Not only muscle mass but also muscle quality is associated with knee extension muscle strength in patients with hip fractures

Improvement of muscle quality assessed using the phase angle is influenced by recovery of knee extension strength in patients with hip fractures

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Studies reported that knee extension strength on the operated side in patients with hip fractures was not recovered to the level on the non-operated side 6 months after surgery or later. In a cross-sectional study, we revealed that a reduction in isometric knee extension muscle strength on the operated side in patients with hip fractures approximately 6 months after surgery was associated with not only a reduction in skeletal muscle mass but also a reduction in muscle quality, characterized by a reduction in the phase angle (PhA). Furthermore, the mechanisms of knee extension strength improvement can be clarified in more detail using the minimal significant change as the index of recovery. However, no longitudinal studies have examined the factors for knee extension strength improvement based on the minimal significant change in patients with hip fractures 6 months after surgery. This study aimed to longitudinally examine the factors influencing the recovery of knee extension strength based on the minimal significant change in patients with hip fractures between 2 weeks and approximately 6 months after surgery.

METHODS

In this study, the outcomes used were basic and medical information, PhA, skeletal muscle index (SMI), pain, one-leg standing time, movement control during one-leg standing, and walking speed. For PhA, SMI, pain, one-leg standing time, movement control during one-leg standing, and walking speed, the amount of change was calculated by subtracting the data at 2 weeks from the data at 6 months. Group classification was determined by dividing the patients into two groups using a previous study as a reference: recovery group if the knee extension strength value approximately 6 months after surgery minus that 2 weeks after surgery was ≥3.3 kgf and non-recovery group if the value was <3.3 kgf. Logistic regression analysis was performed to explore the association between the recovery and non-recovery groups.

RESULTS

The recovery group contained 55 patients, while the non-recovery group comprised 35 patients. The only significant factor associated with knee extension muscle strength in the recovery group was the amount of change in PhA. The odds ratio for the amount of change in PhA was 2.26. The discrimination rate of the model was 62.5%.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that recovery of knee extension strength in patients with hip fractures after surgery was mainly because of improvements in muscle quality, not improvements in muscle mass or pain.