Ten-Year Follow-Up of a Randomized Clinical Trial of Total Thyroidectomy Versus Dunhill Operation Versus Bilateral Subtotal Thyroidectomy for Multinodular Non-toxic Goiter

Total Thyroidectomy Versus Partial Thyroidectomy for Non-Toxic Multinodular Goiter: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

Thyroid follicular nodular disease (non-toxic multinodular goiter), the commonest thyroid disorder, can be managed with different surgical methods, including total thyroidectomy (TT), near-total thyroidectomy (NTT), subtotal thyroidectomy (STT), and Dunhill operation (DO). This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to provide an update on the role of TT versus NTT, STT, or DO in MNG concerning goiter recurrence, thyroid cancer incidence, and reported complications. We conducted a systematic literature search in Medline, EMBASE, and CENTRAL. We included randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that compared TT to partial thyroidectomy (NTT, STT, or DO) in the management of multinodular goiter (MNG). The following outcomes, goiter recurrence, cancer incidence, and adverse events (hypoparathyroidism and recurrent laryngeal nerve injury), were evaluated. We used the risk ratio (RR) to represent the dichotomous outcome. Subgroup analysis was performed based on the different types of partial thyroidectomy (NTT, STT, and DO). A total of 7 RCTs that included 1909 individuals were deemed eligible. TT showed significantly better results compared to PT in terms of goiter recurrence (RR = 0.05, 95% CI 0.02 to 0.13, P = 0.001; I 2  = 0%), whereas it showed similar results compared to PT in terms of thyroid cancer incidence (RR = 1.09, 95% CI 0.76 to 1.57, P = 0.63; I 2  = 0%). PT was significantly better than TT concerning transient adverse events (RR = 2.18, 95% CI 1.64 to 2.89, P = 0.001: I 2  = 63%). This meta-analysis showed that TT has a lower risk of goiter recurrence. TT is comparable to PT in terms of persistent adverse events but has a higher risk for transient adverse events.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13193-024-02057-y.

Demographic, clinical, and surgical features of patients undergoing thyroidectomy due to thyroid lesions in Southern Iran: A cross-sectional study

Background and Aims

The incidence of thyroid cancer has witnessed a significant global increase and stands as one of the most prevalent cancers in Iran. This surge is primarily attributed to the escalating incidence of papillary thyroid cancer (PTC), with overdiagnosis emerging as an equally noteworthy factor. Consequently, this study aims to ascertain the incidence of thyroid cancer, along with its clinical presentation, demographic characteristics, and surgical features in patients undergoing thyroid surgery.

Methods

This cross-sectional study involved the evaluation of patient files from referral centers in Shiraz spanning the years 2015-2020. Demographic and clinical information pertaining to thyroid cancer was extracted and subsequently analyzed using SPSS software.

Results

A total of 533 documented cases of thyroid cancer undergoing surgery revealed an annual rate of 89 cases in our location. The average age of the patients was 43.9 ± 13.4 years (ranging from 13 to 92), with females constituting 429 (83.5%) of the cases, and 278 (54.1%) being malignant. Conventional PTC emerged as the most prevalent pathology, accounting for 239 (45.0%) of the cases. Patients with thyromegaly exhibited significantly higher incidences of nonmalignant tumors (p = 0.01), while those with malignant tumors were notably younger than those with nonmalignant tumors (p = 0.001).

Conclusion

Our study revealed a progressive rise in the number of patients undergoing thyroidectomy over the years, with PTC constituting the majority of cases. Malignant cases were more frequently observed in younger patients, and in smaller lesion sizes, highlighting the importance of early screening and optimizing detection methods, especially in high-risk populations.

The two-year prognosis of multinodular goiter following radiofrequency ablation: based on all nodule burdens

OBJECTIVE

Few studies used all nodule burdens to specify the prognosis of multinodular goiter (MNG) following radiofrequency ablation (RFA), so this study addresses this question for MNG after completely ablating dominant nodules.

METHODS

The RFA indications for MNG included a total of 2-5 benign nodules with over 50% normal tissue on ultrasound, 1-3 well-defined benign dominant nodules on cytology, largest diameter ≥20 mm and/or with clinical complaints, and patient refusal or unable of surgery. A retrospective study of 185 MNG patients with completely ablated dominant nodules in a single-session RFA was conducted. The efficacy and complications were evaluated at 1, 6, 12 months and yearly thereafter. Based on retreatment risks, progressive disease (PD), stable disease (SD) and complete relief (CR) were introduced to assess all nodule load changes. PD was clarified as having new/non-target nodules newly appeared to ACR TI-RADS≥4, or new/enlarged non-target nodules ≥1 cm.

RESULTS

The initial ablation ratios of target nodules were 100% at one month. During a mean 22.38±13.75 months (range, 12-60 months), the VRR of ablated nodules was 98.25% at 24 months without regrowth. Cosmetic and symptomatic scores decreased to 1 and 0, respectively, after 48 months. 9.7% of patients (18/185) had PD and the retreatment rate was 2.2% (4/185). The complication rate was 2.7% (5/185).

CONCLUSIONS

RFA provides cosmetic and symptomatic relief for an average of two years. RFA is an useful minimally invasive treatment modality for selected MNG patients.

Total vs less than total thyroidectomy for benign multinodular non-toxic goiter: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

We have performed an updated meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCT) comparing total thyroidectomy (TT) with less than total thyroidectomy (LTT) for benign multinodular non-toxic goiter (BMNG).

OBJECTIVES

The objective was to evaluate the effects and outcomes of TT as compared to LTT.

METHODS

Eligibility criteria: RCTs comparing TT vs LTT.

INFORMATION SOURCES

PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library and online registers were searched for articles comparing TT with LTT. Risk of bias: Articles were assessed for risk of bias using the Cochrane's revised tool to assess risk of bias in randomized trials (RoB 2 tool).

SYNTHESIS OF RESULTS

The main summary measures were risk difference using a random effects model.

RESULTS

Five randomized controlled trials were included in the meta-analysis. Recurrence rate was lower for TT compared to LTT. Adverse events like temporary or permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) palsy and permanent hypoparathyroidism were similar in both groups except for the rate of temporary hypoparathyroidism which was lower in the LTT group.

DISCUSSION

All studies had unclear risk of bias for blinding of the participants and personnel and high risk of bias for certain selective reporting. This meta-analysis did not show any clear benefit or harm of either procedure (TT vs LTT) for goiter recurrence and re-operation rates (for both recurrence and incidental thyroid cancer). However, re-operation for goiter recurrence was significantly higher in the LTT group based on a single RCT. Evidence suggests increased rates of temporary hypoparathyroidism with TT but there was no difference in the rate of RLN palsy and permanent hypoparathyroidism between the two methods. The overall quality of evidence was low to moderate.

Total thyroidectomy for giant nodular goiter guided by pre-operative 3D computed tomography reconstruction and 3D printing: A case report

BACKGROUND

Nodular goiter is a common clinical problem, and thyroidectomy is preferred in patients with obstructive symptoms. Thyroidectomy is a complex procedure with some common complications. Three-dimensional (3D) computed tomography (CT) reconstruction and 3D printing provide visualized 3D anatomical structure, posing an enormously valuable potential in precise surgery with optimal efficacy and minimum complications. Here, we aimed to perform a precise thyroidectomy guided by this technology.

METHODS

The patient was an 80-year-old woman with 10 years of goiter, 1 year of labored dyspnea, and a history of thyroid surgery 62 years ago. In addition to ultrasonography examination, CT images were obtained to construct the 3D model to identify the 3D relationship between the lesion and adjacent structures, and a 3D model of the trachea was created and printed using a 3D printer.

RESULTS

The 3D model clearly presented the diffuse enlargement of the two lobes and isthmus and the compression of the goiter. Under the 3D guidance, the operative resection specimen of the right lobe and isthmus was 12 ´ 7 ´ 5 cm, whereas the left lobe specimen was 12 ´ 9 ´ 6 cm. Nodular goiter and lymphocytic thyroiditis were confirmed by postoperative histopathology. There were no complications after total thyroidectomy except for non-permanent hypocalcemia and hypoparathyroidism.

CONCLUSION

Our results proved that total thyroidectomy for giant goiter is challenging, and 3D image-guided thyroidectomy facilitates precise and safe resection with fewer complications. 3D CT reconstruction and 3D printing can provide anatomical details and may be considered in thyroidectomy planning for patients with giant goiter.

Non-Toxic Multinodular Goiter: From Etiopathogenesis to Treatment

Goiter term is generally used for defining the enlargement of thyroid gland. Thyroid nodules are very common and some of these nodules may harbor malignancy. Multinodular goiter (MNG) disease without thyroid dysfunction is defined as non-toxic MNG. There are many factors in etiology for development of MNG. They can be classified as iodine dependent and non-iodine dependent factors basically. Beyond this basic classification, the effect of many environmental and acquired factors is also effective on the development of goiter. Many methods have described for diagnosis and treatment for non-toxic MNG. Biochemical tests, imagining methods, invasive and non-invasive methods have been used for diagnosis for many years. Each method has advantages and disadvantages, separately. Although the best method for diagnosis is still debatable, distinguishing malignant nodules from benign nodules is the first and most important step for MNG. Biochemical tests such as serum thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) measurement, thyroid hormone measurement; and thyroid ultrasonography are used for diagnosis of MNG, traditionally. Nowadays, there are some new techniques were developed like ultrasound-elastography. Furthermore, thyroid scintigraphy may be used if there is abnormal TSH measurement. Fine-needle aspiration biopsy and some cross-sectional imaging methods (computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, and positron emission tomography) could be used, too. After a certain diagnosis is made, treatment options should be evaluated. Many treatment methods have been used for goiter from ancient times upon today. From non-invasive methods such as medical follow-up to invasive methods such as lobectomy or thyroidectomy are options for treatment. Patients with compression symptoms due to an enlarged thyroid gland are usually candidates for surgery. In this study, it is aimed to determine the most appropriate treatment for the patient by discussing the advantages and disadvantages of all these methods. The present review discusses definition of goiter term, etiology, epidemiology, pathogenesis, diagnostic methods, and treatment methods for nontoxic MNG.

Current approach to surgical management of hyperthyroidism

Hyperthyroidism is a set of disorders that involve excess synthesis and secretion of thyroid hormones by the thyroid gland, which leads to thyrotoxicosis. The most common forms of hyperthyroidism include diffuse toxic goiter (Graves' disease), toxic multinodular goiter (Plummer disease), and a solitary toxic adenoma. The most reliable screening measure of thyroid function is the thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) level. Options for treatment of hyperthyroidism include: antithyroid drugs, radioactive iodine therapy (the preferred treatment of hyperthyroidism among US thyroid specialists), or thyroidectomy. Massive thyroid enlargement with compressive symptoms, a suspicious nodule, Graves' orbitopathy, and patient preference are indications for surgical treatment of thyrotoxicosis. This paper reviews the current literature and controversies on the surgical approach to the management of hyperthyroidism.

The Impact of Regional Variation in Clinical Practice on Thyroid Cancer Diagnosis: A National Population-Based Study

OBJECTIVE

Regional variation in thyroid cancer incidence in Belgium, most pronounced for low risk cancer, was previously shown to be related to variation in clinical practice, with higher thyroid surgery rates and lower proportions of preoperative fine-needle aspiration (FNA) in regions with high thyroid cancer incidence (period 2004-2006). The objective of this study was to investigate regional thyroid cancer incidence variation in relation with variation in thyroid surgery threshold in a more recent Belgian thyroid cancer cohort.

METHODS

A population-based cohort of thyroid cancer patients that underwent a (near) total thyroidectomy in the period 2009-2011 (n = 2,329 patients) was identified and studied by linking data from the Belgian cancer registry and the Belgian health insurance companies, and case-by-case study of the pathology protocols. The execution of preoperative FNA and the thyroid resection specimen weight were compared between high and low thyroid cancer incidence regions. Thyroid weight in the pT1a-restricted group was studied as a proxy for surgical threshold for benign nodular goiter. Furthermore, time trend analyses were performed for the execution of FNA for the period 2004-2012.

RESULTS

Although a lower proportion of FNA in the high thyroid cancer incidence region persisted in the period 2009-2011 (41.2% [31.9-50.9] vs. 72.9% [64.9-79.7] in the low-incidence region (LIR), p < 0.001), a positive time trend was observed for the period 2004-2012. The median thyroid surgical specimen weight was lower in the high incidence region compared to the LIR (27.0 g [IQR 18.0-45.3] vs. 36.0 g [IQR 22.0-73.0], p < 0.0001), and this finding was corroborated in the pT1a-restricted group.

CONCLUSION

Interregional differences in use of FNA and surgical thyroid specimen weight are consistent with an inverse relation between thyroid cancer incidence and thyroid surgery threshold, carrying risk for overdiagnosis.

Hemithyroidectomy for benign euthyroid asymmetric nodular goitre

BACKGROUND

There is no consensus on the optimal surgery extent for patients with benign euthyroid asymmetric nodular goitre (AMNG).

METHODS

We reviewed medical literature using the PubMed engine to address the following issues: definition and prevalence, rationale for hemithyroidectomy, long-term outcomes, follow-up, revision surgery and image-guided thermal ablation of contralateral benign thyroid nodules following hemithyroidectomy for AMNG.

RESULTS

In total, 102 articles were found in MEDLINE using a keyword search strategy; subsequently, we selected 36 articles with clinical pertinence.

CONCLUSIONS

AMNG is a common clinical and surgical problem. Depending on the extent of the disease and individual surgeon preferences, either unilateral or bilateral thyroidectomy can be performed. Hemithyroidecomy can be considered for some patients with AMNG and the low risk of recurrent disease as a safer alternative to total thyroidectomy but it requires life-long follow-up, is associated with a higher recurrence risk and a need for revision thyroidectomy in selected subjects.

Visual and electrophysiological identification of the external branch of superior laryngeal nerve in redo thyroid surgery compared with primary thyroid surgery

Purpose

Thyroid reoperations are surgically challenging because of significant anatomical variance. Visual and functional identification of the external branch of the superior laryngeal nerve (EBSLN) were studied in 2 groups of patients who underwent primary and redo thyroid surgery.

Methods

This study was conducted on 200 patients: 100 patients with redo and 100 patients with primary thyroid surgery. In addition to visual identification, nerve branches were functionally identified by intraoperative nerve monitoring (IONM). Visual, functional, and total identification rates of the EBSLN in both primary and redo surgery were determined and compared between the 2 groups.

Results

We attempted to identify 138 and 170 EBSLNs at risk in redo and primary surgery, respectively. Visual identification rates were 65.3% and 30.4% (P < 0.001) in primary and redo surgery groups, respectively. In total, 164 (96.5%) and 97 EBSLNs (70.3%) were identified in primary and redo surgery, respectively (P < 0.001), including the use of IONM. In primary surgery group, 53 nonvisualized EBSLNs of 164 identified nerves (32.3%) were determined by IONM alone. In redo surgery group, 55 of 97 identified nerves (56.7%) were determined by IONM alone (P < 0.001).

Conclusion

Both visual and total identification rates of the EBSLN are significantly decreased in reoperative thyroidectomy. IONM increases the total identification rate of the EBSLN in primary and redo thyroid surgery. Electrophysiological monitoring makes a substantial contribution to the identification of the EBSLN both in primary and especially in redo thyroid surgery.

European Perspective on 2015 American Thyroid Association Management Guidelines for Adult Patients with Thyroid Nodules and Differentiated Thyroid Cancer: Proceedings of an Interactive International Symposium

BACKGROUND

The American Thyroid Association (ATA) management guidelines for patients with thyroid nodules and differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) are highly influential practice recommendations. The latest revision appeared in 2015 ("ATA 2015"). These guidelines were developed predominantly by North American experts. European experts frequently have different perspectives, given epidemiological, technological/methodological, practice organization, and medicolegal differences between the respective regions.

SUMMARY

Divergent viewpoints were the focus of an invited symposium organized by the European Association of Nuclear Medicine involving 17 European thyroidologists, four ATA Guidelines Taskforce members, and an audience of 200 international experts. The group discussed the preoperative assessment of thyroid nodules, surgery and the role of pathology, radioiodine (RAI) therapy (RAIT), the assessment of initial therapy and dynamic risk stratification, and the treatment of persistent disease, recurrences, and advanced thyroid cancer. The dialogue resulted in this position paper contrasting European and ATA 2015 perspectives on key issues. One difference pertains to the permissiveness of ATA 2015 regarding lobectomy for primary tumors ≤4 cm. European panelists cited preclusion of RAIT, potential need for completion thyroidectomy, frequent inability to avoid chronic thyroid hormone replacement, and limitations of supportive evidence as arguments against widely applying lobectomy. Significant divergence involved ATA 2015's guidance regarding RAIT. European panelists favored wider use of postoperative RAIT than does ATA 2015. Rationales included the modality's association with favorable patient outcomes and generally limited toxicity, and lack of high-quality evidence supporting withholding RAIT. Additionally, European panelists favored recombinant human thyrotropin (rhTSH) in more settings than does ATA 2015, citing avoidance of hypothyroid morbidity and quality-of-life impairment, without apparent sacrifice in oncologic outcomes. Based on clinical evidence plus theoretical advantages, European experts advocated dosimetric versus fixed-activity RAIT approaches for advanced DTC. European panelists noted that the ATA 2015 risk-stratification system requires information sometimes unavailable in everyday practice. ATA 2015 recommendations regarding RAI-refractory DTC should consider potential palliative benefits of RAIT in patients who also have RAI-susceptible lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

European panelists suggested modifications to approximately one-third of ATA 2015 recommendations. Varying European and ATA 2015 perspectives can stimulate analysis and discussion of the literature and performance of primary research to resolve discrepant recommendations and potentially improve patient outcomes.

Unilateral benign multinodular versus solitary goiter: Long-term contralateral reoperation rates after lobectomy

BACKGROUND

Few long-term studies define the appropriate extent of surgery and recurrence rates for unilateral multinodular goiter. We compared the rate and time to reoperation in patients with multinodular goiter who underwent lobectomy to that of patients with benign solitary nodule.

METHODS

Retrospective study of a prospective database of all patients who underwent lobectomy for multinodular goiter or solitary nodule from 1991 to 2017. We analyzed reoperation rates and time to reoperation. Reoperation was defined as the need for completion thyroidectomy determined the following citeria: nodule greater than 3 cm, multiple nodules, nodule growth or suspicion for malignancy by ultrasound or fine-needle aspiration biopsy, or compressive symptoms.

RESULTS

Included in the study were 2,675 lobectomies; 852 (31.85%) for multinodular goiter. In total, 394 patients (14.7%) underwent reoperation: 261 (30.6%) with a previous multinodular goiter and 133 (7.29%) with solitary nodule (P < .0001). A total of 80% of the patients with multinodular goiter and 67.66% with solitary nodule recurred as multinodular goiter; 3.5% of all recurrences were carcinomas. The mean time to reoperation was 14.8 years, without difference between groups (P = .5765). Patients without reoperation were younger (47 ± 15 vs 54 ± 13 years of age, P < .0001) and more likely to be male (P < .0001).

CONCLUSION

Lobectomy for unilateral multinodular goiter is the procedure of choice given the length of time to reoperation. Patients and surgeons should be aware of the need for long-term surveillance.

Nontoxic Multinodular Goitre and Incidental Thyroid Cancer: What Is the Best Surgical Strategy?-A Retrospective Study of 2032 Patients

OBJECTIVES

A discussion with regard to the most optimal surgical procedure in nontoxic multinodular goitre (NTMNG). We assessed and compared three main types of operations in 2032 patients with NTMNG.

METHODS

This is a retrospective study of 2032 patients operated on in one center due to NTMNG. The observation period was 48 to 120 months (mean and SD: 87 ± 20).

RESULTS

The early complications included uni- and bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis (URLNP, BRLNP), overt tetany (OT), and postoperative bleeding (POB). We observed after TT, STT, and DO URLNP: 15 (1.73%), 3 (0.64%), and 2 (0.28%), respectively (p < 0.05); BRLNP: 3 (0.34%), 2 (0.43%), and 0 (0.0%), respectively (p = 0.25); OT: 42 (4.84%), 6 (1.29%), and 9 (1.28%), respectively (p < 0.0001); and POB: 11 (1.26%), 4 (0.86%), and 3 (0.42%), respectively (p = 0.209). Persistent complications we observed after TT, STT, and DO are the following: URLNP: 9 (1.03%), 3 (0.64%), and 1 (0.14%), respectively (p = 0.086); BRLNP: 1 (0.11%), 1 (0.21%), and 0 (0.0%), respectively (p = 0.51); and OT: 11 (1.26%), 2 (0.43%), and 2 (0.28%), respectively (p = 0.052). Incidental thyroid cancer (ITC) was recognized after TT, STT, and DO in 18 (2.07%), 21 (4.52%), and 11 (1.56%), respectively (p = 0.039). Recurrent goitre (RG) was observed in 1 (0.11%) after TT, 3 (0.64%) after STT, and 2 (0.28%) after DO (p = 0.234).

CONCLUSIONS

Performing less radical surgery in NTMNG is associated with a significantly lower risk of early and late URLNP and OT. In the case of BRLNP (early and persistent) and POB, no statistically significant differences are seen. The occurrence of ITC is higher following more radical surgeries. Less radical surgery is connected with a higher risk of RG.