Second-tier trio exome sequencing after negative solo clinical exome sequencing: an efficient strategy to increase diagnostic yield and decipher molecular bases in undiagnosed developmental disorders

Next-generation sequencing and comprehensive data reassessment in 263 adult patients with neuromuscular disorders: insights into the gray zone of molecular diagnoses

BACKGROUND

Neuromuscular disorders (NMDs) are heterogeneous conditions with a considerable fraction attributed to monogenic defects. Despite the advancements in genomic medicine, many patients remain without a diagnosis. Here, we investigate whether a comprehensive reassessment strategy improves the diagnostic outcomes.

METHODS

We analyzed 263 patients with NMD phenotypes that underwent diagnostic exome or genome sequencing at our tertiary referral center between 2015 and 2023. We applied a comprehensive reassessment encompassing variant reclassification, re-phenotyping and NGS data reanalysis. Multivariable logistic regression was performed to identify predictive factors associated with a molecular diagnosis.

RESULTS

Initially, a molecular diagnosis was identified in 53 cases (20%), while an additional 23 (9%) had findings of uncertain significance. Following comprehensive reassessment, the diagnostic yield increased to 23%, revealing 44 distinct monogenic etiologies. Reasons for newly obtained molecular diagnoses were variant reclassifications in 7 and NGS data reanalysis in 3 cases including one recently described disease-gene association (DNAJB4). Male sex reduced the odds of receiving a molecular diagnosis (OR 0.42; 95%CI 0.21-0.82), while a positive family history (OR 5.46; 95%CI 2.60-11.76) and a myopathy phenotype (OR 2.72; 95%CI 1.11-7.14) increased the likelihood. 7% were resolved through targeted genetic testing or classified as acquired etiologies.

CONCLUSION

Our findings reinforce the use of NGS in NMDs of suspected monogenic origin. We show that a comprehensive reassessment enhances diagnostic accuracy. However, one needs to be aware that genetic diagnoses are often made with uncertainty and can even be downgraded based on new evidence.

The First Korean Case with Cardiac, Facial, and Digital Anomalies with Developmental Delay Caused by De Novo TRAF7 p.Arg655Gln Variant

TRAF7-related disorders represent some of the rarest inherited disorders, exhibiting clinical features that overlap with cardiac, facial, and digital anomalies with developmental delay (CAFDADD) syndrome, as well as blepharophimosis-mental retardation syndrome (BMRS). A 36-year-old male, presenting with total blindness, blepharophimosis, and intellectual disability, was admitted for the assessment of resting dyspnea several months previously. He had a history of being diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). Transesophageal and transthoracic echocardiography unveiled right ventricular dilatation without significant pulmonary hypertension, bicuspid aortic valve with aortic root aneurysm, and aortic regurgitation in the proband. Sanger sequencing identified a de novo TRAF7 variant (c.1964G>A; p.Arg655Gln). Subsequently, aortic root replacement using the Bentall procedure was performed. However, despite the surgery, he continued to experience dyspnea. Upon re-evaluating OSA with polysomnography, it was discovered that continuous positive airway pressure support alleviated his symptoms. The underlying cause of his symptoms was attributed to OSA, likely exacerbated by the vertebral anomaly and short neck associated with CAFDADD syndrome. Clinicians should be attentive to the symptoms associated with OSA as it is a potentially serious medical condition in patients with TRAF7 variants.

Multiple molecular diagnoses in the field of intellectual disability and congenital anomalies: 3.5% of all positive cases

PURPOSE

Wide access to clinical exome/genome sequencing (ES/GS) enables the identification of multiple molecular diagnoses (MMDs), being a long-standing but underestimated concept, defined by two or more causal loci implicated in the phenotype of an individual with a rare disease. Only few series report MMDs rates (1.8% to 7.1%). This study highlights the increasing role of MMDs in a large cohort of individuals addressed for congenital anomalies/intellectual disability (CA/ID).

METHODS

From 2014 to 2021, our diagnostic laboratory rendered 880/2658 positive ES diagnoses for CA/ID aetiology. Exhaustive search on MMDs from ES data was performed prospectively (January 2019 to December 2021) and retrospectively (March 2014 to December 2018).

RESULTS

MMDs were identified in 31/880 individuals (3.5%), responsible for distinct (9/31) or overlapping (22/31) phenotypes, and potential MMDs in 39/880 additional individuals (4.4%).

CONCLUSION

MMDs are frequent in CA/ID and remain a strong challenge. Reanalysis of positive ES data appears essential when phenotypes are partially explained by the initial diagnosis or atypically enriched overtime. Up-to-date clinical data, clinical expertise from the referring physician, strong interactions between clinicians and biologists, and increasing gene discoveries and improved ES bioinformatics tools appear all the more fundamental to enhance chances of identifying MMDs. It is essential to provide appropriate patient care and genetic counselling.

A rigorous in silico genomic interrogation at 1p13.3 reveals 16 autosomal dominant candidate genes in syndromic neurodevelopmental disorders

Genome-wide chromosomal microarray is extensively used to detect copy number variations (CNVs), which can diagnose microdeletion and microduplication syndromes. These small unbalanced chromosomal structural rearrangements ranging from 1 kb to 10 Mb comprise up to 15% of human mutations leading to monogenic or contiguous genomic disorders. Albeit rare, CNVs at 1p13.3 cause a variety of neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) including development delay (DD), intellectual disability (ID), autism, epilepsy, and craniofacial anomalies (CFA). Most of the 1p13.3 CNV cases reported in the pre-microarray era encompassed a large number of genes and lacked the demarcating genomic coordinates, hampering the discovery of positional candidate genes within the boundaries. In this study, we present four subjects with 1p13.3 microdeletions displaying DD, ID, autism, epilepsy, and CFA. In silico comparative genomic mapping with three previously reported subjects with CNVs and 22 unreported DECIPHER CNV cases has resulted in the identification of four different sub-genomic loci harboring five positional candidate genes for DD, ID, and CFA at 1p13.3. Most of these genes have pathogenic variants reported, and their interacting genes are involved in NDDs. RT-qPCR in various human tissues revealed a high expression pattern in the brain and fetal brain, supporting their functional roles in NDDs. Interrogation of variant databases and interacting protein partners led to the identification of another set of 11 potential candidate genes, which might have been dysregulated by the position effect of these CNVs at 1p13.3. Our studies define 1p13.3 as a genomic region harboring 16 NDD candidate genes and underscore the critical roles of small CNVs in in silico comparative genomic mapping for disease gene discovery. Our candidate genes will help accelerate the isolation of pathogenic heterozygous variants from exome/genome sequencing (ES/GS) databases.

Case Report: Infantile Cerebellar-Retinal Degeneration With Compound Heterozygous Variants in ACO2 Gene-Long-Term Follow-Up of a Sibling

Infantile cerebellar-retinal degeneration (ICRD) is an extremely rare, infantile-onset neuro-degenerative disease, characterized by autosomal recessive inherited, global developmental delay (GDD), progressive cerebellar and cortical atrophy, and retinal degeneration. In 2012, a biallelic pathogenic variant in ACO2 gene (NM_001098.3) was found to be causative of this disease. To date, approximately 44 variants displaying various clinical features have been reported. Here, we report a case of two siblings with compound heterozygous variants in the ACO2 gene. Two siblings without perinatal problems were born to healthy non-consanguineous Korean parents. They showed GDD and seizures since infancy. Their first brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), electroencephalography, and metabolic workup revealed no abnormal findings. As they grew, they developed symptoms including ataxia, dysmetria, poor sitting balance, and myopia. Follow-up brain MRI findings revealed atrophy of the cerebellum and optic nerve. Through exome sequencing of both siblings and their parents, we identified the following compound heterozygous variants in the ACO2: c.85C > T (p.Arg29Trp) and c.2303C > A (p.Ala768Asp). These two variants were categorized as likely pathogenic based on ACMG/AMP guidelines. In conclusion, this case help to broaden the genetic and clinical spectrum of the ACO2 variants associated with ICRD. We have also documented the long-term clinical course and serial brain MRI findings for two patients with this extremely rare disease.

Short stature leads to a diagnosis of Jansen-de Vries syndrome in two unrelated Taiwanese girls: A case report and literature review

Short stature and intellectual disability are two of the major components of many dysmorphic syndromes. Jansen-de Vries syndrome (JDVS) is a rare syndromic disorder that was discovered recently using next-generation sequencing. It is characterized by hypotonia, developmental delay, a dysmorphic face, short stature, and high pain threshold and is caused by the variants of the protein phosphatase magnesium-dependent 1D (PPM1D) gene. Here, we report the first two cases of PPM1D mutations in Taiwan; both had de novo variants in exon 6. Both presented with short stature, developmental delay, and dysmorphic faces. In addition to the characteristics listed above, syndactyly was noted in one. Genetic studies should be considered when approaching a patient with growth retardation, intellectual disability, and other major or minor dysmorphisms.

The extended clinical and genetic spectrum of CTNNB1-related neurodevelopmental disorder

PURPOSE

Loss-of-function mutations of CTNNB1 have been established as the cause of neurodevelopmental disorder with spastic diplegia and visual defects. Although most patients share key phenotypes such as global developmental delay and intellectual disability, patients with CTNNB1-related neurodevelopmental disorder show a broad spectrum of clinical features.

METHODS

We enrolled 13 Korean patients with CTNNB1-related neurodevelopmental disorder who visited Seoul National University Children's Hospital (5 female and 8 male patients with ages ranging from 4 to 22 years). They were all genetically confirmed as having pathogenic loss-of-function variants in CTNNB1 using trio or singleton whole exome sequencing. Variants called from singleton analyses were confirmed to be de novo through parental Sanger sequencing.

RESULTS

We identified 11 de novo truncating variants in CTNNB1 in 13 patients, and two pathogenic variants, c.1867C > T (p.Gln623Ter) and c.1420C > T (p.Arg474Ter), found in two unrelated patients, respectively. Five of them were novel pathogenic variants not listed in the ClinVar database. While all patients showed varying degrees of intellectual disability, impaired motor performance, and ophthalmologic problems, none of them had structural brain abnormalities or seizure. In addition, there were three female patients who showed autistic features, such as hand stereotypy, bruxism, and abnormal breathing. A literature review revealed a female predominance of autistic features in CTNNB1-related neurodevelopmental disorder.

CONCLUSION

This is one of the largest single-center cohorts of CTNNB1-related neurodevelopmental disorder. This study investigated variable clinical features of patients and has expanded the clinical and genetic spectrum of the disease.

Interest of exome sequencing trio-like strategy based on pooled parental DNA for diagnosis and translational research in rare diseases

Background

Exome sequencing (ES) has become the most powerful and cost‐effective molecular tool for deciphering rare diseases with a diagnostic yield approaching 30%–40% in solo‐ES and 50% in trio‐ES. We applied an innovative parental DNA pooling method to reduce the parental sequencing cost while maintaining the diagnostic yield of trio‐ES.

Methods

We pooled six (Agilent‐CRE‐v2–100X) or five parental DNA (TWIST‐HCE–70X) aiming to detect allelic balance around 8–10% for heterozygous status. The strategies were applied as second‐tier (74 individuals after negative solo‐ES) and first‐tier approaches (324 individuals without previous ES).

Results

The allelic balance of parental‐pool variants was around 8.97%. Sanger sequencing uncovered false positives in 1.5% of sporadic variants. In the second‐tier approach, we evaluated than two thirds of the Sanger validations performed after solo‐ES (41/59–69%) would have been saved if the parental‐pool segregations had been available from the start. The parental‐pool strategy identified a causative diagnosis in 18/74 individuals (24%) in the second‐tier and in 116/324 individuals (36%) in the first‐tier approaches, including 19 genes newly associated with human disorders.

Conclusions

Parental‐pooling is an efficient alternative to trio‐ES. It provides rapid segregation and extension to translational research while reducing the cost of parental and Sanger sequencing.

Biallelic variants in HPDL cause pure and complicated hereditary spastic paraplegia

Human 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase-like (HPDL) is a putative iron-containing non-heme oxygenase of unknown specificity and biological significance. We report 25 families containing 34 individuals with neurological disease associated with biallelic HPDL variants. Phenotypes ranged from juvenile-onset pure hereditary spastic paraplegia to infantile-onset spasticity and global developmental delays, sometimes complicated by episodes of neurological and respiratory decompensation. Variants included bona fide pathogenic truncating changes, although most were missense substitutions. Functionality of variants could not be determined directly as the enzymatic specificity of HPDL is unknown; however, when HPDL missense substitutions were introduced into 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD, an HPDL orthologue), they impaired the ability of HPPD to convert 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate into homogentisate. Moreover, three additional sets of experiments provided evidence for a role of HPDL in the nervous system and further supported its link to neurological disease: (i) HPDL was expressed in the nervous system and expression increased during neural differentiation; (ii) knockdown of zebrafish hpdl led to abnormal motor behaviour, replicating aspects of the human disease; and (iii) HPDL localized to mitochondria, consistent with mitochondrial disease that is often associated with neurological manifestations. Our findings suggest that biallelic HPDL variants cause a syndrome varying from juvenile-onset pure hereditary spastic paraplegia to infantile-onset spastic tetraplegia associated with global developmental delays.