Tonsillotomy: facts and fiction

Tonsillectomy Versus Tonsillotomy in Pediatric Sleep-Disordered Breathing: A Systematic Review and Multi-subgroup Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the potential of tonsillotomy (TT) as an alternative to tonsillectomy (TE) for treating children with obstructive sleep-disordered breathing (oSDB).

DATA SOURCES

Two independent reviewers searched PubMed, the Cochrane Library, Embase, and additional sources to identify controlled studies comparing TT versus TE in pediatric patients with oSDB.

REVIEW METHODS

We evaluated post-surgery symptom relief, and short- and long-term postoperative benefits for children. Fixed-effect meta-analysis, sensitivity analysis, and subgroup analysis were conducted.

RESULTS

In our analysis of 32 studies with 9,430 children, the analysis revealed TT group had a similar therapeutic effect on improvement of OSA-18 as TE group (MD = 5.20, 95% CI: -32.67 to 43.07, p = 0.96). In terms of short-term outcome, the days to return to normal diet for TT group were shorter than that for TE group (MD = -2.49, 95%CI: -3.57 to -1.28; p < 0.001), less analgesics use (MD = -3.19, 95% CI = -3.44 to -2.93, p < 0.001), and lower postoperative secondary bleeding (RR = 0.33; 95%CI: 0.23 to 0.47; p < 0.001). But the risk of reoperation (OR = 8.28; 95%CI: 2.66 to 12.64; p < 0.001), oSDB recurrence (OR = 2.16; 95%CI: 1.20-3.86; p = 0.01), and postoperative infection (OR = 1.82; 95%CI: 1.34 to 2.47; p < 0.001) in TT group was significantly higher than that in TE group.

CONCLUSIONS

Tonsillotomy reduces postoperative pain and bleeding, speeding up recovery for children with oSDB, and improving their quality of life. Yet, the risk of recurrent infections from residual tonsil tissue, which may require reoperation, calls for a careful evaluation of the procedure's short-term gains against its long-term risks.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 135:529-539, 2025.

Long-term effectiveness of tonsillotomy versus tonsillectomy: A 12-year follow-up study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the long-term effectiveness of tonsillotomy (TT) compared to tonsillectomy (TE) with respect to disease-specific quality of life (QOL), sleep-disordered breathing symptoms, throat infections, and rate of reoperations over a median follow-up period of 12 years.

METHODS

All patients < 16 years of age who underwent tonsil surgery between 2010 and 2011 at Helsinki University Hospital, Finland, were included in the study. In 2023, the patients answered a questionnaire concerning tonsil-related issues and a modified Tonsil and Adenoid Health Status Instrument (disease-specific QOL). Information about possible revisits and reoperations was gathered.

RESULTS

The study population consisted of 189 respondents, of which 87 had undergone TT and 102 TE. The median follow-up was 11.8 years in the TT group and 12.4 years in the TE group. The disease-specific QOL was equally good in both groups. Throat infections had not been an issue for the vast majority of patients and occurred to the same extent after TT and TE. The majority of participants (79.0% TT, 86.9% TE) were satisfied with the surgery, with no significant differences between the groups. After TT and TE, there were only a few revisits due to tonsil-related problems, and the reoperation rate was 6.9% and 1.0%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Long-term clinical effectiveness of TT seems excellent. Compared to TE, with TT, equal disease-specific QOL can be achieved with a less invasive surgical method. Over a median follow-up period of 12-years, TT was not shown to be associated with an increased risk of tonsil infection problems.

Total versus subtotal tonsillectomy for recurrent tonsillitis: 5-year follow up of a prospective randomized noninferiority clinical trial

PURPOSE

In long-term follow-up, it remains uncertain whether tonsillectomy, a procedure associated with significant comorbidity, can be substituted with partial tonsillectomy in patients with recurrent tonsillitis. This paper is to present the 5-year follow-up data of our previous study titled "Total versus subtotal tonsillectomy for recurrent tonsillitis-a prospective randomized noninferiority clinical trial."

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The underlying study was performed as single-blinded prospective noninferiority procedure in patients with recurrent chronic tonsil infection, where one side was removed completely (tonsillectomy) and the other side partially (intracapsular/partial tonsillectomy). Five years after surgery, we collected data on the frequency of tonsillitis in the first, second, third, fourth, and fifth year post-surgery. We obtained assessments from patients, their ENT physicians, and general practitioners separately. To assess the impact of surgical therapy on overall quality of life, we employed the Glasgow Benefit Inventory (GBI).

RESULTS

Out of the 111 patients initially included in the years 2015-2018, 79 were eligible for the 5-year follow-up, representing a 71% follow-up rate. The mean follow-up time was 60 months. Notably, during the first 12 months post-surgery, no cases of bacterial inflammation were observed in the remaining tonsillar tissue following partial tonsillectomy, suggesting noninferiority compared to total tonsillectomy. This effect remained consistent over the 5-year study period. GBI results indicate that both total and partial tonsillectomy positively impact the physical and mental health of patients with recurrent tonsillitis.

CONCLUSION

Considering that partial tonsillectomy is associated with less pain and reduced postoperative bleeding, it may emerge as a potential replacement for total tonsillectomy as the standard method in the future.

The efficacy of perioperative antibiotic therapy in adenotonsillectomy children

PURPOSE

To evaluate the role of perioperative antibiotics use in children after adenotonsillectomy.

METHODS

SPSS 27.0 was used for statistical analysis. Two independent samples mean T test was used to evaluate the throat pain scores consecutive 3 days after the surgery, the time to resume to normal diet, and the wound healing time. Logistic regression analysis was used to evaluate the independent risk factors of the two groups. The generalized estimation model was used to evaluate the correlation between age and postoperative pain scores, and the relationship between different tonsillar bed gradings and postoperative pain scores.

RESULTS

The pain scores were 5.83 ± 1.879, 5.20 ± 1.933, and 4.02 ± 1.936 in the observation group; and 6.83 ± 1.892, 6.17 ± 2.001, and 5.29 ± 2.068 in the control group on days 1-3 after surgery, respectively. The time of pain disappearance was 6.24 ± 2.121 days in the observation group and 7.73 ± 2.210 days in the control group. The wound repair time was 18.66 ± 2.200 days in the observation group and 18.70 ± 2.468 days in the control group. Logistic regression analysis showed that fever was an independent risk factor for the two groups and was negatively correlated (B =  - 1.237, P < 0.001, OR = 0.290). Generalized estimation model showed that there was a positive correlation between age and pain scores (P < 0.001), and with the increasing grading of tonsillar bed, the higher the pain scores was (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Perioperative use of antibiotics in children with adenotonsillectomy can effectively reduce postoperative fever, throat pain symptoms, and shorten the pain time. With the increasing of tonsillar bed grading, perioperative antibiotic therapy was more necessary.

Comparison of three common tonsil surgery techniques: cold steel with hot hemostasis, monopolar and bipolar diathermy

PURPOSE

To analyze the risk of postoperative hemorrhage in tonsil surgery with different surgical methods, instruments, indications, and age groups. Monopolar diathermy compared to bipolar diathermy was of particular interest.

METHODS

The data from tonsil surgery patients were retrospectively collected between 2012 and 2018 in the Hospital District of Southwest Finland. The surgical method, instruments, indication, sex and age and their association with a postoperative hemorrhage were analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 4434 patients were included. The postoperative hemorrhage rate for tonsillectomy was 6.3% and for tonsillotomy 2.2%. The most frequently used surgical instruments were monopolar diathermy (58.4%) cold steel with hot hemostasis (25.1%) and bipolar diathermy (6.4%) with the overall postoperative hemorrhage rates 6.1%, 5.9% and 8.1%, respectively. In tonsillectomy patients, the risk for a secondary hemorrhage was higher with bipolar diathermy compared to both monopolar diathermy (p = 0.039) and the cold steel with hot hemostasis technique (p = 0.029). However, between the monopolar and the cold steel with hot hemostasis groups, the difference was statistically non-significant (p = 0.646). Patients aged > 15 years had 2.6 times higher risk for postoperative hemorrhage. The risk of a secondary hemorrhage increased with tonsillitis as the indication, primary hemorrhage, tonsillectomy or tonsillotomy without adenoidectomy, and male sex in patients aged ≤ 15 years.

CONCLUSION

Bipolar diathermy increased the risk for secondary bleedings compared to both monopolar diathermy and the cold steel with hot hemostasis technique in tonsillectomy patients. Monopolar diathermy did not significantly differ from the cold steel with hot hemostasis group regarding the bleeding rates.

Adenotonsillotomy versus adenotonsillectomy in pediatric obstructive sleep apnea: A 5-year RCT

Objectives

Adenotonsillectomy (ATE) is a common treatment for pediatric obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). Intracapsular adenotonsillotomy (ATT) is associated with less postoperative morbidity. Our previous randomized controlled trial (RCT) compared ATE and ATT in otherwise healthy children with moderate to severe OSA. No differences in polysomnographic (PSG) and OSA-18 were found between the groups at one-year follow-up. This study presents the long-term results of the RCT.

Methods

Non-obese children (n = 79, 2–6 years) who had undergone either ATE (n = 40) or ATT (n = 39) were offered PSG and OSA-18 questionnaire five-years after surgery. Primary outcome was the group difference in postoperative Obstructive Apnea/Hypopnea Index (OAHI). ATE was recommended to the ATT group if they had a relapse of OSA.

Results

The follow-up was completed by 45 of 79 (57%) children; 28 (35%) drop-outs, and six of 39(15%) in the ATT group were excluded after ATE. After ATE(n = 17), OAHI decreased from mean 12.3(SD 8.0) to 0.6(0.7), and after ATT(n = 28) from 12.6(7.4) to 0.5(0.6), a mean difference in postoperative OAHI of 0.1(95% CI -0.3 – 0.5). Sensitivity analyses did not change the results. The median OSA-18 decreased in the ATE group from 57(interquartile range 47–79) to 27(22–36), and in the ATT group from 67(53–79) to 32(25–44), without group differences for postoperative values.

Conclusion

The results of this five-year follow-up of otherwise healthy OSA-children showed a high drop-out rate, but indicates that ATT could be an effective treatment for pediatric OSA. However, ATT warrants follow-up due to the risk of recurrence, and further studies are needed.

•

Adenotonsillotomy is an effective treatment for Obstructive sleep apnea in otherwise healthy children.

•

Six children out of 39 were reoperated with adenotonsillectomy within three years.

•

Follow-up after adenotonsillotomy is recommended.

Erwägungen zur Durchführung und Qualitätssicherung ambulanter Operationen im HNO-Bereich in Deutschland

Hintergrund Die deutsche Gesundheitspolitik hat eine Ausweitung ambulanter Operationen und Verfahren propagiert und die Diskussion darüber eingeleitet. Die HNO-Heilkunde bietet Möglichkeiten, derzeit stationär durchgeführte Eingriffe ambulant zu erbringen.

Methoden Die Deutsche Gesellschaft für HNO-Heilkunde, Kopf- und Hals-Chirurgie und der Deutsche Berufsverband der HNO-Ärzte haben Arbeitsgruppen ins Leben gerufen, die die HNO-fachlichen Aspekte der Leistungsverlagerungen in den ambulanten Bereich beurteilen und bewerten sollen. Die Arbeitsgruppen bekamen den Auftrag dabei organisatorische, strukturelle und personelle Definitionen der Qualitätssicherung zu erarbeiten und zu berücksichtigen.

Empfehlung Es wurden ausführlich Tatbestände bestimmt, die eine ambulante Operation im HNO-Fachgebiet ausschließen. Grundlage bildeten hierbei sowohl operationsbedingte als auch patientenbedingte Tatbestände. Schließlich wurden Operationen benannt, die als ambulante Operationen durchgeführt werden können.

Diskussion Es erfolgte eine HNO-fachliche Bewertung. Voraussetzung für eine Ambulantisierung ist eine Neuordnung der Vergütung. Das bisherige DRG- und EBM-System bieten hierzu keinen befriedigenden Rahmen, der EBM ermöglicht keine wirtschaftliche Erbringung operativer Eingriffe im HNO-Bereich. Die Entwicklung eines adäquaten Finanzierungsmodells ist für einen Erfolg der Umsetzung genauso zwingend erforderlich wie die Integration und Finanzierung der HNO-ärztlichen Weiterbildung.

Intracapsular tonsillectomy in the treatment of recurrent and chronic tonsillitis in adults: a protocol of a prospective, single-blinded, randomised study with a 5-year follow-up (the FINITE trial)

INTRODUCTION

The standard surgical treatment for recurrent or chronic tonsillitis is extracapsular tonsillectomy. Recent studies show that intracapsular tonsillectomy has the potential to reduce the postoperative morbidity of patients undergoing tonsil surgery. The Finnish Intracapsular Tonsillectomy (FINITE) trial aims to provide level I evidence to support the hypothesis that the recovery time from tonsil surgery can be reduced with intracapsular tonsillectomy. Additionally, from this trial, major benefits in quality of life, reduction of postoperative complications, treatment costs and throat symptoms might be gained.

METHODS AND ANALYSIS

The FINITE trial is a prospective, randomised, controlled, patient-blinded, three-arm clinical trial. It is designed to compare three different surgical methods being extracapsular monopolar tonsillectomy versus intracapsular microdebrider tonsillectomy versus intracapsular coblation tonsillectomy in the treatment of adult patients (16-65 years) suffering from recurrent or chronic tonsillitis. The study started in September 2019, and patients will be enrolled until a maximum of 200 patients are randomised. Currently, we are in the middle of the study with 125 patients enrolled as of 28 February 2022 and data collection is scheduled to be completed totally by December 2027. The primary endpoint of the study will be the recovery time from surgery. Secondary endpoints will be the postoperative pain scores and the use of analgesics during the first 3 weeks of recovery, postoperative haemorrhage, quality of life, tonsillar remnants, need for revision surgery, throat symptoms, treatment costs and sick leave. A follow-up by a questionnaire at 1-21 days and at 1, 6, 24 and 60 months will be conducted with a follow-up visit at the 6-month time point.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

Ethical approval was obtained from the Medical Ethics Committee of the Hospital District of Southwest Finland (reference number 29/1801/2019). Results will be made publicly available in peer-reviewed scientific journals.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT03654742.

Safety and long-term efficacy of tonsillectomy versus subtotal tonsillectomy in children with sleep disordered breathing

OBJECTIVES

to compare safety and long-term symptoms after TE compared to Subtotal Tonsillectomy (STT).

METHODS

A retrospective review data of 412 patients, one to twelve years old that underwent either TE or STT, as treatment for sleep disorder breathing, at two different medical centers. Symptoms were assessed by a questionnaire 3-5 years post-surgery. Additionally, data regarding immediate post-operative symptoms and complications were also collected.

RESULTS

Long-term symptoms score was significantly lower in the TE group: 1.585 (±1.719) compared to 1.967 (±1.815) in the STT group (p = 0.033); 51.3% of patients in the ST group presented long-term SDB symptoms, compared to 40.6% in the TE group (p = 0.035); The main difference between the groups was snoring as 49% of the STT group suffered from snoring, versus 28.9% in the TE group (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

TE showed an advantage over STT in resolving snoring in the long term.

Do tonsils regrow after partial tonsillectomy? - Histology of regrown tonsils and predisposing factors for tonsillar regrowth

OBJECTIVES

It has been suggested that after partial tonsillectomy, referred here as tonsillotomy (TT), the remaining tonsillar tissue might be altered, leading to scarring or chronic tonsillitis. The objectives were to compare the histology of regrown tonsillar tissues with native tonsils and to assess the incidence of reoperations and predictive factors for tonsillar regrowth after TT.

METHODS

Tonsillar tissues of 1) children that underwent TT and later requiring resurgery and 2) children operated on for the first time with TT were prospectively analysed. To assess the incidence of resurgery because of tonsillar regrowth and predictive factors for tonsillar regrowth, the data covering TTs and tonsillectomies performed in 2009-2020 were retrospectively retrieved.

RESULTS

Altogether 11 children formed the regrowth group, with the control group consisting of 19 children. In the histological analysis of tonsillar tissues, neutrophil infiltration in the epithelium and crypts and severe lymphoplasmacytic infiltration in the epithelium were significantly more frequent in samples of the regrowth group relative to the control group. The number of germinal centres was greater in the regrowth group. In the retrospective analysis of 3141 children, the incidence of resurgery after primary TT was 1.9%. Logistic regression analysis showed that age was the only significant predisposing factor for resurgery.

CONCLUSION

Inflammatory cells were present more often in regrown tonsillar tissues but there was no evidence of severe chronic inflammation or scarring in the regrown tonsils. The risk of resurgery after TT was low. Young age predisposed to tonsillar regrowth, no other risk factors were found.

Pediatric Obstructive Sleep Apnea: Update for the Primary Care Provider

Pediatric obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is a common entity that can cause both daytime and nighttime issues. Children with symptoms should be screened for OSA. If possible, polysomnography should be performed to evaluate symptomatic children. Depending on the severity, first-line options for treatment of pediatric OSA may include observation, weight loss, medication, or surgery. Even after adenotonsillectomy, about 20% of children will have persistent OSA. Sleep endoscopy and cine MRI are tools that may be used to identify sites of obstruction, which in turn can help in the selection of site-specific treatment.

Extracapsular versus intracapsular tonsillectomy: Outcomes in children with a focus on developmental delay

INTRODUCTION

Outcomes following intracapsular tonsillectomy (IT) have not been well established in children with developmental delays. The objective of this study was to compare outcomes and complications between intracapsular and extracapsular tonsillectomy (TT) in pediatric patients with developmental delay (DD) in comparison to non-developmentally delayed children.

METHODS

This is a retrospective study of pediatric patients with DD undergoing tonsillectomy between 2016 and 2019 at a tertiary care hospital. This group included patients with Down Syndrome, Autism Spectrum Disorder, other genetic syndromes, and patients with a diagnosis of global developmental delay. Outcomes and complications were analyzed for IT and TT.

RESULTS

2267 charts were reviewed, and 320 patients were identified with DD. Of those, 72 patients underwent IT and 248 underwent TT. In the DD cohort, the IT group had a shorter length of stay (0.97 vs 1.7 days, p < .0001) and was less likely to receive post-operative narcotic medication (2.8% vs 35%, p < .0001) and corticosteroids (9.7% vs 64%, p < .0001) during their hospital stay. Reductions in emergency room (ER) visits (5.6% vs 10%, p = .21) and post-op bleeding (PTH) (1.4% vs 4.8%, p = .31) for IT vs TT were not statistically significant in the DD group. In the NDD group, fewer patients undergoing IT returned to the ER (11% vs 2.3%, p < .0001) or had PTH (4.8% vs 0.25%, p, 0.0001) as compared to those children undergoing TT. There was no difference between parental report of symptom improvement between the groups (39% vs 33%, p = .39). Analysis of 180 patients with preoperative and postoperative sleep study data revealed post-op Apnea Hypopnea Index (AHI) improved with both techniques (74% TT vs 79% IT, p = .7). There were no differences noted for persistent obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) among the two techniques for both study groups (p = .63).

CONCLUSION

Children with DD undergoing IT have reduced length of stay and reduced inpatient administration of post-operative opioids and steroids. IT has comparable efficacy to TT in treating symptoms of pediatric sleep apnea with a better safety profile. Overall, children undergoing IT return to the operating room less frequently than those undergoing TT. Longer follow-up studies will be needed to evaluate rate of tonsil regrowth, risk of revision surgery and persistence of OSA in these patients.

Monopolar tonsillotomy versus cold dissection tonsillectomy in children: Prospective study on postoperative recovery

OBJECTIVES

To compare postoperative self-reported recovery results with monopolar tonsillotomy and cold dissection tonsillectomy in children. To evaluate the feasibility of the monopolar technique in tonsillotomy.

METHODS

Children <12 years undergoing tonsillotomy or tonsillectomy between April 2018 and March 2020 who (with a caregiver) were willing to participate in a two-week follow-up formed the study group. They filled in a questionnaire about pain-related outcomes, return to normal activities, weight changes, complications, and length of home care.

RESULTS

Altogether 166 patients were recruited; 103 (62%) returned the questionnaire. The first pain-free day with tonsillotomy was day 5 and with tonsillectomy day 11. After tonsillotomy, patients returned to normal activities faster, e.g. they were able to eat normally 6.5 days earlier than tonsillectomy patients. During the first postoperative week weight dropped after tonsillectomy, but not after tonsillotomy. The length of home care was 6 days with tonsillotomy and 10 days with tonsillectomy. The incidence of postoperative hemorrhage (including minor bleedings at home) was 14% after tonsillotomy and 32% after tonsillectomy. Hemorrhages needing interventions were 0% with tonsillotomy and 2% with tonsillectomy.

CONCLUSION

Children operated on with monopolar tonsillotomy recovered faster and had less postoperative hemorrhage than those undergoing tonsillectomy. They were able to return earlier to daycare/school and their caregivers back to work. Recovery results with monopolar tonsillotomy were equal to other tonsillotomy techniques reported in the literature, hence the monopolar technique can be considered an alternative method to perform tonsillotomy.

Pediatric tonsillectomy: A short-term and long-term comparison of intracapsular versus extracapsular techniques

OBJECTIVE

To review a cohort of over 2500 patients and investigate the short and long-term outcomes of intracapsular as compared to extracapsular tonsillectomy, and show if the complication rates are comparable between methods.

STUDY DESIGN

A multicenter, retrospective chart review was conducted, evaluating pediatric tonsillectomies performed from 2004 to 2014. The electronic medical record was reviewed through December 2018, providing up to 14 years of follow-up data.

SETTING

Two tertiary care, academic medical centers.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

A retrospective chart review was conducted to identify children undergoing tonsillectomy and adenotonsillectomy. A chart review was first performed of patients by a single surgeon (MEG) and then the analysis was repeated using enterprise data warehouse (EDW) to search for complications and interventions using International Classification of Diseases, ninth revision, (ICD-9) and Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes. The second surgeon's patients (JLC) patients were added to increase the cohort. Patients were excluded from the review of long-term outcomes if there was less than two-year follow-up. Short-term outcomes examined included rate of post-tonsillectomy hemorrhage and re-presentation for dehydration, while long-term outcomes included rates of peritonsillar abscess and tonsillar regrowth requiring revision tonsillectomy.

RESULTS

A total of 2508 pediatric patients were identified who had undergone tonsillectomy or adenotonsillectomy. In 1456 (58.1%) of these patients, the intracapsular technique was used and in 1052 (41.9%) patients, the extracapsular technique was used. The mean documented follow-up time was 8.2 years. Thirty-five patients (1.4%) were identified with post-tonsillectomy hemorrhage, 2 of these patients (5.7%) with primary hemorrhage and 33 patients (94.3%) with secondary hemorrhage. 11 underwent intracapsular tonsillectomy and 24 underwent extracapsular tonsillectomy (p = 0.0042). The rate of post-tonsillectomy hemorrhage with intracapsular tonsillectomy was 0.76%, compared to 2.3% in the extracapsular group. Three patients (0.12%) undergoing intracapsular tonsillectomy required revision tonsillectomy; no patients in the extracapsular group required revision surgery. Three patients (0.12%) developed peritonsillar abscess post-operatively, two following intracapsular tonsillectomy and one following extracapsular tonsillectomy.

CONCLUSION

This retrospective review comparing the intracapsular and extracapsular techniques for tonsillectomy provides further evidence of the benefits of this technique. It is worthwhile to continue offering intracapsular tonsillectomy to patients and their families during pre-operative discussions.

Tonsillectomy versus tonsillotomy for obstructive sleep-disordered breathing in children

BACKGROUND

Obstructive sleep-disordered breathing (oSDB) is a condition encompassing breathing problems when asleep due to upper airway obstruction. In children, hypertrophy of the tonsils and/or adenoids is thought to be the commonest cause. As such, (adeno)tonsillectomy has long been the treatment of choice. A rise in partial removal of the tonsils over the last decade is due to the hypothesis that tonsillotomy is associated with lower postoperative morbidity and fewer complications.

OBJECTIVES

To assess whether partial removal of the tonsils (intracapsular tonsillotomy) is as effective as total removal of the tonsils (extracapsular tonsillectomy) in relieving signs and symptoms of oSDB in children, and has lower postoperative morbidity and fewer complications.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the Cochrane ENT Trials Register; Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL); MEDLINE; EMBASE; CINAHL; Web of Science; ClinicalTrials.gov; ICTRP and additional sources for published and unpublished trials. The search date was 22 July 2019.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) comparing the effectiveness of (adeno)tonsillectomy with (adeno)tonsillotomy in children aged 2 to 16 years with oSDB.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

We used standard Cochrane methods and assessed the certainty of the evidence for our pre-defined outcomes using GRADE. Our primary outcomes were disease-specific quality of life, peri-operative blood loss and the proportion of children requiring postoperative medical intervention (with or without hospitalisation). Secondary outcomes included postoperative pain, return to normal activity, recurrence of oSDB symptoms as a result of tonsil regrowth and reoperation rates.

MAIN RESULTS

We included 22 studies (1984 children), with predominantly unclear or high risk of bias. Three studies used polysomnography as part of their inclusion criteria. Follow-up duration ranged from six days to six years. Although 19 studies reported on some of our outcomes, we could only pool the results from a few due both to the variety of outcomes and the measurement instruments used, and an absence of combinable data. Disease-specific quality of life Four studies (540 children; 484 (90%) analysed) reported this outcome; data could not be pooled due to the different outcome measurement instruments used. It is very uncertain whether there is any difference in disease-specific quality of life between the two surgical procedures in the short (0 to 6 months; 3 studies, 410 children), medium (7 to 13 months; 2 studies, 117 children) and long term (13 to 24 months; 1 study, 67 children) (very low-certainty evidence). Peri-operative blood loss We are uncertain whether tonsillotomy reduces peri-operative blood loss by a clinically meaningful amount (mean difference (MD) 14.06 mL, 95% CI 1.91 to 26.21 mL; 8 studies, 610 children; very low-certainty evidence). In sensitivity analysis (restricted to three studies with low risk of bias) there was no evidence of a difference between the groups. Postoperative complications requiring medical intervention (with or without hospitalisation) The risk of postoperative complications in the first week after surgery was probably lower in children who underwent tonsillotomy (4.9% versus 2.6%, risk ratio (RR) 1.75, 95% CI 1.06 to 2.91; 16 studies, 1416 children; moderate-certainty evidence). Postoperative pain Eleven studies (1017 children) reported this outcome. Pain was measured using various scales and scored by either children, parents, clinicians or study personnel. When considering postoperative pain there was little or no difference between tonsillectomy and tonsillotomy at 24 hours (10-point scale) (MD 1.09, 95% CI 0.88 to 1.29; 4 studies, 368 children); at two to three days (MD 0.93, 95% CI -0.14 to 2.00; 3 studies, 301 children); or at four to seven days (MD 1.07, 95% CI -0.40 to 2.53; 4 studies, 370 children) (all very low-certainty evidence). In sensitivity analysis (restricted to studies with low risk of bias), we found no evidence of a difference in mean pain scores between groups. Return to normal activity Tonsillotomy probably results in a faster return to normal activity. Children who underwent tonsillotomy were able to return to normal activity four days earlier (MD 3.84 days, 95% CI 0.23 to 7.44; 3 studies, 248 children; moderate-certainty evidence). Recurrence of oSDB and reoperation rates We are uncertain whether there is a difference between the groups in the short (RR 0.26, 95% CI 0.03 to 2.22; 3 studies, 186 children), medium (RR 0.35, 95% CI 0.04 to 3.23; 4 studies, 206 children) or long term (RR 0.21 95% CI 0.01 to 4.13; 1 study, 65 children) (all very low-certainty evidence).

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

For children with oSDB selected for tonsil surgery, tonsillotomy probably results in a faster return to normal activity (four days) and in a slight reduction in postoperative complications requiring medical intervention in the first week after surgery. This should be balanced against the clinical effectiveness of one operation over the other. However, this is not possible to determine in this review as data on the long-term effects of the two operations on oSDB symptoms, quality of life, oSDB recurrence and need for reoperation are limited and the evidence is of very low quality leading to a high degree of uncertainty about the results. More robust data from high-quality cohort studies, which may be more appropriate for detecting differences in less common events in the long term, are required to inform guidance on which tonsil surgery technique is best for children with oSDB requiring surgery.

[Surgical treatment for sleep disorders breathing in children and teenagers]

Adenotonsillectomy is the standard surgery for moderate and severe sleep disorders breathing (SDB) in 2 to 6-year-old children, often due to tonsillar and adenoidal hypertrophy. Recently, partial subtotal intracapsular tonsillotomy has been developed to prevent risks linked to surgery, especially haemorrhages leading to death in extreme cases. Children with apnea, poor quality of life (sleep problems, daytime tiredness), poor academic performance or late growth are candidates for adenotonsillectomy. The management of children with mild SDB is still evolving. Adenotonsillectomy is usually not recommended for adenoidal hypertrophy. Treatment options with mild OSA include watchful waiting, inhaled nasal corticosteroids, and adeno-tonsillectomy. The treatment decision should be made after a discussion between the patient, caregivers and the surgeon regarding the risks and benefits of possible therapies. The surgical procedure is efficient in more than 75% of cases. Close clinical follow-up is necessary, especially in obese children. Primary and secondary haemorrhaging, as well as postoperative pain, are considerably reduced in partial tonsillotomy. Tonsillotomy (intracapsular or subtotal tonsillectomy) is a modern technique because it has been suggested that perioperative pain and postoperative haemorrhage are reduced with the tonsillotomy technique. There is no significant difference in subjective outcome between tonsillotomy and tonsillectomy. These findings may support wider use of tonsillotomy for the treatment of sleep disorders breathing in children. Children with residual disorder may be candidates for surgical procedures such as nasal disobstruction, pharyngoplasty, lingual tonsillectomy or maxillofacial surgery.

Intracapsular versus extracapsular dissection tonsillectomy for adults: A systematic review

OBJECTIVES

Tonsillectomy is an extremely common ENT surgical procedure. There is a growing interest in the role of intracapsular dissection tonsillectomy (ICDT) due to reported reduced perioperative complications. We aim to compare the outcomes associated with ICDT versus traditional extracapsular dissection tonsillectomy (ECDT) in the adult population.

METHODS

Systematic review of all randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing ICDT and ECDT for all indications in the adult population. Electronic searches performed through CENTRAL, PubMed, Ovid EMBASE, Web of Science, ClinicalTrials.gov, and WHO ICTRP. Review Manager 5.3 (RevMan 2014) was used to carry out the meta-analysis.

RESULTS

Nine RCTs were included with a total of 11 reports with mean age of 23.9 years including 181 patients who received ICDT compared to 176 patients receiving ECDT. We found statistically significant reduced postoperative pain and analgesia requirement as well as a reduced rate of secondary postoperative bleeding in patients undergoing ICDT versus ECDT. There appears to be no significant difference in controlling recurrent tonsillitis between the ICDT and ECDT groups.

CONCLUSION

Across the recorded outcomes we noted no clear benefit to performing ECDT over ICDT and evidence suggests high patient satisfaction with ICDT. Laryngoscope, 130:2325-2335, 2020.

Radiofrequency Coblation-Assisted Resection of Skull Base Neoplasms Using an Endoscopic Endonasal Approach

OBJECTIVES

We describe our early experiences with resecting skull base tumors using a radiofrequency ablation-assisted endoscopic endonasal approach. Ninety-seven patients with skull base tumors who were admitted to the Otorhinolaryngology department at Shanghai Jiaotong University Affiliated Shanghai Sixth People's Hospital between January 2014 and December 2016 were operated on using a radiofrequency ablation-assisted endoscopic endonasal approach. Complete resection was achieved in all patients. This paper describes the operative technique and presents the degree of resection, complications, and early clinical outcomes.

METHODS

We investigated the safety and feasibility of the technique and assessed preliminary treatment outcomes.

RESULTS

No patients experienced a new neurological deficit, cerebrospinal fluid leak, or meningitis after surgery. No deaths related to skull base tumors were observed during the follow-up period (14-50 months). The volume of intraoperative blood loss was 100-1,200 mL (median 350 mL), the duration of operation was 40-510 min (median 180 min), and the hospital stay was 6-65 days (median 18).

CONCLUSIONS

Our limited experience indicates that this technique is feasible and safe for complete resection of some skull base tumors in selected cases and in the future will have an increasing role to play in endoscopic sinonasal and skull base tumor dissection.

What's New with Tubes, Tonsils, and Adenoids?

Evidence-based recommendations are constantly being updated for various pediatric surgical procedures, including the role for tympanostomy tubes, as well as indications for adenoidectomy and tonsillectomy. With a growing body of research available on some of the most prevalent pediatric conditions, an update on the current concepts surrounding management is warranted.

Changing trends in pediatric tonsil surgery

OBJECTIVES

We analyzed trends in tonsil surgery over a 10-year period in a single tertiary care hospital and evaluated the effects of these changes on use of hospital services and healthcare costs.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study based on data from databases at the Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Helsinki University Hospital, Helsinki, Finland. Children under 16 years of age with tonsillectomy (TE) or tonsillotomy (TT) performed during 2007-2016 were included in the study.

RESULTS

In 10 years, 4979 tonsil surgeries were performed on 4951 children: TE in 3170 (64%) and TT in 1781 (36%) children. The total number of tonsil surgeries stayed nearly constant. TT operations commenced in the study hospital in 2009 and from 2012 onwards have been more common than TE procedures. Altogether 279 patients visited the emergency department because of complications; TE patients had 9.0 visits/100 surgeries and TT patients 1.8 visits/100 surgeries. The most common complication was postoperative hemorrhage: 200 cases (6.3%) in the TE group and 11 cases (0.6%) in the TT group. During the two-year follow-up after tonsil surgery the total costs of healthcare services were significantly lower in the TT group than in the TE group.

CONCLUSION

Considerable changes have occurred in tonsil surgery in children during the 10-year study period; TT is today performed more often than TE. As a consequence, complications, readmissions to hospital, and number of patients treated in the operating room because of postoperative hemorrhage have decreased, lowering the costs of healthcare.

Comparative intraindividual ablative tissue effects of diode laser 980 nm versus radiofrequency in tonsillar hypertrophy management

Tonsillotomy (tonsillar ablation) using diode laser and radiofrequency has been introduced for management of tonsillar hypertrophy as it is associated with fewer hazards to deep structures. We compared tissue volume and histological changes in the tonsils following radiofrequency tonsillotomy versus diode laser tonsillotomy in tonsillar hypertrophy. 40 tonsils excised from 20 patients were included in this study. Twenty tonsils were subjected to radiofrequency tonsillotomy (RFT) group 1, and the other 20 tonsils were subjected to diode laser 980 nm tonsillotomy (DLT) group 2. Both procedures were followed by cold dissection tonsillectomy for macroscopic and histological examination of tonsils. Tonsillar volume reduction was evident in both groups with a non-significant difference between groups. Histological changes were evident in both groups. In our study, both radiofrequency and diode laser were effective in tonsillar ablation in terms of volume reduction and keeping the histological pattern intact.

[Tonsil surgery: impact of the mouth gag on pharyngeal diameter]

BACKGROUND

Photo documentation of hypertrophic tonsils is requested by some insurance companies to justify reimbursement of tonsillotomy. In 2017, a standardized photo documentation was introduced in tonsillotomy patients to verify the indication and effectiveness of the procedure.

OBJECTIVE

Using the archived photo documentation, this study aimed to evaluate the impact of two different positions of the mouth gag on the oropharyngeal airway.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Pictures were taken through the operating microscope after insertion of the mouth gag but without suspension (D1), after suspension before tonsillotomy (D2), and after resection of tonsillar tissue with the mouth gag under tension (D3). For each picture, a 10-mm scale from a single-use paper ruler was placed on the uvula. For this retrospective study, the patient's images were inserted into PowerPoint slides. Distances were measured with the use of an inserted rectangular grid.

RESULTS

The files of 149 patients undergoing tonsillotomy in a 6-month period were eligible for evaluation. Gender was balanced. The youngest patient was 16 months, the oldest patient 48 years old (mean: 6.95 years; median: 5 years). In all patients, tension of the mouth gag had significantly widened the oropharyngeal diameter (p < 0.001), making the tonsils appear smaller.

CONCLUSION

Suspension of the mouth gag results in a significant relative "downsizing" of the tonsils due to expansion of the oropharynx. Intraoperative photo documentation should also be performed without suspension of the mouth gag. Further studies may clarify whether stretching of the oropharynx has an impact on the distance between the tonsils and surrounding greater arteries.

Tonsillotomy versus tonsillectomy in adults suffering from tonsil-related afflictions: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

Tonsillotomy has emerged as an alternative for tonsillectomy in treating patients with tonsil-related afflictions. Tonsillotomy provides favourable outcomes in children, but treatment of choice in adults remains unclear. This systematic review sought to evaluate the current literature on the efficacy and adverse events of tonsillotomy compared to tonsillectomy in adults.

METHODS

A Medline and Cochrane search was conducted for randomized clinical trials (RCTs) and cohort studies comparing tonsillotomy to tonsillectomy in adults. Risk of bias was assessed. Outcome measures were efficacy of the procedure in resolving the initial tonsil-related symptoms (tonsillitis, obstructive sleep apnoea, tonsil stones, halitosis, dysphagia), procedure-related complications, recovery time, post-operative use of analgesics, patient satisfaction, and operating time.

RESULTS

In total nine papers were included. These trials had a high risk of bias and the inter-comparability of results was poor. The reported studies found generally a similar efficacy for both interventions. With regard to pain, the use of analgesics, patient satisfaction and operation time, the results were generally in favour of tonsillotomy. Post-operative haemorrhages were more frequent after tonsillectomy.

CONCLUSION

Current evidence suggests an equal efficacy of tonsillotomy and tonsillectomy in adults and a preference for tonsillotomy in terms of pain, analgesics use, patient-satisfaction, operation time and post-operative complications.

Current perspectives on the role of tonsillectomy

Tonsillectomy is one of the most common paediatric surgical procedures performed in Australasia. The aim of this paper is to provide an up-to-date review of the indications for the procedure (and the evidence base for each of these indications), as well as describe the surgical technique and perioperative management and risks for a non-surgical audience. The primary indications for tonsillectomy are obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) (where it is most commonly performed in association with adenoidectomy) and recurrent pharyngotonsillitis. There is now high-quality evidence that tonsillectomy improves objective measures of OSA on sleep studies, as well as quality of life and child behaviour. The impact of surgery on cognitive function is less well delineated. For recurrent pharyngotonsillitis, tonsillectomy has a modest impact on recurrent sore throat symptoms - clinicians should ensure an appropriate pre-operative observation period and adequately discuss the potential benefits with parents prior to surgery. Traditional approaches to tonsillectomy involve surgically dissecting the entire tonsil from the underlying pharyngeal muscle. Subtotal tonsillectomy (intracapsular tonsillectomy or tonsillotomy) is described for OSA and may reduce perioperative morbidity. Children younger than 3 years and those with moderate to severe OSA or significant comorbidities should be admitted for overnight observation. Simple analgesia is adequate for most patients postoperatively. Codeine is contraindicated due to reports of postoperative death due to respiratory suppression. Overall, tonsillectomy is a well-tolerated procedure, with pain and postoperative haemorrhage (2-4%) being the most common complications. Haemorrhage can be life threatening; however, the mortality rate remains very small at approximately 1:30 000.

The effect of tonsillotomy on chronic recurrent tonsillitis in children

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study is to determine whether partial tonsillectomy (tonsillotomy) impacts the occurrence of acute or recurrent tonsillitis in children.

METHODS

One hundred and eighty patients (1-14 years) were retrospectively surveyed by a questionnaire or by data analysis of a regional database. Subjects who suffered from severe systemic diseases or immunodeficiency syndromes were excluded. Episodes of acute tonsillitis before and after surgery, rate of antibiotic treatment, postoperative hemorrhage, and re-operation were obtained.

RESULTS

Fifty-one patients suffered from preoperative tonsillitis. The rate of reinfection was 9.8%. The frequency of tonsillitis was significantly reduced in children after tonsillotomy (p < .001). Further, tonsillotomy led to a significant reduction of antibiotic treatment (p < .001). The rate of definitive tonsillectomy was 1.1% and thus effectiveness was very high. About 1.7% of all children suffered from postoperative bleeding, of which one (0.6%) required surgical revision. None of the bleedings was life threatening.

CONCLUSIONS

Tonsillotomy is beneficial for patients with recurrent tonsillitis and carries less risk of postoperative complications than tonsillectomy.

Indirect costs related to caregivers' absence from work after paediatric tonsil surgery

Tonsillotomy has gradually replaced tonsillectomy as the surgical method of choice in children with upper airway obstruction during sleep, because of less postoperative pain and a shorter recovery time. The aim of this study was to examine the costs related to caregivers' absenteeism from work after tonsillectomy (TE) and tonsillotomy (TT). All tonsillectomies and tonsillotomies in Sweden due to upper airway obstruction during 1 year, reported to the National Tonsil Surgery Register in children aged 1-11 were included, n = 4534. The number of days the child needed analgesics after surgery was used as a proxy to estimate the number of work days lost for the caregiver. Data from the Social Insurance Agency (Försäkringskassan) regarding the days the parents received temporary parental benefits in the month following surgery were also analysed. The indirect costs due to the caregivers' absenteeism after tonsillectomy vs tonsillotomy were calculated, using the human capital method. The patient-reported use of postoperative analgesic use was 77% (n = 3510). Data from the Social Insurance Agency were gathered for all 4534 children. The mean duration of analgesic treatment was 4.6 days (indirect cost of EUR 747). The mean number of days with parental benefits was 2.9 (EUR 667). The indirect cost of tonsillectomy was 61% higher than that of tonsillotomy (EUR 1010 vs EUR 629). The results show that the choice of surgical method affects the indirect costs, favouring the use of tonsillotomy over tonsillectomy for the treatment of children with SDB, due to less postoperative pain.

Self-reported postoperative recovery in children after tonsillectomy compared to tonsillotomy

OBJECTIVES

Tonsil surgery is associated with significant morbidity during recovery. Patient-reported outcome measures (PROM) are the golden standard for the planning and follow-up of delivered care, which should also be an axiom for children. The current aims were to describe self-reported postoperative recovery in children after tonsil surgery, and to compare tonsillotomy and tonsillectomy in this respect.

METHODS

In total, 238 children (4-12 years old) with a history of obstructive problems and/or recurrent tonsillitis, and undergoing tonsil surgery were included. Forty-eight per cent were operated with partial tonsil resection/tonsillotomy (TT) and 52% with total tonsillectomy (TE), all in day surgery. Postoperative recovery was assessed on days 1, 4 and 10 using the validated self-rating instrument PRiC, Postoperative Recovery in Children. This includes 23 items covering different aspects of recovery after tonsil surgery. A higher score indicates worse status in the respective items.

RESULTS

Daily life activities (sleeping, eating and playing), physical symptoms (e.g., headache, stomach ache, sore throat, otalgia, dizziness, nausea, defecation, urination), and emotional aspects (sadness, frightening dreams) were affected during the recovery period. The TE-girls showed higher scores than the boys regarding stomach ache, defecation and dizziness. Children above 6 years of age reported higher values for the physical comfort variables, while the younger group showed worse emotional states. Postoperative recovery improved from day 1-10 in all surgical groups. The TE-group showed lower recovery compared to the TT-group (p < 0.01-0.001) in most items.

CONCLUSION

The goal of postoperative management is to minimize or eliminate discomfort, facilitating the recovery process and avoiding complications. Children are able to describe their recovery, and thus, PRiC seems to be able to serve as a PROM to obtain patient-centered data after tonsil surgery. The recovery process after TT causes less postoperative morbidity and a quicker return to normal activity compared to TE.

Hyperplasia and the degree and activity of inflammation in chronic recurrent tonsillitis: a histopathological study

Postoperative haemorrhage following tonsillectomy occurs in 5.98% of all cases with up to 10 deaths reported annually in Germany. When comparing tonsillectomy (TE) and tonsillotomy (TT), the same long-term frequency of ENT infections is displayed in children and young adults. However, taking postoperative haemorrhaging into account, TT is more favourable. Chronic tonsillitis is one of the most common indications for TE in the adult population; however, a histopathological characterization may reveal objective criteria and provide a foundation for routinely performing TT in adults too. Three essential parameters hyperplasia (HP), grade of inflammation (GOI) and activity of inflammation (AOI), which are responsible for, and associated with a clinically relevant disease were histopathologically examined in the tonsils of 100 adult patients with chronic recurrent tonsillitis. The parameters were analysed and compared separately in the pharyngeal and basal parts of the tonsils as well as in three sections (upper and lower pole of the tonsil, middle part) as this may influence the indication for TT. The comparison of the basal and pharyngeal portions displayed a significant difference in the GOI and the HP in all three sections: grade 2 HP as well as GOI were more commonly found in the basal than pharyngeal portions (p > 0.001). AOI (grade 2) displayed the same properties in the middle section (p < 0.002), but did not reach statistical significance in the cranial and caudal sections (p = 0.107 and p = 0.186). An overabundance of grade 1 GOI, AOI, and HP was seen in the pharyngeal sections. The results show that two out of three relevant parameters that demonstrate histopathological changes in recurrent inflamed tonsils have a significantly stronger presence in the basal section of the tonsil as opposed to the pharyngeal section. The processes initiated by inflammation next to the surface responsible for a clinically relevant recurrent tonsillitis seem to cause stronger reactions in the deep follicular portion of the tonsils.

Adenotonsillotomy Versus Adenotonsillectomy in Pediatric Obstructive Sleep Apnea: An RCT

BACKGROUND

Adenotonsillectomy (ATE) is a well-established and effective treatment of pediatric obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). In recent years, a more conservative method, adenotonsillotomy (ATT), has gained popularity because it is associated with less postoperative morbidity. Yet no previous randomized study has compared these 2 methods regarding their effectiveness in treating pediatric OSA in terms of polysomnographic data, which was the primary aim of this study. The hypothesis was that ATT is noninferior to ATE after 1 year.

METHODS

Seventy-nine children, aged 2 to 6 years, with OSA (Apnea-Hypopnea Index [AHI] 5-30) were randomized to ATT (n = 40) or ATE (n = 39). Polysomnography (PSG) and questionnaire OSA-18 were assessed at baseline and 1 year postsurgery.

RESULTS

Mean difference between groups in the primary outcome, change in AHI, was 0.83, 95% confidence interval -3.2 to 4.9, not exceeding the noninferiority margin of 5. After ATE, AHI decreased from median 12.7 (interquartile range 8.3-19.1) to 2.0 (1.2-3.1) and after ATT from 15.8 (8.5-21.2) to 4.0 (1.2-5.1). For both groups, significant improvements of PSG and OSA-18 questionnaire outcomes were observed, with no significant differences between groups. Five children (13%) in the ATT group needed repeated surgery for tonsil regrowth and recurrence of OSA.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that ATT is noninferior to ATE in treating pediatric OSA regarding PSG outcomes after 1 year. ATT could be considered an alternative to ATE for treatment of pediatric OSA. However, after ATT, there is a nonnegligible risk of recurrence of OSA, and this should be taken into account when selecting surgical method.

Indirect costs related to caregivers' absence from work after paediatric tonsil surgery

Tonsillotomy has gradually replaced tonsillectomy as the surgical method of choice in children with upper airway obstruction during sleep, because of less postoperative pain and a shorter recovery time. The aim of this study was to examine the costs related to caregivers' absenteeism from work after tonsillectomy (TE) and tonsillotomy (TT). All tonsillectomies and tonsillotomies in Sweden due to upper airway obstruction during 1 year, reported to the National Tonsil Surgery Register in children aged 1-11 were included, n = 4534. The number of days the child needed analgesics after surgery was used as a proxy to estimate the number of work days lost for the caregiver. Data from the Social Insurance Agency (Försäkringskassan) regarding the days the parents received temporary parental benefits in the month following surgery were also analysed. The indirect costs due to the caregivers' absenteeism after tonsillectomy vs tonsillotomy were calculated, using the human capital method. The patient-reported use of postoperative analgesic use was 77% (n = 3510). Data from the Social Insurance Agency were gathered for all 4534 children. The mean duration of analgesic treatment was 4.6 days (indirect cost of EUR 747). The mean number of days with parental benefits was 2.9 (EUR 667). The indirect cost of tonsillectomy was 61% higher than that of tonsillotomy (EUR 1010 vs EUR 629). The results show that the choice of surgical method affects the indirect costs, favouring the use of tonsillotomy over tonsillectomy for the treatment of children with SDB, due to less postoperative pain.

Rethinking surgical technique and priorities for pediatric tonsillectomy

The past 100years have witnessed dramatic shifts in the concept of ideal surgical goals and operative technique in tonsil surgery. Surgeons are reviving a technique of intracapsular tonsillectomy with increasing precision thanks to modern technology. With intracapsular tonsillectomy, pediatric patients recover faster, use less pain medication, and have a lower risk of dehydration and hemorrhage. Various considerations will dictate the adoption of this technology in the coming years. This current review explores concepts and controversies surrounding tonsillectomy with a focus on quality improvement.

Laser CO2 tonsillotomy versus argon plasma coagulation (APC) tonsillotomy: A retrospective study with 10-year follow-up

INTRODUCTION

Tonsillotomy is increasingly gaining acceptance as the treatment for tonsillar hyperplasia resulting in obstructive symptoms. The aim of this study was to compare the long-term results of CO₂ laser tonsillotomy with those of argon plasma coagulation (APC) tonsillotomy.

METHODS

The data of 64 children, aged 2-10 years (mean 4.7 years), treated in the Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, in Homburg, Germany with APC (36 patients) or CO₂ laser (28 patients) for tonsillar hyperplasia between June 2004 and December 2004 were available for analysis.

RESULTS

Forty-five (APC: 26 patients, CO₂: 19 patients) of the 64 patients (70.3%) could be contacted and were available for follow-up in a telephone survey conducted 10 years after surgery. The mean operation time was 17 min (range 10-25 min) in the APC group and 23 min (range 13-32 min) in the CO₂ group (p = 0.0003). No case of intra- or postoperative bleeding was documented. One minor intraoperative complication in the form of a superficial lip burn was documented in the APC group. During the minimum 10 years of follow-up, 1 patient treated with APC underwent a surgical revision because of tonsillar regrowth, whereas in the group of patients treated with CO₂, no surgical revision was needed. Regarding the parents' assessment of their children's symptoms, 89.4% of the parents of the CO₂ laser group and 84.6% of the parents of the APC group reported that the overall long-term operation results of their children to be "very satisfying." Regarding complications, the need for secondary tonsillectomy, and parents' satisfaction, no statistically significant differences were found.

CONCLUSIONS

Both CO₂ laser tonsillotomy and APC tonsillotomy are safe procedures leading to very satisfying results with respect to intra- and postoperative complications.

Indications for tonsillectomy stratified by the level of evidence

Background: One of the most significant clinical trials, demonstrating the efficacy of tonsillectomy (TE) for recurrent throat infection in severely affected children, was published in 1984. This systematic review was undertaken to compile various indications for TE as suggested in the literature after 1984 and to stratify the papers according to the current concept of evidence-based medicine. Material and methods: A systematic Medline research was performed using the key word of "tonsillectomy" in combination with different filters such as "systematic reviews", "meta-analysis", "English", "German", and "from 1984/01/01 to 2015/05/31". Further research was performed in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, National Guideline Clearinghouse, Guidelines International Network and BMJ Clinical Evidence using the same key word. Finally, data from the "Trip Database" were researched for "tonsillectomy" and "indication" and "from: 1984 to: 2015" in combination with either "systematic review" or "meta-analysis" or "metaanalysis". Results: A total of 237 papers were retrieved but only 57 matched our inclusion criteria covering the following topics: peritonsillar abscess (3), guidelines (5), otitis media with effusion (5), psoriasis (3), PFAPA syndrome (6), evidence-based indications (5), renal diseases (7), sleep-related breathing disorders (11), and tonsillitis/pharyngitis (12), respectively. Conclusions: 1) The literature suggests, that TE is not indicated to treat otitis media with effusion. 2) It has been shown, that the PFAPA syndrome is self-limiting and responds well to steroid administration, at least in a considerable amount of children. The indication for TE therefore appears to be imbalanced but further research is required to clarify the value of surgery. 3) Abscesstonsillectomy as a routine is not justified and indicated only for cases not responding to other measures of treatment, evident complications, or with a significant history of tonsillitis. In particular, interval-tonsillectomy is not justified as a routine. 4) TE, with or without adenoidectomy, is efficacious to resolve sleep-related breathing disorders resulting from (adeno)tonsillar hypertrophy in children. However, the benefit is reduced by co-morbidities, such as obesity, and further research is required to identify prognostic factors for this subgroup of patients. Further research is indicated to clarify selection criteria not only for this subpopulation that may benefit from less invasive procedures such as tonsillotomy in the long-term. 5) Further trials are also indicated to evaluate the efficacy of TE on the clinical course in children with psoriasis guttata as well as on psoriasis vulgaris in adults, not responding to first-line therapy. 6) Conflicting results were reported concerning the role of TE in the concert to treat Ig-A nephropathy, mandating further clinical research. 7) Most importantly, randomized-controlled clinical trials with an adequate long-term follow-up are desirable to clarify the benefit of TE in patients with recurrent episodes of tonsillitis, with or without pharyngitis. Factors like age, spontaneous healing rate and postoperative quality of life have to be included when comparing TE with antibiotic therapy.

Post-operative morbidity and 1-year outcomes in CO2-laser tonsillotomy versus dissection tonsillectomy

OBJECTIVE

In this study a type of partial tonsil surgery, CO2-laser tonsillotomy, was compared to regular tonsillectomy. The effectiveness and post-operative recovery rate of both interventions in adult patients was assessed by using a questionnaire.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective follow-up non-randomized cohort study.

METHOD

One hundred and seven adults were included; 46 tonsillectomies and 61 tonsillotomies were performed. Patients in the tonsillectomy group underwent general anaesthesia, while tonsillotomy was performed in an ambulatory setting with local anaesthesia. Post-operative questionnaires were administered by mail after 2 weeks, 6 months, and 1 year to assess recovery rate and symptom recurrence.

RESULTS

In total, 72.5% of patients were cured from their initial symptoms after tonsillotomy. Three patients (7.5%) required re-surgery for their initial complaints. After tonsillectomy, 97.2% of patients were cured. Both groups showed equally high satisfaction scores after treatment. Post-operative evaluation after 2 weeks showed a mean pain-intensity score of 5.4 (Visual Analogue Scale 0-10) after tonsillotomy and a mean pain-intensity score of 7.7 after tonsillectomy. The post-operative use of analgesics was twice as long in the tonsillectomy group compared to the tonsillotomy group and the tonsillectomy group required twice as many days for full recovery. After tonsillectomy a higher rate of major post-operative haemorrhage was seen.

CONCLUSION

CO2-laser tonsillotomy is associated with a shorter and less painful recovery period. Both surgical methods are equal in terms of long-term satisfaction, although tonsillotomy comes with a higher recurrence rate of mild symptoms. A strict pre-operative patient selection for CO2-laser tonsillotomy is necessary.

Bipolar tonsillotomy: A novel and effective tonsillotomy technique

OBJECTIVE

To present, for the first time, tonsil size reduction using reusable bipolar forceps electrocautery (RBFE), as a treatment for pediatric OSAS and to assess the safety and efficacy of the procedure.

METHODS

A prospective interventional design study was performed. Thirty children aged 2-15 years with OSAS (AHI>5) diagnosed by means of polysomnography were included. All children were treated with adenoidectomy and RBFE tonsillotomy without dissection. Re-polysomnography was performed after 1 year. The size of the tonsils was blindly assessed by two ENT specialists and the parents were asked to fill out 'Pediatric Sleep Questionnaires' (PSQ), before surgery, and one month and one year after surgery.

RESULTS

There were no complications during or after surgery. There were no events involving postoperative bleeding or dehydration. The surgery mean time, including adenoidectomy, was 20.6min. The AHI was 10.9 before surgery and decreased to 1.8 after surgery (p<0.001), minimum saturation (SaO2 min) increased from 86.1% to 93.2% (p<0.001). The size of the tonsils decreased from a mean of +3.3 before surgery to +1.3 and +1.4 one month and one year after surgery, respectively. The mean of the PSQ scores went down from 23.6 to 5.5 and to 6.2 one month and one year after surgery, respectively.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrated that simple cauterization of the tonsils using a RBFE device with an adenoidectomy is a safe and effective treatment to decrease tonsil size in OSAS. In addition, the method is inexpensive, rapid and does not cause bleeding, which may be particularly interesting in the presence of coagulation problems.

Population-based analysis of tonsil surgery and postoperative hemorrhage

Although tonsil surgery is one of the most frequent otorhinolaryngological procedures, not many population-based regional or country-wide studies are published on the incidence of postoperative bleeding and its risk factors. 2,216 patients underwent tonsil surgery in 2012 in Thuringia, a federal state in Germany. Most frequent indications were recurrent tonsillitis (44 % of all cases), tonsillar abscess (27 %), and tonsillar hyperplasia (20 %). 29 % of the patients were <10 years of age. Most frequent methods of surgery were tonsillectomy (73 %) and tonsillotomy (19 %). 215 patients (10 %) had 221 events of a postoperative hemorrhage. Re-surgery for hemostasis was necessary in 137 patients (6 %). The interval to re-surgery was 4.4 ± 4.6 days. The re-surgery rate was 8, 0.2, and 15 % after tonsillectomy, tonsillotomy, and radical tonsillectomy, respectively. In cases of recurrent tonsillitis, male gender (p < 0.001), age >24.78 years (median; (p = 0.018), and waiving of perioperative antibiotics (p = 0.029) were independent factors associated with hemorrhage. In cases of tonsillar hyperplasia tonsillectomy instead of tonsillotomy, the only significant risk factor was postoperative hemorrhage (p = 0.005). The overall incidence of tonsillar surgery was 87.6/100,000. The highest incidence was seen for patients 3-4 years of age with 862.7/100,000. In children <10 years, the incidence was always higher for boys than for girls. Throughout all age groups, a reverse gender relation was only seen, if surgery was indicated for recurrent tonsillitis. We recommend establishing national guidelines for indication of tonsil surgery, especially of tonsillectomy, including recommendations for perioperative care to decrease variations in tonsil surgery rates and minimize postoperative complications.