Insights into the interaction between Cren7 and DNA: the role of loop β3-β4

Essentiality of core hydrophobicity to the structure and function of archaeal chromatin protein Cren7

Studies on the structure-function relationship of protein greatly help to understand not only the principles of protein folding but also the rationales of protein engineering. Crenarchaeal chromatin protein Cren7 provides an excellent research model for this issue. The small protein adopts a 'β-barrel' fold, formed by the double-stranded antiparallel β-sheet 1 tightly packing with the triple-stranded antiparallel β-sheet 2. The simple structure of Cren7 is stabilized by the hydrophobic core between the β-sheets, consisting of the side chains of V8, V10, L20, V25, F41 and F50. In the present work, mutation analyses by alanine substitution of each of the residues in the hydrophobic core were performed. Circular dichroism spectra and nuclear magnetic resonance analyses showed that mutation of F41 led to a significant misfolding of Cren7 through disruption of the β-sheets. Meanwhile, the mutant F41A showed a reduced thermostatility (Tm of 53.2 °C), as compared with the wild-type Cren7 (Tm > 80 °C). Biolayer interferometry and nick-closure assays showed the largely unchanged activities in DNA binding and supercoiling of F41A, indicating the DNA interface of Cren7 was generally retained in F41A. However, F41A was unable to mediate DNA bridging, probably due to the impairment in forming oligomers/polymers on DNA. Atomic force microscopic images of the F41A-DNA complexes also revealed that F41A nearly completely lost the ability to compact DNA into highly condensed structures. Our results not only reveal the critical role of F41 in protein folding of Cren7 but also provide new insights into the structure-function relationships of thermostable proteins.

Lysine Methylation Modulates the Interaction of Archaeal Chromatin Protein Cren7 With DNA

Cren7 and Sis7d, two chromatin proteins from Sulfolobus islandicus, undergo extensive methylations at multiple lysine residues to various extents. Whether this highly conserved protein serves an epigenetic role in the regulation of the structure and function of the chromosome remains unclear. In the present study, we show that methylation significantly affects Cren7, but not Sis7d, in the ability to bind DNA and to constrain negative DNA supercoils. Strikingly, methylated Cren7 was significantly less efficient in forming oligomers or mediating intermolecular DNA bridging. Single-site substitution mutation with glutamine reveals that methylation of the four lysine residues (K24, K31, K42, and K48) of Cren7 at the protein-DNA interface, which are variably conserved among Cren7 homologues from different branches of the Crenarchaeota, influenced Cren7-DNA interactions in different manners. We suggest that dynamic methylation of Cren7 may represent a potential epigenetic mechanism involved in the chromosomal regulation in crenarchaea.

Archaeal Chromatin Proteins Cren7 and Sul7d Compact DNA by Bending and Bridging

Archaeal chromatin proteins Cren7 and Sul7d from Sulfolobus are DNA benders. To better understand their architectural roles in chromosomal DNA organization, we analyzed DNA compaction by Cren7 and Sis7d, a Sul7d family member, from Sulfolobus islandicus at the single-molecule (SM) level by total single-molecule internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (SM-TIRFM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM). We show that both Cren7 and Sis7d were able to compact singly tethered λ DNA into a highly condensed structure in a three-step process and that Cren7 was over an order of magnitude more efficient than Sis7d in DNA compaction. The two proteins were similar in DNA bending kinetics but different in DNA condensation patterns. At saturating concentrations, Sis7d formed randomly distributed clusters whereas Cren7 generated a single and highly condensed core on plasmid DNA. This observation is consistent with the greater ability of Cren7 than of Sis7d to bridge DNA. Our results offer significant insights into the mechanism and kinetics of chromosomal DNA organization in Crenarchaea.IMPORTANCE A long-standing question is how chromosomal DNA is packaged in Crenarchaeota, a major group of archaea, which synthesize large amounts of unique small DNA-binding proteins but in general contain no archaeal histones. In the present work, we tested our hypothesis that the two well-studied crenarchaeal chromatin proteins Cren7 and Sul7d compact DNA by both DNA bending and bridging. We show that the two proteins are capable of compacting DNA, albeit with different efficiencies and in different manners, at the single molecule level. We demonstrate for the first time that the two proteins, which have long been regarded as DNA binders and benders, are able to mediate DNA bridging, and this previously unknown property of the proteins allows DNA to be packaged into highly condensed structures. Therefore, our results provide significant insights into the mechanism and kinetics of chromosomal DNA organization in Crenarchaeota.

Architectural roles of Cren7 in folding crenarchaeal chromatin filament

Archaea have evolved various strategies in chromosomal organization. While histone homologues exist in most archaeal phyla, Cren7 is a chromatin protein conserved in the Crenarchaeota. Here, we show that Cren7 preferentially binds DNA with AT-rich sequences over that with GC-rich sequences with a binding size of 6~7 bp. Structural studies of Cren7 in complex with either an 18-bp or a 20-bp double-stranded DNA fragment reveal that Cren7 binds to the minor groove of DNA as monomers in a head-to-tail manner. The neighboring Cren7 monomers are located on the opposite sides of the DNA duplex, with each introducing a single-step sharp kink by intercalation of the hydrophobic side chain of Leu28, bending the DNA into an S-shape conformation. A structural model for the chromatin fiber folded by Cren7 was established and verified by the analysis of cross-linked Cren7-DNA complexes by atomic force microscopy. Our results suggest that Cren7 differs significantly from Sul7, another chromatin protein conserved among Sulfolobus species, in both DNA binding and deformation. These data shed significant light on the strategy of chromosomal DNA organization in crenarchaea.

Evolutionary convergence and divergence in archaeal chromosomal proteins and Chromo-like domains from bacteria and eukaryotes

SH3-fold-β-barrel domains of the chromo-like superfamily recognize epigenetic marks in eukaryotic proteins. Their provenance has been placed either in archaea, based on apparent structural similarity to chromatin-compacting Sul7d and Cren7 proteins, or in bacteria based on the presence of sequence homologs. Using sequence and structural evidence we establish that the archaeal Cren7/Sul7 proteins emerged from a zinc ribbon (ZnR) ancestor. Further, we show that the ancestral eukaryotic chromo-like domains evolved from bacterial versions, likely acquired from early endosymbioses, which already possessed an aromatic cage for recognition of modified amino-groups. These bacterial versions are part of a radiation of secreted SH3-fold domains, which spawned both chromo-like domains and classical SH3 domains in the context of peptide-recognition in the peptidoglycan or the extracellular matrix. This establishes that Cren7/Sul7 converged to a “SH3”-like state from a ZnR precursor via the loss of metal-chelation and acquisition of stronger hydrophobic interactions; it is unlikely to have participated in the evolution of the chromo-like domains. We show that archaea possess several Cren7/Sul7-related proteins with intact Zn-chelating ligands, which we predict to play previously unstudied roles in chromosome segregation during cell-division comparable to the PRC barrel and CdvA domain proteins.

Roles of Leu28 side chain intercalation in the interaction between Cren7 and DNA

Crenarchaeal chromatin protein Cren7 binds double-stranded DNA in the minor groove, introducing a sharp single-step DNA kink. The side chain of Leu28, a residue conserved among all Cren7 homologs, intercalates into the kinked DNA step. In the present study, we replaced Leu28 with a residue containing a hydrophobic side chain of different sizes (i.e. L28A, L28V, L28I, L28M and L28F). Both the stability of the Cren7-DNA complex and the ability of Cren7 to constrain DNA supercoils correlated well with the size of the intercalated side chain. Structural analysis shows that L28A induces a kink (∼43°), nearly as sharp as that produced by wild-type Cren7 (∼48°), in the bound DNA fragment despite the lack of side chain intercalation. In another duplex DNA fragment, L28F inserts a large hydrophobic side chain deep into the DNA step, but introduces a smaller kink (∼39°) than that formed by the wild-type protein (∼50°). Mutation of Leu28 into methionine yields two protein conformers differing in loop β3-β4 orientation, DNA-binding surface and DNA geometry in the protein-DNA structure. Our results indicate that side chain intercalation is not directly responsible for DNA kinking or bending by Cren7, but plays a critical role in the stabilization of the Cren7-DNA complex. In addition, the flexibility of loop β3-β4 in Cren7, as revealed in the crystal structure of L28M-DNA, may serve a role in the modulation of chromosomal organization and function in the cell.

Sequence-Dependent T:G Base Pair Opening in DNA Double Helix Bound by Cren7, a Chromatin Protein Conserved among Crenarchaea

T:G base pair arising from spontaneous deamination of 5mC or polymerase errors is a great challenge for DNA repair of hyperthermophilic archaea, especially Crenarchaea. Most strains in this phylum lack the protein homologues responsible for the recognition of the mismatch in the DNA repair pathways. To investigate whether Cren7, a highly conserved chromatin protein in Crenarchaea, serves a role in the repair of T:G mispairs, the crystal structures of Cren7-GTAATTGC and Cren7-GTGATCGC complexes were solved at 2.0 Å and 2.1 Å. In our structures, binding of Cren7 to the AT-rich DNA duplex (GTAATTGC) induces opening of T2:G15 but not T10:G7 base pair. By contrast, both T:G mispairs in the GC-rich DNA duplex (GTGATCGC) retain the classic wobble type. Structural analysis also showed DNA helical changes of GTAATTGC, especially in the steps around the open T:G base pair, as compared to GTGATCGC or the matched DNAs. Surface plasmon resonance assays revealed a 4-fold lower binding affinity of Cren7 for GTAATTGC than that for GTGATCGC, which was dominantly contributed by the decrease of association rate. These results suggested that binding of Cren7 to DNA leads to T:G mispair opening in a sequence dependent manner, and therefore propose the potential roles of Cren7 in DNA repair.