Causal Measures of the Treatment Effect Captured by Candidate Surrogate Endpoints

Measuring Surrogacy in Clinical Research: With an application to studying surrogate markers for HIV Treatment-as-Prevention

In clinical research, validated surrogate markers are highly desirable in study design, monitoring, and analysis, as they do not only reduce the required sample size and follow-up duration, but also facilitate scientific discoveries. However, challenges exist to identify a reliable marker. One particular statistical challenge arises on how to measure and rank the surrogacy of potential markers quantitatively. We review the main statistical methods for evaluating surrogate markers. In addition, we suggest a new measure, the so-called "population surrogacy fraction of treatment effect," or simply the p-measure, in the setting of clinical trials. The p-measure carries an appealing population impact interpretation and supplements the existing statistical measures of surrogacy by providing "absolute" information. We apply the new measure along with other prominent measures to the HIV Prevention Trial Network 052 Study, a landmark trial for HIV/AIDS treatment-as-prevention.

Proportion of treatment effect mediated by surrogate endpoints

One of the central aims in randomized clinical trials is to find well-validated surrogate endpoints to reduce the sample size and/or duration of trials. Clinical researchers and practitioners have proposed various surrogacy measures for assessing candidate surrogate endpoints. However, most existing surrogacy measures have the following shortcomings: (i) they often fall outside the range [0,1], (ii) they are imprecisely estimated, and (iii) they ignore the interaction associations between a treatment and candidate surrogate endpoints in the evaluation of the surrogacy level. To overcome these difficulties, we propose a new surrogacy measure, the proportion of treatment effect mediated by candidate surrogate endpoints (PMS), based on the decomposition of the treatment effect into direct, indirect, and interaction associations mediated by candidate surrogate endpoints. In addition, we validate the advantages of PMS through Monte Carlo simulations and the application to empirical data from ORIENT (the Olmesartan Reducing Incidence of Endstage Renal Disease in Diabetic Nephropathy Trial).