Bridging knee arthrodesis for limb salvage using an intramedullary cemented nail: a retrospective outcome analysis of a case series

Transfemoral amputation versus knee arthrodesis for failed total knee replacement: A systematic review of outcomes

BACKGROUND

The options available to salvage a failed total knee replacement (TKR) include transfemoral amputation (TFA) and knee arthrodesis (KA). This systematic review aims to evaluate outcomes following either TFA or KA, comparing ambulatory status, additional subsequent surgery, postoperative infection, pain, health-related quality of life (HRQoL), and mortality rate.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted in EMBASE, Ovid Medline, and PubMed. Only primary research studies were included and data were independently extracted using a standardized form. The methodological quality of the studies was evaluated using Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.

RESULTS

Forty-four papers were included, comprising 470 TFA and 1034 KA patients. The methodological quality of the studies was moderate. No TFA versus KA randomized controlled trials could be identified. Pooled data totals via subgroup analyses were performed, owing to inconsistent reporting methods in the included studies. Prosthesis use rate by TFA patients was 157/316 = 49.7%. Significant differences included that TFA patients had lower rates of ambulatory capacity than KA patients (139/294 = 45.6% versus 248/287 = 86.4%, p < 0.001), TFA ambulators were less likely to use an ambulatory aid (55/135 = 40.7% versus 167/232 = 72.0%, p < 0.001), and TFA was associated with a greater postoperative infection rate than KA (29/118 = 24.6% versus 129/650 = 17.2%, p = 0.054). There was a similar rate of revision surgery between TFA and KA (37/183 = 20.2% versus 145/780 = 18.6%, p = 0.612). Data on HRQoL for both TFA and KA were limited, contradictory, and heterogeneous.

CONCLUSION

No randomized controlled trials comparing TFA versus KA exist;therefore, current data likely reflects substantial selection bias. The currently available evidence suggests that KA patients are significantly more likely to achieve independent bipedal ambulation than TFA patients. In both treatment cohorts, subsequent infection and revision surgery remain a relatively common occurrence.

Floating Knee Arthrodesis After Prosthetic Knee Infection: A Report of 48 Cases

BACKGROUND

Knee arthrodesis is a means of avoiding above-knee amputation after a prosthetic joint infection (PJI). The objective of this study was to analyze the results of floating knee arthrodesis in patients who had a history of aprosthetic knee infection. The analysis consisted of determining reinfection rates, functional results, and the survival of arthrodesis.

METHODS

There were 48 patients who underwent a cemented floating knee arthrodesis in cases of PJI retrospectively included in the study, having been operated on between 2012 and 2020. In addition to being evaluated clinically, analytically, and radiographically, the patients were assessed functionally by means of a newly-created scale.

RESULTS

At a mean follow-up of 4 years (1 year to 9 years), 7 patients suffered reinfection (14.6%). The recurrence of infection was not observed to be significantly affected by sex (P = .16), age(P = .09), or the type of surgery previously undergone (P = .18), nor was the McPherson Host Grade (P = .4) observed to have a significant effect. Patients who had a McPherson Limb Grade 3 were more likely to suffer reinfection than those with a McPherson Limb Grade 2 (P = .034). There were 26 patients (54%)fully evaluated and scored on the Knee Arthrodesis Functional Scale(BAOR). For 11 patients (42%), the results were evaluated as excellent, for 11 (42%) acceptable, for 3 (12%) low, and for 1(4%) poor.

CONCLUSION

The arthrodesis nail is an effective and safe procedure for patients who have a recurrent PJI, providing an effective alternative when the criteria for a new revision total knee arthroplasty are not met.

Knee arthrodesis using a custom modular intramedullary nail in failed, infected knee arthroplasties: A concise follow-up note of 31 cases at a median of 13 years post-arthrodesis

INTRODUCTION

Knee arthrodesis utilizes an arthrodesis nail as a salvage technique for infected total knee arthroplasty (TKA), especially when the extensor mechanism is damaged, or the skin is compromised. This implant helps to minimize or prevent leg length discrepancy, while allowing immediate weight bearing without requiring bone fusion. However, there is a risk of infection. Surgical revisions were required in 19% of patients at 50 months' follow-up in our team's initial 31-patient case series. Since there is little long-term outcome data, we reviewed this same group of patients after a mean of 13 years to determine: (1) the implant's long-term survival, (2) the functional outcomes, (3) the microbiological changes in revision cases.

HYPOTHESIS

The long-term survival of knee arthrodesis using an arthrodesis nail for failed infected TKA is acceptable.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Thirty-one patients operated on between January 2005 and December 2008 were retrospectively included in the initial study. The functional outcomes consisted of pain on a visual analog scale (VAS), neuropathic pain (DN4) and the Oxford Knee Score. All surgical revisions were documented with repeat microbiology samples.

RESULTS

The median follow-up time was 13.1 years [11.5-13.5]. No mechanical failure (implant failure or aseptic loosening) was observed. Eight patients were re-operated on due to new infections. The nail had to be removed in five of these patients. None of the patients required an amputation. Among the eight patients who were re-operated on, only two (25%) had been re-operated on since the initial study and underwent a two-stage arthrodesis revision. At 10 years, the cumulative incidence of surgical revision at the knee was 26% [95% CI: 12%-43%] and 16% [95% CI: 5.7%-31%] for an implant change. Six (75%) of the re-operated patients had their revision within the first 72 months of the initial TKA, while 4 (50%) had it within the first 26 months. Among the 15 patients who were still alive, the median Oxford Knee Score was 17/48 [12-28]. At the final assessment, the median pain level was 0 [0-5], although 4 of the 10 analyzable patients (of the 15 living patients, 3 had a cognitive impairment and 2 refused to participate) had neuropathic pain and pain on VAS of 3/10. The microbiologic findings were the same during the surgical revision in five of the eight re-operated patients (62%); however, one patient who had a Staphylococcus aureus infection had acquired a resistance to methicillin. In one patient, only one of the two bacteria identified initially was still present (methicillin-susceptible Coagulase-negative staphylococci [CNS]) and while in two patients, the infectious agent changed completely (shift from Gram-negative bacilli to methicillin-susceptible CNS, and the opposite for the other patient).

DISCUSSION

Knee arthrodesis with a custom modular intramedullary nail is a viable limb salvage option in failed infected TKA cases with long-term survival, and it is comparable to other arthrodesis techniques. In most cases, recurrence of the infection occurred in the short term (<72 months). Later recurrences of the infection (>72 months) were rarer and were found in only two of our patients (6%). There were no mechanical failures.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV; Retrospective cohort study.

Knee Arthrodesis With an Intramedullary Antegrade Rod as a Salvage Procedure for the Chronically Infected Total Knee Arthroplasty

Infection is a challenging complication after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) that is often treatable. However, recurrent infection may require resection, amputation, or arthrodesis. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of antegrade nailing with an intramedullary rod for the treatment of a chronically infected TKA.

Two-Stage Arthrodesis after an Infected Total Knee Replacement Using a Coupled Nail and Dual-Plate Construct: A Third-World Solution and Review of Options

Infection following total knee arthroplasty is a serious and increasingly common complication. Several treatment options are available. Although a two-stage revision remains the gold standard, salvage procedures are sometimes needed. We describe a case of an infected knee arthroplasty that was salvaged using a novel technique combining two linked intramedullary nails and bilateral compression plating.

Conversion of cemented revision total knee prostheses to arthrodesis using custom-made arthrodesis modules that preserve the cemented stem anchorage in patients with long-established extensor mechanism insufficiency: A case series

INTRODUCTION

Long-established extensor mechanism insufficiency that defies reconstruction is a rare, but devastating, complication after revision total knee arthroplasty (RTKA) that may require arthrodesis. For cemented stem guided knee prostheses with firmly attached stems, prosthesis explantation can lead to significant bone stock loss that may, at worst, make knee arthrodesis significantly more difficult or impossible to achieve. Under these circumstances, conversion of the cemented knee prosthesis with custom-made arthrodesis modules that preserve the existing stem anchorage may be a low-risk alternative. This case series presents this type of conversion to arthrodesis, which was performed for patients with a non-reconstructable, long-established extensor mechanism insufficiency.

METHODS

After intraoperatively ascertaining that reconstruction of the extensor mechanism insufficiency was impossible, the inlying revision prosthesis was converted into arthrodesis with custom-made arthrodesis modules, without explanting the cemented stems.

RESULTS

Conversion to arthrodesis was performed in four patients. There was no histopathological or microbiological evidence of a periprosthetic joint infection. Clinical follow-up showed a low level of pain, with a stable knee joint and proper implant position. The Oxford Knee Score increased from 20.5 (95% CI 17-26) to 35.5 (95% CI 30-36) points. The visual analog scale decreased from 5.5 (95% CI 4-7) pre-operatively to 1.5 (95% CI 1-2) points at last follow-up. No implant-specific complications occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

Conversion of cemented RTKA with firmly attached cemented stems, without evidence of loosening, to arthrodesis might be a surgical treatment strategy for patients with a long-established extensor mechanism insufficiency that cannot be reconstructed.

Two-stage knee arthrodesis with a modular intramedullary nail due to septic failure of revision total knee arthroplasty with extensor mechanism deficiency

BACKGROUND

Periprosthetic joint infection is a serious complication and reconstruction after failed revision total knee arthroplasty with significant bone loss and compromised soft-tissues can be challenging. Objective of this study was to assess clinical and functional results, implant survival and infection recurrence rates in patients treated with two-stage arthrodesis after failed revision TKA with extensor mechanism deficiencies due to PJI, and to identify the factors that affect outcomes after surgery.

METHODS

Thirty seven patients with PJI treated within a two-stage exchange and reimplantation of an arthrodesis nail between 2008 and 2014 were included. Systemic and local risk factors were graded preoperatively according to McPherson et al. All patients were treated according to a structured treatment algorithm. Clinical and functional evaluation was performed using the Oxford Knee Score and the Visual Analogue Scale.

RESULTS

Thirty two of 37 patients (86.5%) were graded as free of infection. Five patients (13.5%) had recurrent infection after arthrodesis with the need of revision surgery. Mean leg-length discrepancy was 2.2cm. The mean VAS for pain was three, the mean Oxford Knee Score was 38±9. Total implant survival at a 74month follow-up was 74.3% (95% CI: 45.4 to 91.1%), as determined by Kaplan-Meier survival curves. Local McPherson Score, as well as number of revisions was found to be of significant influence to the survival rate.

CONCLUSIONS

Septic failure of revision knee arthroplasty can be effectively treated with two-stage arthrodesis using a modular intramedullary nail, providing a stable and painless limb with satisfactory functional results and acceptable infection eradication rates.

Arthroscopic-assisted Arthrodesis of the Knee Joint With the Ilizarov Technique: A Case Report and Literature Review

Arthrodesis of the knee joint is a mainly a salvage surgical procedure performed in cases of infected total knee arthroplasty, tumor, failed knee arthroplasty or posttraumatic complication.The authors report the case of 18-year-old male with posttraumatic complication of left knee because of motorbike accident 1 year before. He was treated immediately after the injury in the local Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology. The examination in the day of admission to our department revealed deformation of the left knee, massive scar tissue adhesions to the proximal tibial bone and multidirectional instability of the knee. The plain radiographs showed complete lack of lateral compartment of the knee joint and patella. The patient complained of severe instability and pain of the knee and a consecutive loss of supporting function of his left limb. The authors decided to perform an arthroscopic-assisted fusion of the knee with Ilizarov external fixator because of massive scar tissue in the knee region and the prior knee infection.In the final follow-up after 54 months a complete bone fusion, good functional and clinical outcome were obtained.This case provides a significant contribution to the development and application of low-invasive techniques in large and extensive surgical procedures in orthopedics and traumatology. Moreover, in this case fixation of knee joint was crucial for providing good conditions for the regeneration of damaged peroneal nerve.

No improvement in the post-TKA infection prognosis when the implant is not reimplanted: Retrospective multicentre study of 72 cases

INTRODUCTION

For the surgeon and patient, permanent removal of an infected knee prosthesis is an unwelcome decision taken out of necessity because unfavourable local or general conditions may increase the likelihood of mechanical or infectious failure upon prosthesis reimplantation. The purpose of this study was to determine if permanent removal of an infected total knee arthroplasty (TKA) implant controls the infection and prevents above-the-knee amputation when reimplantation turns out to be too risky. It was hypothesized that removal without reimplantation contributes to eradicating the infection and helps to avoid amputation.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Seventy-two consecutive patients who underwent TKA removal between 2000 and 2010 at 14 hospitals were reviewed. The TKA removal was followed by knee fusion in 29 cases or implantation of a permanent cement spacer in 43 cases.

RESULTS

If failure is defined as clinically obvious recurrence of the infection, the survival rate was 65 ± 5% at 2 years; 44% of patients had a recurrence of the infection, 8% had undergone amputation and 19% presented with nonunion at the last follow-up. The male gender and the presence of multiple co-morbidities were predisposing factors for failure.

DISCUSSION

Control of the infection is not guaranteed upon TKA implant removal; the success rate is lower than in cases of two-stage reimplantation. The outcomes in this study are worse than those of other published studies. This is likely due to the heterogeneity in the patient population and treatments, along with the presence of co-morbidities. This treatment option should be the last recourse before amputation.

Septic single-stage knee arthrodesis after failed total knee arthroplasty using a cemented coupled nail

Knee arthrodesis is a potential salvage procedure for limb preservation after failure of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) due to infection. In this study, we evaluated the outcome of single-stage knee arthrodesis using an intramedullary cemented coupled nail without bone-on-bone fusion after failed and infected TKA with extensor mechanism deficiency. Between 2002 and 2012, 27 patients (ten female, 17 male; mean age 68.8 years; 52 to 87) were treated with septic single-stage exchange. Mean follow-up duration was 67.1months (24 to 143, n = 27) (minimum follow-up 24 months) and for patients with a minimum follow-up of five years 104.9 (65 to 143,; n = 13). A subjective patient evaluation (Short Form (SF)-36) was obtained, in addition to the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS). The mean VAS score was 1.44 (SD 1.48). At final follow-up, four patients had recurrent infections after arthrodesis (14.8%). Of these, three patients were treated with a one-stage arthrodesis nail exchange; one of the three patients had an aseptic loosening with a third single-stage exchange, and one patient underwent knee amputation for uncontrolled sepsis at 108 months. All patients, including the amputee, indicated that they would choose arthrodesis again. Data indicate that a single-stage knee arthrodesis offers an acceptable salvage procedure after failed and infected TKA.

Salvage of infected intramedullary knee arthrodesis with vascularized free fibula and staged fixation

Intramedullary knee arthrodesis is indicated when an infected total knee arthroplasty revision is failed. There is a high risk of infection after this procedure and the only option of treatment considered in these cases is AK amputation. We present an alternative to AK amputation in intramedullary arthrodesis infected cases that has been successful in all patients we have treated. From 2008 to 2012 five patients (4 men and one woman) were treated. The treatment protocol was staged: (1) debridement, removing intramedullary implant and cement, PMMa as spacer and placement of a double-frame external fixator. Gastrocnemius flap was used when there was a significant cutaneous defect. (2) Removing PMMa and transfer a contralateral free fibular osteocutaneous flap. (3) Change external fixation for an internal fixation. There was no mortality associated to the treatment protocol. There were no septic complications after the first and second stages. Two patients developed deep infection after the third stage. One patient developed stress fracture of the fibular flap. All cases showed integration of the fibular bone six to eight months postoperatively. Limb shortening was 3.8cm on average. All patients were able to walk independently with one crutch. In conclusion, although our series is short to export results, our protocol treatment is a good alternative to AK amputation. The treatment entails at least three major surgical procedures through a protracted period of time, but the avoidance of an AK amputation seems worth the risk in a fully informed and compliant patient.

[Arthrodesis without bone fusion with an intramedullary modular nail for revision of infected total knee arthroplasty]

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the outcome of knee fixation without bone fusion using an intramedullary modular nail and interposed cement.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Retrospective study of 29 infected total knee arthroplasties with prospective data collection and a mean follow-up of 4.2 years (3-5).

RESULTS

Complications included 2 recurrent infections, 1 peri-implant fracture, and 1 cortical erosion due to the tip of the femoral component. All of these were revised with successful results. The mean limb length discrepancy was 0.8 cm, with 24<1cm. Twenty-five patients reported no pain. The mean WOMAC-pain was 86.9, WOMAC-function 56.4, SF12-physical 45.1, and SF12-mental 53.7. Four patients needed a walking frame, and only two were dependent for daily activities.

CONCLUSIONS

The Endo-Model Link nail is an effective method for knee fixation that restores the anatomical alignment of the limb with adequate leg length.

Success of different knee arthrodesis techniques after failed total knee arthroplasty: is there a preferred technique?

Arthrodesis is a widely accepted treatment for failed total knee arthroplasty when further revision is contraindicated. In this study, we retrospectively review the pre-operative characteristics, operation techniques, treatment plans, and eventual outcomes in 42 consecutive patients (43 knees) who underwent knee arthrodesis at a single institution. Femorotibial fusion was achieved in 30 cases (75.0%). No cases of implant failure were recorded. Post-operative complications occurred in 20 cases (46.5%). Repeat arthrodesis was performed in 4 cases, and 2 patients eventually required above-the-knee amputation. Comparing the cases with successful vs. unsuccessful outcomes, there was a significant difference in days until hospital discharge following arthrodesis (P = .026), mean erythrocyte sedimentation rate prior to arthrodesis (P = .012), and the proportion of patients with post-operative wound complications (P = .021).

Cementless modular intramedullary nail without bone-on-bone fusion as a salvage procedure in chronically infected total knee prosthesis: long-term results

PURPOSE

Our purpose was to evaluate long-term results of two-stage cementless intramedullary nailing without achieving bone-to-bone fusion for treating chronically infected total knee arthroplasty (TKA).

METHODS

Thirty-eight patients treated according to the same protocol were retrospectively evaluated for clinical, functional, laboratory and radiological outcomes.

RESULTS

Spacer exchange was necessary for infection persistence in one case. At a minimum two year follow-up, 34 patients (89.5%) showed no infection recurrence; among these 34 patients, 29 (85.3%) reported no or moderate pain [visual analogue scale (VAS) ≤3]; mild to moderate handicap (Lequesne Algofunctional Index < 7.5) was observed in 18 patients (52.9%). No patient underwent revision for aseptic loosening, and no nail breakage was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Two-stage cementless intramedullary nailing without achieving bone-to-bone fusion is a viable option for treating chronically infected TKA in selected, complex cases.

Arthrodesis in septic knees using a long intramedullary nail: 17 consecutive cases

BACKGROUND

Intramedullary nailing using long or modular nails is the most reliable mean of achieving femorotibial fusion. Here, we report the operative, clinical, functional, and radiological outcomes of 17 long intramedullary nail arthodeses in patients with infection.

HYPOTHESIS

Clinical and functional outcomes after long intramedullary nailing are at least as good as those obtained using other implants.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively reevaluated 17 patients after unilateral two-stage knee arthrodesis with a long titanium intramedullary nail and autologous bone grafting. We evaluated satisfaction, leg length discrepancy, and function (Lequesne and WOMAC indices). Radiographs were obtained to assess fusion, time to fusion, and femorotibial angles.

RESULTS

No cases of material failure were recorded. One or more complications occurred in seven patients. Mean limb shortening was 27.6mm. Of the 17 patients, 15 were satisfied with the procedure. The mean Lequesne index was 10.5/24 and the mean overall WOMAC score was 26/88. Fusion was achieved in 16 patients, with a mean time to fusion of 5 months. Mean femorotibial angles were 178.6° of varus and 1.9° of flexion.

DISCUSSION

This simple and rapid surgical technique provides functional outcomes similar to those obtained using modular nails. The fusion rate is high. Nail extraction is simple and causes minimal damage, in contrast to modular nails. Increased attention to misalignment is needed.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, retrospective study.