Experimental study on temperature rise of acoustic radiation force elastography

Examination of rapid adjustment system based on screen score obtained using continuous shear wave elastography

PURPOSE

Continuous shear wave elastography (C-SWE) can be expected to be applied to portable muscle elasticity diagnosis. To establish diagnostic technology, it will be necessary to improve measurement techniques and quantitative measurement accuracy.

METHODS

In this study, we investigated two screen scores: the quality index (Q-index), which determines whether the intensity of a power Doppler image is appropriate, and the shear wave propagation direction index (SWDI), which determines the uniformity of shear wave propagation.

RESULTS

First, we performed numerical simulations with white noise and found that the coefficient of variation of shear wave velocity estimation was less than 5% when the normalized Q-index was greater than 0.27. Furthermore, regarding the SWDI, we clarified the relationship between the standard deviation in shear wave propagation direction and the SWDI. Next, the relationship between the Q-index and coefficient of variation of estimated shear wave velocity was evaluated through experiments using a tissue-mimicking phantom. The results showed that there was a negative correlation between the Q-index and the coefficient of variation, and the fluctuation of the propagation velocity could be inferred from the Q-index. Finally, we showed the results of applying the screen scores to muscle relaxation monitoring and confirmed its usefulness in clinical applications.

CONCLUSION

By applying the screen scores, we showed improved stability in speed estimation in C-SWE, and demonstrated the possibility of clinical applicability.

In Vivo Temperature Rise Measurements of Rabbit Liver and Femur Bone Surface Exposed to an Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse

Acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) imaging and shear wave elastography use a "push pulse." The push pulse, which is referenced as an ARFI in this study, has a longer duration than that of conventional diagnostic pulses (several microseconds). Therefore, there are concerns regarding thermal safety in vivo. However, few in vivo studies have been conducted using living animals. In this study, to suggest a concept for deciding an ARFI output and cooling time while considering thermal safety, the liver (with and without an ultrasound contrast agent) and femur bone surface of living rabbits were exposed to an ARFI, and the maximum temperature rise, temperature rise for 5-min duration, and cooling time were measured via a thermocouple. While testing within the regulation limits of diagnostic ultrasound outputs, a maximum temperature rise on the femur bone surface exceeded the allowable temperature rise (1.5°C) in the British Medical Ultrasound Society (BMUS) statement. However, using the linear relationships between the pulse intensity integral (PII) of a single pulse and the above three temperature parameters, PII may be determined so that the maximum temperature rise is within the allowable temperature rise in the BMUS statement. The cooling time can be estimated from the PII.

A review of physical and engineering factors potentially affecting shear wave elastography

It has been recognized that tissue stiffness provides useful diagnostic information, as with palpation as a screening for diseases such as cancer. In recent years, shear wave elastography (SWE), a technique for evaluating and imaging tissue elasticity quantitatively and objectively in diagnostic imaging, has been put into practical use, and the amount of clinical knowledge about SWE has increased. In addition, some guidelines and review papers regarding technology and clinical applications have been published, and the status as a diagnostic technology is in the process of being established. However, there are still unclear points about the interpretation of shear wave speed (SWS) and converted elastic modulus in SWE. To clarify these, it is important to investigate the factors that affect the SWS and elastic modulus. Therefore, physical and engineering factors that potentially affect the SWS and elastic modulus are discussed in this review paper, based on the principles of SWE and a literature review. The physical factors include the propagation properties of shear waves, mechanical properties (viscoelasticity, nonlinearity, and anisotropy), and size and shape of target tissues. The engineering factors include the region of interest depth and signal processing. The aim of this review paper is not to provide an answer to the interpretation of SWS. It is to provide information for readers to formulate and verify the hypothesis for the interpretation. Therefore, methods to verify the hypothesis for the interpretation are also reviewed. Finally, studies on the safety of SWE are discussed.

Temperature Elevation in an Instrumented Phantom Insonated by B-Mode Imaging, Pulse Doppler and Shear Wave Elastography

Diagnostic ultrasound is the gold standard for obstetric scanning and one of the most important imaging techniques for perinatal and neonatal monitoring and diagnosis. Ultrasound provides detailed real-time anatomic information, including blood flow measurements and tissue elasticity. The latter is provided through various techniques including shear wave elastography (SWE). SWE is increasingly used in many areas of medicine, especially in detection and diagnosis of breast, thyroid and prostate cancers and liver disease. More recently, SWE has found application in gynaecology and obstetrics. This method mimics manual palpation, revealing the elastic properties of soft biological tissues. Despite its rising potential and expanding clinical interest in its use in obstetrics and gynaecology (such as for assessment of cervical ripening or organ development and structure during pregnancy), its effects on and potential risks to the developing fetus remain unknown. Risks should be evaluated by regulatory bodies before recommendations are made on the use of SWE. Because ultrasound is known to produce thermal and mechanical effects, this study measured the temperature increase caused by B-mode, pulse Doppler (PD) and SWE, using an instrumented phantom with 11 embedded thermocouples. Experiments were performed with an Aixplorer diagnostic ultrasound system (Supersonic Imagine, Aix-en-Provence, France). As expected, the greatest heating was detected by the thermocouple closest to the surface in contact with the transducer (2.9°C for SWE, 1.2°C for PD, 0.7°C for B-mode after 380-s excitation). Both conduction from the transducer face and direct heating owing to ultrasound waves contribute to temperature increase in the phantom with SWE associated with a larger temperature increase than PD and B-mode. This article offers a methodological approach and reference data for future safety studies, as well as initial recommendations about SWE safety in obstetrics and gynaecology.

A Preliminary Study on the Safety of Elastography during Pregnancy: Hypoacusia, Anthropometry, and Apgar Score in Newborns

Transient or acoustic radiation force elastography (ARFE) is becoming the most extended technology to assess cervical effacement, additionally to the Bishop test and conventional ultrasound. However, a debate on the fetal safety has been opened due to the high intensity focused beam emitted to produce shear waves. This work is aimed at providing preliminary data to assess clinical effects of fetal exposure. A follow-up study in newborns of 42 women exposed to ARFE during pregnancy was carried out to explore neonatal hypoacusia, Apgar test, and anthropometry. No hypoacusia cases attributable to ARFE were observed. The Apgar test at five minutes scored normally in all the newborns. Comparisons between anthropometric measurements showed no significant statistically differences. The results preclude to state the harmfulness nor the safety of ARFE. However, given the concern on the high level of energy and the potential risk of harmful bioeffects, larger studies are recommended.

Placental ARFI elastography and biometry evaluation in bitches

Placental rigidity and biometry of twelve pregnant bitches were evaluated using B-mode and Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse (ARFI) ultrasonography, performed once daily, from day 15 of gestation until parturition. Specific software (Virtual Touch Tissue Quantification® VTTQ and Virtual Touch Tissue Imaging Quantification® VTTIQ) were used. Values for results for variables were correlated and regression models related to gestational day were used to make evaluations. Maternal-fetal placental thickness increased to day 63 (P < 0.0001; R² = 0.91); maternal placental thickness increased until day 40 (P = 0.0340; R² = 0.54); and fetal placental thickness increased to day 50 (P < 0.0001; R² = 0.83) of gestation. Shear wave velocity (SWV) of the dorsal (P < 0.0010) was greater than lateral, which in turn was greater (P = 0.020) than the ventral area. The SWV of the dorsal area as determined using VTTQ, decreased from day 21-35 and increased to day 56 of gestation (P = 0.0291; R² = 0.4021); lateral SWV decreased from day 24-45 and increased until the time of parturition (P < 0.001; R² = 0.6055). The SWV of the dorsal area, as determined using VTTIQ, decreased from day 21-43 and then increased to day 60 of gestation (P = 0.0016; R² = 0.5075); and ventral area SWV increased from day 21-23 and decreased until the time of parturition (P < 0.001; R² = 0.8055). Placental alterations reflect structural and biochemical gestational adaptations and can become useful techniques for obstetrics.

Temperature Rise Caused by Shear Wave Elastography, Pulse Doppler and B-Mode in Biological Tissue: An Infrared Thermographic Approach

The aim of this study was to determine the interest in and relevance of the use of infrared thermography, which is a non-invasive full-field surface temperature measurement technique, to characterize the heterogeneous heating caused by ultrasound in biological tissue. Thermal effects of shear wave elastography, pulse Doppler and B-mode were evidenced in porcine tissue. Experiments were performed using a high-frequency echography Aixplorer system (Supersonic Imagine, Aix-en-Provence, France). For all three modes, ultrasound was applied continuously for 360 s while the temperature at the sample surface was recorded with a Cedip Jade III-MWIR infrared camera (Flir, Torcy, France). Temperature changes were detected for the three modes. In particular, "heat tunnels" crossing the sample were visualized from the early stages of the experiment. Heat conduction from the transducer was also involved in the global warming of the sample. The study widens the prospects for studies on tolerability, potentially in addition to classic approaches such as those using thermocouples.

Gestational age-related changes in shear wave speed of the uterine cervix in normal pregnancy at 12-35 weeks' gestation

Background This study aimed to analyze age-related changes in shear wave speed (SWS) of the normal uterine cervix. Methods We studied 362 women with a normal singleton pregnancy at 12-35 weeks' gestation. The SWS of the cervix was measured using transvaginal ultrasonography at the internal os region of the anterior cervix (IOA), posterior cervix (IOP) and cervical canal (IOC), and at the external os region of the anterior cervix (EOA), posterior cervix (EOP) and cervical canal (EOC). The following parameters were analyzed: (1) time trend of SWS of the individual sampling points, (2) comparison of SWS in the internal cervical region and SWS in the external cervical region, and (3) comparison of SWS between the internal and external cervical regions. Statistical analyses were performed using mixed-effects models. Results The SWS of IOP decreased in bilinear regression, with a critical change in the rate at 22 weeks, whereas the SWS of the remaining points decreased linearly. The estimated values of SWS of IOP at 84, 154 and 251 days were higher than those of IOA and IOC (P<0.001). The estimated values of SWS of IOP at 84 and 154 days were higher than those of EOP (P<0.001). Significant differences between IOP and EOP were shown until 244 days (P<0.05). The estimated value of SWS of IOC at 84 days was higher than that of EOC (P<0.001). Significant differences between IOC and EOC were shown until 210 days (P<0.05). Conclusion The SWS of the uterine cervix in pregnancy decreases with advancing gestation. The SWS of IOP had the highest value among the sampling points with unique characteristics.

Shear wave estimation by using Shear Wave Holography with normal vibration: Preliminary results

Mechanical properties of soft human tissue are linked to their pathological state. One way to assess these properties is through the Young modulus measurement, which is related to the shear wave speed in the medium when considering tissues as nearly incompressible. In order to characterize its elastic properties using sonoelastography, we introduce a new technique for shear wave estimation from a static interference pattern based on Shear Wave Holography. A relation between the mathematical representation of the interference pattern and the local shear speed is derived using the Phase Derivative approach. The experimental scheme is presented, detailing the advantages of the new configuration. Homogeneous and heterogeneous elastic media were simulated, generating an interference pattern on them. The shear speed estimation algorithm was explained and applied to obtain the speed map, calculating the mean value over each medium. The technique was tested on a nearly incompressible homogeneous elastic phantom, yielding a maximum and a mean estimation error of 6% and 4.6% respectively. Overall, Shear Wave Holography using normal vibration is feasible and shows promising results in estimating shear wave speed in elastic materials.

Shear wave elastography of placenta: in vivo quantitation of placental elasticity in preeclampsia

PURPOSE

We aimed to evaluate the utility of shear wave elastography (SWE) for assessing the placenta in preeclampsia disease.

METHODS

A total of 50 pregnant women in the second or third trimester (23 preeclampsia patients and 27 healthy control subjects) were enrolled in the study. Obstetrical grayscale and Doppler ultrasonography, SWE findings of placenta, and prenatal/postnatal clinical data were analyzed and the best SWE cutoff value which represents the diagnosis of preeclampsia was determined. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), and diagnostic accuracy of preeclampsia were calculated based on SWE measurements.

RESULTS

Mean stiffness values were much higher in preeclamptic placentas in all regions and layers than in normal controls. The most significant difference was observed in the central placental area facing the fetus where the umbilical cord inserts, with a median of 21 kPa (range, 3-71 kPa) for preeclampsia and 4 kPa (range, 1.5-14 kPa) for the control group (P < 0.01). The SWE data showed a moderate correlation with the uterine artery resistivity and pulsatility indices. The cutoff value maximizing the accuracy of diagnosis was 7.35 kPa (area under curve, 0.895; 95% confidence interval, 0.791-0.998); sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV, and accuracy were 90%, 86%, 82%, 92%, and 88%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Stiffness of the placenta is significantly higher in patients with preeclampsia. SWE appears to be an assistive diagnostic technique for placenta evaluation in preeclampsia.