Comparing the Wada Test and Functional MRI for the Presurgical Evaluation of Memory in Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

[Memory impairments in temporal lobe epilepsy]

Temporal lobe epilepsy is known to present with various cognitive impairments, among which memory deficits are frequently reported by patients. Memory deficits can be classified into two types: classical hippocampal amnesia, which is characterized by abnormalities detected in neuropsychological assessments, and atypical memory deficits, such as accelerated long-term amnesia and autobiographical memory impairment, which cannot be identified using standard testing methods. These deficits are believed to arise from a complex interplay among structural brain abnormalities, interictal epileptic discharges, pharmacological factors, and psychological states. While fundamental treatments are limited, there are opportunities for interventions such as environmental adjustments and rehabilitation. This review article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the types, underlying pathophysiology, and intervention methods for memory disorders observed in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy.

New insights for predicting surgery outcome in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy. A systematic review

Resective surgery is the treatment of choice for one-third of adult patients with focal, drug-resistant epilepsy. This procedure is associated with substantial clinical and cognitive risks. In clinical practice, there is no validated model for epilepsy surgery outcome prediction (ESOP). Meta-analyses on ESOP studies assessing prognostic factors report discrepancies in terms of study design. Our review aims to systematically investigate methodological and analytical aspects of studies predicting clinical and cognitive outcomes after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery. A systematic review of ESOP studies published between 2000 and 2022 from three databases (MEDLINE, Web of Science, and PsycINFO) was completed by following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. It yielded 4867 articles. Among them, 21 corresponded to our inclusion criteria and were therefore retained in the final review. The risk of bias was assessed using A Tool to Assess Risk of Bias and Applicability of Prediction Model Studies (PROBAST). Data extracted from the 21 studies were analyzed using narrative synthesis and descriptive statistics. Our findings show an increase in the use of multimodal datasets and machine learning analyses in recent ESOP studies, although regression remained the most frequently used approach. We also identified a more frequent use of network notions in recent ESOP studies. Nevertheless, several methodological issues were noted, such as small sample sizes, lack of information on the follow-up period, variability in seizure outcome, and the definition of neuropsychological postoperative change. Of 21 studies, only one provided a clinical tool to anticipate the cognitive outcome after epilepsy surgery. We conclude that methodological issues should be overcome before we move towards more complete models to better predict clinical and cognitive outcomes after epilepsy surgery. Recommendations for future studies to harness the possibilities of multimodal datasets and data fusion, are provided. A stronger bridge between fundamental and clinical research may result in developing accessible clinical tools.

WADA test for postoperative memory prediction in left TLE. Is it still useful in the 21st century?

BACKGROUND

Epilepsy surgery offers an effective treatment to achieve seizure freedom in refractory temporal lobe epilepsy. Since left temporal lobe surgery can be associated with verbal memory deterioration, control of cognitive decline is a main goal of therapy. This study analyzes the prognostic value of intracarotid amobarbital procedure (Wada test) in addition to specific neuropsychological and clinical variables for postoperative memory changes.

METHOD

Between 2013 and 2021 thirty-six patients (18 females, 18 males, mean age 41.0 years) from the Epilepsy Center Erlangen (ECE) with left hemispheric temporal lobe epilepsy underwent neuropsychological assessment preoperatively - including the Wada test - and six months postoperatively. In addition, a group of 92 patients (40 females, 52 males, mean age 36.1 years) with left or right hemispheric focus who underwent Wada test and surgery before 2013 was included as a standardization group. In all patients Wada test was carried out preoperatively to determine language dominance and memory capacity.

RESULTS

Postoperative verbal memory scores showed no significant difference from preoperative performance. Preoperative verbal memory performance as well as the hippocampal resection extent is particularly important in predicting postoperative verbal memory change. After left temporal lobe surgery, a significantly higher postoperative functional level was shown for figural memory. Specifically, a good contralateral hemispheric performance level assessed by the Wada test proved to be a compensatory factor for postoperative losses.

CONCLUSION

The Wada test is no longer necessary as a diagnostic tool for a broad group of patients with temporal lobe epilepsy. However, it can be useful for a subgroup of patients with clinical indicators such as nonspecific or incongruent preoperative verbal and figural memory impairments. In this study, Wada test data about the functional level of the contralateral hemisphere specifically allowed estimation of postoperative figural memory changes.

Roles of fMRI and Wada tests in the presurgical evaluation of language functions in temporal lobe epilepsy

Surgical treatment of pharmacoresistant temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) carries risks for language function that can significantly affect the quality of life. Predicting the risks of decline in language functions before surgery is, consequently, just as important as predicting the chances of becoming seizure-free. The intracarotid amobarbital test, generally known as the Wada test (WT), has been traditionally used to determine language lateralization and to estimate their potential decline after surgery. However, the test is invasive and it does not localize the language functions. Therefore, other noninvasive methods have been proposed, of which functional magnetic resonance (fMRI) has the greatest potential. Functional MRI allows localization of language areas. It has good concordance with the WT for language lateralization, and it is of predictive value for postsurgical naming outcomes. Consequently, fMRI has progressively replaced WT for presurgical language evaluation. The objective of this manuscript is to review the most relevant aspects of language functions in TLE and the current role of fMRI and WT in the presurgical evaluation of language. First, we will provide context by revising the language network distribution and the effects of TLE on them. Then, we will assess the functional outcomes following various forms of TLE surgery and measures to reduce postoperative language decline. Finally, we will discuss the current indications for WT and fMRI and the potential usefulness of the resting-state fMRI technique.

Multimodal Presurgical Evaluation of Medically Refractory Focal Epilepsy in Adults: An Update for Radiologists

Surgery is a potentially curative treatment option for patients with medically refractory focal epilepsy. Advanced neuroimaging modalities often improve surgical outcomes by contributing key information during the highly individualized surgical planning process and intraoperative localization. Hence, neuroradiologists play an integral role as part of the multidisciplinary management team. In this review, we initially present the conceptual background and practical framework of the presurgical evaluation process, including a description of the surgical treatment approaches in medically refractory focal epilepsy in adults. This background is followed by an overview of the advanced modalities commonly used during the presurgical workup at level IV epilepsy centers including diffusion imaging techniques, blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) functional MRI (fMRI), PET, SPECT, and subtraction ictal SPECT, as well as by introductions to 7-T MRI and electrophysiologic techniques including electroencephalography (EEG) and magnetoencephalography (MEG). We also provide illustrative case examples of multimodal neuroimaging including PET/MRI, PET/MRI-DTI, subtraction ictal SPECT, and image-guided stereotactic planning with fMRI-DTI.

Association Between Microstructural Asymmetry of Temporal Lobe White Matter and Memory Decline After Anterior Temporal Lobectomy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Risk for memory decline is a substantial concern in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) undergoing anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL). Although prior studies have identified associations between memory and integrity of white matter (WM) networks within the medial temporal lobe (MTL) preoperatively, we contribute a study examining whether microstructural asymmetry of deep and superficial WM networks within the MTL predicts postoperative memory decline.

METHODS

Patients with drug-resistant TLE were recruited from 2 epilepsy centers in a prospective longitudinal study. All patients completed preoperative T1 and diffusion-weighted MRI (DWI) as well as preoperative and postoperative neuropsychological testing. Preoperative fractional anisotropy (FA) of the WM directly beneath the neocortex (i.e., superficial WM [SWM]) and of deep WM tracts associated with memory were calculated. Asymmetry was calculated for hippocampal volume and FA of each WM tract or region and examined in linear and logistic regressions with preoperative to postoperative memory change as the primary outcome.

RESULTS

Data were analyzed from 42 patients with TLE (19 left TLE [LTLE], 23 right TLE [RTLE]) who underwent ATL. Leftward FA asymmetry of the entorhinal SWM was associated with decline on prose and associative recall in LTLE, whereas leftward FA asymmetry of the uncinate fasciculus (UNC) was associated with decline on prose recall only. After controlling for preoperative memory score and hippocampal volume, leftward FA asymmetry of the entorhinal SWM uniquely contributed to decline in both prose and associative recall (β = -0.46; SE 0.14 and β = -0.68; SE 0.22, respectively) and leftward FA asymmetry of the UNC uniquely contributed to decline in prose recall (β = -0.31; SE 0.14). A model combining asymmetry of hippocampal volume and entorhinal FA correctly classified memory outcomes in 79% of patients with LTLE for prose (area under the curve [AUC] 0.89; sensitivity 82%; specificity 75%) and 81% of patients for associative (AUC 0.79; sensitivity 83%; specificity 80%) recall. Entorhinal SWM asymmetry was the strongest predictor in both models.

DISCUSSION

Preoperative asymmetry of deep WM and SWM integrity within the MTL is a strong predictor of postoperative memory decline in TLE, suggesting that surgical decision-making may benefit from considering each patient's WM network adequacy and reserve in addition to hippocampal integrity.

CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE

This study provides Class II evidence that preoperative asymmetry of deep WM and SWM integrity within the MTL is a predictor of postoperative memory decline.

Mapping of Language-and-Memory Networks in Patients With Temporal Lobe Epilepsy by Using the GE2REC Protocol

Preoperative mapping of language and declarative memory functions in temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) patients is essential since they frequently encounter deterioration of these functions and show variable degrees of cerebral reorganization. Due to growing evidence on language and declarative memory interdependence at a neural and neuropsychological level, we propose the GE2REC protocol for interactive language-and-memory network (LMN) mapping. GE2REC consists of three inter-related tasks, sentence generation with implicit encoding (GE) and two recollection (2REC) memory tasks: recognition and recall. This protocol has previously been validated in healthy participants, and in this study, we showed that it also maps the LMN in the left TLE (N = 18). Compared to healthy controls (N = 19), left TLE (LTLE) showed widespread inter- and intra-hemispheric reorganization of the LMN through reduced activity of regions engaged in the integration and the coordination of this meta-network. We also illustrated how this protocol could be implemented in clinical practice individually by presenting two case studies of LTLE patients who underwent efficient surgery and became seizure-free but showed different cognitive outcomes. This protocol can be advantageous for clinical practice because it (a) is short and easy to perform; (b) allows brain mapping of essential cognitive functions, even at an individual level; (c) engages language-and-memory interaction allowing to evaluate the integrative processes within the LMN; (d) provides a more comprehensive assessment by including both verbal and visual modalities, as well as various language and memory processes. Based on the available postsurgical data, we presented preliminary results obtained with this protocol in LTLE patients that could potentially inform the clinical practice. This implies the necessity to further validate the potential of GE2REC for neurosurgical planning, along with two directions, guiding resection and describing LMN neuroplasticity at an individual level.

A clinically applicable functional MRI memory paradigm for use with pediatric patients

OBJECTIVE

Clinically employable functional MRI (fMRI) memory paradigms are not yet established for pediatric patient epilepsy surgery workups. Seeking to establish such a paradigm, we evaluated the effectiveness of memory fMRI tasks we developed by quantifying individual activation in a clinical pediatric setting, analyzing patterns of activation relative to the side of temporal lobe (TL) pathology, and comparing fMRI and Wada test results.

METHODS

We retrospectively identified 72 patients aged 6.7-20.9 years with pathology (seizure focus and/or tumor) limited to the TL who had attempted memory and language fMRI tasks over a 9-year period as part of presurgical workups. Memory fMRI tasks required visualization of autobiographical memories in a block design alternating with covert counting. Language fMRI protocols involved verb and sentence generation. Scans were both qualitatively interpreted and quantitatively assessed for blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) signal change using region of interest (ROI) masks. We calculated the percentage of successfully scanned individual cases, compared 2 memory task activation masks in cases with left versus right TL pathology, and compared fMRI with Wada tests when available. Patients who had viable fMRI and Wada tests had generally concordant results.

RESULTS

Of the 72 cases, 60 (83%), aged 7.6-20.9 years, successfully performed the memory fMRI tasks and 12 (17%) failed. Eleven of 12 unsuccessful scans were due to motion and/or inability to perform the tasks, and the success of a twelfth was indeterminate due to orthodontic metal artifact. Seven of the successful 60 cases had distorted anatomy that precluded employing predetermined masks for quantitative analysis. Successful fMRI memory studies showed bilateral mesial temporal activation and quantitatively demonstrated: (1) left activation (L-ACT) less than right activation (R-ACT) in cases with left temporal lobe (L-TL) pathology, (2) nonsignificant R-ACT less than L-ACT in cases with right temporal lobe (R-TL) pathology, and (3) lower L-ACT plus R-ACT activation for cases with L-TL versus R-TL pathology. Patients who had viable fMRI and Wada tests had generally concordant results.

SIGNIFICANCE

This study demonstrates evidence of an fMRI memory task paradigm that elicits reliable activation at the individual level and can generally be accomplished in clinically involved pediatric patients. This autobiographical memory paradigm showed activation in mesial TL structures, and cases with left compared to right TL pathology showed differences in activation consistent with extant literature in TL epilepsy. Further studies will be required to assess outcome prediction.

Functional connectivity of hippocampus in temporal lobe epilepsy depends on hippocampal dominance: a systematic review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Lateralized alterations in hippocampal function in the resting-state have been demonstrated for patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). However, resting-state fMRI of the hippocampus has yet to be substantiated as an adjunct to standard pre-operative assessments of the seizure focus.

OBJECTIVE

Here we report the results of a systematic review of resting-state fMRI studies investigating laterality of hippocampal network connectivity in TLE patients.

METHODS

A search of the PubMed, SCOPUS, Web of Science, and Embase databases for full-length articles written in English was conducted through June 2020 using the following terms: 'resting state fMRI,' 'hippocampus,' 'epilepsy,' and 'laterality.'

RESULTS

Our literature search yielded a total of 42 papers. After excluding studies that did not include patients with epilepsy, utilize resting-state fMRI, or explore the relationship between functional connectivity and disease lateralization, 20 publications were selected for inclusion. From these studies, a total of 528 patients, 258 with left TLE and 270 with right TLE, and 447 healthy controls were included. Of the 20 studies included, 18 found that patients with TLE demonstrated decreased hippocampal functional connectivity ipsilateral to the epileptogenic focus and 10 additionally reported increased hippocampal functional connectivity contralateral to the epileptogenic focus. Several studies demonstrated that the duration of disease was correlated with these changes in functional connectivity. This implies that a compensatory mechanism may be present in patients with treatment-refractory TLE.

CONCLUSION

The consistency of this hippocampal connectivity pattern across multiple studies suggests resting-state fMRI may be useful as a non-invasive diagnostic tool for preoperative evaluation of TLE patients.

Drug load and memory during intracarotid amobarbital procedure in epilepsy

BACKGROUND

Anti-seizure medications (ASMs) have been related to poor cognitive function, but their relationship with intracarotid amobarbital procedure (IAP) results remains unclear.

AIMS OF THE STUDY

To elucidate whether the number and drug load of ASMs are associated with memory scores of the IAP and the neuropsychological assessment.

METHODS

Fifty-nine adult patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (mean age = 36.1, SD = 11.6) underwent bilateral IAP (with drawings and words as memory items) and a neuropsychological assessment to assess the risk of post-surgical memory decline. Total ASM drug load was calculated by summing the daily dose/defined daily dose ratio of every ASM of each patient. Pearson's correlations and hierarchical regressions were computed.

RESULTS

Total IAP memory score was associated with total ASM drug load (r = -0.30, p = 0.02) and seizure frequency (r = -0.25, p = 0.05). After controlling clinical variables, total ASM drug load explained 16% of the variance of total IAP memory score. This relationship was especially prominent in patients with left hemisphere focus (r = -0.33, p = 0.04). The number of current ASMs was not related to IAP memory score (r = -0.16, p = 0.24). The number or drug load of ASMs were not related to neuropsychological assessment results (for all, p > 0.07).

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that total drug load can be a confounding variable in the IAP memory performance that could explain, at least in part, the reverse asymmetries reported in different studies.

Interactive mapping of language and memory with the GE2REC protocol

Previous studies have highlighted the importance of considering cognitive functions from a dynamic and interactive perspective and multiple evidence was brought for a language and memory interaction. In this study performed with healthy participants, we present a new protocol entitled GE2REC that interactively accesses the neural representation of language-and-memory network. This protocol consists of three runs related to each other, providing a link between tasks, in order to assure an interactive measure of linguistic and episodic memory processes. GE2REC consists of a sentence generation (GE) in the auditory modality and two recollecting (2REC) memory tasks, one recognition performed in the visual modality, and another one recall performed in the auditory modality. Its efficiency was evaluated in 20 healthy volunteers using a 3T MR imager. Our results corroborate the ability of GE2REC to robustly activate fronto-temporo-parietal language network as well as temporal mesial, prefrontal and parietal cortices in encoding during sentence generation and recognition. GE2REC is useful because it: (a) requires simultaneous and interactive language-and-memory processes and jointly maps their neural basis; (b) explores encoding and retrieval, managing to elicit activation of mesial temporal structures; (c) is easy to perform, hence being suitable for more restrictive settings, and (d) has an ecological dimension of tasks and stimuli. GE2REC may be useful for studying neuroplasticity of cognitive functions, especially in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy who show reorganization of both language and memory networks. Overall, GE2REC can provide valuable information in terms of the practical foundation of exploration language and memory interconnection.

Wada test results contribute to the prediction of change in verbal learning and verbal memory function after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery

In recent years, the clinical usefulness of the Wada test (WT) has been debated among researchers in the field. Therefore, we aimed to assess its contribution to the prediction of change in verbal learning and verbal memory function after epilepsy surgery. Data from 56 patients with temporal lobe epilepsy who underwent WT and subsequent surgery were analyzed retrospectively. Additionally, a standard neuropsychological assessment evaluating attentional, learning and memory, visuospatial, language, and executive function was performed both before and 12 months after surgery. Hierarchical linear regression analyses were used to determine the incremental value of WT results over socio-demographic, clinical, and neuropsychological characteristics in predicting postsurgical change in patients' verbal learning and verbal memory function. The incorporation of WT results significantly improved the prediction models of postsurgical change in verbal learning (∆R² = 0.233, p = .032) and verbal memory function (∆R² = 0.386, p = .005). Presurgical performance and WT scores accounted for 41.8% of the variance in postsurgical change in verbal learning function, and 51.1% of the variance in postsurgical change in verbal memory function. Our findings confirm that WT results are of significant incremental value for the prediction of postsurgical change in verbal learning and verbal memory function. Thus, the WT contributes to determining the risks of epilepsy surgery and, therefore, remains an important part of the presurgical work-up of selected patients with clear clinical indications.

The cognitive costs, contraindications and complications of epilepsy surgery in adults

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Access to epilepsy surgery is rapidly growing throughout the world. While it is an established and effective treatment for seizures, epilepsy surgery has the potential to exacerbate cognitive comorbidities of the condition.

RECENT FINDINGS

Not all surgical patients experience a postoperative decline in cognitive function. Postoperative cognitive function depends upon the functional integrity of the tissue to be removed and the functional reserve of the structures that remain in situ. While developments in surgical technique can reduce the cognitive morbidity of epilepsy surgery, the same procedure may result in different cognitive outcomes for different candidates, depending on their preoperative characteristics and postoperative trajectories. Multivariate models can be used to identify those most at risk of cognitive decline. There remains a significant lack of research into clinical interventions aimed at reducing the impact of surgically induced cognitive deficits on the lives of the patients who experience them.

SUMMARY

Accurate identification of the cognitive risks associated with surgery, based on an individual's personal risk profile rather than the generic risks associated with the procedure, is now recognized as a mandatory part of the preoperative evaluation and is one of the pillars of informed consent for the procedure.

Concordance between fMRI and Wada test for memory lateralization in temporal lobe epilepsy: A meta-analysis and systematic review

OBJECTIVE

The Wada test (WT) is increasingly being replaced by functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to evaluate memory lateralization before temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) surgery. We aimed to determine, via meta-analysis, agreement between the two tests and identify predictors of disagreement.

METHODS

We performed a systematic search for studies comparing WT and fMRI for memory lateralization with individual-patient data. If results were provided as laterality indexes instead of hemispheric lateralization, the cutoff point for memory lateralization was set to the usual ±2 for WT and ±0.20 for fMRI. We also evaluated results at our Epilepsy Center.

RESULTS

Seven published series plus our own were included, comprising 124 patients. Wada test was performed by recognizing objects in half of the studies, and scenes, drawings, and words in the rest. All used scenes or pictures encoding for fMRI. Wada test-fMRI agreement across the studies ranged from 21.1 to 100%, averaging 46.8% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 37.6-56.0%). When cases with bilateral memory in either test were excluded, agreement reached 78.7% (95% CI: 67.6-89.8%), and concordance with contralateral TLE foci 86.4% for the WT and 83.0% for fMRI. Higher agreement was associated with using multiple items during WT (p = 0.001) and higher disagreement with presence of a lesion on MRI (p = 0.024). Binary logistic regression confirmed use of multiple items on WT as the strongest predictor of agreement (odds ratio [OR]: 6.95, 95% CI: 1.84-26.22; p = 0.004) and a bilateral result on the WT or fMRI of disagreement (OR: 0.24, 95% CI: 0.07-0.89 and OR: 0.12, 95% CI: 0.03-0.45; p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Concordance between WT and fMRI for memory lateralization is low in patients with TLE and bilateral memoryl memory distribution or a structural etiology, and it improves with encoding of a varied set of items. Both tests can help to lateralize the TLE foci.