Short- and long-term effects of copper on anammox under gradually increased copper concentrations

Environmental proteomics as a useful methodology for early-stage detection of stress in anammox engineered systems

Anammox bacteria are widely applied worldwide for denitrification of urban wastewater. Differently, their application in the case of industrial effluents has been more limited. Those frequently present high loads of contaminants, demanding an individual evaluation of their treatability by anammox technologies. Bioreactors setting up and recovery after contaminants-derived perturbations are slow. Also, toxicity is frequently not acute but cumulative, which causes negative macroscopic effects to appear only after medium or long-term operations. All these particularities lead to relevant economic and time losses. We hypothesized that contaminants cause changes at anammox proteome level before perturbations in the engineered systems are detectable by macroscopic analyses. In this study, we explored the usefulness of short-batch tests combined with environmental proteomics for the early detection of those changes. Copper was used as a model of stressor contaminant, and anammox granules were exposed to increasing copper concentrations including previously reported IC50 values. The proteomic results revealed that specific anammox proteins involved in stress response (bacterioferritin, universal stress protein, or superoxide dismutase) were overexpressed in as short a time as 28 h at the higher copper concentrations. Consequently, EPS production was also increased, as indicated by the alginate export family protein, polysaccharide biosynthesis protein, and sulfotransferase increased expression. The described workflow can be applied to detect early-stage stress biomarkers of the negative effect of other metals, organics, or even changes in physical-chemical parameters such as pH or temperature on anammox-engineered systems. On an industrial level, it can be of great value for decision-making, especially before dealing with new effluents on facilities, deriving important economic and time savings.

Toxic effect of copper ions on anammox in IFFAS process filled with ZVI-10 modified carriers

The inhibitory effects of heavy metals on anammox bacteria (AnAOB) have attracted attention worldwide. However, most are conducted in activated sludge rather than biofilm systems. The toxic effect and resistance response of anammox biofilm are not predictable from those of free-living AnAOB. Zero valent iron (ZVI) has been demonstrated to enhance anammox performance, but whether ZVI can promote AnAOB resistance to heavy metal stress remains unclear. Herein, the toxic effect of copper ions (Cu(II)) on anammox in integrated floating-film activated sludge (IFFAS) process filled with 10 wt% ZVI modified carriers (R1) was investigated. Results indicated half inhibiting concentration (IC50) of Cu(II) in R1 was 9.13 mg/L, which was much higher than that in R0 filled with conventional carriers made of high density polyethylene (HDPE) (3.94 mg/L). Long-term effect of Cu(II) demonstrated that Cu(II) concentrations less than 1.0 mg/L could not inhibit anammox biofilm significantly, whereas R1 performed better anammox process than R0 under the stress of 0.1-1.0 mg/L Cu(II). The ZVI modified carriers induced more extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) to trap Cu(II) to attenuate the toxicity to AnAOB. Besides, the activities of functional enzymes related to anammox (NIR and HDH), as well as heme-c contents, were always higher in R1 than R0 regardless of the Cu(II) dosage. Candidatus Kuenenia was identified as the predominant AnAOB, which had stronger resistance to Cu(II) stress compared to other genera in the IFFAS process. Metal resistance genes (MRGs) analysis identified AnAOB induced multi-responses to resist Cu(II) stress, such as the up-regulation of copC, cutA, cutC, cutF, cueR and cueO, to synthesize more proteins with functions of copper exocytosis, conjugation and oxidation.