Development of the neonatal rabbit retina in organ culture. 1. Comparison with histogenesis in vivo, and the effect of a gliotoxin (alpha-aminoadipic acid)

Retinal explant culture: A platform to investigate human neuro-retina

The retina is the tissue responsible for light detection, in which retinal neurons convert light energy into electrical signals to be transported towards the visual cortex. Damage of retinal neurons leads to neuronal cell death and retinal pathologies, compromising visual acuity and eventually leading to irreversible blindness. Models of retinal neurodegeneration include 2D systems like cell lines, disassociated cultures and co-cultures, and 3D models like organoids, organotypic retinal cultures and animal models. Of these, ex vivo human retinal cultures are arguably the most suitable models for translational research as they retain complex inter-cellular interactions of the retina and precisely mimic in-situ responses. In this review, we summarize the distinguishing features of the human retina which are important to preserve in experimental culture, the historical development of human retinal culture systems, the factors affecting ex vivo human retinal culture and the applications and challenges associated with current methods of human retinal explant culture.

Development of the New Zealand White Rabbit Eye: I. Pre- and Postnatal Development of Eye Tunics

The New Zealand white (NZW) rabbit has been and is right now regularly utilized in ophthalmic surgery evaluation. Inside NZW rabbit eye, the visibility of ocular structures throughout surgical procedure is fantastic. Younger rabbits are used in different ages for the evaluation of ophthalmic surgery. Complete studies of ocular development in the NZW rabbits have not been reported previously. The aim of the present investigation was to describe the major landmarks and the time course of the pre- and post-natal development of the complete eye tunics of the NZW rabbit to give a superb model as well as a fruitful area for further ophthalmological investigations. Serial histological sections of NZW rabbit prenatal (E13-E28) and post-natal (P1-P14) stages were examined, respectively. The eye of the NZW rabbit developed in a similar manner to that of the human and domestic animals eyes; the principal differences were at the time of occurrence of certain developmental events, absence of pigmentation which represent an exploited benefit for ophthalmic surgery, remarkable Bowman's membrane at E25, poor developed ciliary stroma and juvenile retinal layer until P9. In human, the basic morphogenetic processes of the development of eye tunics are completed towards the end of the first half of gestation period. However, the latter represents the beginning stage of the development of eye tunics in the rabbit. Thus, allowing various extensive ophthalmic researches to be performed.

PEDF counteracts DL-α-aminoadipate toxicity and rescues gliotoxic damages in RPE-free chicken retinal explants

Gliotoxic responses complicate human eye diseases, the causes of which often remain obscure. Here, we activated Müller cells (MCs) by the gliotoxin DL-α-aminoadipate (AAA) and assayed possible protective effects by pigment epithelium-derived factor (PEDF) in RPE-free retinal explants of the E6 chick embryo. These models are suited to analyze gliotoxic reactions in vitro, since the avian retina contains only Müller cells (MCs) as glial components, and the RPE-free explants are devoid of a major PEDF source. ChAT- and AChE-immunohistochemistry (IHC) revealed that AAA treatment disrupted the differentiation of cholinergic amacrine cells in the inner plexiform layer. At the applied concentration of 1 mM AAA, apoptosis of MCs was slightly increased, as shown by TUNEL and caspase-3 activity assays. Concomitantly, cell-free gaps emerged in the middle of the retina, where MCs were swollen and amassed glutamine synthetase (shown by GS and Vimentin IHC). AAA treatment strongly activated MCs, as shown by GFAP IHC, and by an increase of stress-related catalase activity. Remarkably, nearly all effects of AAA on MCs were effectively counter-balanced by 50 ng/ml PEDF co-treatment, as also shown by RT-PCR. These findings suggest that supplementation with PEDF can protect the retina against gliotoxic attacks. Further studies should establish whether PEDF similarly protects a gliotoxic human retina.

Organotypic culture of neural retina as a research model of neurodegeneration of ganglion cells

Organotypic models deserve special attention among the large variety of methods of vertebrate retina cultivation. The purpose of this study was to make a detailed qualitative and quantitative characterization of a model employing roller organotypic cultivation of the neural retina of rat eye posterior segment, with special attention to morphological and functional characteristics of retinal ganglion cells. The study included morphological analysis of retina histological preparations as well as estimation of RNA synthesis and evaluation of neuron survival by the Brachet and TUNEL methods, respectively. Retina has been shown to display normal morphofunctional characteristics for the first 12 h of cultivation. After 24 h, a substantial number of ganglion cells underwent pyknosis and stopped RNA synthesis. Almost all the cells of the retinal ganglion layer became apoptotic by 3-4 days in vitro. In the course of cultivation, neural retina is detached from the underlying layers of the posterior eye segment and undergoes significant cytoarchitectonic changes. The causes of ganglion cell death during organotypic cultivation of eye posterior segment are discussed. This method can serve as a suitable model for the screening of new retinoprotectors and for research on ganglion cell death resulting from retina degenerative diseases, e.g. glaucoma.

Retinal vascular changes after glial disruption in rats

Glial dysfunction is found in a number of retinal vascular diseases but its link with blood-retinal barrier (BRB) breakdown remains poorly understood. The present study tested the hypothesis that glial dysfunction is a major contributor to the BRB breakdown that is a hallmark of retinal vascular diseases. We investigated the specificity of the purportedly selective glial toxin, DL-alpha-aminoadipic acid (DL-alpha-AAA) on different types of ocular cells in vitro and then tested the effect of glial disruption on retinal vasculature after intraocular injection of DL-alpha-AAA or siRNA targeting glutamine synthetase (GS) in rats. DL-alpha-AAA was toxic to astrocytes and Müller cells but not to other types of BRB-related cells in vitro. Subretinal injection of DL-alpha-AAA disrupted retinal glial cells, induced vascular telangiectasis and increased vascular permeability from 4 days to over 2 months post-injection. Vascular changes induced by DL-alpha-AAA were observed predominantly in regions of glial disruption, as reflected by reduced expression of GS and increased expression of glial fibrillary acidic protein and vimentin. Confocal microscopy showed changes in all three layers of the retinal vasculature, which co-localised with areas of Müller cell disruption. Double labeling immunohistochemistry revealed that retinal glial disruption after DL-alpha-AAA injection was accompanied by increased expression of vascular endothelial growth factor and reduced expression of the tight junction protein claudin-5. Intravitreal injection of GS siRNA induced similar changes in Müller cells and BRB breakdown. Our data are consistent with the hypothesis that glial dysfunction is a primary contributor to the BRB breakdown in retinal vascular diseases.

Structural changes in the developing retina maintained in vitro

The present study examined the emergence of structural remodeling in explanted neonatal rat retina. Immunohistochemical analysis demonstrated signs of glial and neuronal remodeling after 11 days in vitro and included the activation of Müller cells, the formation of ectopic neuropil areas and sprouting of photoreceptor terminals. We also observed that cholinergic and GABA-ergic amacrine cells displayed signs of disorganized laminations. These results demonstrate that retinal culturing initiates structural changes that show morphological similarities to glial and neuronal remodeling identified in retinitis pigmentosa retinas and experimentally detached retinas.

Müller cells in allogeneic adult rabbit retinal transplants

Müller cell morphology and degree of activation in adult retinal transplants have, to our knowledge, never been reported previously. We transplanted adult rabbit neuroretinal full-thickness sheets, prepared under strict control, to the subretinal space of adult rabbits. After surviving 6-174 days, eyes were examined in the light microscope, and grafts displaying the normal laminated morphology were labeled with antibodies against vimentin and glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP). Müller cells in the grafts displayed the normal vertical arrangement, from outer limiting membrane to vitread endfeet. They showed an initial degree of activation, evident by GFAP upregulation, which diminished with increasing survival times, and was absent in the oldest specimens. In the host retina, Müller cells in the transplant area became progressively more disorganized with increasing survival times, and their degree of activation increased. Our results suggests that adult full-thickness neuroretinal grafts are structurally stable, even in long-term specimens, and thrive in spite of their allogeneic environment. The gliotic change seen in the host retina covering the graft is identical to the one seen in earlier reported eyes receiving embryonic grafts, and is due to the merangiotic nature of the rabbit neuroretina.

Mouse retina explants after long-term culture in serum free medium

The neonatal mouse retina remains viable as an explant in serum-supplemented growth media for more than 4 weeks. Interpretation of drug effects on this tissue is compromised by the enigmatic composition of the serum. We sought to remove this ambiguity by culturing neonatal as well as late postnatal mouse retina in serum-free nutrient medium. In this study three important observations were made, (1) there is histotypic development of neonatal as well as preservation of late postnatal mouse retinal structure during long-term culture in serum-free medium, although the late postnatal tissue tends to show some loss of cells in the outer nuclear layer. (2) Protein expression in explant photoreceptor cells was similar to that in the litter-matched ones, except for green cone opsin and interphotoreceptor retinoid-binding protein, although mRNA of the latter is present at similar amounts as in age-matched in vivo controls. (3) Cells of the inner retina stained by antibodies to calcium-binding proteins display some novel sprouting of processes. The results show that the mouse retina can be cultured as an explant for more than 4 weeks in a serum-free medium. This represents an important step forward because, (1) the possibility of interference of drug effects by unknown serum factors has been eliminated; and (2) the spent culture medium can be analyzed to investigate biomolecules released by the retina in vitro.

Cell differentiation, synaptogenesis, and influence of the retinal pigment epithelium in a rat neonatal organotypic retina culture

This study was focused on the analysis of cell type differentiation and synaptogenesis as well as outer segment formation in an organotypic culture of the neonatal rat retina during a 6-14 day period of in vitro development. Moreover, the effects of the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) on these processes were investigated. The in vitro development resulted in a retinal architecture and lamination comparable to that of in vivo retinas. The RPE influences the proper alignment of photoreceptors as well as the formation of the outer limiting membrane (OLM), but not processes of cell differentiation, synaptogenesis and inner retinal lamination.

Developmental regulation of calcium channel-mediated currents in retinal glial (Müller) cells

Whole cell voltage-clamp recordings of freshly isolated cells were used to study changes in the currents through voltage-gated Ca(2+) channels during the postnatal development of immature radial glial cells into Müller cells of the rabbit retina. Using Ba(2+) or Ca(2+) ions as charge carriers, currents through transient low-voltage-activated (LVA) Ca(2+) channels were recorded in cells from early postnatal stages, with an activation threshold at -60 mV and a peak current at -25 mV. To increase the amplitude of currents through Ca(2+) channels, Na(+) ions were used as the main charge carriers, and currents were recorded in divalent cation-free bath solutions. Currents through transient LVA Ca(2+) channels were found in all radial glial cells from retinae between postnatal days 2 and 37. The currents activated at potentials positive to -80 mV and displayed a maximum at -40 mV. The amplitude of LVA currents increased during the first postnatal week; after postnatal day 6, the amplitude remained virtually constant. The density of LVA currents was highest at early postnatal days (days 2-5: 13 pA/pF) and decreased to a stable, moderate level within the first three postnatal weeks (3 pA/pF). A significant expression of currents through sustained, high-voltage-activated Ca(2+) channels was found after the third postnatal week in approximately 25% of the investigated cells. The early and sole expression of transient currents at high-density may suggest that LVA Ca(2+) channels are involved in early developmental processes of rabbit Müller cells.

Growth of postnatal rat retina in vitro. Development of neurotransmitter systems

In this study, we demonstrate that explanted neonatal rat retina can be maintained in culture for periods up to 3 weeks. The cultured retinas displayed a distinct layering that was almost identical to litter-matched retinas of the same age, but the majority of the ganglion cells did not survive and photoreceptor outer segments did not develop properly. Distinct synaptophysin immunoreactivity was expressed in both the inner and outer plexiform layers of cultured retina and the pattern mimicked that one observed in vivo. After 2-3 weeks in vitro, the inner retina expressed immunoreactivities to various components of the cholinergic and nitrergic transmitter systems, including nitric oxide activated cyclic GMP immunoreactivity. The investigated cell populations displayed similar distribution patterns as in situ, but morphological differences appeared in vitro. Such differences were mainly observed as irregularities in the arborization patterns in the inner part of the inner plexiform layer. We suggest that these discrepancies may arise as a result of reduced ganglion cell survival. Our observations demonstrate that some neurotransmitter systems develop in vitro and their neural circuitry appears similar to the in vivo situation. The presence of synapses, receptor proteins and transmitter substances implies that neural communication can occur in cultured retinas.

Role of glial K(+) channels in ontogeny and gliosis: a hypothesis based upon studies on Müller cells

The electrophysiological properties of Müller cells, the principal glial cells of the retina, are determined by several types of K(+) conductances. Both the absolute and the relative activities of the individual types of K(+) channels undergo important changes in the course of ontogenetic development and during gliosis. Although immature Müller cells express inwardly rectifying K(+) (K(IR)) currents at a very low density, the membrane of normal mature Müller cells is predominated by the K(IR) conductance. The K(IR) channels mediate spatial buffering K(+) currents and maintain a stable hyperpolarized membrane potential necessary for various glial-neuronal interactions. During "conservative" (i.e., non-proliferative) reactive gliosis, the K(IR) conductance of Müller cells is moderately reduced and the cell membrane is slightly depolarized; however, when gliotic Müller cells become proliferative, their K(IR) conductances are dramatically down-regulated; this is accompanied by an increased activity of Ca(2+)-activated K(+) channels and by a conspicuous unstability of their membrane potential. The resultant variations of the membrane potential may increase the activity of depolarization-activated K(+), Na(+) and Ca(2+) channels. It is concluded that in respect to their K(+) current pattern, mature Müller cells pass through a process of dedifferentiation before proliferative activity is initiated.

9-cis-retinoic acid in combination with retinal pigment epithelium induces apoptosis in cultured retinal explants only during early postnatal development

Retinoic acid is one of the active metabolites of vitamin A and has profound effects on the development of the CNS including retina. Previously, we have shown that rod-specific apoptosis is induced in retinal explants from neonatal mice by exposure to 9-cis-retinoic acid (9CRA) when the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) is present. In explants lacking RPE, it instead has a differentiation-promoting effect seen as an accelerated opsin expression on postnatal day 3. To investigate the long-term effect of 9CRA exposure, we have explanted retinas from neonatal C3H mice with or without RPE attached and placed in organ culture. After 19 or 48 h in culture or 7, 8 or 13 days in culture, the explants were either fixed for histochemical examination or frozen for assay of DEVDase activity. We found that long-term exposure to 9CRA caused a decrease in the number of cell layers in the outer nuclear layer (ONL) only in explants with the RPE attached. When explants with RPE attached were exposed to 9CRA only during the second postnatal week, neither an increase in DEVDase activity, TUNEL-positive cells, nor a decrease in cell layers of the ONL could be demonstrated, indicating that the retina was insensitive to the apoptosis-inducing effect of 9CRA after the first postnatal week. The absence of RPE in control explants resulted in a higher number of rosettes and the extrusion of cells into the subretinal space.

Expression of beta-amyloid precursor and Bcl-2 proto-oncogene proteins in rat retinas after intravitreal injection of aminoadipic acid

In order to investigate the role of glia in relation to factors that affect the expression of beta-amyloid precursor protein (betaAPP) and B cell lymphoma oncogene protein (Bcl-2) in the central nervous tissue, the patterns of expression of betaAPP and Bcl-2 in developing and mature rat retinas were studied immunocytochemically after intravitreal injection of alpha-aminoadipic acid (alpha-AAA), a glutamate analogue and gliotoxin that is known to cause injury of retinal Müller glial cells. In normal developing retinas, betaAPP and Bcl-2 were expressed primarily but transiently in a small number of neurons in the ganglion cell layer during the first postnatal week. Immunoreactivity of betaAPP and Bcl-2 appeared in the endfeet and proximal part of the radial processes of Müller glial cells from the second postnatal week onwards. In rats that received intravitreal injection of alpha-AAA at birth, there was a loss of immunoreactivity to vimentin, and a delayed expressed on betaAPP or Bcl-2 in Muller glial cells until 3-5 weeks post-injection. Immunoreactive neurons were also observed in the inner retina especially in the ganglion cell layer from 5 to 35 days after injection. A significant reduction in numerical density of cells with large somata in the ganglion cell layer was observed in the neonatally injected retinas at P56, which was accompanied by an increased immunostaining in radial processes of Müller glial cells. In contrast, no detectable changes in the expression of betaAPP and Bcl-2 were observed in retina that received alpha-AAA as adults. These results indicate that the gliotoxin alpha-AAA has long lasting effects on the expression of betaAPP and Bcl-2 in Müller glial cells as well as neurons in the developing but not mature retinas. The loss of vimentin and delayed expression of betaAPP and Bcl-2 in developing Müller glial cells suggests that the metabolic integrity of Müller cells was temporarily compromised, which may have adverse effects on developing neurons that are vulnerable or dependent on trophic support from the Müller glial cells.

Expression of potassium channels during postnatal differentiation of rabbit Müller glial cells

The postnatal maturation of Müller glial cells from immature radial glial cells is accompanied by specific changes in the activity of distinct types of K+ channels, as shown by whole-cell and cell-attached records on freshly isolated cells from retinae of young (postnatal days 1-30, P1-P30) and adult rabbits. (i) The density of inwardly rectifying currents, providing the main K+ conductance in adult Müller cells, was very low (0.8 pA/pF) from P1 to P6 but increased rapidly thereafter until a relatively stable level of 11.0 pA/pF was established at P17. (ii) Transient (A-type) K+ currents were expressed in all immature cells at a high density (9.6 pA/pF). After P12, both the percentage of cells with A-type currents and the peak amplitudes of the currents (2.8 pA/pF) declined. (iii) Delayed rectifying K+ currents developed slowly until after P30. (iv) The postnatal maturation of radial glial cells was accompanied by a strong decrease in the activity of large-conductance, Ca2+-activated K+ channels, the open probability of which (measured at the resting membrane potential) decreased from 0.69 at P2-4 to 0.06 at P13-14. The developmental decrease of the activity of Ca2+-activated K+ channels is assumed to be mainly caused by alteration of the resting membrane potential which developed from low values (-49 mV) at P1-6 to high adult values (-84 mV) after P13. The activity of each distinct type of K+ channel investigated is differently modulated by developmental regulation. This may reflect different functional requirements of immature and mature Müller cells.