Analysis of an esterase linked to a locus involved in the regulation of the melanoma oncogene and isolation of polymorphic marker sequences in Xiphophorus

Oncogenic allelic interaction in Xiphophorus highlights hybrid incompatibility

The Bateson–Dobzhansky–Muller (BDM) model describes negative epistatic interactions that occur between genes with a different evolutionary history to account for hybrid incompatibility and is a central theory explaining genetic mechanisms underlying speciation. Since the early 1900 s when the BDM model was forwarded examples of BDM incompatibility have been described in only a few nonvertebrate cases. This study reports the only vertebrate system, with clearly defined interacting loci, that supports the BDM model. In addition, this study also poses that tumorigenesis serves as a novel mechanism that accounts for postzygotic isolation.

Mixing genomes of different species by hybridization can disrupt species-specific genetic interactions that were adapted and fixed within each species population. Such disruption can predispose the hybrids to abnormalities and disease that decrease the overall fitness of the hybrids and is therefore named as hybrid incompatibility. Interspecies hybridization between southern platyfish and green swordtails leads to lethal melanocyte tumorigenesis. This occurs in hybrids with tumor incidence following progeny ratio that is consistent with two-locus interaction, suggesting melanoma development is a result of negative epistasis. Such observations make Xiphophorus one of the only two vertebrate hybrid incompatibility examples in which interacting genes have been identified. One of the two interacting loci has been characterized as a mutant epidermal growth factor receptor. However, the other locus has not been identified despite over five decades of active research. Here we report the localization of the melanoma regulatory locus to a single gene, rab3d, which shows all expected features of the long-sought oncogene interacting locus. Our findings provide insights into the role of egfr regulation in regard to cancer etiology. Finally, they provide a molecular explainable example of hybrid incompatibility.

Molecular genetic analysis of the melanoma regulatory locus in Xiphophorus interspecies hybrids

Development of spontaneous melanoma in Xiphophorus interspecies backcross hybrid progeny, (X. hellerii × [X. maculatus Jp 163 A × X. hellerii]) is due to Mendelian segregation of a oncogene (xmrk) and a molecularly uncharacterized locus, called R(Diff), on LG5. R(Diff) is thought to suppresses the activity of xmrk in healthy X. maculatus Jp 163 A parental species that rarely develop melanoma. To better understand the molecular genetics of R(Diff), we utilized RNA-Seq to study allele-specific gene expression of spontaneous melanoma tumors and corresponding normal skin samples derived from 15 first generation backcross (BC₁ ) hybrids and 13 fifth generation (BC₅ ) hybrids. Allele-specific expression was determined for all genes and assigned to parental allele inheritance for each backcross hybrid individual. Results showed that genes residing in a 5.81 Mbp region on LG5 were exclusively expressed from the X. hellerii alleles in tumor-bearing BC₁ hybrids. This observation indicates this region is consistently homozygous for X. hellerii alleles in tumor bearing animals, and therefore defines this region to be the R(Diff) locus. The R(Diff) locus harbors 164 gene models and includes the previously characterized R(Diff) candidate, cdkn2x. Twenty-one genes in the R(Diff) region show differential expression in the tumor samples compared to normal skin tissue. These results further characterize the R(Diff) locus and suggest tumor suppression may require a multigenic region rather than a single gene variant. Differences in gene expression between tumor and normal skin tissue in this region may indicate interactions among several genes are required for backcross hybrid melanoma development.

Xiphophorus and Medaka Cancer Models

Besides recently developed zebrafish cancer models, other fish species have been employed for many years as cancer models in laboratory studies. Two models, namely in Xiphophorus and medaka have proven useful in providing important clues to cancer etiology. Medaka is a complementary model to zebrafish in many areas of research since it offers similar resources and experimental tools. Xiphophorus provides the advantages of a natural ("evolutionary mutant") model with established genetics. Xiphophorus hybrids can develop spontaneous and radiation or carcinogen induced cancers. This chapter describes the tumor models in both species, which mainly focus on melanoma, and summarizes the main findings and future research directions.

Expression regulation triggers oncogenicity of xmrk alleles in the Xiphophorus melanoma system

The Xiphophorus melanoma model has gained attention in biomedical research as a genetic model for tumor formation. Melanoma development in interspecific hybrids of Xiphophorus is connected to pigment cell specific overexpression of the mutationally activated receptor tyrosine kinase Xmrk. In purebred fish the oncogenic function of xmrk is suppressed by a so far unknown regulator locus R. To test the hypothesis that R is involved in transcriptional regulation of xmrk and consequently acts upstream of the xmrk signal, we performed a quantitative analysis of xmrk transcript levels in normal and melanoma tissues of different Xiphophorus genotypes carrying either a highly tumorigenic or a non-tumorigenic xmrk allele. Our results demonstrate that expression of the tumorigenic xmrk allele is highly increased in malignant melanomas compared to benign lesions, macromelanophore spots, and healthy skin. Transcription of the non-tumorigenic xmrk allele in pigment cells, in contrast, is not influenced by the presence or absence of R. These findings strongly indicate that differential transcriptional regulation of the xmrk promoter determines the tumorigenic potential of xmrk alleles in the Xiphophorus melanoma system, thereby supporting the hypothesis that R suppresses the oncogenic function of xmrk on the level of transcriptional control.

The genetic map of Xiphophorus fishes represented by 24 multipoint linkage groups

Hybrids between distinct Xiphophorus species have been utilized for over 70 years to study melanoma and other neoplasms that can develop spontaneously in hybrid offspring. Genetic linkage mapping has proven to be important in delineating genomic areas that harbor oncogenes and tumor suppressors. Within this report, two parallel backcrosses have been utilized to generate a genetic linkage map for Xiphophorus fishes. Isozyme/allozyme, RFLP and PCR-based mapping techniques, including AP-PCR/RAPDs and microsatellite loci were utilized. The derived linkage map provides a total of 403 mapped polymorphisms distributed among 24 linkage groups, representative of 24 acro- and telocentric chromosome pairs. Genomic coverage is approximately one marker per 5.8 cM. Detailed genotypic analysis of the utilized hybrids revealed two areas of the genome that show significant segregation distortion. Loci within the linkage group harboring the sex determining locus (LG 24) and an autosomal linkage group (LG 21) show highly significant deviations from Mendelian expectations. This phenomenon is not present in a hybrid cross that utilizes a different backcross hybrid progenitor species. The derived map with sequence-tagged markers provides a framework for physical map generation, large-scale genomic sequencing and will further enable cross-genome comparisons of vertebrate genomes.

Structural organization, mapping, characterization and evolutionary relationships of CDKN2 gene family members in Xiphophorus fishes

Xiphophorus fishes and their hybrids are used as models for the study of melanoma and other diseases. The cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor gene family in humans is comprised of four members, including CDKN2A (P16), and dysregulation of this gene is implicated in numerous neoplasms including melanomas. We have investigated the status of the gene family in the southern platyfish X. maculatus. Xiphophorus harbors at least two such loci, which we now term CDKN2A/B and CDKN2D. Both loci map to Xiphophorus linkage group 5, a genomic area that has long been known to harbor the DIFF tumor suppressor locus. Within this report, we report on the complete cloning, genomic exon/intron boundary delineation, linkage mapping and expressional characteristics of Xiphophorus CDKN2D. We also compare and contrast this expression to that of the previously isolated CDKN2AB locus in normal and neoplastic tissues derived from non-hybrid and hybrid fishes. The hypothetical evolutionary relationships of gene family members and their involvement in melanoma is evaluated. In comparison to CDKN2A/B, the RNA expression of Xiphophorus CDKN2D differs in normal tissues and is not associated with melanotic/pathologic tissues, confirming functional divergence between obvious homologues.

Xiphophorus interspecies hybrids as genetic models of induced neoplasia

Fishes of the genus Xiphophorus (platyfishes and swordtails) are small, internally fertilizing, livebearing, and derived from freshwater habitats in Mexico, Guatemala, Belize, and Honduras. Scientists have used these fishes in cancer research studies for more than 70 yr. The genus is presently composed of 22 species that are quite divergent in their external morphology. Most cancer studies using Xiphophorus use hybrids, which can be easily produced by artificial insemination. Phenotypic traits, such as macromelanophore pigment patterns, are often drastically altered as a result of lack of gene regulation within hybrid fishes. These fish can develop large exophytic melanomas as a result of upregulated expression of these pigment patterns. Because backcross hybrid fish are susceptible to the development of melanoma and other neoplasms, they can be subjected to potentially deleterious chemical and physical agents. It is thus possible to use gene mapping and cloning methodologies to identify and characterize oncogenes and tumor suppressors implicated in spontaneous or induced neoplasia. This article reviews the history of cancer research using Xiphophorus and recent developments regarding DNA repair capabilities, mapping, and cloning of candidate genes involved in neoplastic phenotypes. The particular genetic complexity of melanoma in these fishes is analyzed and reviewed.

MNU induction of neoplasia in a platyfish model

Interspecific hybrid crosses between members of the fish genus Xiphophorus have been used for over 70 years to study the genetic aspects of melanoma formation. In the well-established "Gordon-Kosswig" cross, the platyfish X. maculatus is outcrossed to the swordtail X. helleri, and the resulting backcross segregants spontaneously develop melanoma. We recently produced a distinct cross between X. maculatus and another platyfish species, X. couchianus. X. maculatus strain Jp 163 A is homozygous for several X-linked pigment pattern genes, including the Spotted dorsal (Sd), Dorsal red (Dr), and Anal fin spot (Af). Af is a sex-limited trait, coding exclusively for melanophores distributed on the modified anal fin or "gonopodium" in the adult male fish. Within F1 and BC1 hybrids (to X. couchianus), the Sd pigment pattern is phenotypically suppressed, whereas Dr and Af are enhanced. We exposed BC1 hybrids to the direct-acting carcinogen N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU). Treatment led to the development of schwannomas, fibrosarcomas, and retinoblastomas. In addition, numerous MNU-treated males that inherited Af developed a pronounced melanotic phenotype, with melanin-containing cells oftentimes totally covering the gonopodium and extending further to grow within the ventral regions of the fish. Genetic linkage analysis of the BC1 hybrids revealed a significant (p < 0.01) association between CDKN2X genotype and the phenotypic degree of melanization. Such an association is consistent with a locus within linkage group V playing a role in the development of melanosis and delineates three genetic preconditions and a carcinogenic scheme resulting in melanosis of the ventral regions of hybrid fish. The overall study further alludes to the potential of using Xiphophorus fish to study carcinogenic mechanisms for tumors other than melanoma (schwannoma, fibrosarcoma, and retinoblastoma) and should enable extensive pathologic and molecular genetic studies of derived neoplastic abnormalities.

Overexpression of a fish CDKN2 gene in a hereditary melanoma model

The fish genus Xiphophorus provides a vertebrate model useful in etiological studies of cancer. Hybrid fish can spontaneously develop melanomas deriving from the inheritance of melanistic pigment patterns and the simultaneous absence of proper genetic regulation. A cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor gene, termed CDKN2X, was mapped to a genomic region that is implicated in fish melanoma tumor suppression. The related human tumor suppressor locus CDKN2A (P16, INK4A, MTS1) is deleted, mutated or transcriptionally repressed through methylation of cytosine bases within the 5' CpG island in a variety of neoplasms, including melanoma. The fish CDKN2X locus harbors a CpG island within its promoter and first exon, analogous in location to CpG islands in human CDKN2A and CDKN2B loci. The methylation state of individual CpG dinucleotides was investigated in genomic DNA derived from control tissues and melanomas within the CDKN2X 5' CpG island. The studied genomic area was found to be virtually unmethylated in all tested tissues including melanomas. In addition, RNA expression studies of the fish CDKN2X locus revealed that it is significantly overexpressed in melanoma, in contrast to what has been reported for the human CDKN2A locus in melanoma. Such overexpression may be a consequence of the pronounced upregulation of the Xmrk-2 receptor tyrosine kinase oncogene reported in several Xiphophorus melanoma models.

A CDKN2-like polymorphism in Xiphophorus LG V is associated with UV-B-induced melanoma formation in platyfish-swordtail hybrids

The genetic basis of spontaneous melanoma formation in spotted dorsal (Sd) Xiphophorus platyfish-swordtail hybrids has been studied for decades, and is adequately explained by a two-gene inheritance model involving a sex-linked oncogene, Xmrk, and an autosomal tumor suppressor, DIFF. The Xmrk oncogene encodes a receptor tyrosine kinase related to EGFR; the nature of the DIFF tumor suppressor gene is unknown. We analyzed the gentic basis of UV-B-induced melanoma formation in closely related, spotted side platyfish-swordtail hybrids, which carry a different sex-linked pigment pattern locus, Sp. We UV-irradiated spotted side Xiphophorus platyfish-swordtail backcross hybrids to induce melanomas at frequencies 6-fold higher than occur spontaneously in unirradiated control animals. To identify genetic determinants of melanoma susceptibility in this UV-inducible Xiphophorus model, we genotyped individual animals from control and UV-irradiated experimental regimes using allozyme and DNA restriction fragment length polymorphisms and tested for joint segregation of genetic markers with pigmentation phenotype and UV-induced melanoma formation. Joint segregation results show linkage of a CDKN2-like DNA polymorphism with UV-B-induced melanoma formation in these hybrids. The CDKN2-like polymorphism maps to Xiphophorus linkage group V and exhibits recombination fractions with ES1 and MDH2 allozyme markers consistent with previous localization of the DIFF tumor suppressor locus. Our results indicate that the CDKN2-like sequence we have cloned and mapped is a candidate for the DIFF tumor suppressor gene.

Nonmammalian models for sunlight carcinogenesis: genetic analysis of melanoma formation in Xiphophorus hybrid fish

Genetic hybrids of Xiphophorus fishes have been used for decades to study heritable melanoma formation. In these models, overexpression of pigmentation patterns from melanin-producing pigment cells can lead to genetically regulated melanoma formation in backcross hybrids. In the best studied of these models, the Gordon-Kosswig hybrid melanoma, tumors form spontaneously in all individuals of a subset of backcross hybrids between the platyfish Xiphophorus maculatus Jp 163 A and the swordtail species Xiphophorus helleri. Backcross hybrids susceptible to melanoma formation inherit a sex-linked oncogene, Xmrk, associated with the spotted dorsal (Sd) pigment pattern and have lost both copies of an autosomal gene, DIFF, from the X. maculatus parent. Spontaneous melanoma formation conforms to simple, two-gene Mendelian inheritance in which DIFF behaves as a recessive tumor suppressor gene. Recently, Xiphophorus hybrids in which melanomas can be induced by UV and near-UV visible light exposure have been described. We report here results of genetic linkage analysis of one of these Xiphophorus light-inducible hybrid melanoma models, in backcross hybrids between the two platyfish species X. maculatus Jp 163 B and Xiphophorus couchianus. Our linkage results provide the first estimate of recombination between the tumor suppressor locus, DIFF, and glycerate-2-dehydrogenase (GLYDH) in Xiphophorus linkage group V. Also, they demonstrate that DIFF regulates hyperplasia of spotted side (Sp) pigment cells in this hybrid model, analogous to its regulation of hyperplasia of Sd pigment cells in the "classical" Gordon-Kosswig hybrid. Joint segregation analyses of melanoma-bearing fish indicate that segregation of DIFF is genetically linked to melanoma induction by 405 nm light in this model but that induction of melanomas by UV wavelengths apparently does not depend on segregation of the DIFF locus.

Genetic mapping in Xiphophorus hybrid fish: assignment of 43 AP-PCR/RAPD and isozyme markers to multipoint linkage groups

The combined use of the arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction [AP-PCR, also known as random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD)] and isozyme mapping resulted in the production of 87 potential marker loci, enabling an overall expansion within the genetic map of the fish genus Xiphophorus. Use of DNA sequencing-style acrylamide gels and carefully controlled conditions of amplification and silver staining allowed exceptional resolution and reproducibility of AP-PCR/RAPD generated markers. Linkage analysis of AP-PCR/RAPD and isozyme markers resulted in the addition of 16 new markers to Xiphophorus linkage groups (LGs) I, II, III, V, IX, X, XII, and XIV. Addition of 5 AP-PCR/RAPD markers to linkage group U6 containing the Tailspot pigment pattern locus (P) and designation of eight new unassigned linkage groups with 22 markers was also accomplished. Genetic linkage data allowed inference of the existence of a novel pigment pattern modifier locus. Expansion of the Xiphophorus gene map by linkage analysis of AP-PCR/RAPD markers in conjunction with isozyme polymorphisms should lead to the rapid saturation of genetic linkage groups such as LG V, which will probably be instrumental to cloning the Diff tumor suppressor gene locus.

Platyfish and swordtails: a genetic system for the analysis of molecular mechanisms in tumor formation

Inspired by recent reports, many geneticists would agree that it is worth looking into aquaria or even replacing the Drosophila bottles in their laboratories with fish tanks. Indeed, encouraging results from large-scale mutagenesis screens in zebrafish have promoted this organism to a prominent position in the research of vertebrate developmental biology. Some other small aquarium fish species still inhabit side streams or backwaters of science, like the zebrafish did before, serving smaller communities of researchers as tools in fields such as developmental biology and neurobiology. One such type of fish is Xiphophorus, which offers a genetic system for the analysis of molecular mechanisms in tumorigenesis.