Moving beyond simple answers to complex disorders in sarcomeric cardiomyopathies: the role of integrated systems

Novel Mutation Lys30Glu in the TPM1 Gene Leads to Pediatric Left Ventricular Non-Compaction and Dilated Cardiomyopathy via Impairment of Structural and Functional Properties of Cardiac Tropomyosin

Pediatric dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) is a rare heart muscle disorder leading to the enlargement of all chambers and systolic dysfunction. We identified a novel de novo variant, c.88A>G (p.Lys30Glu, K30E), in the TPM1 gene encoding the major cardiac muscle tropomyosin (Tpm) isoform, Tpm1.1. The variant was found in a proband with DCM and left ventricular non-compaction who progressed to terminal heart failure at the age of 3 years and 8 months. To study the properties of the mutant protein, we produced recombinant K30E Tpm and used various biochemical and biophysical methods to compare its properties with those of WT Tpm. The K30E substitution decreased the thermal stability of Tpm and its complex with actin and significantly reduced the sliding velocity of the regulated thin filaments over a surface covered by ovine cardiac myosin in an in vitro motility assay across the entire physiological range of Ca2+ concentration. Our molecular dynamics simulations suggest that the charge reversal of the 30th residue of Tpm alters the actin monomer to which it is bound. We hypothesize that this rearrangement of the actin-Tpm interaction may hinder the transition of a myosin head attached to a nearby actin from a weakly to a strongly bound, force-generating state, thereby reducing myocardial contractility. The impaired myosin interaction with regulated actin filaments and the decreased thermal stability of the actin-Tpm complex at a near physiological temperature likely contribute to the pathogenicity of the variant and its causative role in progressive DCM.

In silico and in vitro models reveal the molecular mechanisms of hypocontractility caused by TPM1 M8R

Dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) is an inherited disorder often leading to severe heart failure. Linkage studies in affected families have revealed hundreds of different mutations that can cause DCM, with most occurring in genes associated with the cardiac sarcomere. We have developed an investigational pipeline for discovering mechanistic genotype-phenotype relationships in DCM and here apply it to the DCM-linked tropomyosin mutation TPM1 M8R. Atomistic simulations predict that M8R increases flexibility of the tropomyosin chain and enhances affinity for the blocked or inactive state of tropomyosin on actin. Applying these molecular effects to a Markov model of the cardiac thin filament reproduced the shifts in Ca2+sensitivity, maximum force, and a qualitative drop in cooperativity that were observed in an in vitro system containing TPM1 M8R. The model was then used to simulate the impact of M8R expression on twitch contractions of intact cardiac muscle, predicting that M8R would reduce peak force and duration of contraction in a dose-dependent manner. To evaluate this prediction, TPM1 M8R was expressed via adenovirus in human engineered heart tissues and isometric twitch force was observed. The mutant tissues manifested depressed contractility and twitch duration that agreed in detail with model predictions. Additional exploratory simulations suggest that M8R-mediated alterations in tropomyosin-actin interactions contribute more potently than tropomyosin chain stiffness to cardiac twitch dysfunction, and presumably to the ultimate manifestation of DCM. This study is an example of the growing potential for successful in silico prediction of mutation pathogenicity for inherited cardiac muscle disorders.

Sex-Specific Response to A1BG Loss Results in Female Dilated Cardiomyopathy

Background

Cardiac disease often manifests differently in terms of frequency and pathology between men and women. However, the mechanisms underlying these differences are not fully understood. The glycoprotein A1BG is necessary for proper cardiac function in females but not males. Despite this, the role of A1BG in the female heart remains poorly studied.

Methods

To determine the sex differential function of A1BG, we generated a novel conditional A1bg allele and a novel conditional A1bg Rosa26 knockin allele. Histology, electrocardiography, transcriptional profiling (RNA-seq), transmission electron microscopy, western blot analyses, mass spectrometry, and immunohistochemistry were used to assess cardiac structure and function.

Results

The study reveals that the absence of A1BG results in significant cardiac dysfunction in female but not male mice. Gene expression underscores that A1BG plays a critical role in metabolic processes and the integrity of intercalated discs in female cardiomyocytes. This dysfunction may be related to sex-specific A1BG cardiac interactomes and manifests as structural and functional alterations in the left ventricle indicative of dilated cardiomyopathy, thus suggesting a sex-specific requirement for A1BG in cardiac health.

Conclusion

The loss of A1BG in cardiomyocytes leads to dilated cardiomyopathy in females, not males.

Mouse Models of Cardiomyopathies Caused by Mutations in Troponin C

Cardiac muscle contraction is regulated via Ca2+ exchange with the hetero-trimeric troponin complex located on the thin filament. Binding of Ca2+ to cardiac troponin C, a Ca2+ sensing subunit within the troponin complex, results in a series of conformational re-arrangements among the thin filament components, leading to an increase in the formation of actomyosin cross-bridges and muscle contraction. Ultimately, a decline in intracellular Ca2+ leads to the dissociation of Ca2+ from troponin C, inhibiting cross-bridge cycling and initiating muscle relaxation. Therefore, troponin C plays a crucial role in the regulation of cardiac muscle contraction and relaxation. Naturally occurring and engineered mutations in troponin C can lead to altered interactions among components of the thin filament and to aberrant Ca2+ binding and exchange with the thin filament. Mutations in troponin C have been associated with various forms of cardiac disease, including hypertrophic, restrictive, dilated, and left ventricular noncompaction cardiomyopathies. Despite progress made to date, more information from human studies, biophysical characterizations, and animal models is required for a clearer understanding of disease drivers that lead to cardiomyopathies. The unique use of engineered cardiac troponin C with the L48Q mutation that had been thoroughly characterized and genetically introduced into mouse myocardium clearly demonstrates that Ca2+ sensitization in and of itself should not necessarily be considered a disease driver. This opens the door for small molecule and protein engineering strategies to help boost impaired systolic function. On the other hand, the engineered troponin C mutants (I61Q and D73N), genetically introduced into mouse myocardium, demonstrate that Ca2+ desensitization under basal conditions may be a driving factor for dilated cardiomyopathy. In addition to enhancing our knowledge of molecular mechanisms that trigger hypertrophy, dilation, morbidity, and mortality, these cardiomyopathy mouse models could be used to test novel treatment strategies for cardiovascular diseases. In this review, we will discuss (1) the various ways mutations in cardiac troponin C might lead to disease; (2) relevant data on mutations in cardiac troponin C linked to human disease, and (3) all currently existing mouse models containing cardiac troponin C mutations (disease-associated and engineered).

Modeling Human Cardiac Thin Filament Structures

Striated muscle contraction is regulated in a calcium-dependent manner through dynamic motions of the tropomyosin/troponin polymer, a multicomponent complex wrapped around actin-containing thin filaments. Tropomyosin/troponin sterically blocks myosin-binding at low-calcium concentrations but moves to expose myosin-binding sites at high-calcium concentrations leading to force development. Understanding the key intermolecular interactions that define these dynamic motions will promote our understanding of mutation-induced contractile dysfunction that eventually leads to hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, dilated cardiomyopathy, and skeletal myopathies. Advancements in cryoelectron microscopy (cryoEM) have resulted in a partial elucidation of structures of the thin filament, revealing many atomic-level interactions between the component proteins and critical calcium-dependent conformational alterations. However, building models at the resolutions achieved can be challenging since landmarks in the maps are often missing or ambiguous. Therefore, current computational analyses including de novo structure prediction, protein-protein docking, molecular dynamics flexible fitting, and molecular dynamics simulations are needed to ensure good quality models. We review here our efforts to model the troponin T domain spanning the head-to-tail overlap domain of tropomyosin, improving previous models. Next, we refined the published cryoEM modeled structures, which had mistakenly compressed alpha helices, with a model that has expected helical parameters while matching densities in the cryoEM volume. Lastly, we used this model to reinterpret the interactions between tropomyosin and troponin I showing key features that hold the tropomyosin cable in its low-calcium, sterically blocking position. These revised thin filament models show improved intermolecular interactions in the key low- and high-calcium regulatory states, providing novel insights into function.

Humans and machines in biomedical knowledge curation: hypertrophic cardiomyopathy molecular mechanisms' representation

Background

Biomedical knowledge is dispersed in scientific literature and is growing constantly. Curation is the extraction of knowledge from unstructured data into a computable form and could be done manually or automatically. Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is the most common inherited cardiac disease, with genotype–phenotype associations still incompletely understood. We compared human- and machine-curated HCM molecular mechanisms’ models and examined the performance of different machine approaches for that task.

Results

We created six models representing HCM molecular mechanisms using different approaches and made them publicly available, analyzed them as networks, and tried to explain the models’ differences by the analysis of factors that affect the quality of machine-curated models (query constraints and reading systems’ performance). A result of this work is also the Interactive HCM map, the only publicly available knowledge resource dedicated to HCM. Sizes and topological parameters of the networks differed notably, and a low consensus was found in terms of centrality measures between networks. Consensus about the most important nodes was achieved only with respect to one element (calcium). Models with a reduced level of noise were generated and cooperatively working elements were detected. REACH and TRIPS reading systems showed much higher accuracy than Sparser, but at the cost of extraction performance. TRIPS proved to be the best single reading system for text segments about HCM, in terms of the compromise between accuracy and extraction performance.

Conclusions

Different approaches in curation can produce models of the same disease with diverse characteristics, and they give rise to utterly different conclusions in subsequent analysis. The final purpose of the model should direct the choice of curation techniques. Manual curation represents the gold standard for information extraction in biomedical research and is most suitable when only high-quality elements for models are required. Automated curation provides more substance, but high level of noise is expected. Different curation strategies can reduce the level of human input needed. Biomedical knowledge would benefit overwhelmingly, especially as to its rapid growth, if computers were to be able to assist in analysis on a larger scale.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13040-021-00279-2.

Shared Molecular Mechanisms of Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy and Its Clinical Presentations: Automated Molecular Mechanisms Extraction Approach

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is the most common inherited cardiovascular disease with a prevalence of 1 in 500 people and varying clinical presentations. Although there is much research on HCM, underlying molecular mechanisms are poorly understood, and research on the molecular mechanisms of its specific clinical presentations is scarce. Our aim was to explore the molecular mechanisms shared by HCM and its clinical presentations through the automated extraction of molecular mechanisms. Molecular mechanisms were congregated by a query of the INDRA database, which aggregates knowledge from pathway databases and combines it with molecular mechanisms extracted from abstracts and open-access full articles by multiple machine-reading systems. The molecular mechanisms were extracted from 230,072 articles on HCM and 19 HCM clinical presentations, and their intersections were found. Shared molecular mechanisms of HCM and its clinical presentations were represented as networks; the most important elements in the intersections’ networks were found, centrality scores for each element of each network calculated, networks with reduced level of noise generated, and cooperatively working elements detected in each intersection network. The identified shared molecular mechanisms represent possible mechanisms underlying different HCM clinical presentations. Applied methodology produced results consistent with the information in the scientific literature.

Hypertrophic and Dilated Cardiomyopathy-Associated Troponin T Mutations R130C and ΔK210 Oppositely Affect Length-Dependent Calcium Sensitivity of Force Generation

Length-dependent activation of calcium-dependent myocardial force generation provides the basis for the Frank-Starling mechanism. To directly compare the effects of mutations associated with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and dilated cardiomyopathy, the native troponin complex in skinned trabecular fibers of guinea pigs was exchanged with recombinant heterotrimeric, human, cardiac troponin complexes containing different human cardiac troponin T subunits (hcTnT): hypertrophic cardiomyopathy-associated hcTnT^R130C, dilated cardiomyopathy-associated hcTnT^ΔK210 or the wild type hcTnT (hcTnT^WT) serving as control. Force-calcium relations of exchanged fibers were explored at short fiber length defined as 110% of slack length (L₀) and long fiber length defined as 125% of L₀ (1.25 L₀). At short fiber length (1.1 L₀), calcium sensitivity of force generation expressed by −log [Ca²⁺] required for half-maximum force generation (pCa₅₀) was highest for the hypertrophic cardiomyopathy-associated mutation R130C (5.657 ± 0.019), intermediate for the wild type control (5.580 ± 0.028) and lowest for the dilated cardiomyopathy-associated mutation ΔK210 (5.325 ± 0.038). Lengthening fibers from 1.1 L₀ to 1.25 L₀ increased calcium sensitivity in fibers containing hcTnT^R130C (delta-pCa₅₀ = +0.030 ± 0.010), did not alter calcium sensitivity in the wild type control (delta-pCa₅₀ = −0.001 ± 0.010), and decreased calcium sensitivity in fibers containing hcTnT^ΔK210 (delta-pCa₅₀ = −0.034 ± 0.013). Length-dependent activation indicated by the delta-pCa₅₀ was highly significantly (P < 0.001) different between the two mutations. We hypothesize that primary effects of mutations on length-dependent activation contribute to the development of the diverging phenotypes in hypertrophic and dilated cardiomyopathy.

Implications of the complex biology and micro-environment of cardiac sarcomeres in the use of high affinity troponin antibodies as serum biomarkers for cardiac disorders

Cardiac troponin I (cTnI), the inhibitory-unit, and cardiac troponin T (cTnT), the tropomyosin-binding unit together with the Ca-binding unit (cTnC) of the hetero-trimeric troponin complex signal activation of the sarcomeres of the adult cardiac myocyte. The unique structure and heart myocyte restricted expression of cTnI and cTnT led to their worldwide use as biomarkers for acute myocardial infarction (AMI) beginning more than 30 years ago. Over these years, high sensitivity antibodies (hs-cTnI and hs-cTnT) have been developed. Together with careful determination of history, physical examination, and EKG, determination of serum levels using hs-cTnI and hs-cTnT permits risk stratification of patients presenting in the Emergency Department (ED) with chest pain. With the ability to determine serum levels of these troponins with high sensitivity came the question of whether such measurements may be of diagnostic and prognostic value in conditions beyond AMI. Moreover, the finding of elevated serum troponins in physiological states such as exercise and pathological states where cardiac myocytes may be affected requires understanding of how troponins may be released into the blood and whether such release may be benign. We consider these questions by relating membrane stability to the complex biology of troponin with emphasis on its sensitivity to the chemo-mechanical and micro-environment of the cardiac myocyte. We also consider the role determinations of serum troponins play in the precise phenotyping in personalized and precision medicine approaches to promote cardiac health.

•

Serum levels of cardiac TnI and cardiac TnT permit stratification of patients with chest pain.

•

Release of troponins into blood involves not only frank necrosis but also programmed necroptosis.

•

Genome wide analysis of serum troponin levels in the general population may be prognostic about cardiovascular health.

•

Significant levels of serum troponins with exhaustive exercise may not be benign.

•

Troponin in serum can lead to important data related to personalized and precision medicine.

Molecular Mechanisms of Pathologies of Skeletal and Cardiac Muscles Caused by Point Mutations in the Tropomyosin Genes

The review is devoted to tropomyosin (Tpm) - actin-binding protein, which plays a crucial role in the regulation of contraction of skeletal and cardiac muscles. Special attention is paid to myopathies and cardiomyopathies - severe hereditary diseases of skeletal and cardiac muscles associated with point mutations in Tpm genes. The current views on the molecular mechanisms of these diseases and the effects of such mutations on the Tpm structure and functions are considered in detail. Besides, some part of the review is devoted to analysis of the properties of Tpm homodimers and heterodimers with myopathic substitutions of amino acid residues in only one of the two chains of the Tpm dimeric molecule.

Modifications of Sarcoplasmic Reticulum Function Prevent Progression of Sarcomere-Linked Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy Despite a Persistent Increase in Myofilament Calcium Response

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is a genetic disorder caused by mutations in different genes mainly encoding myofilament proteins and therefore called a “disease of the sarcomere.” Despite the discovery of sarcomere protein mutations linked to HCM almost 30 years ago, the cellular mechanisms responsible for the development of this disease are not completely understood and likely vary among different mutations. Moreover, despite many efforts to develop effective treatments for HCM, these have largely been unsuccessful, and more studies are needed to better understand the cellular mechanisms of the disease. In experiments reported here, we investigated a mouse model expressing the mutant cTnT-R92Q, which is linked to HCM and induces an increase in myofilament Ca²⁺ sensitivity and diastolic dysfunction. We found that early correction of the diastolic dysfunction by phospholamban knockout (PLNKO) was able to prevent the development of the HCM phenotype in troponin T (TnT)-R92Q transgenic (TG) mice. Four groups of mice in FVB/N background were generated and used for the experiments: (1) non-transgenic (NTG)/PLN mice, which express wild-type TnT and normal level of PLN; (2) NTG/PLNKO mice, which express wild-type TnT and no PLN; (3) TG/PLN mice, which express TnT-R92Q and normal level of PLN; (4) TG/PLNKO mice, which express TnT-R92Q and no PLN. Cardiac function was determined using both standard echocardiographic parameters and speckle tracking strain measurements. We found that both atrial morphology and diastolic function were altered in TG/PLN mice but normal in TG/PLNKO mice. Histological analysis showed a disarray of myocytes and increased collagen deposition only in TG/PLN hearts. We also observed increased Ca²⁺/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) phosphorylation only in TG/PLN hearts but not in TG/PLNKO hearts. The rescue of the HCM phenotype was not associated with differences in myofilament Ca²⁺ sensitivity between TG/PLN and TG/PLNKO mice. Moreover, compared to standard systolic echo parameters, such as ejection fraction (EF), speckle strain measurements provided a more sensitive approach to detect early systolic dysfunction in TG/PLN mice. In summary, our results indicate that targeting diastolic dysfunction through altering Ca²⁺ fluxes with no change in myofilament response to Ca²⁺ was able to prevent the development of the HCM phenotype and should be considered as a potential additional treatment for HCM patients.

The intrinsically disordered C terminus of troponin T binds to troponin C to modulate myocardial force generation

Aberrant regulation of myocardial force production represents an early biomechanical defect associated with sarcomeric cardiomyopathies, but the molecular mechanisms remain poorly defined. Here, we evaluated the pathogenicity of a previously unreported sarcomeric gene variant identified in a pediatric patient with sporadic dilated cardiomyopathy, and we determined a molecular mechanism. Trio whole-exome sequencing revealed a de novo missense variant in TNNC1 that encodes a p.I4M substitution in the N-terminal helix of cardiac troponin C (cTnC). Reconstitution of this human cTnC variant into permeabilized porcine cardiac muscle preparations significantly decreases the magnitude and rate of isometric force generation at physiological Ca2+-activation levels. Computational modeling suggests that this inhibitory effect can be explained by a decrease in the rates of cross-bridge attachment and detachment. For the first time, we show that cardiac troponin T (cTnT), in part through its intrinsically disordered C terminus, directly binds to WT cTnC, and we find that this cardiomyopathic variant displays tighter binding to cTnT. Steady-state fluorescence and NMR spectroscopy studies suggest that this variant propagates perturbations in cTnC structural dynamics to distal regions of the molecule. We propose that the intrinsically disordered C terminus of cTnT directly interacts with the regulatory N-domain of cTnC to allosterically modulate Ca2+ activation of force, perhaps by controlling the troponin I switching mechanism of striated muscle contraction. Alterations in cTnC-cTnT binding may compromise contractile performance and trigger pathological remodeling of the myocardium.

New insights provided by myofibril mechanics in inherited cardiomyopathies

Cardiomyopathies represent a heterogeneous group of cardiac disorders that perturb cardiac contraction and/or relaxation, and can result in arrhythmias, heart failure, and sudden cardiac death. Based on morphological and functional differences, cardiomyopathies have been classified into hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM), dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), and restrictive cardiomyopathy (RCM). It has been well documented that mutations in genes encoding sarcomeric proteins are associated with the onset of inherited cardiomyopathies. However, correlating patient genotype to the clinical phenotype has been challenging because of the complex genetic backgrounds, environmental influences, and lifestyles of individuals. Thus, "scaling down" the focus to the basic contractile unit of heart muscle using isolated single myofibril function techniques is of great importance and may be used to understand the molecular basis of disease-causing sarcomeric mutations. Single myofibril bundles harvested from diseased human or experimental animal hearts, as well as cultured adult cardiomyocytes or human cardiomyocytes derived from induced pluripotent stem cells, can be used, thereby providing an ideal multi-level, cross-species platform to dissect sarcomeric function in cardiomyopathies. Here, we will review the myofibril function technique, and discuss alterations in myofibril mechanics, which are known to occur in sarcomeric genetic mutations linked to inherited HCM, DCM, and RCM, and describe the therapeutic potential for future target identification.

Multiscale Models of Cardiac Muscle Biophysics and Tissue Remodeling in Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathies

Myocardial hypertrophy is the result of sustained perturbations to the mechanical and/or neurohormonal homeostasis of cardiac cells and is driven by integrated, multiscale biophysical and biochemical processes that are currently not well defined. In this brief review, we highlight recent computational and experimental models of cardiac hypertrophy that span mechanisms from the molecular level to the tissue level. Specifically, we focus on: (i) molecular-level models of the structural dynamics of sarcomere proteins in hypertrophic hearts, (ii) cellular-level models of excitation-contraction coupling and mechanosensitive signaling in disease-state myocytes, and (iii) organ-level models of myocardial growth kinematics and predictors thereof. Finally, we discuss how spanning these scales and combining multiple experimental/computational models will provide new information about the processes governing hypertrophy and potential methods to prevent or reverse them.

Kettin, the large actin-binding protein with multiple immunoglobulin domains, is essential for sarcomeric actin assembly and larval development in Caenorhabditis elegans

Among many essential genes in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, let-330 is located on the left arm of chromosome V and was identified as the largest target of a mutagen in this region. However, let-330 gene has not been characterized at the molecular level. Here, we report that two sequenced let-330 alleles are nonsense mutations of ketn-1, a previously characterized gene encoding kettin. Kettin is a large actin-binding protein of 472 kDa with 31 immunoglobulin domains and is expressed in muscle cells in C. elegans. let-330/ketn-1 mutants are homozygous lethal at the first larval stage with mild defects in body elongation. These mutants have severe defects in sarcomeric actin and myosin assembly in striated muscle. However, α-actinin and vinculin, which are components of the dense bodies anchoring actin to the membranes, were not significantly disorganized by let-330/ketn-1 mutation. Kettin localizes to embryonic myofibrils before α-actinin is expressed, and α-actinin deficiency does not affect kettin localization in larval muscle. Depletion of vinculin minimally affects kettin localization but significantly reduces colocalization of actin with kettin in embryonic muscle cells. These results indicate that kettin is an essential protein for sarcomeric assembly of actin filaments in muscle cells.

The Effect of Tropomyosin Mutations on Actin-Tropomyosin Binding: In Search of Lost Time

The initial binding of tropomyosin onto actin filaments and then its polymerization into continuous cables on the filament surface must be precisely tuned to overall thin-filament structure, function, and performance. Low-affinity interaction of tropomyosin with actin has to be sufficiently strong to localize the tropomyosin on actin, yet not so tight that regulatory movement on filaments is curtailed. Likewise, head-to-tail association of tropomyosin molecules must be favorable enough to promote tropomyosin cable formation but not so tenacious that polymerization precedes filament binding. Arguably, little molecular detail on early tropomyosin binding steps has been revealed since Wegner's seminal studies on filament assembly almost 40 years ago. Thus, interpretation of mutation-based actin-tropomyosin binding anomalies leading to cardiomyopathies cannot be described fully. In vitro, tropomyosin binding is masked by explosive tropomyosin polymerization once cable formation is initiated on actin filaments. In contrast, in silico analysis, characterizing molecular dynamics simulations of single wild-type and mutant tropomyosin molecules on F-actin, is not complicated by tropomyosin polymerization at all. In fact, molecular dynamics performed here demonstrates that a midpiece tropomyosin domain is essential for normal actin-tropomyosin interaction and that this interaction is strictly conserved in a number of tropomyosin mutant species. Elsewhere along these mutant molecules, twisting and bending corrupts the tropomyosin superhelices as they "lose their grip" on F-actin. We propose that residual interactions displayed by these mutant tropomyosin structures with actin mimic ones that occur in early stages of thin-filament generation, as if the mutants are recapitulating the assembly process but in reverse. We conclude therefore that an initial binding step in tropomyosin assembly onto actin involves interaction of the essential centrally located domain.