In Vitro-In Vivo Correlation of Blood-Brain Barrier Permeability of Drugs: A Feasibility Study Towards Development of Prediction Methods for Brain Drug Concentration in Humans

Assessing central nervous system drug delivery

INTRODUCTION

Delivering drugs to the central nervous system (CNS) remains a major challenge due to the blood-brain barrier, restricting the entry of drugs into the brain. This limitation contributes to the ongoing lack of effective treatments for CNS diseases. To improve the process of drug discovery and development, it is crucial to streamline methods that measure clinically relevant parameters, allowing for good selection of drug candidates.

AREA COVERED

In this paper, we discuss the essential prerequisites for successful CNS drug delivery and review relevant methods. We emphasize the need for closer collaboration between in vitro and in vivo scientists to improve the relevance of these methods and increase the success rate of developing effective CNS therapies. While our focus is on small molecule drugs, we also touch on some aspects of larger molecules.

EXPERT OPINION

Significant progress has been made in recent years in method development and their application. However, there is still work to be done before the use of in silico models, in vitro cell systems, and AI can consistently offer meaningful correlations and relationships to clinical data. This gap is partly due to limited patient data, but a lot can be achieved through in vivo research in animal models.

An Improved In Vitro Blood-Brain Barrier Model for the Evaluation of Drug Permeability Using Transwell with Shear Stress

The development of drugs targeting the central nervous system (CNS) is challenging because of the presence of the Blood-Brain barrier (BBB). Developing physiologically relevant in vitro BBB models for evaluating drug permeability and predicting the activity of drug candidates is crucial. The transwell model is one of the most widely used in vitro BBB models. However, this model has limitations in mimicking in vivo conditions, particularly in the absence of shear stress. This study aimed to overcome the limitations of the transwell model using immortalized human endothelial cells (hCMEC/D3) by developing a novel dish design for an orbital shaker, providing shear stress. During optimization, we assessed cell layer integrity using trans-endothelial electrical resistance measurements and the % diffusion of lucifer yellow. The efflux transporter activity and mRNA expression of junctional proteins (claudin-5, occludin, and VE-cadherin) in the newly optimized model were verified. Additionally, the permeability of 14 compounds was evaluated and compared with published in vivo data. The cell-layer integrity was substantially increased using the newly designed annular shaking-dish model. The results demonstrate that our model provided robust conditions for evaluating the permeability of CNS drug candidates, potentially improving the reliability of in vitro BBB models in drug development.

Usefulness of a humanized tricellular static transwell blood-brain barrier model as a microphysiological system for drug development applications. - A case study based on the benchmark evaluations of blood-brain barrier microphysiological system

Microphysiological system (MPS), a new technology for in vitro testing platforms, have been acknowledged as a strong tool for drug development. In the central nervous system (CNS), the blood‒brain barrier (BBB) limits the permeation of circulating substances from the blood vessels to the brain, thereby protecting the CNS from circulating xenobiotic compounds. At the same time, the BBB hinders drug development by introducing challenges at various stages, such as pharmacokinetics/pharmacodynamics (PK/PD), safety assessment, and efficacy assessment. To solve these problems, efforts are being made to develop a BBB MPS, particularly of a humanized type. In this study, we suggested minimal essential benchmark items to establish the BBB-likeness of a BBB MPS; these criteria support end users in determining the appropriate range of applications for a candidate BBB MPS. Furthermore, we examined these benchmark items in a two-dimensional (2D) humanized tricellular static transwell BBB MPS, the most conventional design of BBB MPS with human cell lines. Among the benchmark items, the efflux ratios of P-gp and BCRP showed high reproducibility in two independent facilities, while the directional transports meditated through Glut1 or TfR were not confirmed. We have organized the protocols of the experiments described above as standard operating procedures (SOPs). We here provide the SOPs with the flow chart including entire procedure and how to apply each SOP. Our study is important developmental step of BBB MPS towards the social acceptance, which enable end users to check and compare the performance the BBB MPSs.