Orthopedic applications of gene therapy

The Role of Angiogenesis-Inducing microRNAs in Vascular Tissue Engineering

Angiogenesis is an important process in tissue repair and regeneration as blood vessels are integral to supply nutrients to a functioning tissue. In this review, the application of microRNAs (miRNAs) or anti-miRNAs that can induce angiogenesis to aid in blood vessel formation for vascular tissue engineering in ischemic diseases such as peripheral arterial disease and stroke, cardiac diseases, and skin and bone tissue engineering is discussed. Endothelial cells (ECs) form the endothelium of the blood vessel and are recognized as the primary cell type that drives angiogenesis and studied in the applications that were reviewed. Besides ECs, mesenchymal stem cells can also play a pivotal role in these applications, specifically, by secreting growth factors or cytokines for paracrine signaling and/or as constituent cells in the new blood vessel formed. In addition to delivering miRNAs or cells transfected/transduced with miRNAs for angiogenesis and vascular tissue engineering, the utilization of extracellular vesicles (EVs), such as exosomes, microvesicles, and EVs collectively, has been more recently explored. Proangiogenic miRNAs and anti-miRNAs contribute to angiogenesis by targeting the 3'-untranslated region of targets to upregulate proangiogenic factors such as vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), basic fibroblast growth factor, and hypoxia-inducible factor-1 and increase the transduction of VEGF signaling through the PI3K/AKT and Ras/Raf/MEK/ERK signaling pathways such as phosphatase and tensin homolog or regulating the signaling of other pathways important for angiogenesis such as the Notch signaling pathway and the pathway to produce nitric oxide. In conclusion, angiogenesis-inducing miRNAs and anti-miRNAs are promising tools for vascular tissue engineering for several applications; however, future work should emphasize optimizing the delivery and usage of these therapies as miRNAs can also be associated with the negative implications of cancer.

The Application of microRNAs in Biomaterial Scaffold-Based Therapies for Bone Tissue Engineering

In recent years, the application of microRNAs (miRNAs) or anti-microRNAs (anti-miRNAs) that can induce expression of the runt-related transcription factor 2 (RUNX2), a master regulator of osteogenesis, has been investigated as a promising alternative bone tissue engineering strategy. In this review, biomaterial scaffold-based applications that have been used to deliver cells expressing miRNAs or anti-miRNAs that induce expression of RUNX2 for bone tissue engineering are discussed. An overview of the components of the scaffold-based therapies including the miRNAs/anti-miRNAs, cell types, gene delivery vectors, and scaffolds that have been applied are provided. To date, there have been nine miRNAs/anti-miRNAs (i.e., miRNA-26a, anti-miRNA-31, anti-miRNA-34a, miRNA-135, anti-miRNA-138, anti-miRNA-146a, miRNA-148b, anti-miRNA-221, and anti-miRNA-335) that have been incorporated into scaffold-based bone tissue engineering applications and investigated in an in vivo bone critical-sized defect model. For all of the biomaterial scaffold-based miRNA therapies that have been developed thus far, cells that are transfected or transduced with the miRNA/anti-miRNA are loaded into the scaffolds and implanted at the site of interest instead of locally delivering the miRNA/anti-miRNAs directly from the scaffolds. Thus, future work may focus on developing biomaterial scaffolds to deliver miRNAs or anti-miRNAs into cells in vivo.

Wnt Pathway in Bone Repair and Regeneration - What Do We Know So Far

Wnt signaling plays a central regulatory role across a remarkably diverse range of functions during embryonic development, including those involved in the formation of bone and cartilage. Wnt signaling continues to play a critical role in adult osteogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells. Disruptions in this highly-conserved and complex system leads to various pathological conditions, including impaired bone healing, autoimmune diseases and malignant degeneration. For reconstructive surgeons, critically sized skeletal defects represent a major challenge. These are frequently associated with significant morbidity in both the recipient and donor sites. The Wnt pathway is an attractive therapeutic target with the potential to directly modulate stem cells responsible for skeletal tissue regeneration and promote bone growth, suggesting that Wnt factors could be used to promote bone healing after trauma. This review summarizes our current understanding of the essential role of the Wnt pathway in bone regeneration and repair.

Stem cell-derived exosomes: A promising strategy for fracture healing

OBJECTIVES

To describe the biological characteristics of exosomes and to summarize the current status of stem cell-derived exosomes on fracture healing. Meanwhile, future challenges, limitations and perspectives are also discussed.

METHODS

Search and analyze the related articles in pubmed database through the multi-combination of keywords like "stem cells","exosomes","bone regeneration" and "fracture healing".

CONCLUSION

Stem cell-derived exosome therapy for fracture healing has been enjoying popularity and is drawing increasing attention. This strategy helps to promote proliferation and migration of cells, as well as osteogenesis and angiogenesis, in the process of bone formation. Although the exact mechanisms remain elusive, exosomal miRNAs seem to play vital roles. Future studies are required to solve multiple problems before clinical application, including comprehensive and thorough understanding of exosomes, the exact roles of exosomes in regulating bone formation, and the optimal source, dose and frequency of treatment, as well as technical and safety issues. Moreover, studies based on fracture models of large animals are could offer guidance and are in demand.

Biomaterial-Based Implantable Devices for Cancer Therapy

This review article focuses on the current local therapies mediated by implanted macroscaled biomaterials available or proposed for fighting cancer and also highlights the upcoming research in this field. Several authoritative review articles have collected and discussed the state-of-the-art as well as the advancements in using biomaterial-based micro- and nano-particle systems for drug delivery in cancer therapy. On the other hand, implantable biomaterial devices are emerging as highly versatile therapeutic platforms, which deserve an increased attention by the healthcare scientific community, as they are able to offer innovative, more effective and creative strategies against tumors. This review summarizes the current approaches which exploit biomaterial-based devices as implantable tools for locally administrating drugs and describes their specific medical applications, which mainly target resected brain tumors or brain metastases for the inaccessibility of conventional chemotherapies. Moreover, a special focus in this review is given to innovative approaches, such as combined delivery therapies, as well as to alternative approaches, such as scaffolds for gene therapy, cancer immunotherapy and metastatic cell capture, the later as promising future trends in implantable biomaterials for cancer applications.

Recent biological trends in management of fracture non-union

Bone regeneration is a complex, well-orchestrated physiological process of bone formation, which can be seen during normal fracture healing, and is involved in continuous remodelling throughout adult life. Currently, there is a plethora of different strategies to augment the impaired or “insufficient” bone-regeneration process, including the “gold standard” autologous bone graft, free fibula vascularised graft, allograft implantation, and use of growth factors, osteoconductive scaffolds, osteoprogenitor cells and distraction osteogenesis. Improved “local” strategies in terms of tissue engineering and gene therapy, or even “systemic” enhancement of bone repair, are under intense investigation, in an effort to overcome the limitations of the current methods, to produce bone-graft substitutes with biomechanical properties that are as identical to normal bone as possible, to accelerate the overall regeneration process, or even to address systemic conditions, such as skeletal disorders and osteoporosis. An improved understanding of the molecular and cellular events that occur during bone repair and remodeling has led to the development of biologic agents that can augment the biological microenvironment and enhance bone repair. Orthobiologics, including stem cells, osteoinductive growth factors, osteoconductive matrices, and anabolic agents, are available clinically for accelerating fracture repair and treatment of compromised bone repair situations like delayed unions and nonunions. A lack of standardized outcome measures for comparison of biologic agents in clinical fracture repair trials, frequent off-label use, and a limited understanding of the biological activity of these agents at the bone repair site have limited their efficacy in clinical applications.

Role of angiogenesis in bone repair

Bone vasculature plays a vital role in bone development, remodeling and homeostasis. New blood vessel formation is crucial during both primary bone development as well as fracture repair in adults. Both bone repair and bone remodeling involve the activation and complex interaction between angiogenic and osteogenic pathways. Interestingly studies have demonstrated that angiogenesis precedes the onset of osteogenesis. Indeed reduced or inadequate blood flow has been linked to impaired fracture healing and old age related low bone mass disorders such as osteoporosis. Similarly the slow penetration of host blood vessels in large engineered bone tissue grafts has been cited as one of the major hurdle still impeding current bone construction engineering strategies. This article reviews the current knowledge elaborating the importance of vascularization during bone healing and remodeling, and the current therapeutic strategies being adapted to promote and improve angiogenesis.

Bone graft substitutes: What are the options?

Currently, a number of bone grafting materials are available in the clinical setting to enhance bone regeneration, varying from autologous bone to several bone graft substitutes. Although autologous bone remains the "gold standard" for stimulating bone repair and regeneration, the morbidity from its harvesting and its restricted availability generated the need for the development of other materials or strategies either to substitute autologous bone graft or expand its limited supply. Bone graft substitutes can possess one or more components: an osteoconductive matrix, acting as a scaffold; osteoinductive proteins and other growth factors to induce differentiation and proliferation of bone-forming cells; and osteogenic cells for bone formation. Based on their distinct properties, all these bone grafting alternatives have specific indications, and can be used either alone or in combination. In this review, we summarise the available bone grafting materials, focussing mainly on the various bone substitutes and their characteristics, in an effort to specify the indications for their use.

Treatment of irradiated mandibles with mesenchymal stem cells transfected with bone morphogenetic protein 2/7

PURPOSE

The study aimed to evaluate whether mesenchymal stem cells transfected with bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) 2/7 could increase bone regeneration after radiotherapy using a rabbit model of mandibular distraction osteogenesis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twelve rabbits were randomly assigned to the sham control, radiotherapy control, nontransfected mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), and MSCs transfected with BMP-2/7 groups. All rabbits, except those in the sham control group, received preoperative radiation of 9 Gy for 5 fractions. One month after radiotherapy, all rabbits underwent unilateral mandibular distraction at a rate of 0.9 mm/d for 11 days. At the end of active distraction, MSCs combined with bovine collagen were injected into the distraction zone. After 4 weeks of consolidation, the mandibular samples were collected and subjected to radiographic, microcomputed tomographic, and histologic examinations.

RESULTS

By radiographic examination, animals injected with nontransfected MSCs or MSCs encoding BMP-2/7 exhibited more bone formation than the control groups. Histologic examination showed that the group with MSCs encoding BMP-2/7 had a more mature medullary cavity than the nontransfected MSCs group.

CONCLUSIONS

MSCs encoding BMP-2/7 can increase bone healing in irradiated mandibular bone.

Evaluation of direct in vivo gene transfer in an equine metacarpal IV ostectomy model using an adenoviral vector encoding the bone morphogenetic protein-2 and protein-7 gene

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate gene transfer in an equine metacarpal IV (MCIV) ostectomy model using adenoviral vectors encoding the human bone morphogenetic protein-2 and protein-7 gene (Ad-BMP-2/-7).

STUDY DESIGN

EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS

Healthy adult horses (n = 15).

METHODS

A plate stabilized, critical size 1.5 cm ostectomy was created in left and right MCIV. The ostectomy site was injected with either Ad-green fluorescent protein (Ad-GFP) or Ad-hBMP-2/-7 at completion of surgery; the same treatment was assigned to both the left and right forelimb of each horse (n = 5 horses/group). Bone healing was evaluated radiographically every 2 weeks for 16 weeks. Horses in a pilot study (n = 5) were used as untreated controls for radiographic evaluation to 8 weeks. After euthanasia at 16 weeks bone healing was evaluated using dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) and histomorphometry. Data were analyzed using an ANOVA or Kruskal-Wallis test. Level of significance was P < .05.

RESULTS

At 4 and 6 weeks, the Ad-GFP group had a significantly lower percentage defect ossification compared with the untreated control group. There was no significant difference between untreated and Ad-hBMP-2/-7 groups at any time point and no significant difference in bone healing radiographically, histologically, or using DEXA between any groups at 16 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

Ad-hBMP-2/-7 did not improve bone healing in horses at 16 weeks.

Bone regeneration: current concepts and future directions

Bone regeneration is a complex, well-orchestrated physiological process of bone formation, which can be seen during normal fracture healing, and is involved in continuous remodelling throughout adult life. However, there are complex clinical conditions in which bone regeneration is required in large quantity, such as for skeletal reconstruction of large bone defects created by trauma, infection, tumour resection and skeletal abnormalities, or cases in which the regenerative process is compromised, including avascular necrosis, atrophic non-unions and osteoporosis. Currently, there is a plethora of different strategies to augment the impaired or 'insufficient' bone-regeneration process, including the 'gold standard' autologous bone graft, free fibula vascularised graft, allograft implantation, and use of growth factors, osteoconductive scaffolds, osteoprogenitor cells and distraction osteogenesis. Improved 'local' strategies in terms of tissue engineering and gene therapy, or even 'systemic' enhancement of bone repair, are under intense investigation, in an effort to overcome the limitations of the current methods, to produce bone-graft substitutes with biomechanical properties that are as identical to normal bone as possible, to accelerate the overall regeneration process, or even to address systemic conditions, such as skeletal disorders and osteoporosis.

Delivery of plasmid DNA encoding bone morphogenetic protein-2 with a biodegradable branched polycationic polymer in a critical-size rat cranial defect model

This study investigated the delivery of plasmid DNA (pDNA) encoding bone morphogenetic protein-2 in the form of polyplexes with a biodegradable branched triacrylate/amine polycationic polymer (TAPP) that were complexed with gelatin microparticles (GMPs) loaded within a porous tissue engineering scaffold. More specifically, the study investigated the interplay between TAPP degradation, gelatin degradation, pDNA release, and bone formation in a critical-size rat cranial defect model. The pDNA release kinetics in vitro were not affected by the crosslinking density of the GMPs but depended, rather, on the degradation rates of the TAPPs. Besides the initial release of polyplexes not bound to the GMPs and the minimal release of polyplexes through diffusion or dissociation from the GMPs, the pDNA was likely released as naked pDNA or as part of an incomplete polyplex, after the degradation of fragments of the polycationic polymer. After 30 days, significantly higher amounts of pDNA were released (93%-98%) from composite scaffolds containing naked pDNA or pDNA complexed with P-AEPZ (synthesized with 1-[2-aminoethyl]piperazine, a faster degrading TAPP) compared with those containing pDNA complexed with P-DED (synthesized with N,N-dimethylethylenediamine, a slower degrading TAPP) (74%-82%). Composite scaffolds containing GMPs complexed with TAPP/pDNA polyplexes did not result in enhanced bone formation, as analyzed by microcomputed tomography and histology, in a critical-size rat cranial defect at 12 weeks postimplantation compared with those loaded with naked pDNA. The results demonstrate that polycationic polymers with a slow degradation rate can prolong the release of pDNA from the composite scaffolds and suggest that a gene delivery system comprising biodegradable polycationic polymers should be designed to release the pDNA in an intact polyplex form.

Prevalence of degenerative imaging findings in lumbar magnetic resonance imaging among young adults

STUDY DESIGN

A cross-sectional imaging study of young adults.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the prevalence of disc degeneration (DD) and displacement, anular tears, and Modic changes in lumbar magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) among young adults.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Although low back pain in young adulthood is common, the prevalence of spinal MRI findings at this age remains virtually unknown.

METHODS

The study population was a subcohort of the Northern Finland Birth Cohort 1986. Subjects living within 100 km of Oulu (n = 874) were invited to participate in lumbar MRI at 20 to 22 years of age (mean: 21.2 years). Degree of DD, type of Modic changes, and presence of disc bulges, herniations, high intensity zone (HIZ) lesions, and radial tears at all lumbar levels were assessed.

RESULTS

Three hundred twenty-five women and 233 men (n = 558) attended the MR imaging. DD was significantly more frequent in men (54% vs. 42%, P = 0.005), as was multiple DD (21% vs. 14%, P = 0.036). The prevalences of disc bulges and radial tears were 25% and 9.1%, respectively, without gender differences. HIZ lesions were more common among women than men (8.6% vs. 4.3%, P = 0.046), whereas herniations were significantly more common among men (5.6% vs. 2.5%, P = 0.047). Only 2 disc extrusions were observed, one in each gender. All degenerative disc findings were more common at the L5-S1 level except HIZ lesions, which were most likely at L4-L5. The prevalence of the Modic changes was 1.4%, without gender difference, type I being more common than type II. Typically, Modic changes were located adjacent to a DD Grade 4 disc and at the 2 lowest levels.

CONCLUSION

Almost half of young Finnish adult aged 21 years had at least one degenerated disc, and a quarter had a bulging disc. Modic changes and disc herniations were, however, relatively rare.

Combination of beta-TCP and BMP-2 gene-modified bMSCs to heal critical size mandibular defects in rats

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effects of mandibular defects repaired by a tissue engineered bone complex with beta-tricalcium phosphate (beta-TCP) and bone morphogenic protein-2 (BMP-2) gene-modified bone marrow stromal cells (bMSCs).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

bMSCs derived from Fisher 344 rats were cultured and transduced with adenovirus AdBMP-2, AdEGFP gene in vitro. Osteogenic differentiation of bMSCs was determined by alkaline phosphatase staining, von Kossa assay and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction. Gene transduced or untransduced bMSCs were seeded on beta-TCP scaffolds to repair mandibular full thickness defects with a diameter of 5 mm. Eight weeks post-operation, X-ray examination, micro-computerized tomography and histological and histomorphological analysis were used to evaluate the bone healing effects.

RESULTS

Alkaline phosphatase staining and mineralized nodules formation were more pronounced in AdBMP-2 group 14 days after gene transduction when compared with that of AdEGFP or untransduced group. The mRNA expression of osteopontin and osteocalcin also significantly increased 9 days after AdBMP-2 gene transduction. Mandibular defects were successfully repaired with AdBMP-2-transduced bMSCs/beta-TCP constructs. The percentage of new bone formation in AdBMP-2 group was significantly higher than that of other control groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Bone morphogenic protein-2 regional gene therapy together with beta-TCP scaffold could be used to promote mandibular repairing and bone regeneration.

Fracture healing and bone repair: an update

Bone healing represents a physiological process of repair and restoration of function. Recent advances in a variety of medical disciplines have enabled scientists and clinicians to characterise this phenomenon at the molecular level. A number of molecular mediators and cells interact utilising different pathways. Despite the involvement of many local and systemic factors failure of the naturally occurring mechanisms can occur leading to either delayed union or non-union. This review article is focused on the recent understanding of the mechanisms governing the bone repair process.

Mandibular repair in rats with premineralized silk scaffolds and BMP-2-modified bMSCs

Premineralized silk fibroin protein scaffolds (mSS) were prepared to combine the osteoconductive properties of biological apatite with aqueous-derived silk scaffold (SS) as a composite scaffold for bone regeneration. The aim of present study was to evaluate the effect of premineralized silk scaffolds combined with bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) modified bone marrow stromal cells (bMSCs) to repair mandibular bony defects in a rat model. bMSCs were expanded and transduced with adenovirus AdBMP-2, AdLacZ gene in vitro. These genetically modified bMSCs were then combined with premineralized silk scaffolds to form tissue-engineered bone. Mandibular repairs with AdBMP-2 transduced bMSCs/mSS constructs were compared with those treated with AdLacZ-transduced bMSCs/mSS constructs, native (nontransduced) bMSCs/mSS constructs and mSS alone. Eight weeks after post-operation, the mandibles were explanted and evaluated by radiographic observation, micro-CT, histological analysis and immunohistochemistry. The presence of BMP-2 gene enhanced tissue-engineered bone in terms of the most new bone formed and the highest local bone mineral densities (BMD) found. These results demonstrated that premineralized silk scaffold could serve as a potential substrate for bMSCs to construct tissue-engineered bone for mandibular bony defects. BMP-2 gene therapy and tissue engineering techniques could be used in mandibular repair and bone regeneration.

Use of bone morphogenetic proteins for augmentation of bone regeneration

A large body of preclinical and clinical data now documents that recombinant BMPs can be used for skeletal regeneration in humans and animals. Recombinant human BMP-2 and BMP-7 have been approved for use in human patients with long-bone fractures and nonunions and in patients undergoing lumbar fusion or various maxillofacial and dental regenerative procedures. These products have also been made available for veterinary use.

Tracking expression of virally mediated BMP-2 in gene therapy for bone repair

Ex vivo gene therapy using stem cells transduced with viral vectors is a useful method for delivering a therapeutic protein to augment bone repair in animal models. However, the duration of cell-mediated protein production and the fate of the transduced cells are unknown. We constructed an adenoviral vector encoding Myc epitope tagged bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-2 gene (AdBMP-2). Rat bone marrow cells transduced with this vector produced biologically active BMP-2 protein, which was confirmed by Western blot analysis and alkaline phosphatase assay. Implantation of bone marrow cells infected ex vivo with AdBMP-2 caused orthotopic bone formation in mouse hindlimbs and bony union of critical-sized mouse radial defects. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that rBMCs expressed Myc epitope-tagged BMP-2 protein for 14 days in vivo and became incorporated in the endochondral fracture callus. This novel adenovirus encoding for epitope-tagged BMP-2 can be used for immunohistochemical tracking of transduced cells in ex vivo gene therapy for bone repair.

Regional gene therapy for full-thickness articular cartilage lesions using naked DNA with a collagen matrix

A novel gene therapy approach for treating damaged cartilage is proposed that involves placing endotoxin-free cDNA containing the gene for bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) in type I collagen sponges and then transferring the naked plasmid DNA construct to the injury site. A full-thickness cartilaginous defect in rabbits implanted with plasmid containing a marker gene (beta-galactosidase) showed expressed protein as detected by immunostaining. At 1 week postimplantation, mesenchymal cells subjacent to the defect had incorporated the implanted naked plasmid DNA and, once transfected, served as local bioreactors, transiently producing the gene product. Plasmids containing the gene for BMP-2 implanted in collagen sponges in cartilage lesions stimulated hyalinelike articular cartilage repair at 12 weeks postimplantation, nearly equivalent in quality to that induced by collagen sponges with recombinant BMP-2 protein. Our approach circumvents the risks of inflammation and immunogenic response associated with the use of viral vectors. Naked plasmid DNA as a vehicle for transferring therapeutic genes has been shown to be effective in a therapeutic model within rabbit articular cartilage and appears to be safe and cost effective.

Gene therapy in orthopaedics

Impressive advances in our knowledge of the molecular genetic basis of skeletal disorders and fracture healing have led to the development of novel therapeutics based on ectopic expression of one or more genes in patient cells that can influence repair or regenerative processes in bone. Gene therapy is an attractive new approach to the treatment of bone disorders. Orthopaedics has become one of the most promising areas of research into gene therapy. This is because many potential orthopaedic targets for gene therapy, unlike traditional targets such as cancer and severe genetic disorders, neither present difficult delivery problems nor require prolonged periods of gene expression. Gene therapy offers new possibilities for the clinical management of orthopaedic conditions that are difficult to treat by traditional surgical or medical means. Impaired bone healing, need for extensive bone formation, cartilage repair and metabolic bone diseases are all conditions where alterations of the signalling peptides involved may provide cure or improvement. In orthopaedic oncology, gene therapy may achieve induction of tumour necrosis and increased tumour sensitivity to chemotherapy. An increasing amount of evidence indicates that gene transfer can aid the repair of articular cartilage, menisci, intervertebral disks, ligaments and tendons. These developments have the potential to transform many areas of musculoskeletal care, leading to treatments that are less invasive, more effective and less expensive than existing modalities.

Current concepts of molecular aspects of bone healing

Fracture healing is a complex physiological process. It involves the coordinated participation of haematopoietic and immune cells within the bone marrow in conjunction with vascular and skeletal cell precursors, including mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) that are recruited from the surrounding tissues and the circulation. Multiple factors regulate this cascade of molecular events by affecting different sites in the osteoblast and chondroblast lineage through various processes such as migration, proliferation, chemotaxis, differentiation, inhibition, and extracellular protein synthesis. An understanding of the fracture healing cellular and molecular pathways is not only critical for the future advancement of fracture treatment, but it may also be informative to our further understanding of the mechanisms of skeletal growth and repair as well as the mechanisms of aging.

Application of bone morphogenetic proteins in orthopaedic practice: their efficacy and side effects

Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) have been extensively studied since the discovery of agents within bone that could induce bone formation at ectopic sites by Urist in the 1960s. Extensive preclinical research has been carried out showing the efficacy of these products in promoting bone healing. Clinical trials are encouraging, with meta-analysis of results revealing better rates of healing than treatment with autologous bone grafting (risk ratio [RR]: 0.845; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.772 - 0.924; p < 0.001 for clinical outcome and RR: 0.884; 95% CI: 0.825 - 0.948; p < 0.001 for radiological outcome). Preclinical and clinical safety assessments have revealed little evidence of toxic effects and there have been few reports of adverse events related to their use. A small rate of immunological reaction following administration, resulting in antibody formation, has been observed in some patients, without clinical consequence, although the long-term implications of this are unknown. Ongoing research is revealing that BMPs act on an extremely wide range of body tissues in a variety of manners and this is far from fully understood. It should be noted, however, that given the role of BMP as a differentiation factor, the production of undifferentiated neoplastic tissue seems unlikely. It has also been shown in an animal model that artificially administered BMP can cross the placenta and subsequently be detected in the growing embryo. As this area has been little investigated, use in pregnancy is currently contraindicated. Until the long-term safety profile is more fully documented it would seem sensible to continue to carefully control use and monitor patients closely. However, the current evidence is very promising.

Delivery of Growth Factors Using Gene Therapy to Enhance Bone Healing

OBJECTIVE

To review the delivery of growth factors using gene therapy for enhancing long-bone fracture healing.

STUDY DESIGN

Literature review.

METHODS

MEDLINE and CAB Abstracts literature search (1980-2004).

RESULTS

Non-union and infected non-union are relatively common complications of long-bone fractures in human and veterinary patients. Growth factors are cytokines that regulate many cell functions important in fracture healing. Exogenous growth factors can be delivered to the fracture site as recombinant proteins or using gene therapy. Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 and -7 (rhBMP-2 and -7), in particular, enhance fracture healing in numerous experimental and clinical studies. Some limitations with use of recombinant proteins may be overcome by use of gene therapy. Gene therapy involves delivery of the growth factor gene to cells at the fracture site using a viral or non-viral vector. The gene is then expressed (protein synthesis) by cells at the fracture site. Delivery of the BMP gene to the fracture site using gene therapy has been evaluated in laboratory animal models of non-union, with favorable results and without complications.

CONCLUSION

Delivery of growth factors, particularly members of BMP family, to the fracture site using gene therapy may be a method to enhance fracture healing. Use of this technology may improve the prognosis for patients with long-bone fractures.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Clinical application of gene therapy could improve the prognosis for human and veterinary patients with long-bone fractures, but has not been evaluated clinically.

Combination of adeno-associated virus and adenovirus vectors expressing bone morphogenetic protein-2 produces enhanced osteogenic activity in immunocompetent rats

We have previously shown that gene therapy using adeno-associated virus (AAV) carrying bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) is a promising strategy for new bone formation in vivo in SD rats. However, it had a relatively low transduction efficiency. We investigate here whether enhanced osteogenic activity can be achieved without eliciting a severe immune response, using a cocktail of AAV-BMP2 and adenovirus (Ad)-BMP2 as a vector system. The muscles of SD rats were injected with either AAV-BMP2, Ad-BMP2, or an AAV-BMP2/Ad-BMP2 cocktail, and the in vivo bone formation was determined at eight weeks post-injection. Radiographic examination demonstrated that the addition of a low level of Ad-BMP2 to AAV-BMP2 produced significantly higher new bone formation than the use of AAV-BMP2 alone. Histological and immunohistological analysis revealed an enlarged bone-forming area and a long-term BMP2 expression, without pronounced infiltration of lymphocytes. Our results provide the first evidence that the introduction of a low level of adenovirus in vivo in immunocompetent subjects can greatly enhance AAV-mediated gene transfer, without inducing severe immune responses. This cocktail vector system may offer an attractive way of improving the efficiency of AAV-based gene delivery.

Dissection of complex genetic disease: implications for orthopaedics

The sequencing of the human genome is a landmark achievement in the history of mankind and, in conjunction with new developments in genetic technology, is paving the way to a new era in biomedical research. The complete anatomy of the human genome is almost available. Detailed dissection to identify genes contributing to clinical disorders is underway and these will shape our understanding and treatment of common clinical conditions. This already is beginning to make an impact in medicine in terms of understanding disease etiology, clinical heterogeneity, and differential diagnosis. Furthermore it is advancing risk prediction for susceptibility, severity and outcome, the identification of new targets for drug discovery, and pharmacogenetic profiling of patients to predict their response to individual therapies. Major advances in genetics are occurring and it is important for clinicians in all areas of medicine to be aware of genomic approaches to understanding human disease. This is particularly important regarding orthopaedic conditions where the underlying genetic components are being established. This article does not presume a detailed knowledge in genetics by the reader and is intended to provide an introduction and concise overview of the potential future applications of genetics with reference to some orthopaedic conditions.

Gene therapy approaches for osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a heterogeneous group of genetic disorders that affect connective tissue integrity. The hallmark of OI is bone fragility, although other manifestations, which include osteoporosis, dentigenesis imperfecta, blue sclera, easy bruising, joint laxity and scoliosis, are also common among OI patients. The severity of OI ranges from prenatal death to mild osteopenia without limb deformity. Most forms of OI result from mutations in the genes that encode either the proalpha1or proalpha2 polypeptide chains that comprise type I collagen molecules, the major structural protein of bone. Treatment depends mainly on the severity of the disease with the primary goal to minimize fractures and maximize function. Current treatments include surgical intervention with intramedullarly stabilization and the use of prostheses. Pharmacological agents have also been attempted with limited success with the exception of recent use of bisphosphonates, which have been to shown to have some effect. Since OI is a genetic disease, these agents are not expected to alter the course of the collagen mutations. Cell and gene therapies as potential treatments for OI are therefore currently being actively investigated. The design of gene therapies for OI is however complicated by the genetic heterogeneity of the disease and by the factor that most of the OI mutations are dominant negative where the mutant allele product interferes with the function of the normal allele. The present review will discuss the molecular changes seen in OI, the current treatment options and the gene therapy approaches being investigated as potential future treatments for OI.

Adeno-associated virus-mediated bone morphogenetic protein-4 gene therapy for in vivo bone formation

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) is so far the most valuable vehicle for gene therapy because it has no association with immune response and human disease. The present study was conducted to investigate the feasibility of AAV-mediated BMP4 gene transfer for bone formation. In vitro study suggested that AAV-BMP4 vectors could transduce myoblast C2C12 cells and produce osteogenic BMP4. In vivo study demonstrated that new bone formation could be induced by direct injection of AAV-BMP4 into the skeletal muscle of immunocompetent rats. Histological analysis revealed that the newly formed bone was induced through endochondral mechanism. Immunohistochemical staining further demonstrated that AAV-BMP4 gene delivery could mediate long-term transduction, and the involvement of BMP4 expression was responsible for the endochondral ossification. This study is, to our knowledge, the first report in the field of AAV-based BMP gene transfer and should be promising for clinical orthopaedic applications.

Gene therapy for new bone formation using adeno-associated viral bone morphogenetic protein-2 vectors

Previous reports have suggested that bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) gene therapy could be applied for in vivo bone regeneration. However, these studies were conducted either using immunodeficient animals because of immunogenicity of adenovirus vectors, or using ex vivo gene transfer technique, which is much more difficult to handle. Adeno-associated virus (AAV) is a replication-defective virus without any association with immunogenicity and human disease. This study was conducted to investigate whether orthotopic new bone formation could be induced by in vivo gene therapy using AAV-based BMP2 vectors. To test the feasibility of this approach, we constructed an AAV vector carrying human BMP2 gene. Mouse myoblast cells (C2C12) transduced with this vector could produce and secrete biologically active BMP2 protein and induce osteogenic activity, which was confirmed by ELISA and alkaline phosphatase activity assay. For in vivo study, AAV-BMP2 vectors were directly injected into the hindlimb muscle of immunocompetent Sprague-Dawley rats. Significant new bone under X-ray films could be detected as early as 3 weeks postinjection. The ossification tissue was further examined by histological and immunohistochemical analysis. This study is, to our knowledge, the first to establish the feasibility of AAV-based BMP2 gene therapy for endochondral ossification in immunocompetent animals.

Gene therapy and tissue engineering in repair of the musculoskeletal system

Historically, surgeons have sought and used different procedures in order to augment the repair of various skeletal tissues. Now, with the completion of the Human Genome Project, many researchers have turned to gene therapy as a means to aid various ailments. In the orthopedic field, many strides have been made toward using gene therapy and tissue engineering in a clinical setting. In this review, several studies are outlined in different areas that gene therapy has or will influence orthopedic surgery. Gene therapy and tissue engineering can aid in fracture healing and spinal fusions by inducing bone formation, ligamentous repairs by increasing the production of connective tissue fibers, intervertebral disc disease by creating potential replacements, and articular cartilage repairs by providing means to improve cartilage. As we continue to see great contributions, such as the few mentioned here, this field will continue to mature and develop.

Enhancement of bone repair with a helper-dependent adenoviral transfer of bone morphogenetic protein-2

Regional gene therapy, which involves the delivery of growth factors to a specific anatomic site, has the potential to enhance bone formation in clinical application. Helper-dependent adenoviral vectors, which have deleted all of the viral coding regions, have been shown to be safe and highly efficient with long-lasting transgene expression. In this study, we constructed a helper-dependent adenoviral vector producing bone morphogenetic protein-2 (AdHDBMP-2). The AdHDBMP-2 increased the alkaline phosphatase activity of W-20-17 cells in vitro. In addition, when AdHDBMP-2 infected rat bone marrow cells were implanted into the hindlimbs of SCID mice, orthotopic bone formation was shown at 2 weeks. To our knowledge, this is the first study to demonstrate bone formation with the helper-dependent adenoviral vector with the BMP-2 expression cassette. This type of gene therapy vector could prove to be highly useful for bone augmentation in patients with bone loss associated with trauma, revision total joint arthroplasty, or cancer.

In vivo new bone formation by direct transfer of adenoviral-mediated bone morphogenetic protein-4 gene

Previous studies have demonstrated that bone morphogenetic protein-4 (BMP4) could participate in vivo endochondral ossification and is one of the main local contributing factors in the early stage of fracture healing. To investigate the effectiveness of BMP4 gene transfer, we constructed an adenoviral vector, Ad-BMP4, and evaluated its osteoinduction activity both in vitro and in vivo. In vitro study suggested that this vector could efficiently transduce mouse myoblast C2C12 cells and produce osteogenic BMP4 protein, as confirmed by immunofluorescence analysis and alkaline phosphatase activity assay. For in vivo study, Ad-BMP4 was directly injected into the hind limb muscles of male athymic nude rats. Visible new bone formation under X-ray films could be detected as early as three weeks post-injection. The bone tissue was further analyzed by histological staining and revealed a typical remodeled bone structure. In conclusion, this study is the first to establish the feasibility of adenovirus-based BMP4 gene therapy for bone regeneration.