Analysis of denitrifier community in a bioaugmented sequencing batch reactor for the treatment of coking wastewater containing pyridine and quinoline

Aerobic biodegradation of quinoline under denitrifying conditions in membrane-aerated biofilm reactor

Aerobic denitrification is being investigated as a novel biological nitrogen removal process, yet the knowledge on aerobic denitrification is limited to pure culture isolations and its occurrence in bioreactors remains unclear. This study investigated the feasibility and capacity of applying aerobic denitrification in membrane aerated biofilm reactor (MABR) for biological treatment of quinoline-laden wastewater. Stable and efficient removals of quinoline (91.5 ± 5.2%) and nitrate (NO₃^-) (86.5 ± 9.3%) were obtained under different operational conditions. Enhanced formation and function of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) were observed at increasing quinoline loadings. MABR biofilm was highly enriched with aerobic quinoline-degrading bacteria, with a predominance of Rhodococcus (26.9 ± 3.7%) and secondary abundance of Pseudomonas (1.7 ± 1.2%) and Comamonas (0.94 ± 0.9%). Metagenomic analysis indicated that Rhodococcus contributed significantly to both aromatic degradation (24.5 ± 21.3%) and NO₃^- reduction (4.5 ± 3.9%), indicating its key role in aerobic denitrifying quinoline biodegradation. At increasing quinoline loadings, abundances of aerobic quinoline degradation gene oxoO and denitrifying genes of napA, nirS and nirK increased; there was a significant positive correlation of oxoO with nirS and nirK (p < 0.05). Aerobic quinoline degradation was likely initiated by hydroxylation, encoded by oxoO, followed by stepwise oxidations through 5,6-dihydroxy-1H-2-oxoquinoline or 8-hydroxycoumarin pathway. The results advance our understanding of quinoline degradation during biological nitrogen removal, and highlight the potential implementation of aerobic denitrification driven quinoline biodegradation in MABR for simultaneous removal of nitrogen and recalcitrant organic carbon from coking, coal gasification and pharmaceutical wastewaters.

Correlating bacterial and archaeal community with efficiency of a coking wastewater treatment plant employing anaerobic-anoxic-oxic process in coal industry

Coking wastewater (CWW) contains various complex pollutants, and biological treatment processes are frequently applied in the coking wastewater treatment plants (CWWTPs). The present work is to evaluate the contaminants removal of a full-scale CWWTP with an anaerobic-anoxic-oxic process (A/A/O), to reveal function of bacterial and archaeal community involved in different bioreactors, and to clarify the relationship between the performance and microbial community. Illumina Miseq sequencing of bacteria showed that β-proteobacteria dominated in three bioreactors with relative abundance of 60.2%~81.7%. 75.2% of sequences were assigned to Petrobacter in the bioreactor A1, while Thiobacillus dominated in A2 and O with relative abundance of 31.8% and 38.7%, respectively. Illumina Miseq sequencing of archaea revealed a high diversity of methanogens existed in A1 and A2 activated sludge. Moreover, Halostagnicola was the dominant archaea in A1 and A2 activated sludge with relative abundance of 41.8% and 66.5%, respectively. Function predicted analysis explored that function of bacteria was similar to that of archaea but the relative abundance differed from each other. A putative biodegradation model of CWW treatment in A/A/O process indicated that A1 and A2 activated sludge mainly reduced carbohydrate, protein, TN, phenol and cyanide, as well as methane production. Bacteria in the bioreactor O were responsible for aerobic biotransformation of residual carbohydrates, refractory organics and nitrification. The redundancy analysis (RDA) further revealed that removal of COD, TN, and NO₃^--N, phenol and cyanides were highly correlated with some anaerobic bacteria and archaea, whereas the transformation of NH₄⁺-N was positively correlated with some aerobic bacteria.

Cross-Feeding between Members of Thauera spp. and Rhodococcus spp. Drives Quinoline-Denitrifying Degradation in a Hypoxic Bioreactor

We experimentally verified that the second most abundant taxon, Rhodococcus, played a role in degrading quinoline to 2-hydroxyquinoline, while the most abundant taxon, Thauera, degraded 2-hydroxyquinoline. Metabolites from Thauera further served to provide metabolites for Rhodococcus. Hence, an ecological guild composed of two isolates was assembled, revealing the different roles that keystone organisms play in the microbial community. This report, to the best of our knowledge, is the first on cross-feeding between the initial quinoline degrader and a second bacterium. Specifically, the quinoline degrader (Rhodococcus) did not benefit metabolically from quinoline degradation to 2-hydroxyquinoline but instead benefited from the metabolites produced by the second bacterium (Thauera) when Thauera degraded the 2-hydroxyquinoline. These results could be a significant step forward in the elucidation of the microbial mechanism underlying quinoline-denitrifying degradation.

The complex bacterial community in a quinoline-degrading denitrifying bioreactor is predominated by several taxa, such as Thauera and Rhodococcus. However, it remains unclear how the interactions between the different bacteria mediate quinoline metabolism under denitrifying conditions. In this study, we designed a sequence-specific amplification strategy to isolate the most predominant bacteria and obtained four strains of Thauera aminoaromatica, a representative of a key member in the bioreactor. Tests on these isolates demonstrated that all were unable to degrade quinoline but efficiently degraded 2-hydroxyquinoline, the hypothesized primary intermediate of quinoline catabolism, under nitrate-reducing conditions. However, another isolate, Rhodococcus sp. YF3, corresponding to the second most abundant taxon in the same bioreactor, was found to degrade quinoline via 2-hydroxyquinoline. The end products and removal rate of quinoline by isolate YF3 largely varied according to the quantity of available oxygen. Specifically, quinoline could be converted only to 2-hydroxyquinoline without further transformation under insufficient oxygen conditions, e.g., less than 0.5% initial oxygen in the vials. However, resting YF3 cells aerobically precultured in medium with quinoline could anaerobically convert quinoline to 2-hydroxyquinoline. A two-strain consortium constructed with isolates from Thauera (R2) and Rhodococcus (YF3) demonstrated efficient denitrifying degradation of quinoline. Thus, we experimentally verified that the metabolic interaction based on 2-hydroxyquinoline cross-feeding between two predominant bacteria constitutes the main quinoline degradation mechanism. This work uncovers the mechanism of quinoline removal by two cooperative bacterial species existing in denitrifying bioreactors.

IMPORTANCE We experimentally verified that the second most abundant taxon, Rhodococcus, played a role in degrading quinoline to 2-hydroxyquinoline, while the most abundant taxon, Thauera, degraded 2-hydroxyquinoline. Metabolites from Thauera further served to provide metabolites for Rhodococcus. Hence, an ecological guild composed of two isolates was assembled, revealing the different roles that keystone organisms play in the microbial community. This report, to the best of our knowledge, is the first on cross-feeding between the initial quinoline degrader and a second bacterium. Specifically, the quinoline degrader (Rhodococcus) did not benefit metabolically from quinoline degradation to 2-hydroxyquinoline but instead benefited from the metabolites produced by the second bacterium (Thauera) when Thauera degraded the 2-hydroxyquinoline. These results could be a significant step forward in the elucidation of the microbial mechanism underlying quinoline-denitrifying degradation.

A pilot-scale three-dimensional electrochemical reactor combined with anaerobic-anoxic-oxic system for advanced treatment of coking wastewater

Coking wastewater is highly concentrated and extremely toxic, greatly challenging the treatment technologies. Conventional biological technology such as anaerobic-anoxic-oxic (A²O) system is inefficient, since various biological reactions are inhibited by toxicants in coking wastewater. In this work, a pilot-scale three-dimensional electrochemical reactor (3DER) is integrated into the A²O system as a pretreatment unit to improve the treatment efficiency of coking wastewater. The results indicate that 3DER pretreatment increased the biodegradability of coking wastewater, promoting the degradation of coking wastewater in A²O system. The integrated 3DER-A²O system can remove 94.4% of COD and 76.2% of TN from coking wastewater, and the energy consumption was only 0.22 kWh/kg COD and 4.69 kWh/kg TN. The components of coking wastewater were significantly simplified and the acute toxicity was reduced from 99% to 12% after the treatment. The integrated 3DER-A²O system provides a new solution for coking wastewater treatment, showing a promising application potential.

Structure and function of microbial community involved in a novel full-scale prefix oxic coking wastewater treatment O/H/O system

A novel full-scale prefix oxic coking wastewater (CWW) biological treatment O/H/O system had been operated steadily six years with the effluent quality meeting national discharge standard. Comparing to the traditional CWW biological treatment process, which usually have an anaerobic unit at the start of the process, here the O/H/O system has obvious advantages in COD removal, total nitrogen removal and reduced energy consumption. It is very necessary to illustrate the structure and function of the microbial community involved in different bioreactors of the O/H/O system. High-throughput MiSeq sequencing was used to examine the 16S rRNA genes in this system. Results revealed a contrasting microbial composition among the activated sludge samples of three sequential bioreactors: the β-Proteobacteria related sequences dominated in the O₁ activated sludge with the relative abundance of 56.44% while 7.53% of the sequences were assigned to Thiobacillus; Rhodoplanes related sequences dominated in the bioreactor H and O₂ activated sludge with relative abundance of 8.86% and 8.92%, respectively. The physico-chemical characteristics of CWW were analyzed by standard methods and the operational parameters were routinely monitored to examine their effects on the microbial communities. The bioinformatics software package of phylogenetic investigation of communities by reconstruction of unobserved states (PICRUSt) was used to predict the microbial community functional profiling and found three dominant genera of Rhodoplanes, Lysobacter and Leucobacter enriched the xenobiotics biodegradation and metabolism pathway. The diverse and distinct microbial community involved in biological treatment processes of CWW treatment indicating that water characteristics and operational parameters determined the microbial community composition. These results significantly expanded our knowledge of the biodiversity and population dynamics of microorganisms and discerned the relationships between bacterial communities and environmental variables in the biological treatment processes. Moreover, in this study, we proposed a comprehensive biodegradation model of CWW treatment and defined as O/H/O system.

Structure and function of microbial community associated with phenol co-substrate in degradation of benzo[a]pyrene in coking wastewater

Coking wastewater (CWW) contains high contents of phenols and other toxic and refractory compounds including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) with the most carcinogenic benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) among them. The mechanism of PAHs/BaP degradation in activated sludge of CWW treatment with phenol as co-substrate was studied. For characterizing the structure and functions of microbial community associated with BaP degradation with phenol as co-substrate, high-throughput MiSeq sequencing was used to examine the 16S rRNA genes of microbiology, revealing noticeable shifts in CWW activated sludge bacterial populations. Major genera involved in anaerobic degradation were Tissierella_Soehngenia, Diaphorobacter and Geobacter, whereas in aerobic degradation Rhodanobacter, Dyella and Thauera prevailed. BaP degradation with phenol as co-substrate induced bacterial diversification in CWW activated sludge in opposite trends when anaerobic and aerobic conditions were applied. In order to predict the microbial community functional profiling, a bioinformatics software package of phylogenetic investigation of communities by reconstruction of unobserved states (PICRUSt) was run to find that some dominant genera enriched in the BaP pathway may own the ability to degrade PAHs/BaP. Further experiments should focus on testing the dominant genera in BaP degradation at different oxygen levels.

Cost-efficient improvement of coking wastewater biodegradability by multi-stages flow through peroxi-coagulation under low current load

Cost-effective pretreatment of the highly concentrated and biorefractory coking wastewater to improve biodegradability is of significant importance, while green electrochemical technologies without external chemicals addition are charming but still challenging due to its high energy consumption. In this work, a novel multi-stages flow through peroxi-coagulation (PC) was for the first time developed with graphite felt cathode modified by graphene, showing an excellent performance in removal of 71.5% COD, 72.3% phenol and 59.4% NH₃-N and significant biodegradability enhancement with a low energy consumption as 1.2 kWh/m³. Compared with conventional flow PC, this process was more cost-effective due to more intensive ^.OH production and higher utilization of generated active species. Through UV spectrophotometry and GC-MS analysis, the improvement of biodegradability was attributed to the reduction of both low and high molecular weight compounds content in the coking wastewater. Comparing to the electro-Fenton, electrocoagulation and ozonation process, the proposed PC process was highly cost-effective, providing a promising and new alternative for pretreatment of coking wastewater.

Evaluation of the detoxification efficiencies of coking wastewater treated by combined anaerobic-anoxic-oxic (A2O) and advanced oxidation process

Coking wastewater contains many types of toxic and hazardous pollutants that have serious toxic effects on human beings as well as aquatic organisms. However, few studies have evaluated the detoxification efficiencies of the treatment processes that are extensively performed in operational coking wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). This study investigates the detoxification efficiencies of a combined anaerobic-anoxic-oxic (A²O)-ozonation and A²O-Fenton oxidation process in two coking WWTPs using an acute immobilization test for Daphnia magna, acute toxicity test for adult zebrafish, embryo toxicity test for zebrafish and the comet assay. The raw coking wastewaters displayed high acute daphnia and fish toxicity, zebrafish embryo toxicity and genotoxicity. The A²O processing unit effectively removed acute and embryo toxicity, but not genotoxicity. In addition, the A²O effluent quality did not meet the integrated wastewater discharge standard in China (GB18918-2002). The ozonation and Fenton oxidation units used as post-treatments in these two plants not only treated the coking wastewater to the discharge standard but also reduced the genotoxicity. However, the final effluents still showed potential genotoxicity after high dilution. The results suggest that the discharge of treated coking wastewater probably poses potential risks to human health and the environment even if it met regulatory standards.

Treatment of high-salinity chemical wastewater by indigenous bacteria--bioaugmented contact oxidation

A 90 m(3) biological contact oxidation system in chemical factory was bioaugmented with three strains of indigenous salt-tolerant bacteria. These three strains were screened from contaminative soil in situ. Their activity of growth and degradation was investigated with lab-scale experiments. Their salt-tolerant mechanism was confirmed to be compatible-solutes strategy for moderately halophilic bacteria, with amino acid and betaine playing important roles. The running conditions of the system were recorded for 150 days. The indigenous bacteria had such high suitability that the reactor got steady rapidly and the removal of COD maintained above 90%. It was introduced that biofilm fragments in sedimentation tank were inversely flowed to each reaction tank, and quantitative PCR demonstrated that this process could successfully maintain the bacterial abundance in the reaction tanks. In addition, the T-RFLP revealed that bioaugmented strains dominated over others in the biofilm.

Biotoxicity evaluation of coking wastewater treated with different technologies using Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes)

The potential biotoxicity to the environment should be addressed during wastewater treatment. In this study, biotoxicity of coking wastewater effluent from MBR, Fenton, electro-Fenton and coagulation treatment processes was evaluated using embryos and larvae of Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes). The acute toxicity based on 96-h larval mortality as well as the chronic toxicity based on embryo hatching, larvae swim-up failure, growth, and sexual ratio were determined. The results showed that different treatment processes have various biotoxicity levels. The acute toxicity of Fenton and electro-Fenton effluents was much higher than that of MBR and coagulation. For the chronic toxicity, the effluent of the Fenton/electro-Fenton process displayed lower embryo hatching, larvae survival and growth in comparison with the effluents of MBR and coagulation. No endocrine disruption was detected in MBR, Fenton and electro-Fenton effluents, but was contained in the coagulation effluent. The biotoxicity test indicated that the effluent of MBR was very safe for the environment. The toxicological indices were necessary for ecological safety maintenance in the industrial wastewater treatment.

Composition and dynamics of microbial community in a zeolite biofilter-membrane bioreactor treating coking wastewater

In this study, a lab-scale anaerobic/anoxic/zeolite biofilter-membrane bioreactor (A1/A2/ZB-MBR) was designed to treat coking wastewater. The 454 pyrosequencing was used to obtain the composition and dynamics of microbial community about the treatment system. The results showed that the system yielded stable effluent chemical oxidation demand (158.5 ± 21.8 mg/L) and ammonia (8.56 ± 7.30 mg/L), but fluctuant total nitrogen (31.4-165.1 mg/L) concentrations. In addition, 66,256 16S rRNA gene sequences were obtained from A2 and ZB-MBR, and the microbial diversity and richness for five samples were determined. Although community compositions in the five samples were quite different, bacteria assigned to phylum Proteobacteria and class Flavobacteria commonly existed and dominated the microbial populations. The pyrosequencing analysis revealed that the microbial community shifted in the ZB-MBR with the presence of zeolite. Some taxa began to appear in ZB-MBR and contributed to the system performance. Additionally, Nitrosomonas and Nitrobacter gradually became the dominant ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria during the operation, respectively, which are favorable for the stabilized ammonia removal. Our results proved that the ZB-MBR is an alternative technique for treating coking wastewater.

Comparison of denitrifier communities in the biofilms of bioaugmented and non-augmented zeolite-biological aerated filters

The denitrifier communities of a bioaugmented and non-augmented zeolite-biological aerated filter (Z-BAFs) were investigated and compared because the bioaugmented Z-BAF provided better and more stable treatment efficiency for nitrate and nitrite removal. Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) and reverse transcription T-RFLP (RT-T-RFLP) were applied to analyse the denitrifier community diversity in the biofilm collected from each Z-BAF. The results showed that the bioaugmentation technology favourably changed the indigenous denitrifier community and enhanced denitrification under nitrogen loading shocks. The cDNA clone libraries were developed to explore the active denitrifier community structures of both filters. The results showed that the active denitrifiers in both the bioaugmented and non-bioaugmented Z-BAF belonged to alpha-, beta- and gamma-proteobacteria. However, the sequence of the introduced denitrifier (Paracoccus sp. BW001) was not found in the clone library of the bioaugmented filter, which implied that the removal of nitrate and nitrite was attributed mainly to the indigenous denitrifiers in the adjusted bacterial community in the bioaugmented Z-BAF.