Radiation induced chromosome aberrations and clonogenic survival in human lymphoblastoid cell lines with different p53 status

A HYPOTHESIS OF RADIORESISTANCE AND CELL-SURVIVAL CURVE SHAPE BASED ON CELL-CYCLE PROGRESSION AND DAMAGE TOLERANCE

Exponential survival curves of early-passage human fibroblasts challenge classic biophysical models of cell inactivation. Thus, X-ray doses of 2-4 Gy inactivate normal, human skin fibroblasts in spite of negligible residual double-strand breaks. By contrast, radioresistant p53-mutant U251 glioblastoma cells proliferate in spite of residual damage. Similarly, p53 wildtype TK6 lymphoblastoid cells show exponential survival curves while the related p53-mutant WTK1 cell line continued to proliferate and showed a shouldered survival curve. Here, we propose a model in which the radioresistant shoulder region is due to tolerance to certain types or amounts of residual damage that would otherwise inactivate normal cells. Thus, the steeper initial slope and absence of a shoulder in the survival curve of normal cells may not imply a higher number of residual lesions but rather non-tolerance to these lesions.

The influence of a magnetic field on photon beam radiotherapy in a normal human TK6 lymphoblastoid cell line

Background

The implementation of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) guided radiotherapy (RT) continues to increase. Very limited in-vitro data on the interaction of ionizing radiation and magnetic fields (MF) have been published. In these experiments we focused on the radiation response in a MF of the TK6 human lymphoblastoid cells which are known to be highly radiosensitive due to efficient radiation-induced apoptosis.

Methods

Clonogenicity was determined 12–14 days after irradiation with 1–4 Gy 6 MV photons with or without a 1.0 Tesla MF. Furthermore, alterations in cell cycle distribution and rates of radiation induced apoptosis (FACS analysis of cells with sub-G1 DNA content) were analyzed.

Results

Clonogenic survival showed an exponential dose-dependence, and the radiation sensitivity parameter (α = 1.57/Gy) was in accordance with earlier reports. Upon comparing the clonogenic survival between the two groups, identical results within error bars were obtained. The survival fractions at 2 Gy were 9% (without MF) and 8.5% (with MF), respectively.

Conclusion

A 1.0 Tesla MF does not affect the clonogenicity of TK6 cells irradiated with 1–4 Gy 6MV photons. This supports the use of MRI guided RT, however ongoing research on the interaction of MF and radiotherapy is warranted.

Hypothermia modulates the DNA damage response to ionizing radiation in human peripheral blood lymphocytes

PURPOSE

Low temperature at exposure has been shown to act in a radioprotective manner at the level of cytogenetic damage. It was suggested to be due to an effective transformation of DNA damage to chromosomal damage at low temperature. The purpose of the study was to analyze the kinetics of aberration formation during the first hours after exposing human peripheral blood lymphocytes to ionizing radiation at 0.8 °C and 37 °C.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

To this end, we applied the technique of premature chromosome condensation. In addition, DNA damage response was analyzed by measuring the levels of phosphorylated DNA damage responsive proteins ATM, DNA-PK and p53 and mRNA levels of the radiation-responsive genes BBC3, FDXR, GADD45A, XPC, MDM2 and CDKN1A.

RESULTS

A consistently lower frequency of chromosomal breaks was observed in cells exposed at 0.8 °C as compared to 37 °C already after 30 minutes postexposure. This effect was accompanied by elevated levels of phosphorylated ATM and DNA-PK proteins and a reduced immediate level of phosphorylated p53 and of the responsive genes.

CONCLUSIONS

Low temperature at exposure appears to promote DNA repair leading to reduced transformation of DNA damage to chromosomal aberrations.

Lymphoblastoid cell lines differing in p53 status show clear differences in basal gene expression with minor changes after irradiation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The genetic profile as determined by microarray is considered to be an ideal marker of the individual radiosensitivity. However, it is still an open question, whether this profile has to be determined prior to or only after irradiation, since the expression of some genes is affected by irradiation. These changes are induced mainly due to a p53-dependent transactivation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this study gene expression profiles were measured for 3 lymphoblastoid cell lines differing in p53 status (p53 wt: TK6; p53null: TK6E6, p53mut: WTK1) measured either prior to or 3h after exposure to 2Gy. The gene expression profile was determined using the Affymetrix Human HG U133A GeneChip and for selective genes, variation in gene expression was validated by qRT-PCR. In addition, different assays were used to characterize the radioresponse of these three strains.

RESULTS

The three strains were found to be different in all aspects of radiosensitivity studied. Cells with p53wt showed more apoptosis, slightly stronger arrest in G1, but less lethal aberrations and a lower viability when compared to cells with mutated p53, whereas cells absent in p53 are characterized by an intermediate response. The gene expression profile measured prior to irradiation already revealed huge differences. Significance analysis of microarrays (SAM) identified 141 genes that changed expression twofold or more with a false discovery rate (FDR) of 5.4%. When compared to p53null cell line with p53wt showed a twofold difference in up- or down-regulation in 28 genes. A much higher variation was even found when p53mut cells were compared with p53null cells with a twofold difference in even 123 genes. The respective genes were found to be involved mainly in apoptosis, cell cycle regulation, metabolisms and signalling but with only one gene relevant for DNA repair. Radiation was found to affect this profile solely for cells with p53wt with a twofold significant up-regulation in only five genes. For selective genes (BCL2, CASP1, CCND2, DDB2, XPC, RAD51C, SESN1, FUCA1, CDKN1A, MDM2, XPC) array data were confirmed by qRT-PCR.

CONCLUSION

The result, that the gene expression profile of lymphoblastoid cells differing in p53 status already displayed clear differences when measured prior to irradiation with only few changes after irradiation, which are solely seen for p53wt cells, suggests, that the differences in radiosensitivity observed for these cells are primarily determined by the variation in expression profile present already prior to irradiation.

Apoptosis induced by MNNG in human TK6 lymphoblastoid cells is p53 and Fas/CD95/Apo-1 related

Agents inducing O(6)-methylguanine (O(6)MeG) in DNA, such as N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG), are not only highly mutagenic and carcinogenic but also cytotoxic because of the induction of apoptosis. In CHO fibroblasts, apoptosis triggered by O(6)MeG requires cell proliferation and MutSalpha-dependent mismatch repair and is related to the induction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Furthermore, it is mediated by Bcl-2 degradation and does not require p53 for which the cells were mutated [Cancer Res. 60 (2000) 5815]. Here we studied cytotoxicity and apoptosis induced by MNNG in a pair of human lymphoblastoid cells expressing wild-type p53 (TK6) and mutant p53 (WTK1) and show that TK6 cells are more sensitive than WTK1 cells to cell killing (determined by a metabolic assay) and apoptosis. Apoptosis was a late response observed <24h after treatment and was related to accumulation of p53 and upregulation of Fas/CD95/Apo-1 receptor as well as Bax. The data indicate that MNNG induces apoptosis in lymphoblastoid cells by activating the p53-dependent Fas receptor-driven pathway. This is in contrast to CHO fibroblasts in which, in response to O(6)MeG, the mitochondrial damage pathway becomes activated.

Characteristics of genomic instability in clones of TK6 human lymphoblasts surviving exposure to 56Fe ions

Genomic instability in the human lymphoblast cell line TK6 was studied in clones surviving 36 generations after exposure to accelerated 56Fe ions. Clones were assayed for 20 characteristics, including chromosome aberrations, plating efficiency, apoptosis, cell cycle distribution, response to a second irradiation, and mutant frequency at two loci. The primary effect of the 56Fe-ion exposure on the surviving clones was a significant increase in the frequency of unstable chromosome aberrations compared to the very low spontaneous frequency, along with an increase in the phenotypic complexity of the unstable clones. The radiation-induced increase in the frequency of unstable chromosome aberrations was much greater than that observed previously in clones of the related cell line, WTK1, which in comparison to the TK6 cell line expresses an increased radiation resistance, a mutant TP53 protein, and an increased frequency of spontaneous unstable chromosome aberrations. The characteristics of the unstable clones of the two cell lines also differed. Most of the TK6 clones surviving exposure to 56Fe ions showed unstable cytogenetic abnormalities, while the phenotype of the WTK1 clones was more diverse. The results underscore the importance of genotype in the characteristics of instability after radiation exposure.

Suppression of apoptosis and clonogenic survival in irradiated human lymphoblasts with different TP53 status

The influence of radiation-induced apoptosis on radiosensitivity was studied in a set of closely related human lymphoblastoid cell lines differing in TP53 status. The clonogenic survival of irradiated TK6 cells (expressing wild-type TP53), WTK1 cells (overexpressing mutant TP53), and TK6E6 cells (negative for TP53 owing to transfection with HPV16 E6) was assessed in relation to the induction of apoptosis and its suppression by caspase inhibition or treatment with PMA as well as after treatment with caffeine. Measurements using the alkaline comet assay and pulsed-field electrophoresis of the induction and repair of DNA strand breaks showed similar kinetics of the processing of early DNA damage in these cell lines. The cytochalasin B micronucleus assay revealed identical levels of residual damage in the first postirradiation mitosis of these cells. Abrogation of TP53-dependent apoptosis in TK6E6 cells resulted in a distinct increase in radioresistance. Further suppression of apoptosis as observed in WTK1 cells overexpressing mutant TP53 apparently was not responsible for the high radioresistance of WTK1 cells, since other means of highly efficient suppression of apoptosis (caspase inhibition or PMA treatment) increased the clonogenic survival of irradiated TK6 cells only to levels similar to those of TK6E6 cells with abrogated TP53-dependent apoptosis. Considering the similar levels of residual chromosomal damage in TK6E6 cells and WTK1 cells, a hitherto unknown mechanism of tolerance needs to be inferred for these TP53 mutant cells. This residual damage tolerance, however, appears to require an intact G2/M-phase checkpoint function since the relative radioresistance of the WTK1 cells was completely lost upon caffeine treatment, which also resulted in a failure of the TK6 and TK6E6 cells to execute apoptosis. In this situation, the cellular response seems to be dominated entirely by TP53-independent mitotic failure.

Characteristics of chromosome instability in the human lymphoblast cell line WTK1

The characteristics of spontaneous and radiation-induced chromosome instability were determined in each of 50 individual clones isolated from control populations of human lymphoblasts (WTK1), as well as from populations of these cells previously exposed to two different types of ionizing radiation, Fe-56 and Cs-137. The types of chromosome instability did not appear to change in clones surviving radiation exposure. Aneuploidy, polyploidy, chromosome dicentrics and translocations, and chromatid breaks and gaps were found in both control and irradiated clones. The primary effect of radiation exposure was to increase the number of cells within any one clone that had chromosome alterations. Chromosome instability was associated with telomere shortening and elevated levels of apoptosis. The results suggest that the proximal cause of chromosome instability is telomere shortening.

Genotoxic effects of high-energy iron particles in human lymphoblasts differing in radiation sensitivity

The effects of (56)Fe particles and (137)Cs gamma radiation were compared in TK6 and WTK1 human lymphoblasts, two related cell lines which differ in TP53 status and in the ability to rejoin DNA double-strand breaks. Both cell lines were more sensitive to the cytotoxic and clastogenic effects of (56)Fe particles than to those of gamma rays. However, the mutagenicity of (56)Fe particles and gamma rays at the TK locus was the same per unit dose and was higher for gamma rays than for (56)Fe particles at isotoxic doses. The respective RBEs for TK6 and WTK1 cells were 1.5 and 1.9 for cytotoxicity and 2.5 and 1.9 for clastogenicity, but only 1 for mutagenicity. The results indicate that complex lesions induced by (56)Fe particles are repaired less efficiently than gamma-ray-induced lesions, leading to fewer colony-forming cells, a slightly higher proportion of aberrant cells at the first division, and a lower frequency of viable mutants at isotoxic doses. WTK1 cells (mutant TP53) were more resistant to the cytotoxic effects of both gamma rays and (56)Fe particles, but showed greater cytogenetic and mutagenic damage than TK6 cells (TP53(+)). A deficiency in the number of damaged TK6 cells (a) reaching the first mitosis after exposure and (b) forming viable mutants can explain these results.