Iron responsive element RNA flexibility described by NMR and isotropic reorientational eigenmode dynamics

Conservation in the Iron Responsive Element Family

Iron responsive elements (IREs) are mRNA stem-loop targets for translational control by the two iron regulatory proteins IRP1 and IRP2. They are found in the untranslated regions (UTRs) of genes that code for proteins involved in iron metabolism. There are ten “classic” IRE types that define the conserved secondary and tertiary structure elements necessary for proper IRP binding, and there are 83 published “IRE-like” sequences, most of which depart from the established IRE model. Here are structurally-guided discussions regarding the essential features of an IRE and what is important for IRE family membership.

RNA Dynamics by NMR Spectroscopy

An ever-increasing number of functional RNAs require a mechanistic understanding. RNA function relies on changes in its structure, so-called dynamics. To reveal dynamic processes and higher energy structures, new NMR methods have been developed to elucidate these dynamics in RNA with atomic resolution. In this Review, we provide an introduction to dynamics novices and an overview of methods that access most dynamic timescales, from picoseconds to hours. Examples are provided as well as insight into theory, data acquisition and analysis for these different methods. Using this broad spectrum of methodology, unprecedented detail and invisible structures have been obtained and are reviewed here. RNA, though often more complicated and therefore neglected, also provides a great system to study structural changes, as these RNA structural changes are more easily defined-Lego like-than in proteins, hence the numerous revelations of RNA excited states.

Elucidating the Relation between Internal Motions and Dihedral Angles in an RNA Hairpin Using Molecular Dynamics

Molecular dynamics simulations were performed to characterize the internal motions of the ribonucleic acid apical stem loop of human hepatitis B virus. The NMR relaxation rates calculated directly from the trajectory are in good agreement with the experiment. Calculated order parameters follow the experimental pattern. Order parameters lower than 0.8 are observed for nucleotides that are weakly hydrogen bonded to their base pair partner, unpaired, or part of the loop. These residues show slow decay of the internal correlation functions of their base and sugar C-H vectors. Concerted motions around backbone dihedral angles influence the amplitude of motion of the sugar and base C-H vectors. The order parameters for base C-H vectors are also affected by the fluctuation of the glycosidic dihedral angle.

What NMR Relaxation Can Tell Us about the Internal Motion of an RNA Hairpin: A Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study

Classical molecular dynamics simulations of a 14-mer UUCG RNA hairpin are performed to study its conformational dynamics and corresponding NMR relaxation parameters. The direct calculation of the relaxation rates from the trajectory yields good agreement with experiment, indicating the validity of the theoretical model. Various ways to provide a link between theory and experiment are considered, including the "model-free approach" of Lipari and Szabo and Gaussian axial fluctuation model of Brüschweilwer. It is studied if the underlying assumptions of these approaches are satisfied in the case of a flexible RNA hairpin. Being consistent with the analysis of the NMR experiments, Lipari-Szabo fits of the first 100 or 1000 ps of the internal correlation functions lead to a nice agreement between calculated and experimental order parameters and internal correlation times. Finally, the relation between NMR order parameters and the underlying internal motion of the RNA hairpin is discussed in detail. A principal component analysis reveals that the principal motions of the molecule account only partially for the measured NMR order parameters, because the latter are insensitive to internal dynamics occurring on a nanosecond time scale due to molecular tumbling.

NMR studies of nucleic acid dynamics

Nucleic acid structures have to satisfy two diametrically opposite requirements; on one hand they have to adopt well-defined 3D structures that can be specifically recognized by proteins; on the other hand, their structures must be sufficiently flexible to undergo very large conformational changes that are required during key biochemical processes, including replication, transcription, and translation. How do nucleic acids introduce flexibility into their 3D structure without losing biological specificity? Here, I describe the development and application of NMR spectroscopic techniques in my laboratory for characterizing the dynamic properties of nucleic acids that tightly integrate a broad set of NMR measurements, including residual dipolar couplings, spin relaxation, and relaxation dispersion with sample engineering and computational approaches. This approach allowed us to obtain fundamental new insights into directional flexibility in nucleic acids that enable their structures to change in a very specific functional manner.

Synergistic applications of MD and NMR for the study of biological systems

Modern biological sciences are becoming more and more multidisciplinary. At the same time, theoretical and computational approaches gain in reliability and their field of application widens. In this short paper, we discuss recent advances in the areas of solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations that were made possible by the combination of both methods, that is, through their synergistic use. We present the main NMR observables and parameters that can be computed from simulations, and how they are used in a variety of complementary applications, including dynamics studies, model-free analysis, force field validation, and structural studies.

Characterizing RNA dynamics at atomic resolution using solution-state NMR spectroscopy

Many recently discovered noncoding RNAs do not fold into a single native conformation but sample many different conformations along their free-energy landscape to carry out their biological function. Here we review solution-state NMR techniques that measure the structural, kinetic and thermodynamic characteristics of RNA motions spanning picosecond to second timescales at atomic resolution, allowing unprecedented insights into the RNA dynamic structure landscape. From these studies a basic description of the RNA dynamic structure landscape is emerging, bringing new insights into how RNA structures change to carry out their function as well as applications in RNA-targeted drug discovery and RNA bioengineering.

MD simulations of the dsRBP DGCR8 reveal correlated motions that may aid pri-miRNA binding

Over the past decade, microRNAs (miRNAs) have been shown to affect gene regulation by basepairing with messenger RNA, and their misregulation has been directly linked with cancer. DGCR8, a protein that contains two dsRNA-binding domains (dsRBDs) in tandem, is vital for nuclear maturation of primary miRNAs (pri-miRNAs) in connection with the RNase III enzyme Drosha. The crystal structure of the DGCR8 Core (493-720) shows a unique, well-ordered structure of the linker region between the two dsRBDs that differs from the flexible linker connecting the two dsRBDs in the antiviral response protein, PKR. To better understand the interfacial interactions between the two dsRBDs, we ran extensive MD simulations of isolated dsRBDs (505-583 and 614-691) and the Core. The simulations reveal correlated reorientations of the two domains relative to one another, with the well-ordered linker and C-terminus serving as a pivot. The results demonstrate that motions at the domain interface dynamically impact the conformation of the RNA-binding surface and may provide an adaptive separation distance that is necessary to allow interactions with a variety of different pri-miRNAs with heterogeneous structures. These results thus provide an entry point for further in vitro studies of the potentially unique RNA-binding mode of DGCR8.

Referencing strategy for the direct comparison of nuclear magnetic resonance and molecular dynamics motional parameters in RNA

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are both techniques that can be used to characterize the structural dynamics of biomolecules and their underlying time scales. Comparison of relaxation parameters obtained through each methodology allows for cross validation of techniques and for complementarity in the analysis of dynamics. Here we present a combined NMR/MD study of the dynamics of HIV-1 transactivation response (TAR) RNA. We compute relaxation constants (R(1), R(2), and NOE) and model-free parameters (S(2) and tau) from a 65 ns molecular dynamics (MD) trajectory and compare them with the respective parameters measured in a domain-elongation NMR experiment. Using the elongated domain as the frame of reference for all computed parameters allows for a direct comparison between experiment and simulation. We see good agreement for many parameters and gain further insight into the nature of the local and global dynamics of TAR, which are found to be quite complex, spanning multiple time scales. For the few cases where agreement is poor, comparison of the dynamical parameters provides insight into the limits of each technique. We suggest a frequency-matching procedure that yields an upper bound for the time scale of dynamics to which the NMR relaxation experiment is sensitive.

The unstable part of the apical stem of duck hepatitis B virus epsilon shows enhanced base pair opening but not pico- to nanosecond dynamics and is essential for reverse transcriptase binding

Hepatitis B virus (HBV) replication starts with binding of reverse transcriptase (RT) to the apical stem-loop region of epsilon, a conserved element of the RNA pregenome. For duck HBV, an in vitro replication system has provided molecular details of this interaction. Further insights can be obtained from the structure and dynamics of the duck and human apical stem-loops. Previously, we reported these for the human apical stem-loop. Here, we present the same for the duck counterpart. Unlike its human counterpart, the duck apical stem is unstable in its middle/upper part and contains noncanonical base pairs. This dynamics study is the first of an unstable RNA-DNA stem. Similar to the human stem, the duck apical stem comprises two helical segments with a bend angle of ca. 10 degrees , separated by a nonpaired mobile U residue. It is capped by a well-structured conserved UGUU loop with two residues mobile on the pico- to nanosecond time scale, one of which is involved in RT binding. Remarkably, the unstable middle/upper part of the stem does not show enhanced pico- to nanosecond time scale dynamics. Instead, adenine dispersion relaxation studies indicate enhanced millisecond time scale dynamics involving base pair opening. It can then be concluded that base pair opening is essential for epsilon-RT binding, because stabilization of the stem abolishes binding. We hypothesize that binding occurs by conformational capture of bases in the base pair open state. The unstable secondary structure of the apical stem-loop makes duck epsilon-RT binding unusual in light of recent classifications of RNA target interactions that assume stable secondary structures.

RNA phosphodiester backbone dynamics of a perdeuterated cUUCGg tetraloop RNA from phosphorus-31 NMR relaxation analysis

We have analyzed the relaxation properties of all (31)P nuclei in an RNA cUUCGg tetraloop model hairpin at proton magnetic field strengths of 300, 600 and 900 MHz in solution. Significant H, P dipolar contributions to R (1) and R (2) relaxation are observed in a protonated RNA sample at 600 MHz. These contributions can be suppressed using a perdeuterated RNA sample. In order to interpret the (31)P relaxation data (R (1), R (2)), we measured the (31)P chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) by solid-state NMR spectroscopy under various salt and hydration conditions. A value of 178.5 ppm for the (31)P CSA in the static state (S (2) = 1) could be determined. In order to obtain information about fast time scale dynamics we performed a modelfree analysis on the basis of our relaxation data. The results show that subnanosecond dynamics detected around the phosphodiester backbone are more pronounced than the dynamics detected for the ribofuranosyl and nucleobase moieties of the individual nucleotides (Duchardt and Schwalbe, J Biomol NMR 32:295-308, 2005; Ferner et al., Nucleic Acids Res 36:1928-1940, 2008). Furthermore, the dynamics of the individual phosphate groups seem to be correlated to the 5' neighbouring nucleobases.

Preparation, resonance assignment, and preliminary dynamics characterization of residue specific 13C/15N-labeled elongated DNA for the study of sequence-directed dynamics by NMR

DNA is a highly flexible molecule that undergoes functionally important structural transitions in response to external cellular stimuli. Atomic level spin relaxation NMR studies of DNA dynamics have been limited to short duplexes in which sensitivity to biologically relevant fluctuations occurring at nanosecond timescales is often inadequate. Here, we introduce a method for preparing residue-specific (13)C/(15)N-labeled elongated DNA along with a strategy for establishing resonance assignments and apply the approach to probe fast inter-helical bending motions induced by an adenine tract. Preliminary results suggest the presence of elevated A-tract independent end-fraying internal motions occurring at nanosecond timescales, which evade detection in short DNA constructs and that penetrate deep (7 bp) within the DNA helix and gradually fade away towards the helix interior.

Extensive backbone dynamics in the GCAA RNA tetraloop analyzed using 13C NMR spin relaxation and specific isotope labeling

Conformational dynamics play a key role in the properties and functions of proteins and nucleic acids. Heteronuclear NMR spin relaxation is a uniquely powerful site-specific probe of dynamics in proteins and has found increasing applications to nucleotide base side chains and anomeric sites in RNA. Applications to the nucleic acid ribose backbone, however, have been hampered by strong magnetic coupling among ring carbons in uniformly 13C-labeled samples. In this work, we apply a recently developed, metabolically directed isotope labeling scheme that places 13C with high efficiency and specificity at the nucleotide ribose C2' and C4' sites. We take advantage of this scheme to explore backbone dynamics in the well-studied GCAA RNA tetraloop. Using a combination of CPMG (Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill) and R(1rho) relaxation dispersion spectroscopy to explore exchange processes on the microsecond to millisecond time scale, we find an extensive pattern of dynamic transitions connecting a set of relatively well-defined conformations. In many cases, the observed transitions appear to be linked to C3'-endo/C2'-endo sugar pucker transitions of the corresponding nucleotides, and may also be correlated across multiple nucleotides within the tetraloop. These results demonstrate the power of NMR spin relaxation based on alternate-site isotope labeling to open a new window into the dynamic properties of ribose backbone groups in RNA.

Constructing atomic-resolution RNA structural ensembles using MD and motionally decoupled NMR RDCs

A broad structural landscape often needs to be characterized in order to fully understand how regulatory RNAs perform their biological functions at the atomic level. We present a protocol for visualizing thermally accessible RNA conformations at atomic-resolution and with timescales extending up to milliseconds. The protocol combines molecular dynamics (MD) simulations with experimental residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) measured in partially aligned (13)C/(15)N isotopically enriched elongated RNA samples. The structural ensembles generated in this manner provide insights into RNA dynamics and its role in functionally important transitions.

Constructing RNA dynamical ensembles by combining MD and motionally decoupled NMR RDCs: new insights into RNA dynamics and adaptive ligand recognition

We describe a strategy for constructing atomic resolution dynamical ensembles of RNA molecules, spanning up to millisecond timescales, that combines molecular dynamics (MD) simulations with NMR residual dipolar couplings (RDC) measured in elongated RNA. The ensembles are generated via a Monte Carlo procedure by selecting snap-shot from an MD trajectory that reproduce experimentally measured RDCs. Using this approach, we construct ensembles for two variants of the transactivation response element (TAR) containing three (HIV-1) and two (HIV-2) nucleotide bulges. The HIV-1 TAR ensemble reveals significant mobility in bulge residues C24 and U25 and to a lesser extent U23 and neighboring helical residue A22 that give rise to large amplitude spatially correlated twisting and bending helical motions. Omission of bulge residue C24 in HIV-2 TAR leads to a significant reduction in both the local mobility in and around the bulge and amplitude of inter-helical bending motions. In contrast, twisting motions of the helices remain comparable in amplitude to HIV-1 TAR and spatial correlations between them increase significantly. Comparison of the HIV-1 TAR dynamical ensemble and ligand bound TAR conformations reveals that several features of the binding pocket and global conformation are dynamically preformed, providing support for adaptive recognition via a ‘conformational selection’ type mechanism.

RNA in motion

Although RNA duplex regions are highly structured and inflexible, other elements of an RNA molecule are capable of dynamic motions. These flexible regions are the sites of interactions with small molecules, proteins, and other RNAs, yet there are few descriptions of these regions that include the timescale and amplitude of their motions. No one technique is sufficient to accurately describe these motions, but the combination of in vitro methods, particularly NMR relaxation methods, and more robust in silico methods, is beginning to yield the type of data that can be used to understand RNA function. Very few RNAs have been described by both techniques, and here one such RNA and one RNA:protein complex are reviewed.

Assessing the performance of implicit solvation models at a nucleic acid surface

Implicit solvation models are popular alternatives to explicit solvent methods due to their ability to "pre-average" solvent behavior and thus reduce the need for computationally-expensive sampling. Previously, we have demonstrated that Poisson-Boltzmann models for polar solvation and integral-based models for nonpolar solvation can reproduce explicit solvation forces in a low-charge density protein system. In the present work, we examine the ability of these continuum models to describe solvation forces at the surface of a RNA hairpin. While these models do not completely describe all of the details of solvent behavior at this highly-charged biomolecular interface, they do provide a reasonable description of average solvation forces and therefore show significant promise for developing more robust implicit descriptions of solvent around nucleic acid systems for use in biomolecular simulation and modeling. Additionally, we observe fairly good transferability in the nonpolar model parameters optimized for protein systems, suggesting its robustness for modeling general nonpolar solvation phenomena in biomolecular systems.

NMR and MD studies of the temperature-dependent dynamics of RNA YNMG-tetraloops

In a combined NMR/MD study, the temperature-dependent changes in the conformation of two members of the RNA YNMG-tetraloop motif (cUUCGg and uCACGg) have been investigated at temperatures of 298, 317 and 325 K. The two members have considerable different thermal stability and biological functions. In order to address these differences, the combined NMR/MD study was performed. The large temperature range represents a challenge for both, NMR relaxation analysis (consistent choice of effective bond length and CSA parameter) and all-atom MD simulation with explicit solvent (necessity to rescale the temperature). A convincing agreement of experiment and theory is found. Employing a principle component analysis of the MD trajectories, the conformational distribution of both hairpins at various temperatures is investigated. The ground state conformation and dynamics of the two tetraloops are indeed found to be very similar. Furthermore, both systems are initially destabilized by a loss of the stacking interactions between the first and the third nucleobase in the loop region. While the global fold is still preserved, this initiation of unfolding is already observed at 317 K for the uCACGg hairpin but at a significantly higher temperature for the cUUCGg hairpin.

Extending the NMR spatial resolution limit for RNA by motional couplings

Experimental resolution of distinct dynamical processes in molecules can prove impossible when they are correlated to one another. In nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, couplings between internal and overall motions lead to intractable complexity, depriving insights into functionally important motions. Here we demonstrate that motional couplings can be used to anchor NMR frames of reference onto different parts of an RNA molecule, thus extending the spatial resolution limit for dynamical characterization.

Dynamics of large elongated RNA by NMR carbon relaxation

We present an NMR strategy for characterizing picosecond-to-nanosecond internal motions in uniformly 13C/15N-labeled RNAs that combines measurements of R1, R1rho, and heteronuclear 13C{1H} NOEs for protonated base (C2, C5, C6, and C8) and sugar (C1') carbons with a domain elongation strategy for decoupling internal from overall motions and residual dipolar coupling (RDC) measurements for determining the average RNA global conformation and orientation of the principal axis of the axially symmetric rotational diffusion. TROSY-detected pulse sequences are presented for the accurate measurement of nucleobase carbon R1 and R1rho rates in large RNAs. The relaxation data is analyzed using a model free formalism which takes into account the very high anisotropy of overall rotational diffusion (Dratio approximately 4.7), asymmetry of the nucleobase CSAs and noncollinearity of C-C, C-H dipolar and CSA interactions under the assumption that all interaction tensors for a given carbon experience identical isotropic internal motions. The approach is demonstrated and validated on an elongated HIV-1 TAR RNA (taum approximately 18 ns) both in free form and bound to the ligand argininamide (ARG). Results show that, while ARG binding reduces the amplitude of collective helix motions and local mobility at the binding pocket, it leads to a drastic increase in the local mobility of "spacer" bulge residues linking the two helices which undergo virtually unrestricted internal motions (S2 approximately 0.2) in the ARG bound state. Our results establish the ability to quantitatively study the dynamics of RNAs which are significantly larger and more anisotropic than customarily studied by NMR carbon relaxation.

Parameters of Monovalent Ions in the AMBER-99 Forcefield: Assessment of Inaccuracies and Proposed Improvements

The monovalent ion parameters used by the AMBER-99 forcefield are shown to exhibit physically inaccurate behavior in molecular dynamics simulations of strong 1:1 electrolytes. These errors arise from an ad hoc adaptation of Aqvist's cation parameters. The result is the rapid formation of large, unphysical clusters at concentrations that are well below solubility limits. The observed unphysical behavior poses a serious challenge for simulating ions around highly charged polymers such as nucleic acids. In this communication, we explain the source of this unphysical behavior. To facilitate the continued use of the popular AMBER parameters, we prescribe a simple fix whereby Aqvist's cations and anions are used in conjunction with the AMBER forcefield for nucleic acids. A preliminary test of this strategy suggests that the proposed fix is reasonable and is likely to be generalizable for simulating diffuse and specific ion binding to nucleic acids.

NMR studies of RNA dynamics and structural plasticity using NMR residual dipolar couplings

An increasing number of RNAs are being discovered that perform their functions by undergoing large changes in conformation in response to a variety of cellular signals, including recognition of proteins and small molecular targets, changes in temperature, and RNA synthesis itself. The measurement of NMR residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) in partially aligned systems is providing new insights into the structural plasticity of RNA through combined characterization of large-amplitude collective helix motions and local flexibility in noncanonical regions over a wide window of biologically relevant timescales (<milliseconds). Here, we review RDC methodology for studying RNA structural dynamics and survey what has been learnt thus far from application of these methods. Future methodological challenges are also identified.

iRED analysis of TAR RNA reveals motional coupling, long-range correlations, and a dynamical hinge

The HIV-1 transactivation response RNA element (TAR), which is essential to the lifecycle of the virus, has been suggested, based on NMR and hydrodynamic measurements, to undergo substantial, collective, structural dynamics that are important for its function. To deal with the significant coupling between overall diffusional rotation and internal motion expected to exist in TAR, here we utilize an isotropic reorientational eigenmode dynamics analysis of simulated molecular trajectories to obtain a detailed description of TAR dynamics and an accurately quantified pattern of dynamical correlations. The analysis demonstrates the inseparability of internal and overall motional modes, confirms the existence and reveals the nature of collective domain dynamics, and additionally reveals that the hinge for these motions is centered on residues U23, C24, and C41. Results also indicate the existence of long-range communication between the loop and the core of the RNA, and between the loop and the bulge. Additionally, the isotropic reorientational eigenmode dynamics analysis explains, from a dynamical perspective, several existing biochemical mutational studies and suggests new mutations for future structural dynamics studies.

Impact of static and dynamic A-form heterogeneity on the determination of RNA global structural dynamics using NMR residual dipolar couplings

We examined how static and dynamic deviations from the idealized A-form helix propagate into errors in the principal order tensor parameters determined using residual dipolar couplings (rdcs). A 20-ns molecular dynamics (MD) simulation of the HIV-1 transactivation response element (TAR) RNA together with a survey of spin relaxation studies of RNA dynamics reveals that pico-to-nanosecond local motions in non-terminal Watson-Crick base-pairs will uniformly attenuate base and sugar one bond rdcs by approximately 7%. Gaussian distributions were generated for base and sugar torsion angles through statistical comparison of 40 RNA X-ray structures solved to <3.0 A resolution. For a typical number (>or=11) of one bond C-H base and sugar rdcs, these structural deviations together with rdc uncertainty (1.5 Hz) lead to average errors in the magnitude and orientation of the principal axis of order that are <9% and <4 degrees, respectively. The errors decrease to <5% and <4 degrees for >or=17 rdcs. A protocol that allows for estimation of error in A-form order tensors due to both angular deviations and rdc uncertainty (Aform-RDC) is validated using theoretical simulations and used to analyze rdcs measured previously in TAR in the free state and bound to four distinct ligands. Results confirm earlier findings that the two TAR helices undergo large changes in both their mean relative orientation and dynamics upon binding to different targets.

Carbon-13 chemical shift anisotropy in DNA bases from field dependence of solution NMR relaxation rates

Knowledge of (13)C chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) in nucleotide bases is important for the interpretation of solution-state NMR relaxation data in terms of local dynamic properties of DNA and RNA. Accurate knowledge of the CSA becomes particularly important at high magnetic fields, prerequisite for adequate spectral resolution in larger oligonucleotides. Measurement of (13)C relaxation rates of protonated carbons in the bases of the so-called Dickerson dodecamer, d(CGCGAATTCGCG)(2), at 500 and 800 MHz (1)H frequency, together with the previously characterized structure and diffusion tensor yields CSA values for C5 in C, C6 in C and T, C8 in A and G, and C2 in A that are closest to values previously reported on the basis of solid-state FIREMAT NMR measurements, and mostly larger than values obtained by in vacuo DFT calculations. Owing to the noncollinearity of dipolar and CSA interactions, interpretation of the NMR relaxation rates is particularly sensitive to anisotropy of rotational diffusion, and use of isotropic diffusion models can result in considerable errors.