Regarding the manuscript entitled “Association of Radioactive Iodine Treatment With Cancer Mortality in Patients With Hyperthyroidism”

[Guideline for Radioiodine Therapy for Benign Thyroid Diseases (6/2022 - AWMF No. 031-003)]

This version of the guideline for radioiodine therapy of benign thyroid disorders is an update of the version, which was published by the German Society of Nuclear Medicine (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Nuklearmedizin, DGN) in co-ordination with the German Society of Endocrinology (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Endokrinologie, DGE, Sektion Schilddrüse) and the German Society of General- and Visceral-Surgery (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Allgemein- und Viszeralchirurgie, DGAV) in 2015. This guideline was harmonized with the recommendations of the European Association of Nuclear Medicine (EANM). According to the German "Directive on Radiation Protection in Medicine" the physician specialised in nuclear medicine ("Fachkunde in der Therapie mit offenen radioaktiven Stoffen") is responsible for the justification to treat with radioiodine. Therefore, relevant medical indications for radioiodine therapy and alternative therapeutic options are discussed within the guideline. This procedure guideline is developed in the consensus of an expert group. This fulfils the level S1 (first step) within the German classification of Clinical Practice Guidelines.

Does Radioactive Iodine Therapy for Hyperthyroidism Cause Cancer?

Radioactive iodine has been considered a safe and effective therapeutic option for hyperthyroidism secondary to Graves disease and autonomously functioning thyroid nodules since the mid-20th century. The question of whether I-131 at the doses used for hyperthyroidism might increase the risk of cancer has been investigated in a number of observational cohort studies over the years, with the preponderance of evidence being reassuring as to its safety. In particular, the 1998 Cooperative Thyrotoxicosis Therapy Follow-up Study (CTTFUS) has been widely cited as compelling evidence that I-131 is safe in hyperthyroidism therapy with respect to carcinogenesis. However, in 2019, a study by Kitahara and colleagues re-analyzed the CTTFUS cohort, extending the follow-up time and applying a novel dosimetric model for estimating tissue absorbed doses of radiation. This new analysis concluded that radioactive iodine was associated with an increased risk for mortality from overall cancer, breast cancer, and non-breast solid cancers. Reaction to this study was vociferous and particularly negative in the nuclear medicine literature. This mini-review was inspired by the 2019 CTTFUS controversy, and it is intended to provide the necessary context for clinicians to provide nuanced advice to their patients on the subject. To that end, the pre-2019 literature is surveyed, the 2019 CTTFUS study and a 2020 follow-up are discussed, and lessons from the literature and critical commentaries are considered.

The Role of Nuclear Medicine in the Clinical Management of Benign Thyroid Disorders, Part 1: Hyperthyroidism

Benign thyroid disorders, especially hyper- and hypothyroidism, are the most prevalent endocrine disorders. The most common etiologies of hyperthyroidism are autoimmune hyperthyroidism (Graves disease, GD), toxic multinodular goiter (TMNG), and toxic thyroid adenoma (TA). Less common etiologies include destructive thyroiditis (e.g., amiodarone-induced thyroid dysfunction) and factitious hyperthyroidism. GD is caused by autoantibodies against the thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) receptor. TMNG and TA are caused by a somatic activating gain-of-function mutation. Typical laboratory findings in patients with hyperthyroidism are low TSH, elevated free-thyroxine and free-triiodothyronine levels, and TSH-receptor autoantibodies in patients with GD. Ultrasound imaging is used to determine the size and vascularity of the thyroid gland and the location, size, number, and characteristics of thyroid nodules. Combined with lab tests, these features constitute the first-line diagnostic approach to distinguishing different forms of hyperthyroidism. Thyroid scintigraphy with either radioiodine or ^99mTc-pertechnetate is useful to characterize different forms of hyperthyroidism and provides information for planning radioiodine therapy. There are specific scintigraphic patterns for GD, TMNG, TA, and destructive thyroiditis. Scintigraphy with ^99mTc-sestamibi allows differentiation of type 1 from type 2 amiodarone-induced hyperthyroidism. The radioiodine uptake test provides information for planning radioiodine therapy of hyperthyroidism. Hyperthyroidism can be treated with oral antithyroid drugs, surgical thyroidectomy, or ¹³¹I-iodide. Radioiodine therapy is generally considered after failure of treatment with antithyroid drugs, or when surgery is contraindicated or refused by the patient. In patients with TA or TMNG, the goal of radioiodine therapy is to achieve euthyroid status. In GD, the goal of radioiodine therapy is to induce hypothyroidism, a status that is readily treatable with oral thyroid hormone replacement therapy. Dosimetric estimates based on the thyroid volume to be treated and on radioiodine uptake should guide selection of the ¹³¹I-activity to be administered. Early side effects of radioiodine therapy (typically mild pain in the thyroid) can be handled by nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs. Delayed side effects after radioiodine therapy for hyperthyroidism are hypothyroidism and a minimal risk of radiation-induced malignancies.

Cancer incidence and mortality following treatment of hyperthyroidism with radioactive iodine

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Hyperthyroidism is a commonly encountered clinical issue. Radioactive iodine is one of the treatment modalities employed over the last 80 years. Prior studies are conflicting as to whether radioactive iodine is associated with an increased risk of subsequent malignancy and associated mortality. The present article reviews recent publications on this subject.

RECENT FINDINGS

Two recent studies make meaningful contributions to the existing literature; however, data remain inconsistent. The first, conducted using the Clalit Health Services database, evaluated solid tumor incidence after radioactive iodine and found no association with increased risk of solid tumor malignancy. The second, which is an updated analysis of the Cooperative Thyrotoxicosis Therapy Follow-up Study, concluded that there is a dose-dependent increased risk of solid tumor mortality using a novel method of estimating organ-specific radiation exposure.

SUMMARY

In patients with hyperthyroidism, radioactive iodine is a popular and effective treatment option. Prior studies reach conflicting conclusions on the potential relationship between radioactive iodine and both subsequent cancer incidence and mortality. We review recent publications that add to our understanding of this important clinical question.