Real-time sonoelastography using an external reference material: test-retest reliability of healthy Achilles tendons

Biomechanical changes in the gastrocnemius medius-Achilles tendon complex in people with hypermobility spectrum disorders: A cross-sectional compression sonoelastography study

Objective

This study aimed to assess the biomechanical impact of Hypermobility Spectrum Disorders (HSD) on the elasticity of the gastrocnemius medius-Achilles tendon (GM-AT) complex.

Methods

Using a cross-sectional design, the GM-AT complex elasticity was compared using sonoelastography (SEG) in an HSD group and healthy controls during rest and maximal isometric plantar flexion contraction.

Results

The HSD group comprised 28 patients (26 women); mean ± SD age 28.7 ± 8.4 years, compared to 28 controls (26 women); 31.5 ± 8.7 years. During rest, greater elasticity was identified in HSD relative to controls at the GM-AT musculotendinous junction (strain ratio 2.05 ± 1.31 vs. 1.48 ± 0.49), mid-AT (3.60 ± 1.97 vs. 2.66 ± 1.00), and distal AT (4.57 ± 2.69 vs. 3.22 ± 1.94) (all p < 0.05). During contraction, no significant differences were found between groups at the GM-AT musculotendinous junction (3.40 ± 2.16 vs. 2.62 ± 1.07), mid AT (10.75 ± 5.29 vs. 8.49 ± 3.53), or distal AT (8.55 ± 5.39 vs. 8.83 ± 3.51) (all p > 0.05). No significant differences were found between groups in the GM strain ratio during rest (4.05 ± 1.43 vs. 3.62 ± 0.78), or contraction (4.23 ± 1.29 vs. 4.19 ± 1.31). Exploratory Receiver Operator Characteristics curve analysis suggested low sensitivity and specificity of the strain ratio for the diagnosis of HSD.

Conclusion

People with HSD have greater GM-AT complex elasticity. Although statistically significant group differences were identified, further research is required to establish the diagnostic, clinical, and research utility of strain ratio measurements.

Association between Achilles Tendon Softness and Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease in Patients with Familial Hypercholesterolemia

AIMS

Achilles tendon (AT) xanthomas are a specific physical finding of familial hypercholesterolemia (FH) and AT thickness has been used for its diagnosis and evaluation of its severity. Recently, we reported that the AT of FH patients was softer than that of non-FH patients and the combined use of a cut-off value for AT softness with that for AT thickness improved diagnostic accuracy. However, an association between AT softness and severity of atherosclerosis has not been reported. Accordingly, the present study aimed to investigate whether AT softness was associated with carotid atherosclerosis and presence of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD) in FH.

METHODS

The AT of 176 genetically diagnosed FH patients and 98 non-FH patients was examined to measure AT thickness and the elasticity index (EI) as an indicator for assessing AT softness using ultrasonography.

RESULTS

Increased age was associated with AT softness, and overweight was negatively related to AT softness. There were significant inverse correlations between EI and maximum and mean intima-media thickness (IMT) within the common carotid artery only among FH patients. In multiple linear regression analysis, although the relationship between EI and mean IMT was attenuated, the association between EI and maximum IMT remained robust. In logistic regression analysis adjusted for age, sex and traditional cardiovascular risk factors (smoking history, presence of hypertension, presence of diabetes mellitus, overweight, LDL-cholesterol, HDL-cholesterol, and Log triglycerides), EI was associated with presence of ASCVD (Odds ratio per 1-SD increase, 0.37; 95% CI, 0.15 - 0.86; P=0.0252).

CONCLUSION

The degree of lipid deposition in the AT of FH patients could be assessed by its thickness as well as its softness. AT softness is not only useful in diagnosing FH but is also associated with the severity of carotid atherosclerosis and presence of ASCVD. In addition, these findings suggest that AT softness would be helpful in risk assessment for FH patients.

Reliability of Sonoelastography Measurements of Lower Limb Tendon Properties: A Systematic Review

This study investigated the reliability of sonoelastography techniques in quantifying lower limb tendon elasticity. A literature search was conducted using PubMed, Web of Science and CINAHL. The quality of the selected papers was evaluated using the Guidelines for Reporting Reliability and Agreement Studies and the Quality Appraisal Tool for Studies of Diagnostic Reliability checklist. Reliability values were extracted and synthesized. Twenty-four studies were included and were divided by the two main technologies used: strain and shear-wave elastography. The overall methodological quality was questionable; all studies were at risk of bias. Highly variable results ranging from poor to excellent reliability were found for both technologies and for all tendons considered. Intra-rater reliability of strain elastography on the Achilles tendon and shear-wave elastography on the patellar and quadriceps tendon was adequate. Inter-rater, inter-session and inter-machine reliability was insufficient. Caution should be used when interpreting results from sonoelastography studies measuring lower limb tendon elasticity.

Shear wave and strain sonoelastography for the evaluation of the Achilles tendon during isometric contractions

Objectives

Changes in mechanical loading as well as pathology can modify the Achilles tendon mechanical properties and therefore detection of these changes is relevant for the diagnosis and management of Achilles tendinopathy. The aim of this study was to evaluate strain and shear wave sonoelastography for their ability to detect changes in the Achilles tendon mechanical properties during a series of isometric contractions.

Methods

Longitudinal sonoelastography images of the Achilles tendon were acquired from 20 healthy participants using four different ultrasound devices; two implementing strain sonoelastography technology (SE1, SE2) and two, shear wave elastography technology (SWE1, SWE2).

Results

SE1 measured a decreasing strain ratio (tendon become harder) during the different contraction levels from 1.51 (0.92) to 0.33 (0.16) whereas SE2 mesaured a decreasing strain ratio from 1.08 (0.76) to 0.50 (0.32). SWE1 measured decreasing tendon stiffness during contractions of increasing intensity from 33.40 (19.61) to 16.19 (2.68) whereas SWE2 revealed increasing tendon stiffness between the first two contraction levels from 428.65 (131.5) kPa to 487.9 (121.5) kPa followed by decreasing stiffness for the higher contraction levels from 459.35 (113.48) kPa to 293.5 (91.18) kPa.

Conclusions

Strain elastography used with a reference material was able to detect elasticity changes between the different contraction levels whereas shear wave elastography was less able to detect changes in Achilles tendon stiffness when under load. Inconsistent results between the two technologies should be further investigated.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13244-021-00974-y.

Can patient characteristics explain variance in ultrasound strain elastography measures of the quadratus femoris and patellar tendons?

OBJECTIVES

To explore the associations between participant characteristics and magnitudes of difference in paired elastography measures of knee tendon from different ultrasound systems, and to compare strain elastography pattern description.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Quadriceps and patellar tendons of 20 healthy volunteers (40 tendons) were examined by an experienced operator employing two ultrasound systems (GE S8 and Esaote MyLab 70XVG). Pearson/Spearman correlations explored the influence of participant characteristics (BMI, body fat %, leg circumference, activity level) on the magnitude of differences between measures. Paired-sample t test or Wilcoxon signed rank test were performed to compare repeated measures of individual ultrasound systems.

RESULTS

The quadriceps tendon was characteristically stiffer than the patellar tendon. Participant characteristics were associated with within machine differences of the distal quadriceps tendon (BMI; r = 0.49, p = 0.028-0.03 and body fat %; r = 0.43, p = 0.05-0.056) ER measures.

CONCLUSIONS

Anthropometric and body composition parameters were associated with within machine differences for elasticity measures, where high BMI and body fat % contribute to paired measurement variance at the distal quadriceps tendon. Strain elastography protocols should be standardised, repeated ER measures performed using the same US system and patient characteristics considered for future clinical applications.

Intermachine Variation of Ultrasound Strain Elastographic Measures of the Quadriceps and Patellar Tendons in Healthy Participants: Implications for Clinical Practice

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate intermachine variation and compare intraoperator and interoperator agreement and repeatability characteristics of 2 ultrasound (US) systems for measurements of quadriceps and patellar tendons by strain elastography (SE).

METHODS

Forty tendons from 20 healthy participants were investigated by operators with different experience (operator 1, 12 years of US experience and >50 SE examinations; operator 2, no US experience and 1 day of SE training). Repeated measures were performed on GE Healthcare (Waukesha, WI) and Esaote (Genoa, Italy) US systems. The percentage of agreement, Cohen κ, intraclass correlation coefficient, and correlation tests assessed agreement, repeatability, and associations of SE measures. A paired t test and Wilcoxon signed rank test assessed differences in SE measures.

RESULTS

The study participants included 5 male and 15 female volunteers (mean [range] age, 29.3 [21-39] years). Better agreement and repeatability characteristics were observed for the patellar compared to the quadriceps tendon and the color score (CS) method over the elasticity ratio (ER). Intraoperator agreement was better for the experienced operator. Intraoperator repeatability was achieved in 55% of ER (intraclass correlation coefficient, 0.40-0.91; P < .05) and 77% to 85% (κ = -0.25-1) of CS measures. Interoperator repeatability was achieved in 35% (t/z, -2.93-7.94; P < .001-.048) of all ER measures. No significant differences in proximal (z, -0.13- -0.78) and distal patellar (z, -1.52-2.26; P > .5) patellar ER measures were observed. Seventy-four percent to 75% mean agreement (κ = 0-0.5) for CS measures comparable across both US systems was observed. Intermachine ER associations were poor (r = -0.39-0.13; P > .05), whereas greater than 70% agreement (κ = -0.87-0.53) for the CS was achieved.

CONCLUSIONS

The reproducibility of knee tendon SE measurements is influenced by the operator experience, US system, and tendon site.

Intra-rater reliability and smallest detectable change of compression sonoelastography in quantifying the material properties of the musculoskeletal system

Musculoskeletal conditions can change tissue elasticity. Knowledge of musculoskeletal elasticity could therefore aid clinical diagnosis and management. Sonoelastography is an ultrasound-based system that examines the material properties of tissues, and it may be useful in musculoskeletal practice. Therefore, it is important to establish its clinimetric properties. This study aimed to explore the intra-rater reliability and the smallest detectable changes of sonoelastography in examining musculoskeletal structures. A quantitative reliability design was used to examine 22 healthy participants using a compression sonoelastography system that produces color-coded images. The deltoid, biceps brachii, brachioradialis, rectus femoris, gastrocnemius medius muscles, and Achilles tendon were examined twice at 1-hr intervals to assess the intra-rater reliability. The sonoelastography images were analyzed using the strain index, strain ratio, and color pixels. The intra-rater reliability and the smallest detectable changes of each outcome variable were determined. The intra-class correlation coefficient was used to quantify the repeatability of the measurements, and the smallest detectable changes were calculated to determine clinically important differences above the error of measurement. The intra-rater reliability for the strain index, strain ratio, and color pixel analysis ranged from moderate to excellent (intra-class correlation coefficients: .734-.950, .776-.921, and .754-.990, respectively), with color pixel analysis demonstrating the highest reliability. The smallest detectable changes were determined for all structures, including the Achilles tendon (0.11 for the higher boundary of the strain index, 1.80 for the strain ratio, and 2.90% for red pixels, representing soft tissues). Color pixel analysis may be more reliable for sonoelastography interpretation compared with the strain index and strain ratio. The calculated smallest detectable changes could be used to identify clinically important differences.

Quantitative quasi-static ultrasound elastography using reference layer: Ex-vivo study

It is well-documented in the literature that changes in tissue elasticity are generally correlated with disease condition. In the case of diffuse liver disease, the elasticity of the liver reduces progressively. However, this change does not clearly manifest in conventional ultrasound examinations. Although quasi-static elastography is popular in clinical applications where qualitative assessment of relative tissue stiffness is enough, its potential is relatively underutilized in liver imaging due to the need for quantitative stiffness value. Recently, it was demonstrated that using a reference layer of known stiffness, one could produce quantitative modulus elastograms of the target tissue using quasi-static elastography using simulations and phantom experiments. Here, we examined the performance of this approach on ex-vivo goat liver samples and compare the estimated modulus values to that obtained from indentation measurements. The results suggest that using this approach of reference layer yields Young's modulus values within 10% error compared to the ground truth.

Body Mass Index and Segmental Mass Correlation With Elastographic Strain Ratios of the Quadriceps Tendon

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to establish a relationship between quadriceps tendon stiffness and its properties and variations in the body mass index (BMI) and segmental mass.

METHODS

This study was conducted in 3 groups according to their BMI (A, low [<18.5 kg/m² ]; B, normal [18.5-25.0 kg/m² ]; and C, high [>25.0 kg/m² ]). All of the participants included had a sedentary lifestyle and did not do any weightlifting or any kind of sports activity in the previous 6 months. Ultrasound measurements were performed on the participants' lower right extremities, since it was the dominant side for all of the participants.

RESULTS

A total of 40 healthy untrained men participated in the study. The mean age of the participants ± SD was 22.1 ± 1.3 years; the age ranges for groups A (n = 6), B (n = 18), and C (n = 16) were 19-23, 19-25, and 20-25 years, respectively; 28 of the participants were nonsmokers, and 12 of were smokers. A strong statistical difference (all P < .05) was witnessed for most of the parameters (BMI, body fat mass, dominant leg body fat content, fat-free mass index, tendon thickness, and strain ratio) among the groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The length of the tendon did not show a significant increase with an increase in the BMI, body fat mass, dominant leg body fat content, and fat-free mass index. However, a greater intensification was observed for the thickness of the tendon with a significant increase in tendon stiffness (with the use of external reference material).

Strain Ratio Measurements of Patellar and Achilles Tendons With Different Reference Regions in Healthy Volunteers

Strain ratio measurements of tendons vary because of the reference tissue selection. The main purpose of this study is to highlight, in detail, the numeric variability attributable to the use of various reference materials on strain ratio measurements of patellar and Achilles tendons. Measurements were performed at the proximal, middle and distal thirds of the patellar and Achilles tendons on the dominant site of healthy volunteers. A total of 3 references were used: the Hoffa's fat pad for the patellar tendon, the Kager's fat pad for the Achilles tendon, subcutaneous tissue and Aquaflex gel pads (Parker Laboratories, Fairfield, NJ, USA) for both tendons. Although the same methods were used by the same physician for each tendon site on repeated measurements, strain ratio values had numeric variability with various reference materials in each measurement. Therefore, comparison of numeric strain ratio results of various studies with various reference materials could confuse the clinical interpretations of these numeric data, and, using a reference material with standard stiffness like Aquaflex ultrasound gel pads, should be considered by verifying these results with further studies.

Reliability of ultrasound strain elastography in the assessment of the quadriceps and patellar tendon in healthy adults

Objective

To report the intra- and inter-operator reliability of ultrasound strain elastography measures in the assessment of quadriceps and patellar tendons.

Materials and methods

Forty tendons were investigated of 20 healthy volunteers. Five anatomical sites were examined and analysed by three operators of differing levels of experience. Ultrasound was performed over two measures, employing three sonoelastography measurement techniques using a GE S8 with linear probe (L6-15 MHz). The percentage of exact agreement, Cohen's kappa and ICC_2,1 were performed to assess intra- and inter-operator reliability.

Results

The patellar tendon is more reliably measured across all techniques compared to the quadriceps tendon, particularly the distal region. Colour scoring was the most reliable method of sonoelastography. Colour scoring intra- and inter-operator reliability was better for patella tendon sites across all operators (60-95% agreement range), and greatest for experienced operators. Elasticity index intra-operator reliability was greatest for the most experienced operator compared with the least (ICC range 0.35-0.72 and ICC 0.17-0.60). Elasticity ratio intra-operator reliability of the patella tendon was fair-excellent for the experienced operator (ICC range 0.43-0.91), excluding the mid patellar region (ICC 0.13). Poor-fair inter-operator reliability was observed for elasticity ratio (ICC range 0.0-0.54) and elasticity index (ICC range 0.0-0.57).

Conclusions

Strain elastography of the patellar tendon is more reliable than the quadriceps tendon. Intra- and inter-operator reliability was better when undertaken by more experienced operators. Colour scoring was more reliable than elasticity ratio and index methods. Poor-fair intra- and inter-operator reliability of the elasticity ratio and elasticity index was observed.

A novel application of strain sonoelastography can detect changes in Achilles tendon elasticity during isometric contractions of increasing intensity

Background

Mechanical and morphological properties of the Achilles tendon are altered in disease and in response to changes in mechanical loading. In the last few years different ultrasound based technologies have been used to detect tendon mechanical properties changes mainly in resting condition. Therefore the aim of this study was to evaluate if strain sonoelastography can identify changes in Achilles tendon elasticity during isometric contractions of increasing intensity.

Methods

This cross-sectional study enrolled 37 healthy volunteers (19 women) with mean (±SD) age of 27.1 (±7.0) years between January and June 2017. Strain sonoelastography images of the Achilles tendon were acquired during an isometric ramp force (0 kg, 0.5 kg, 1 kg, 2 kg, 5 kg and, 10 kg). An external reference material was used to provide a comparison between the examined tissue and a material of constant elasticity. Friedman test with post hoc pairwise comparison were used to determine the correlation between the difference contraction levels.

Results

The median and interquartile range (IQR) values for the strain ratio were 1.61 (1.5–2.9) in a relaxed state and 1.30 (1.07–2.02), 1.00 (0.76–1.66), 0.81 (0.70–1.19), 0.47 (0.39–0.73) and 0.33 (0.28–0.40) for 0.5 kg, 1 kg, 2 kg, 5 kg and 10 kg, respectively revealing increased tendon hardness with increasing contraction intensities. Friedman test revealed significant differences (p < 0.05) in the strain ratio between all contractions except between 0.5 kg – 1 kg (p = 0.41); 1 kg – 2 kg (p = 0.12) and 5 kg – 10 kg (p = 0.12).

Conclusion

Strain sonoelastography can detect changes in Achilles tendon elasticity between different contraction intensities. The results provide an original force-elasticity curve for the Achilles tendon in a healthy, asymptomatic population.

Trial registration

The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Canton Ticino.

Ultrasound elastography: compression elastography and shear-wave elastography in the assessment of tendon injury

Ultrasound elastography (USE) is a recent technology that has experienced major developments in the past two decades. The assessment of the main mechanical properties of tissues can be made with this technology by characterisation of their response to stress. This article reviews the two major techniques used in musculoskeletal elastography, compression elastography (CE) and shear-wave elastography (SWE), and evaluates the studies published on major electronic databases that use both techniques in the context of tendon pathology. CE accounts for more studies than SWE. The mechanical properties of tendons, particularly their stiffness, may be altered in the presence of tendon injury. CE and SWE have already been used for the assessment of Achilles tendons, patellar tendon, quadriceps tendon, epicondylar tendons and rotator cuff tendons and muscles. Achilles tendinopathy is the most studied tendon injury with USE, including the postoperative period after surgical repair of Achilles rupture tendon. In relation to conventional ultrasound (US), USE potentially increases the sensitivity and diagnostic accuracy in tendinopathy, and can detect pathological changes before they are visible in conventional US imaging. Several technical limitations are recognised, and standardisation is necessary to ensure repeatability and comparability of the results when using these techniques. Still, USE is a promising technique under development and may be used not only to promote an early diagnosis, but also to identify the risk of injury and to support the evaluation of rehabilitation interventions. KEY POINTS: • USE is used for the assessment of the mechanical properties of tissues, including the tendons. • USE increases diagnostic performance when coupled to conventional US imaging modalities. • USE will be useful in early diagnosis, tracking outcomes and monitoring treatments of tendon injury. • Technical issues and lack of standardisation limits USE use in the assessment of tendon injury.

Ultrasound elastography in tendon pathology: state of the art

Elastography assesses the biomechanical and structural properties of tissues by measuring their stiffness. Despite promising results, elastography has not yet earned its place in the daily practice of musculoskeletal radiologists. The purpose of this article is to present and examine the data available to date on ultrasound elastography of the tendons through a review of the literature to provide musculoskeletal radiologists with an overview that may help them better understand and use elastography routinely. The most common techniques in ultrasound elastography are described. Then, the aspects of the physiologic and pathologic tendon are presented and discussed. One must make this technique one's own to better apprehend its contribution to the musculoskeletal imaging field, while bearing in mind that further research will be required before admitting elastography as a reliable and validated tool able to optimize our daily clinical practice.

Poor reproducibility of compression elastography in the Achilles tendon: same day and consecutive day measurements

OBJECTIVE

To determine the reproducibility of compression elastography (CE) when measuring strain data, a measure of stiffness of the human Achilles tendon in vivo, over consecutive measures, consecutive days and when using different foot positions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eight participants (4 males, 4 females; mean age 25.5 ± 2.51 years, range 21-30 years; height 173.6 ± 11.7 cm, range 156-189 cm) had five consecutive CE measurements taken on one day and a further five CE measures taken, one per day, at the same time of day, every day for a consecutive 5-day period. These 80 measurements were used to assess both the repeatability and reproducibility of the technique. Means, standard deviations, coefficient of variation (CV), Pearson correlation analysis (R) and intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC) were calculated.

RESULTS

For CE data, all CVs were above 53%, R values indicated no-to-weak correlations between measures at best (range 0.01-0.25), and ICC values were all classified in the poor category (range 0.00-0.11). CVs for length and diameter measures were acceptably low indicating a high level of reliability.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the wide variation obtained in the CE results, it was concluded that CE using this specific system has a low level of reproducibility for measuring the stiffness of the human Achilles tendon in vivo over consecutive days, consecutive measures and in different foot positions.