Activation of insulin receptors and IGF-1 receptors in COLO-205 colon cancer xenografts by insulin and insulin analogue X10 does not enhance growth under normo- or hypoglycaemic conditions

Evaluation of Cell Proliferation in Rat Mammary Glands Is Not Predictive of the Carcinogenic Potential of Insulin In Vivo

For nonclinical safety-assessment of insulin analogues in vivo, mitogenic effects are compared to that of human insulin. Besides histopathologic evaluation, this usually includes assessment of cell proliferation (CP) in mammary glands. Insulin analogue X10 is recommended as positive control, due to its known carcinogenic effect in rat mammary glands. Here, we discuss the mitogenic effect of insulin in vivo and use of X10 as positive control. We present results from 4 nonclinical rat studies evaluating effects of repeated dosing with insulin detemir (≤26 weeks) or degludec (52 weeks) in mammary glands. Studies included human insulin-dosed groups as comparators, CP, and histopathologic evaluation. One study included an X10-dosed group (26 weeks), another ≤3 weeks of dosing with X10 or human insulin evaluating effects of these comparators. Neither human insulin, insulin detemir, degludec, nor X10 induced mammary tumors or increased CP in the studies. The CP marker proliferating cell nuclear antigen varied within/between studies and was not correlated with the remaining markers or CP fluctuations during estrous cycle, whereas the other CP markers, Ki-67 and 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU), correlated with estrous cycle changes and each other. In conclusion, we propose that the mitogenic effect of insulin in rat mammary glands is weak in vivo. Cell proliferation evaluation in nonclinical safety assessment studies is not predictive of the carcinogenic potential of insulin, thus, the value of including this end point is debatable. Moreover, X10 is not recommended as positive control, due to lack of proliferative effects. Typical CP markers vary greatly in quality, BrdU seemingly most reliable.

Increased insulin receptor binding and increased IGF-1 receptor binding are linked with increased growth of L6hIR cell xenografts in vivo

Insulin analogue X10 has a higher mitogenic potency than native human insulin in vitro and supra-pharmacological doses of insulin X10 increased the incidence of mammary tumours in rats. Compared to native human insulin, insulin X10 has increased binding affinity to the insulin receptor and the IGF-1 receptor, but it is not known whether either or both characteristics are important for stimulation of cell proliferation in vivo. The aim of this study was to explore how increased binding affinity to the insulin receptor or the IGF-1 receptor contributes to stimulation of cell proliferation in vivo. A mouse xenograft model was established with rat L6 myoblast cells transfected with the human insulin receptor (L6hIR cells) and effects of supra-pharmacological doses of native human insulin, insulin X10 or novel insulin analogues with increased binding affinity to either the insulin receptor or the IGF-1 receptor were examined. Treatment with insulin X10 and insulin analogues with increased binding affinity to either the insulin receptor or the IGF-1 receptor increased growth of L6hIR cell xenografts significantly compared to native human insulin. Thus, increased binding affinity to the insulin receptor and the IGF-1 receptor are each independently linked to increased growth of L6hIR cell xenografts in vivo.

Cross-species reactive monoclonal antibodies against the extracellular domains of the insulin receptor and IGF1 receptor

Translation across species of immunoassay results is often challenging due to the lack of cross-species reactivity of antibodies. In order to investigate the biology of insulin and IGF1 receptors, we generated new versatile monoclonal assay antibodies using the extracellular domain of the insulin/IGF1 hybrid receptor as the bait protein in the Adimab yeast antibody discovery platform and as the antigen in a rabbit monoclonal antibody platform. The resulting antibody clones were screened for receptor specificity as well as cross-species reactivity to both tissue and cell line derived samples. Using these strategies, we were able to identify highly specific insulin receptor monoclonal antibodies that lack cross-reactivity to the IGF1 receptor using the Adimab platform and a highly specific IGF1 receptor monoclonal antibody that lacks cross-reactivity to the insulin receptor using the rabbit antibody platform. Unlike earlier monoclonal antibodies reported in the literature, these antibodies show cross-species reactivity to the extracellular domains of mouse, rat, pig, and human receptors, indicating that they bind conserved epitopes. Furthermore, the antibodies work well in several different assay formats, including ELISA, flow cytometry, and immunoprecipitation, and therefore provide new tools to study insulin and IGF1 receptor biology with translation across several species and experimental model systems.