Cognitive stress and cardiovascular reactivity. I. Relationship to hypertension

"Close your eyes and relax": the role of hypnosis in reducing anxiety, and its implications for the prevention of cardiovascular diseases

Anxiety is the most common form of mental health disorder, affecting millions of people worldwide. Psychosocial interventions such as mindfulness and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) have been suggested as an effective treatment in the management of general anxiety and anxiety disorders, with emerging evidence also suggesting the effectiveness of hypnosis. Moreover, anxiety has shown to be linked to the onset and development of several cardiovascular diseases (CVD), which are the leading cause of global death. In this paper, we review the current literature to examine the role that anxiety has on the onset and development of CVD and summarize the current knowledge on the role that hypnosis and hypnotherapy have in reducing anxiety, also explaining how this can impact the cardiovascular system and the prevention of CVD. Review of the evidence suggests that hypnosis and hypnotherapy are effective in treating anxiety and may positively affect the heart and the cardiovascular system, reducing sympathetic activation and increasing parasympathetic tone, potentially preventing the onset of CVD related to increased sympathetic activation. However, further studies are required to further understand how hypnosis and hypnotherapy affect the cardiovascular system through investigation of the neurophysiological components of the hypnotic state and of the mind-body relationship. Healthcare systems should embed mental health screening in patients at risk of developing CVD as part of the clinical pathway and consider the role that hypnosis and hypnotherapy may play in the management of CVD.

Cerebrovascular function in hypertension: Does high blood pressure make you old?

The majority of individuals over an age of 60 have hypertension. Elevated blood pressure and older age are associated with very similar changes in brain structure and function. We review the parallel brain changes associated with increasing age and blood pressure. This review focuses on joint associations of aging and elevated blood pressure with neuropsychological function, regional cerebral blood flow responses to cognitive and metabolic challenges, white matter disruptions, grey matter volume, cortical thinning, and neurovascular coupling. Treatment of hypertension ameliorates many of these changes but fails to reverse them. Treatment of hypertension itself appears more successful with better initial brain function. We show evidence that sympathetic and renal influences known to increase blood pressure also impact brain integrity. Possible central mechanisms contributing to the course of hypertension and aging are then suggested. An emphasis is placed on psychologically relevant factors: stress, cardiovascular reactions to stress, and diet/obesity. The contribution of some of these factors to biological aging remains unclear and may provide a starting point for defining the independent and interacting effects of aging and increasing blood pressure on the brain.

Psychological stress reactivity and future health and disease outcomes: A systematic review of prospective evidence

BACKGROUND

Acute psychological stress activates the sympatho-adrenal medullary (SAM) system and hypothalamo-pituitary adrenal (HPA) axis. The relevance of this stress reactivity to long-term health and disease outcomes is of great importance. We examined prospective studies in apparently healthy adults to test the hypothesis that the magnitude of the response to acute psychological stress in healthy adults is related to future health and disease outcomes.

METHODS

We searched Medline Complete, PsycINFO, CINAHL Complete and Embase up to 15 Aug 2019. Included studies were peer-reviewed, English-language, prospective studies in apparently healthy adults. The exposure was acute psychological stress reactivity (SAM system or HPA axis) at baseline. The outcome was any health or disease outcome at follow-up after ≥1 year.

RESULTS

We identified 1719 papers through database searching and 1 additional paper through other sources. Forty-seven papers met our criteria including 32,866 participants (range 30-4100) with 1-23 years of follow-up. Overall, one third (32 %; 83/263) of all reported findings were significant and two thirds (68 %; 180/263) were null. With regard to the significant findings, both exaggerated (i.e. high) and blunted (i.e. low) stress reactivity of both the SAM system and the HPA axis at baseline were related to health and disease outcomes at follow-up. Exaggerated stress reactivity at baseline predicted an increase in risk factors for cardiovascular disease and decreased telomere length at follow-up. In contrast, blunted stress reactivity predicted future increased adiposity and obesity, more depression, anxiety and PTSD symptoms, greater illness frequency, musculoskeletal pain and regulatory T-Cell percentage, poorer cognitive ability, poorer self-reported health and physical disability and lower bone mass.

CONCLUSION

Exaggerated and blunted SAM system and HPA axis stress reactivity predicted distinct physical and mental health and disease outcomes over time. Results from prospective studies consistently indicate stress reactivity as a predictor for future health and disease outcomes. Dysregulation of stress reactivity may represent a mechanism by which psychological stress contributes to the development of future health and disease outcomes.

[Sympatho-vagal balance and cardiac response to mental challenge]

BACKGROUND

Based on functional relations between the central autonomic network and cortical areas involved in motivational, attentional, affective, and executive function, autonomic regulation can mediate cognitive performance as well as cardiovascular and psychosomatic diseases. Our objective was to test the predictive value of resting heart rate variability (HRV), a measure of sympatho-vagal balance, with regard to the type and intensity of cardiovascular responses to mental challenge.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 248 healthy subjects (85 females, aged 47.3+/-7.6 years; 163 males, aged 47.5+/-6.7 years) were included in the study. All participants underwent standardized psychometric testing (e.g., Stroop's color-word-conflict test).

RESULTS

First, we found significant increases of heart rate and sympatho-vagal balance (low frequency/high frequency) and significant decreases of absolute LF- and HF-power in response to mental tasks. Second, there were significant differences in cardiovascular response to mental challenge when clustering our population on the basis of sympatho-vagal balance at rest.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that short-term recordings of HRV can provide health-related information of cardio-vascular response to mental challenge. However, there is no association between sympatho-vagal balance at rest and classical cardiovascular risk factors.

Differences between men and women on the waiting list for coronary revascularization

This study aims to examine the situation for patients on the waiting list for possible coronary revascularization in terms of waiting time, treatment and various aspects of well-being in relation to gender. Patients on the waiting list for coronary angiography, percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty or coronary artery bypass grafting in September 1990 were approached with a questionnaire dealing with various aspects as described above. Of the 831 patients who participated in the evaluation, 174 (21%) were women. Although age was similar for men and women, men had a higher prevalence of previous myocardial infarction and a lower prevalence of previous hypertension. In terms of medication, women were more frequently treated with diuretics and sedatives than men. Women reported a higher frequency than men with regard to the following symptoms: chest pain at rest and at night, dyspnoea when walking, tachycardia, tiredness, headache, dizziness and sweating. Women also suffered more frequently from difficulty going to sleep, difficulty waking up, repeated awakening and insomnia. Men, on the other hand, suffered more frequently from restlessness, inability to act and irritability. Among patients on the waiting list for possible coronary revascularization, women differed from men by being more frequently treated with diuretics, reporting a higher frequency of various cardiovascular symptoms including chest pain and dyspnoea and, furthermore, reporting more sleeping disorders. Gender differences were found but they were not consistent.

Reproducibility of exercise-induced modulation of cardiovascular responses to cold stress

The modulation of cardiovascular responses to the cold pressor test (CPT) as produced by exercise was studied in 13 volunteers. The reproducibility of the measurements selected for the study, i.e. heart rate (HR), blood pressure (BP), blood flow (BF) and skin temperature (ST), was investigated through repeat experiments in the fall of 1994 and the winter of 1995. HR was monitored before, during and after a 10-min period of bicycling at 70% of reserve HR. BP, cutaneous BF and ST were measured before and after exercise. Two CPTs (hand into ice-cold water for 1 min) were performed: one preceding exercise and another at 3 min after exercise. The results obtained allow us to conclude that in non-hypertensive volunteers (1) the pronounced cardiovascular responses (ST, BF and BP) induced by CPT are reproducible (p > 0.2) when compared to basal level values and (2) cardiovascular responses to cold stress are significantly attenuated by exercise (p < 0.03). Our study, therefore, supports and validates the use of our coupled exercise-CPT method in ongoing epidemiological studies attempting to identify individuals at risk for the development of hypertension as well as those most likely to benefit from preventative exercise programs.

Differences in pulse rate and heart rate and effects on the calculation of heart rate reactivity during periods of mental stress

Heart rate and reactivity from pulse and ECG were compared over rest and mental arithmetic periods of 2-min duration each for 32 males and 50 females. Data from the two sources of heart rate were not significantly different during the rest period but did differ significantly during periods of heart rate acceleration and deceleration. Sex effects were also noted, with females having consistently higher heart rates from both sources of measurement. Calculation of heart rate reactivity via five procedures based upon the wider literature revealed significant differences between data from different sources of heart rate. Implications for assessment of heart rate reactivity to laboratory stressors are discussed, with suggestions for future research.

Familial influences on heart rate, blood pressure, and self-report anxiety responses to stress: results from 100 twin pairs

Two hundred healthy adolescent to middle-aged individuals (12-44 years, M = 20 years) were tested in a standardized stress protocol. These individuals comprised 20 monozygotic female, 20 monozygotic male, 20 same-sex dizygotic female, 20 same-sex dizygotic male, and 20 opposite-sex dizygotic twin pairs. Familial influences on heart rate, blood pressure, and self-report anxiety responses to four different kinds of stressors (Visual-Verbal Test for Conceptual Thought, mental arithmetic, isometric handgrip, cold pressor) were assessed using biometrical genetic model fitting. Evidence of significant genetic effects on resting heart rate and blood pressure was obtained, providing heritability estimates of .65, .63, and .58 for resting heart rate and systolic and diastolic blood pressure, respectively. Cardiovascular reactivity to the Visual-Verbal Test, mental arithmetic, and the cold pressor test appeared to be primarily influenced by genetic and idiosyncratic (nonfamilial) environmental factors, whereas reactivity to handgrip was more related to effects of the family environment. The results of multivariate model fitting suggested that the genetic effects on reactivity were relatively independent of those affecting resting heart rate and blood pressure and that there was significant overlap of genetic influences on heart rate and blood pressure responses to the two active coping tasks.

Cardiac response of trained and untrained males to a repeated psychological stressor

The authors examined cardiac response to repeated exposure to a psychological stressor of aerobically conditioned (n = 15) and unconditioned subjects (n = 15). Heart rate and electrocardiographic T-wave amplitude responses of 10 trials of the Stroop Test were monitored during and after performance. Both groups' adaptation patterns were similar, with a plateauing of heart rate response after the third trial. Compared with the unconditioned group, however, the aerobically conditioned subjects recorded lower absolute heart rate responses during and after the stressor for every trial. Relative heart rate responses during the stressor and recovery were similar for both groups. There was also no difference between groups in T-wave response during or after the stressor. These data suggest that absolute heart rate response during and after repeated exposure to a psychological stressor is lower for aerobically trained individuals.

Effects of psychological stress on cold pressor test results

The authors evaluated the incidence of a psychological stressor in the modification of blood pressure induced by the cold pressor test in normotensive and medicated hypertensive subjects. The study was carried out in two stages: In the first, 28 (14 normotensive and 14 hypertensive) subjects were administered a cold pressor test. Fifteen days later, 14 subjects repeated the same experiment. The remaining 14 subjects (7 hypertensive and 7 normotensive) also repeated the cold pressor test, with the difference that, to add a stressful psychological situation, the physician "abandoned" them at the beginning. The addition of the psychological stress significantly increased only systolic blood pressure in both the hypertensive and the normotensive subjects. Furthermore, the hypertensive subjects did not recover their basal blood pressure values following the cold pressor test when the psychologically stressful situation had been added. These results show the importance of considering psychological aspects when applying physical pressor tests.

The effect of participation in an exercise training program on cardiovascular reactivity in sedentary middle-aged males

Exaggerated cardiovascular reactivity to mental stressors may be a risk factor for cardiovascular disease. To determine if participation in a moderate intensity aerobic exercise training program reduces cardiovascular reactivity to laboratory stressors, 40 sedentary middle-aged males were randomly assigned: training group (n = 25) and control group (n = 15). Cardiovascular reactivity during and after three mental stressors (passive responding, push-button Stroop and verbal Stroop) and mild exercise (bicycle ergometer) was assessed before and after an 8-week intervention. VO2(peak) was determined using the Balke protocol. Among 19 subjects who completed the training, VO2(peak) increased 13.7%. Also, trained compared to untrained subjects showed significant reductions in baseline and absolute heart rate responses to all stressors. Baseline adjusted heart rates were significantly lower during push-button Stroop recovery and during verbal Stroop. Blood pressure, T-wave amplitude, finger pulse amplitude and pulse transit time responses were unaffected by exercise training. It was concluded that participation in a short-term, moderate intensity aerobic exercise training program may have a cardioprotective effect by significantly reducing absolute and baseline-adjusted heart rate responses to stressors.

Haemodynamic findings and response rates to beta-blocker--and diuretic monotherapy in mild and moderate hypertension. A one year randomized, double blind study in 100 men

In a randomized double blind study 100 men (mean age 46 (22-64) years) with mild to moderate hypertension were followed every 3rd month for one year. Fifty were randomized to atenolol 50 mg and 50 to hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg+amiloride 5 mg (co-amiloride) once daily. The doses were doubled at 3 or 6 months if diastolic blood pressure (DBP) remained > or = 95 mmHg. If DBP was > or = 95 mmHg even at 6 or 9 months, patients were classified as non-responders, and nifedipine 20 mg b.i.d. was added. After one year 31/50 randomized to atenolol and 17/50 randomized to co-amiloride had responded to monotherapy (p < 0.05). Neither clinical findings nor haemodynamic measurements by Doppler at baseline could distinguish between co-amiloride responders and non-responders. Conversely, non-responders to atenolol as compared with atenolol responders had higher body weight (p = 0.02), higher systolic BP (p = 0.03), higher DBP (p = 0.009), stroke volume (p = 0.04), and cardiac output (p = 0.0002) combined with lower total systemic vascular resistance (p = 0.02). This suggests that some were apparent non-responders due to too low dosing of atenolol rather than true non-responders. Measurements of haemodynamics may be of importance in the assessment of optimal antihypertensive therapy according to baseline and follow-up haemodynamic aberrations.

The long-term reproducibility of clinical tests of autonomic cardiovascular function in normal man

Tests for the integrity of autonomic cardiovascular reflexes have been widely used in the clinic and in space physiology for decades. However, whereas some information on the short-term reproducibility of such tests are available, little is known about their long-term reproducibility. The work in this study was, therefore, directed towards assessing intra- and inter-subject variations in responses (heart rate, mean arterial blood pressure, forearm blood flow and forearm vascular conductance) to cortical arousal, cold face stimulation and lower body negative pressure (at 10, 30 and 50 mmHg) in eleven healthy male subjects (aged between 22 and 45 years). Subjects were studied repeatedly (each month) over a 6-month period. It was found that forearm vascular conductance responses to cold face stimulation were the most reproducible (mean coefficient of variation 10.9%), and with diminishing reproducibility curve responses to lower body negative pressure at 50 mmHg (mean coefficient of variation 12.4%), lower body negative pressure at 30 mmHg (mean coefficient of variation 18.9%), lower body negative pressure at 10 mmHg (mean coefficient of variation 28.0%), and responses to cortical arousal (mean coefficient of variation 39.6%). Generally, subjects who showed the largest responses to cold face stimulation also showed the largest responses to the other tests, and vice versa. It is concluded that there is intra-individual variability in the responsiveness and reproducibility of cardiovascular tests and that the cardiovascular responses to cold face stimulation and lower body negative pressure at 50 mmHg are the most reproducible.

Critical review: the health significance of environmental odor pollution

Environmental odor pollution problems generate a significant fraction of the publicly initiated complaints received by air pollution control districts. Such complaints can trigger a variety of enforcement activities under existing state and local statutes. However, because of the frequently transient timing of exposures, odor sources often elude successful abatement. Furthermore, because of the predominantly subjective nature of associated health complaints, air pollution control authorities may predicate their enforcement activities upon a judgment of the public health impact of the odor source. Noxious environmental odors may trigger symptoms by a variety of physiologic mechanisms, including exacerbation of underlying medical conditions, innate odor aversions, aversive conditioning phenomena, stress-induced illness, and possible pheromonal reactions. Whereas relatively consistent patterns of subjective symptoms have been reported among individuals who live near environmental odor sources, documentation of objective correlates to such symptoms would require as-yet unproven research tools. Therefore, given our current state of knowledge, any differential regulatory response to environmental odor pollution, which is based upon the distinction between community "annoyance reactions" and "health effects," is a matter of legal--not scientific--interpretation.

Follow-Up of a Respiratory Rate Modulated Pacemaker

The efficacy of 27 respiration sensitive rate modulated pacemakers (Biorate RDP-3 Biotec) implanted in the left pectoral area was evaluated every 3 months during a mean follow-up period of 29 months (range 10-50 months). Rate modulation function was unchanged other than for three patients in whom the auxiliary leads became displaced. Two implants lost ventricular sensing in this nonprogrammable model. In all but the three patients, Holter monitoring demonstrated pacing rate variation corresponding to daily activity. Stress test duration increased from 8.2 +/- 1.5 minutes (in fixed rate VVI rate) to 12.83 +/- 2.0 minutes (in the VVIR mode) (P less than 0.05). Right arm movement increased the pacing rate by 5 +/- 3 beats/min (NS), while the left arm movement increase was 30 +/- 5 beats/min (P less than 0.05). Mental, arithmetic, and nifedipine tests did not change the rate modulated pacing rate. The system responded to a change in respiratory rate by an increase in stimulation rate. A satisfactory response in sensitivity and velocity was present only with medium-high workloads. Interference with rate modulation occurred with movement of the arm ipsilateral to the implanted pulse generator.

Effects of caffeine on pressor regulation during rest and exercise in men at risk for hypertension

Caffeine-induced blood pressure elevations are well documented in habitual consumers, occurring through both vasoconstrictive and cardiostimulatory actions. Whether caffeine hinders pressor regulation during exercise has been uncertain, particularly in those at risk for hypertension. Thus effects of caffeine versus placebo were studied during supine bicycle exercise in healthy men (ages 20 to 35). Hypertension risk was defined during screening: high risk (HRISK) = 135 to 154/85 to 94 mm Hg plus parental hypertension (n = 20); low risk (LRISK) = less than or equal to 132/84 mm Hg and no parental hypertension (n = 14). Exaggerated pressor responses (greater than or equal to 230/100 mm Hg) seen during exercise after placebo identified a subgroup of seven HRISKs indistinguishable at rest from the remaining HRISK men. This subgroup showed a larger resting diastolic response to caffeine (p less than 0.05) than LRISKs and other HRISKs. Compared with placebo, caffeine increased the number of LRISK (0% to 36%) and HRISK (35% to 50%) men reaching abnormal exercise blood pressures, and blunted normal increments in cardiac index at higher workloads among HRISK men (p = 0.05). Thus restriction of caffeine before exercise might benefit persons with either risk for hypertension or unusual sensitivity to caffeine.

A comparison of two automated monitors in the measurement of blood pressure reactivity. Trials of Hypertension Prevention Collaborative Research Group

Cardiovascular reactivity is the change in blood pressure, pulse, and other parameters of cardiovascular function in response to a challenging task. During the conduct of cardiovascular reactivity protocols, researchers frequently use automated blood pressure devices to measure blood pressure reactivity. However, the accuracy of automated devices in measuring blood pressure reactivity is unknown. To investigate the accuracy and precision of the Dinamap 1846 SXP and the VitaStat 2600B in the measurement of blood pressure reactivity, we compared blood pressure reactivity recorded by the VitaStat and Dinamap with that obtained by observers using a conventional mercury sphygmomanometer. At three sites, 159 normotensive subjects performed the same task twice, once with blood pressure reactivity measured by the manual observers and once by the VitaStat (n = 79) or Dinamap (n = 80), with the order determined at random. Ratios (VitaStat/Dinamap) of aggregate within-person variance for baseline and task, systolic and diastolic blood pressures ranged from 1.53 to 4.93 (all P < 0.01), suggesting that the Dinamap has better precision than the VitaStat. For both diastolic and systolic blood pressure reactivity and for both types of automated devices, the mean differences in blood pressure reactivity between manual and automated measurements were small (range, -1.8 to 0.8 mm Hg). However, the VitaStat versus manual scatter plot of diastolic blood pressure reactivity showed greater dispersion (correlation coefficient r = 0.16, P = 0.15) than the Dinamap versus manual scatter plot (r = 0.36, P = 0.001). For systolic blood pressure reactivity, the VitaStat versus manual and Dinamap versus manual scatter plots were similar. Our data indicate that the Dinamap is superior to the VitaStat in the measurement of blood pressure reactivity. The substantial performance differences between the VitaStat and Dinamap suggest that other automated blood pressure monitors must be evaluated prior to use in cardiovascular reactivity studies.

Cardiovascular reactivity and smoking in coronary prone (type A) and non-coronary prone (type B) subjects

Twenty-nine Type A subjects, (greater than 75 percentile on the Jenkins Activity Survey) and 28 Type B's (less than 25 percentile of Jenkins) were asked to smoke 1 cigarette (1.0 mg nicotine, 16 mg tar, 14 mg CO) using a standardized smoking procedure. The results showed that both Type A and B subjects experienced significant smoking induced changes in heart rate, skin temperature and pulse transit time. An analysis of covariance also revealed that the Type A subjects exhibited greater heart rate reactivity due to smoking than their type B counter parts. The results are discussed in terms of the possible role of cardiovascular reactivity in the mediation of the subjective and behavioral effects of smoking in the type A individual.

Heart rate and its variability in juvenile hypertonics during respiratory maneuvers

In 27 children (14 juvenile hypertonics and 13 healthy control children, with the mean age 14.7 +/- 0.4 y. or 15.2 +/- 0.5 y., respectively, P greater than 0.05) the changes of heart rate (HR), its variability (HRV) during deep inspiration and subsequent expiration, Valsalva's maneuver, doubled breathing frequency and the deepening of breathing were studied. The resting supine mean HR was significantly higher (P less than 0.001) in hypertonics than in controls. Deep inspiration was in both groups accompanied with the HR increase. However, the percentage increase in hypertonics was significantly lower than in normals (P less than 0.02). With subsequent expiration, the HR fell in both groups. There was no significant difference between the percentage decreases in both groups (P greater than 0.05). During the Valsalva's maneuver, in the first phase the tachycardic response occurred, which was in hypertonics significantly less pronounced. After the recovery of breathing a bradycardic reaction occurred which was equal in both groups (P greater than 0.05). Both, in juvenile hypertonics and in controls the doubled frequency of breathing increased the mean HR and decreased the HRV. During the deepened breathing there was an increase in mean HR in both groups, and only in the controls there was an increase in HRV. Heart rate variability in hypertonics was lower than in the controls under all the conditions.