months of culture. The first sign of the emergence of an established line was the ability of the cells to maintain a constant or rising potential growth rate. This occurred while the cultures were morphologically unchanged. The growth rate continued to increase until it equaled or exceeded that of the original culture. The early established cells showed an increasing metabolic autonomy, as indicated by decreasing dependence on cell-to-cell feeding. It is suggested that the process of establishment involves an alteration in cell permeability properties. Chromosome studies indicated that the cells responsible for the upturn in growth rate were diploid, but later the population shifted to the tetraploid range, often very rapidly. Still later, marker chromosomes appeared. Different lines acquired different properties, depending on the culture conditions employed; one line developed which is extremely sensitive to contact inhibition.

Multicomponent investigations of the hydrogen peroxide- and hydroxyl radical-scavenging antioxidant capacities of biofluids: the roles of endogenous pyruvate and lactate. Relevance to inflammatory joint diseases

High field proton (1H) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis of biofluids (health human blood sera and inflammatory knee-joint synovial fluids) has been employed to evaluate the hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)- and hydroxyl radical (0OH)- scavenging antioxidant capacities of a range of polar, low-molecular-mass endogenous metabolites therein. Data obtained indicate that consumption of H2O2 by pyruvate (generating acetate and CO2 via an oxidative decarboxylation reaction) and 0OH radical by lactate (generating pyruvate, and subsequently acetate and CO2) may serve to protect alternative biofluid components (e.g., macromolecules) against reactive oxygen species-mediated oxidative damage in vivo. The mechanistic, physiological and potential therapeutic implications of these results are discussed with special reference to inflammatory joint diseases.

METABOLIC CONTROLS IN CULTURED MAMMALIAN CELLS

A number of apparently unrelated factors are known to have a profound effect on the metabolism of cultured mammalian cells; and some of these may be operative as metabolic controls in the whole animal as well. The more complete exploration of (i) homotypic and heterotypic cellular interactions, (ii) the spontaneous transformations sometimes observed in cultured cells, (iii) the mode of action of cytotoxic agents, (iv) the multiple metabolic effects of viral infection, and (v) the conditions necessary for the maintenance of specialized function in cultured cells, can be expected to throw light on the basic mechanisms underlying such complex processes as differentiation, senescence, and cancer.

A free-radical hypothesis for the instability and evolution of genotype and phenotype in vitro

It has been known for several decades that cultured murine cells undergo a defined series of changes, i.e., an in vitro evolution, which includes crisis, spontaneous transformation ('immortalization'), aneuploidy, and spontaneous neoplastic transformation. These changes have been shown to be caused by the in vitro environment rather than an inherent instability of the murine phenotype or genotype. Serum amine oxidases were recently identified as a predominant cause of crisis. These enzymes generate hydrogen peroxide from polyamine substrates that enter the extracellular milieu. This finding implicates free-radical toxicity as the underlying cause of in vitro evolution. We propose an oxyradical hypothesis to explain each of the stages of in vitro evolution and discuss its significance for cytotechnology and long-term cultivation of mammalian cell types.

Secretion of pyruvate. An antioxidant defense of mammalian cells

Cells in culture are exposed to marked oxidative stress, H2O2 being one of the predominant agents. Pyruvate and other alpha-ketoacids reacted rapidly, stoichiometrically, and nonenzymatically with H2O2, and they protected cells from its cytolytic effects. All five human and murine cell types studied, both malignant and nonmalignant, released pyruvate at an initial rate of 35-60 microM/h/2.5 X 10(6) cells when placed in 1 ml pyruvate-free medium. After 6-12 h a plateau of 60-150 microM pyruvate was attained, corresponding to concentrations reported for normal human serum and plasma. The rate of pyruvate accumulation was almost doubled in the presence of exogenous catalase, suggesting that released pyruvate functions as an antioxidant. The rate of pyruvate accumulation was dependent on cell number. Succinate, fumarate, citrate, oxaloacetate, alpha-ketoglutarate, and malate were not secreted in significant amounts from P815 cells; export was specific for pyruvate and lactate among the metabolites tested. Extracellular pyruvate was in equilibrium with intracellular stores. Thus, cells conditioned the extracellular medium with pyruvate at the expense of intracellular pyruvate, until homeostatic levels were attained in both compartments. We propose that cells plated at low density in the absence of exogenous pyruvate fail to thrive for two reasons: prolonged depletion of intracellular pyruvate and prolonged vulnerability to oxidant stress.

Specific replacements of pyruvate for trophic support of central and peripheral nervous system neurons

When embryonic central nervous system neurons are seeded at low densities with Eagle's basal medium supplemented with the serum substitute N1, glucose, and glutamine, neuronal survival for even 24 h requires the additional supply of exogenous pyruvate--and so does the survival of many peripheral nervous system neurons. Pyruvate can be replaced by alpha-ketoglutarate or oxaloacetate, but not by Krebs cycle substrates that are not keto acids. Most other alpha-keto acids tested (though not beta- or gamma-keto acids) also mimic pyruvate. The apparent equivalence to pyruvate of all these compounds includes identical ED50 values (300 microM for embryonic avian fore-brain neurons, 30-40 microM for rat hippocampal neurons), and also identical susceptibilities to the pyruvate-sparing effects of other low-molecular-weight agents present in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium or in astroglia conditioned medium. The substitute alpha-keto acids, however--unlike pyruvate, alpha-ketoglutarate, or oxaloacetate--support cell survival only in the presence of alpha-amino acids that transaminate to alpha-ketoglutarate, oxaloacetate, or pyruvate. The alpha-keto acids, therefore, operate as acceptors of amino groups from appropriate donors to generate Krebs cycle-relevant substrates. Consistent with this view, [14C]glutamate did not generate appreciable 14CO2 unless accompanied by a suitable alpha-keto acid.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Pyruvate regulation of growth and differentiation in primary cultures of rat tracheal epithelial cells

These studies examined the effect of exogenous pyruvate on the growth and differentiation of primary cell cultures of rat tracheal epithelial cells. The cell cultures were derived from outgrowths of tracheal explants, and require pyruvate for survival and growth in the presence of 10% FBS. In pyruvate-supplemented (2 mM) medium, the number of cells attached to the dish increased rapidly, while exfoliation of cells into the medium as well as formation of cornified envelopes were relatively low. The growth response to pyruvate was concentration-dependent in these cell cultures. In the absence of pyruvate, the extent of terminal differentiation to keratinization gradually increased. This was characterized by a cessation of growth after one week, and an increase in exfoliation until all cells had sloughed from the dish. Accompanying these changes was a marked increase in the formation of cornified envelopes. Cells undergoing DNA synthesis were present throughout 2 weeks of culture in pyruvate-deprived medium, even as the total number of cells was diminishing. Several compounds, including other 2-oxocarboxylic acids, were ineffective growth substitutes for pyruvate. These results indicate that the requirement for pyruvate is quite stringent in these cultures and that one way pyruvate promotes the growth of tracheal epithelial cells is by inhibiting terminal differentiation.

The respiration-linked limiting step of tumor cell transition from the non-cycling to the cycling state: its inhibition by oxidizable substrates and its relationships to purine metabolism

The recruitment into the cycling state of resting Yoshida AH 130 hepatoma cells was studied with respect to its dependence on respiration in an experimental system wherein the overall energy requirement for this recruitment can be supplied by the glycolytic ATP. The G1-S transition of these cells, unaffected by 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP) at concentrations which uncouple the respiratory phosphorylation, is impaired either by blocking the electron flow to oxygen by antimycin A or by adding an excess of some oxidizable substrates, chiefly pyruvate and oxalacetate. An experimental analysis, focused on pyruvate activity, showed that the inhibition of cell recruitment into S is not related to the depressing effects of this substrate on aerobic glycolysis of tumor cells, nor is it modified by forcing, in the presence of DNP, pyruvate oxidation through the tricarboxylic acid cycle as well as the overall oxygen consumption. Addition of suitable concentrations of preformed purine bases (mainly adenine), completely removes the block of the G1-S transition produced either by the excess of oxidizable substrates or by antimycin A. These findings indicate the existence of a respiration-linked step in purine metabolism, which restricts the above transition and is equally impaired by blocking the respiratory chain or by saturating it with an excess of reducing equivalents derived from unrelated oxidations. The inhibitory effects of pyruvate and antimycin A can be largely removed by the addition of folate and tetrahydrofolate, suggesting that the respiration-linked restriction point of tumor cell cycling involves the folate metabolism and its connections to purine synthesis.

Effects of pyruvate on the growth of normal and transformed hamster embryo fibroblasts

The growth of NIL and NILpy hamster embryo fibroblasts was determined in the presence and absence of pyruvate as a component of the growth medium. It was demonstrated that NIL cells respond to the presence of pyruvate by decreasing cell doubling time, glucose utilization, glutamine utilization, and increasing lactate production with the effects being more pronounced at low inoculum densities. Polyoma-virus transformed NIL cells (NILpy) demonstrate none of the above effects upon pyruvate addition regardless of initial cell inoculum density.

L-Lactate or pyruvate stimulated growth of Novikoff rat hepatoma cells

Novikoff rat hepatoma cells (subline N1S1-67) grew when 30 mM L-lactate or pyruvate was substituted for D-glucose in Swim's medium 67 supplemented with dialyzed calf bovine serum. A 2.6-fold increase in cell number (1.34 generations) was obtained. RNA, DNA, protein and dry weight increased in proportion to the cell number. In control medium lacking L-lactate, pyruvate or D-glucose, cell growth of 0.42 generation was obtained. Growth with L-lactate was dependent on the L-lactate concentration up to 30 mM at which the greatest increase in cell number occurred. Significant growth did not occur when D-lactate, glycerol, acetate, alpha-ketoglutarate, succinate or malate, each at 30 mM, was substituted for D-glucose. Growth in the medium containing L-lactate was not due to the utilization of D-glucose or some other substrate carried into the culture with the inoculum. Medium contamination by D-glucose was insufficient to explain the growth obtained in the medium containing L-lactate, but could have accounted for growth in the control medium. Throughout growth, the concentration of L-lactate in the medium remained unchanged. The increase in cell number cannot be explained by L-lactate triggering the utilization of glycogen, nor by oxidation and degradation of protein, amino acids, fatty acids, or carbohydrate moieties of glycoprotein in the medium. L-Lactate does not serve as a significant carbon or energy source in the growth of these cells.