Evaluation of coronary artery disease by an improved method of exercise electrocardiography: the ST segment/heart rate slope

A new criterion combining ST/HR slope and deltaST/deltaHR index for detection of coronary artery disease in patients on digoxin therapy

We evaluated the clinical value of a new index combining deltaST/delta heart rate (HR) index and ST/HR slope for diagnosing coronary artery disease (CAD) in patients on digoxin therapy. Exercise treadmill tests were performed by 72 patients on digoxin therapy. Simple HR-adjusted indexes of ST-segment depression during exercise (deltaST/deltaHR index) and the decline calculated from the final 12 data points relating ST-segment depression to HR (ST/HR slope) were determined. A new index was obtained by subtracting the deltaST/deltaHR index from the ST/HR slope. On thallium scintigraphy, 37 of the 72 patients showed reversible perfusion defects related to the diseased coronary artery. The new index derived from this ST-HR relation was 4.1 +/- 3.6 microV/beats/min in the ischemic group and 1.3 +/- 1.0 microV/beats/min in the group of patients without ischemia (p <0.0001). An ST-HR relation > or = 1.5 was found in 33 of the 37 patients in the ischemic group, and in 7 of the 35 patients without ischemia (p <0.0001). The sensitivity of this criterion for prediction of myocardial ischemia was 89%, the specificity was 80%, and the predictive accuracy was 85%. Thus, this new ST-HR index is useful for detecting CAD in patients on digoxin therapy.

A new predictor of restenosis after successful percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty in patients with multivessel coronary artery disease

With the goal of improving prediction of restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) for multivessel coronary artery disease (CAD), we evaluated the usefulness of serial exercise treadmill tests. We previously reported that an increase in the deltaST/delta heart rate (HR) index at follow-up over the value obtained several days after PTCA was useful for detecting restenosis following PTCA for 1-vessel CAD. In that report, comparison of the deltaST/deltaHR index was made based on measurements from the lead disclosing the greatest ST displacement before PTCA. This method was not applicable to patients with multivessel CAD. Seventy-eight patients with multivessel CAD before and several days after PTCA and just before follow-up performed exercise treadmill tests. Simple HR-adjusted indexes of ST-segment depression during exercise (deltaST/deltaHR index) and the sum of the deltaST/deltaHR index in leads II, III, aVF, V4, V5, and V6 (sigma deltaST/deltaHR index) were determined. We compared the predictive power of an increase in sigma deltaST/deltaHR index at follow-up with that of a positive exercise treadmill test and a positive thallium scintigram for restenosis. At follow-up, 37 of the 78 patients showed restenosis. The sigma deltaST/deltaHR index had increased in 30 of these 37 patients (81%), and in 12 of the 41 patients (29%) without restenosis. An increase in sigma deltaST/deltaHR index had a significantly higher sensitivity than the other methods and a significantly higher specificity than a positive exercise treadmill test.

Increase in the delta ST/delta heart rate (HR) index: a new predictor of restenosis after successful percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty

With the goal of improving the prediction of restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA), we evaluated the usefulness of the delta ST/delta heart rate (HR) index derived from serial exercise treadmill tests. Exercise treadmill tests were performed by 125 patients with single-vessel coronary artery disease before and several days after PTCA, and just before follow-up angiography 3 to 12 months later. Simple HR-adjusted indexes of ST-segment depression during exercise (delta ST/delta HR index) were derived. We compared the usefulness of the increase in delta ST/delta HR index at follow-up over the value obtained several days after PTCA for prediction of restenosis with that of a positive exercise treadmill test and a positive thallium scintigram at follow-up. At follow-up, 47 of the 125 patients showed restenosis. The delta ST/delta HR index increased in 43 of 47 patients in the restenosis group and in 18 of 78 patients without restenosis (p < 0.0001). Separate analysis of each criterion revealed the following respective values for sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values for prediction of restenosis; increased delta ST/delta HR index of follow-up: 91%, 77%, 70%, and 94%; positive exercise treadmill test: 83%, 65%, 59%, and 86%; and positive thallium scintigram: 79%, 78%, 69%, and 86%. The increased delta ST/delta HR index had a significantly (p < 0.05) higher sensitivity than the positive thallium scintigram and a significantly (p < 0.01) higher specificity than the positive exercise treadmill test. An increased delta ST/delta HR index at follow-up identifies subgroups of patients who are at high risk for restenosis after PTCA.

An emergency department-based protocol for rapidly ruling out myocardial ischemia reduces hospital time and expense: results of a randomized study (ROMIO)

OBJECTIVES

We tested the hypothesis that an emergency department-based protocol for rapidly ruling out myocardial ischemia would reduce hospital time and expense but maintain diagnostic accuracy.

BACKGROUND

Patients with a missed diagnosis of myocardial infarction have a high mortality rate; however, providing routine hospital care to low risk patients may not be time- or cost-effective.

METHODS

One hundred low risk patients were entered into the study and randomized either to an emergency department-based rapid rule-out protocol (n = 50) or to routine hospital care (n = 50). Patients receiving routine care were managed by their attending physicians. The rapid protocol included serum enzyme testing at 0, 3, 6 and 9h, serial electrocardiograms with continuous ST segment monitoring and, if results were negative, a predischarge graded exercise test. Study patients were also compared with 160 historical control subjects.

RESULTS

Myocardial infarction or unstable angina occurred in 6% of patients within 30 days; no diagnoses were missed. By intention to treat analysis (n = 50 in each group), the hospital stay was shorter and charges were lower with the rapid protocol than with routine care (p = 0.001). Among patients in whom ischemia was ruled out, those assigned to the rapid protocol had a shorter hospital stay (median 11.9 vs. 22.8 h, p = 0.0001) and lower initial ($893 vs $1,349, p = 0.0001) and 30-day ($898 vs. $1,522, p = 0.0001) hospital charges than did patients given routine care. In historical control subjects, the hospital stay was longer (median 34.5 h, p = 0.001 vs. either group) and charges greater (median $2,063, p = 0.001, vs rapid protocol, p = 0.02, vs. routine care group).

CONCLUSIONS

In low risk patients who present to the emergency department with chest pain, the rapid protocol ruled out myocardial infarction and unstable angina more quickly and cost-effectively than did routine hospital care.

Asymptomatic coronary artery disease detection: update 1996. A screening protocol using 16-lead high-resolution ECG, ultrafast CT, exercise testing, and radionuclear imaging

The authors have proposed a new four-step screening algorithm to detect asymptomatic coronary artery disease (CAD) in flight school candidates, cadets, and rated flyers of the Unites States Air Force (USAF). In step 1, the USAF Armstrong Laboratory (USAF/AL) risk profile and improved 16-lead high-resolution electrocardiogram/vectorcardiogram will be recorded at baseline. On routine follow-up evaluations, quantitative serial comparisons will be performed by the method of Kornreich. In step 2, beginning with flight school candidates and cadets, all three groups will be studied by the ultrafast computed tomograph (CT) protocol. Those candidates positive for coronary calcium will be studied by coronary angiography and ventriculography, and their eligibility for continued rated flight status will be determined by present criteria. In step 3, those candidates negative for coronary calcium by ultrafast CT will then be screened by the newly defined and improved high-sensitivity treadmill exercise test criteria. In step 4, candidates with a positive treadmill exercise test result, or who are also found in the upper quintile of the USAF/AL risk profile, wild also have exercise nuclear wall motion studies and perfusion scans. If these are abnormal and suggestive of myocardial ischemia, this subset will also be studied by heart catheterization and coronary angiography, and their eligibility for continued rated flight status will be determined by present criteria. The incidence of coronary calcium/no calcium for each degree of stenosis in the 6,000 flyers in each quintile was used to develop the following projections: (1) that more than 3 of 4 rated flyers with unsuspected CAD, and (2) more than 9 of 10 with severe flow-limiting CAD can be identified by these upgraded screening procedures. Evidence is herein presented that these enhancements will result in a major (5-8-fold) increase in case finding of this disease. Based on the estimate of four lost high-performance aircrafts per year from sudden incapacitation of the pilot due to CAD, when this four-step screen is fully operational, it can be expected to reduce the $80 million annual losses to the United States government from CAD by 85%, a savings of $68 million per year.

Comparison of ST-segment/heart rate slope analysis with standard ST-segment measurement criteria to outcome of exercise thallium-201 imaging

We compared standard ST-segment analysis and ST/HR slope analysis of exercise ECG studies with reference to outcome of exercise thallium-201 studies in 341 patients. Sensitivity was significantly better using ST/HR slope compared with standard ST analysis. Specificity was not significantly different.

Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression and performance of the exercise electrocardiogram: a critical evaluation

Analysis of the rate-related change in exercise-induced ST segment depression using the exercise ST segment/heart rate slope and ST segment/heart rate index can improve the accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) for the identification of patients with coronary artery disease, recognition of patients with anatomically or functionally severe coronary obstruction and detection of patients at increased risk for future coronary events. These methods provide a more physiologic approach to analysis of the ST segment response to exercise by adjusting the apparent severity of ischemia for the corresponding increase in myocardial oxygen demand, which in turn can be linearly related to increasing heart rate. Solid-angle theory provides a model for the linear relation of ST segment depression to heart rate during exercise and a framework for understanding the relation of the ST segment/heart rate slope to the presence and extent of coronary artery disease. False positive and false negative test results of the heart rate-adjusted methods are well known in selected populations and require further clarification. Application of these methods is also highly dependent on the type of exercise protocol, number of ECG leads examined, timing of ST segment measurement relative to the J point and accuracy and precision of ST segment measurement. These methodologic details have been an important limitation to test application when traditional protocols and measurement procedures are required. When applied with attention to required details, the heart rate-adjusted methods can improve the usefulness of the exercise ECG in a range of clinically relevant populations.

Compartmental multivariate analysis of exercise ECGs for accurate detection of myocardial ischaemia

An accurate computer-assisted diagnostic method for detection of myocardial ischaemia, called MUSTA, is developed. MUSTA is based on compartmental multivariate analysis of variables available in the exercise ECGs, and is definitively implemented in Prolog. It is heuristically developed by determining diagnostic criteria, which interrelate a modified ST/HR-slope, ST-segment value and shape, and maximum heart rate, so that concordance with the TI-201 SPECT is maximised. In the learning group consisting of 47 patients, MUSTA provides a diagnostic accuracy of 98%, the detection of ischaemia being in absolute concordance with TI-201 SPECT. MUSTA is evaluated in a similar but independent group of 60 patients. Then, accuracy is 90%, and sensitivity is 94%. The performance characteristics are significantly better than those of the standard exercise ECG, whose diagnostic accuracy in these groups is 77% and 70%, respectively. This study suggests that MUSTA is a significant improvement for computerised assessment of myocardial ischaemia.

Solid-angle theory and heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression for the identification and quantification of coronary artery disease

Determinants of the ST-segment response to exercise can be mathematically modeled by solid-angle theory, and heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of exercise-induced ST-segment depression can remodel the solid-angle relationship to provide a theoretic and practical basis for application of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST depression in exercise electrocardiography. Solid-angle theory indicates that the magnitude of ST depression recorded at a surface electrode (epsilon) can be described as the product of spatial and nonspatial determinants: epsilon = (omega/4 pi).(delta Vm).K (equation 1), where omega is the solid angle subtending the boundary of the ischemic territory, delta Vm is the difference in transmembrane voltage between the ischemic and adjacent nonischemic regions, and K is a term correcting for differences in intracellular and extracellular conductivity and changes in end-plate conductance. As a consequence, the magnitude of ST depression recorded by a surface electrode will be proportional both to the area of ischemic territory subtended by the recording electrode, which reflects the solid angle, and to the local transmembrane potential difference, which in turn reflects the electric consequences of the metabolic severity of ischemia at the level of the myocardial cell. It follows from equation 1 that the amplitude of ST depression can accurately reflect the area of ischemic boundary only when the severity of ischemia is constant or otherwise controlled, and differences in ST depression will only reflect varying areas of underlying ischemia when similar severity of ischemia is present. During exercise the severity of ischemia is directly proportional to changes in myocardial oxygen demand and coronary blood flow, which in turn are directly related to increasing heart rate (delta HR). Because the change in transmembrane voltage across the ischemic boundary is linearly proportional to delta HR, delta Vm/delta HR remains constant as ischemia develops. Dividing the solid-angle relationship in equation 1 by delta HR and making the appropriate substitution for a constant delta Vm/delta HR then indicates that epsilon/delta HR = (omega/4 pi).(c . K) [equation 2], where c is the new constant. Under conditions where changes in conductance are proportional or small, this simplified relationship reduces to delta ST/delta HR = c'.omega [equation 3], where delta ST reflects the magnitude of ST depression recorded by the surface electrode, delta HR the change in heart rate during developing ischemia, and c' the resulting empiric constant.

Population selection and performance of the exercise ECG for the identification of coronary artery disease

To quantify the effect of population selection on the performance of exercise ECG criteria for the detection of coronary artery disease, the exercise ECGs of 212 clinically normal nonvolunteer subjects, 31 patients with no significant coronary disease at angiography, 153 patients with clinically stable angina, and 184 patients with catheterization-proved coronary disease were examined. Test specificity was examined separately in clinically normal subjects and in patients with angiographically normal coronary arteries, and test sensitivity was determined separately in patients with stable angina and those with catheterization-proved disease. Definition and selection of normal and abnormal study populations had marked effects on test performance. Standard ECG criteria, a simple ST depression magnitude partition of 150 microV, an ST segment/heart rate (ST/HR) index partition of 1.60 microV/beat/min, and an ST/HR slope partition of 2.40 microV/beat/min, identified coronary disease with comparably high specificities (94% to 97%) in clinically normal subjects, but with significantly lower specificities (68% to 77%, p = 0.002 to 0.0001) in patients with angiographically normal coronary arteries. Although sensitivity was significantly lower in patients with stable angina than in patients with catheterization-proved coronary disease for standard criteria (54% vs 70%, p = 0.004) and for the ST/HR index (88% vs 95%, p = 0.04), there was no significant difference in the poor sensitivity of the simple ST depression magnitude criteria (51% vs 58%) or in the high sensitivity of the ST/HR slope (93% vs 96%) in these abnormal patient groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Performance characteristics of various exercise ECG classifiers in different clinical populations

To improve the diagnostic power of the exercise electrocardiographic test in detecting myocardial ischemia, the authors have recently developed a diagnostic method called multivariate ST-segment/heart rate (ST/HR) analysis (MUSTA). The goal of this study was to evaluate the validity of MUSTA in different clinical populations and to compare its performance characteristics with ST-segment depression, the ST/HR slope, and the delta ST/HR index in these populations. The computerized exercise electrocardiographic measurements were performed on 1,507 cases, and 382 patients were selected as the study population: 161 with significant coronary artery disease according to coronary angiography and 221 with a low likelihood of coronary artery disease. The diagnostic accuracy of MUSTA in the pooled population was 77.7% (297 out of 382 patients), which was clearly better than the accuracy of 69.6% (266 out of 382 patients) using the conventional ST-segment depression criterion of 0.10 mV in detecting coronary artery disease and exercise-induced myocardial ischemia. According to receiver operating characteristics analysis, MUSTA had significantly better diagnostic power than the other classifiers. These findings suggest that multivariate and compartmental analysis methods like MUSTA can further improve the clinical importance of the exercise electrocardiogram.

Evaluation of exercise-induced QRS amplitude changes (Athens score) and their clinical value

The index of exercises-induced amplitude changes in a combination of Q, R and S waves, named Athens score, was tested in 213 patients, who underwent coronary angiography within 3 days of a maximal exercise test. Of the 155 cases with conclusive exercise test results, according to the coronary angiography document, 23 (14.8%) were diagnosed as having no significant coronary artery disease (CAD); 27 (17.4%) as 1-vessel disease; 28 (18.1%) as 2-vessel disease and 77 (49.7%) as 3-vessel disease. The Athens score for them was 4.87 +/- 2.89, 0.02 +/- 3.35, -1.70 +/- 3.68, -1.75 +/- 3.98 respectively, F = 19.65, P < 0.01. An Athens score of 2 mm predicted CAD with sensitivity of 84.9% and specificity of 78.3% both being higher than those of ST segment depression (75.0% and 60.9%). It was concluded that the Athens score was a promising index for improving the efficiency of exercise test to predict CAD.

Value and limitations of heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression criteria for the identification of anatomically severe coronary obstruction: test performance in relation to method of rate correction, definition of extent of disease, and beta-blockade

Performance of the linear regression-based ST/HR (heart rate) slope, the simple ST/HR index, and ST segment depression alone for the identification of anatomically severe coronary obstruction was examined in relation to the definition of the extent of disease and the presence or absence of beta-blockade during treadmill exercise using the Cornell protocol in 172 catheterized patients. Whether severe disease was defined by three-vessel obstruction, by Gensini scores partitioned at 35 or at 48, or by Duke jeopardy scores exceeding 6, the 83% to 100% sensitivities of an ST/HR slope criterion of 6.0 microV/beat/min were each significantly higher than the corresponding 65% to 80% sensitivities of 150 microV of ST segment depression closely matched specificities. The ST/HR slope was significantly more sensitive than a simple ST/HR index criterion of 3.4 microV/beat/min for detection of high Gensini scores, but despite consistently intermediate performance trends, in no case did sensitivity of the simple ST/HR index criterion significantly exceed that of ST depression alone. Each method performed better and with comparable sensitivity in patients not receiving beta-blockers. In contrast, the 82% to 100% sensitivities of the ST/HR slope for identification of severe disease were significantly higher than the 63% to 77% sensitivities of ST depression in patients taking beta-blocking drugs; however, simple heart rate adjustment using the ST/HR index had intermediate performance that in no case was significantly more sensitive than ST segment depression alone.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Accuracy of ST/heart rate index in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease

The accuracy of ST/heart rate (ST HR) index was evaluated in patients presenting for exercise electrocardiography with suspected coronary disease. In all, 420 patients (235 men and 185 women) with normal electrocardiograms at rest underwent exercise testing, followed within 3 months by coronary angiography. The sensitivity and specificity for standard ST criteria (greater than or equal to 1 mm horizontal or downsloping depression) were 48% (78 of 162) and 81% (208 of 258), respectively. An ST HR-index threshold of 1.86 microV/beta/min had the exact same specificity with a sensitivity of 44% (71 of 162; p = not significant). Consideration of greater than or equal to 1.5 mm upsloping depression had no significant impact on the aforementioned results. Using multivariate logistic regression analysis, age, sex, symptoms, cigarette smoking, diabetes mellitus, qualitative ST slope, rate-pressure product, METs achieved and exercise angina were evaluated with and without ST HR index and ST depression. According to this analysis, age, sex, symptoms and ST slope were good predictors of presence or absence of disease. Neither ST HR index nor ST depression had significance in the multivariate analysis. However, when a separate analysis was performed in men and women, the 2 quantitative ST variables showed significance in men, but not in women. Comparisons of discriminative accuracy using receiver-operating characteristic curves demonstrated differences between men and women, but no difference between ST HR index and ST depression. Therefore, concerning questions of coronary disease diagnosis, consideration of ST HR index was not better than standard ST criteria, and added nothing to multivariate analysis of other available variables.

Identifying coronary artery disease in women by heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression and improved performance of linear regression over simple averaging method with comparison to standard criteria

Performance of exercise electrocardiography for the detection of coronary artery disease (CAD) in women has been limited by relatively poor sensitivity and specificity of standard test criteria. Recent studies suggest that diagnostic methods incorporating heart rate (HR) adjustment of ST-segment depression during exercise may improve the accuracy of exercise testing in women, but the relative performance of different rate-adjusted methods for this purpose is unknown. To assess the effect of gender on relative test performance of the ST-segment/HR (ST/HR) slope, the simple ST/HR index, the HR-recovery loop, and standard ST-depression criteria for the identification of CAD, the exercise electrocardiograms of 254 patients with known or suspected CAD (67 women and 187 men) and of 150 clinically normal subjects (29 women and 121 men) were analyzed. Specificity of each method was comparable in men and women: ST/HR slope 98% (118 of 121) vs 97% (28 of 29), ST/HR index 97% (117 of 121) vs 97% (28 of 29), and HR-recovery loop 96% (116 of 121) vs 93% (27 of 29). In contrast, although there was no difference in sensitivity of the ST/HR slope (95% [177 of 187] vs 93% [62 of 67]; p = not significant [NS]) or HR-recovery loop (90% [168 of 187] vs 87% [58 of 67]; p = NS) between men and women, the ST/HR index was less sensitive for CAD in women than in men (82% [55 of 67] vs 93% [173 of 187]; p less than 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Exercise-induced ST depression and ST/heart rate index to predict triple-vessel or left main coronary disease: a multicenter analysis

The aim of this investigation was to determine the difference in accuracy between two frequently published noninvasive indicators of severity of coronary artery disease (exercise-induced ST segment depression and heart rate-adjusted ST depression [ST/HR index]). The study was designed as a survey of consecutive patients undergoing exercise electrocardiography and coronary angiography. There were a total of 2,270 patients without prior myocardial infarction or cardiac valvular disease referred for angiography from eight institutions in three countries; 401 of these patients had triple-vessel or left main coronary artery disease. The sensitivities of ST depression and ST/HR index in detecting triple-vessel or left main coronary artery disease were, respectively, 75% and 78% (p = 0.08) at cut point values where their specificities were equal (64%). This small increase in the accuracy of the ST/HR index was evident only at peak exercise heart rates below the median value of 132 beats/min, where the sensitivities of ST depression and ST/HR index were 73% and 76% (p = 0.03), respectively, at cut point values corresponding to a specificity of 60%. These results were consistent at all eight participating institutions. The increase in accuracy achieved by dividing exercise-induced ST depression by heart rate is small and confined exclusively to a low exercise heart rate. This lack of superiority cannot be generalized to all methods of heart rate adjustment.

A combination of electrocardiographic methods represents a further step toward the noninvasive identification of patients with syndrome X

Identification of patients with angina but normal coronary arteriograms (syndrome X) using noninvasive means would be desirable. The ability of four established exercise electrocardiographic methods to identify angina patients with and without coronary artery disease was compared with that of a method based on a combination of the above (combined method). A treadmill score, a multivariate method, the ST segment recovery loop, the ST/heart rate adjustment, and the combined method were applied to 112 patients who had typical exertional angina and positive exercise tests (greater than 1 mm ST segment depression); 90 had documented coronary artery disease and 22 had syndrome X. The combined method and the treadmill score had a significantly higher diagnostic accuracy (both 81%, as 91 of the 112 patients were correctly identified by both methods) than the multivariate (66%) and ST segment recovery loop (64%) methods (p less than 0.05). The ST/heart rate adjustment had a lower sensitivity for syndrome X than any other method (1 of 22). Thus methods that involve the assessment of both ST and non ST segment variables have greater accuracy in separating syndrome X and coronary artery disease patients than methods relying more heavily on ST segment changes.

Heart rate adjustment of the time-voltage ST segment integral: identification of coronary disease and relation to standard and heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression criteria

To assess the effect of heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of the ST integral (ST-HR integral) on exercise test performance, the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) of 50 clinically normal subjects and 100 patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease was analyzed. At matched specificity of 96% with standard ECG criteria (greater than or equal to 0.1 mV of additional horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression), an unadjusted ST integral partition of 16 microV-s identified coronary disease in the 100 patients with known or suspected disease with a sensitivity of only 41%, a value significantly lower than the 59% sensitivity of standard ECG criteria (p less than 0.01) and the 65% sensitivity of an ST depression partition of 130 microV (p less than 0.001). However, test performance of the ST integral was greatly improved by simple heart rate adjustment: at a matched specificity of 96%, an ST-HR integral partition of 0.154 microV-s/beat per min identified coronary disease in the 100 patients with a sensitivity of 90%, a value significantly greater than the 59% sensitivity of standard criteria and 65% sensitivity of ST depression criteria (each p less than 0.001) and similar to the 91% sensitivity of the ST-HR index and 93% sensitivity of the ST-HR slope (each p = NS). Comparison of receiver-operating characteristic curves confirmed the superior overall test performance of the ST-HR integral relative to the ST integral and ST segment depression, and demonstrated improved performance that was comparable with that of the ST-HR index and the ST-HR slope.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

ST/HR slope and improved exercise ECG detection of myocardial ischemia in patients with suspected coronary artery disease

Predictive values of ST/HR slope and ST-segment displacement during symptom-limited exercise were determined in 85 patients who underwent coronary angiography for suspected coronary artery disease, using perfusional and functional radionuclide images with 99mTc-2-methoxy-isobutil-isonitrile as an index of stress-induced myocardial ischemia. ST/HR slope showed a better sensitivity than conventional stress-induced changes of ST-segment displacement (96% vs. 73%, respectively). In patients with clinical suspicion of coronary artery disease, the main result was the negative predictive value of ST/HR slope when compared with conventional ST-segment displacement (98% vs. 41%). ST/HR slope was unable to perfectly separate patients with different degrees of ischemia, however, subjects without scintigraphic signs of stress-induced ischemia and patients with ischemic impairment in three myocardial regions were correctly identified as distinct populations. In patients with a previous myocardial infarction, no difference was found between the two criteria and a wide overlap of ST/HR slope values was present. The authors conclude that ST/HR slope is useful to detect the rate of change in electric parameters during exercise and might therefore more adequately be used to separate normal from definitely abnormal responses to exercise.

Effect of ST segment measurement point on performance of standard and heart rate-adjusted ST segment criteria for the identification of coronary artery disease

BACKGROUND

Recent reports critical of the performance of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST depression during exercise electrocardiography have used J-point rather than ST segment measurements. However, no standard exists for the optimal time after the J-point at which to measure ST segment deviation.

METHODS AND RESULTS

To assess the effect of ST segment measurement position on performance of standard exercise electrocardiographic criteria, the delta ST segment/heart rate (delta ST/HR) index, and the ST segment/heart rate (ST/HR) slope for the detection of coronary artery disease, the exercise electrocardiograms of 50 clinically normal subjects and 80 patients with known or likely coronary disease were analyzed using ST depression measured at both the J-point and at 60 msec after the J-point (J + 60). A positive exercise electrocardiogram by standard criteria, defined as 0.1 mV or more of additional horizontal or downsloping ST depression at end exercise, had a specificity of 96% when ST depression was measured at either the J-point or J + 60. There was no difference in sensitivity of standard electrocardiographic criteria at J + 60 and J point (both 59%, p = NS). However, at matched specificity of 96%, the delta ST/HR index and ST/HR slope calculated using ST depression at J + 60 were significantly more sensitive (90% and 93%) than when calculated using J-point depression (64% and 61%, each p less than 0.001). Comparison of areas under respective receiver operating characteristic curves confirmed the superior performance of J + 60 as opposed to J-point measurements for both the delta ST/HR index (0.98 versus 0.89, p = 0.006) and the ST/HR slope (0.96 versus 0.87, p = 0.007) and also demonstrated modestly improved overall test performance for standard electrocardiographic criteria using J + 60 measurements (0.88 versus 0.82, p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Use of J-point measurements significantly degrades performance of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST depression but has less effect on standard criteria.

Improved diagnostic performance of the exercise ECG test by computerized multivariate ST-segment/heart rate analysis

The exercise ECG test is the most widely used noninvasive method of evaluating myocardial ischemia. To determine whether it is possible to enhance its diagnostic power, the authors carried out computerized ECG measurements on 118 nonischemic patients and 38 ischemic patients with or without myocardial infarctions (MIs). Forty-seven (all ischemic and nine normal cases) underwent T1-201 SPECT. The diagnostic variables include ST-segment deviation, modified ST/HR-slope, ST-segment shape, and maximum heart rate. These variables are interrelated by means of compartmental and specific decision rules by computer. The diagnostic method discussed in this article is called the multivariate ST/HR analysis (MUSTA). When compared with MUSTA, the T1-201 SPECT images detected myocardial ischemia with a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 89%. Its diagnostic performance was influenced by neither previous MIs nor cardiac medication of the 47 patients tested. MUSTA was also compared to the nonmodified ST/HR analyses (ST60/HR and ST80/HR) and the standard exercise ECG test. It performed significantly better than these methods. The authors conclude that the multivariate ST/HR analysis is comparable to T1-201 SPECT in diagnosing myocardial ischemia among the study subjects. Furthermore, MUSTA is executed during the noninvasive exercise ECG test and is easily applied using an IBM/AT-compatible microcomputer. However, further evaluation of MUSTA with a separate and unselected patient population is needed.

Heart rate adjustment of exercise-induced ST segment depression. Improved risk stratification in the Framingham Offspring Study

BACKGROUND

Simple heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression during exercise (delta ST/HR index) and the pattern of ST depression as a function of heart rate during exercise and recovery (the rate-recovery loop) have been shown to improve the ability of the exercise electrocardiogram to detect the presence of coronary heart disease (CHD), but the performance of these methods for the prediction of future coronary events remains to be examined.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We compared the delta ST/HR index and the rate-recovery loop with standard electrocardiographic criteria for prediction of CHD events in 3,168 asymptomatic men and women in the Framingham Offspring Study who underwent treadmill exercise electrocardiography and who, at entry, were free of clinical and electrocardiographic evidence of CHD. After a mean follow-up of 4.3 years, there were 65 new CHD events: four sudden deaths, 24 new myocardial infarctions, and 37 incident cases of angina pectoris. When a Cox proportional hazards model with adjustment for age and sex was used, a positive exercise electrocardiogram by standard criteria (greater than or equal to 0.1 mV horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression) was not predictive of new CHD events (chi 2 = 0.40, p = 0.52). In contrast, stratification according to the presence or absence of a positive delta ST/HR index (greater than or equal to 1.6 microV/beat/min) and a positive (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loop was associated with CHD event risk (chi 2 = 9.45, p less than 0.01) and separated subjects into three groups with varying risks of coronary events: high risk, when both tests were positive (relative risk 3.6; 95% confidence interval, 2.4-5.4); intermediate risk, when either the delta ST/HR index or the rate-recovery loop was positive (relative risk, 1.9; 95% confidence interval, 1.3-2.8); and low risk, when both tests were negative. After multivariate adjustment for age, sex, smoking, total cholesterol level, fasting glucose level, diastolic blood pressure, and electrocardiographic evidence of left ventricular hypertrophy, the combined delta ST/HR index and rate-recovery loop criteria remained predictive of coronary events (chi 2 = 5.45, p = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression by the delta ST/HR index and the rate-recovery loop during exercise electrocardiography can improve prediction of future coronary events in asymptomatic men and women.

Effect of precision of ST-segment measurement on identification and quantification of coronary artery disease by the ST/HR index

To assess the effect of varying precision of ST-segment depression measurement on test performance of the ST-segment/heart rate (ST/HR) index for the identification and quantification of coronary artery disease, the exercise electrocardiograms (ECGs) of 100 clinically normal subjects and 154 patients with angiographically proved coronary disease were reviewed. The ST/HR index was calculated by dividing the maximal additional ST-segment depression at end exercise by the exercise-induced change in heart rate. ST-segment depression was measured to the nearest 10 microV (ST10) at a point 60 ms after the J point on a computerized exercise ECG system, and was subsequently rounded down to the nearest 50 microV (ST50) and the nearest 100 microV (ST100) to simulate measurements to these precisions. An ST10/HR index partition of 1.60 microV/bpm with a specificity of 95% (95/100) in normal subjects identified the presence of coronary disease with a sensitivity of 94% (144/154). Precision of ST-segment measurement significantly affected sensitivity for coronary disease. At matched specificity of 95%, an ST50/HR index partition of 1.55 microV/bpm had a sensitivity of 88% (135/154, p less than 0.01) and an ST100/HR index partition of 1.22 microV/bpm had a sensitivity of 84% (130/154, p less than 0.001) for the detection of coronary obstructions. Comparison of receiver-operating characteristic curves (ROC) confirmed the superior overall performance of the ST/HR index using ST10 measurements for the identification of coronary disease. By contrast, test performance for the identification of three-vessel coronary disease was not affected by the precision of ST-segment measurement with no significant difference in test sensitivity or areas under respective ROCs.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Clinical significance of simple heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression in supine leg exercise in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease

To evaluate the clinical significance of simple heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression (delta ST/delta HR) in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease, 42 patients with stable exertional angina underwent supine leg exercise testing and cardiac catheterization. During exercise, heart rate, a multilead electrocardiogram, and pulmonary artery wedge pressure were recorded. The sensitivity and accuracy of the delta ST/delta HR criteria (greater than or equal to 3.0 microV/beat/min) were significantly greater than the conventional analysis of ST segment depression criteria (greater than or equal to 0.2 mV) for detecting three-vessel coronary artery disease at a matched specificity of 72% (100% versus 46%, 81% versus 64%, p less than 0.01). A significant linear correlation was found between maximum pulmonary artery wedge pressure increments during exercise (delta PAWP) or Gensini score and the delta ST/delta HR (delta PAWP: r = 0.51, p less than 0.001; Gensini score: r = 0.47, p less than 0.001). There were no statistically significant differences in the delta PAWP or Gensini score between patients with three-vessel disease who had delta ST/delta HR greater than or equal to 3.0 microV/beat/min and those with one- or two-vessel disease who had delta ST/delta HR greater than or equal to 3.0 microV/beat/min (delta PAWP: 18.1 +/- 2.0 versus 21.9 +/- 3.3, p = NS; Gensini score: 68.5 +/- 6.6 versus 66.3 +/- 11.3, p = NS). These findings demonstrate that delta ST/delta HR is more useful than a conventional analysis of ST segment depression for identifying not only anatomically severe coronary artery disease but also functionally severe coronary artery disease.

ST changes in relation to heart rate during bicycle exercise in patients with coronary artery disease

Exercise test on cycle ergometer and coronary angiography were performed on 190 patients with chest pain. Volunteers with a normal thallium scintigraphy (n = 47) served as controls. The load started at 20 W and increased at a rate of 10 W min-1 until exhaustion or symptoms. Conventional 12-lead ECGs were recorded by means of computer before, during and after exercise. Minimum ST amplitude 60 ms after the STJ point (ST60) at end of work with a cut-off level of -1.10 mm had a sensitivity of 69% (52/75) and a specificity of 89% (37/42) when individuals with a normal resting ECG were considered. ST80 and sum of ST60 in left ventricular leads had slightly lower values of sensitivity and specificity. Changes in ST60 during exercise discriminated less well between the groups. Final heart rate during exercise (less than 148 min-1) had a sensitivity of 88% (53/60) and a specificity of 89% (42/47). The change in heart rate during exercise (less than 66 min-1) had a sensitivity of 50/60 (only patients without beta-blockers were considered). The best discrimination was obtained by defining a test score (TS) according to the linear equation TS = 2.95-0.23 x HRE-0.301 X ST60 where a positive value indicates a positive test and a negative value a negative test. Sensitivity and specificity were 21/23 (91%) and 40/42 (95%), respectively. The test score was also calculated in those patients having significant coronary disease and an abnormal resting ECG (no bundle branch block, no beta-blockers) and this yielded a sensitivity of 30/34.

New coronary artery disease index based on exercise-induced QRS changes

Exercise-induced changes in Q, R, and S wave amplitudes have been reported to detect coronary artery disease but with low specificity, low sensitivity, or both; it was hypothesized that their incorporation into a composite index (Athens QRS score) might improve specificity and sensitivity. For this purpose 246 patients were analyzed retrospectively and 160 prospectively. All patients underwent maximal exercise testing with a standard Bruce protocol and coronary arteriography as part of the diagnostic evaluation for possible or definite coronary artery disease. The Athens QRS score was decreased as the number of obstructed coronary arteries increased (normal coronary arteries = 7.85 +/- 5.23 mm, one-vessel disease = 5.2 +/- 5.3 mm, two-vessel disease = -0.85 +/- 5.4 mm, three-vessel disease = -3.5 +/- 5.8 mm; p less than 0.0001); the score was unrelated to exercise-induced ST segment depression, and negative (less than 0) scores were always associated with coronary artery disease. An Athens QRS score of 5 mm predicted coronary artery disease with sensitivity ranging from 75% to 86% and a specificity ranging from 73% to 79%, values higher than those of the Q wave (75% and 50%, respectively), R wave (65% and 55%), and S wave (70% and 10%) and of the ST segment depression (62% and 70%). It is concluded that exercise-induced changes in the QRS complex provide a useful index not only for the diagnosis but also for the assessment of severity of coronary artery disease.

Effect of baseline ST segment elevation on test performance of standard and heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression criteria

Whether the ST segment shift used to evaluate the presence and severity of myocardial ischemia should include the additional deviation due to decreasing amounts of baseline ST segment elevation was examined in 100 clinically normal subjects and in 124 patients with coronary disease. Exercise ST segment depression was calculated in two ways: as the difference between exercise and resting ST segment depression, but excluding any resting ST elevation (STdep), and as the total ST segment difference or excursion, including any baseline resting ST elevation (STdiff). These values were also used for separate calculation of the maximal ST/heart rate slope and delta ST/heart rate index in each case. Given partition values with matched specificity of 95% in clinically normal subjects, 150 microV of STdep was significantly more sensitive for coronary disease than 220 microV of STdiff (61% [76 of 124] versus 50% [62 of 124], p less than 0.005). Comparison of receiver operating characteristic curves confirmed the superior test performance of STdep for the identification of coronary disease in this population (area under the curve 0.920 versus 0.869, p = 0.0019). In contrast, detection of three-vessel coronary obstruction by standard ST segment criteria was not affected by definition of ST segment excursion. Substitution of STdiff for STdep did not change the performance of the ST/heart rate slope of the delta ST/heart rate index for either the detection of coronary disease or for the identification of three-vessel coronary obstruction.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Computer-based implementation of the ST-segment/heart rate slope

The ST-segment/heart rate (ST/HR) slope has markedly improved the accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram for the identification and quantification of coronary artery disease. However, clinical use of this technique has been limited by time-consuming manual ST-segment measurements and calculator-based linear regression analyses after testing. To assess the accuracy of on-line computerized measurement of ST-segment depression and recently implemented ST/HR slope algorithms, 50 patients exercised with a Marquette Electronics CASE 12 system and 50 patients exercised with a Quinton Q5000 system were evaluated. Computerized ST-segment measurements, to the nearest 10 microV, were compared with averaged manual measurements from the raw signal, to the nearest 25 microV, at peak exercise in leads II and CM5. The CASE 12 and Q5000 algorithms for selection of data and calculation of the maximal ST/HR slope were compared with the ST/HR slope calculated from end-stage data points according to a standard off-line procedure. Manual ST-segment measurements correlated highly with CASE 12 and Q5000 determinations (r = 0.996 to 0.998). The slopes of their regression lines approached unity (range 0.98 to 1.02), and the standard errors of the estimate ranged from 12 to 15 microV. Each on-line program selected data points and determined ST/HR slopes in complete accordance with standard calculations. It is concluded that computer-based measurement of the ST/HR slope can be performed with a high degree of accuracy.

Recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression in the heart rate domain. Identification of coronary artery disease by the rate-recovery loop

Although the time course of ST segment depression after exercise has been related to the presence and severity of coronary artery disease, recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression with reference to changing heart rate have not been quantified. We have found distinct recovery loop patterns of ST segment depression that distinguish subjects without coronary disease from patients with coronary artery disease when ST segment depression is examined in the heart rate domain. Continuous plots of ST segment depression and heart rate were constructed throughout treadmill exercise and recovery in 100 clinically normal subjects, in 124 patients with coronary artery disease proven by catheterization, and in 17 patients with no significant coronary disease at catheterization. Among clinically normal subjects, 95% (95 of 100) had normal (clockwise) rate-recovery loops, and 5% (five of 100) had abnormal (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loops. In these normal subjects, the resulting 95% specificity of a normal rate-recovery loop was similar to the 93% (93 of 100) specificity of standard end-exercise ST segment depression criteria. Among patients with coronary disease proven by angiography, 93% (115 of 124) had abnormal (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loops, and 7% (nine of 124) had normal rate-recovery loops. In contrast was the significantly lower 74% (92 of 124) sensitivity of standard ST segment criteria (p less than 0.001 vs. the rate-recovery loop). Specificity of a normal rate-recovery loop (71%, 12 of 17) and standard ST segment depression criteria (71%, 12 of 17) were similar in the patients with normal coronary arteries at angiography.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of exercise protocol and lead selection on the accuracy of heart rate-adjusted indices of ST-segment depression for detection of three-vessel coronary artery disease

To assess the effect of exercise protocol and number of monitoring leads on the ability of the ST/HR slope and delta ST/HR index to identify three-vessel coronary artery disease, the exercise ECGs of 50 patients who had coronary arteriography were reviewed. Test performance of the ST/HR slope using the Cornell exercise protocol with 13 leads was compared with performance obtained from the standard 12 leads and from sets of only 3 leads, as well as with test outcome using Bruce protocol equivalent stages with multiple-lead sets. ST/HR slopes could be calculated in 100% of patients using data from the Cornell protocol, but in only 80% of patients using the Bruce protocol with 13 leads (chi 2 = 8.1, p less than 0.005) and 54% of patients using the Bruce protocol with 3 leads (chi 2 = 21.0, p less than 0.001). With the Cornell protocol and 13 leads, an ST/HR slope partition of 6.0 microV/bpm identified three-vessel disease with a sensitivity of 96%, specificity of 58%, and overall test accuracy of 76%. At matched specificity, the Bruce protocol 13-lead ST/HR slope partition of 5.0 microV/bpm had a sensitivity of only 48% and overall test accuracy of 53% for three-vessel disease in those patients with calculable test outcomes (each p less than 0.01). Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis confirmed the superior performance of data acquired with the Cornell protocol and demonstrated no significant loss of Cornell ST/HR slope performance calculated from fewer monitored leads. Performance of the delta ST/HR index was similar with 3 leads and with 13 leads.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression for improved detection of coronary artery disease

Normal values for heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST segment depression during treadmill exercise electrocardiography (the ST segment/heart rate slope and the delta ST segment/heart rate index) were derived from evaluation of 150 subjects with a low likelihood of coronary artery disease, including 100 normal subjects and 50 subjects with nonanginal chest pain. Partitions chosen by the method of percentile estimation to include 95% of normal subjects remained highly specific in subjects with nonanginal pain syndromes. Sensitivities of the derived partitions for detection of myocardial ischemia were tested in an additional 150 patients with a high likelihood of coronary disease, including 100 patients with angiographically demonstrated coronary obstruction and 50 patients with stable angina. In contrast to the 68% (102 of 150 subjects) sensitivity of standard exercise electrocardiographic criteria for the detection of disease in this population, the sensitivity of an ST segment/heart rate slope partition of 2.4 muV/beats/min was 95% (142 of 150 subjects, p less than 0.001), and the sensitivity of a delta ST segment/heart rate index partition of 1.6 muV/beats/min was 91% (137 of 150 subjects, p less than 0.001). Analysis of receiver-operating curves confirmed the superior performance of the heart rate-adjusted indexes throughout a wide range of test specificities. These findings suggest that heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression can markedly improve the clinical usefulness of the treadmill exercise electrocardiogram.

Heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression for reduction of false positive electrocardiographic responses to exercise in asymptomatic men screened for coronary artery disease

The ability of heart rate (HR) correction of exercise-induced ST-segment depression (the delta ST/HR index) to reduce the number of false positive exercise electrocardiograms during initial screening for occult coronary artery disease (CAD) was examined in active, asymptomatic men from the Army Reserve. Among 606 consecutive men given treadmill tests, 62 asymptomatic subjects with normal results on resting electrocardiograms but abnormal outcomes on standard exercise electrocardiograms underwent rest and exercise radionuclide cineangiography, and the 10 subjects with abnormal radionuclide findings then underwent coronary angiography. A previously established delta ST/HR index less than 1.6 microV/beat/min correctly identified 34 of 52 subjects (65%) who, despite abnormal standard exercise electrocardiographic findings, had no rest or exercise radionuclide abnormalities. A delta ST/HR index greater than or equal to 1.6 microV/beta/min detected 7 of 7 subjects with abnormal radionuclide cineangiograms who had CAD at cardiac catheterization, but also identified 2 of 3 subjects with an abnormal radionuclide test who had no CAD. In contrast to the 7 of 62 subjects (11%) with abnormal standard exercise test criteria who had radionuclide and angiographic evidence of CAD, a delta ST/HR index partition of 1.6 microV/beat/min separated subjects into subgroups with 0% (0 of 35) vs 26% (7 of 27) prevalences of CAD by serial diagnostic evaluation (p less than 0.01). Thus, among asymptomatic subjects with abnormal electrocardiographic responses to exercise, simple HR correction of the magnitude of ST-segment depression reduced by 56% the number of subjects with standard exercise test criteria leading to referral for additional diagnostic evaluation, without loss of sensitivity for angiographically proven CAD and with accurate negative predictive value.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The prognostic value of the exercise test

Numerous investigators have demonstrated that responses to exercise testing enable prediction of the severity of underlying coronary disease and the patient's prognosis. However, exercise testing cannot predict angiographic findings or a poor prognosis with absolute certainty. Because survival can only be improved in specific clinical subsets of patients, it is important to carefully select for catheterization those in whom intervention can improve both quality and quantity of life. To deliver cost-effective health care, an effort has been made to use decision analysis to select those who should undergo cardiac catheterization. Decision analysis depends on reliable information regarding the predictive accuracy of the exercise test. Thus, this review is timely. Recent studies investigating the prognostic value of the exercise test are reviewed in this monograph. Patients include those recovering from a recent myocardial infarction (MI), those with stable coronary heart disease (including studies that have considered coronary angiographic findings, cardiac end points, and/or improved survival with coronary artery bypass surgery), and apparently healthy individuals. From this review, we conclude that silent ischemia induced by exercise testing in apparently healthy men is not as predictive of a poor outcome as once thought. Also, the use of the exercise test for screening is even more misleading than previously appreciated because of the higher rate of false positive results. Review of the 24 available studies of exercise testing in post-MI patients demonstrates that clinical judgment can be used to identify the high-risk patients, and that ST-segment shifts are not as predictive of high risk as an abnormal systolic blood pressure response or a poor exercise capacity. In patients with stable coronary heart disease, studies considering angiographic findings, cardiac events, and the differential outcome of coronary artery bypass surgery as compared with medical therapy have shown the exercise test to have prognostic power. From this perspective, it is obvious that there is much information supporting the use of exercise testing as the first noninvasive step after the history, physical examination, and resting electrocardiogram in the prognostic evaluation of patients with coronary artery disease. It accomplishes both purposes of prognostic testing: to provide information regarding the patient's status, and to help make recommendations for optimal management. The exercise test results help us make reasonable decisions for selection of patients who should undergo coronary angiography-including quality-of-life issues.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Improved accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram in detection of coronary artery and three-vessel coronary disease

The study objective was to assess the widespread applicability of ST/HR slope for the modified Bruce exercise test using a computerized electrocardiogram (ECG); compare the usefulness of the ST/HR slope with standard ECG criteria in detection of coronary artery disease (CAD) and identification of three-vessel or left main CAD; and then develop a new, modified ST/HR score (MSHS) for improving the diagnostic accuracy of ST/HR slope. The studies were retrospective and prospective in design, conducted in referral-based cardiology clinics at a national cardiovascular center. A selected sample of 142 patients underwent exercise ECG and coronary angiography, as did a normal control group of 402 patients who were apparently free from CAD. Sixty three other patients who underwent coronary angiography were also studied prospectively. No limitations of medical treatment were exacted for the test except digitalis treatment. Linear regression analysis, from which ST/HR slope was derived, was done with seven measurements of HR and ST displacement at 60 ms from J point in leads a VF and V5 during 6 min before the end of exercise. MSHS was derived from a multiple regression model with peak HR (% maximum HR), ST index (ST depression + ST slope), and ST/HR slope. Although the usual ST criteria (sensitivity = 63 percent, specificity = 73 percent), ST index (71 percent, 80 percent), and ST/HR slope (70 percent, 97 percent) were equally accurate in detection of CAD, MSHS showed significantly improved sensitivity (88 percent) with similar specificity (81 percent). In identification of three-vessel or left main CAD, when compared with other criteria, ST/HR slope and MSHS provided improved diagnostic accuracy: sensitivity (74 and 78 percent, respectively), specificity (88 and 93 percent) and overall test accuracy (85 and 89 percent). The improved accuracy of ST/HR slope and MSHS was prospectively validated in 63 other patients. ST/HR slope was applicable to computerized ECG data for the standard treadmill test, and showed improved accuracy in detection of three-vessel or left main CAD. The new, modified ST/HR score more accurately predicted not only the presence but also the severity of CAD.

Changes in myocardial ischaemia during isosorbide dinitrate or indoramin therapy in patients with stable angina using relations between the ST segment and heart rate

The effect of isosorbide dinitrate or indoramin on myocardial ischaemia was examined in patients with stable angina pectoris. In a prospective trial, randomization resulted in 8 and 9 patients, respectively, given isosorbide dinitrate in a dose of 30-90 mg daily, and indoramin in a dose of 75-225 mg daily; 2 of these patients were serially examined during the two types of therapy. Changes in myocardial ischaemia were assessed by exercise testing using 12 standard electrocardiographic leads and a bipolar lead CM5. Individual and group comparisons showed that isosorbide dinitrate resulted in an increase in ST segment depression, the maximal ST/heart rate slope and the ratio of net ST segment depression to increases in heart rate (at least P less than 0.01). In contrast, with indoramin therapy there were no significant changes in these indices. The results in these patients suggest that isosorbide dinitrate leads more consistently to increases in the severity of myocardial ischaemia than indoramin, although this effect on ischaemia is apparently less than the benefit of these agents on exercise performance.

Identification of anatomically extensive coronary artery disease by the exercise ECG ST segment/heart rate slope

To assess the ability of the ST segment/heart rate (ST/HR) slope to identify three-vessel coronary disease and the relationship between the ST/HR slope and the anatomic extent of disease as determined by the Gensini and Duke jeopardy scores, the exercise ECGs of 128 patients with stable angina were compared with findings at coronary cineangiography. A ST/HR slope greater than or equal to 6 microV/beat/min identified three-vessel coronary disease with a sensitivity of 93% compared with sensitivities of only 50% for early positive standard test responses (p less than 0.001) and 66% for markedly positive standard test responses (p less than 0.01). The negative predictive value of this ST/HR slope partition for three-vessel disease was 94%. Patients with ST/HR slopes greater than or equal to 6 who did not have three-vessel disease had anatomically more extensive obstruction than did patients with lower test values (mean Gensini score 43 +/- 5 vs 22 +/- 3, p less than 0.002 and mean jeopardy score 4.8 +/- 0.4 vs 3.0 +/- 0.3, p less than 0.01). Test performance of the calculated ST/HR slope exceeded that of a simplified index derived by dividing the total change in ST segment depression by the total change in heart rate. These findings demonstrate that a ST/HR slope greater than or equal to 6 is highly sensitive for the identification of three-vessel coronary disease and also identifies patients with anatomically severe obstruction. A ST/HR slope less than 6 makes three-vessel coronary disease or otherwise anatomically extensive coronary obstruction unlikely.

Comparison between manual and computer measurement of ST-segment amplitude during exercise

Several studies have shown that the maximal ST/HR slope may be used as a reliable index of myocardial ischemia as assessed by coronary angiography, but this involves laborious training and derivation, particularly with respect to the measurement of ST segment amplitude, which is obtained by averaging values measured in at least 10 cardiac cycles in the steady state. The authors compared manual measurement of ST-segment amplitude with computer-processed beat using cardiac cycles in six consecutive patients with standard 12-lead records obtained over 5 seconds and a beat processed by the recorder to represent each lead (modal beat, over 10 seconds). All recordings were made in the steady state. Two patients had myocardial ischemia, as assessed by means including the maximal ST/HR slope and the occurrence of ST-segment depression at the end of exercise. Comparisons were made between measurements in 324 pairs of ST-segment amplitude obtained, respectively, from manually averaged recorded beats (average beat) and the modal beat during each step of the exercise test. The level of the ST-segment, (80 msec after the end of QRS complex) was independently obtained from the two records in a blinded fashion. The group data showed that the modal beat gave significantly lower values of ST-segment amplitude than the average beat. Similar results were obtained when 286 pairs of positive amplitudes were compared in the range of 0-7.25 mm. In the remaining 38 pairs in which ST-segment depression was found, the amplitude in the modal beats was not significantly different from the average beats.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Computer-based ST/HR slope calculation on Marquette CASE 12: development and technical considerations

Computer-based implementation of the ST/HR slope on Marquette CASE 12 is described. ST-segment measurement is performed with improved software for QRS detection and incremental signal updating, and on-line test calculation results from automated linear regression, leading to graphic display of the maximum ST/HR slope at the end of exercise.

Aortic valve disease and the ST segment/heart rate relationship: a longitudinal study before and after aortic valve replacement

The ST segment/heart rate relationship or maximal ST/HR slope has been validated as an index of myocardial ischemia in selected populations of patients with angina pectoris. The present study involved patients selected as having aortic valve disease unaccompanied by angiographic coronary artery narrowing. In each of seven patients, so far examined, a slope value and ST segment depression of greater than 1 mm were obtained which, according to previous experience, indicated myocardial ischemia equivalent to coronary heart disease. After aortic valve replacement, there was a significant reduction in heart size as assessed using the cardiothoracic ratio, and the amplitude of QRS complex on the electrocardiogram. The slope was abolished (two patients) or markedly reduced (five patients), and the decrease in the seven patients was statistically significant. ST segment depression could be obtained in one patient. This study has shown the occurrence of maximal ST/HR slope in patients without large coronary artery disease who have aortic valve disease and cardiac enlargement.

Merits and limitations of quantitative treadmill exercise score

This study examined the ability of the treadmill exercise score (TES) in determining the presence and extent of coronary artery disease (CAD). The score was derived from the integrated area of ST segment depression and ST slope in two leads (V5 and a VF), corrected for R wave amplitude, exercise time, and percent of maximum predicted heart rate. The ST segment depression was measured at 80 msec after the J point. There were 34 patients with no significant CAD, 38 patients with one-vessel CAD (greater than or equal to 50% diameter stenosis), and 58 patients with multivessel CAD. The TES showed a considerable scatter in patients with and without CAD. A receiver operating characteristic curve showed different levels of sensitivity and specificity, depending on the cut-point. The TES was similar to ST segment depression in detecting CAD (predictive accuracy, 77% vs 78%, p = NS). A markedly abnormal score (less than -1.0) was seen in 41 patients, of whom 32 (78%) had multivessel CAD. On the other hand, a score greater than 0 was seen in 49 patients, of whom 40 (82%) had no or one-vessel CAD. In 40 patients with TES between -1.0 and 0, 17 (43%) had multivessel CAD and 23 (57%) had no or one-vessel CAD. In 51 patients with nondiagnostic ST changes, the TES correctly classified the extent of CAD in 20 patients (40%). Thus, the TES has a similar accuracy to the ST segment depression criteria in detecting CAD. The extent of CAD can, however, be ascertained in 80% of the patients with very high or very low TES.