Correction of asymmetric calf hypertrophy with differential selective neurectomy

Endoscopic Concurrent Gastrocnemius Muscle Resection and Soleus Muscle Neurectomy for Severe Muscular Calf Hypertrophy

BACKGROUND

Selective neurectomy or muscle resection techniques for calf reduction conventionally focus on the gastrocnemius muscle. However, the underlying soleus muscle plays an important role in muscular calf hypertrophy. In the authors' experience, the results of calf reduction have been suboptimal in patients with severe muscular calf hypertrophy who underwent gastrocnemius muscle resection only. This article describes a new calf reduction method that uses concurrent gastrocnemius muscle resection and soleus muscle neurectomy using an endoscope-assisted single-incision approach in patients with severe muscular calf hypertrophy.

METHODS

A total of 139 patients who underwent simultaneous gastrocnemius muscle resection and soleus muscle neurectomy for severe calf hypertrophy from March of 2017 to June of 2020 were retrospectively analyzed.

RESULTS

After combined gastrocnemius resection (mean weight per calf, 349 g) and soleus neurectomy, about 3.8 to 8.2 cm (mean, 6.4 cm) or 12.8% to 24.3% (mean, 16.6%) of the calf was reduced. Complications included cellulitis, hematoma, seroma, and mild depression ( n = 1 each). Two patients had traction injury to the sural nerve. One patient developed Achilles tendon rupture at 2 months postoperatively. No patient complained of functional impairment with respect to easy fatigability, stability, gait, or sport activities at 6 months postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

This study is the first to combine gastrocnemius muscle resection with selective soleus muscle neurectomy to achieve the most efficient calf reduction for severe muscular calf hypertrophy.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, IV.

Distal overactivation of gastrocnemius medialis in persistent plantarflexion weakness following Achilles tendon repair

Structural alterations of the triceps surae and Achilles tendon (AT) can promote plantarflexion weakness one-year following an AT repair, influencing the activation strategies of the Gastrocnemius Medialis (GM) muscle. However, this is yet to be demonstrated. We aimed to determine whether patients with plantar flexion weakness one-year after AT repair show altered GM spatial activation. In this cross-sectional and case-control study, ten middle-aged men (age 34 ± 7 years old, and 12.9 ± 1.1 months post-surgery) with a high AT total rupture score who attended conventional physiotherapy for six months after surgery, and ten healthy control men (age 28 ± 9 years old), performed maximal and submaximal (40, 60 and 90%) voluntary isometric plantarflexion contractions on a dynamometer. The peak plantar flexor torque was determined by isokinetic dynamometry and the GM neuromuscular activation was measured with a linear surface-electromyography (EMG) array. Overall EMG activation (averaged channels) increased when the muscle contraction levels increased for both groups. EMG spatial analysis in AT repaired group showed an increased activation located distally at 85-99%, 75-97%, and 79-97% of the electrode array length for 40%, 60%, and 90% of the maximal voluntary isometric contractions, respectively. In conclusion, patients with persistent plantar flexion weakness after AT rupture showed higher distal overactivation in GM.

Calf Reduction by Partial Resection of Gastrocnemius Using a Suction-Assisted Cartilage Shaver

BACKGROUND

Long-term aesthetic reduction of the legs in Asians is gaining increasing popularity among cosmetic patients. Current treatment options include botulinum toxin injection, radiofrequency, neurectomy, and total, subtotal, or partial muscle resection of the gastrocnemius. Partial resection using Kelly forceps was introduced in 2000. This article presents the use of a suction-assisted cartilage shaver to perform partial resection, describing the procedures and shaver modifications and evaluating its use.

METHODS

A retrospective review of 71 cases with a minimum 6-month follow-up (average, 36.5 months; range, 6 to 160 months) was performed. Twenty partial calf reductions were performed with a short shaver, 27 with a long shaver, and 24 with an endoscope-guided long shaver.

RESULTS

Mean reduction of calf circumference was 2 cm (range, -1 to 6 cm); the mean preoperative and postoperative calf circumferences were 35.8 cm and 33.8 cm, respectively. Mean tissue reduction per calf was 110 g (range, 25 to 300 g).Two patients developed larger calves after surgery, one because of weight gain and the other because of weight training. Complications included surface irregularity (n = 4, 5.6 percent), numbness over the lateral ankle or lateral foot (n = 9, 12.7 percent), hematoma clot requiring surgical evacuation (n = 11, 15.5 percent), prolonged seroma (n = 2, 2.8 percent), and left ankle plantar-flexion contracture due to tight, sustained postsurgery bandaging (n = 1, 1.5 percent). Scar-related complications were hyperpigmentation (n = 6, 8.5 percent), depressed scars (n = 5, 7 percent), and hypertrophic scars (n = 2, 2.8 percent).

CONCLUSIONS

Short, long, and endoscope-guided long suction-assisted cartilage shavers for partial resection of calf muscles can be used effectively to reduce the calf. Several mostly treatable complications were noted.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, IV.

Validated Assessment Scales for the Female Asian Calf

BACKGROUND

Clinical photonumeric scales have been developed and validated to objectively measure the effectiveness of aesthetic treatments in specific anatomical areas; however, these are based on the typical features of Caucasian patients. No clinical scale for Asian calf appearance currently exists.

OBJECTIVE

To develop and validate a calf assessment scale for use in the female Asian patient population.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

During 2 validation sessions, 13 raters assessed calf images of female Asian subjects (N = 35) viewed from behind with feet flat on the floor (at rest) and on tiptoes (dynamic). Images were rated from 0 (very slim, linear profile) to 4 (very severe convex profile).

RESULTS

Inter-rater and intra-rater reliability were "substantial" (≥0.6, intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC] and weighted kappa) for the calf-at rest, calf-dynamic, and calf summary score. Reliability was "substantial" for calf-at rest and calf-dynamic (≥0.6, ICC and weighted kappa) and "almost perfect" (0.85) for the calf summary score. BMI and calf circumference were highly correlated with scale ratings, and calf circumference was a significant predictor.

CONCLUSION

This new photonumeric assessment scale has value for assessing the female Asian calf, providing a standardized measure of calf appearance in clinical practice and clinical research settings.

Simultaneous Use of Selective Neurectomy With Liposuction for Calf Reduction in Asians

BACKGROUND

Calf contouring continues to be popular among Northeast Asians. Calf hypertrophy and distorted leg contours are stressful to many women. Several calf reduction techniques such as a selective neurectomy or calf muscle resection have been attempted, but have inconsistent results.

OBJECTIVES

This study was designed to demonstrate improved outcomes when combining a selective neurectomy with simultaneous liposuction.

METHODS

A total of 780 patients with hypertrophic calves underwent calf reduction from January 2002 to December 2010. Of these, 193 patients were treated by selective neurectomy with simultaneous liposuction. Calf hypertrophy with a circumference below 34 cm was defined as mild, calves with a circumference of 34 to 38 cm were defined as moderate, and a calf circumference above 38 cm was defined as severe. In all groups, patients whose pinch test was above 2 cm underwent a simultaneous liposuction.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight cases (14.5%) were defined as mild, 72 (37.3%) were moderate, and 93 (48.2%) were severe. Over an average of 8.7 months of postoperative follow up, the reduction in calf circumference averaged 3.7 cm in the mild group (11.1%), 4.0 cm in the moderate group (10.7 %), and 4.3 cm in the severe group (10.7%). Overall, 97.5% of patients were satisfied with the results. There were no severe complications including functional problem of lower extremity reported.

CONCLUSIONS

The shape, type, and fat distribution of the hypertrophic calves were considered in our patient analysis. A selective neurectomy with liposuction was performed on 193 patients. This technique allowed for a successful calf reduction and improved the patient's aesthetic satisfaction without any reported functional complications.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE 4

Anatomical study of the nerve regeneration after selective neurectomy in the rabbit: clinical application for esthetic calf reduction

The purposes of this study were therefore to characterize the degeneration and regeneration of nerves to the calf muscles after selective neurectomy, both macroscopically and microscopically, and to determine the incidence of such regeneration in a rabbit model. Seventy four New Zealand white rabbits were used. Selective neurectomy to the triceps surae muscles was performed, and the muscles were subsequently harvested and weighed 1-4 months postneurectomy. The gastrocnemius muscles were stained with Sihler's solution to enable the macroscopic observation of any nerve regeneration that may have occurred subsequent to neurectomy. The change in triceps surae muscle weight was measured along the time course of the experiment. After neurectomy, nerve degeneration was followed by regeneration in all cases. The weight of the triceps surae muscle decreased dramatically between completion of the neurectomy and 1 month postneurectomy, but increased thereafter. The nerve branches were weakly stained with Sihler's solution until 2 months postneurectomy, and then strongly stained after 3 months. The number of myelinated axons was decreased at 2 month after neurectomy compared to nonneurectomized controls, but then gradually increased thereafter. Although there are currently no reports on the incidence of recovery after calf reduction, it may be a very common occurrence in the clinical field based on our findings. The findings of this study provide fundamental anatomical and surgical information to aid planning and practice in calf-reduction surgery.

Safety and Efficacy of Selective Neurectomy of the Gastrocnemius Muscle for Calf Reduction in 300 Cases

BACKGROUND

Liposuction alone is not always sufficient to correct the shape of the lower leg, and muscle reduction may be necessary.

OBJECTIVE

To assess the outcomes of a new technique of selective neurectomy of the gastrocnemius muscle to correct calf hypertrophy.

METHODS

Between October 2007 and May 2010, 300 patients underwent neurectomy of the medial and lateral heads of the gastrocnemius muscle at the Department of Cosmetic and Plastic Surgery, the Second People's Hospital of Guangdong Province (Guangzhou, China) to correct the shape of their lower legs. Follow-up data from these 300 patients were analyzed retrospectively. Cosmetic results were evaluated independently by the surgeon, the patient, and a third party. Preoperative and postoperative calf circumferences were compared. The Fugl-Meyer motor function assessment was evaluated 3 months after surgery.

RESULTS

The average reduction in calf circumference was 3.2 ± 1.2 cm. The Fugl-Meyer scores were normal in all patients both before and 3 months after surgery. A normal calf shape was achieved in all patients. Six patients complained of fatigue while walking and four of scar pigmentation, but in all cases, this resolved within 6 months. Calf asymmetry was observed in only two patients.

CONCLUSION

The present series suggests that neurectomy of the medial and lateral heads of the gastrocnemius muscle may be safe and effective for correcting the shape of the calves.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE V

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

Classification and surgical correction of asymmetric calves in Asians

BACKGROUND

In Asia, one of the most important factors in being physically attractive is to have aesthetically pleasing legs, which has made calf contouring surgery an issue nowadays. When one leg is abnormally changed because of various factors (e.g., iatrogenic causes, poliomyelitis, cerebral palsy, trauma, and tumor resection), the tissue atrophies. Such asymmetric calves can be corrected by various surgical methods.

METHODS

Calf asymmetry is defined as a difference in the maximal circumference greater than 2.0 cm between both calves. From 2005 to 2012, the authors carried out calf contouring operations on 68 patients. For patients with mild or moderate asymmetry, selective neurectomy with or without liposuction was performed on the hypertrophic calf according to shape and severity. For patients with severe asymmetry, selective neurectomy with liposuction was performed for the hypertrophic calf, whereas the hypotrophic calf was treated with fat injection or silicone implantation.

RESULTS

At a minimum of 3 months' follow-up, the mild group patients had a size difference less than 0.5 cm. The moderate and severe asymmetry groups showed size differences less than 1.2 and 2.3 cm, respectively. No functional problems or major complications were shown. Minor complications included five cases of wound dehiscence, three cases of hematoma, and six cases of hypertrophic scar at the incision site.

CONCLUSION

Classifying patients into three groups according to the maximal circumferential difference between both legs and treating them separately using different surgical methods could significantly provide satisfying outcomes in both functional and aesthetic aspects.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, IV.

Bilateral idiopathic calf muscle hypertrophy: an exceptional cause of unsightly leg curvature

The authors present the management of a young female patient who presented with longstanding bilateral calf muscle hypertrophy, with no known cause. Taking into account the patient's wishes and the fact that the hypertrophy was mainly located in the posteromedial compartment, we chose to carry out a subtotal bilateral resection of medial gastrocnemius muscles. This procedure was performed with an harmonic scalpel, permitting a excellent cosmetic result while avoiding complications or functional impairment. After a reviewing of the commonly used techniques, the authors discuss the chosen surgical approach taking into account its clinical particularity.