Degenerative changes of the sacroiliac auricular joint surface-validation of influential factors

Mobility and anthropometry of the sacroiliac joint: range of motion and morphological characteristics

Purpose

The sacroiliac joint (SIJ), a synovial joint with irregular surfaces, is crucial for stabilizing the body and facilitating daily activities. However, recent studies have reported that 15-30% of lower back pain can be attributed to instability in the SIJ, a condition collectively referred to as sacroiliac joint dysfunction (SIJD). The aim of this study is to investigate how the morphological characteristics of the auricular surface may influence the SIJ range of motion (ROM) and to examine differences in SIJ ROM between females and males, thereby contributing to the enhancement of SIJD diagnosis and treatment.

Methods

We measured SIJ ROM using motion-analysis cameras in 24 fresh cadavers of Korean adults (13 males and 11 females). Using three-dimensional renderings of the measured auricular surface, we investigated the correlations between the morphological characteristics of the auricular surface and the ROM of the SIJ.

Results

The SIJ ROM was between 0.2° and 6.7° and was significantly greater in females (3.58° ± 1.49) compared with males (1.38° ± 1.00). Dividing the participants into high-motion (3.87° ± 1.19) and low-motion (1.13° ± 0.62) groups based on the mean ROM (2.39°) showed no significant differences in any measurements. Additionally, bone defects around the SIJ were identified using computed tomography of the high-motion group. In the low-motion group, calcification between auricular surfaces and bone bridges was observed.

Conclusion

This suggests that the SIJ ROM is influenced more by the anatomical structures around the SIJ than by the morphological characteristics of the auricular surface.

A literature review of biomechanical studies on physiological and pathological sacroiliac joints: Articular surface structure, joint motion, dysfunction and treatments

BACKGROUND

Sacroiliac joints are affected by mechanical environments; the joints are formed under mechanical stimulation, receive impact of walking between the upper and lower parts of the bodies and can be a cause of pain due to non-physiological loads. However, there are so far very few studies that reviewed biomechanics of physiological and pathological sacroiliac joints. This review article aims to describe the current sacroiliac joint biomechanics.

METHODS

Previous original papers have been summarized based on three categories: articular surface structure, sacroiliac joint motion and sacroiliac joint dysfunction and treatments.

FINDINGS

Although the articular surface morphologies vary greatly from individual to individual, many researchers have tried to classify the joints into several types. It has been suggested that the surface morphologies may not change regardless of joint dysfunction, however, the relationship between the joint structure and pain are still unclear. The range of sacroiliac joint motion is demonstrated to be less than 1 mm and there is no difference between physiological and pathological joints. The sacroiliac joint absorbs shock within the pelvis by the joint structures of pelvic morphology, ligaments and fat tissues. The morphology and motion of the sacroiliac joints may be optimized for upright bipedal walking.

INTERPRETATION

There is no doubt that pelvic mechanical environments affect pain induction and treatment; however, no one has yet provided a concrete explanation. Future research could help develop treatments based on sacroiliac joint biomechanics to support joint function.

Influence of size and shape of the auricular surfaces on subchondral bone density distribution in the sacroiliac joint

The sacroiliac auricular surface has a variable morphology and size. The impact of such variations on subchondral mineralization distribution has not been investigated. Sixty-nine datasets were subjected to CT-osteoabsorptiometry for the qualitative visualization of chronic loading conditions of the subchondral bone plate using color-mapped densitograms based on Hounsfield Units in CT. Auricular surface morphologies were classified into three types based on posterior angle size: Type 1: >160°, Type 2: 130-160° and Type 3: <130°. Auricular surface size was categorized based on the mean value (15.4 cm2 ) separating the group into 'small' and 'large' joint surfaces. Subchondral bone density patterns were qualitatively classified into four color patterns: two marginal patterns (M1 and M2) and two non-marginal patterns (N1 and N2) and each iliac and sacral surface was subsequently categorized. 'Marginal' meant that 60-70% of the surface was less mineralized compared with the highly dense regions and vice versa for the 'non-marginal' patterns. M1 had anterior border mineralization and M2 had mineralization scattered around the borders. N1 had mineralization spread over the whole superior region, N2 had mineralization spread over the superior and anterior regions. Auricular surface area averaged 15.4 ± 3.6 cm2 , with a tendency for males to have larger joint surfaces. Type 2 was the most common (75%) and type 3 the least common morphology (9%). M1 was the most common pattern (62% of surfaces) by sex (males 60%, females 64%) with the anterior border as the densest region in all three morphologies. Sacra have a majority of surfaces with patterns from the marginal group (98%). Ilia have mineralization concentrated at the anterior border (patterns M1 and N2 combined: 83%). Load distribution differences related to auricular surface morphology seems to have little effect on long-term stress-related bone adaptation visualized with CT-osteoabsorptiometry. Higher iliac side mineralization was observed in larger joint surfaces and age-related morphomechanical size alterations were seen in males.

Auricular surface morphology and surface area does not influence subchondral bone density distribution in the dysfunctional sacroiliac joint

The subchondral lamella of the sacroiliac auricular surface is morphologically inconsistent. Its morpho-mechanical relationship with dysfunction (SIJD) remains unstudied. Here, the iliac and sacral subchondral bone mineralization is compared between morphological subtypes and in large and small surfaces, in SIJD joints and controls. CT datasets from 29 patients with bilateral or unilateral SIJD were subjected to CT-osteoabsorptiometry. Surface areas and posterior angles were calculated and surfaces were classified by size: small (<15 cm³ ) and large (≥15 cm³ ), and morphological types: 1 (>160°), 2 (130°-160°), and 3 (<130°). Mineralization patterns were identified: two marginal (M1 and M2) and two non-marginal (N1 and N2). Each sacral and iliac surface was subsequently classified. Dysfunctional cohort area averaged 15.0 ± 2.4 cm² (males 16.2 ± 2.5 cm² , females 13.7 ± 1.6 cm² ). No age correlations with surface area were found nor mean Hounsfield Unit differences when comparing sizes, sexes or morphology-type. Controls and dysfunctional cohort comparison revealed differences in female sacra (p = 0.02) and small sacra (p = 0.03). There was low-conformity in marginal and non-marginal patterns, 26% for contralateral non-dysfunctional joints, and 46% for dysfunctional joints. The majority of painful joints was of type 2 morphology (59%), equally distributed between small (49%) and large joints (51%). Larger joints had the highest frequency of dysfunctional joints (72%). Auricular surface morphology seems to have little impact on pain-related subchondral lamella adaptation in SIJD. Larger joints may be predisposed to the onset of pain due to the weakening of the extracapsular structures. Dysfunctional joints reflect common conformity patterns of sacral-apex mineralization with corresponding superior corner iliac mineralization.

Sacroiliac joint degeneration is common in patients with end-stage hip osteoarthritis secondary to unilateral developmental dysplasia of the hip: Factors associated with its severity and laterality

BACKGROUND

The etiology of sacroiliac joint (SIJ) degeneration has not been fully elucidated, and there has been almost no report on the relevance between SIJ degeneration and hip osteoarthritis secondary to developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH). We investigated factors associated with SIJ degeneration, specifically its laterality in patients with end-stage hip osteoarthritis secondary to unilateral DDH.

METHODS

We included 152 patients with end-stage unilateral hip osteoarthritis secondary to DDH who underwent primary THA between January 2008 and November 2015. SIJ degeneration was classified (type 0, no degenerative change, to type 3, ankyloses) using preoperative axial computed tomography. SIJ degeneration of the DDH (shorter leg) and contralateral (longer leg) sides was compared; differences in patient demographics and radiological parameters between SIJ degeneration of type 0 or 1 versus type 2 or 3 for the shorter and longer leg sides were analyzed.

RESULTS

SIJ on the longer leg side showed more degenerative changes (p < 0.001). Substantial SIJ degeneration or ankylosis (type 2 or 3) was observed on 62.5% of longer leg sides and 33.6% of shorter leg sides. Factors significantly associated with SIJ degeneration severity were percent hip subluxation and leg length discrepancy for the longer leg side and body weight and body mass index (BMI) for the shorter leg side. Patients with worse degeneration on the shorter leg side (9.9%) had significantly larger BMI and longer sagittal vertical axis, whereas patients with worse degeneration on the longer leg side (46.7%) had significantly longer leg length discrepancy.

CONCLUSION

Severe SIJ degeneration was common in patients with end-stage hip osteoarthritis secondary to unilateral DDH. Patients with worse SIJ degeneration on the longer leg side had more hip subluxation, whereas patients with worse SIJ degeneration on the shorter leg (DDH) side tended to have sagittal spinal imbalance and greater body weight with larger BMI.

The association between sacral morphology and sacroiliac joint conformity demonstrated on CT-based bone models

INTRODUCTION

Knowledge of the stress distribution on structures around the sacroiliac joint (SIJ) is required to treat or prevent SIJ disorders. The purpose of this study was to reveal the association between sacral morphology and SIJ conformity.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This cross-sectional study included 11 adult patients with unilateral SIJ pain who underwent computed tomography (CT) imaging of the pelvis. Bony coordinate systems for the sacrum and innominates were embedded using anatomical landmarks. Local coordinate systems for the auricular surfaces of the sacrum and innominate were also defined. Conformity of the SIJ was quantified by the offset of the coordinate systems between the auricular surfaces of the sacrum and innominate. Repeated measure ANOVA and multiple regression analysis were used for statistical analyses.

RESULTS

There were large variations across subjects in sacral morphology and SIJ conformity. There were no differences in any of the six degrees-of-freedom positions or orientations of the bilateral sacral and innominate auricular surfaces between the symptomatic and asymptomatic sides. The SIJ downward rotation on the asymptomatic and symptomatic sides were 0.0 [-1.0, 1.1]° and 2.1 [1.2, 3.0]°, respectively. Smaller downward rotation of the sacral auricular surface based on the sacral bony coordinate system had significant association with the greater SIJ downward rotation (standard partial regression coefficient: -.44, p = .043).

CONCLUSIONS

The results indicate that the morphology of the sacrum is associated with poor SIJ conformity and that separation of the superior portion of the SIJ can be a risk factor for SIJ pain.

Sex-based differences in human sacroiliac joint shape: a three-dimensional morphological analysis of the iliac auricular surface of modern Japanese macerated bones

The human pelvis is one of the skeletons where sex differences are expressed, but few detailed studies have been conducted on sex-related differences in the sacroiliac joint morphology. Therefore, we conducted a three-dimensional morphological analysis evaluation of the sacroiliac joints to clarify the sex-related difference of the joint's morphology. Right-side macerated innominate bones of Japanese males (n = 100) and females (n = 70) whose ages at death were recorded were included in the study. Three-dimensional images were created from the subjects' iliac auricular surface images, and 16 measurement parameters were acquired on the basis of 11 defined measurement points. All measurement parameters were compared between the male and female groups. The values of the measurement parameters indicating the size of the iliac auricular surface were significantly larger in the male group than in the female group. In addition, the angle between the short and long arms of the auricular surface was larger in the male group. Furthermore, on the basis of the corrected values of the physical disparity, the long arm dimension of the iliac auricular surface was larger in the male group, while the short arm dimension was larger in the female group. The sex-based differences in the iliac auricular surface morphology that were confirmed in this study may reflect the sex-based differences in the sacroiliac joint function. The findings of this study may contribute to the elucidation of the pathophysiology of the sacroiliac joint dysfunction that frequently occurs in women.

Joint coordinate system for biomechanical analysis of the sacroiliac joint

Sacroiliac joint (SIJ) biomechanics have been described in both in vitro and in vivo studies. A standard for joint coordinate systems has been created by the International Society of Biomechanics for most of the joints in the human body. However, a standardized joint coordinate system for sacroiliac joint motion analysis is currently still lacking. This impedes the comparison across studies and hinders communication among scientists and clinicians. As SIJ motion is reported to be quite limited, a proper standardization and reproducibility of this procedure is essential for the interpretation of future biomechanical SIJ studies. This paper proposes a joint coordinate system for the analysis of sacroiliac joint motion, based on the procedure developed by Grood and Suntay, using semi-automated anatomical landmarks on 3D joint surfaces. This coordinate system offers high inter-rater reliability and aspires to a more intuitive representation of biomechanical data, as it is aligned with SIJ articular surfaces. This study aims to encourage further reflection and debate on biomechanical data representation, in order to facilitate interpretation of SIJ biomechanics and improve communication between researchers and clinicians. © 2019 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Orthop Res.

Three-dimensional morphological analysis of the human sacroiliac joint: influences on the degenerative changes of the auricular surfaces

The sacroiliac joint (SIJ) is responsible for weight transmission between the spine and lower extremity. However, details of the structure and function of the SIJ remain unclear. In a previous study, we devised a method of quantitatively evaluating the level of degeneration of the SIJ using an age estimation procedure for the auricular surface of the ilium. Our results in that study suggested that the degree of degeneration of the joint surface may be associated with the morphology of the auricular surface of the ilium. In that study, however, the morphology of the auricular surface of the ilium was simplified for analysis, meaning that more detailed investigations were required in future. In the present study, we focused on individual differences in the shape of SIJ and carried out three-dimensional quantitative evaluation of the morphology of the auricular surface of the ilium to ascertain its association with joint degeneration. We produced three-dimensional images of the right auricular surfaces of the ilium of 100 modern Japanese men (age 19-83), and obtained the three-dimensional rectangular coordinates of 11 defined measurement points. We then calculated 16 parameters indicating the morphological characteristics of the auricular surfaces of the ilium from the three-dimensional rectangular coordinates of these measurement points, and used these to perform principal component analysis to investigate trends in the morphology of the auricular surface of the ilium. We found that the morphology of the auricular surface of the ilium could be characterized in terms of (i) size, (ii) concavity of the posterior border and (iii) amount of undulation. An investigation of the correlation between these parameters and age suggested that the amount of undulation of the auricular surface of the ilium tends to diminish with advancing age. In an investigation of the association between morphology of the auricular surface of the ilium and degeneration of the articular surface when the subjects were divided into a high-degeneration group (n = 55) and a low-degeneration group (n = 45) and the 16 parameters were compared, there was a significant difference in the amount of undulation of the auricular surface of the ilium. In an investigation limited to older subjects aged ≥ 60 (n = 47) at the time of death, there were significant differences between the high-degeneration group (n = 27) and low-degeneration group (n = 20) in terms not only of the parameters indicating the amount of undulation of the auricular surface of the ilium but also of those indicating the amount of the concavity of the posterior border. These results suggested that the amount of undulation of the auricular surface of the ilium may affect the degree of degeneration of the articular surface. In addition, in older subjects, the degree of concavity of the posterior border of the SIJ may also affect the degree of degeneration of the articular surface. It is thus likely that differences in the morphology of the auricular surface of the ilium may affect degenerative changes in the SIJ.