Symbiotic relationship analysis of predominant bacteria in a lab-scale anammox UASB bioreactor

Deciphering the adaptation mechanism of anammox consortia under sulfamethoxazole stress: A model coupling resistance accumulation and interspecies-cooperation

Sulfamethoxazole (SMX) is frequently detected in wastewater where anammox applications are promising. While it has been demonstrated that anammox consortia can adapt to SMX stress, the underlying community adaptation strategy has not yet been fully addressed. Therefore, in this study, we initially ascertained anammox consortia's ability to co-metabolize SMX in batch tests. Then, a 200-day domestication process of anammox consortia under SMX stress was carried out with community variations and transcriptional activities monitored by metagenomic and metatranscriptomic sequencing techniques. Despite the initial drop to 41.88 %, the nitrogen removal efficiency of the anammox consortia rebounded to 84.64 % post-domestication under 5 mg/L SMX. Meanwhile, a 4.85-fold accumulation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) under SMX stress was observed as compared to the control group. Interestingly, the anammox consortia may unlock the SMX-inhibited folate synthesis pathway through a novel interspecies cooperation triangle among Nitrospira (NAA), Desulfobacillus denitrificans (DSS1), and the core anammox population Candidatus Brocadia sinica (AMX1), in which the modified dihydropteroate synthase (encoded by sul1) of NAA reconnected the symbiotic cooperation between AMX1 and DSS1. Overall, this study provides a new model for the adaptation strategies of anammox consortia to SMX stress.

An integrated meta-omics approach reveals the different response mechanisms of two anammox bacteria towards fluoroquinolone antibiotics

The emerging fluoroquinolone antibiotics (FQs) are highly influential in nitrogen removal from livestock wastewater. However, beyond the capability of nitrogen removal, little is known about the molecular mechanisms (e.g., shift of core metabolism and energy allocation) of different anaerobic ammonium-oxidizing bacteria (AnAOB) under continuous FQ stress. This study investigated the effects of ciprofloxacin, ofloxacin and their mixture at concentrations detected in livestock wastewater on two key anammox species in membrane bioreactors. It was found 20 μg/L FQs promoted nitrogen removal efficiency and community stability, and42-51 % of FQs were removed simultaneously. Integrated meta-omics analysis revealed varied gene expression patterns between the two dominant AnAOB, Candidatus Brocadia sapporoensis (B AnAOB) and Candidatus Kuenenia stuttgartiensis (K AnAOB). The nitrogen metabolic processes were bolstered in B AnAOB, while those involved in anammox pathway of K AnAOB were inhibited. This difference was tentatively attributed to the up-regulation of reactive oxygen species scavenger genes (ccp and dxf) and FQ resistance gene (qnrB72) in B AnAOB. Importantly, most enhanced core biosynthesis/metabolism of AnAOB and close cross-feeding with accompanying bacteria were also likely to contribute to their higher levels of biomass yield and metabolism activity under FQ stress. This finding suggests that B AnAOB has the advantage of higher nitrogen metabolism capacity over K AnAOB in livestock wastewater containing FQs, which is helpful for efficient and stable nitrogen removal by the functional anammox species.

Enhancing plant growth in biofertilizer-amended soil through nitrogen-transforming microbial communities

Biofertilizers have immense potential for enhancing agricultural productivity. However, there is still a need for clarification regarding the specific mechanisms through which these biofertilizers improve soil properties and stimulate plant growth. In this research, a bacterial agent was utilized to enhance plant growth and investigate the microbial modulation mechanism of soil nutrient turnover using metagenomic technology. The results demonstrated a significant increase in soil fast-acting nitrogen (by 46.7%) and fast-acting phosphorus (by 88.6%) upon application of the bacterial agent. This finding suggests that stimulated soil microbes contribute to enhanced nutrient transformation, ultimately leading to improved plant growth. Furthermore, the application of the bacterial agent had a notable impact on the accumulation of key genes involved in nitrogen cycling. Notably, it enhanced nitrification genes (amo, hao, and nar), while denitrification genes (nir and nor) showed a slight decrease. This indicates that ammonium oxidation may be the primary pathway for increasing fast-acting nitrogen in soils. Additionally, the bacterial agent influenced the composition and functional structure of the soil microbial community. Moreover, the metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) obtained from the soil microbial communities exhibited complementary metabolic processes, suggesting mutual nutrient exchange. These MAGs contained widely distributed and highly abundant genes encoding plant growth promotion (PGP) traits. These findings emphasize how soil microbial communities can enhance vegetation growth by increasing nutrient availability and regulating plant hormone production. This effect can be further enhanced by introducing inoculated microbial agents. In conclusion, this study provides novel insights into the mechanisms underlying the beneficial effects of biofertilizers on soil properties and plant growth. The significant increase in nutrient availability, modulation of key genes involved in nitrogen cycling, and the presence of MAGs encoding PGP traits highlight the potential of biofertilizers to improve agricultural practices. These findings have important implications for enhancing agricultural sustainability and productivity, with positive societal and environmental impacts.

A review of anammox metabolic response to environmental factors: Characteristics and mechanisms

Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) is a promising low carbon and economic biological nitrogen removal technology. Considering the anammox technology has been easily restricted by environmental factors in practical engineering applications, therefore, it is necessary to understand the metabolic response characteristics of anammox bacteria to different environmental factors, and then guide the application of the anammox process. This review presented the latest advances of the research progress of the effects of different environmental factors on the metabolic pathway of anammox bacteria. The effects as well as mechanisms of conventional environmental factors and emerging pollutants on the anammox metabolic processes were summarized. Also, the role of quorum sensing (QS) mediating the bacteria growth, gene expression and other metabolic process in the anammox system were also reviewed. Finally, interaction and cross-feeding mechanisms of microbial communities in the anammox system were discussed. This review systematically summarized the variations of metabolic mechanism response to the external environment and cross-feeding interactions in the anammox process, which would provide an in-depth understanding for the anammox metabolic process and a comprehensive guidance for future anammox-related metabolic studies and engineering applications.

Potential bacterial isolation by dosing metabolites in cross-feedings

Metabolic cross-feeding, in which species use metabolites of other members to promote their own growth, is vital for bacterial growth and survival. Thus, whether the unculturable bacteria can be isolated or purified from consortia by adding these essential metabolites remains elusive. In this study, mass spectrometry imaging vividly pictured symbionts supplied folate and gluconate to anammox bacteria to support their growth. After dosing folate and gluconate, the relative abundance and activity of anammox bacteria were substantially improved. Such enhancement is originated from the added folate and gluconate significantly eased metabolic burden of anammox bacteria as they no longer secreted the extracellular public goods to others for "resource exchange" during cross-feedings. On the other hand, the decreased supplement of extracellular "public goods" lead to the decay of symbionts with high demand for these metabolites in the consortia. This also deservedly increased the relative abundance of anammox bacteria. This study provides a new dimension to isolate specific functional bacteria based on metabolic cross-feedings.

Comparing the indigenous microorganism system in typical petroleum-contaminated groundwater

The environmental conditions at a contaminated site will impact on the indigenous microbial communities, with implications for the removal of pollutants. An analysis of the characteristics of microbial communities in petroleum-contaminated groundwater can give insights into the relationships between microbial community and environmental factors, and provide guidance about how microbes can be used to remediate and regulate petroleum-contaminated groundwater. This study focuses on two petroleum-contaminated sites in northeast China, the physico-chemical-biological changes in petroleum-contaminated groundwater were analyzed, the response relationship between hydro-chemical indicators and microbial communities was characterized, and the bioindicator that can reflect the petroleum contamination status were established for environmental monitoring and management. The results showed that Proteobacteria was the dominant bacteria in petroleum-contaminated groundwater, with a relative abundance of 42.45%-91.19%. pH, TDS, DO, NO3-, NO2-, SO42-, NH4+, Al, and Mn have significant effects on microbial community. The effect of petroleum pollutants on microbial communities is not only related to the concentration and composition of the pollutants themselves, but also could indirectly affect microbial communities by changing the content of inorganic electron acceptor components such as iron, manganese, sulfate and nitrate in groundwater, and this indirect effect is significantly greater than the direct impact of pollutants on microbial communities. In petroleum-contaminated groundwater, the dominant genera (Polaromonas, Caulobacter) and microbial metabolic functions (methanol oxidation, methylotrophy, ureolysis, and reductive biosynthesis) of the indigenous microbial community can be used as bioindicators to indicate petroleum contamination status. The higher abundance of these bioindicators in petroleum-contaminated groundwater, the more serious petroleum pollution in groundwater.

Metagenomic insights into the symbiotic relationship in anammox consortia at reduced temperature

Anammox as a promising biological nitrogen removal technology has attracted much attention. However, cold temperature would limit its wide application and little is known about the microbial interactions between anammox bacteria (AnAOB) and heterotrophic bacteria at cold temperature. Here, we observed reduced temperature (25-15 °C) promoted the secretion of EPS and thus stimulated bigger size of granular sludge in a laboratory-scale anammox reactor. We further combined co-occurrence network analysis and genome-centered metagenomics to explore the potential interactions between AnAOB and heterotrophic bacteria. Network analysis suggested 22 out of 25 positively related species were reported as definite heterotrophic bacteria in subnetwork of AnAOB. Genome-centered metagenomics analysis yielded 23 metagenomic assembly genomes (MAGs), and we found that Acidobacteriota-affiliated bacteria could biosynthesize most polysaccharides (PS) precursors and contain the most glycosyltransferases and transporters to facilitate exopolysaccharides biosynthesis, together with partial PS precursors produced by AnAOB. AMX1 as the only anammox genome could synthesize most amino acids and cross feed with some heterotrophs to affect the extracellular protein function. Additionally, Bacteroidota, Planctomycetota, Chloroflexota, and Proteobacteria could contribute folate and molybdopterin cofactor for AMX1 to benefit their activity and growth. Superphylum Patescibacteria could survive by cross-feeding with AnAOB and heterotrophic organisms about organic compounds (Glyceraldehyde-3P and lactate). These cross-feedings maintained the stability of anammox reactor performance and emphasize the importance of heterotrophs in anammox system at reduced temperature.

Active assimilators of soluble microbial products produced by wastewater anammox bacteria and their roles revealed by DNA-SIP coupled to metagenomics

Heterotrophic bacteria grow on influent organics or soluble microbial products (SMP) in wastewater anammox processes, playing key roles in facilitating microbial aggregation and reducing excess nitrate. The overgrowth of heterotrophs represents one of the major causes of anammox process failure, while the metabolic functions of coexisting heterotrophs and their roles in anammox process remain vague. This study aimed at revealing metabolic interactions between AnAOB and active SMP assimilators by integrating ¹³C DNA-stable isotope probing, metabolomic and metagenomic approaches. Glycine, aspartate, and glutamate with low biosynthetic energy cost were the major SMP components produced by AnAOB (net yield: 44.8, 10.4, 8.1 mg·g NH₄⁺-N^-1). Glycine was likely synthesized by AnAOB via the reductive glycine pathway which is oxygen-tolerant, supporting heterotrophic growth. Fermentative Chloroflexi bacterium OLB13, denitrifying Gemmatimonadaceae and Burkholderiaceae bacterium JOSHI-001 were active SMP assimilators, which were prevalent in globally distributed wastewater anammox reactors as core taxa. They likely formed a mutualistic relationship with auxotrophic Ca. Kuenenia by providing necessities such as methionine, folate, 4'-phosphopantetheine, and molybdopterin cofactor, and receiving vitamin B₁₂ for methionine synthesis. For the first time, the identify and metabolic features of SMP assimilators in wastewater anammox communities were revealed. Supplying necessities secreted by heterotrophs could be helpful to the endeavor of AnAOB enrichment. Practically, maintaining active but not overgrown SMP assimilators is critical to efficient and stable operation of wastewater anammox processes.

New Insight Into the Interspecies Shift of Anammox Bacteria Ca. "Brocadia" and Ca. "Jettenia" in Reactors Fed With Formate and Folate

The sensitivity of anaerobic ammonium-oxidizing (anammox) bacteria to environmental fluctuations is a frequent cause of reactor malfunctions. It was hypothesized that the addition of formate and folate would have a stimulating effect on anammox bacteria, which in turn would lead to the stability of the anammox process under conditions of a sharp increase in ammonium load, i.e., it helps overcome a stress factor. The effect of formate and folate was investigated using a setup consisting of three parallel sequencing batch reactors equipped with a carrier. Two runs of the reactors were performed. The composition of the microbial community was studied by the 16S rRNA gene profiling and metagenomic analysis. Among anammox bacteria, Ca. "Brocadia" spp. dominated during the first run. A stimulatory effect of folate on the daily nitrogen removal rate (dN) was identified. The addition of formate led to progress in dissimilatory nitrate reduction and stimulated the growth of Ca. "Jettenia" spp. The spatial separation of two anammox species was observed in the formate reactor: Ca. "Brocadia" occupied the carrier and Ca. "Jettenia"-the walls of the reactors. Biomass storage at low temperature without feeding led to an interspecies shift in anammox bacteria in favor of Ca. "Jettenia." During the second run, a domination of Ca. "Jettenia" spp. was recorded along with a stimulating effect of formate, and there was no effect of folate on dN. A comparative genome analysis revealed the patterns suggesting different strategies used by Ca. "Brocadia" and Ca. "Jettenia" spp. to cope with environmental changes.

Metagenomic prediction analysis of microbial aggregation in anammox-dominated community

Aggregation of anammox bacteria is essential to maintain high biomass concentrations and prevent the loss of biomass in anammox processes. PICRUSt (Phylogenetic Investigation of Communities by Reconstruction of Unobserved States) was used in this study to predict the metagenomic potentials and characterize the microbial community structure and functional features in anammox aggregates (e.g., sludge flocs, biofilms, and granules). The results showed that Candidatus Brocadia was the most dominant anammox genera in all aggregates (38.0% in flocs, 69.4% in biofilm, and 52.0% in granules) and the functional gene involved in the anammox process was detected in the highest amount in biofilms, followed by granules and flocs. Furthermore, the anammox microbial aggregation pathway was explored that anammox bacteria have strong motility and high capability for early attachment. Anammox bacteria could produce large amounts of EPS (extracellular polymeric substances) regulated by quinolone and transport to extracellular environment through type II secretion system. The strong ability of c-di-GMP (bis-(3'-5')-cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate) synthesis enabled a stable architectural structure of aggregation. This study elucidated the aggregation mechanism of anammox microorganisms at the genetic level to enhance the stability of anammox processes. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Candidatus Brocadia was the most dominant anammox genera in aggregates. Anammox bacteria have strong motility and high attachment capability. Anammox bacteria possess strong EPS synthesis regulated by quinolone. c-di-GMP synthesis enables a stable structure of aggregation.

Effect of fulvic acid on bioreactor performance and on microbial populations within the anammox process

The long-term effect of fulvic acid (FA) on bioreactor performance and on microbial populations within the anammox process were firstly investigated in this study. The average nitrogen removal rate showed an upward trend when the influent TOC concentration of FA was 25.2-65.1 mg/L. However, when FA was increased to 80.3 mg/L, the reactor performance was slightly inhibited. In addition, judging from the particle size and settling properties, FA can promote anammox sludge granulation. After 53 days of exposure to FA, the genus Anaerolineaincreased in number, while Denitratisoma decreased. Candidatus Jettenia and Candidatus Kuenenia survived and enriched in the changed environment, potentially due to the interaction between anammox bacteria and some heterotrophic bacteria, which could protect anammox bacteria from adverse environments. These results indicate that FA can change the bacterial community and trigger different microbial interaction mechanisms within the anammox reactor.

Genome-based analysis to understanding rapid resuscitation of cryopreserved anammox consortia via sequential supernatant addition

Simple cryopreservation of anaerobic ammonium-oxidation (anammox) consortia has become a promising preservation technology for the fast start-up of the anammox process. Here, we use genome-resolved metagenomics and metatranscriptomics to understand of the microbial interaction in a simple and effective resuscitation process for long-term cryopreserved anammox consortia by sequential addition of anammox SBR supernatant. Performance results showed that sequential addition of anammox supernatant significantly reduced the resuscitation time of the granule-based anammox process from 40 to 20 days. Genome-centric metagenomics were used to recover 19 high-quality draft genomes of anammox and heterotrophic bacteria. Comparative metatranscriptomic analysis was conducted to examine the gene expression of Candidatus Kuenenia stuttgartiensis, the dominant anammox bacterium, and heterotrophic bacteria to better understand their potential interactions. Proteobacteria-affiliated bacteria found in the supernatant were highly active in producing the secondary metabolites molybdopterin cofactor and folate which are needed for growth of the auxotrophic anammox bacteria. In addition, the significantly higher expression levels of hzsA and CO₂-fixtion genes in the Candidatus Kuenenia genome indicated the anammox bacteria were likely more active and growing faster after sequential anammox supernatant addition during the resuscitation process. The resuscitation treatment pulse assays confirmed that sequential addition of supernatant was an effective way for the rapid resuscitation of anammox consortia. Our findings offer the first evidence of cross-feeding during the rapid resuscitation of cryopreserved anammox consortia.

Newly designed high-coverage degenerate primers for nitrogen removal mechanism analysis in a partial nitrification-anammox (PN/A) process

Reliable tools for quantification of different functional populations are required to achieve stable, effective nutrients removal in partial nitrification and anammox (PN/A) processes. Here we report the design and validation of degenerate PCR primer pairs targeting anammox bacteria, aerobic ammonium-oxidizing bacteria (AeAOB) and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) with high coverage but without sacrificing specificity. The new primer pairs are able to cover a broader range of the targeted populations (58.4 vs 21.7%, 49.5 vs 47.6%, 80.7 vs 57.2% and 70.5 vs 42.3% of anammox bacteria, AeAOB, Nitrobacter and Nitrospina, respectively) than previously published primers. Particularly, the Amx719F/875R primer can retrieve a larger number of 16S rRNA genes from different types of samples with amplicons covering all known anammox bacteria genera (100% coverage) including the recently found novel genus, Asahi BRW. These newly desinged primers will provide a more reliable molecular tool to investigate the mechanisms of nitrogen removal in PN/A processes, which can provide clearer links between reactor performance, the metabolic activities and abundances of functional populations, shedding light on conditions that are favorable to the establishment of stable PN/A.

Enhancing biotreatment of incineration leachate by applying an electric potential in a partial nitritation-Anammox system

An electric potential (EP) was applied to enhance biotreatment of anaerobically-treated leachate from municipal solid waste incineration plants using a partial nitritation-Anammox system. At an optimal EP difference of 0.06 V, total nitrogen removal efficiency reached 71.9%, 17.3% higher than the control system without an EP. Removal of organic matter was also stimulated with the EP, particularly macromolecules with molecular weight >20 kDa in the leachate. Applying EP also promoted production of extracellular polymeric substances and improved the protein/polysaccharide ratio. High-throughput DNA sequencing revealed that Anammox bacteria in the genus Candidatus Kuenenia were enriched for on electrodes with the applied EP. Heterotrophic denitrifiers, which potentially could degrade organic macromolecules, were also more abundant on the electrodes with EP compared with the control reactor. These results show that applying an EP could be a useful strategy in Anammox technologies treating real wastewater high in ammonia and refractory organic compounds.

Genome-Centered Metagenomics Analysis Reveals the Symbiotic Organisms Possessing Ability to Cross-Feed with Anammox Bacteria in Anammox Consortia

Although using anammox communities for efficient wastewater treatment has attracted much attention, the pure anammox bacteria are difficult to obtain, and the potential roles of symbiotic bacteria in anammox performance are still elusive. Here, we combined long-term reactor operation, genome-centered metagenomics, community functional structure, and metabolic pathway reconstruction to reveal multiple potential cross-feedings during anammox reactor start-up according to the 37 recovered metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs). We found Armatimonadetes and Proteobacteria could contribute the secondary metabolites molybdopterin cofactor and folate for anammox bacteria to benefit their activity and growth. Chloroflexi-affiliated bacteria encoded the function of biosynthesizing exopolysaccharides for anammox consortium aggregation, based on the partial nucleotide sugars produced by anammox bacteria. Chlorobi-affiliated bacteria had the ability to degrade extracellular proteins produced by anammox bacteria to amino acids to affect consortium aggregation. Additionally, the Chloroflexi-affiliated bacteria harbored genes for a nitrite loop and could have a dual role in anammox performance during reactor start-up. Cross-feeding in anammox community adds a different dimension for understanding microbial interactions and emphasizes the importance of symbiotic bacteria in the anammox process for wastewater treatment.

Negligible seeding source effect on the final ANAMMOX community under steady and high nitrogen loading rate after enrichment using poly(vinyl alcohol) gel carriers

This study investigated the effect of seeding source on the mature anaerobic ammonia oxidation (ANAMMOX) bacterial community niche in continuous poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) gel systems operated under high nitrogen loading rate (NLR) condition. Four identical column reactors packed with PVA gels were operated for 182 d using different seeding sources which had distinct community structures. The ANAMMOX reaction was achieved in all the bioreactors with comparable total and ANAMMOX bacterial 16S rRNA gene quantities. The bacterial community structure of the bioreactors became similar during operation; some major bacteria were commonly found. Interestingly, one ANAMMOX species, "Candidatus Brocadia sinica", was conclusively predominant in all the bioreactors, even though different seeding sludges were used as inoculum source, possibly due to the unique physiological characteristics of "Ca. Brocadia sinica" and the operating conditions (i.e., PVA gel-based continuous system and 1.0 kg-N/(m³·d) of NLR). The results clearly suggest that high NLR condition is a more significant factor determining the final ANAMMOX community niche than is the type of seeding source.

Efficiency of an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor treating potato starch processing wastewater and related process kinetics, functional microbial community and sludge morphology

Herein, an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor was employed to treat potato starch processing wastewater and the efficacy, kinetics, microbial diversity and morphology of sludge granules were investigated. When organic loading rate (OLR) ranging from 2.70 to 13.27kgCOD/m³.d was implemented with various hydraulic retention times (72h, 48h and 36h), COD removal could reach 92.0-97.7%. Highest COD removal (97.7%) was noticed when OLR was 3.65kgCOD/m³.d, but had declined to 92.0% when OLR was elevated to 13.27kgCOD/m³.d. Methane and biogas production increased from 0.48 to 2.97L/L.d and 0.90 to 4.28L/L.d, respectively. Kinetics and predictions by modified-Gompertz model agreed better with experimental data as opposed to first-order kinetic model. Functional population with highest abundance was Chloroflexi (28.91%) followed by Euryarchaeota (22.13%), Firmicutes (16.7%), Proteobacteria (16.25%) and Bacteroidetes (7.73%). Compared with top sludge, tightly-bound extracellular polymeric substances was high within bottom and middle sludge. Morphology was predominantly Methanosaeta-like cells, Methanosarcina-like cells, rods and cocci colonies.