The premature demise of public child and adolescent inpatient psychiatric beds : Part II: challenges and implications

Variation in Evidence-Based Practices Among Youth-Serving Residential Treatment Facilities

BACKGROUND

Residential treatment is among the most intensive and expensive settings for children with behavioral health challenges; yet, the extent to which evidence-based practices are used in these settings is unknown.

AIM

The purpose of this study was to describe the extent which family therapy, case management, telehealth, peer support, and family psychoeducation are provided in residential treatment using data from the National Mental Health Services Survey (N-MHSS). Organizational factors-region, ownership, payment, licensing/accreditation, and facility size-were examined in relation to evidence-based practices to understand disparities in care.

METHODS

This was a secondary analysis of publicly available data from the 2018 N-MHSS. A subpopulation was created consisting of residential facilities that served children (N = 576). Descriptive statistics were used to describe the sample, and Cohen's h was calculated to determine patterns of evidence-based practice utilization.

RESULTS

Evidence-based practices from most to least prevalent were family therapy (76%), family psychoeducation (74%), case management (71.1%), telehealth (17.2%), and peer support (8.7%). The provision of evidence-based practices was not evenly distributed. There were primarily small to moderate differences by organizational factors, including region (i.e., Northeast, Midwest), ownership status (i.e., for-profit), payment type (i.e., self-pay, private insurance), licensing/accreditation (Department of Family and Children Services), and facility capacity (>251 clients served per year).

CONCLUSION

Findings demonstrate a need for research-practice partnerships to determine the barriers that prevent effective evidence-based practices from being implemented in the residential treatment setting.

Prolonged Emergency Department Length of Stay for US Pediatric Mental Health Visits (2005-2015)

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Children seeking care in the emergency department (ED) for mental health conditions are at risk for prolonged length of stay (LOS). A more contemporary description of trends and visit characteristics associated with prolonged ED LOS at the national level is lacking in the literature. Our objectives were to (1) compare LOS trends for pediatric mental health versus non-mental health ED visits and (2) explore patient-level characteristics associated with prolonged LOS for mental health ED visits.

METHODS

We conducted an observational analysis of ED visits among children 6 to 17 years of age using the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (2005-2015). We assessed trends in rates of prolonged LOS and the association between prolonged LOS and demographic and clinical characteristics (race and ethnicity, payer type, and presence of a concurrent physical health diagnosis) using descriptive statistics and survey-weighted logistic regression.

RESULTS

From 2005 to 2015, rates of prolonged LOS for pediatric mental health ED visits increased over time from 16.3% to 24.6% (LOS >6 hours) and 5.3% to 12.7% (LOS >12 hours), in contrast to non-mental health visits for which LOS remained stable. For mental health visits, Hispanic ethnicity was associated with an almost threefold odds of LOS >12 hours (odds ratio 2.74; 95% confidence interval 1.69-4.44); there was no difference in LOS by payer type.

CONCLUSIONS

The substantial rise in prolonged LOS for mental health ED visits and disparity for Hispanic children suggest worsening and inequitable access to definitive pediatric mental health care. Policy makers and health systems should work to provide equitable and timely access to pediatric mental health care.

Predictors of Prolonged Length of Stay in Suicidal Children Transferred to Psychiatric Facilities

OBJECTIVES

To determine if sociodemographic factors or underlying mental health conditions serve as predictors for prolonged length of stay (pLOS) in children hospitalized for suicidal ideation (SI) or suicide attempt (SA) requiring transfer to psychiatric facilities. We hypothesized an association between certain patient and hospital characteristics and pLOS.

METHODS

For this retrospective cross-sectional study, we used the National Inpatient Sample. We included children <18 years old hospitalized with a primary or secondary International Classification of Diseases, 10th Edition, Clinical Modification diagnosis of SI or SA who were dispositioned to psychiatric facilities from 2016 to 2017. Exposures were patient sociodemographics, underlying mental health diagnoses, and hospital characteristics. Our outcome was pLOS. Adjusted prevalence ratios with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were generated with log binomial regression.

RESULTS

Of 12 715 hospitalizations meeting inclusion criteria, 5475 had pLOS. After adjusting for sociodemographics and hospital characteristics, predictive factors for pLOS were public insurance use (prevalence ratio: 1.40; CI: 1.12-1.78), urban nonteaching hospital location (prevalence ratio: 4.61; CI: 2.33-9.12), urban teaching hospital location (prevalence ratio: 3.26; CI: 1.84-5.76), and underlying diagnosis of mood disorder (prevalence ratio: 1.98; CI: 1.63-3.42). Hispanic patients had decreased probability of pLOS (prevalence ratio: 0.69; CI: 0.52-0.93). Otherwise, age, zip income, sex, and hospital region were not predictive of pLOS.

CONCLUSIONS

Among children hospitalized for SI or SA requiring transfer to psychiatric facilities, public insurance, urban hospital location, and diagnoses of mood disorder, depression, and bipolar disorder were predictive of pLOS. Further research is needed on how to decrease disparities in length of stay among this vulnerable population.

Expert Arguments for Trends of Psychiatric Bed Numbers: A Systematic Review of Qualitative Data

Introduction: Mental health policies have encouraged removals of psychiatric beds in many countries. It is under debate whether to continue those trends. We conducted a systematic review of expert arguments for trends of psychiatric bed numbers. Methods: We searched seven electronic databases and screened 15,479 papers to identify expert opinions, arguments and recommendations for trends of psychiatric bed numbers, published until December 2020. Data were synthesized using thematic analysis and classified into arguments to maintain or increase numbers and to reduce numbers. Results: One hundred six publications from 25 countries were included. The most common themes arguing for reductions of psychiatric bed numbers were inadequate use of inpatient care, better integration of care and better use of community care. Arguments to maintain or increase bed numbers included high demand of psychiatric beds, high occupancy rates, increasing admission rates, criminalization of mentally ill, lack of community care and inadequately short length of stay. Cost effectiveness and quality of care were used as arguments for increase or decrease. Conclusions: The expert arguments presented here may guide and focus future debate on the required psychiatric bed numbers. The recommendations may help policymakers to define targets for psychiatric bed numbers. Arguments need careful local evaluation, especially when supporting opposite directions of trends in different contexts.

Trends in Visits and Costs for Mental Health Emergencies in a Pediatric Emergency Department, 2010-2016

OBJECTIVE

Analyze trends in visit numbers, length of stay (LOS), and costs of pediatric mental health emergency department (ED) visits over time.

METHODS

We conducted a cross-sectional, time-series analysis from 2010 to 2016 of mental health visits, identified by billing diagnosis codes, among children 5 to 18years old in a tertiary pediatric ED. We used Poisson regression to analyze trends in rates of mental health visits, patient-hours, and visits with LOS ≥ 24hours. We used time-series analysis to trend median costs per visit.

RESULTS

From 2010 to 2016, there were 197,982 ED visits and 13,367 (6.7%) mental health visits. Mental health visits increased by 45% (from 1462 to 2119), compared to a 13% increase in non-mental health visits. The rate of mental health visits increased from 5.6 to 7.1 per 100 ED visits and increased 5.5% annually, compared to -0.4% annually for non-mental health visits (incidence rate ratio [IRR], 1.06; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.05-1.07). Mental health patient-hours increased 186%, compared to an 18% increase in non-mental health patient-hours. The rate of mental health visits with LOS ≥ 24hours increased from 4.3 to 18.8 per 100 mental health visits and increased 22% annually (IRR, 1.22; 95% CI, 1.19-1.26). Median costs per visit increased by $38 per quarter (95% CI, $28-$48).

CONCLUSIONS

Rates of mental health visits, patient-hours, visits with LOS ≥ 24hours, and visit costs are increasing over time. Additional hospital and community resources are needed to address rising ED utilization for mental illness in children.

An evidence synthesis of risk identification, assessment and management for young people using tier 4 inpatient child and adolescent mental health services

Background

Inpatient child and adolescent mental health services are one part of a complex system, and exist to meet the needs of young people with the greatest mental health difficulties.

Objectives

The research question was ‘What is known about the identification, assessment and management of risk (where “risk” is broadly conceived) in young people (aged 11–18 years) with complex mental health needs entering, using and exiting inpatient child and adolescent mental health services in the UK?’

Data sources

The two-phase Evidence for Policy and Practice Information and Co-ordinating Centre approach was used. In phase 1, scoping searches were made using two databases with an end date of March 2013. Phase 2 centred on the search for citations relating to the risks to young people of ‘dislocation’ and ‘contagion’. Searches were made using 17 databases, with time limits from 1995 to September 2013. Websites were searched, a call for evidence circulated and references of included citations reviewed.

Review methods

Priority risk areas for phase 2 were decided in collaboration with stakeholders including through consultations with young people and the mother of a child who had been in hospital. All types of evidence relating to outcomes, views and experiences, costs and cost-effectiveness, policies, and service and practice responses in the areas of ‘dislocation’ and ‘contagion’ for young people (11–18 years) using inpatient mental health services were considered. A staged approach to screening was used. Data were extracted into tables following guidance from the Centre for Reviews and Dissemination or tables developed for the review. Quality was assessed using appraisal checklists from the Effective Public Health Practice Project or the Critical Skills Appraisal Programme or devised by previous reviewers. No papers were excluded on the grounds of quality, and all materials identified were narratively synthesised.

Results

In phase 1, 4539 citations were found and 124 included. Most were concerned with clinical risks. In phase 2, 15,662 citations were found and 40 addressing the less obvious risks of ‘dislocation’ and ‘contagion’ were included, supplemented by 20 policy and guidance documents. These were synthesised using these categories: Dislocation: Normal Life; Dislocation: Identity; Dislocation: Friends; Dislocation: Stigma; Dislocation: Education; Dislocation: Families; and Contagion. No studies included an economic analysis or economic evaluation. The importance to stakeholders of these less obvious risks contrasted with the limited quantity and quality of research capable of informing policy, services and practice in these areas.

Limitations

Included studies were of variable quality. Data derived could not be used to inform an economic modelling of NHS costs or to analyse cost-effectiveness. Other limitations were the search for only English-language materials and the use of umbrella concepts (‘dislocation’ and ‘contagion’).

Conclusions

The less obvious risks are important, but little evidence exists to support their identification, assessment and management. This has implications for services, and a programme of research is recommended to generate new knowledge.

Funding

The National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research programme.

Trends in pediatric visits to the emergency department for psychiatric illnesses

OBJECTIVES

While recent studies have demonstrated an overall increase in psychiatric visits in the emergency department (ED), none have focused on a nationally representative pediatric population. Understanding trends in pediatric psychiatric ED visits is important because of limited outpatient availability of pediatric specialists, as well as long wait times for psychiatric appointments. The study aim was to evaluate the trends in ED psychiatric visits for children between 2001 and 2010 with comparison by sociodemographic characteristics.

METHODS

This was a retrospective, cross-sectional analysis of ED psychiatric visits for children < 18 years of age using the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NHAMCS). Visits were identified by International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision (ICD-9), codes. Outcome measures included frequency of visits for children with psychiatric diagnosis codes and odds and adjusted odds of psychiatric visits controlling for temporal, demographic, and geographic factors.

RESULTS

From 2001 to 2010, an average of 28.3 million pediatric visits to EDs occurred annually. Among those, an approximately 560,000 (2% of ED visits) were psychiatric visits each year. Pediatric psychiatric ED visits increased from an estimated 491,000 in 2001 to 619,000 in 2010 (p = 0.01). Teenagers (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 3.92, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 3.37 to 4.57) and publicly insured patient visits (AOR = 1.47, 95% CI = 1.25 to 1.74) had increased odds of psychiatric ED visits.

CONCLUSIONS

Pediatric ED psychiatric visits are increasing. Teenagers and children with public insurance appear to be at increased risk. Further investigation is needed to determine what the causative factors are.

Changing trends in inpatient care for psychiatrically hospitalized youth: 1991-2008

Research has focused on changes in the psychiatric treatment of youth in outpatient settings, but less is known about trends in inpatient care. This study documents changes in the lengths of stay (LOS), clinical profiles of youth, and medication use within an inpatient setting in Massachusetts between 1991 and 2008. A chart review of 233 medical records of psychiatrically hospitalized youth was conducted at three points in time (1991, 1998, and 2008). Sample includes youth between ages 4 and 18. Clinical data, including LOS, diagnoses and other clinical variables, and number and type of medications prescribed were compared across sample years. Findings indicate a significant decrease in the LOS coupled with a concurrent increase in psychotropic medication use between each successive sample year. The prescription of anti-psychotic medications, in particular, increased significantly. On clinical indices, findings show that there was an increase in the diagnosis of bipolar spectrum disorders and a concurrent decrease in unipolar diagnoses in the 2008 sample. Attention-deficit and developmental disorders showed little change. Trauma-related disorders were significantly less frequently diagnosed in 2008. Children hospitalized in 1998 and 2008 had more prior hospitalizations and presented with greater acuity than those in the 1991 sample. Results highlight important changes that have occurred in child/adolescent inpatient settings over the past two decades. Data suggest that these changes have not resulted in decreased rates of inpatient hospitalization for youth with more severe psychiatric disorders.

Using systems of care to reduce incarceration of youth with serious mental illness

Youth with serious mental illness come into contact with juvenile justice more than 3 times as often as other youth, obliging communities to expend substantial resources on adjudicating and incarcerating many who, with proper treatment, could remain in the community for a fraction of the cost. Incarceration is relatively ineffective at remediating behaviors associated with untreated serious mental illness and may worsen some youths' symptoms and long-term prognoses. Systems of care represent a useful model for creating systems change to reduce incarceration of these youth. This paper identifies the systemic factors that contribute to the inappropriate incarceration of youth with serious mental illness, including those who have committed non-violent offenses or were detained due to lack of available treatment. It describes the progress of on-going efforts to address this problem including wraparound and diversion programs and others utilizing elements of systems of care. The utility of systems of care principles for increasing access to community-based mental health care for youth with serious mental illness is illustrated and a number of recommendations for developing collaborations with juvenile justice to further reduce the inappropriate incarceration of these youth are offered.

Staff experience, knowledge and attitudes regarding the management of adolescent patients in adult mental health units

OBJECTIVE

Inpatient psychiatric care of adolescents should, where possible, be provided in specialized units. However, admission of adolescent patients to adult mental health units does occur. There is a paucity of data about this practice. This study collates information about the experience, attitudes and knowledge of clinical staff regarding the care of adolescent patients in adult psychiatry units within Northern Sydney Central Coast Area Health Service (NSCCHS).

METHOD

A survey was emailed to all clinical staff with employer accessible email addresses in NSCCHS.

RESULTS

The response rate was 29% (n = 108). The majority of respondents believed their wards were "not at all" (30.7%) or "only a little" (57.4%) equipped to care for adolescent patients. The majority felt "moderately" (39.6%) or "very" (16.8%) confident to care for these patients; however, a significant proportion (43.2%) lacked confidence. There was no significant difference across the responses of psychiatrists, psychiatry registrars and nursing staff to these questions. The majority felt the objectives of these admissions were met "only a little" (47.4%) or "not at all" (16.5%). Many concerns regarding the admission of adolescents to adult wards were reported.

CONCLUSIONS

Generally, staff were not in favour of admitting adolescent patients to adult mental health units apart from in exceptional circumstances. Staff harboured concerns about several aspects of care for adolescents in adult wards.

Adolescent psychiatric patients and their parents: comparison with a non-clinical cohort

The study compared the psychiatric symptoms, coping skills, and family functioning of adolescent psychiatric inpatients and their primary caretakers with a non-clinical comparison group of adolescents and their primary caretakers. Participants completed measures of psychiatric symptoms, life experiences, problem-solving ability, family functioning, and anger. MANOVAs compared the adolescents and caretakers across the normative and clinical samples. A discriminate function analysis predicted membership in the clinical and non-clinical sample. Primary caretakers for the hospitalized adolescents reported significant differences in self-reported family functioning, life stress, psychiatric symptoms, and ratings of adolescent problem behaviors. These variables successfully classified 78% of the sample as inpatient or non-clinical comparison subjects. Adolescents hospitalized for psychiatric reasons did not differ from their non-clinical counterparts on self-report measures of psychiatric symptoms, distress, problem behaviors, problem solving, or trait anger. Independent of psychiatric status, adolescent self-reported family functioning and adolescent problem solving skills predicted the number of problems adolescents endorsed, the number of symptoms adolescents endorsed, and adolescent levels of trait anger. Although a brief psychiatric hospitalization seemed effective in treating adolescent mental health patients, the primary caretakers remained more symptomatic than a non-clinical cohort. Continuing to focus on the development of health care policies that are sensitive to needs of the primary caretakers will likely enhance long-term outcomes.