Malignant transformation of orbital solitary fibrous tumor

Primary orbital sarcoma in adults: a case series with emphasis on post-irradiation sarcoma

PURPOSE

To describe a series of eight adult patients with primary orbital sarcoma and to review the existing literature on orbital sarcoma and post-irradiation sarcoma.

METHODS

Report of eight cases and literature review.

RESULTS

We report eight cases of primary orbital sarcoma, three of which were radiation-induced. Only one patient had a history of retinoblastoma. The most common presentations were painful proptosis and reduced vision. Most tumours arose in the extraconal compartment. The overall median age at diagnosis was 50 years. The pathology comprised a diverse group of tumours. Treatment and outcome varied between patients and their clinical circumstances.

CONCLUSIONS

Adult primary orbital sarcomas are rare. They can comprise a variety of tumour types and are difficult to treat. Irradiation is a significant risk factor, and the incidence of post-irradiation sarcoma of the orbit may be increasing due to the widespread use of radiotherapy and improved survival of patients with cancer. Post-irradiation sarcoma should be considered in the differential diagnosis of an orbital space-occupying lesion in a patient with a history of radiotherapy.

Orbital Solitary Fibrous Tumors: A 20-Year Cases Series Study in a Single Center

PURPOSE

To investigate the clinical manifestations, imaging, pathology, and prognosis of orbital solitary fibrous tumors (OSFTs). In addition, the surgical incisions and the treatment outcomes were also evaluated.

METHODS

A total of 89 patients with pathologically confirmed primary OSFTs were enrolled onto this study. Clinical and histopathological characteristics, imaging data, treatment modalities, and follow-up time, including tumor recurrence and death, were documented. The outcome measures included overall survival and disease-free survival time.

RESULTS

Among 89 eligible cases, the median age of presentation was 39 years (range: 5-80 years) at the initial diagnosis. The most common presenting symptom was painless proptosis (54, 60.67%), then palpable mass (31, 34.83%), swelling (29, 32.58%), and impaired ocular motility (27, 30.34%). Tumor-related severe impaired vision was found in 11 patients (12.36%), including no-light-perception blindness (6, 6.74%), light-perception (2, 2.25%), and hand-movement (1, 1.12%). The preoperative imaging (computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging) accurate diagnostic rate of OSFTs was 17.98% (16, 95% CI: 0.098-0.261), and misdiagnosis rate was 25.84% (23, 95% CI: 0.166-0.351). Grossly intact masses were excised for 27 patients (30.34%). Among the 89 patients, 33 (37.08%) were recurrences, and the median of these recurrent patients' interval between the first and the last operation was 7.33 years (range: 0.12-29.69 years). In 81 patients with complete follow-up data, the median course of the disease was 9.64 years (range: 1.55-33.65 years) from the onset OSFT. The overall survival rate of the 81 patients was 93.83% with a median course of 8.48 years (range: 0.38-30.4 years) from diagnosis of OSFT, and the disease-free survival rate of 81 patients was 91.36% with a median follow-up of 4.76 years (range: 0.08-19.22 years) after the last surgery. Of all the 81 patients, 5 patients (6.17%) developed local recurrence, and 3 patients (3.70%) died from tumor-related diseases, including pulmonary metastasis (2, 2.47%) and complications from intracranial lesions (1, 1.23%). Ten patients (11.24%) received postoperational radiation therapy, including 125I seeds implantation (5, 6.17%) and external beam radiotherapy (5, 6.17%), and remained no recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

In this series, OSFTs showed long courses and easy recurrence. Although it was very important to choose a proper surgical incision for intact resection of OSFTs at the initial surgery to avoiding recurrence, preoperative imaging is of very limited use since it is not able to identify OSFTs effectively. Postoperative radiotherapy may be beneficial to reduce the recurrence of OSFTs with malignant pathologic features.

Malignant recurrent orbital solitary fibrous tumor

Solitary fibrous tumor (SFT) is a rare mesenchymal tumor of fibroblastic origin commonly occurring in pleura. It can occur at many extrapleural sites but is rare in orbit. Most cases are benign and recurrence is not unusual in the head and neck and orbit and is usually due to incomplete surgical excision. However, malignant transformation (MT) in orbital SFT is extremely unusual. We present a case of orbital SFT in adult male who developed recurrence with MT eight years after initial surgical excision. He underwent left orbital exenteration. The recurrent tumor revealed features of malignancy with areas exhibiting morphology typical of SFT. The immunochemistry confirmed the diagnosis of SFT with MT. The patient was given adjuvant radiation and was disease free for the last 18 months. Identification of malignancy in orbital SFT is important for the patient to receive appropriate postoperative treatment, as seen in the present case.

A review of solitary fibrous tumours of the orbit and ocular adnexa

Solitary fibrous tumour (SFT) is an uncommon spindle cell tumour of mesenchymal origin characterised by NAB2-STAT6 gene fusion. Although it was first described in the pleura, it can occur in connective tissue in any part of the body, but rarely presents in the orbit and ocular adnexa. SFT, which is part of the same disease spectrum as other fibroblastic tumours such as giant cell angiofibroma, haemangiopericytoma and fibrous histiocytoma, usually presents as a painless, slow-growing mass in any age group and generally follows a benign course, with a good prognosis after complete excision. However, malignant forms rarely occur. Even for benign tumours a more aggressive clinical behaviour is possible, with relentless infiltrative local growth, frequent recurrence following surgery, and malignant transformation with the potential for metastatic spread. Careful long-term follow-up is essential. The published literature on SFTs of the orbit and ocular adnexa is reviewed, and the aetiology, clinical presentation, epidemiology, radiological features, histopathology, immunohistochemistry, risk stratification, clinical management, and prognosis are discussed, reflecting on our own experience.

Novel Therapeutic Options for Solitary Fibrous Tumor: Antiangiogenic Therapy and Beyond

SFT is an ultrarare mesenchymal ubiquitous tumor, with an incidence rate <1 case/million people/year. The fifth WHO classification published in April 2020 subdivided SFT into three categories: benign (locally aggressive), NOS (rarely metastasizing), and malignant. Recurrence can occur in up to 10-40% of localized SFTs, and several risk stratification models have been proposed to predict the individual risk of metastatic relapse. The Demicco model is the most widely used and is based on age at presentation, tumor size, and mitotic count. Total en bloc resection is the standard treatment of patients with a localized SFT; in case of advanced disease, the clinical efficacy of conventional chemotherapy remains poor. In this review, we discuss new insights into the biology and the treatment of patients with SFT. NAB2-STAT6 oncogenic fusion, which is the pathognomonic hallmark of SFT, is supposedly involved in the overexpression of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF). These specific biological features encouraged the successful assessment of antiangiogenic drugs. Overall, antiangiogenic therapies showed a significant activity toward SFT in the advanced/metastatic setting. Nevertheless, these promising results warrant additional investigation to be validated, including randomized phase III trials and biological translational analysis, to understand and predict mechanisms of efficacy and resistance. While the therapeutic potential of immunotherapy remains elusive, the use of antiangiogenics as first-line treatment should be considered.

Fate and Management of Incompletely Excised Solitary Fibrous Tumor of the Orbit: A Case Series and Literature Review

PURPOSE

There is an imperfect correlation between the histology and behavior of solitary fibrous tumor (SFT). In addition, recurrence is common, and dedifferentiation may occur over time. Preferred primary treatment is intact excision, but friable pseudocapsules and tenacious attachments can thwart this goal in the crowded, visually sensitive orbit. This study addresses the fate and appropriate management of incompletely excised orbital SFT.

METHODS

Among a single surgeon's 7-case experience with orbital SFT, 3 cases involved incomplete primary excision, either before (2 cases) or after (1 case) referral. We reviewed the clinicopathologic data in these 3 cases, with follow-up intervals of 18, 21, and 52 years after initial presentation. We reviewed the English-language literature on SFT, with special attention to evolving nomenclature, orbital involvement, recurrence, malignant transformation, and management options.

RESULTS

Benign versus malignant designations of SFT vary with histological and behavioral criteria. Approximately 150 orbital cases have been reported. Published rates of primary malignancy and recurrence across all histologic categories are 6% to 12% and 30% to 37%, respectively. We identified 43 well-documented recurrences (range, 6 months-33 years; median, 3 years) and 10 cases of histological dedifferentiation (range, 14 months-33 years). Because of SFT's rarity and needed follow-up intervals, the value of adjuvant therapy is not yet proven. In follow up of 18, 21, and 52 years after initial presentation, our 3 cases with incomplete excision showed either no recurrence (Case 1) or no morphological dedifferentiation (Cases 2, 3).

CONCLUSION

A treatment algorithm is predicated on the completeness of surgical excision and histological features. However, we recommend case-by-case multidisciplinary decisions in a tumor-board setting.

Factors for postoperative recurrence of orbital solitary fibrous tumor: an analysis of long-term clinical follow-up results from a Chinese tertiary hospital

BACKGROUND

This study analyzed the clinical features, imaging manifestations, histopathology, immunohistochemistry, and surgical approaches of the orbital solitary fibrous tumor (OSFT), as well as the factors for postoperative recurrence of such disease.

METHODS

The clinical data of 16 patients with OSFT treated in our center from 2003 to 2020 were analyzed retrospectively, and the clinical symptoms, treatment methods, and follow-up results were recorded.

RESULTS

Of the 16 patients, 8 were females (50.0 %) and 8 were males (50.0 %); the average age of treatment was 37 ± 7 years and the median follow-up time was 74 (8, 228) months. Sixteen patients with OSFT underwent a total of 29 operations, of which 12 were transorbital approach operations and 17 were transfronto-orbital approach operations. Ten patients (10/16, 62.5 %) had recurrence. The recurrence rate of transorbital approach operations was 83.3 % (10/12), and the recurrence rate of transfronto-orbital approach operations was 17.6 % (3/17). No patients had treatment-related complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The main pathological feature of OSFT is a benign tumor. OSFT has a tendency to grow toward the cranio-orbital junction. The postoperative recurrence rate of OSFT is relatively high, so complete tumor resection is very important for prognosis. Inappropriate surgical approaches can lead to incomplete removal of the tumor and cause recurrence. Choosing the correct operation approach according to the position of the OSFT in the orbit and complete removal of the dura mater and bone affected by the tumor is crucial for the prognosis. Nevertheless, regular long-term follow-up after complete resection is necessary.

Endoscopic resection of solitary fibrous tumor of the ethmoid: Case report review of the literature

INTRODUCTION

Solitary fibrous tumour (SFT), as are benign neoplasms of fibroblastic cells. Nasosinusal localisation is exremely rare, difficult to diagnose and to manage.

CASE REPORT

We report a rare case of Solitary fibrous tumour in the nasal cavity in a 47-year-old- woman, with complete surgical resection.

DISCUSSION

SFTs are of mesenchymal origin, mainly from serous membranes. The head and neck region is affected with a percentage ranging from 5 to 27%. On the other hand, LTS unusually affects the nasal tract (NTS). Because of this rarity and its variable morphological appearance, it is difficult to distinguish TNS from other mesenchymal lesions.

CONCLUSION

Although there are no standard clinical guidelines, the preferred treatment for FLS is radical surgical resection.

A Clinicopathologic Study of Seven Cases of Orbital Solitary Fibrous Tumours

Objective

To describe the patient demographics, clinical findings, investigations, surgical outcomes, and histopathological findings of seven cases of orbital solitary fibrous tumours.

Method

This was a retrospective review of seven cases of orbital solitary fibrous tumour, which were followed up in Hospital Serdang, a national oculoplastic centre, from years 2008-2017.

Results

This study included seven patients with ages between 21 and 35 years old; two were males and five were females. All seven patients presented with painless chronic unilateral proptosis. Radiological imaging of the orbit showed a localized contrast enhancing intraorbital mass. All patients underwent orbitotomy and excisional biopsy. Intraoperative findings showed a well-encapsulated and vascularized mass. Histological findings of spindle-shaped cells were noted. All cases had positive staining for cluster of differentiation (CD) 34, five were positive for CD 99, four were positive for B-cell lymphoma (BCL-2), and five patients had positive staining for S-100. Three of the patients did not have clear margins during the primary operation and subsequently had a recurrence within two years.

Conclusion

A solitary fibrous tumour is a rare mesenchymal tumour with a pleural origin. The orbit is the most common extrapleural site of the tumour and they are usually benign. Immunohistochemistry is important to differentiate it from other, more aggressive forms of orbital tumours. Regular follow-up is important to monitor for recurrence.

The Role of Adjuvant Radiation in the Management of Solitary Fibrous Tumors of the Central Nervous System: A National Cancer Database Analysis of 155 Patients

Solitary fibrous tumors (SFT) are a rare neoplasm of mesenchymal origin. There is limited evidence on the epidemiology, treatment, and outcomes of SFT in the central nervous system (CNS). The National Cancer Database (NCDB) was queried for patients diagnosed with an SFT in the CNS as their only tumor diagnosis between 2003 and 2011. The final cohort included 155 patients who received surgery and had adequate information for analysis. Descriptive statistics, logistic regression, and Kaplan-Meier survival analyses were performed. Significance was calculated using a t-test, Fisher’s exact test, chi-square, log-rank test, or Cox model. Twenty-three patients (15%) underwent both surgery and adjuvant radiation while 132 (85%) underwent surgery alone. The treatment groups had comparable demographics and tumor size; median age 53 (range 25-80) and 11 females (48%) in the surgery and adjuvant radiation group, compared to 55 (20-89) and 71 (54%) in the surgery alone group, respectively. Radiotherapy methods included conventional and stereotactic dose and fractionations schemes. Information on margin status and re-resection rates was not available. No variables were significantly associated with receipt of adjuvant radiation. In single (p = 0.78) and multivariable (p = 0.86) survival analyses, the addition of adjuvant radiation did not significantly affect overall survival. Five-year overall survival was 88% with surgery alone versus 93% with adjuvant radiation. SFTs are rare neoplasms, especially in the CNS. Our study did not demonstrate an overall survival benefit for adjuvant radiation. The role of adjuvant radiation is still unclear and warrants further investigation.

Orbital solitary fibrous tumor: a clinicopathologic study from a Chinese tertiary hospital with a literature review

Purpose

To report the clinical features, imaging manifestations, histopathology, and immunohistochemical features of several cases of orbital solitary fibrous tumors (SFTs) in a Chinese tertiary hospital, and to undertake a literature review of this rare disease.

Methods

A non-comparative retrospective review of clinical presentations, imaging manifestations, histopathology, and immunohistochemical features as well as the management and disease outcomes of patients with orbital SFT was conducted along with a review of orbital SFT cases in the literature.

Results

This study includes two male and two female patients, with an average age of 53 years. Common presentations among these patients included a palpable subcutaneous mass, swelling of the eyelid, proptosis, diplopia, and vision disturbance. Three patients (cases 2–4) underwent imaging scans. All patients had complete surgical excisions and the tissue was subjected to pathological analysis. One patient (Case 4) experienced a recurrence with malignant transformation and received a re-excision surgery and postoperative radiotherapy. All patients remain alive and well after a minimum follow-up of 12 months (range 12–34 months).

Conclusion

Despite its rare occurrence, we suggest that the possibility of orbital SFTs needs to be considered when a painless, slowly growing orbital mass is identified. Typical characteristic magnetic resonance imaging features of orbital SFTs are iso- or hypointense signals on T1 and T2-weighted images, with marked enhancement. A positive cluster of differentiation 34 (CD34) staining is an important diagnostic clue favoring SFT. Some orbital SFTs are infiltrating, aggressive, or recur with malignant transformation. Therefore, regular long-term follow-up after complete excision is mandatory.

Ocular adnexal (orbital) solitary fibrous tumor: nuclear STAT6 expression and literature review

PURPOSE

To report the clinico-pathological features of solitary fibrous tumor occurring in the ocular adnexa (OA) in a single center. To assess the presence of NAB2-STAT6 genes fusion in OA solitary fibrous tumor detected by nuclear overexpression of STAT6.

METHODS

Retrospective study including orbital and OA solitary fibrous tumors treated between 2006 and 2014 in our center. The clinical, radiological, and histopathological findings were evaluated. STAT6 expression was assessed by immunohistochemistry.

RESULTS

Five patients were identified and presented with a chronic OA mass. The tumors were radiologically well delimited, highly vascularized and without bone erosion. All the patients underwent complete surgical excision. Pathological examination confirmed solitary fibrous tumor in all cases. All tumors demonstrated a nuclear expression of STAT6. There were no recurrences, with a mean follow-up of 5 years after surgery. Our review demonstrated that proptosis was the most common presentation occurring in 60 % of the cases. In the ocular adnexa, adverse histological criteria were found in 19.7 % of the tumors, and recurrences were observed in 48 % of these cases. Thirty-six percent of patients presented at least one local recurrence, and metastastic spread was found in 2.4 % of the cases. Tumor-related death was described in two cases.

CONCLUSION

Ocular adnexal SFT are rare and usually present as a chronic orbital mass with proptosis. In the OA, solitary fibrous tumor demonstrates STAT6 nuclear expression, as documented in other locations. Recurrences are unusual and metastasis exceptional. Initial surgical resection should be complete in order to avoid recurrence.

Four cases of solitary fibrous tumour of the eye and orbit: one with sarcomatous transformation after radiotherapy and one in a 5-year-old child's eyelid

BACKGROUND

Solitary fibrous tumour (SFT) is quite a rare neoplasm involving the eye and the orbit. It is described as showing benign behaviour in adults, but malignant cases are exceptionally reported in this location. This report describes four new cases of SFT/giant cell angiofibroma (GCA) of the eyelid and orbit, one in a 5-year-old child, and one with sarcomatous dedifferentiated transformation occurring 9 years after radiotherapy.

METHODS

Four cases of ocular SFT/GCA were retrieved from the database of the Pathological Anatomy Unit, University of Padova; immunohistochemistry and RT-PCR were used to identify COL1A1-PDBGF fusion gene transcripts in all cases.

RESULTS

In case 1, late relapse 9 years later was characterised by abrupt transition into a high-grade component, associated with a non-distinctive high-grade sarcomatous area. The latter component was CD34, CD99 and Bcl2 negative and smooth muscle actin positive. Molecular characterisation showed the absence of COL1A1-PDGFB fusion transcripts in cases 1, 3 and 4, excluded diagnosis of giant cell fibroblastoma in all cases. Analysis could not be performed in case 2.

CONCLUSIONS

An eyelid SFT/GCA in a 5-year-old child is the youngest case reported in the literature, indicating that the tumour is not exclusive to adults. The case with sarcomatous transformation, with dedifferentiated features occurring 9 years after radiotherapy, raises some questions about the choice of treatment for ocular SFT, in which excision is sometimes difficult without devastating surgery.