Surface induced dissociation yields quaternary substructure of refractory noncovalent phosphorylase B and glutamate dehydrogenase complexes

Oxidized and Reduced Dimeric Protein Complexes Illustrate Contrasting CID and SID Charge Partitioning

Charge partitioning during the dissociation of protein complexes in the gas phase is influenced by many factors, such as interfacial interactions, protein flexibility, protein conformation, and dissociation methods. In the present work, two cysteine-containing homodimer proteins, β-lactoglobulin and α-lactalbumin, with the disulfide bonds intact and reduced, were used to gain insight into the charge partitioning behaviors of collision-induced dissociation (CID) and surface-induced dissociation (SID) processes. For these proteins, we find that restructuring dominates with CID and dissociation with symmetric charge partitioning dominates with SID, regardless of whether intramolecular disulfide bonds are oxidized or reduced. CID of the charge-reduced dimeric protein complex leads to a precursor with a slightly smaller collision cross section (CCS), greater stability, and more symmetrically distributed charges than the significantly expanded form produced by CID of the higher charged dimer. Collision-induced unfolding plots demonstrate that the unfolding-restructuring of the protein complexes initiates the charge migration of higher charge-state precursors. Overall, gas collisions reveal the charge-dependent restructuring/unfolding properties of the protein precursor, while surface collisions lead predominantly to more charge-symmetric monomer separation. CID's multiple low-energy collisions sequentially reorganize intra- and intermolecular bonds, while SID's large-step energy jump cleaves intermolecular interfacial bonds in preference to reorganizing intramolecular bonds. The activated population of precursors that have taken on energy without dissociating (populated in CID over a wide range of collision energies, populated in SID for only a narrow distribution of collision energies near the onset of dissociation) is expected to be restructured, regardless of the activation method.

Simulation of Energy-Resolved Mass Spectrometry Distributions from Surface-Induced Dissociation

Understanding the relationship between protein structure and experimental data is crucial for utilizing experiments to solve biochemical problems and optimizing the use of sparse experimental data for structural interpretation. Tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) can be used with a variety of methods to collect structural data for proteins. One example is surface-induced dissociation (SID), which is used to break apart protein complexes (via a surface collision) into intact subcomplexes and can be performed at multiple laboratory frame SID collision energies. These energy-resolved MS/MS experiments have shown that the profile of the breakages depends on the acceleration energy of the collision. It is possible to extract an appearance energy (AE) from energy-resolved mass spectrometry (ERMS) data, which shows the relative intensity of each type of subcomplex as a function of SID acceleration energy. We previously determined that these AE values for specific interfaces correlated with structural features related to interface strength. In this study, we further examined the structural relationships by developing a method to predict the full ERMS plot from the structure, rather than extracting a single value. First, we noted that for proteins with multiple interface types, we could reproduce the correct shapes of breakdown curves, further confirming previous structural hypotheses. Next, we demonstrated that interface size and energy density (measured using Rosetta) correlated with data derived from the ERMS plot (R² = 0.71). Furthermore, based on this trend, we used native crystal structures to predict ERMS. The majority of predictions resulted in good agreement, and the average root-mean-square error was 0.20 for the 20 complexes in our data set. We also show that if additional information on cleavage as a function of collision energy could be obtained, the accuracy of predictions improved further. Finally, we demonstrated that ERMS prediction results were better for the native than for inaccurate models in 17/20 cases. An application to run this simulation has been developed in Rosetta, which is freely available for use.

Symmetry of 4-Oxalocrotonate Tautomerase Trimers Influences Unfolding and Fragmentation in the Gas Phase

The recent discovery of asymmetric arrangements of trimers in the tautomerase superfamily (TSF) adds structural diversity to this already mechanistically diverse superfamily. Classification of asymmetric trimers has previously been determined using X-ray crystallography. Here, native mass spectrometry (MS) and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) are employed as an integrated strategy for more rapid and sensitive differentiation of symmetric and asymmetric trimers. Specifically, the unfolding of symmetric and asymmetric trimers initiated by collisional heating was probed using UVPD, which revealed unique gas-phase unfolding pathways. Variations in UVPD patterns from native-like, compact trimeric structures to unfolded, extended conformations indicate a rearrangement of higher-order structure in the asymmetric trimers that are believed to be stabilized by salt-bridge triads, which are absent from the symmetric trimers. Consequently, the symmetric trimers were found to be less stable in the gas phase, resulting in enhanced UVPD fragmentation overall and a notable difference in higher-order re-structuring based on the extent of hydrogen migration of protein fragments. The increased stability of the asymmetric trimers may justify their evolution and concomitant diversification of the TSF. Facilitating the classification of TSF members as symmetric or asymmetric trimers assists in delineating the evolutionary history of the TSF.

Native top-down mass spectrometry for higher-order structural characterization of proteins and complexes

Progress in structural biology research has led to a high demand for powerful and yet complementary analytical tools for structural characterization of proteins and protein complexes. This demand has significantly increased interest in native mass spectrometry (nMS), particularly native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS) in the past decade. This review highlights recent advances in nTDMS for structural research of biological assemblies, with a particular focus on the extra multi-layers of information enabled by TDMS. We include a short introduction of sample preparation and ionization to nMS, tandem fragmentation techniques as well as mass analyzers and software/analysis pipelines used for nTDMS. We highlight unique structural information offered by nTDMS and examples of its broad range of applications in proteins, protein-ligand interactions (metal, cofactor/drug, DNA/RNA, and protein), therapeutic antibodies and antigen-antibody complexes, membrane proteins, macromolecular machineries (ribosome, nucleosome, proteosome, and viruses), to endogenous protein complexes. The challenges, potential, along with perspectives of nTDMS methods for the analysis of proteins and protein assemblies in recombinant and biological samples are discussed.

Surface-induced Dissociation Mass Spectrometry as a Structural Biology Tool

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) is evolving into a workhorse for structural biology. The plethora of online and offline preparation, separation, and purification methods as well as numerous ionization techniques combined with powerful new hybrid ion mobility and mass spectrometry systems has illustrated the great potential of nMS for structural biology. Fundamental to the progression of nMS has been the development of novel activation methods for dissociating proteins and protein complexes to deduce primary, secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure through the combined use of multiple MS/MS technologies. This review highlights the key features and advantages of surface collisions (surface-induced dissociation, SID) for probing the connectivity of subunits within protein and nucleoprotein complexes and, in particular, for solving protein structure in conjunction with complementary techniques such as cryo-EM and computational modeling. Several case studies highlight the significant role SID, and more generally nMS, will play in structural elucidation of biological assemblies in the future as the technology becomes more widely adopted. Cases are presented where SID agrees with solved crystal or cryoEM structures or provides connectivity maps that are otherwise inaccessible by "gold standard" structural biology techniques.

Investigation of Charge-State-Dependent Compaction of Protein Ions with Native Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry and Theory

The precise relationship between native gas-phase protein ion structure, charge, desolvation, and activation remains elusive. Much evidence supports the Charge Residue Model for native protein ions formed by electrospray ionization, but scaling laws derived from it relate only to overall ion size. Closer examination of drift tube CCSs across individual native protein ion charge state distributions (CSDs) reveals deviations from global trends. To investigate whether this is due to structure variation across CSDs or contributions of long-range charge-dipole interactions, we performed in vacuo force field molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of multiple charge conformers of three proteins representing a variety of physical and structural features: β-lactoglobulin, concanavalin A, and glutamate dehydrogenase. Results from these simulated ions indicate subtle structure variation across their native CSDs, although effects of these structural differences and long-range charge-dependent interactions on CCS are small. The structure and CCS of smaller proteins may be more sensitive to charge due to their low surface-to-volume ratios and reduced capacity to compact. Secondary and higher order structure from condensed-phase structures is largely retained in these simulations, supporting the use of the term "native-like" to describe results from native ion mobility-mass spectrometry experiments, although, notably, the most compact structure can be the most different from the condensed-phase structure. Collapse of surface side chains to self-solvate through formation of new hydrogen bonds is a major feature of gas-phase compaction and likely occurs during the desolvation process. Results from these MD simulations provide new insight into the relationship of gas-phase protein ion structure, charge, and CCS.

Surface-induced dissociation of protein complexes on a cyclic ion mobility spectrometer

We describe the implementation of a simple three-electrode surface-induced dissociation (SID) cell on a cyclic ion mobility spectrometer (cIMS) and demonstrate the utility of multipass mobility separations for resolving multiple conformations of protein complexes generated during collision-induced and surface-induced unfolding (CIU & SIU) experiments. In addition to CIU and SIU, SID of protein complexes is readily accomplished within the native instrument software and with no additional external power supplies by entering a single SID collision energy, a simplification in user experience compared to prior implementations. A set of cyclic homomeric protein complexes and a heterohexamer with known CID and SID behavior were analyzed to investigate mass and mobility resolution improvements, the latter of which improved by 20-50% (median: 33%) compared to a linear travelling wave device. Multiple passes of intact complexes, or their SID fragments, increased the mobility resolution by an average of 15% per pass, with the racetrack effect being observed after ∼3 or 4 passes, depending on the drift time spread of the analytes. Even with modest improvements to apparent mobility resolving power, multipass experiments were particularly useful for separating conformations produced from CIU and SIU experiments. We illustrate several examples where either (1) multipass experiments revealed multiple overlapping conformations previously unobserved or obscured due to limited mobility resolution, or (2) CIU or SIU conformations that appeared 'native' in a single pass experiment were actually slightly compacted or expanded, with the change only being measurable through multipass experiments. The work conducted here, the first utilization of multipass cyclic ion mobility for CIU, SIU, and SID of protein assemblies and a demonstration of a wholly integrated SIU/SID workflow, paves the way for widespread adoption of SID technology for native mass spectrometry and also improves our understanding of gas-phase protein complex CIU and SIU conformationomes.

Approaches to Heterogeneity in Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is aimed at preserving and determining the native structure, composition, and stoichiometry of biomolecules and their complexes from solution after they are transferred into the gas phase. Major improvements in native MS instrumentation and experimental methods over the past few decades have led to a concomitant increase in the complexity and heterogeneity of samples that can be analyzed, including protein-ligand complexes, protein complexes with multiple coexisting stoichiometries, and membrane protein-lipid assemblies. Heterogeneous features of these biomolecular samples can be important for understanding structure and function. However, sample heterogeneity can make assignment of ion mass, charge, composition, and structure very challenging due to the overlap of tens or even hundreds of peaks in the mass spectrum. In this review, we cover data analysis, experimental, and instrumental advances and strategies aimed at solving this problem, with an in-depth discussion of theoretical and practical aspects of the use of available deconvolution algorithms and tools. We also reflect upon current challenges and provide a view of the future of this exciting field.

Surface-Induced Dissociation of Protein Complexes Selected by Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (nMS), particularly in conjunction with gas-phase ion mobility spectrometry measurements, has proven useful as a structural biology tool for evaluating the stoichiometry, conformation, and topology of protein complexes. Here, we demonstrate the combination of trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) and surface-induced dissociation (SID) on a Bruker SolariX XR 15 T FT-ICR mass spectrometer for the structural analysis of protein complexes. We successfully performed SID on mobility-selected protein complexes, including the streptavidin tetramer and cholera toxin B with bound ligands. Additionally, TIMS-SID was employed on a mixture of the peptides desArg1 and desArg9 bradykinin to mobility-separate and identify the individual peptides. Importantly, results show that native-like conformations can be maintained throughout the TIMS analysis. The TIMS-SID spectra are analogous to SID spectra acquired using quadrupole mass selection, indicating little measurable, if any, structural rearrangement during mobility selection. Mobility parking was used on the ion or mobility of interest and 50-200 SID mass spectra were averaged. High-quality TIMS-SID spectra were acquired over a period of 2-10 min, comparable to or slightly longer than SID coupled with ion mobility on various instrument platforms in our laboratory. The ultrahigh resolving power of the 15 T FT-ICR allowed for the identification and relative quantification of overlapping SID fragments with the same nominal m/z based on isotope patterns, and it shows promise as a platform to probe small mass differences, such as protein/ligand binding or post-translational modifications. These results represent the potential of TIMS-SID-MS for the analysis of both protein complexes and peptides.

Tandem surface-induced dissociation of protein complexes on an ultrahigh resolution platform

We describe instrumentation for conducting tandem surface-induced dissociation (tSID) of native protein complexes on an ultrahigh resolution Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometer. The two stages of SID are accomplished with split lenses replacing the entrance lenses of the quadrupole mass filter (stage 1, referred to herein as SID-Q) and the collision cell (stage 2, Q-SID). After SID-Q, the scattered projectile ions and subcomplexes formed in transit traverse the 20 mm pre-filter prior to the mass-selecting quadrupole, providing preliminary insights into the SID fragmentation kinetics of noncovalent protein complexes. The isolated SID fragments (subcomplexes) are then fragmented by SID in the collision cell entrance lens (Q-SID), generating subcomplexes of subcomplexes. We show that the ultrahigh resolution of the FT-ICR can be used for deconvolving species overlapping in m/z, which are particularly prominent in tandem SID spectra due to the combination of symmetric charge partitioning and narrow product ion charge state distributions. Various protein complex topologies are explored, including homotetramers, homopentamers, a homohexamer, and a heterohexamer.

Fast Molecular Compression by a Hyperthermal Collision Gives Bond-Selective Mechanochemistry

Using electrospray ion beam deposition, we collide the complex molecule Reichardt's dye (C_{41}H_{30}NO^{+}) at low, hyperthermal translational energy (2-50 eV) with a Cu(100) surface and image the outcome at single-molecule level by scanning tunneling microscopy. We observe bond-selective reaction induced by the translational kinetic energy. The collision impulse compresses the molecule and bends specific bonds, prompting them to react selectively. This dynamics drives the system to seek thermally inaccessible reactive pathways, since the compression timescale (subpicosecond) is much shorter than the thermalization timescale (nanosecond), thereby yielding reaction products that are unobtainable thermally.

Higher-order structural characterisation of native proteins and complexes by top-down mass spectrometry

In biology, it can be argued that if the genome contains the script for a cell's life cycle, then the proteome constitutes an ensemble cast of actors that brings these instructions to life. Their interactions with each other, co-factors, ligands, substrates, and so on, are key to understanding nearly any biological process. Mass spectrometry is well established as the method of choice to determine protein primary structure and location of post-translational modifications. In recent years, top-down fragmentation of intact proteins has been increasingly combined with ionisation of noncovalent assemblies under non-denaturing conditions, i.e., native mass spectrometry. Sequence, post-translational modifications, ligand/metal binding, protein folding, and complex stoichiometry can thus all be probed directly. Here, we review recent developments in this new and exciting field of research. While this work is written primarily from a mass spectrometry perspective, it is targeted to all bioanalytical scientists who are interested in applying these methods to their own biochemistry and chemical biology research.

Simple and Minimally Invasive SID Devices for Native Mass Spectrometry

We describe a set of simple devices for surface-induced dissociation of proteins and protein complexes on three instrument platforms. All of the devices use a novel yet simple split lens geometry that is minimally invasive (requiring a few millimeters along the ion path axis) and is easier to operate than prior generations of devices. The split lens is designed to be small enough to replace the entrance lens of a Bruker FT-ICR collision cell, the dynamic range enhancement (DRE) lens of a Waters Q-IM-TOF, or the exit lens of a transfer multipole of a Thermo Scientific Extended Mass Range (EMR) Orbitrap. Despite the decrease in size and reduction in number of electrodes to 3 (from 10 to 12 in Gen 1 and ∼6 in Gen 2), we show sensitivity improvement in a variety of cases across all platforms while also maintaining SID capabilities across a wide mass and energy range. The coupling of SID, high resolution, and ion mobility is demonstrated for a variety of protein complexes of varying topologies.

Population Distributions from Native Mass Spectrometry Titrations Reveal Nearest-Neighbor Cooperativity in the Ring-Shaped Oligomeric Protein TRAP

Allostery pervades macromolecular function and drives cooperative binding of ligands to macromolecules. To decipher the mechanisms of cooperative ligand binding, it is necessary to define, at a microscopic level, the thermodynamic consequences of binding of each ligand to its energetically coupled site(s). However, extracting these microscopic constants is difficult for macromolecules with more than two binding sites, because the observable [e.g., nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) chemical shift changes, fluorescence, and enthalpy] can be altered by allostery, thereby distorting its proportionality to site occupancy. Native mass spectrometry (MS) can directly quantify the populations of homo-oligomeric protein species with different numbers of bound ligands, provided the populations are proportional to ion counts and that MS-compatible electrolytes do not alter the overall thermodynamics. These measurements can help decipher allosteric mechanisms by providing unparalleled access to the statistical thermodynamic partition function. We used native MS (nMS) to study the cooperative binding of tryptophan (Trp) to Bacillus stearothermophilus trp RNA binding attenuation protein (TRAP), a ring-shaped homo-oligomeric protein complex with 11 identical binding sites. MS-compatible solutions did not significantly perturb protein structure or thermodynamics as assessed by isothermal titration calorimetry and NMR spectroscopy. Populations of Trp_n-TRAP₁₁ states were quantified as a function of Trp concentration by nMS. The population distributions could not be explained by a noncooperative binding model but were described well by a mechanistic nearest-neighbor cooperative model. Nonlinear least-squares fitting yielded microscopic thermodynamic constants that define the interactions between neighboring binding sites. This approach may be applied to quantify thermodynamic cooperativity in other ring-shaped proteins.

Ion Mobility and Surface Collisions: Submicrometer Capillaries Can Produce Native-like Protein Complexes

The use of submicrometer capillaries for nanoelectrospray ionization of native proteins and protein complexes effectively reduces the number of nonspecific salt adducts to biological molecules, therefore increasing the apparent resolution of a mass spectrometer without any further instrument modifications or increased ion activation. However, the increased interaction between proteins and the surface of the capillary has been shown to promote protein expansion and therefore loss of native structure. Here, we compare the effect of micrometer and submicrometer sized capillaries on the native structures of the protein complexes streptavidin, concanavalin A, and C-reactive protein under charge reducing conditions. We observe that the use of submicrometer capillaries did not result in a significantly higher charge state distribution, indicative of expansion, when compared to micrometer sized capillaries for complexes in 100 mM ammonium acetate and 100 mM triethylammonium acetate and for streptavidin in 200 mM ammonium acetate with no charge reduction. Additionally, no significant differences in collision cross sections were observed using ion mobility mass spectrometry. Finally, the dissociation behaviors of protein complexes ionized using micrometer and submicrometer capillaries were compared to determine if any structural perturbation occurred during ionization. Protein complexes from both capillary sizes displayed similar surface-induced dissociation patterns at similar activation energies. The results suggest that submicrometer capillaries do not result in significant changes to protein complex structure under charge reducing conditions and may be used for native mass spectrometry experiments. Submicrometer capillaries can be used to resolve small mass differences of biological systems on a QTOF platform; however, a laser tip puller is required for pulling reproducible submicrometer capillaries, and disruption in spray due to clogging was observed for larger protein complexes.

Design and Performance of a Second-Generation Surface-Induced Dissociation Cell for Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance Mass Spectrometry of Native Protein Complexes

A second-generation ("Gen 2") device capable of surface-induced dissociation (SID) and collision-induced dissociation (CID) for Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry of protein complexes has been designed, simulated, fabricated, and experimentally compared to a first-generation device ("Gen 1"). The primary goals of the redesign were to (1) simplify SID by reducing the number of electrodes, (2) increase CID and SID sensitivity by lengthening the collision cell, and (3) increase the mass range of the device for analysis of larger multimeric proteins, all while maintaining the normal instrument configuration and operation. Compared to Gen 1, Gen 2 exhibits an approximately 10× increase in sensitivity in flythrough mode, 7× increase in CID sensitivity for protonated leucine enkephalin (m/z 556), and 14× increase of CID sensitivity of 53 kDa streptavidin tetramer. It also approximately doubles the useful mass range (from m/z 8000 to m/z 15 000) using a rectilinear ion trap with a smaller inscribed radius or triples it (to m/z 22 000) using a hexapole collision cell and yields a 3-10× increase in SID sensitivity. We demonstrate the increased mass range and sensitivity on a variety of model molecules spanning nearly 3 orders of magnitude in absolute mass and present examples where the high resolution of the FT-ICR is advantageous for deconvoluting overlapping SID fragments.

Predicting Protein Complex Structure from Surface-Induced Dissociation Mass Spectrometry Data

Recently, mass spectrometry (MS) has become a viable method for elucidation of protein structure. Surface-induced dissociation (SID), colliding multiply charged protein complexes or other ions with a surface, has been paired with native MS to provide useful structural information such as connectivity and topology for many different protein complexes. We recently showed that SID gives information not only on connectivity and topology but also on relative interface strengths. However, SID has not yet been coupled with computational structure prediction methods that could use the sparse information from SID to improve the prediction of quaternary structures, i.e., how protein subunits interact with each other to form complexes. Protein-protein docking, a computational method to predict the quaternary structure of protein complexes, can be used in combination with subunit structures from X-ray crystallography and NMR in situations where it is difficult to obtain an experimental structure of an entire complex. While de novo structure prediction can be successful, many studies have shown that inclusion of experimental data can greatly increase prediction accuracy. In this study, we show that the appearance energy (AE, defined as 10% fragmentation) extracted from SID can be used in combination with Rosetta to successfully evaluate protein-protein docking poses. We developed an improved model to predict measured SID AEs and incorporated this model into a scoring function that combines the RosettaDock scoring function with a novel SID scoring term, which quantifies agreement between experiments and structures generated from RosettaDock. As a proof of principle, we tested the effectiveness of these restraints on 57 systems using ideal SID AE data (AE determined from crystal structures using the predictive model). When theoretical AEs were used, the RMSD of the selected structure improved or stayed the same in 95% of cases. When experimental SID data were incorporated on a different set of systems, the method predicted near-native structures (less than 2 Å root-mean-square deviation, RMSD, from native) for 6/9 tested cases, while unrestrained RosettaDock (without SID data) only predicted 3/9 such cases. Score versus RMSD funnel profiles were also improved when SID data were included. Additionally, we developed a confidence measure to evaluate predicted model quality in the absence of a crystal structure.

Experimental and theoretical investigation of overall energy deposition in surface-induced unfolding of protein ions

Recent advances in native mass spectrometry have enabled its use to probe the structure of and interactions within biomolecular complexes. Surface-induced dissociation, in which inter- and intramolecular interactions are disrupted following an energetic ion-surface collision, is a method that can directly interrogate the topology of protein complexes. However, a quantitative relationship between the ion kinetic energy at the moment of surface collision and the internal energy deposited into the ion has not yet been established for proteins. The factors affecting energy deposition in surface-induced unfolding (SIU) of protein monomers were investigated and a calibration relating laboratory-frame kinetic energy to internal energy developed. Protein monomers were unfolded by SIU and by collision-induced unfolding (CIU). CIU and SIU cause proteins to undergo the same unfolding transitions at different values of laboratory-frame kinetic energy. There is a strong correlation between the SIU and CIU energies, demonstrating that SIU, like CIU, can largely be understood as a thermal process. The change in internal energy in CIU was modeled using a Monte Carlo approach and theory. Computed values of the overall efficiency were found to be approximately 25% and used to rescale the CIU energy axis and relate nominal SIU energies to internal energy. The energy deposition efficiency in SIU increases with mass and kinetic energy from a low of ∼20% to a high of ∼68%, indicating that the effective mass of the surface increases along with the mass of the ion. The effect of ion structure on energy deposition was probed using multiple stages of ion activation. Energy deposition in SIU strongly depends on structure, decreasing as the protein is elongated, due to decreased effective protein-surface collisional cross section and increased transfer to rotational modes.

Surface-Induced Dissociation of Noncovalent Protein Complexes in an Extended Mass Range Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer

Native mass spectrometry continues to develop as a significant complement to traditional structural biology techniques. Within native mass spectrometry (MS), surface-induced dissociation (SID) has been shown to be a powerful activation method for the study of noncovalent complexes of biological significance. High-resolution mass spectrometers have become increasingly adapted to the analysis of high-mass ions and have demonstrated their importance in understanding how small mass changes can affect the overall structure of large biomolecular complexes. Herein we demonstrate the first adaptation of surface-induced dissociation in a modified high-mass-range, high-resolution Orbitrap mass spectrometer. The SID device was designed to be installed in the Q Exactive series of Orbitrap mass spectrometers with minimal disruption of standard functions. The performance of the SID-Orbitrap instrument has been demonstrated with several protein complex and ligand-bound protein complex systems ranging from 53 to 336 kDa. We also address the effect of ion source temperature on native protein-ligand complex ions as assessed by SID. Results are consistent with previous findings on quadrupole time-of-flight instruments and suggest that SID coupled to high-resolution MS is well-suited to provide information on the interface interactions within protein complexes and ligand-bound protein complexes.

Conditions for Analysis of Native Protein Structures Using Uniform Field Drift Tube Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry and Characterization of Stable Calibrants for TWIM-MS

Determination of collisional cross sections (CCS) by travelling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry (TWIM-MS) requires calibration against standards for which the CCS has been measured previously by drift tube ion mobility mass spectrometry (DTIM-MS). The different extents of collisional activation in TWIM-MS and DTIM-MS can give rise to discrepancies in the CCS of calibrants across the two platforms. Furthermore, the conditions required to ionize and transmit large, folded proteins and assemblies may variably affect the structure of the calibrants and analytes. Stable hetero-oligomeric phospholipase A₂ (PDx) and its subunits were characterized as calibrants for TWIM-MS. Conditions for acquisition of native-like TWIM (Synapt G1 HDMS) and DTIM (Agilent 6560 IM-Q-TOF) mass spectra were optimized to ensure the spectra exhibited similar charge state distributions. CCS measurements (DTIM-MS) for ubiquitin, cytochrome c, holo-myoglobin, serum albumin and glutamate dehydrogenase were in good agreement with other recent results determined using this and other DTIM-MS instruments. PDx and its β and γ subunits were stable across a wide range of cone and trap voltages in TWIM-MS and were stable in the presence of organic solvents. The CCS of PDx and its subunits were determined by DTIM-MS and were used as calibrants in determination of CCS of native-like cytochrome c, holo-myoglobin, carbonic anhydrase, serum albumin and haemoglobin in TWIM-MS. The CCS values were in good agreement with those measured by DTIM-MS where available. These experiments demonstrate conditions for analysis of native-like proteins using a commercially available DTIM-MS instrument, characterize robust calibrants for TWIM-MS, and present CCS values determined by DTIM-MS and TWIM-MS for native proteins to add to the current literature database. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

An integrated native mass spectrometry and top-down proteomics method that connects sequence to structure and function of macromolecular complexes

Mass spectrometry (MS) has become a crucial technique for the analysis of protein complexes. Native MS has traditionally examined protein subunit arrangements, while proteomics MS has focused on sequence identification. These two techniques are usually performed separately without taking advantage of the synergies between them. Here we describe the development of an integrated native MS and top-down proteomics method using Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) to analyse macromolecular protein complexes in a single experiment. We address previous concerns of employing FTICR MS to measure large macromolecular complexes by demonstrating the detection of complexes up to 1.8 MDa, and we demonstrate the efficacy of this technique for direct acquirement of sequence to higher-order structural information with several large complexes. We then summarize the unique functionalities of different activation/dissociation techniques. The platform expands the ability of MS to integrate proteomics and structural biology to provide insights into protein structure, function and regulation.

Ion Mobility Collision Cross Section Compendium

In this review, we focus on an important aspect of ion mobility (IM) research, namely the reporting of quantitative ion mobility measurements in the form of the gas-phase collision cross section (CCS), which has provided a common basis for comparison across different instrument platforms and offers a unique form of structural information, namely size and shape preferences of analytes in the absence of bulk solvent. This review surveys the over 24,000 CCS values reported from IM methods spanning the era between 1975 to 2015, which provides both a historical and analytical context for the contributions made thus far, as well as insight into the future directions that quantitative ion mobility measurements will have in the analytical sciences. The analysis was conducted in 2016, so CCS values reported in that year are purposely omitted. In another few years, a review of this scope will be intractable, as the number of CCS values which will be reported in the next three to five years is expected to exceed the total amount currently published in the literature.

Salt Bridge Rearrangement (SaBRe) Explains the Dissociation Behavior of Noncovalent Complexes

Native electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry, with gas-phase activation and solution compositions that partially release subcomplexes, can elucidate topologies of macromolecular assemblies. That so much complexity can be preserved in gas-phase assemblies is remarkable, although a long-standing conundrum has been the differences between their gas- and solution-phase decompositions. Collision-induced dissociation of multimeric noncovalent complexes typically distributes products asymmetrically (i.e., by ejecting a single subunit bearing a large percentage of the excess charge). That unexpected behavior has been rationalized as one subunit "unfolding" to depart with more charge. We present an alternative explanation based on heterolytic ion-pair scission and rearrangement, a mechanism that inherently partitions charge asymmetrically. Excessive barriers to dissociation are circumvented in this manner, when local charge rearrangements access a lower-barrier surface. An implication of this ion pair consideration is that stability differences between high- and low-charge state ions usually attributed to Coulomb repulsion may, alternatively, be conveyed by attractive forces from ion pairs (salt bridges) stabilizing low-charge state ions. Should the number of ion pairs be roughly inversely related to charge, symmetric dissociations would be favored from highly charged complexes, as observed. Correlations between a gas-phase protein's size and charge reflect the quantity of restraining ion pairs. Collisionally-facilitated salt bridge rearrangement (SaBRe) may explain unusual size "contractions" seen for some activated, low charge state complexes. That some low-charged multimers preferentially cleave covalent bonds or shed small ions to disrupting noncovalent associations is also explained by greater ion pairing in low charge state complexes. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Ion Mobility Spectrometry-Hydrogen Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry of Anions: Part 3. Estimating Surface Area Exposure by Deuterium Uptake

Gas-phase hydrogen deuterium exchange (HDX), collision cross section (CCS) measurement, and molecular dynamics simulation (MDS) techniques were utilized to develop and compare three methods for estimating the relative surface area exposure of separate peptide chains within bovine insulin ions. Electrosprayed [M - 3H](3-) and [M - 5H](5-) insulin ions produced a single conformer type with respective collision cross sections of 528 ± 5 Å(2) and 808 ± 2 Å(2). [M - 4H](4-) ions were comprised of more compact (Ω = 676 ± 3 Å(2)) and diffuse (i.e., more elongated, Ω = 779 ± 3 Å(2)) ion conformer types. Ions were subjected to HDX in the drift tube using D2O as the reagent gas. Collision-induced dissociation was used to fragment mobility-selected, isotopically labeled [M - 4H](4-) and [M - 5H](5-) ions into the protein subchains. Deuterium uptake levels of each chain can be explained by limited inter-chain isotopic scrambling upon collisional activation. Using nominal ion structures from MDS and a hydrogen accessibility model, the deuterium uptake for each chain was correlated to its exposed surface area. In separate experiments, the per-residue deuterium content for the protonated and deprotonated ions of the synthetic peptide KKDDDDDIIKIIK were compared. The differences in deuterium content indicated the regional HDX accessibility for cations versus anions. Using ions of similar conformational type, this comparison highlights the complementary nature of HDX data obtained from positive- and negative-ion analysis.

Refining the Structural Model of a Heterohexameric Protein Complex: Surface Induced Dissociation and Ion Mobility Provide Key Connectivity and Topology Information

Toyocamycin nitrile hydratase (TNH) is a protein hexamer that catalyzes the hydration of toyocamycin to produce sangivamycin. The structure of hexameric TNH and the arrangement of subunits within the complex, however, have not been solved by NMR or X-ray crystallography. Native mass spectrometry (MS) clearly shows that TNH is composed of two copies each of the α, β, and γ subunits. Previous surface induced dissociation (SID) tandem mass spectrometry on a quadrupole time-of-flight (QTOF) platform suggests that the TNH hexamer is a dimer composed of two αβγ trimers; furthermore, the results suggest that α-β interact most strongly (Blackwell et al. Anal. Chem. 2011, 83, 2862-2865). Here, multiple complementary MS based approaches and homology modeling have been applied to refine the structure of TNH. Solution-phase organic solvent disruption coupled with native MS agrees with the previous SID results. By coupling surface induced dissociation with ion mobility mass spectrometry (SID/IM), further information on the intersubunit contacts and relative interfacial strengths are obtained. The results show that TNH is a dimer of αβγ trimers, that within the trimer the α, β subunits bind most strongly, and that the primary contact between the two trimers is through a γ-γ interface. Collisional cross sections (CCSs) measured from IM experiments are used as constraints for postulating the arrangement of the subunits represented by coarse-grained spheres. Covalent labeling (surface mapping) together with protein complex homology modeling and docking of trimers to form hexamer are utilized with all the above information to propose the likely quaternary structure of TNH, with chemical cross-linking providing cross-links consistent with the proposed structure. The novel feature of this approach is the use of SID-MS with ion mobility to define complete connectivity and relative interfacial areas of a heterohexameric protein complex, providing much more information than is available from solution disruption. That information, when combined with CCS-guided coarse-grained modeling and covalent labeling restraints for homology modeling and trimer-trimer docking, provides atomic models of a previously uncharacterized heterohexameric protein complex.

Analysis of Native-Like Proteins and Protein Complexes Using Cation to Anion Proton Transfer Reactions (CAPTR)

Mass spectra of native-like protein complexes often exhibit narrow charge-state distributions, broad peaks, and contributions from multiple, coexisting species. These factors can make it challenging to interpret those spectra, particularly for mixtures with significant heterogeneity. Here we demonstrate the use of ion/ion proton transfer reactions to reduce the charge states of m/z-selected, native-like ions of proteins and protein complexes, a technique that we refer to as cation to anion proton transfer reactions (CAPTR). We then demonstrate that CAPTR can increase the accuracy of charge state assignments and the resolution of interfering species in native mass spectrometry. The CAPTR product ion spectra for pyruvate kinase exhibit ~30 peaks and enable unambiguous determination of the charge state of each peak, whereas the corresponding precursor spectra exhibit ~6 peaks and the assigned charge states have an uncertainty of ±3%. 15+ bovine serum albumin and 21+ yeast enolase dimer both appear near m/z 4450 and are completely unresolved in a mixture. After a single CAPTR event, the resulting product ions are baseline resolved. The separation of the product ions increases dramatically after each subsequent CAPTR event; 12 events resulted in a 3000-fold improvement in separation relative to the precursor ions. Finally, we introduce a framework for interpreting and predicting the figures of merit for CAPTR experiments. More generally, these results suggest that CAPTR strongly complements other mass spectrometry tools for analyzing proteins and protein complexes, particularly those in mixtures. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Characterization of native protein complexes using ultraviolet photodissociation mass spectrometry

Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) mass spectrometry (MS) was used to characterize the sequences of proteins in native protein-ligand and protein-protein complexes and to provide auxiliary information about the binding sites of the ligands and protein-protein interfaces. UVPD outperformed collisional induced dissociation (CID), higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD), and electron transfer dissociation (ETD) in terms of yielding the most comprehensive diagnostic primary sequence information about the proteins in the complexes. UVPD also generated noncovalent fragment ions containing a portion of the protein still bound to the ligand which revealed some insight into the nature of the binding sites of myoglobin/heme, eIF4E/m(7)GTP, and human peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase 1 (Pin1) in complex with the peptide derived from the C-terminal domain of RNA polymerase II (CTD). Noncovalently bound protein-protein fragment ions from oligomeric β-lactoglobulin dimers and hexameric insulin complexes were also produced upon UVPD, providing some illumination of tertiary and quaternary protein structural features.

Surface induced dissociation: dissecting noncovalent protein complexes in the gas phase

The quaternary structures of proteins are both important and of interest to chemists, because many proteins exist as complexes in vivo, and probing these structures allows us to better understand their biological functions. Conventional structural biology methods such as X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance provide high-resolution information on the structures of protein complexes and are the gold standards in the field. However, other emerging biophysical methods that only provide low-resolution data (e.g. stoichiometry and subunit connectivity) on the structures of the protein complexes are also becoming more important to scientists. Mass spectrometry is one of these approaches that provide lower than atomic structural resolution, but the approach is higher throughput and provides not only better mass information than other techniques but also stoichiometry and topology. Fragile noncovalent interactions within the protein complexes can be preserved in the gas phase of MS under gentle ionization and transfer conditions. Scientists can measure the masses of the complexes with high confidence to reveal the stoichiometry and composition of the proteins. What makes mass spectrometry an even more powerful method is that researchers can further isolate the protein complexes and activate them in the gas phase to release subunits for more structural information. The caveat is that, upon gas-phase activation, the released subunits need to faithfully reflect the native topology so that useful information on the proteins can be extracted from mass spectrometry experiments. Unfortunately, many proteins tend to favor unfolding upon collision with neutral gas (the most common activation method in mass spectrometers). Therefore, this typically results in limited insights on the quaternary structure of the precursor without further manipulation of other experimental factors. Scientists have observed, however, that valuable structural information can be obtained when the gas-phase proteins are activated by collision with a surface. Subcomplexes released after surface collision are consistent with the native quaternary structure of several protein systems studied, even for a large chaperone protein, GroEL, that approaches megadalton mass. The unique and meaningful data generated from surface induced dissociation (SID) have been attributed to the fast and energetic activation process upon collision with a massive target, the surface. In this Account, we summarize our SID studies of protein complexes, with emphasis on the more recent work on the combination of ion mobility (IM) with SID. IM has gained popularity over the years not only as a gas-phase separation technique but also as a technique with the ability to measure the size and shape of the proteins in the gas phase. Incorporation of IM before SID allows different conformations of a protein to be separated and examined individually by SID for structural details. When IM is after SID, the cross sections of the SID products can be measured, providing insight on the dissociation pathways, which may mimic disassembly pathways. Furthermore, the separation by IM greatly reduces the peak overlapping (same m/z) and coalescence (merging) of SID products, improving the resolving power of the method. While there are still many unanswered questions on the fundamental properties of gas-phase proteins and a need for further research, our work has shown that SID can be a complementary gas-phase tool providing useful information for studying quaternary structures of noncovalent protein complexes.