Tiered analysis of whole-exome sequencing for epilepsy diagnosis

Genetic variant interpretation for the neurologist - A pragmatic approach in the next-generation sequencing era in childhood epilepsy

Genetic advances over the past decade have enhanced our understanding of the genetic landscape of childhood epilepsy. However a major challenge for clinicians ha been understanding the rationale and systematic approach towards interpretation of the clinical significance of variant(s) detected in their patients. As the clinical paradigm evolves from gene panels to whole exome or whole genome testing including rapid genome sequencing, the number of patients tested and variants identified per patient will only increase. Each step in the process of variant interpretation has limitations and there is no single criterion which enables the clinician to draw reliable conclusions on a causal relationship between the variant and disease without robust clinical phenotyping. Although many automated online analysis software tools are available, these carry a risk of misinterpretation. This guideline provides a pragmatic, real-world approach to variant interpretation for the child neurologist. The focus will be on ascertaining aspects such as variant frequency, subtype, inheritance pattern, structural and functional consequence with regard to genotype-phenotype correlations, while refraining from mere interpretation of the classification provided in a genetic test report. It will not replace the expert advice of colleagues in clinical genetics, however as genomic investigations become a first-line test for epilepsy, it is vital that neurologists and epileptologists are equipped to navigate this landscape.

Refining the electroclinical spectrum of NPRL3-related epilepsy: A novel multiplex family and literature review

OBJECTIVE

NPRL3-related epilepsy (NRE) is an emerging condition set within the wide GATOR-1 spectrum with a particularly heterogeneous and elusive phenotypic expression. Here, we delineated the genotype-phenotype spectrum of NRE, reporting an illustrative familial case and reviewing pertinent literature.

METHODS

Through exome sequencing (ES), we investigated a 12-year-old girl with recurrent focal motor seizures during sleep, suggestive of sleep-related hypermotor epilepsy (SHE), and a family history of epilepsy in siblings. Variant segregation analysis was performed by Sanger sequencing. All previously published NRE patients were thoroughly reviewed and their electroclinical features were analyzed and compared with the reported subjects.

RESULTS

In the proband, ES detected the novel NPRL3 frameshift variant (NM_001077350.3): c.151_152del (p.Thr51Glyfs*5). This variant is predicted to cause a loss of function and segregated in one affected brother. The review of 76 patients from 18 publications revealed the predominance of focal-onset seizures (67/74-90%), with mainly frontal and frontotemporal (32/67-47.7%), unspecified (19/67-28%), or temporal (9/67-13%) onset. Epileptic syndromes included familial focal epilepsy with variable foci (FFEVF) (29/74-39%) and SHE (11/74-14.9%). Fifteen patients out of 60 (25%) underwent epilepsy surgery, 11 of whom achieved complete seizure remission (11/15-73%). Focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) type 2A was the most frequent histopathological finding.

SIGNIFICANCE

We reported an illustrative NPRL3-related epilepsy (NRE) family with incomplete penetrance. This condition consists of a heterogeneous spectrum of clinical and neuroradiological features. Focal-onset motor seizures are predominant, and almost half of the cases fulfill the criteria for SHE or FFEVF. MRI-negative cases are prevalent, but the association with malformations of cortical developments (MCDs) is significant, especially FCD type 2a. The beneficial impact of epilepsy surgery in patients with MCD-related epilepsy further supports the inclusion of brain MRI in the workup of NRE patients.

A cryptic microdeletion del(12)(p11.21p11.23) within an unbalanced translocation t(7;12)(q21.13;q23.1) implicates new candidate loci for intellectual disability and Kallmann syndrome

In a patient diagnosed with both Kallmann syndrome (KS) and intellectual disability (ID), who carried an apparently balanced translocation t(7;12)(q22;q24)dn, array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) disclosed a cryptic heterozygous 4.7 Mb deletion del(12)(p11.21p11.23), unrelated to the translocation breakpoint. This novel discovery prompted us to consider the possibility that the combination of KS and neurological disorder in this patient could be attributed to gene(s) within this specific deletion at 12p11.21-12p11.23, rather than disrupted or dysregulated genes at the translocation breakpoints. To further support this hypothesis, we expanded our study by screening five candidate genes at both breakpoints of the chromosomal translocation in a cohort of 48 KS patients. However, no mutations were found, thus reinforcing our supposition. In order to delve deeper into the characterization of the 12p11.21-12p11.23 region, we enlisted six additional patients with small copy number variations (CNVs) and analyzed eight individuals carrying small CNVs in this region from the DECIPHER database. Our investigation utilized a combination of complementary approaches. Firstly, we conducted a comprehensive phenotypic-genotypic comparison of reported CNV cases. Additionally, we reviewed knockout animal models that exhibit phenotypic similarities to human conditions. Moreover, we analyzed reported variants in candidate genes and explored their association with corresponding phenotypes. Lastly, we examined the interacting genes associated with these phenotypes to gain further insights. As a result, we identified a dozen candidate genes: TSPAN11 as a potential KS candidate gene, TM7SF3, STK38L, ARNTL2, ERGIC2, TMTC1, DENND5B, and ETFBKMT as candidate genes for the neurodevelopmental disorder, and INTS13, REP15, PPFIBP1, and FAR2 as candidate genes for KS with ID. Notably, the high-level expression pattern of these genes in relevant human tissues further supported their candidacy. Based on our findings, we propose that dosage alterations of these candidate genes may contribute to sexual and/or cognitive impairments observed in patients with KS and/or ID. However, the confirmation of their causal roles necessitates further identification of point mutations in these candidate genes through next-generation sequencing.

Functional investigation of SCN1A deep-intronic variants activating poison exons inclusion

Dravet syndrome is a devastating epileptic syndrome characterized by intractable epilepsy with an early age of onset, regression of developmental milestones, ataxia, and motor deficits. Loss-of-function pathogenic variants in the SCN1A gene are found in the majority of patients with Dravet syndrome; however, a significant number of patients remain undiagnosed even after comprehensive genetic testing. Previously, it was shown that intronic elements in the SCN1A gene called poison exons can incorporate into SCN1A mRNA, leading to haploinsufficiency and potentially causing Dravet syndrome. Here, we developed a splicing reporter assay for all described poison exons of the SCN1A gene and validated it using previously reported and artificially introduced variants. Overall, we tested 18 deep-intronic single nucleotide variants and one complex allele in the SCN1A gene. Our approach is capable of evaluating the effect of both variants affecting cis-regulatory sequences and splice-site variants, with the potential to functionally annotate every possible variant within these elements. Moreover, using antisense-modified uridine-rich U7 small nuclear RNAs, we were able to block poison exon incorporation in mutant constructs, an approach that could be used as a promising therapeutic intervention in Dravet syndrome patients with deep-intronic variants.

A microdeletion del(12)(p11.21p11.23) with a cryptic unbalanced translocation t(7;12)(q21.13;q23.1) implicates new candidate loci for intellectual disability and Kallmann syndrome

In an apparently balanced translocation t(7;12)(q22;q24)dn exhibiting both Kallmann syndrome (KS) and intellectual disability (ID), we detected a cryptic heterozygous 4.7 Mb del(12)(p11.21p11.23) unrelated to the translocation breakpoint. This new finding raised the possibility that KS combined with neurological disorder in this patient could be caused by gene(s) within this deletion at 12p11.21-12p11.23 instead of disrupted or dysregulated genes at the genomic breakpoints. Screening of five candidate genes at both breakpoints in 48 KS patients we recruited found no mutation, corroborating our supposition. To substantiate this hypothesis further, we recruited six additional subjects with small CNVs and analyzed eight individuals carrying small CNVs in this region from DECIPHER to dissect 12p11.21-12p11.23. We used multiple complementary approaches including a phenotypic-genotypic comparison of reported cases, a review of knockout animal models recapitulating the human phenotypes, and analyses of reported variants in the interacting genes with corresponding phenotypes. The results identified one potential KS candidate gene ( TSPAN11 ), seven candidate genes for the neurodevelopmental disorder ( TM7SF3 , STK38L , ARNTL2 , ERGIC2 , TMTC1 , DENND5B , and ETFBKMT ), and four candidate genes for KS with ID ( INTS13 , REP15 , PPFIBP1 , and FAR2 ). The high-level expression pattern in the relevant human tissues further suggested the candidacy of these genes. We propose that the dosage alterations of the candidate genes may contribute to sexual and/or cognitive impairment in patients with KS and/or ID. Further identification of point mutations through next generation sequencing will be necessary to confirm their causal roles.

In-silico analysis of nonsynonymous genomic variants within CCM2 gene reaffirm the existence of dual cores within typical PTB domain

Purpose

The objective of this study is to validate the existence of dual cores within the typical phosphotyrosine binding (PTB) domain and to identify potentially damaging and pathogenic nonsynonymous coding single nuclear polymorphisms (nsSNPs) in the canonical PTB domain of the CCM2 gene that causes cerebral cavernous malformations (CCMs).

Methods

The nsSNPs within the coding sequence for PTB domain of human CCM2 gene, retrieved from exclusive database searches, were analyzed for their functional and structural impact using a series of bioinformatic tools. The effects of mutations on the tertiary structure of the PTB domain in human CCM2 protein were predicted to examine the effect of nsSNPs on the tertiary structure of PTB Cores.

Results

Our mutation analysis, through alignment of protein structures between wildtype CCM2 and mutant, predicted that the structural impacts of pathogenic nsSNPs is biophysically limited to only the spatially adjacent substituted amino acid site with minimal structural influence on the adjacent core of the PTB domain, suggesting both cores are independently functional and essential for proper CCM2 PTB function.

Conclusion

Utilizing a combination of protein conservation and structure-based analysis, we analyzed the structural effects of inherited pathogenic mutations within the CCM2 PTB domain. Our results predicted that the pathogenic amino acid substitutions lead to only subtle changes locally, confined to the surrounding tertiary structure of the PTB core within which it resides, while no structural disturbance to the neighboring PTB core was observed, reaffirming the presence of independently functional dual cores in the CCM2 typical PTB domain.

•

The pathogenic amino acid mutants lead to subtle structural changes in the PTB core.

•

No structural disturbance to the neighboring PTB core was observed.

•

Data reaffirm the presence of dual functional cores in the CCM2 PTB domain.

•

More new genetic variants leading to CCM pathogenesis were suggested.

Genetic Diagnosis Spectrum and Multigenic Burden of Exome-Level Rare Variants in a Childhood Epilepsy Cohort

Childhood epilepsy is a considerably heterogeneous neurological condition with a high worldwide incidence. Genetic diagnosis of childhood epilepsy provides the most accurate pathogenetic evidence; however, a large proportion of highly suspected cases remain undiagnosed. Accumulation of rare variants at the exome level as a multigenic burden contributing to childhood epilepsy should be further evaluated. In this retrospective analysis, exome-level sequencing was used to depict the mutation spectra of 294 childhood epilepsy patients from Shanghai Children’s Medical Center, Department of Neurology. Furthermore, variant information from exome sequencing data was analyzed apart from monogenic diagnostic purposes to elucidate the possible multigenic burden of rare variants related to epilepsy pathogenesis. Exome sequencing reached a diagnostic rate of 30.61% and identified six genes not currently listed in the epilepsy-associated gene list. A multigenic burden study revealed a three-fold possibility that deleterious missense mutations in ion channel and synaptic genes in the undiagnosed cohort may contribute to the genetic risk of childhood epilepsy, whereas variants in the gene categories of cell growth, metabolic, and regulatory function showed no significant difference. Our study provides a comprehensive overview of the genetic diagnosis of a Chinese childhood epilepsy cohort and provides novel insights into the genetic background of these patients. Harmful missense mutations in genes related to ion channels and synapses are most likely to produce a multigenic burden in childhood epilepsy.

Genetic cause of epilepsy in a Greek cohort of children and young adults with heterogeneous epilepsy syndromes

We describe a cohort of 10 unrelated Greek patients (4 females, 6 males; median age 6.5 years, range 2-18 years) with heterogeneous epilepsy syndromes with a genetic basis. In these patients, causative genetic variants, including two novel ones, were identified in 9 known epilepsy-related genes through whole exome sequencing. A patient with glycine encephalopathy was a compound heterozygote for the p.Arg222Cys and the p.Ser77Leu AMT variant. A patient affected with Lafora disease carried the homozygous p.Arg171His EPM2A variant. A de novo heterozygous variant in the GABRG2 gene (p.Pro282Thr) was found in one patient and a pathogenic variant in the GRIN2B gene (p.Gly820Val) in another patient. Infantile-onset lactic acidosis with seizures was associated with the p.Arg446Ter PDHX gene variant in one patient. In two additional epilepsy patients, the p.Ala1662Val and the novel non-sense p.Phe1330Ter SCN1A gene variants were found. Finally, in 3 patients we observed a novel heterozygous missense variant in SCN2A (p.Ala1874Thr), a heterozygous splice site variant in SLC2A1 (c.517-2A>G), as a cause of Glut1 deficiency syndrome, and a pathogenic variant in STXBP1 (p.Arg292Leu), respectively. In half of our cases (patients with variants in the GRIN2B, SCN1A, SCN2A and SLC2A1 genes), a genetic cause with potential management implications was identified.

Operative list of genes associated with autism and neurodevelopmental disorders based on database review

The genetics of neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD) has made tremendous progress during the last few decades with the identification of more than 1,500 genes associated with conditions such as intellectual disability and autism. The functional roles of these genes are currently studied to uncover the biological mechanisms influencing the clinical outcome of the mutation carriers. To integrate the data, several databases and curated gene lists have been generated. Here, we provide an overview of the main databases focusing on the genetics of NDD, that are widely used by the medical and scientific communities, and extract a list of high confidence NDD genes (HC-NDD). This gene set can be used as a first filter for interpreting large scale omics dataset or for diagnostic purposes. Overall HC-NDD genes (N = 1,586) are expressed at very early stages of fetal brain development and enriched in several biological pathways such as chromosome organization, cell cycle, metabolism and synaptic function. Among those HC-NDD genes, 204 (12,9%) are listed in the synaptic gene ontology SynGO and are enriched in genes expressed after birth in the cerebellum and the cortex of the human brain. Finally, we point at several limitations regarding the relatively poor standardized information available, especially on the carriers of the mutations. Progress on the phenotypic characterization and genetic profiling of the carriers will be crucial to improve our knowledge on the biological mechanisms and on risk and protective factors for NDD.

The MinION as a cost-effective technology for diagnostic screening of the SCN1A gene in epilepsy patients

The MinION is a portable DNA sequencer that allows real time sequencing at low capital cost investment. We assessed accuracy and cost-effectivess of the MinION for genetic diagnostic testing of known SCN1A mutations that cause Dravet Syndrome (DS). DNA samples (n = 7) from DS patients previously shown to carry SCN1A mutations via Ion Torrent and Sanger sequencing were sequenced using the MinION. SCN1A amplicons for 8 exons were sequenced using the MinION with 1D chemistry on an R9.4 flow cell. All known missense mutations were detected in all samples showing 100 % concordance with results from other methods. However, the MinION failed to detect the insertions/deletions (INDELs) present in these patients. Nevertheless, these results indicate that MinION is a cost-effective platform for use as an initial screening step in the detection of nucleotide substitution mutations in in SCN1A, especially in under-resourced laboratories or hospitals. Further improvements are required to reliably detect INDELS in this gene.

Comprehensive Exonic Sequencing of Known Ataxia Genes in Episodic Ataxia

Episodic Ataxias (EAs) are a small group (EA1–EA8) of complex neurological conditions that manifest as incidents of poor balance and coordination. Diagnostic testing cannot always find causative variants for the phenotype, however, and this along with the recently proposed EA type 9 (EA9), suggest that more EA genes are yet to be discovered. We previously identified disease-causing mutations in the CACNA1A gene in 48% (n = 15) of 31 patients with a suspected clinical diagnosis of EA2, and referred to our laboratory for CACNA1A gene testing, leaving 52% of these cases (n = 16) with no molecular diagnosis. In this study, whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed on 16 patients who tested negative for CACNA1A mutations. Tiered analysis of WES data was performed to first explore (Tier-1) the ataxia and ataxia-associated genes (n = 170) available in the literature and databases for comprehensive EA molecular genetic testing; we then investigated 353 ion channel genes (Tier-2). Known and potential causal variants were identified in n = 8/16 (50%) patients in 8 genes (SCN2A, p.Val1325Phe; ATP1A3, p.Arg756His; PEX7, p.Tyr40Ter; and KCNA1, p.Arg167Met; CLCN1, p.Gly945ArgfsX39; CACNA1E, p.Ile614Val; SCN1B, p.Cys121Trp; and SCN9A, p.Tyr1217Ter). These results suggest that mutations in these genes might cause an ataxia phenotype or that combinations of more than one mutation contribute to ataxia disorders.