[Is the number of tonsillectomies and tonsillotomies a relevant issue? German version]

Physicians' Perspectives on the Implementation of the Second Opinion Directive in Germany-An Exploratory Sequential Mixed-Methods Study

A new Second Opinion Directive (SOD) was introduced in Germany in December 2018 for hysterectomy, tonsillotomy, and tonsillectomy to support shared decision making and to avoid unnecessary surgeries. Owing to its recent implementation, evidence and insights regarding outcomes and challenges encountered with the SOD are lacking, notably from the physicians' perspective. To assess this, we undertook an exploratory sequential mixed-methods design with an initial qualitative phase followed by a quantitative evaluation. A qualitative analysis of 22 interviews with specialists in gynecology and otorhinolaryngology was followed by a statistical analysis of a survey of 136 physicians in those disciplines. The specialists expressed a generally positive opinion of the new SOD, emphasizing the aspects of patient orientation, support in decision making, and patient safety. However, they also highlighted the following structural problems regarding the SOD implementation: In addition to an increased organisational effort, the specialists criticised the SOD with regard to its implementation in rural regions with a low availability of specialists for referral. Barriers that impede the implementation of the current directive, such as the adaptation of the qualifying requirements for authorized second opinion physicians, as well as the inclusion of relevant indications, need focused consideration to obtain better alignment with everyday practice.

Impact of the COVID-pandemic on the incidence of tonsil surgery and sore throat in Germany

Purpose

To longitudinally evaluate the impact of the COVID-19-pandemic on the incidence of inpatient tonsil surgery and outpatient primary care of sore throat in Germany.

Methods

A retrospective interrupted time-series analysis was conducted. The national database of the Hospital Remuneration System was used to retrieve the number of operations performed between January 2019 and September 2021 including elective and non-elective cases with the exception of malign diseases. Three episodes were compared on a weekly basis: before, during, and after the first national lockdown (March 16–May 3, 2020). We also analysed the number of outpatient doctor contacts of sore throat patients in 2019 and 2020.

Results

Overall, 144,069 surgical cases were included in the analysis. The first lockdown resulted in an abrupt and significant decrease of all types of tonsil surgery (p < 0.01). The incidence of tonsillectomy decreased from 556 (before) to 111 (during) and 326 (after) cases per week (relative risk 0.24; 95% CI 0.19–0.30, and 0.82; 95% CI 0.73–0.92). After the lockdown, the incidence persisted on a lower level compared to 2019. The number of doctor contacts decreased from 2,967,322 in 2019 to 1,976,617 in 2020 (− 33.4%).

Conclusions

The first lockdown was associated with a significant decrease of all types of tonsil surgery. A return to pre-pandemic surgical activity was not identified. The findings were accompanied by a significant decrease of outpatient doctor contacts of sore throat patients in primary care, particularly in the subgroup of children and adolescents. The impact of the second lockdown, starting in December 2020, was by far not comparable.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00405-022-07308-8.

[Second opinion process for tonsillectomy and tonsillotomy: analysis of the quantitative and qualitative justifying conditions]

BACKGROUND

In 2017, the Federal Joint Committee determined tonsillectomy and hysterectomy in non-oncologic diseases as well as tonsillotomy for second opinion procedure. We discuss the suitability of tonsillectomy and tonsillotomy for the second opinion procedure on its quantitative and qualitative characteristics.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data from the Federal Statistical Office concerning numbers of cases were evaluated. Numbers and regional distribution of ENT-specialists providing second opinion were analyzed by websites of Associations of SHI Physicians.

RESULTS

Between 2005 and 2018a significant decrease in tonsillectomy cases from 119 808 to 42 548 is observable that is by far not compensated by increasing tonsillotomy numbers from 4659 (2007) to 18 369. At the same time, surgical procedure rates at regional levels remain volatile. 218 ENT-specialists in 142 towns provide second opinion. On basic of case numbers in 2018a relationship of 1(ENT-specialist): 280 (tonsillectomy/tonsillotomy patients) results (range from 1:90 to 1:800).

CONCLUSIONS

On the background of decreasing surgical rates tonsil surgery does not comply with the requirements of second opinion procedure. Reachability of second opinion providers is difficult in many regions, such compromising a compensation of different levels of surgery. As a result of our investigation we recommend scientific supervision of currently second opinion procedures and a survey of actual demand from the patient's viewpoint.

[Frequency of secondary tonsillectomy in Germany]

BACKGROUND

Tonsillar remnants are occasionally the subject of clinical negligence claims in tonsillectomy patients, but obligatory in every tonsillotomy procedure. In both cases, clinically relevant symptoms can require a secondary tonsillectomy (STE).

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this retrospective longitudinal study was to identify the prevalence of STE in Germany between 2005 and 2018, using a report commissioned by the Federal Office for Statistics.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

STE was identified using the operation and procedure key (Operationen- und Prozedurenschlüssel, OPS) code 5‑281.4, and the prevalence stratified by year, age, and gender. Linear regression analysis was performed. In addition, the prevalence of tonsillectomy and tonsillotomy was determined by the OPS codes 5‑281.5, 5‑281.0, and 5.282.0.

RESULTS

Between 2005 and 2018, 11,018 patients underwent STE in Germany. The total number of STE per year decreased significantly from 1080 in 2005 to 483 in 2018 (p < 0.001). The number of inpatient tonsillotomy cases increased between 2007 and 2018 from 4658 to 18,369.

CONCLUSION

The annual number of STE in Germany decreased continually during the observation period. The population-based data used in the study were insufficient to determine whether STE had been performed after tonsillectomy or tonsillotomy. Further patient-level research is thus required.