Different Stationary Phase Selectivities and Morphologies for Intact Protein Separations

Online Mixed-Bed Ion Exchange Chromatography for Native Top-Down Proteomics of Complex Mixtures

Native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS) allows characterization of protein structure and noncovalent interactions with simultaneous sequence mapping and proteoform characterization. The majority of nTDMS studies utilize purified recombinant proteins, with significant challenges hindering application to endogenous systems. To perform native top-down proteomics (nTDP), where endogenous proteins from complex biological systems are analyzed by nTDMS, it is essential to separate proteins under nondenaturing conditions. However, it remains difficult to achieve high resolution with MS-compatible online chromatography while preserving protein tertiary structure and noncovalent interactions. Herein, we report the use of online mixed-bed ion exchange chromatography (IEC) to enable separation of endogenous proteins from complex mixtures under nondenaturing conditions, preserving noncovalent interactions for nTDP analysis. We have successfully detected large proteins (>146 kDa) and identified endogenous metal-binding and oligomeric protein complexes in human heart tissue lysate. The use of a mixed-bed stationary phase allowed retention and elution of proteins over a wide range of isoelectric points without altering the sample or mobile phase pH. Overall, our method provides a simple online IEC-MS platform that can effectively separate proteins from complex mixtures under nondenaturing conditions and preserve higher-order structure for nTDP applications.

Identification of proteoforms by top-down proteomics using two-dimensional low/low pH reversed-phase liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry

In top-down (TD) proteomics, efficient proteoform separation is crucial to reduce the sample complexity and increase the depth of the analysis. Here, we developed a two-dimensional low pH/low pH reversed-phase liquid chromatography separation scheme for TD proteomics. The first dimension for offline fractionation was performed using a polymeric reversed-phase (PLRP-S) column with trifluoroacetic acid as ion-pairing reagent. The second dimension, a C4 nanocolumn with formic acid as ion-pairing reagent, was coupled online with a high-field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) Orbitrap Tribrid mass spectrometer. For both dimensions several parameters were optimized, such as the adaption of the LC gradients in the second dimension according to the elution time (i.e., fraction number) in the first dimension. Avoidance of elevated temperatures and prolonged exposure to acidic conditions minimized cleavage of acid labile aspartate-proline peptide bonds. Furthermore, a concatenation strategy was developed to reduce the total measurement time. We compared our low/low pH with a previously published high pH (C4, ammonium formate)/low pH strategy and found that both separation strategies led to complementary proteoform identifications, mainly below 20 kDa, with a higher number of proteoforms identified by the low/low pH separation. With the optimized separation scheme, more than 4900 proteoforms from 1250 protein groups were identified in Caco-2 cells.

Mass spectrometry-based methods to characterize highly heterogeneous biopharmaceuticals, vaccines, and nonbiological complex drugs at the intact-mass level

The intact-mass MS measurements are becoming increasingly popular in characterization of a range of biopolymers, especially those of interest to biopharmaceutical industry. However, as the complexity of protein therapeutics and other macromolecular medicines increases, the new challenges arise, one of which is the high levels of structural heterogeneity that are frequently exhibited by such products. The very notion of the molecular mass measurement loses its clear and intuitive meaning when applied to an extremely heterogenous system that cannot be characterized by a unique mass, but instead requires that a mass distribution be considered. Furthermore, convoluted mass distributions frequently give rise to unresolved ionic signal in mass spectra, from which little-to-none meaningful information can be extracted using standard approaches that work well for homogeneous systems. However, a range of technological advances made in the last decade, such as the hyphenation of intact-mass MS measurements with front-end separations, better integration of ion mobility in MS workflows, development of an impressive arsenal of gas-phase ion chemistry tools to supplement MS methods, as well as the revival of the charge detection MS and its triumphant entry into the field of bioanalysis already made impressive contributions towards addressing the structural heterogeneity challenge. An overview of these techniques is accompanied by critical analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of different approaches, and a brief overview of their applications to specific classes of biopharmaceutical products, vaccines, and nonbiological complex drugs.

Studying protein structure and function by native separation–mass spectrometry

Alterations in protein structure may have profound effects on biological function. Analytical techniques that permit characterization of proteins while maintaining their conformational and functional state are crucial for studying changes in the higher order structure of proteins and for establishing structure-function relationships. Coupling of native protein separations with mass spectrometry is emerging rapidly as a powerful approach to study these aspects in a reliable, fast and straightforward way. This Review presents the available native separation modes for proteins, covers practical considerations on the hyphenation of these separations with mass spectrometry and highlights the involvement of affinity-based separations to simultaneously obtain structural and functional information of proteins. The impact of these approaches is emphasized by selected applications addressing biomedical and biopharmaceutical research questions.

A new ionic liquid bridged periodic mesoporous organosilicas stationary phase for per aqueous liquid chromatography and its application in the detection of biogenic amines

In order to solve the problems of using a large proportion of acetonitrile on the hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) columns that was not environmentally friendly, and the poor acid and base resistance of traditional bonded silica columns, we reported a novel stationary phase of Au nanoparticles (Au NPs) covalently bonded to ionic liquid (ILs) bridged periodic mesoporous organosilicas (PMO) hydrophilic microspheres (PMO-ILs-Au NPs) for per aqueous liquid chromatography (PALC). The PMO hydrophilic microspheres were prepared by condensation of 1,3-bis(trimethoxysilylpropyl)imidazoliumchloride and 1, 2-Bis (triethoxysilyl) ethane and then modified with Au NPs the surface. The obtained materials were characterized by elemental analysis, FT-IR spectra, scanning electron microscope and transmission electron microscopy. The retention behavior was evaluated by investigating the effect of various chromatographic factors on the retention of different types of solutes. The retention mechanism of the stationary phases in PALC was a mixed type of anion-exchange and hydrophobic interaction. Compared with C₁₈-SiO₂ column, the acid and base resistance of the stationary phase were greatly improved. Compared with the HILIC column and C₁₈ column, some hydrophilic compounds such as six organic acids and eight biogenic amines were baseline separated with the enhanced resolution of the PMO-ILs-Au NPs column under the PALC mode. The efficiency of the new column was significantly higher than that of the HILIC column. Furthermore, the analysis of PALC-triple quadrupole mass spectrometry was developed for simultaneous detection of eight biogenic amines. This method could improve detection efficiency, save reagent and reduce environmental pollution. PALC as a green chromatography analytical method was suitable for the replacement of HILIC.

Stability-Indicating Analytical Approach for Stability Evaluation of Lactoferrin

Lactoferrin is a multifunctional iron-binding glycoprotein in milk. Due to its potential for the treatment of various diseases, interest in products containing lactoferrin is increasing. However, as a protein, it is prone to degradation, which critically affects the quality of products. Therefore, the main purpose of our work was to develop a stability-indicating analytical approach for stability evaluation of lactoferrin. We were focused on two complementary methods: reversed-phase and size-exclusion chromatography. The stability-indicating nature of the selected methods was confirmed. They were successfully validated by following the ICH guidelines and applied to preliminary lactoferrin stability studies. Up to three degradation products, as well as aggregates and fragments of lactoferrin, were detected in various samples using complementary reversed-phase and size-exclusion chromatographic methods. The analytical approach was additionally extended with three spectroscopic techniques (absorbance, intrinsic fluorescence, and bicinchoninic acid method), which may provide valuable complementary information in some cases. The presented analytical approach allows the stability evaluation of lactoferrin in various samples, including the ability to detect differences in its degradation mechanisms. Furthermore, it has the potential to be used for the quality control of products containing lactoferrin.

Novel Strategies to Address the Challenges in Top-Down Proteomics

Top-down mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics is a powerful technology for comprehensively characterizing proteoforms to decipher post-translational modifications (PTMs) together with genetic variations and alternative splicing isoforms toward a proteome-wide understanding of protein functions. In the past decade, top-down proteomics has experienced rapid growth benefiting from groundbreaking technological advances, which have begun to reveal the potential of top-down proteomics for understanding basic biological functions, unraveling disease mechanisms, and discovering new biomarkers. However, many challenges remain to be comprehensively addressed. In this Account & Perspective, we discuss the major challenges currently facing the top-down proteomics field, particularly in protein solubility, proteome dynamic range, proteome complexity, data analysis, proteoform-function relationship, and analytical throughput for precision medicine. We specifically review the major technology developments addressing these challenges with an emphasis on our research group's efforts, including the development of top-down MS-compatible surfactants for protein solubilization, functionalized nanoparticles for the enrichment of low-abundance proteoforms, strategies for multidimensional chromatography separation of proteins, and a new comprehensive user-friendly software package for top-down proteomics. We have also made efforts to connect proteoforms with biological functions and provide our visions on what the future holds for top-down proteomics.

Highly Efficient Separation of Methylated Peptides Utilizing Selective Complexation between Lysine and 18-Crown-6

Protein methylation is one of the most common and important post-translational modifications, and it plays vital roles in epigenetic regulation, signal transduction, and chromatin metabolism. However, due to the diversity of methylation forms, slight difference between methylated sites and nonmodified ones, and ultralow abundance, it is extraordinarily challenging to capture and separate methylated peptides from biological samples. Here, we introduce a simple and highly efficient method to separate methylated and nonmethylated peptides using 18-crown-6 as a mobile phase additive in high-performance liquid chromatography. Selective complexation between lysine and 18-crown-6 remarkably increases the retention of the peptides on a C18 stationary phase, leading to an excellent baseline separation between the lysine methylated and nonmethylated peptides. A possible binding mechanism is verified by nuclear magnetic resonance titration, biolayer interferometry technology, and quantum chemistry calculation. Through establishment of a simple enrichment methodology, a good selectivity is achieved and four methylated peptides with greatly improved signal-to-noise (S/N) ratios are successfully separated from a complex peptide sample containing 10-fold bovine serum albumin tryptic digests. By selecting rLys N as an enzyme to digest histone, methylation information in the histone could be well identified based on our enrichment method. This study will open an avenue and provide a novel insight for selective enrichment of lysine methylated peptides in post-translational modification proteomics.

Influence of Blood Collection Methods and Long-Term Plasma Storage on Quorum-Sensing Peptide Stability

Finding adequate biomarkers for rapid and accurate disease detection, prognosis, and therapy is increasingly important. Quorum-sensing peptides are herein a new emerging group, produced by bacteria, fungi, protozoa, and viruses, with blood being the most straightforward sample type to detect/quantitate them. However, detailed information about suitable blood sample collection methods and storage conditions for measuring these quorum-sensing peptides hampers further clinical research and development. Here, we first tested the time-dependent stability of a set of chemically diverse quorum-sensing peptides, spiked in blood at different temperatures (4, 21, and 37 °C) in four different ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA)-containing plasma tubes (with different protein-stabilizing additives) over a period of up to 7.5 h. Next, we determined the storage stability of these quorum-sensing peptides in plasma at different temperatures (4, -35, and -80 °C). UPLC/MS-MS was used to selectively detect and quantify the spiked quorum-sensing peptides. The results of this study indicate that a cost-effective tube, designed for traditional proteomics and stored at 4 °C, is the preferred collection condition when quorum-sensing peptides need to be detected/quantified in human plasma. When the tubes are handled at room temperature (21 °C), a more specialized tube is required. Long-term storage of plasma samples, even under low-temperature conditions (-80 °C), indicates rapid degradation of certain quorum-sensing peptides.

Proteoform-Resolved FcɤRIIIa Binding Assay for Fab Glycosylated Monoclonal Antibodies Achieved by Affinity Chromatography Mass Spectrometry of Fc Moieties

Fcɤ receptors (FcɤR) mediate key functions in immunological responses. For instance, FcɤRIIIa is involved in antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC). FcɤRIIIa interacts with the fragment crystallizable (Fc) of immunoglobulin G (IgG). This interaction is known to be highly dependent on IgG Fc glycosylation. Thus, the impact of glycosylation features on this interaction has been investigated in several studies by numerous analytical and biochemical techniques. FcɤRIIIa affinity chromatography (AC) hyphenated to mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful tool to address co-occurring Fc glycosylation heterogeneity of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). However, MS analysis of mAbs at the intact level may provide limited proteoform resolution, for example, when additional heterogeneity is present, such as antigen-binding fragment (Fab) glycosylation. Therefore, we investigated middle-up approaches to remove the Fab and performed AC-MS on the IgG Fc to evaluate its utility for FcɤRIIIa affinity assessment compared to intact IgG analysis. We found the protease Kgp to be particularly suitable for a middle-up FcɤRIIIa AC-MS workflow as demonstrated for the Fab glycosylated cetuximab. The complexity of the mass spectra of Kgp digested cetuximab was significantly reduced compared to the intact level while affinity was fully retained. This enabled a reliable assignment and relative quantitation of Fc glycoforms in FcɤRIIIa AC-MS. In conclusion, our workflow allows a functional separation of differentially glycosylated IgG Fc. Consequently, applicability of FcɤRIIIa AC-MS is extended to Fab glycosylated IgG, i.e., cetuximab, by significantly reducing ambiguities in glycoform assignment vs. intact analysis.

Separation methods hyphenated to mass spectrometry for the characterization of the protein glycosylation at the intact level

Glycosylation is one of the most common post-translational modifications of proteins that affects their biological activity, solubility, and half-life. Therefore, its characterization is of great interest in proteomic, particularly from a diagnostic and therapeutic point of view. However, the number and type of glycosylation sites, the degree of site occupancy and the different possible structures of glycans can lead to a very large number of isoforms for a given protein, called glycoforms. The identification of these glycoforms constitutes an important analytical challenge. Indeed, to attempt to characterize all of them, it is necessary to develop efficient separation methods associated with a sensitive and informative detection mode, such as mass spectrometry (MS). Most analytical methods are based on bottom-up proteomics, which consists in the analysis of the protein at the glycopeptides level after its digestion. Even if this approach provides essential information, including the localization and composition of glycans on the protein, it is also characterized by a loss of information on macro-heterogeneity, i.e. the nature of the glycans present on a given glycoform. The analysis of glycoforms at the intact level can overcome this disadvantage. The aim of this review is to detail the state-of-the art of separation methods that can be easily hyphenated with MS for the characterization of protein glycosylation at the intact level. The different electrophoretic and chromatographic approaches are discussed in detail. The miniaturization of these separation methods is also discussed with their potential applications. While the first studies focused on the development and optimization of the separation step to achieve high resolution between isoforms, the recent ones are much more application-oriented, such as clinical diagnosis, quality control, and glycoprotein monitoring in formulations or biological samples.

Simple Tip-Based Sample Processing Method for Urinary Proteomic Analysis

Mass spectrometry-based urinary proteomics is one of the most attractive strategies to discover proteins for diagnosis, prognosis, monitoring, or prediction of therapeutic responses of urological diseases involving the kidney, prostate, and bladder; however, interfering compounds found in urine necessitate sample preparation strategies that are currently not suitable for urinary proteomics in the clinical setting. Herein, we describe the C4-tip method, comprising a simple, automated strategy utilizing a reverse-phase resin tip-based format and "on-tip" digestion to examine the urine proteome. We first determined the optimal conditions for protein isolation and protease digestion on the C4-tip using the standard protein bovine fetuin. Next, we applied the C4-tip method to urinary proteomics, identifying a total of 813 protein groups using LC-MS/MS, with identified proteins from the C4-tip method displaying a similar distribution of gene ontology (GO) cellular component assignments compared to identified proteins from an ultrafiltration preparation method. Finally, we assessed the reproducibility of the C4-tip method, revealing a high Spearman correlation R-value for shared proteins identified across all tips. Together, we have shown the C4-tip method to be a simple, robust method for high-throughput analysis of the urinary proteome by mass spectrometry in the clinical setting.

LC/MS at the whole protein level: Studies of biomolecular structure and interactions using native LC/MS and cross-path reactive chromatography (XP-RC) MS

Interfacing liquid chromatography (LC) with electrospray ionization (ESI) to enable on-line MS detection had been initially implemented using reversed phase LC, which in the past three decades remained the default type of chromatography used for LC/MS and LC/MS/MS studies of protein structure. In contrast, the advantages of other types of LC as front-ends for ESI MS, particularly those that allow biopolymer higher order structure to be preserved throughout the separation process, enjoyed relatively little appreciation until recently. However, the past few years witnessed a dramatic surge of interest in the so-called "native" (with "non-denaturing" being perhaps a more appropriate adjective) LC/MS and LC/MS/MS analyses within the bioanalytical and biophysical communities. This review focuses on recent advances in this field, with an emphasis on size exclusion and ion exchange chromatography as front-end platforms for protein characterization by LC/MS. Also discussed are the benefits provided by the integration of chemical reactions in the native LC/MS analyses, including both ion chemistry in the gas phase (e.g., limited charge reduction for characterization of highly heterogeneous biopolymers) and solution-phase reactions (using the recently introduced technique cross-path reactive chromatography).

Mobile Affinity Sorbent Chromatography

The objective in routine analyses is generally to determine a small number of analytes. With samples containing ∼103 or more components there will be insufficient peak capacity to resolve analytes from nonanalytes. This issue was addressed herein through a new type of separation mechanism in which small groups of targeted analytes are bound with high affinity to a soluble analyte-sequestering transport phase (ASTP) composed of a ∼25 nm Stokes radius hydrophilic polymer core (HPC). When introduced into a 30 nm pore diameter size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) column, ASTP/analyte complexes elute within minutes, together, unretained, and relatively pure in the first chromatographic peak. Nonanalytes, in contrast, enter pore matrices of the packing material, are retarded in elution velocity, and are eluted later, separated from analytes. Fabrication of ASTPs was achieved by covalently coupling an antibody or some other affinity selector to a high molecular weight HPC. Beyond sequestering analytes, the function of ASTPs is to act as a molecular weight shifting agent, conveying an effective molecular weight to analytes that is much larger than that of nonanalytes and causing them to elute in the SEC void volume. This mode of separation is referred to as mobile affinity sorbent chromatography (MASC). Subsequent to their purification, ASTP/analyte complexes were detected by fluorescence spectrometry.

Continuous Elution Proteoform Identification of Myelin Basic Protein by Superficially Porous Reversed-Phase Liquid Chromatography and Fourier Transform Mass Spectrometry

Myelin basic protein (MBP) plays an important structural and functional role in the neuronal myelin sheath. Translated MBP exhibits extreme microheterogeneity with numerous alternative splice variants (ASVs) and post-translational modifications (PTMs) reportedly tied to central nervous system maturation, myelin stability, and the pathobiology of various de- and dys-myelinating disorders. Conventional bioanalytical tools cannot efficiently examine ASV and PTM events simultaneously, which limits understanding of the role of MBP microheterogeneity in human physiology and disease. To address this need, we report on a top-down proteomics pipeline that combines superficially porous reversed-phase liquid chromatography (SPLC), Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS), data-independent acquisition (DIA) with nozzle-skimmer dissociation (NSD), and aligned data processing resources to rapidly characterize abundant MBP proteoforms within murine tissue. The three-tier proteoform identification and characterization workflow resolved four known MBP ASVs and hundreds of differentially modified states from a single 90 min SPLC-FTMS run on ∼0.5 μg of material. This included 323 proteoforms for the 14.1 kDa ASV alone. We also identified two novel ASVs from an alternative transcriptional start site (ATSS) of the MBP gene as well as a never before characterized S-acylation event linking palmitic acid, oleic acid, and stearic acid at C78 of the 17.125 kDa ASV.