Weak link of tendon-bone healing and a control experiment to promote healing

Hyperbaric oxygen therapy enhances graft healing and mechanical properties after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: An experimental study in rabbits

Hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT) has proven successful in wound healing. However, its potential effects on anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries remain uncertain. This study aimed to investigate the impact of HBOT on graft healing following ACL reconstruction in rabbits. Male New Zealand rabbits underwent ACL reconstruction and were randomly divided into two groups: the HBOT group and the ambient air group. The HBOT group received 100% oxygen at 2.5 atmospheres absolute for 2 h daily for 5 consecutive days, starting from the first day after surgery. The ambient air group was maintained in normal room air throughout the entire period. After 12 weeks following the surgery, animals were euthanized, and their knees were harvested for analysis. The HBOT group demonstrated superior graft maturation and integration in comparison to the ambient air group, as evidenced by lower graft signal intensity on magnetic resonance imaging, decreased femoral and tibial tunnel size, and higher bone mineral density values on high-resolution peripheral quantitative computed tomography scans. Additionally, biomechanical testing indicated that the HBOT group had greater load to failure and stiffness values than the ambient air group. In conclusion, the adjuvant use of HBOT improved ACL graft maturation and integration, reduced tunnel widening, and enhanced the biomechanical properties of the graft. These results may provide important insights into the potential clinical application of HBOT as a therapeutic intervention to enhance graft healing after ACL reconstruction, paving the way for further research in this area.

Synthetic grafts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery

The quest for a good and durable substitute to anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is driving scientists to explore new promising areas of research. Autologous and allogenic ligament reconstruction bring satisfactory results in managing ACL surgery although their use is associated with significant drawbacks. To overcome the limitations of biologic grafts, many artificial devices have been developed and implanted as a substitute to the native ACL over the past decades. Although many synthetic grafts used in the past have been withdrawn from the market due to early mechanical failures ultimately leading to synovitis and osteoarthritis, there is recently a resurgence of interest in the use of synthetic ligaments for ACL reconstruction. However, this new generation of artificial ligaments, despite promising initial results, have shown to produce serious side effects such as high rupture rates, insufficient tendon-bone healing and loosening. For these reasons, recent advancements in biomedical engineering are focusing on improving technical features of artificial ligaments combining mechanical properties to biocompatibility. Bioactive coatings and surface modification methods have been proposed to enhance synthetic ligament biocompatibility and promote osseointegration. The path to the development of a safe and effective artificial ligament is still full of challenges, however recent advancements are leading the way towards a tissue-engineered substitute to the native ACL.

Strategies to promote tendon-bone healing after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: Present and future

At present, anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction still has a high failure rate. Tendon graft and bone tunnel surface angiogenesis and bony ingrowth are the main physiological processes of tendon-bone healing, and also the main reasons for the postoperative efficacy of ACL reconstruction. Poor tendon-bone healing has been also identified as one of the main causes of unsatisfactory treatment outcomes. The physiological process of tendon-bone healing is complicated because the tendon-bone junction requires the organic fusion of the tendon graft with the bone tissue. The failure of the operation is often caused by tendon dislocation or scar healing. Therefore, it is important to study the possible risk factors for tendon-bone healing and strategies to promote it. This review comprehensively analyzed the risk factors contributing to tendon-bone healing failure after ACL reconstruction. Additionally, we discuss the current strategies used to promote tendon-bone healing following ACL reconstruction.

BMSC-derived exosomes promote tendon-bone healing after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction by regulating M1/M2 macrophage polarization in rats

Background

Recent studies have shown that bone marrow stromal cell-derived exosomes (BMSC-Exos) can be used for tissue repair. However, whether the BMSC-Exos can promote tendon-bone healing after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) is still unclear. In this study, we observed in vivo and in vitro the effect of rat BMSC-Exos on tendon-bone healing after ACLR and its possible mechanism.

Methods

Highly expressed miRNAs in rat BMSC-Exos were selected by bioinformatics and verified in vitro. The effect of overexpressed miRNA in BMSC-Exos on M2 macrophage polarization was observed. A rat model of ACLR was established. The experimental components were divided into three groups: the control group, the BMSC-Exos group, and the BMSC-Exos with miR-23a-3p overexpression (BMSC-Exos mimic) group. Biomechanical tests, micro-CT, and histological staining were performed for analysis.

Results

Bioinformatics analysis showed that miR-23a-3p was highly expressed in rat BMSC-Exos and could target interferon regulatory factor 1 (IRF1, a crucial regulator in M1 macrophage polarization). In vitro, compared with the control group or the BMSC-Exos group, the BMSC-Exos mimic more significantly promoted the polarization of macrophages from M1 to M2. In vivo, at 2 weeks, the number of M2 macrophages in the early local stage of ACLR was significantly increased in the BMSC-Exos mimic group; at 4 and 8 weeks, compared with the control group or the BMSC-Exos group, the bone tunnels of the tibia and femur sides of the rats in the BMSC-Exos mimic group were significantly smaller, the interface between the graft and the bone was narrowed, the bone volume/total volume ratio (BV/TV) increased, the collagen type II alpha 1 level increased, and the mechanical strength increased.

Conclusions

BMSC-Exos promoted M1 macrophage to M2 macrophage polarization via miR-23a-3p, reduced the early inflammatory reaction at the tendon-bone interface, and promoted early healing after ACLR.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13287-022-02975-0.

Biological modulations to facilitate graft healing in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR), when and where to apply? A systematic review

Background

When and where to apply the biological modulations is effective to promote healing in the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction remains unclear.

Purpose

To perform a systematic review of preclinical animal studies on biological modulation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) concerning the time and site of delivery.

Study design

Systematic review of controlled laboratory studies.

Methods

PubMed, Ovid, and Scopus were searched until December 2020 using a combination of keywords and their synonym to retrieve all animal studies about biological modulation in ACLR. Studies that assessed mechanical strength after ACLR and compared with negative control were included. The methodological quality of animal studies was evaluated.

Results

33 studies were included in this review and the majority reported mechanical strength improvement. 79 ​% of studies applied the biological modulations intra-operatively with different delivery systems used. For 21 ​% of post-operative delivery studies, intermittent delivery was tried. 21 of the included studies directly applied the biological modulations in the bone tunnels, 5 studies applied intra-articularly while 7 studies applied both in the bone tunnels and intra-articular part. Biological modulations applied intra-operatively and those applied in both parts showed better mechanical strength increase. A shift of the failure mode of pull-out from the bone tunnel in the early healing phase, to mid-substance rupture in the later phase was observed in most studies.

Conclusion

The improvement of the mechanical strength depends on how the biological modulations (delivery phase, delivery site, delivery form) are applied. The intra-operative delivery showed an overall higher mechanical strength increase and bone tunnel only delivery or intra-articular and bone tunnel both delivery are preferred than intra-articular only delivery. In addition, intra-articular and bone tunnel both delivery can have better mechanical strength increase for a long follow-up time. Thus, intra-operative application with a carrier to control release rate in both parts should be recommended. Further studies are needed to achieve a better healing outcome and more attention should be given to the intra-articular remodeling of the graft along with the tendon bone healing to increase the final mechanical strength.

The Translational potential of this article

Here, a systematic review of preclinical evidence of the time, site and the method the biological modulations being applied for ACLR to improve the graft healing would be performed. After reviewing the available studies, a choice of when and where to apply the biological modulations can achieve better mechanical strength after ACLR can be obtained. It provides evidence for both researchers and clinicians to decide when and where to apply the biological modulations can achieve their best effectiveness for ACLR before implementing. Promoting graft healing with targeted time and targeted site may reduce the risk of graft failure, safeguard return to sport.

Effect of Demineralized Bone Matrix, Bone Marrow Mesenchymal Stromal Cells, and Platelet-Rich Plasma on Bone Tunnel Healing After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Comparative Micro-Computed Tomography Study in a Tendon Allograft Sheep Model

Background:

The effect of demineralized bone matrix (DBM), bone marrow–derived mesenchymal stromal cells (BMSCs), and platelet-rich plasma (PRP) on bone tunnel healing in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) has not been comparatively assessed.

Hypothesis:

These orthobiologics would reduce tunnel widening, and the effects on tunnel diameter would be correlated with tunnel wall sclerosis.

Study Design:

Controlled laboratory study.

Methods:

A total of 20 sheep underwent unilateral ACLR using tendon allograft and outside-in interference screw fixation. The animals were randomized into 4 groups (n = 5 per group): Group 1 received 4mL of DBM paste, group 2 received 10 million BMSCs in fibrin sealant, group 3 received 12 mL of activated leukocyte-poor platelet-rich plasma, and group 4 (control) received no treatment. The sheep were euthanized after 12 weeks, and micro-computed tomography scans were performed. The femoral and tibial tunnels were divided into thirds (aperture, midportion, and exit), and the trabecular bone structure, bone mineral density (BMD), and tunnel diameter were measured. Tunnel sclerosis was defined by a higher bone volume in a 250-µm volume of interest compared with a 4-mm volume of interest surrounding the tunnel.

Results:

Compared with the controls, the DBM group had a significantly higher bone volume fraction (bone volume/total volume [BV/TV]) (52.7% vs 31.8%; P = .020) and BMD (0.55 vs 0.47 g/cm³; P = .008) at the femoral aperture and significantly higher BV/TV at femoral midportion (44.2% vs 32.9%; P = .038). There were no significant differences between the PRP and BMSC groups versus controls in terms of trabecular bone analysis or BMD. In the controls, widening at the femoral tunnel aperture was significantly greater than at the midportion (46.7 vs 41.7 mm²; P = .034). Sclerosis of the tunnel was common and most often seen at the femoral aperture. In the midportion of the femoral tunnel, BV/TV (r = 0.52; P = .019) and trabecular number (r_S = 0.50; P = .024) were positively correlated with tunnel widening.

Conclusion:

Only DBM led to a significant increase in bone volume, which was seen in the femoral tunnel aperture and midportion. No treatment significantly reduced bone tunnel widening. Tunnel sclerosis in the femoral tunnel midportion was correlated significantly with tunnel widening.

Clinical Relevance:

DBM might have potential clinical use to enhance healing in the femoral tunnel after ACLR.

Combination of graphene oxide and platelet-rich plasma improves tendon-bone healing in a rabbit model of supraspinatus tendon reconstruction

The treatment of rotator cuff tear is one of the major challenges for orthopedic surgeons. The key to treatment is the reconstruction of the tendon-bone interface (TBI). Autologous platelet-rich plasma (PRP) is used as a therapeutic agent to accelerate the healing of tendons, as it contains a variety of growth factors and is easy to prepare. Graphene oxide (GO) is known to improve the physical properties of biomaterials and promote tissue repair. In this study, PRP gels containing various concentrations of GO were prepared to promote TBI healing and supraspinatus tendon reconstruction in a rabbit model. The incorporation of GO improved the ultrastructure and mechanical properties of the PRP gels. The gels containing 0.5 mg/ml GO (0.5 GO/PRP) continuously released transforming growth factor-β1 (TGF-β1) and platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF)-AB, and the released TGF-β1 and PDGF-AB were still at high concentrations, ∼1063.451 pg/ml and ∼814.217 pg/ml, respectively, on the 14th day. In vitro assays showed that the 0.5 GO/PRP gels had good biocompatibility and promoted bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells proliferation and osteogenic and chondrogenic differentiation. After 12 weeks of implantation, the magnetic resonance imaging, micro-computed tomography and histological results indicated that the newly regenerated tendons in the 0.5 GO/PRP group had a similar structure to natural tendons. Moreover, the biomechanical results showed that the newly formed tendons in the 0.5 GO/PRP group had better biomechanical properties compared to those in the other groups, and had more stable TBI tissue. Therefore, the combination of PRP and GO has the potential to be a powerful advancement in the treatment of rotator cuff injuries.

Electrodeposition of calcium phosphate onto polyethylene terephthalate artificial ligament enhances graft-bone integration

It is a big challenge to develop a polyethylene terephthalate (PET) artificial ligament with excellent osteogenetic activity to enhance graft-bone integration for ligament reconstruction. Herein, we evaluated the effect of biomineralization (BM) and electrodeposition (ED) method for depositing calcium-phosphate (CaP) on the PET artificial ligament in vitro and in vivo. Scanning electron microscopy and energy-dispersive X-Ray spectrometer mapping analysis revealed that the ED-CaP had more uniform particles and element distribution (Ca, P and O), and thermogravimetric analysis showed there were more CaP on the PET/ED-CaP than the PET/BM-CaP scaffold. Moreover, the hydrophilicity of PET scaffolds was significantly improved after CaP deposition. In vitro study showed that CaP coating via BM or ED method could improve the attachment and proliferation of MC3T3-E1 cells, and ED-CaP coating significantly increased osteogenic differentiation of the cells, in which the Wnt/β-catenin signaling pathway might be involved. In addition, radiological, histological and immunohistochemical results of in vivo study in a rabbit anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction model demonstrated that the PET/BM-CaP and PET/ED-CaP scaffolds significantly improved graft-bone integration process compared to the PET scaffold. More importantly, larger areas of new bone ingrowth and the formation of fibrocartilage tissue were observed at 12 weeks in the PET/ED-CaP group, and the biomechanical tests showed increased ultimate failure load and stiffness in PET/ED-CaP group compared to PET/BM-CaP and PET group. Therefore, ED of CaP is an effective strategy for the modification of PET artificial ligament and can enhance graft-bone integration both in vitro and in vivo.

Osteoprotegerin/bone morphogenetic protein 2 combining with collagen sponges on tendon-bone healing in rabbits

INTRODUCTION

The aim was to investigate the effect of collagen sponges (CS) as a delivery device for osteoprotegerin (OPG)/bone morphogenetic protein 2 (BMP-2) and support matrix on the tendon-bone healing after anterior crusicate ligament (ACL) reconstruction in modeled rabbits.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sixty New Zealand white rabbits were randomly divided into four groups based on treatments they received at the tendon-bone interface after left knee ACL reconstruction: the control group, OPG/BMP-2, CS, and OPG/BMP-2/CS combination. At 4, 8 and 12 weeks post-surgery, five rabbits from each group were euthanized to examine the tendon-bone healing. Levels of OPG and BMP-2 in synovial fluid, the bone tunnel enlargement value, the histomorphological typing of tendon-bone interface, and the bone tunnel area of the tendon-bone interface were compared among different treatments.

RESULTS

The OPG/BMP-2/CS combination treatment group had the highest levels of OPG and BMP-2 in synovial fluid (both P < 0.05), the greatest number of Sharpey-like collagen fibers at all test points (P < 0.05), the most fibrocartilage enthesis on week 12, the greatest bone tunnel area (P < 0.05), and the greatest decrease in bone tunnel enlargement on week 12 (P < 0.05). Histomorphological typing of tendon-bone interface of all groups showed changes varying from tendon-bone separation to firm healing, and the change was most significant in the OPG/BMP-2/CS combination treatment group.

CONCLUSION

CS treatment alone serves as a fixing support, and CS combining with growth factors OPG/BMP-2 ensures slow and stable release of OPG/BMP-2, significantly improves the tendon-bone healing in the rabbit ACL model.

Stem Cell-Conditioned Medium Promotes Graft Remodeling of Midsubstance and Intratunnel Incorporation After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction in a Rat Model

BACKGROUND

Stem cell-conditioned medium (CM) has been increasingly used in regenerative medicine. However, its effect on graft-host integration after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR) remains unclear.

PURPOSE

To examine the effect of human bone marrow stem cell (hBMSC)-CM on graft-bone integration and graft midsubstance ligamentization in a rat model of ACLR.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

CM was obtained from the supernatant of commercially available hBMSCs in serum-free Dulbecco's modified Eagle medium (DMEM). In a rat model of an ACL injury, isometric ACLR was performed. Three groups were established: CM injection group (CM; n = 40), control injection group (CI; n = 40) with serum-free DMEM injections, and no injection group (NI; n = 40). An intra-articular injection was performed weekly. Micro-computed tomography was conducted at 2, 4, and 8 weeks postoperatively. Histological and biomechanical analyses were conducted at 4 and 8 weeks postoperatively. The NIH3T3 fibroblast was utilized as a model in vitro to examine the effect of CM using the cell counting kit-8 (CCK-8) assay and immunofluorescence staining of Ki-67, α-smooth muscle actin (α-SMA), and collagen 1 (Col 1).

RESULTS

At 4 and 8 weeks, the femoral and tibial bone tunnel areas as well as the interface between the graft and host bone were smaller, while the bone volume/total volume ratio was higher, in the CM group. Sharpey-like fibers formed at 8 weeks in the CM group. At 4 and 8 weeks, more Col 1 was noticed in the CM group than in the NI group (both P < .001) or CI group (both P < .001). Immunohistochemically, the α-SMA-positive area was up-regulated at the graft-bone interface at 4 weeks (P < .001) and declined at 8 weeks (P < .001) in the CM group compared with the other 2 groups. At the midsubstance, α-SMA expression decreased from 4 to 8 weeks in all groups and was significantly lower in the CM group than in the NI group (P < .01) or CI group (P < .05) at 8 weeks. The CCK-8 assay showed that CM increased NIH3T3 viability (P < .001) and the level of Ki-67 (P < .05), α-SMA (P < .001), and Col 1 (P < .001) in CM-educated NIH3T3 cells.

CONCLUSION

hBMSC-CM accelerates graft-bone incorporation and midsubstance ligamentization and enhances the proliferation, differentiation, and collagen synthesis of fibroblasts.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Graft-host integration is essential after ACLR. The current study identified a novel agent, that is, hBMSC-CM, as a candidate for promoting integration.

Biological augmentation of graft healing in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review

Aims

The success of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) depends on osseointegration at the graft-tunnel interface and intra-articular ligamentization. Our aim was to conduct a systematic review of clinical and preclinical studies that evaluated biological augmentation of graft healing in ACLR.

Materials and Methods

In all, 1879 studies were identified across three databases. Following assessment against strict criteria, 112 studies were included (20 clinical studies; 92 animal studies).

Results

Seven categories of biological interventions were identified: growth factors, biomaterials, stem cells, gene therapy, autologous tissue, biophysical/environmental, and pharmaceuticals. The methodological quality of animal studies was moderate in 97%, but only 10% used clinically relevant outcome measures. The most interventions in clinical trials target the graft-tunnel interface and are applied intraoperatively. Platelet-rich plasma is the most studied intervention, but the clinical outcomes are mixed, and the methodological quality of studies was suboptimal. Other biological therapies investigated in clinical trials include: remnant-augmented ACLR; bone substitutes; calcium phosphate-hybridized grafts; extracorporeal shockwave therapy; and adult autologus non-cultivated stem cells.

Conclusion

There is extensive preclinical research supporting the use of biological therapies to augment ACLR. Further clinical studies that meet the minimum standards of reporting are required to determine whether emerging biological strategies will provide tangible benefits in patients undergoing ACLR. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2018;100-B:271-84.

Effects of tendon-bone healing of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction by osteoprotegerin combined with deproteinized bovine bone

Background

The healing of a tendon graft in a bone tunnel depends on bone ingrowth into the interface between tendon and bone, or that can enhance tendon-bone healing, which is important to reduce the failure rate after ACL reconstruction.

Methods

Sixty skeletally mature, New Zealand white rabbits underwent left ACL reconstruction. OPG/DBB compound (concentration ratio of 30%, 60%, 100%) was delivered to the tendon-bone interface with use of a DBB carrier, and nothing as control group. Twenty animals were killed at 4, 8 and 12 weeks after surgery. I-IV levels of semi-quantitative and Sharpey fibers at the healing tendon-bone interface were evaluated, and the biomechanical properties were tested.

Results

A significantly greater amount of Sharpey fibers at the healing tendon-bone interface in the concentration ratio of 100% OPG/DBB-treated group was found compared with the others at all time-points (P<0.05), and it is the same to the Grade Scores at 12 weeks (P<0.05). The femur-ACL-tibia complex of the concentration ratio of 100% OPG/DBB-treated group has significantly increased stiffness compared with the others at 12 weeks (P<0.05).

Conclusion

The concentration ratio of 100% OPG/DBB compound significantly improve bone formation around the grafted tendon and improve the stiffness at the healing tendon-bone junction in a rabbit model.

Biological enhancement of graft-tunnel healing in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

The sites where graft healing occurs within the bone tunnel and where the intra-articular ligamentization process takes place are the two most important sites of biological incorporation after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, since they help to determine the mechanical behavior of the femur-ACL graft-tibia complex. Graft-tunnel healing is a complex process influenced by several factors, such as type of graft, preservation of remnants, bone quality, tunnel length and placement, fixation techniques and mechanical stress. In recent years, numerous experimental and clinical studies have been carried out to evaluate potential strategies designed to enhance and optimize the biological environment of the graft-tunnel interface. Modulation of inflammation, tissue engineering and gene transfer techniques have been applied in order to obtain a direct-type fibrocartilaginous insertion of the ACL graft, similar to that of native ligament, and to accelerate the healing process of tendon grafts within the bone tunnel. Although animal studies have given encouraging results, clinical studies are lacking and their results do not really support the use of the various strategies in clinical practice. Further investigations are therefore needed to optimize delivery techniques, therapeutic concentrations, maintenance of therapeutic effects over time, and to reduce the risk of undesirable effects in clinical practice.

Comparison of different femoral fixation implants and fit techniques for tunnel widening and clinical outcome in ACL reconstruction using hamstring autograft

PURPOSE

The purpose of the current study is to investigate in different femoral fixation devices whether tight (undersize drilled) fit technique decreases the tunnel widening and improves the clinical outcome compared to conventional technique in ACL reconstruction using hamstring tendon autograft.

METHODS

93 patients, who underwent Arthroscopic ACL reconstruction whether cortical-cancellous suspension (CP) or cortical suspension (BF) used as fixation device for the hamstring tendon autograft, were included in the study. The cases also grouped as undersize drilled (tight fit) and normal drilled (normal fit) according to their autograft size. There was no difference in demographic data of these four subgroups (CP-TF, CP-NF, BF-TF, and BF-NF) preoperatively.

RESULTS

The patients, who had been followed for at least 2 years were included in the study. They were looked for their clinical outcome (Lysholm and IKDC scoring), tunnel widening (on AP and lateral radiographs), and also anterior translation. The BF-TF subgroup showed significantly the best clinical results compared to other three subgroups. There was no difference between BF-TF, CP-TF, and CP-NF in terms of tunnel widening.

CONCLUSION

Button fixation of femoral side in ACL reconstruction surgery has good clinical outcome and lower complication rate. Undersize drilling might be preferred in button fixation in order to reduce TW and improve stability and clinical satisfaction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic case series, Level IV.

New and emerging strategies in platelet-rich plasma application in musculoskeletal regenerative procedures: general overview on still open questions and outlook

Despite its pervasive use, the clinical efficacy of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) therapy and the different mechanisms of action have yet to be established. This overview of the literature is focused on the role of PRP in bone, tendon, cartilage, and ligament tissue regeneration considering basic science literature deriving from in vitro and in vivo studies. Although this work provides evidence that numerous preclinical studies published within the last 10 years showed promising results concerning the application of PRP, many key questions remain unanswered and controversial results have arisen. Additional preclinical studies are needed to define the dosing, timing, and frequency of PRP injections, different techniques for delivery and location of delivery, optimal physiologic conditions for injections, and the concomitant use of recombinant proteins, cytokines, additional growth factors, biological scaffolds, and stems cells to develop optimal treatment protocols that can effectively treat various musculoskeletal conditions.

Systematic Review of Biological Modulation of Healing in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Background:

Whether biological modulation is effective to promote healing in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction remains unclear.

Purpose:

To perform a systematic review of both clinical and experimental evidence of preclinical animal studies on biological modulation to promote healing in ACL reconstruction.

Study Design:

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 2.

Methods:

A systematic search was performed using the PubMed, Ovid, and Scopus search engines. Inclusion criteria were clinical and animal studies involving subjects with ACL injury with the use of biological modulation to promote healing outcomes. Methodological quality of clinical studies was evaluated using the Critical Appraisal Skill Programme (CASP) appraisal tool, and animal studies were evaluated by a scoring system based on a published checklist of good animal studies.

Results:

Ten clinical studies and 50 animal studies were included. Twenty-five included studies were regarded as good quality, with a methodological score ≥5. These studies suggested that transforming growth factor–beta (TGF-β), mesenchymal stem cells, osteogenic factors, and modalities that reduce local inflammation may be beneficial to promote graft healing in ACL reconstruction.

Conclusion:

This systematic review suggests that biological modulation is able to promote healing on top of surgical treatment for ACL injuries. This treatment strategy chiefly works through promotion of healing at the tunnel-graft interface, but the integrity of the intra-articular midsubstance of the graft would be another target for biological modulation.