Heavy metal stabilization remediation in polluted soils with stabilizing materials: a review

Heavy metals and probabilistic risk assessment via Prunella vulgaris (food and medicine homology) consumption in Guangdong Province, China

Prunella vulgaris is widely used as the main ingredient of herb tea in Southeast Asia, as well as a traditional Chinese medicine. However, the heavy metal contaminations such as arsenic, cadmium, mercury and lead in P. vulgaris may be a cause for concern due to the environment pollution around, plantation and processing contamination. Thus, this study intented to assess both non-carcinogenic risks and carcinogenic risks attributed to cumulative exposure to the four heavy metals in P. vulgaris. The contaminations levels of heavy metals were determined in 90 batches of P. vulgaris. And the consumption level was obtained through a questionnaire survey among a total of 6,235 adult participants in Guangdong province. This study estimated the probabilistic health risks using Monte Carlo simulation, and found that the estimated mean and the 95th percentile values for cumulative noncarcinogenic risk (HI value) and carcinogenic risk (TCR value) of P. vulgaris were all within the acceptable risk. And the assessment results indicated that arsenic was the primary contributors to both noncarcinogenic and carcinogenic risks through P. vulgaris consumption. These findings and continuing the surveillance of heavy metals in P. vulgaris will be particularly relevant to both consumers and policy makers.

Magnesium polypeptide combined with microbially induced calcite precipitation for remediation of lead contamination in phosphate mining wasteland soil

Soil Pb contamination is inevitable, as a result of phosphate mining. It is essential to explore more effective Pb remediation approaches in phosphate mining wasteland soil to ensure their viability for a gradual return of soil quality for cultivation. In this study, a Pb-resistant urease-producing bacterium, Serratia marcescens W1Z1, was screened for remediation using microbially induced carbonate precipitation (MICP). Magnesium polypeptide (MP) was prepared from soybean meal residue, and the combined remediation of Pb contamination with MP and MICP in phosphate mining wasteland soil was studied. Remediation of Pb using a combination of MP with MICP strain W1Z1 (WM treatment) was the most effective, with the least exchangeable Pb at 30.37% and the most carbonate-bound Pb at 40.82%, compared to the other treatments, with a pH increase of 8.38. According to the community analysis, MP moderated the damage to microbial abundance and diversity caused by MICP. Total nitrogen (TN) was positively correlated with Firmicutes, pH, and carbonate-bound Pb. Serratia inoculated with strain W1Z1 were positively correlated with bacteria belonging to the Firmicutes phylum and negatively correlated with bacteria belonging to Proteobacteria. The available phosphate (AP) in the phosphate mining wasteland soil could encapsulate the precipitated Pb by ion exchange with carbonate, making it more stable. Combined MP-MICP remediation of Pb contamination in phosphate mining wasteland soil was effective and improved the soil microenvironment.

Impact of particle size separation on the stabilisation efficiency of heavy-metal-contaminated soil: a meta-analysis

The separation of heavy-metal-contaminated soil by particle size is crucial for minimising the volume of contaminated soil because of the pronounced variability in the heavy-metal distribution among different soil particle sizes. However, relevant analyses on the effect of soil particle size sorting on stabilisation are limited. Therefore, we screened 2766 peer-reviewed papers published from January 2010 to April 2022 in the Web of Science database, of which 117 met the screening requirements, and conducted a meta-analysis to explore how soil particle size sorting and the interaction between sorting particle size and soil properties affect the stabilisation of heavy metals. The results showed that: (1) For fractionations ≤0.15 mm and from 0.15-2 mm, the materials demonstrating the highest average unit stabilisation efficiency were phosphate (45.0%/%) and organic matter (59.5%/%), respectively. (2) The smaller the size of soil particles, the greater the effect of the initial pH on stabilisation efficiency. (3) Similarly, for soil organic matter, smaller particle sizes (≤0.15 mm) combined with a lower initial content (≤1%) significantly increased the heavy metal stabilisation efficiency. (4) The impact of soil particle size fractionation on unit stabilisation efficiency was observed to be similar for typical heavy metals, specifically Cd and Pb. The relationship between particle size and unit stabilisation efficiency shows an inverted U shape. Particle size sorting can affect the distribution of heavy metals, but the type of stabilisation agent should also be considered in combination with the soil properties and heavy metal types.

Co-pyrolysis of alkali-fused fly ash and corn stover to synthesize biochar composites for remediating lead-contaminated soil

Fly ash (FA) is mainly composed of silica, alumina, and other metal oxide components, and has a positive stabilizing effect on soil heavy metals. Biochar composites produced from FA and corn stover (CS) can improve its remediation performance. Therefore, a batch of biochar composites (alkali-fused FA-CS biochars, ABs), synthesized via co-pyrolysis of CS and alkali-fused FA (AFFA) at different temperatures of 300, 500, and 700 °C (AB300-1, AB500-1, and AB700-1) and CS to AFFA mass ratios of 10:1, 10:2, and 10:5 (AB500-1, AB500-2, and AB500-5), was used to remediate lead (Pb)-contaminated soil. Compared with pristine biochars (BCs), ABs were enriched with oxygen-containing functional groups (Si-O-Si and Si-O) and aromatic structures. The ABs prepared at lower pyrolytic temperature (≤500 °C) and lower ratio of CS to AFFA (10:1) showed higher yield and stability. The contents of Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP)-extractable Pb and DTPA-CaCl2-triethanolamine (DTPA)-extractable Pb were generally lower in the soils amended with ABs than BCs. Compared with other ABs such as AB300-1, AB500-2, AB500-5, and AB700-1, the soil amended with AB500-1 had lower contents of TCLP and DTPA-extractable Pb (24% reduction), exhibiting superior performance in stabilizing Pb in the soil. The gradual decrease of DTPA-extractable Pb content in the soil with increasing dosage of AB500-1 amendments suggests that AB500-1 facilitated the conversion of bioavailable Pb to the stable and less toxic residual fractions. Specifically, the highest percentage of residual fraction of Pb in soil amended with AB500-1 was 14%. Correlation analyses showed that the soil DTPA-extractable Pb content decreased with the increase of soil pH and cation-exchange capacity (CEC) value. ABs stabilize Pb in the soils mainly via electrostatic attraction, precipitation, cation-π interaction, cation exchange, and complexation. These findings provide insights for producing functionalized biochar composites from industrial waste like FA and biomass waste for remediating the soils polluted by heavy metals.

Effect of intercropping and biochar amendments on lead removal capacity by Corchorus olitorius and Zea mays

Intercropping is a sustainable strategy recognized for boosting crop production and mitigating heavy metal toxicity in contaminated soils. This study investigates the effects of biochar amendments on Pb-contaminated soil, utilizing monocropping and intercropping techniques with C. olitorius and Z. mays. The research assesses Pb removal capacity, nutrient uptake, antioxidant enzymes, and soil Pb fractionation. In monocropping, the phytoremediation ratio for C. olitorius increased from 16.67 to 27.33%, while in intercropping, it rose from 19.00 to 28.33% with biochar amendments. Similarly, Z. mays exhibited an increased phytoremediation ratio from 53.33 to 74.67% in monocropping and from 63.00 to 78.67% in intercropping with biochar amendments. Intercropping significantly increased the peroxidase (POD) activity in Z. mays roots by 22.53%, and there were notable increases in shoot POD of C. olitorius (11.54%) and Z. mays (16.20%) with biochar application. CAT showed consistent improvements, increasing by 37.52% in C. olitorius roots and 74.49% in Z. mays roots with biochar. Biochar amendments significantly increased N content in soil under sole cropping of Z. mays and intercropping systems. In contrast, Cu content increased by 56.34%, 59.05%, and 79.80% in monocropping (C. olitorius and Z. mays) and intercropping systems, respectively. This suggests that biochar enhances nutrient availability, improving phytoremediation efficacy in Pb-contaminated soil. Phyto availability of trace metals (Zn, Mn, Cu, and Fe) exhibited higher levels with biochar amendments than those without. The findings indicate that intercropping and biochar amendments elevate antioxidant enzyme levels, reducing reactive oxygen species and mitigating Pb toxicity effects. This approach improves phytoremediation efficiency and holds promise for soil pollution remediation while enhancing nutrient content and crop quality in Pb-contaminated soil.

Mechanism and ecological environmental risk assessment of peroxymonosulfate for the treatment of heavy metals in soil

Oxidation technologies based on peroxymonosulfate (PMS) have been effectively used for the remediation of soil organic pollutants due to their high efficiency. However, the effects of advanced PMS-based oxidation technologies on other soil pollutants, such as heavy metals, remain unknown. In this study, changes in the form of heavy metals in soil after using PMS and the risk of pollution to the ecological environment were investigated. Furthermore, two risk assessment methods, the mung bean germination toxicity test and groundwater leaching soil column test, were employed to evaluate the soil before and after PMS treatment. The results showed that PMS has a strong ability to degrade complex compounds, enabling the transformation of heavy metals, such as Cd, Pb, and Zn, from stable to active states in the soil. The risk assessments showed that PMS treatment activated heavy metals in the soil, which delayed the growth of plants, increased heavy metal content in plant tissues and the risk of groundwater pollution. These findings provide a new perspective for understanding the effects of PMS on soil, thus facilitating the sustained and reliable development of future research in the field of advanced oxidation applied to soil treatment.

Recent advances in clay minerals for groundwater pollution control and remediation

Clay minerals are abundant on Earth and have been crucial to the advancement of human civilization. The ability of clay minerals to absorb chemicals is frequently utilized to remove hazardous compounds from aquatic environments. Moreover, clay-based adsorbent products are both environmentally acceptable and affordable. This study provides an overview of advances in clay minerals in the field of groundwater remediation and related predictions. The existing literature was examined using data and information aggregation approaches. Keyword clustering analysis of the relevant literature revealed that clay minerals are associated with groundwater utilization and soil pollution remediation. Principal component analysis was used to assess the relationships among clay mineral modification methods, pollutant properties, and the Langmuir adsorption capacity (Qmax). The results demonstrated that pollutant properties affect the Qmax of pollutants adsorbed by clay minerals. Systematic cluster analysis was utilized to classify the collected data and investigate the relationships. The pollution adsorption mechanism of the unique structure of clay minerals was investigated based on the characterization results. Modified clay minerals exhibited changes in surface functional groups, internal structure, and pHpzc. This review provides a summary of recent clay-based materials and their applications in groundwater remediation, as well as discussions of their challenges and future prospects.

Amendment-driven soil health restoration through soil pH and microbial robustness in a Cd/Cu-combined acidic soil: A ten-year in-situ field experiment

Soil health arguably depends on biodiversity and has received wide attention in heavy-metal (HM) contaminated farmland remediation in recent years. However, long-term effects and mechanisms of soil amendment remain poorly understood with respect to soil microbal community. In this in-situ field study, four soil amendments (attapulgite-At, apatite-Ap, montmorillonite-M, lime-L) at three rates were applied once only for ten years in a cadmium (Cd)-copper (Cu) contaminated paddy soil deprecated for over five years. Results showed that after ten years and in compared with CK (no amendment), total Cd concentration and its risk in plot soils were not altered by amendments (p > 0.05), but total Cu concentration and its risk were significantly increased by both Ap and L, especially the former, rather than At and M (p < 0.05), through increased soil pH and enhanced bacterial alpha diversity as well as plant community. Soil microbial communities were more affected by amendment type (30%) than dosage (11%), microbial network characteristics were dominated by rare taxa, and soil multifunctionality was improved in Ap- and L-amended soils. A structural equation model (SEM) indicated that 57.3% of soil multifunctionality variances were accounted for by soil pH (+0.696) and microbial network robustness (-0.301). Moreover, microbial robustness could be potentially used as an indicator of soil multifunctionality, and Ap could be optimized to improve soil health in combined with biomass removal. These findings would advance the understanding of soil microbial roles, especially its network robustness, on soil multifunctionality for the remediation of metal contaminated soils and metal control management strategies in acidic soils. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPLICATION: Farmland soil contamination by heavy metals (HMs) has been becoming a serious global environmental challenge. However, most studies have been conducted over the short term, leading to a gap in the long-term remediation efficiency and ecological benefits of soil amendments. For the successful deployment of immobilization technologies, it is critical to understand the long-term stability of the immobilized HMs and soil health. Our study, to the best of our knowlege, is the first to state the long-term effects and mechanisms of soil amendments on soil health and optimize an effective and eco-friendly amendment for long-term Cd/Cu immobilization.

NaH2PO4 synergizes with organic matter to stabilize chromium in tannery sludge

Heavy metal stabilization is an effective method to treat chromium in tannery sludge. Here we show that mainly investigated NaH2PO4 (MSP) and organic matter (OM) to stabilize chromium in tannery sludge. The experimental investigation revealed that the addition of montmorillonite (MMT) and MSP samples showed a significant increase in the percentage of reducible and oxidizable Cr in the former compared to the samples with the addition of MMT. This is attributed to the formation of Cr-O bond, which allows the MSP to undergo an inner-sphere complexation reaction with the metal oxide of Cr via ligand exchange. Significantly, the MSP moiety adsorbs on the surface of OM through monodentate, which increases the adsorption sites of OM for Cr6+ and promotes the reduction of Cr6+ to Cr3+. Moreover, PO43- reacts with Cr3+ to produce CrPO4 precipitation, thus reducing the free Cr3+ content. Finally, DFT calculations confirmed that a ternary system is formed between PO43-, OM, and Cr, and the binding energy is negative, which indicated that PO43- could co-stabilize Cr with OM.

Co-utilization of sepiolite and ferromanganese ore reduces rice Cd and As concentrations via soil immobilization and root Fe-Mn plaque resistance

Cadmium (Cd) and arsenic (As), common toxic elements in farmland soil, are easily absorbed by rice and accumulate in grains. Combined amendment is likely to ameliorate Cd-As-contaminated soil; however, studies on this aspect are limited. Therefore, we explored the effects of co-utilizing sepiolite and ferromanganese ore (SF) on Cd-As accumulation in rice by conducting pot experiments on Cd-As-contaminated paddy soil. The results showed that 4 g kg-1 SF (4SF) reduced Cd (55.9 %/48.5 %) and As (82.9 %/64.7 %) concentrations in grain in early and late rice. The Fe concentration in Fe-Mn plaque (IMP) (FeIMP) first decreased and then increased, and the Mn concentration in IMP (MnIMP) increased with an increase in the SF addition amount. This resulted in the 4SF treatment maximizing the Cd adsorption capacity of IMP, whereas the 2 g kg-1 SF treatment (2SF) minimized the As adsorption capacity of IMP. More importantly, when the total Cd and As were 9.7 mg kg-1 and 304.2 mg kg-1, respectively, in the soil, 4SF application reduced CaCl2-extractable Cd (80.5 %/87.9 %), and 2SF reduced available As (24.0 %/20.9 %) in early and late rice. Additionally, SF decreased the Cd and As ion contents in soil pore water. Overall, SF has good immobilization and sustained effect on Cd-As and can be used as an effective material for remediation of Cd-As-contaminated soil.

Carbon quantum dots-containing poly(β-cyclodextrin) for simultaneous removal and detection of metal ions from water

This study investigates the synthesis and characterization of supramolecular composites composed of poly(β-cyclodextrin-co-citric acid) and carbon quantum dots (QDs). These composites serve a dual purpose as adsorbents and photoluminescent probes for divalent metal ions, including Ni(II), Cu(II), Cd(II), and Pb(II), which can have detrimental effects on the environment. Various characterization techniques were employed to confirm the successful synthesis of the composites and the interaction between cyclodextrins and QDs. By using mathematical tools, optimal conditions for metal adsorption were determined, resulting in the composites exhibiting high adsorption capacities, reaching 220 mg/g, and impressive removal efficiencies exceeding 90 % for Ni(II) and Cu(II). The supramolecular composites also exhibit selective adsorption of metal ions with small ionic radio and can be reused with minimal loss of efficiency. In addition to their adsorption capabilities, these composites display luminescence quenching upon the adsorption of metal ions, which can be utilized for sensing applications. Spectroscopic evaluation reveals Stern-Volmer quenching constants for the accessible fraction of QDs in the range of 3777 to 13,359 M-1. The high stability of QDs on the composites allows for long-term storage. In summary, this original supramolecular composite shows promise for simultaneously monitoring and treating water and wastewater, making it a valuable tool in environmental applications.